New Culture Forum - February 27, 2019


1. How BBC Bias Works

8. Martin Daubney: Men Under Attack?

Episode Stats


Length

35 minutes

Words per minute

149.33

Word count

5,257

Sentence count

186


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 hello there and welcome to the very first edition of so what you're saying is i'm peter whittle i'm
00:00:11 director of the new culture forum and this is the very first of a weekly series of interviews
00:00:18 discussions and debates which we're going to be doing and which we hope will provide an opportunity
00:00:24 an alternative for different voices and different viewpoints because let's face it our own media now
00:00:30 is becoming incredibly restricted incredibly biased and it's always promoting a liberal agenda
00:00:37 so please do subscribe if you like what we're going to be doing here and also if you particularly
00:00:43 like it then of course you can always donate by going to this link now my very first guest
00:00:50 knows everything that there is about working in the liberal broadcasting media.
00:00:57 Robin Akin, who was at the BBC for 25 years,
00:01:01 working as a local reporter, then right up to the Today programme,
00:01:05 is also the author of a new book which is called The Noble Liar
00:01:09 and how the BBC distorts the news and promotes a liberal agenda.
00:01:14 It's right here.
00:01:16 It's great that he's our very first guest today.
00:01:18 So welcome, Robin.
00:01:20 Robin, the title of your book, what's noble about it?
00:01:25 The concept, Peter, of a noble lie comes from Plato originally.
00:01:31 And the idea is that some lies are told with good intent.
00:01:38 And so the title of the book, The Noble Liar, as it refers to the BBC,
00:01:44 is to say that the BBC, in my view,
00:01:51 tells a series of well-meaning untruths
00:01:55 which it believes are in our best interests.
00:01:59 So it disguises, sometimes ignores,
00:02:05 occasionally distorts reality
00:02:08 to suit its own particular agenda
00:02:14 agenda. Its agenda is not a malevolent agenda, but I believe that it's wrong-headed of the
00:02:24 BBC to do this. I think that what the BBC's job is, or should be, is to tell the unvarnished
00:02:31 truth. And I don't believe it does.
00:02:33 I mean, if we can sort of turn, first of all, to Brexit, obviously, there's a feeling, and
00:02:38 I think it, you know, when I look at it, it's certainly something that I feel, that the
00:02:42 BBC have kind of doubled down, right, since the referendum. During the referendum, they appear to
00:02:49 play by the rules. I don't know whether you feel that, but now it is virtually undisguised,
00:02:55 wouldn't you say? I think, yes, I mean, I think you make a very good point. I think that during
00:02:59 the referendum campaign itself, the BBC played it absolutely by the book. And there's an important
00:03:06 thing which not everyone understands but in the run-up to a general election or the run-up to a
00:03:14 referendum we're now having more of them obviously so it's more relevant. The BBC is bound by
00:03:20 something called the representation of the People's Act and this means that broadcasters are strictly
00:03:25 under an injunction to give fair allocation of airtime to the various political viewpoints.
00:03:31 So in the run-up to the referendum, the BBC was absolutely scrupulous about giving 50% to yes and 50% to no, whereas hitherto, before that, for decades, the balance had been completely askew.
00:03:49 And you had, and I think there are some statistics in the book which are drawn from some research which was paid for by Lord Pearson of Rannoch, a UKIP man, who actually did an inventory on BBC Current Affairs Outbook and found this imbalance between pro-European and anti-European views.
00:04:13 And there was a tiny percentage of people who were anti-EU, being interviewed back in the 1990s and so on.
00:04:23 But that did change during the period of the referendum itself because the BBC was legally obliged to do so.
00:04:29 And it kept to the letter of the law.
00:04:32 But I think Rod Liddle once said, you know, when he was at the Today programme as editor for a BBC,
00:04:37 one of his colleagues said, you know, you've got to realise, Rod, these people are mad.
00:04:41 He was talking about people who we'd now call Brexiteers, Eurosceptics.
00:04:45 These people are mad.
00:04:47 See, this is the point.
00:04:47 When you say that it's a noble liar, that they feel they're doing good,
00:04:51 it's harder and harder, surely, to sustain that feeling
00:04:54 when you look at panels that have got four Remainers and one Brexiteer.
00:04:59 That looks like, to most people looking at, wait a minute,
00:05:02 there's something else going on here.
00:05:04 Well, and in passing, Rod Liddle was the best editor I ever worked for.
00:05:10 Oh, right.
00:05:10 I mean, a man, it was a pleasure to work for him.
00:05:18 The point is this, Peter, that the BBC's view of Brexit and the EU is, I think, this.
00:05:29 The vast majority of people within the BBC think that the EU is a force for good
00:05:34 and think that Britain should be part of it.
00:05:37 They think that internationalism and joint endeavour by nation-states leading to the formation of a federal Europe is the right answer to our problems as a nation and individually.
00:05:55 Therefore, when they slant things in favour of the EU, they think genuinely and sincerely
00:06:03 they're doing us a favour because they think that is the way that leads to harmony and prosperity.
00:06:10 And so they're not distorting the truth for, in their view, an evil aim.
00:06:20 They're doing it for our own good. That's the point.
00:06:23 Isn't that also, in a way, that's a very definition of authoritarianism, isn't it, as well?
00:06:28 I mean, in the sense that people always think, you know, they're doing something for your own good or whatever.
00:06:35 The way in which people who are Brexiteers or people who have been Eurosceptics once,
00:06:40 the way in which they are treated, though, is with a real disdain, surely, isn't it?
00:06:45 I mean, how many Brexiteers, how many Eurosceptics were there at the BBC when you were there?
00:06:51 I mean did you do you have to remain quiet in a corner what? Well my own experience was that
00:06:58 there were very very few people who were skeptical like I was of the EU and I
00:07:10 it was viewed as a sort of personality problem yeah it was as if you had some if you had the
00:07:19 mark of Cain on you yeah if you were if you weren't fully signed up to the the the pro-EU
00:07:26 project and the problem about the BBC and I think this is it goes much wider than the BBC actually
00:07:33 and it's the problem in our universities as well there's a political monoculture in most of these
00:07:39 institutions. You know academics who are right-wing if you like or who have
00:07:50 conservative instincts shall we say are such a tiny minority that they've I mean
00:07:56 they formed their own organization now this thing called the Heterodox Academy
00:08:01 which is a sort of cross-Atlantic thing where this small
00:08:06 All beleaguered bands, a band of conservative academics, are banding together to make their case because they're so outnumbered in the senior common rooms of our universities.
00:08:19 And it's the same in the BBC. The thing is, if you're in that bubble and if you're thinking like the majority think within those circumstances, it's very difficult then to see your own biases for what they really are.
00:08:35 In the same way that if you and I inhabited a universe where everyone thought like we do, you know, if we were surrounded by social conservatives, cultural conservatives, then it would be difficult for us to see our bias.
00:08:49 That's exactly the way it is in the BBC.
00:08:51 I think this is a case with the general what you might call cultural establishment, isn't it?
00:08:55 Absolutely.
00:08:56 It goes right to the arts, it goes through broadcasting and what have you.
00:08:59 I mean to what extent you you do talk about this in the book it's a really important point I think
00:09:05 when you talk about this kind of you know just monoliths of opinion people say well how did it
00:09:11 get like that you know how did it get like that it's not just a case surely like Andrew Marr I
00:09:16 think admitted didn't he that there's a strong element you know disproportionate amount of young
00:09:21 liberal people metropolitan people at the BBC you know we hear this phrase long march through the
00:09:26 institutions. How do you feel that has worked with the BBC, this idea actually that institutions
00:09:33 have been effectively captured? Do you think the BBC had a long march? Yes I do and I think that
00:09:40 the answer to your question is that it's what I call cultural Marxism. So I think what the
00:09:47 progressive left in the UK has taken from Marxism is the idea that history is a one-way ticket
00:09:56 and there's no getting off the train, that the end destination is a progressive destination,
00:10:04 their definition of progress by the way, and that this is an ineluctable process.
00:10:12 So there's no stopping it and so we will in this mindset, we will arrive at some point in a
00:10:20 federal Europe. We will arrive in a country which is completely atheistic and a country
00:10:28 which has lost all sense of natural patriotic pride in itself. All that is to be subsumed
00:10:38 in a greater self. That's what I mean by cultural Marxism, the idea that that is a destination
00:10:47 which is certain to arrive at some point. I think it's nonsense actually. I don't believe in
00:10:54 the Marxist interpretation of history. I don't think that any rational observer of history
00:11:04 over the past 200 years can see that there have been sudden jolts, sudden turnings in
00:11:11 the road. And that's the way history it is. It doesn't go in a straight line to a predestination.
00:11:15 And I sense, I mean, the one thing that I feel is quite hopeful at the moment in Britain, and of course, Brexit is the actualization of it in some ways, is that that was the first time in my lifetime that people, the people, the voters, actually said, no, that's not what we want.
00:11:39 they were given the opportunity and they said no this is stopping right here that's why there's
00:11:44 been such that's why it's so painful for the bbc yes it's so painful for the cultural left
00:11:50 this you know brexit is something which wounds them deeply because it offends their sense that
00:11:56 actually you know maybe we're not going to get to that destination which was something they always
00:12:02 took for granted but you know that this there is this sense of complete lack of understanding
00:12:08 of the other side. This is where it's different. They might be very offended by this, what they
00:12:14 see as an attack on their very selves, actually. But there is also a sense in which they just
00:12:19 simply refuse to actually understand why people might have voted the way they did.
00:12:25 They still don't, they argue about Brexit in economic terms for a start, wouldn't you say?
00:12:30 Oh, absolutely. Oh, yes. I mean, you know, the economic determinism is absolutely at
00:12:38 the forefront of the Brexit debate from the Remain side. Everything is couched in terms of the
00:12:44 economy as if nothing else matters. And it's such a misunderstanding, I think, of why people voted
00:12:53 the way they did. I think that the, you know, it was the first opportunity, I think, that a lot of
00:13:01 people felt their vote because it was a simple yes no question and it was a question of an
00:13:08 absolute majority right across the nation it was the first time when people knew that their vote
00:13:14 would actually count and they were engaged by that and they were saying they were saying
00:13:19 we don't like the way things have gone we want to have our own country back we want to be able to
00:13:25 run our own country make our own laws it's such a a simple fundamental demand in a a a a democracy
00:13:36 that you would think it should be you know everyone could sign up for it but clearly they
00:13:41 can't I mean I'm always reminded by of the you know the remark of Tony Benn you know if you
00:13:47 can't vote the buggers out then you don't live in a democracy and I think he was absolutely right
00:13:53 there that if you can't vote out the people in Brussels so you so you're not
00:13:57 really living in a functioning democracy unless you've got those unless the
00:14:02 people have their hands on the leavers you know the voting leavers what sort
00:14:07 of democracy is it well you know you obviously with the BBC 25 years you
00:14:13 covered many sections of the corporation as we mentioned the day program local
00:14:18 right across the board. Can you just give us a flavour? If I would say that you are a bit,
00:14:25 I'd characterise you as a small c conservative maybe or whatever, what actually was it like
00:14:30 therefore, what is it like for someone conservative viewpoint working at the BBC? What was it like,
00:14:37 if you could give us some examples, how difficult it could be or what?
00:14:43 Well, yes, I mean it was, it was uncomfortable at times.
00:14:52 I think because of the sort of person I am, I actually rather enjoyed it because
00:15:01 I take the view that journalism should be a bit about causing as much of a stink as you can.
00:15:07 you know that you know what's the point of being a journalist if you're not going to cause a bit
00:15:11 of mischief so if you're sitting in the today morning meeting discussing ideas it's great fun
00:15:19 to say something that you know will be disagreed with by 95% of the colleagues sitting around you
00:15:29 you know you have to have the confidence to do it but the point is it's worth doing luckily as I
00:15:34 mean I mentioned Rod Liddell. The reason why he was such a great guy to work for in my view was
00:15:40 because although he didn't think as I did then he seems to have come much more to our way of
00:15:50 thinking actually since he's freed himself from the shackles of the BBC but he in those days he
00:15:57 was the first BBC editor I ever worked for who was prepared to accept an idea
00:16:03 which came from if you like the a conservative way of thinking you know a
00:16:09 story. Even though he was labourer. Even though he was labourer because he was
00:16:12 like because he had an intellectual curiosity but working for other editors
00:16:18 I can think of I mean I worked on the the money program for a good few years
00:16:23 and there I was really quite shocked actually when I first moved there because it was the way
00:16:32 in which the scripts were written from a purely theoretical point of view before you ever left the
00:16:40 building. So we were writing the story that would appear before it ever appeared on the screen and
00:16:46 then we would go out with our cameras and our microphones to illustrate the script we had
00:16:52 written. Because this is actually very interesting if I can interrupt because I was going to ask for
00:16:56 most people you know when we talk about bias in the BBC and all the rest of it it seems very
00:17:00 conceptual actually on a practical level how does that bias work I mean you're telling us it's very
00:17:07 interesting almost like on a step-by-step basis how does it work? Okay so Peter you've been
00:17:14 in journalism long enough to know that all journalism is a question of selection so the
00:17:22 first step in the process is this you've got a guy like you or me sitting at a desk a news desk
00:17:28 and they've got information coming in from all over the world stories pouring in from every
00:17:33 quarter of the globe which stories are you going to cover that's the first question and that is
00:17:38 where the first the bias first makes its mark. So for instance let's suppose there
00:17:48 is a story of a knife attack or a gun attack in Sweden by an Islamist. Are we
00:17:59 going to cover that on the BBC today? Probably not. Why do we make that
00:18:06 decision well do we really want to draw attention to that kind of thing it's not really our kind of
00:18:12 story on the other hand you know let's say there has been a racist attack by a white racist in the
00:18:22 north of England on a black guy now that's much more our kind of story that's the kind of story
00:18:29 we want why do we want that story because it fits our view of the world our view of the world is
00:18:35 this that Muslims are always victims and they are victimized and Islamophobia is
00:18:43 rife in the country and that's the story we want to tell do we want to tell
00:18:49 stories about Muslims behaving badly you know attacking Jews or attacking women
00:18:56 no we don't really want to tell those stories that's why for instance it took
00:19:01 so long and it took some brave journalism by the Times newspaper to bring that whole thing about
00:19:07 the Pakistani rape gangs into the open. What a struggle that was. How was it that all the
00:19:15 authorities and all the journalists were sort of complicit in that silence? It's extraordinary but
00:19:23 isn't it as well something again you allude to in the book or something I've always found is that
00:19:27 the BBC, again, they might think they're being noble, although it's sounding less and less
00:19:31 noble from what you're saying. They sort of believe that they are one of the upholders
00:19:37 of multiculturalism, that that is actually one of their tenets. They actually see it
00:19:42 as something they should promote. Well, that goes completely against the kind of idea of
00:19:47 multiculturalism as being a very, very benign thing, doesn't it?
00:19:50 Well, I'll say this again. The thing is that the reason why the BBC journalist might take a decision to ignore, or if you like to use a stronger word, suppress a story about a Muslim attacking a woman or whatever,
00:20:15 is because the calculus is that this is a story which will damage community relations.
00:20:28 So when they say we won't tell this story because if we tell this story it'll upset people,
00:20:35 race relations will be harmed, multiculturalism will be harmed, so we don't tell the story.
00:20:40 That's the way it works. And it's done, that's what I mean, they're doing it,
00:20:44 They think they're doing us a favor, but actually the problem with that approach is that the people at ground level, ordinary people, know the reality of these things.
00:20:59 And the disconnect between what the BBC is telling us and what people know is happening becomes ever and ever greater.
00:21:09 And that's why I think there is a danger in this for the BBC.
00:21:14 I think the BBC has to wake up to the fact that it has a culture which actually separates it from the reality as experienced by many, many millions of British people.
00:21:27 I think this is when people used to complain about bias.
00:21:33 I remember it used to always be Tory MPs usually complaining about lack of Tory voices strictly on the news agenda or whatever.
00:21:40 but my feeling now really which is really echoing what you're saying is that people the pennies
00:21:45 drop slightly that in the general population there is a sort of sense people feel for example
00:21:51 that they're being handled more they do you think that's true I mean do you think that people
00:21:56 basically are more aware of this now than they maybe would the general public I think they are
00:22:02 and I think there's a number of different reasons for that one is that the people's exposure to
00:22:08 media, of course, has changed enormously, hasn't it, over the past 10, 15 years, 20 years.
00:22:14 You know, now people know they have in their hands powerful computers and they can access
00:22:18 information from anywhere in the world via the internet, right? And people are wising
00:22:24 up to the fact that on the internet, you know, there are some sources of information which
00:22:29 are not terribly reliable. But of course, once the penny drops in that way, then you're
00:22:35 much more likely to ask the question about the people who are appearing on
00:22:39 your terrestrial TV channels what about them are they I mean is that what I'm
00:22:44 what I think is that that people are more media savvy than they were and so
00:22:50 this idea that you know and the great you know the great exemplar of this at
00:22:57 the moment is Trump and his fake news isn't it it's very interesting that fake
00:23:01 news thing because, you know, people think that that sort of Guardian reading classes
00:23:09 think that what Trump is saying is that what appears in The Guardian and The New York Times
00:23:16 and on the main the main TV channels in America is inaccurate and false. That's not really
00:23:26 what he's saying i don't think i think that what trump is saying when he says fake news what he
00:23:32 means is you guys only tell negative stories about me right that's why it's fake it's not because
00:23:40 you're it's not because you're lying it's because you're selecting negative information and only
00:23:46 negative information about me the president that's why it's fake when with some exceptions usually
00:23:53 when people talk about fake news they're talking about good old-fashioned bias aren't they yeah
00:23:57 bias by omission or whatever this is something as well uh which again you go to in your book in
00:24:04 great detail for example immigration bbc pro-immigration almost you know to a man and
00:24:13 that is one of the huge divides isn't it between you know where the majority of people sit and where
00:24:20 the BBC sits. There's a case that you mentioned in the book as well, which I remember very vividly.
00:24:25 It was the case of Andrew Never, who was a former writer for Tony Blair, I believe,
00:24:31 wrote this piece where he was very clear about Labour and its social aims, migration. Do you
00:24:38 remember, rub the nose of the right in diversity, all of that stuff. Now, why, I mean, or maybe,
00:24:45 you know you've already answered this why did that not become a bigger deal on
00:24:50 the BBC because frankly you know when you look at it that should have been
00:24:53 covered everywhere shouldn't it? Yes well it would be if people like you
00:24:59 and I were news editors in the BBC yeah but if you're a BBC news editor who
00:25:04 thinks diversity you know diversity is one of those words it comes loaded
00:25:07 freighted with good intentions you know diversity you can't have too much
00:25:11 diversity after all, you know, can you? I think you can actually. I think there is a definite limit
00:25:18 to the amount of diversity that a society can digest. In the case of Nether, he let the cat
00:25:26 out of the bag about why it was that there was an ideological undertow to the Blair government's
00:25:35 policies on immigration. They wanted more immigration because they knew that it undermines
00:25:43 the conservative position. Because our position as conservatives, as social conservatives and
00:25:52 political conservatives, is that I'm proud of the country. I think Britain has given far more to the
00:26:02 world than it has taken from it. I think we are have been and remain an essentially good country
00:26:09 and I think that the it's you know it was said a long time ago and it remains the case
00:26:19 that British intellectuals are almost unique in the world in hating their own country.
00:26:25 George Orwell. Exactly. Would rather steal from a poor box than stand for what would then God save the king, right?
00:26:32 Yeah, exactly. That's the quote. The French don't have this. No, they don't. I mean, the French, I mean, you know, talk about national pride.
00:26:41 There it goes, you know, you know, for my taste as an Englishman, it goes a little bit far the other way, but you know what I mean.
00:26:47 but you know the but but british intellectuals i mean they're so contemptuous of the society
00:26:55 which has which has borne them and they're so um sneering and undermining of many of the things
00:27:06 which should be a source of pride and a source of a way of binding us together the thing is though
00:27:14 Okay, maybe these people, they feel what they do, you know, genuinely and out of reasons they think is good for us and everything.
00:27:24 But really, Robert, I mean, it does seem that when you're talking about such big issues as like immigration or multiculturalism or even Brexit,
00:27:30 you know, effectively, they are damaging, surely, damaging the social fabric by simply not addressing these things and putting them, basically demonising them.
00:27:41 And I think it's still the case, wouldn't you say?
00:27:43 I agree. It's still the case on these sorts of issues. Oh, absolutely. I couldn't agree more. I mean, I think that the I mean, I I say in the book, I think I use the analogy of I think that I think all healthy societies have a measure of immigration and emigration.
00:28:02 People leaving and coming. That's natural. It's good. It's wholesome. And it's right. And it's good for the country, good for the economy. In every sense, it's good. But the analogy I use in the book is that it's like a digestive system.
00:28:18 You know, if you overeat, you're going to get indigestion with potentially unpleasant results.
00:28:26 And the number of people that society can happily and harmoniously welcome in and integrate, there is a sweet spot, you know, for the numbers.
00:28:42 It is a numbers thing. If you get too many, too suddenly, too concentrated in one area,
00:28:48 you're going to get problems. And that's what we've had. And that's the result, in my view,
00:28:53 of this exactly the thing which Andrew never put his finger on, you know, rubbing the right's
00:29:00 noses in diversity. That's where it leads you into mass immigration. And then you get a reaction. And
00:29:06 And of course you get a reaction because people don't wish to see their familiar neighbourhoods
00:29:13 and societies.
00:29:16 People naturally don't wish massive influxes of foreigners and why should they?
00:29:24 On immigration, you also go into social conservatism, moral conservatism in your book a lot.
00:29:31 It seems now to me, and I'm sure to many people watching, that it's not just about the BBC
00:29:35 anymore.
00:29:36 Obviously, we pay for the BBC, you know, under threat of jail, actually.
00:29:43 But also Channel 4 News, Sky News, amazingly, Channel 5, whatever, essentially they're much
00:29:50 of a muchness now.
00:29:52 It seems that the general landscape has changed.
00:29:57 Why do you think that is?
00:29:58 first of all, Peter, I agree with you absolutely. Your analysis is right. I don't think there's
00:30:02 much of a difference between any of them, really. Channel 4, BBC, Sky, their political
00:30:10 and cultural outlook is much the same. I mean, there are some slight variations. The reason
00:30:15 for it is, I think, one of the reasons for it is because they all recruit in the same
00:30:21 pool. And where do these young journalists get their education from? Well, they get their
00:30:27 education from in universities mainly and then they go into training courses media study courses
00:30:34 that sort of thing and um there is as has been well publicized in the press over the past few
00:30:44 years you know there's a growing intolerance on university campuses towards um different ways of
00:30:50 thinking different approaches to cultural to cultural you know different cultural attitudes
00:30:56 are frowned upon. And you know, there's a sort of political monoculture on a lot of university
00:31:00 campuses. And journalistic training in particular, I think, is slanted more towards turning out
00:31:08 social activists than it is turning out proper journalists. Well, this is the whole thing,
00:31:14 is that basically journalists or reporters are actually, you know, political activists,
00:31:21 in disguise
00:31:23 when we look to the future
00:31:26 what do you see
00:31:28 I mean are you
00:31:30 do you think that the
00:31:32 BBC will change
00:31:34 simply because it has to
00:31:36 because of the changing landscape
00:31:37 and the license fee becoming
00:31:39 more and more difficult
00:31:41 to justify, is that how it will change
00:31:44 or will there be a cult, do you think
00:31:46 we're trying hard
00:31:47 will there be a cultural change
00:31:50 do you think that will help it along
00:31:51 um well predictions are risky i suppose i think that the bbc um i think that it's
00:32:02 there is a lot of support for the bbc within the political establishment
00:32:08 because the way the bbc is at the moment suits the majority of those who are in the political
00:32:17 and cultural elite
00:32:18 because the views
00:32:21 and biases of the BBC
00:32:23 are by and large the views
00:32:25 and biases of them
00:32:27 I mean
00:32:29 and this is very clear in the Brexit issue
00:32:31 I mean the BBC
00:32:33 is a
00:32:35 Remainer and so are most of the people
00:32:37 in the building across the road
00:32:39 the MPs
00:32:39 and nearly all the people in the House of Lords
00:32:42 are Remainers
00:32:43 so you've got
00:32:44 you know so so um so i mean they're all in it together in that sense but i do think i sense
00:32:53 or maybe this is just wildly optimism wild optimism on my part i sense there is change in
00:33:01 the air yes i do i mean i i i think that people have got um that the scales are dropping from
00:33:10 people's eyes and people are seeing things for um how they really are let me just give you one
00:33:17 little example this week they announced the turner prize could it have been a more predictable
00:33:25 and boring choice than it actually was yeah you know in the you know it's a joke yeah yeah those
00:33:34 To give the prize, supposedly Britain's foremost artistic prize,
00:33:43 to a young woman who's made a video of herself coming out as gay in rural Scotland.
00:33:51 Honestly, it sounds like the title of a comedy sketch.
00:33:56 There she is, wailing about her plight to the empty mountains, the valleys and the sheep.
00:34:01 No one who gives a monkey.
00:34:04 I mean really it's so self-absorbed it's so kind of look at me you know and and I think that that
00:34:13 people are just yeah it's just a very small example it wouldn't mean much to a lot of people
00:34:18 who don't take an interest in such things but it's that kind of thing it's the sort of arrogance of
00:34:23 the cultural elite which will be its undoing this idea that there is only one way of thinking about
00:34:28 things and that we all must accept that all these things that they think are great we all must think
00:34:33 of us great but we don't and i think an increasing number of us are saying enough is enough and
00:34:39 you know thinking for ourselves that's what i hope anyway and finding ways as well of expressing
00:34:45 that which is a great thing robin it's great thank you very very much i would say again
00:34:50 the book the noble liar how the bbc is producing a liberal agenda this is it here really worth
00:34:58 reading thank you very much Robin and we will be back next week thanks very much
00:35:04 watching so what you're saying is and please do subscribe won't you thank you
00:35:09 bye-bye