New Culture Forum - March 04, 2019


8. Martin Daubney: Men Under Attack?

1. How BBC Bias Works 9. James Delingpole: Right & Proud

Episode Stats


Length

28 minutes

Words per minute

188.42

Word count

5,309

Sentence count

57


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Hello, I'm Peter Whittle. Welcome to So What You're Saying Is. Now, the American Psychology
00:00:10 Association recently called traditional masculinity harmful. It seems that a day doesn't go past now
00:00:17 when we don't hear this phrase toxic masculinity. It was only last month that the shaving firm
00:00:22 Gillette put out an ad which caused a fair amount of controversy when it appeared to show men how
00:00:27 not to behave. Now at the same time there are other things happening with men. First of all
00:00:32 boys are doing very badly at school, men's mental health issues are on the rise and indeed suicide
00:00:40 has now become the main cause of death for men under 50. Are these things related in some way?
00:00:46 Are men and masculinity actually under some form of attack? Now with me to discuss this is Martin
00:00:53 daubney martin is the go-to voice when it comes to men and boys issues now he is a founder of the men
00:01:01 and boys coalition but before that he was known as king of the lads when he edited a loaded
00:01:08 magazine he's an award-winning broadcaster and journalist i'm thrilled to have him with us
00:01:13 today welcome what a splendid intro thank you what is your reaction uh when you hear the phrase
00:01:21 traditional masculinity is harm for? I find it extremely offensive and poisonous I'm the son
00:01:29 of a coal miner I'm the first boy in my family that ever made it to university I escaped the
00:01:34 destiny of sort of servitude if you like my dad spent all 16 hours a day underground digging coal
00:01:41 and I thought that was what my life was was going to be and I was encouraged through through male
00:01:47 role models at school teachers who had a belief in me a father who had a belief in me despite the
00:01:52 fact he was dyslexic and had been abandoned by the education system like many boys today and i
00:01:57 decided to to strive forward and you know that was a traditional patriarch my male role model doing
00:02:04 that now where's the bad in that so i just think that the the the the war on the concept of
00:02:12 masculinity by the media by academia and by the the wider political establishment is a gross
00:02:18 dereliction of duty which does men no favors you know you mentioned very serious issues at the
00:02:23 beginning issues sadly such as male suicide and the fact that boys are the bottom of education
00:02:29 stack from reception to university and at the very bottom of that are white working class lads
00:02:34 you know people like myself you know of a generation before and yet there is very little
00:02:39 political will to help them. I've been in numerous committee room meetings. I've sat down just this
00:02:45 close with politicians who pay great lip service. The Prime Minister Theresa May in her first speech
00:02:51 pointed out the fact that male suicide is a serious issue and that white working class boys
00:02:56 are at the bottom of the sack. Literally nothing has happened in all that time. Okay, but a small
00:03:00 thing called Brexit in the way. But my point is, if we are able to identify need, if we are able to
00:03:08 identify inequality which we can provably through data such as education stats and male suicide
00:03:13 stats then then why don't we do anything about that and I think that's because we do have this
00:03:18 this broader concept that that to be born male is to be born privileged and in particular
00:03:24 to be born a white man means you've automatically won life's lottery as I look at the evidence
00:03:30 Donald Trump rules the world there are more CEOs on the FTSE 100 called John than women now this
00:03:36 this is all true but there are also 93 percent of the prison population are men 85 percent of the
00:03:44 homeless are men three quarters of suicides are men so we could go on all day but this is the
00:03:50 problem you see we we are forced into this kind of oppression olympics i feel that we're for the
00:03:56 first time in in human history we it's a race to the bottom to prove that we're the most oppressed
00:04:01 the most hard done by it becomes a competitive sport and there's a good reason for that and
00:04:07 that is if you can prove that people are suffering inequalities then you can offer them protected
00:04:13 status which allows policy to be made it allows the the appropriation of funding to help
00:04:19 disadvantaged groups and men don't fall into that the only men who are protected
00:04:24 are by the dint of their skin color their religion or their sexuality so we have a situation where
00:04:30 politically white men have no allies and have no recourse to power despite the data showing us
00:04:37 that actually they need help and i think that's a terrible injustice do you think therefore is
00:04:42 because you've sort of segued there and it's something that's occurred to me too is this
00:04:47 and when i said it's an attack on masculinity is it actually more specifically an attack on
00:04:51 on white masculinity i mean i'm thinking of that you know that gillette ad yeah actually i mentioned
00:04:58 in the in the intro that seemed to actually have that in it i mean i don't mean to be too
00:05:04 paranoid about this but it seemed to be mostly white guys who were doing the things that you
00:05:08 shouldn't do is that right do you think well um let's be absolutely honest um in particularly
00:05:12 in the social media era where careers can end overnight um it's absolutely safe to say that
00:05:19 the white men or the the last group left that it's safe to hate i mean you absolutely can
00:05:25 or hate white men and it's almost seen as a virtue you know particularly by the liberal left now is
00:05:31 it's a badge of honor to support oppressed minorities and to to that to these people the
00:05:37 very notion that that's not the case by showing them data it kind of they can't compute that but
00:05:43 you see the odd thing about this martin so let's say you talked about your father there my father
00:05:47 was a manual worker too you know he was a driver he was a good boy right that's right exactly he
00:05:51 was he was a chauffeur um and uh his life he and your father are in in their terms they were more
00:05:59 privileged than the queen of england yeah because they were white males yeah and straight male what
00:06:05 was your attitude when you saw which we'll probably see a bit of actually the gillette
00:06:10 for example what what did you feel i had a very visceral feeling oh god no not again well um i was
00:06:16 invited onto the piers morgan show good morning britain to talk about it and my immediate reaction
00:06:21 was one of repulsion not by peers but by the advert although the jury's out on both but um
00:06:27 quite simply um what i hate about all this stuff and i believe by the way it's the worst advertising
00:06:33 campaign in my entire 25 years as a journalist it was despicable what it did was quite simply
00:06:39 um it took the worst actions of the worst men and somehow found this out to be the problem
00:06:46 of every man and if you're not actively doing something about this then you're a part of the
00:06:50 problem it didn't invite men to be a part of the solution it labeled all of us as part of the
00:06:55 problem and that's the trouble with identity politics it forces us to take sides now we can
00:07:00 all agree that ending sexual violence ending sexual harassment are things that are good
00:07:05 like none of us want there to be sexual harassment or rape but to to have a bunch of you know white
00:07:11 guys at a barbecue encouraging their sons to kind of beat other boys up i've literally never seen
00:07:17 that i've got two kids i've got my entire life it doesn't happen and the whole notion that that men
00:07:23 are groping women in boardrooms is like okay well i've spent many many years in boardrooms and i've
00:07:27 i'm not saying it doesn't exist because i haven't seen it but what i'm saying is if you take the
00:07:32 worst most toxic tropes of masculinity and make out that that's the whole morass of being a man
00:07:38 then you immediately as we saw you lose 90 of men they hated the advert in the most visceral way i've
00:07:45 ever seen do you actually know what's happened to that ad since i mean have they sort of withdrawn
00:07:49 it it's not been seen as a huge mistake or anything no so so okay so to be a conspiracy
00:07:55 theorist for a moment we could say um that the procter and gamble stable which is vastly products
00:08:03 bought by women because the those who rallied around the advert that its supporters were
00:08:08 media commentators of what they kind of have to because otherwise they'd be misogynists
00:08:11 and the creative industries and particularly women so they loved it and they have to stand
00:08:19 by their guns they made a huge political statement to withdraw it would be an admission that they
00:08:23 were wrong and then they would incur the wrath of the me too movement and the time's up movement
00:08:27 so they they had to stand by their guns but the the incidentally i do i do some work for for harry's
00:08:32 shaving brand and they enjoyed a huge upsurge in trade without doing anything people just
00:08:38 abandoned Gillette. And I think with good reason. I found myself actually in boots going and looking
00:08:44 in. It was Gillette, Gillette, Gillette, Gillette. And I was thinking I wanted to change, make some
00:08:48 kind of... You did actually a report for Harry's, didn't you? And that has some really quite
00:08:53 interesting results about what is important to men. Can you just take us through that? Sure.
00:08:59 So in 2017, I co-wrote with John Barry, who's the founder of the Male Psychology Network
00:09:05 from university college london the harris masculinity report and what we did there was
00:09:10 the opposite of gillette so rather than taking the worst bits and making out that's a problem
00:09:15 need to be fixed or men were broken and this had to be solved we asked men what gave them
00:09:20 contentment and well-being and we found some really wholesome and and quite beautiful things
00:09:27 because guess what men take greatest well-being from providing for others from having fulfilling
00:09:33 work through having loving partners you know of any sexuality the more committed you are the more
00:09:40 happy men are this is the opposite of what we hear that men somehow enjoy being sexual predators
00:09:45 and take fulfillment from that we also found that british men were going through a renaissance of
00:09:51 talking about their mental health conversations that have been led by pioneers such as prince
00:09:56 harry you know prince william professor green the rapper harry kane sportsmen like that who are being
00:10:03 open about it's okay to talk lads and so our attitude was listen to men um form a root map
00:10:09 of the happiest men and therefore say look this works for these guys perhaps you should try it
00:10:14 which is the opposite if you think about it of what Gillette were doing they were saying here's
00:10:19 the worst stuff don't be like this which men will never respond to because we're being hectored
00:10:23 I mean you obviously journalists many many years standing editor commentator the Gillette ad is
00:10:30 just one example it's been a drip drip drip thing hasn't it my perception is and it's not based on
00:10:35 any data is that just men are on the whole portrayed as being a bit dumb a bit stupid
00:10:40 would you say that's true in ads particularly in ads yeah so i remember i was part of the
00:10:45 advisory committee of the advertising standards association because they brought in new laws on
00:10:50 stereotypes of gender tropes in advertising interestingly and what got all the headlines
00:10:55 was the beach body ready adverts you know sadiq khan famously wanted that ripped off the cheese
00:11:00 because it body shamed women and there's a huge storm about that advert at the time but
00:11:04 when you actually looked at what people were complaining about in adverts as many people
00:11:08 were complaining about the the thick dad you know the crap dads who who spoil christmas by burning
00:11:14 all the food the guy who who can't even make a washing machine work despite the fact men invented
00:11:19 the internet and the washing machine itself you know it's those lazy tropes of men being
00:11:24 bumbling buffoons they got more complaints and actually a lot of the complaints were from women
00:11:31 you're not saying men aren't stupid like this but nevertheless it's a it's become safe pasture
00:11:37 to mock men like that you mentioned something about this before you know you said you know
00:11:41 what is sorted behind it but where would you say it really came from is it something you know
00:11:47 because there is this what there is this view you know maybe people on the right say this is all down
00:11:51 to to to feminism right this is like not liking men would you go along with that or not um i think
00:11:58 if we go downstream so we need to understand how people with these opinions formed those opinions
00:12:05 where did they learn this script and i think we have to solely lie the blame and at the foot of
00:12:11 academia so if you go into any university now you you try and find a conservative professor professor
00:12:17 answer you try and find anybody who who will even admit i think we've got one on the show soon
00:12:22 you try and find an academic who would even put their hand up in a room who admits admits the
00:12:28 voting brexit or you you get an academic to say hey do you think donald trump might have some good
00:12:33 ideas these these opinions are are suppressed on campus and um patriarchy theory you know which is
00:12:41 the the theory that society is structured for the benefit of men and the impression of women and men
00:12:47 are in control is it's a lie but it's taught as a fact at all of our universities now without
00:12:53 without sort of exception and so if you come through the ranks believing that that women are
00:12:59 oppressed and men are the oppressors is it any wonder that when those people move into our media
00:13:05 particularly at the BBC and and they start looking for stories that highlight their own worldview so
00:13:11 we're continually zoning in on the gender pay gap which anyone with half a brain knows
00:13:15 is provably untrue if you compare actual like for like work yet jumping on that theory to signal
00:13:23 boost it to prove what they've been taught therefore men are still oppressing um is the
00:13:28 absolute meat and drink of of the of the daily grind of the news cycle in the uk that came out
00:13:33 today and the the emergence of the the independence group is now being blamed on misogyny it's like
00:13:39 yeah they was it's not because they're anti-brex which they obviously are it's because they were
00:13:43 bullied online and were forced out you know most abusive politicians happens towards men
00:13:49 most misogyny online studies show is conducted by other women towards women yet we don't get that
00:13:57 that version of of the truth the actual truth we get the one-sided version and so we're so immersed
00:14:04 in this all the time that we believe it and and there's there's powerful reasons that we do believe
00:14:10 it and it comes from historically we had to convince ourselves that men were disposable
00:14:16 because they were often sent away to fight at wars and we rewarded them with with medals or
00:14:22 the badge of heroism they were disposable heroes we and we had to that helped us cope with with
00:14:28 that loss and interestingly last year the the 100th year of of the of getting the votes
00:14:35 universally. Every time I have a debate on television, I say, OK, so eight million women
00:14:42 got the vote. And I say, how many men got the vote at that day? And I met with silence. It was
00:14:47 five million. Five million men, working class men, like our fathers, you know, they wouldn't have
00:14:54 been able to vote. You know, 700,000 men died in World War I, and the huge majority of those men
00:15:00 would have never had the chance to vote in their lives. This is airbrushed out of history. It's
00:15:05 all about the suffrage movement overcoming the evil patriarchy in actual fact 700 000 men who
00:15:11 were conscripted without choice and died in the mud in the trenches their voices mattered too
00:15:16 yet we don't talk about them it's a classic example of how we've become immune to male
00:15:23 sufferance and i think it's terrible do you do you think your attitudes on these issues have they
00:15:31 how long have you been a journalist now 20 25 years 25 years have they kind of hardened have
00:15:38 they evolved since you started out absolutely yeah because you know back in the day you know
00:15:43 when we were on the lads mags you know ladism lad culture which by the way is talked about
00:15:48 on university campuses now with with more vitriol than than than isis you think i'm joking that the
00:15:53 head of the nus you know wouldn't come out and condemn isis but has a lad culture program to
00:16:00 deprogram men about drinking beer and singing rugby songs you know it's ridiculous um so back
00:16:05 in those days this didn't really exist i mean there were always party poopers who hated what
00:16:08 the lad movement stood for and serious arguments started to emerge about pornography and the
00:16:16 relationship between the lads mags and pornography pornography became in around about 2013 um the hot
00:16:21 potato of our time proof that men were becoming poisoned by porn and going out you made a program
00:16:27 I did. I made a program called Porn on the Brain for Channel 4. We spent six months
00:16:30 going around the world, talking to every expert, and we got 23 young lads who were watching serious
00:16:36 amounts of porn. They felt it was damaging their life chances, and we got them help. We put them
00:16:41 in a brain scan study at Cambridge University. But more than that, we really got inside their
00:16:45 lives, and we understood the true nature of this issue. And it was not that these men were going
00:16:50 out and becoming poisoned and committing crimes. It was that they were ruining their lives. It was
00:16:54 stopping them working was stopping them studying it was stopping them having healthy relationships
00:16:59 and so it was much more nuanced than the media script we were getting but like a lot of people
00:17:05 that got involved in in the men's issues movement if you like it was it was because of personal loss
00:17:10 you know i i suffered the loss of friends who took their own lives um too soon you know what
00:17:17 you mean to relate it actually to the use of porn or no no no so i'm talking about personal friends
00:17:23 who committed suicide and then i became really aware of of this new emergence of of male suicide
00:17:30 data and it sort of really profoundly moved me on a personal level to start getting involved in
00:17:36 in charity work and trying to find out if i could be a voice to do something about it and that's
00:17:41 when i started to run into resistance in terms of government so when i launched the men and boys
00:17:47 coalition in 2017 and coffee actually who's just defected to the independence group yeah she she
00:17:53 underwrote the um the the the meeting that was because she she'd had experience of boys being
00:18:00 groomed as drug traffickers in her constituency in stockport so when we when we got into parliament
00:18:06 and we were going right so so here's all the evidence now can we please have some action on
00:18:11 this that's when i started to realize that that politicians were kind of frozen in the headlights
00:18:15 and they all they were all saying behind closed doors this is this is really important but we
00:18:21 expect resistance and what do you mean how can you not help the we just laid out the evidence
00:18:27 that these men are suffering that they they need help and they need help and here's all of our
00:18:33 expert opinion which is showing they will benefit from a gendered approach a male specific solution
00:18:39 to a male specific problem which would seem logical right but you sort of you go back to
00:18:45 the porn bit again your your attitude to that did change didn't it i mean i think you've written
00:18:51 about it saying that you know you really now distance yourself from what you maybe once
00:18:56 thought about it yeah so so what happened so that that was a part of my personal journey where
00:19:00 towards the end of my tenureship of the editor of loaded um i started to look back um i became a
00:19:06 father um i left the magazine to become a stay-at-home dad so i went from like alpha male
00:19:11 to vomit covered buggy boy you know there's a real change and i started to write about that and
00:19:17 explore the changing way of being a man and part of that the major part was looking back at the
00:19:23 allegations i'd received um that my magazine was a was a part of this problem um it was like a
00:19:29 marijuana that was getting young lads into the heroin of misogynistic body punishing rape fantasy
00:19:35 porn were my fingerprints on that because the even more serious allegation was that this was
00:19:41 encouraging violence towards women which is something that I've sort of seen at first hand
00:19:45 within my family and deeply bothered me that I was being accused of being a part of this matrix I
00:19:50 wanted to find out the truth and I started to write about it which led to making the tv show
00:19:55 and I spoke with sexual psychologists criminologists who were treating some of the
00:20:02 most serious sexual offenders in the UK the addicts themselves and always I would ask at
00:20:08 the end of the filming did they mention the lads mags you know was this a part of it and they kind
00:20:13 of laughed at me like you're joking you know they're just going straight to hardcore porn on
00:20:16 the internet now so part of that journey was was a kind of exorcism um of my of my role when i go
00:20:23 into schools now i've delivered talks on on porn safeguarding to about 35 000 british teenagers
00:20:29 over the last four years and i always have a great sort of rapport with them because my my
00:20:36 slightly shady cv means they know i'm not like a vicar or a copper yeah so we can have you know
00:20:42 constructive conversations where we can encourage people to be more thoughtful about their their own
00:20:48 consumption so i do feel that i've if i was a small part of the problem then i'm helping to be
00:20:52 a part of the solution now would you agree with the there are more calls aren't there now for
00:20:57 porn uh to actually be as it were you can't get into without id or it's blocked and all the rest
00:21:04 it now anybody if we all know this any kid can look at it on their phone yeah so would you agree
00:21:10 with that sort of prohibition um no because it won't work so i was involved in that consultation
00:21:17 as well with baroness joanna shields who was david cameron's internet safety minister all those years
00:21:21 ago when when cameron wanted the internet service providers to make people opt in for porn one
00:21:28 company did that talk talk and they lost like 30 of their customers overnight because it's like do
00:21:33 want porn our phone sky our phone virgin so we saw straight away that wasn't going to work the
00:21:39 latest raft of proposals is to make any British consumer of porn wherever it comes from in the
00:21:46 world if you consume it in the UK you have to prove that you're over 18 either by a credit
00:21:52 card number well what kind of idiot will give their credit card number to a pornographer or a
00:21:56 mobile phone number because when you took that contract out you had to prove your and of course
00:22:00 there are loads of ways around that and you know every time i go into schools and talk about this
00:22:05 the kids just sit there sniggering because they know that within four seconds they can get around
00:22:10 these blocks and one kid will share that with the entire school but the parents and the politicians
00:22:15 meanwhile think this problem's been dealt with and it just hasn't a far more sensible solution
00:22:21 would be to do what our continental cousins do in holland where they start to have age
00:22:27 appropriate conversations about sexual conduct and intimacy from age six and the results of that
00:22:34 are the lowest teen pregnancies in in the whole of europe the highest age of first sexual contact
00:22:40 because guess what if you treat children like you know mature responsible individuals they will go
00:22:46 on to make mature responsible decisions but instead we have this no sex please with british
00:22:51 attitude which is completely out of kilter with the internet era and every child in britain knows
00:22:57 it's pointless why don't the politicians when it comes to schools because this part of your
00:23:02 campaign is the fact that boys are doing badly or not as well as girls at school it's been going
00:23:08 for some time now again you know this is from an outside point of view it seems to me that for
00:23:14 example when it comes to the state school system not the private one but the state
00:23:18 competition for example which is seen as a traditional masculine trait if you like to
00:23:24 be competitive that has been downgraded has it not is that am i way off beam there or is that
00:23:30 something you would recognize as being a problem i mean these are the things you're now campaigning
00:23:34 over aren't they so when we look specifically at the challenges faced by boys in british education
00:23:40 the moment boys start to fall behind was the moment the gcse went from exams to coursework
00:23:48 so boys typically perform better under pressure on exam day girls are more kind of attentive and
00:23:56 studious throughout the year and do coursework so straight away so since then it's been about
00:24:01 21 years of straight data and the gender gap by the way is is widening boys are falling behind
00:24:06 every year for every socio-economic background so white boys and white girls the boys do worse
00:24:12 black boys black girls the boys do worse and so on and so forth it's not an issue of poverty
00:24:16 it's an issue of gender related attitudes and how we teach and how we
00:24:22 mock so for example when we look to schemes in
00:24:26 America where they have attempted to recruit more role models more
00:24:30 more male teachers they've seen a great success
00:24:33 in throughput because of course many of the most problematic boys
00:24:36 in education are coming into school from problem backgrounds oftentimes they
00:24:42 haven't had a father in their lives or a strong
00:24:44 a positive male role model so they move into a school system where now we have like 90 of the
00:24:49 teaching community is is women back in my day and you probably recall yourself teachers were
00:24:57 former army men yeah yeah we can look back with misty eyes about the clip around the ear but we
00:25:02 certainly knew where we stood yes and if we didn't have a male role model at home we could damn sure
00:25:08 find one at school and we knew where the barriers were and we worked within those constraints we
00:25:13 are also allowed to compete at sport you know to run off the steam like a greyhound you know
00:25:19 there was a report out yesterday saying children need more exercise at school so 50% of schools
00:25:26 have less than 55 minutes breaks per day and we know from studies that boys in particular
00:25:33 need to burn off energy so when they go back into the classroom they are ready to learn give them a
00:25:39 breakfast in the morning i went to a school in milton keen's where they've there's on a on a
00:25:43 sort of council estate where they've had incredible results with boys because they they learned that
00:25:48 getting lads from the community who who became teachers who were also football coaches wow you're
00:25:54 great at football yeah now try some maths okay because they respect the guy there are lots of
00:25:58 really clever things that are working but back to a previous point there seems to be little will to
00:26:03 to enact them the thing is you see it seems to be you are dealing with the consequences yeah of all
00:26:09 of this you're trying to make that better right but ultimately it comes back doesn't it to you
00:26:14 talked about the academic world and how it's all flowed through from that the attitude to men
00:26:19 yeah how do we deal with that i know we're just about to wrap up but how the hell do you deal
00:26:25 with that i mean the source as it were how are we going to change that culture it's a huge problem
00:26:31 And make no mistake, a very well-armed, you know, machine doesn't want that to change.
00:26:39 What we, the only thing we can do is make evidence-based, compassionate pleas.
00:26:45 And, you know, I'm hoping after Brexit is dealt with, we might be able to go back to looking at some more specific policies.
00:26:52 If we could just get, you know, someone like Harry Kane, I interviewed Harry Kane a couple of days ago.
00:26:56 So, you know, Harry Kane is somebody who's talking about his mental health,
00:27:00 who's talking about, you know, how he fought back from adversity.
00:27:04 He was dropped by Arsenal when he was eight.
00:27:06 His father put his arm around him, beautiful, closed in, protected ranks,
00:27:11 and he went on to be, you know, he's now the world's most valuable,
00:27:14 second most valuable footballer.
00:27:16 It was about adversity and bouncing back and having positive,
00:27:20 supportive role models around you.
00:27:23 And that's what our boys so desperately need.
00:27:25 And that can come in many ways. It can come in people who go into schools and talk. It can come from celebrities, from footballers. It can come from fathers, uncles. But empowering men to be a part of that solution, rather than, as we said earlier with Gillette, treating men as some toxic, endemic part of the problem, that's the starting point. Until we have empathy for boys and men and their issues, we've got no chance.
00:27:48 perfect way to stop it actually martin thank you very very much for coming in and all the very best
00:27:54 with your campaign and the men and boys coalition's fantastic you're doing that uh that's it for uh so
00:28:00 what you're saying is this week do subscribe there is a little logo i'm told is here
00:28:05 which you can just click on and we'll see you next time thank you very much thank you