New Culture Forum - March 17, 2019


10. Rod Liddle - Brexit, BBC Bias & The Liberal Elite

9. James Delingpole: Right & Proud 11. Culture & Heritage: Losing Our Marbles

Episode Stats


Length

39 minutes

Words per minute

150.42

Word count

5,973

Sentence count

371


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 hello there and welcome to so what you're saying is i'm peter whittle now that rare thing or should
00:00:12 i say a unique thing is a journalist selling out the london palladium but that's what my
00:00:17 guests this week did rod liddle is associate editor of the spectator for whom he also writes
00:00:23 a column but he's also a columnist for the sunday times and for the sun and without wishing to
00:00:29 You embarrass him with too much flattery.
00:00:31 He is one of that very select group of journalists
00:00:34 for whom people actually buy the paper specifically to read.
00:00:38 He's with me.
00:00:39 Thanks very much for coming.
00:00:40 Very kindly.
00:00:40 Thank you very much.
00:00:41 You've been filming today, haven't you?
00:00:44 Yes.
00:00:45 But you're not in London anymore, isn't that right?
00:00:48 No, I don't live in London because I can't stand the place.
00:00:51 But I usually have to come in on a Thursday.
00:00:53 I do a film every week for the Sunday Times.
00:00:56 And politicians are usually in London,
00:00:58 and it's often interviewing politicians
00:00:59 but if we can get out of London a bit more
00:01:01 it's always better
00:01:02 and the people are nicer
00:01:03 but you say you can't stand it
00:01:05 because we actually grew up in roughly the same area
00:01:09 I mean I was a Shooters Hill, you and Abbey Wood
00:01:11 but I mean you're not
00:01:12 would you call yourself a Londoner by birth then?
00:01:15 not really
00:01:16 I mean my mum was from London
00:01:17 but from Bermondsey
00:01:21 which is how can I support Millwall really
00:01:24 and it's the first game I ever saw in my life
00:01:26 But most of my family, the vast majority of my family is from the north-east of England, Middlesbrough, Stockton, Bishop Auckland.
00:01:33 My dad's from there, and all my relatives are there.
00:01:36 And that's where it feels like home, to be honest.
00:01:40 But you said you can't stand a place.
00:01:42 Yeah.
00:01:42 I mean, why?
00:01:44 Oh, because of its mewing smugness, the idea that it feels itself above the rest of us, its sense of self-regard.
00:01:52 Also, you know, the fact that sometimes in various parts of London
00:01:57 I feel a foreigner myself walking through it
00:02:00 in much the same sort of racist way that Nigel Farage once said.
00:02:06 Because of its claustrophobia and because there's too many people
00:02:09 and I'm of a certain age and presumably tired of life.
00:02:14 It's not just a demographic thing, it's also an economic thing.
00:02:17 It's an economic thing.
00:02:18 I mean, if I lived in London, I would be in court for punching a hipster.
00:02:22 You know, it just would happen.
00:02:23 I'd be a member of class war, probably.
00:02:26 I've got friends who are in class war.
00:02:29 They are perpetually infuriated by the...
00:02:34 Because it seems to me that London,
00:02:38 which has an incredibly high regard for itself,
00:02:40 it always thinks of itself as being this wonderfully integrated place.
00:02:43 It's such diversity.
00:02:45 This is what we've got in London.
00:02:46 It's so diverse.
00:02:47 What you've actually got is virtually Dubai, a slave state, where there's an affluent white elite preying on the appalling wages of incoming service people from abroad.
00:03:04 I think it's a disgusting way to live.
00:03:07 But also it's a place now as well, if you are a Brexiteer, it's kind of a lonely place in some ways.
00:03:14 Well, it shouldn't be.
00:03:15 I mean, you say that, it's interesting.
00:03:16 I mean, more than one in three Londoners voted for Brexit.
00:03:22 And once you get beyond the people with their goatees
00:03:27 and their top knots out towards the green belt a little bit,
00:03:34 then it's very, very pro-Brexit.
00:03:36 People get the Brexit vote wrong.
00:03:40 They're too simplistic about it.
00:03:42 One in three Londoners, who'd have thought it?
00:03:44 Oh, yeah, it was much bigger.
00:03:45 I think that originally people thought it would be about something like 29%, something like that.
00:03:50 It was actually over 40% voted for Brexit in London.
00:03:53 Absolutely.
00:03:54 It's just that the feel of London and the people who set the tone could not be less Brexite.
00:03:59 That's right.
00:04:00 It's a liberal elite, which is one reason to be out of London.
00:04:02 I mean, you're absolutely right.
00:04:04 And I think London, that liberal elite of London,
00:04:07 was one of the reasons that Brexit was slowly strangled right from the start.
00:04:13 You see, when did this, I put it down in the past 20 years or so,
00:04:17 but it seems to me that, you know, London changing, you know,
00:04:22 you said earlier that 1972 might be quite good to be in London.
00:04:27 Interesting things, although economically things were,
00:04:29 there were lots of battles going on.
00:04:31 Pretty wrecked.
00:04:32 Yes, but at the same time, culturally things were more intact, were they not?
00:04:35 Well, it was a far more homogenous city, I think, at the time.
00:04:40 Whether that's good or bad is another issue.
00:04:41 I think if you live in London, most people like to live amongst people who are pretty much the same as them,
00:04:51 who have sort of the same shared values and so on.
00:04:54 And I think for an awful lot of Londoners that's changed, which is why we had, you know, around 1972,
00:05:01 and before then, I mean, my parents were part of it, which was a white flight to the suburbs.
00:05:06 So my lot got out to Bexley Heath.
00:05:08 and
00:05:10 had we been London
00:05:13 I think we'd have got out from
00:05:15 Bexley Heath to Chislehurst
00:05:17 and then out to Bromley and then out to
00:05:19 Deal until we could go
00:05:21 no further. Luckily
00:05:23 we're from the north so we just got
00:05:25 the hell out up to the A1
00:05:26 Very nice
00:05:29 You know
00:05:30 we're filming this right in the middle of what
00:05:33 seems to be a very surreal time
00:05:35 You've always been a staunch
00:05:37 Brexiteer.
00:05:41 Broadly speaking,
00:05:42 what's your reading of the current situation?
00:05:44 I mean, I think in the
00:05:46 long term, I suppose what I'm asking is
00:05:48 when you see all the things
00:05:50 that are happening at the moment,
00:05:51 what do you feel are going to be
00:05:54 the long-term effects of this whole
00:05:56 Brexit period
00:05:58 in England?
00:06:01 I mean, I think Brexit
00:06:02 it's a bit of a hostage to fortune, but I think
00:06:06 Brexit will not be allowed to happen in the form that anyone wished it to happen
00:06:10 for a succession of reasons, most of which can be boiled down
00:06:14 to the fact that there's a 2-1 majority against it in the House of Commons, pushing on 3-1.
00:06:20 There are nine, ten parties in the
00:06:22 House of Commons, of which nine are pro-remain
00:06:26 in the majority. The House of Lords
00:06:29 is pro-remain. Our broadcast media is pro-remain.
00:06:34 London is pro-Remain
00:06:37 it is
00:06:39 an inevitability
00:06:41 under those circumstances
00:06:43 what will come of it
00:06:44 I would like to think
00:06:46 is a realignment
00:06:48 of politics in Westminster
00:06:50 because I think what we've learned from Brexit
00:06:52 is that the divide which exists within society
00:06:55 isn't remotely
00:06:56 reflected by the divide
00:06:58 which is in Parliament
00:07:01 one of the most
00:07:03 hilarious things about the whole Brexit and Corbyn episode was the sudden formation of
00:07:09 a new party called the Independents, this group of originally seven, then eight Labour
00:07:14 defectors, and then I think it was four Conservatives, who formed this new party, characterised by
00:07:22 being pro-Remain, which all the other parties are, and characterised by being socially liberal,
00:07:29 which all the other parties are
00:07:31 save for the Democratic Unionist Party
00:07:32 perhaps, which has only 10 members
00:07:34 so you have this
00:07:37 vast edifice, the people we
00:07:39 vote for
00:07:40 who are
00:07:43 all socially liberal
00:07:44 a lot of them, a Conservative Party
00:07:47 when you look at
00:07:48 one of the stories which has been
00:07:51 inflaming people recently
00:07:53 is
00:07:53 the government's plans for sex education
00:07:57 in schools
00:07:58 which is telling kids
00:08:00 about same-sex
00:08:02 relationships and transgenderism
00:08:04 there's a
00:08:06 conservative government
00:08:07 it's a conservative government
00:08:09 and it's not
00:08:12 don't you think the Conservative Party
00:08:14 just simply threw in the towel
00:08:16 long ago on anything
00:08:18 what you might call socially conservative
00:08:20 completely
00:08:22 completely didn't understand even the culture
00:08:24 war if there is such a thing
00:08:26 That's right.
00:08:27 They don't understand the culture war.
00:08:28 And I think that if you do need a party in Parliament,
00:08:32 which to my mind is economically,
00:08:36 this is why I was never a huge fan of UKIP in many ways,
00:08:40 though I liked the anti-political correctness,
00:08:42 I liked the stance on Europe,
00:08:44 even though Brexit was actually a close call for me originally.
00:08:48 Really?
00:08:48 Yeah, yeah, yeah, quite a close call.
00:08:50 What were you juggling then?
00:08:52 Oh, juggling the notion of democracy and my liking for a nation-state
00:08:59 versus a genuine worry that some of the good stuff which the EU did,
00:09:09 which circumvented our parliament, and thus the five-year cycle of parliament,
00:09:13 such as funding for science and research
00:09:16 and equally funding for deprived areas.
00:09:23 You know, if I thought for a single minute
00:09:25 that 350 million quid a week was going to be spent
00:09:29 on the National Health Service as a consequence of Brexit
00:09:31 I'd probably have voted Remain.
00:09:33 You know, I mean, just why would you do that?
00:09:37 Even though I think it needs more money at the moment
00:09:40 but not that much more money.
00:09:42 So I had to juggle.
00:09:43 all that stuff. But it was nice waking up on June the 24th and seeing the result, feeling
00:09:52 a slight tremor of shock, then delight, looking at Dimbleby looking as if someone had shat
00:09:58 in his handbag, and feeling a bit nervous for a while, and then hearing the result from
00:10:05 Middlesbrough, 67%. I've done right by my own people. But I think if there is a divide
00:10:15 in the country, then I think someone like David Goodhart's probably got it right. And
00:10:20 this devolves from Brexit, of course. I came up with it at the same time as David, but
00:10:27 didn't do as much work on it I'd been at a at a at a reunion of my old comprehensive school in
00:10:35 Middlesbrough just south of Middlesbrough Gisbrough 40 years since we left and there were 100 of us
00:10:42 there which is a great turnout it was a very big school and I did a bit of amateur sociology it
00:10:48 It was two weeks after the referendum.
00:10:51 And almost to a man and woman,
00:10:57 everybody who had left Teesside and not come back was for remain.
00:11:04 Everyone who had stayed in Teesside was for leave.
00:11:09 And this was true even if the people who'd left Teesside to make their fortunes
00:11:13 had done very badly for themselves and were broke and had bad lives.
00:11:18 And it was true also back in Teesside that if they were very, very rich
00:11:22 and made their fortune, they were still for leave.
00:11:27 And David's book, which goes into it in brilliant detail.
00:11:31 It's the Anywheres and Somewheres.
00:11:32 It's Anywheres and Somewheres.
00:11:34 And I think if you are, like me, very, very much a somewhere,
00:11:39 I feel a sense of belonging.
00:11:40 So am I.
00:11:41 And I feel a sense of belonging to the nation state,
00:11:44 and I feel a sense of belonging to my area,
00:11:46 to a degree to my class, though that I suppose is arguable now,
00:11:53 but also to my family, that these things root us.
00:11:59 And there is no political party in Westminster, in the House of Commons,
00:12:05 which represents that point of view, which I think is desperately sad.
00:12:10 But don't you think as well, I'm speaking broadly here,
00:12:14 but if you like the Remain establishment, for want of a better expression,
00:12:19 it's not a question of not agreeing with, they just don't get these points.
00:12:23 No, they don't get that point.
00:12:25 But there's also an interesting demographic about it,
00:12:30 which is, as a lever, I would say roughly 50% of my friends are Remainers.
00:12:35 There's no problem with them.
00:12:38 We get on fine and we talk about it, and it's interesting.
00:12:41 but an awful lot of that remain vote was cast in a bubble in a way that the leave vote kind of
00:12:51 wasn't the leave vote was dispersed the remain vote was a corral of middle class i'm sure very
00:13:00 nice people in london in cambridge in oxford in bristol and who lived in that bubble it's like
00:13:09 the BBC. The BBC
00:13:11 does not think it's misrepresenting
00:13:13 Brexit. They
00:13:15 all think the same. There is not a
00:13:17 single one of them, you know, who
00:13:19 voted, who voted, well I say
00:13:21 not a single one of them. I've asked around, I
00:13:23 haven't found anyone who
00:13:25 currently works for it, who voted
00:13:27 Leave. Needle in a
00:13:29 haystack, I think.
00:13:30 But it's that bubble, you
00:13:33 know? That is why they don't get it,
00:13:35 why they don't understand it.
00:13:37 It's rather like that comment from Margaret Thatcher
00:13:39 You know, I do know poor people.
00:13:41 I saw one once or whatever it was.
00:13:43 I suppose that the reason I draw that conclusion
00:13:46 is if you look at the past two years
00:13:48 or the past two and a half years, whatever it is,
00:13:51 all of the debate we see on the media
00:13:53 seems to be almost entirely in economic terms.
00:13:57 Yeah.
00:13:57 I mean, sovereignty.
00:13:59 You mentioned the nation state.
00:14:01 Huge issue, isn't it?
00:14:02 The return of the nation state.
00:14:03 Huge thing.
00:14:05 And particularly, I would say, immigration.
00:14:07 That's almost been avoided, hasn't it, wouldn't you say, over the past two years?
00:14:11 Well, yes. I mean, immigration is another of those.
00:14:17 I mean, there are a whole bunch of subjects which the parties in Parliament will not touch.
00:14:22 Immigration is one of them.
00:14:23 There's this vague idea that we might reduce it at some point.
00:14:26 You know, 80% of our country wants immigration stopped.
00:14:31 You know? Stopped.
00:14:33 And thinks that untrambelled immigration has been bad for the country.
00:14:37 Poll after poll tells us this.
00:14:39 That's one of them.
00:14:39 Another one is, as I was talking about, the family.
00:14:43 You know, they want support for traditional families
00:14:45 and for people who do the right thing,
00:14:48 who, you know, save up before they have a kid,
00:14:50 don't go on welfare with nine children,
00:14:52 all that kind of stuff.
00:14:54 This kind of stuff which the Guardian and the BBC
00:14:57 would consider recidivist and reactionary,
00:15:00 but isn't actually.
00:15:01 It's communitarian.
00:15:03 It's doing what's good for the country.
00:15:05 And no, there is nothing in Parliament, not even the Conservative Party, which reflects that at all.
00:15:14 And you're right, I mean, on the economics issue, the economics of Brexit are important without question.
00:15:22 But you're right, all the other stuff gets left behind.
00:15:25 On immigration, the BBC, I mean, the BBC thinks immigration is a good thing and that's it.
00:15:31 There is no argument in the BBC about immigration.
00:15:35 I mean, as John Sartre, the former chief political editor of the BBC, said,
00:15:40 for decades the BBC ignored the issue, moved away from the issue, didn't deal with the issue.
00:15:46 I would go further and say that it was actually very, very pro-immigration all the way through.
00:15:52 I think it's completely... I mean, it's not just in the news, but in their extra news material, in their dramas or in their comedies.
00:16:01 Yes, it's even worse in the drama, in the comedy, in the panel shows.
00:16:08 But, I mean, you've written a huge amount about this particular topic, Rod.
00:16:11 I mean, what it strikes me is that it's not just a case of people being pro-migration in the BBC or whatever.
00:16:20 We are talking about, surely, historically unprecedented population movement.
00:16:26 Huge numbers.
00:16:28 It's never been like this in my lifetime or yours, I'm sure.
00:16:31 And it just seems that that is not, no one has come to grips with that,
00:16:36 or at least I say the majority of people have.
00:16:37 Because they can't, because they can't.
00:16:39 Because they have this, you know, I don't think the BBC is actually very left-wing bias.
00:16:45 I know some people do. I think it's liberal bias.
00:16:47 And it doesn't think it's a bias at all.
00:16:50 It thinks it's a civility.
00:16:53 It thinks it's a politeness and a decent way to behave.
00:16:56 So having come to the conclusion that immigration is a good thing
00:16:59 and so you will always have a shot of a worthy immigrant coming into the country,
00:17:08 having reached that conclusion, they then can't say,
00:17:11 well, no, but we ought to stop at 20,000 a year.
00:17:14 It should be whoever.
00:17:15 They can't make that leap.
00:17:18 Well, it's like London.
00:17:18 You sort of think London is now what they call super diverse.
00:17:21 you sort of think
00:17:23 what is the end result
00:17:26 when will you be happy
00:17:27 I think it's like London's now
00:17:30 45% white British or something
00:17:32 when actually will you be
00:17:34 I think
00:17:36 white British are a minority
00:17:38 in the majority of London
00:17:40 boroughs
00:17:41 it's a good one
00:17:43 it's a good one this
00:17:44 I've seen loads of studies
00:17:48 done
00:17:50 It's incredible how they get away with this,
00:17:52 and they're always reported by the BBC and by the liberal press,
00:17:55 which shows that districts which are high in immigration
00:18:00 tend to be in favour of immigration,
00:18:06 and districts which are low in immigration tend to be anti-immigration.
00:18:09 And the conclusion they draw from that is that actually
00:18:11 when the immigrants are coming, everything gets on bloody marvellously.
00:18:15 What they fail to say when they're doing these studies in Newham Tower Hamlets and Camden is that 50% of the people they're asking if they're in favour of immigration are immigrants.
00:18:36 I mean, how can they not, as a social scientist, you know, which was my background, don't they see?
00:18:45 Yes, yes.
00:18:46 Well, they don't want to see.
00:18:47 It's bizarre.
00:18:51 So immigration's a problem, you know.
00:18:53 And immigration's a problem in two or three ways.
00:18:56 I can see why a Conservative Party would be in favour of a constant stream of low-paid workers coming in the country to boost the economy, which it does.
00:19:06 boost the economy briefly, why a left-wing party would agree to it,
00:19:11 I cannot remotely understand its exploitation.
00:19:16 But anyway, sorry, go on.
00:19:17 No, before we just leave the EU point, two things, though.
00:19:20 The immigration comes into it, actually.
00:19:23 When you're talking about the long-term consequences of Brexit,
00:19:28 I think, and I don't know what you think about this,
00:19:30 it seems to me that the big difference now
00:19:33 is that millions of people now know
00:19:37 what the establishment think of them
00:19:38 in a way that they might have suspected before,
00:19:42 but they didn't really.
00:19:43 Now they know, because they're worried about migration,
00:19:46 they're racist, they're bigoted,
00:19:48 particularly the stupid, uneducated, all these things.
00:19:51 They now know they're armed with that knowledge.
00:19:53 Now, that surely is going to have a political effect
00:19:56 somewhere along the line, is it or not?
00:19:58 Wish it did. I have my doubts.
00:20:00 I have my doubts
00:20:03 I think what it means
00:20:04 I think what it will lead to
00:20:06 is a further corrosive
00:20:08 winnowing away of
00:20:10 respect and involvement
00:20:12 in democracy
00:20:14 I think it will be
00:20:17 a sullen retreat
00:20:18 and the animus against the
00:20:23 politicians will increase
00:20:24 but I don't see
00:20:27 anything more profound than that
00:20:28 Unless a new party comes along, which challenges that.
00:20:32 Well, a lot of people would say they're politically homeless right now.
00:20:37 You were Labour for, what, 40 years?
00:20:39 Nearly 40, 39.
00:20:41 But you've just, in your column this week in Spatow,
00:20:44 you've been talking about joining a new party.
00:20:47 Why that one? Why the social, the SDP?
00:20:51 The SDP, yeah.
00:20:52 Well, it's a terrible thing to think that if this had been me in 1985...
00:20:58 Oh, we can all say that.
00:20:59 Yeah, but good Lord.
00:21:01 I can remember when the SDP began in 81
00:21:04 and loathing David Owen so much
00:21:08 that as a junior journalist,
00:21:09 I interviewed him with a giant trout
00:21:11 with a pen sticking out the end
00:21:13 just so that he looked stupid.
00:21:16 I couldn't bear them.
00:21:17 Obviously, I thought it was treacherous
00:21:19 to the Labour Party at the time.
00:21:22 And I'd not given them much thought
00:21:24 until a year or so ago.
00:21:25 and particularly six months ago
00:21:28 when I read
00:21:29 what their policies were
00:21:31 and they are bang on
00:21:34 I shall give you
00:21:36 I shall give you some policies
00:21:37 thank you
00:21:38 new declaration
00:21:43 you'd like it
00:21:44 basically it's what I was looking for
00:21:47 and I feel more at home in this party
00:21:49 certainly I didn't feel at home in the Labour Party
00:21:51 for the last 15 years
00:21:53 I mean, I didn't feel very much at home under Tony Blair, as Blue Labour, which is always what I was a part of,
00:22:00 as one Blue Labour guy said to me about Jeremy Corbyn and Tony Blair, you know, two cheeks of the same liberal arsehole.
00:22:09 The SDP isn't liberal, but it is economically centre-leftish, redistributive a little,
00:22:16 social market
00:22:17 in favour of a bit of capital
00:22:20 expenditure
00:22:20 but it's very, very pro-family
00:22:24 pro-state, pro-community
00:22:25 in a way that
00:22:27 the other parties simply are not
00:22:30 it resists
00:22:31 this sort of blanket liberalism
00:22:34 which has been
00:22:35 sprayed upon us
00:22:37 Will you actually
00:22:38 Will you actually become
00:22:41 active, would you ever
00:22:44 stand for anything?
00:22:45 No, I don't think I'd stand, because I think I'd bring discredit upon them.
00:22:50 I think it would be iniquitous for me to stand.
00:22:55 But I'll go out leafleting and speak, happily do that,
00:22:59 and it's lovely to be involved again.
00:23:01 And it's a good party.
00:23:02 I mean, you can understand how it's got into a position
00:23:07 where it doesn't like liberalism.
00:23:09 If you look back to 1986-7, and the people who wanted to ally themselves with the Liberal Party became the Liberal Democrats, the rest remained.
00:23:21 They wanted nothing to do with them.
00:23:24 And it's staunchly pro-Brexit.
00:23:29 As I say, the nation-state, which you wouldn't find that kind of statement in the manifesto of other political parties,
00:23:36 apart from you probably on the nation state
00:23:37 and particularly
00:23:41 it's
00:23:42 it's loathing of the
00:23:45 intersectional victimhoods
00:23:47 which increasingly
00:23:49 the Conservatives, Lib Dems and Labour
00:23:51 all buy into, they buy into this crap
00:23:54 I want you to talk about that
00:23:55 just a little bit later if we can
00:23:57 while we're on
00:23:59 the political issue particularly here
00:24:01 you wrote recently that
00:24:03 the Liberal class
00:24:05 would do everything they could to thwart Brexit.
00:24:08 I think that's obviously quite clear.
00:24:10 But you also added the phrase,
00:24:11 it's their final victory before they're expunged.
00:24:15 That's probably wishful thinking.
00:24:17 I was interested in that,
00:24:18 because there is this kind of idea of the stinging,
00:24:21 the bee, the sting of the bee that then dies.
00:24:23 Well, yes, if only it were that simple.
00:24:26 I don't think it is.
00:24:28 But what I mean is,
00:24:29 and I've been saying this for a couple of years,
00:24:30 I think cultural paradigms take a long time to turn round.
00:24:35 And cultural elites take a long time to change.
00:24:39 But I think we've seen in the USA and in Europe,
00:24:43 and increasingly with the rise of UKIP,
00:24:46 maybe with the rise of the SDP,
00:24:49 though it hasn't risen much yet,
00:24:51 but a real, real acid reflux against this liberalism,
00:24:59 which in Britain was expressed brilliantly by Brexit.
00:25:02 Brexit is one of those symptoms of a disquiet of the liberal elite.
00:25:08 And I think it's on the run throughout Europe,
00:25:09 and the election results throughout Europe.
00:25:12 You see the liberal parties are down like that.
00:25:15 And the populists, whether they be of the left or the right,
00:25:18 and I have quite a bit of time for Syriza, you know,
00:25:21 and for Five Star,
00:25:25 and those populists are on the rise everywhere.
00:25:28 So I think the paradigm is changing.
00:25:29 It just takes so long to change.
00:25:32 It's hard to think, but, you know, 40 years ago, 45 years ago,
00:25:38 our elite was conservative, and I hated that just as much.
00:25:44 It was authoritarianly conservative.
00:25:46 The judiciary, the police, the media, the BBC was a conservative media.
00:25:54 The BBC, don't you think, in this past couple of years,
00:25:58 having played ball roughly maybe during the referendum campaign,
00:26:02 They really have been undisguised, haven't they, in the past?
00:26:05 Their attitudes have been absolutely undisguised.
00:26:08 Absolutely undisguised.
00:26:11 And you can count it up.
00:26:15 The Institute for Economic Affairs did a study of Question Time.
00:26:20 And it showed that...
00:26:22 So this is the main issue before the public is Brexit
00:26:26 and has been for two years, two and a half years.
00:26:28 Question Time is the BBC's main political current affairs
00:26:32 programme, and
00:26:34 the guests on it have
00:26:36 been 67%
00:26:38 remain.
00:26:40 Why?
00:26:42 I mean, there is some get-out
00:26:44 for the BBC, for Question Time,
00:26:47 which is
00:26:48 that the poor bastards have to balance
00:26:50 so many other things. They have to have
00:26:52 representation, equal representation,
00:26:54 roughly across the series from within the House
00:26:56 of Commons, given that the House of Commons
00:26:58 is 60-30.
00:26:59 so difficult they also have to have uh uh equal representation of women ethnic minorities
00:27:07 uh uh gay etc so they have all these other things to try and balance out uh before they get round to
00:27:16 the big issue of brexit but still you know yeah no it's it's been undisguised and uh the most
00:27:24 hilarious thing of all of it is
00:27:26 the BBC's fact checker
00:27:28 or reality checker, Chris Morris
00:27:30 so you will have
00:27:32 a debate about Brexit
00:27:33 between a Brexiteer and a
00:27:36 Remainer and Chris Morris will come on
00:27:38 and say the Remainer was right
00:27:39 thank you
00:27:42 thank you, as if Chris
00:27:44 Morris, you know this
00:27:46 bloke, is the sole repository
00:27:48 of truth in the known universe
00:27:49 we must go to our reality checker
00:27:52 Chris Morris, yes
00:27:54 Yeah, you know, it's infantile and egregious bollocks, isn't it?
00:27:59 Well, one of our, in fact, our first guest on this show was Robin Akin.
00:28:03 He called you the best editor he'd worked with when you were at the Today programme.
00:28:10 Very lovely man.
00:28:10 He's a lovely bloke.
00:28:11 He's written books about BBC bias or whatever.
00:28:13 It's not just, though, is it, about the news?
00:28:16 You were very much, you know, the Today programme at the forefront of the news.
00:28:20 But it's not really just about news with the BBC output, is it?
00:28:24 No, no. Brexit aside, where the news has been egregious, I mean, the news coverage has just been unrelenting bias.
00:28:36 But Brexit aside, at least politically, the programmes are watched by the powers that be to make sure they give equal time to various people.
00:28:46 it's beyond there, it's in the dramas
00:28:50 it's in the panel shows and the comedy shows
00:28:54 even the food programme
00:28:57 you will find it everywhere
00:29:00 even Doctor Fucking Who
00:29:03 they had, you know
00:29:07 there was one, my daughter stopped watching it
00:29:10 because she said, I just want to see some aliens
00:29:14 I just want to see a Dalek come on and kill someone
00:29:20 I don't want to lecture about how lovely it is
00:29:24 that a Muslim guy can marry a Hindu girl
00:29:27 and they're both peaceable and wonderful
00:29:30 just fuck off
00:29:32 just give us the programmes we want
00:29:35 without this constant drip of propaganda
00:29:39 do you think this is
00:29:40 it seems to me that over the past few years
00:29:43 this is kind of throughout broadcasting media now.
00:29:47 The difference, of course, is BBC, we have to pay for it,
00:29:49 or the threat of jail, etc.
00:29:51 But Sky, ITV, certainly Channel 4 News,
00:29:55 they pretty much seem to be cut from the same cloth now.
00:29:59 Yes, that's right. The broadcast media is.
00:30:01 I know this sounds...
00:30:02 You were very active in left-wing politics in the 70s,
00:30:07 and weren't you, in the 80s, presumably?
00:30:09 Yes.
00:30:09 Socialist Workers' Party, I think, and all the rest of it.
00:30:11 For nine months. Give me a break.
00:30:13 It was great fun.
00:30:14 No, but the reason I'm asking is, you know,
00:30:17 we talk a lot about the long march through the institutions,
00:30:20 which I include in that, the media.
00:30:22 Of course, yeah.
00:30:24 Did you have any sense of that happening then?
00:30:26 No, 80s.
00:30:28 80s?
00:30:29 The 80s.
00:30:31 Around about the time the Commission for Racial Equality
00:30:33 told journalists that Chinese people should be regarded as black.
00:30:37 Right.
00:30:37 I think that was my first...
00:30:39 No, it was definitely the 80s.
00:30:41 The 80s was a time when those two things came together, two very, very individualistic philosophies.
00:30:49 One was the Chicago School of Economics, which, of course, Thatcher and Reagan both embraced, Friedman and Hayek,
00:31:01 and this feeling that there should be no restraints on the individual and his ability to spend.
00:31:09 the state should butt out
00:31:12 the devil takes the hindmost
00:31:14 which is a very coarse way of describing Chicago
00:31:17 but very individualistic
00:31:18 and the Frankfurt School
00:31:20 which whilst supposedly from the left
00:31:24 was pretty much the same thing
00:31:26 you look at Marcuse
00:31:27 it's do your own thing
00:31:32 it's the 60s spirit of
00:31:34 abolished bourgeois constructs
00:31:37 such as family, marriage and so on
00:31:39 do your own thing
00:31:39 and march through the institutions, take over the institutions.
00:31:43 And it's very compelling.
00:31:45 It's very compelling if you're in these organisations.
00:31:48 It's a very nice thing to think, but it's catastrophic.
00:31:52 But do you think, therefore, was it random or was this actually quite deliberate?
00:31:58 I mean, I don't mean people sat in a room and planned,
00:32:00 but the idea that actually you should hollow the culture from the outside,
00:32:06 from the inside out, you know, that you should...
00:32:08 You're not going to get people on the streets, as it were,
00:32:10 so you go into the cultural institutions.
00:32:12 I think it probably was in the case of people like Danny Cohn-Bendit
00:32:18 and some of the other 1968 troublemakers,
00:32:23 and certainly in the case of Marcuse and Habermas
00:32:25 and all those deadly Marxist boars.
00:32:29 I don't think most of it was there.
00:32:31 I think cultures change and cultural elites change.
00:32:36 You know, I can remember working in the House of Commons
00:32:41 in the early 80s for the Labour Party,
00:32:43 writing speeches for the front bench
00:32:46 and saying we ought to do something for the teachers
00:32:49 because badly paid, having had a pay rise for ages.
00:32:55 And I was told by a Shutter Covenant member,
00:32:58 we're not doing anything for those cunts, they're all Tories.
00:33:03 And it's funny to think back.
00:33:04 This is 1983. They were all Tories. They voted Tory.
00:33:08 You know, the establishment until the middle of the 80s was in the hands of the right.
00:33:13 It's now in the hands of the left, of the liberal left.
00:33:16 It'll change.
00:33:17 But you see, you're talking about teachers there being called Tories or whatever.
00:33:22 This is one area now where it is so completely different.
00:33:26 I don't know how to deal with teaching. I just do not know what to do.
00:33:28 You wrote about it recently. The reason I mention it is that we had someone a few weeks ago on the programme,
00:33:34 James Bartholomew, and he was home teaching his sort of...
00:33:38 You took exception to that at one point.
00:33:41 I took the piss a little bit, yes.
00:33:43 But then you came back saying, actually, I understand why.
00:33:46 What had changed your mind?
00:33:50 My daughter's at a state school, a good one,
00:33:53 a grammar school, past the 11 plus.
00:33:54 The propaganda is continuous, authoritarian, absolutist,
00:34:04 and crosses every subject, apart from the sciences.
00:34:08 It's just, it's everywhere.
00:34:10 I mean, I'm well aware, you know,
00:34:12 that geography is now the provisional wing of Marxist sociology.
00:34:15 Oh, yeah.
00:34:17 But history, it's the same.
00:34:19 English, you know, it's in every single subject.
00:34:25 And if they try to query it, they get docked points.
00:34:29 It's so intolerant.
00:34:31 this is sort of like now going across most all fields it's not it's not just educate it's
00:34:36 charities it's the lot isn't it everything along with identity politics along with all of this
00:34:41 and i mean do you think as well a bit like we were talking about the liberals being if you like the
00:34:48 being expunged at some point is this some kind of final flourish of theirs or is this really now
00:34:55 kind of are they've got the wind in their sails now do you think these people because it seems
00:35:00 No, truth be told, I think that we've reached peak wank, if I can put it like that.
00:35:12 And I think the subject which, the issue which I think it's beginning to turn on is transgenderism.
00:35:23 Now, it's a good one because there are, as Julie Birchall once put it, these screaming me-me's and bedwetters.
00:35:32 They're shrieking about things, shrieking for the right to be thought of that their current gender is as authentic as the one they were assigned to at birth.
00:35:44 No, it isn't. You are not women.
00:35:49 You know, that's what science says.
00:35:52 and fortunately on that issue
00:35:54 you have
00:35:55 a coalition
00:35:57 which says this is bollocks
00:36:00 you have Peter Tatchell
00:36:02 you have the radical feminists
00:36:04 the TERFs as they're now called
00:36:06 and you have people who
00:36:08 have never gone along
00:36:10 with this shrieking
00:36:12 victimhood
00:36:13 of any of the intersectional
00:36:16 Julie Burshaw
00:36:17 Julie Bindle is another one
00:36:19 Julie Bindle is another one
00:36:21 Yeah, I mean, Jermaine Greer.
00:36:23 Yeah, yeah.
00:36:24 They're sort of eating their own, as it were, aren't they?
00:36:27 Yeah, they are.
00:36:29 But I think...
00:36:31 I think that that is one of the subjects where...
00:36:37 Because the government swallowed it whole.
00:36:39 Yeah.
00:36:40 The government goes along with it all.
00:36:43 So do the universities, so does the BBC, etc.
00:36:46 But people don't.
00:36:48 and more and more often
00:36:51 I'm beginning to hear
00:36:53 the other side of the argument
00:36:55 being put in a way which doesn't happen
00:36:57 for example on immigration
00:36:59 and various other subjects
00:37:00 that suddenly people are saying
00:37:01 well actually
00:37:02 this might mean an end to women's sport
00:37:05 yes exactly
00:37:06 actually what is going on
00:37:09 at the bloody Tavistock clinic
00:37:10 what the hell
00:37:12 and I think that is the one where
00:37:14 where the shibboleths and the victimhood stuff will be defeated.
00:37:23 And I think once you've defeated one of them,
00:37:26 then we can start picking away at the rest.
00:37:29 We've got to, you know, wind up now,
00:37:33 because I know you've got to get off and everything.
00:37:35 It's lovely to talk to you.
00:37:36 I just want to ask you...
00:37:37 Lovely to talk to you.
00:37:38 It's a big question, but it's actually...
00:37:40 If you talk, we've reached peak wank on that issue.
00:37:43 I hope that phrase gets picked up.
00:37:45 Oh, so do I.
00:37:46 But thank you.
00:37:48 But I think the thing is really is,
00:37:51 if you think back to when you started out as a journalist
00:37:54 and to now,
00:37:57 are you broadly more optimistic
00:38:01 or more pessimistic for us as a culture, if you like?
00:38:05 Oh, less pessimistic.
00:38:06 Far, far, far more pessimistic.
00:38:08 You're far more?
00:38:08 Yeah, yeah.
00:38:10 Right.
00:38:11 Yeah, it's not the culture which I grew up in.
00:38:13 No.
00:38:13 not remotely.
00:38:17 And I think some of that's a natural consequence of globalism.
00:38:23 But I think we need a party such as the Social Democratic Party,
00:38:27 which has a few answers to globalism
00:38:30 and how to preserve culture within this globalised economy.
00:38:37 But do you think that political parties desire from it?
00:38:41 Do you think that there is the will?
00:38:42 this is the thing, it's like in Douglas Murray's book
00:38:45 is there the will
00:38:47 if you like, to
00:38:48 preserve our culture
00:38:50 or do you think that
00:38:52 we sort of have lost faith in what we are
00:38:55 I think probably
00:38:57 in 19, when I started out as a journalist
00:38:59 1979, 1980
00:39:00 I think probably
00:39:03 three quarters
00:39:05 of the country would have
00:39:07 called themselves somewheres
00:39:09 yeah, yeah, yeah
00:39:10 I think today it's probably, well, 51.8%.
00:39:16 So I think it's far more difficult now.
00:39:21 Well, on that note, beautifully, Port.
00:39:23 Thank you very much indeed for coming in.
00:39:25 Pleasure. Enjoyed it.
00:39:26 Yeah, great. Thank you very much.
00:39:27 Cheers, mate.
00:39:27 Thanks very much for watching.
00:39:29 So what you're saying is, if you enjoyed it, please do subscribe.
00:39:34 This thing should be appearing here.
00:39:36 Just tap on that and you subscribe to the channel.
00:39:39 I look forward to seeing you next time. Thank you.