New Culture Forum - March 25, 2019


11. Culture & Heritage: Losing Our Marbles

10. Rod Liddle - Brexit, BBC Bias & The Liberal Elite 12. Richard Tice - Rallying For Brexit

Episode Stats


Length

30 minutes

Words per minute

170.22

Word count

5,122

Sentence count

101


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Hello, welcome to So What You're Saying Is, I'm Peter Whittle.
00:00:08 Now, culture, it's said, is upstream of politics, but sometimes now it seems that we are at war
00:00:15 with our own cultural history. Or indeed, have we actually lost faith in it? If this is the case,
00:00:23 then how is that reflected in our everyday cultural life and indeed in cultural policy?
00:00:28 Now, with me to discuss this is Tiffany Jenkins.
00:00:31 She is a commentator, academic and writer and author of a highly acclaimed book called Keeping Their Marbles,
00:00:38 how the treasures of the past ended up in museums and why they should stay there.
00:00:44 She's with me now. I'm very pleased that you've come, Tiffany. Thank you very much.
00:00:49 With the book, which came out a few years ago, you were arguing, basically, that against the tide, isn't that right?
00:00:57 what museums particularly you know we're doing in the sense that you're basically
00:01:02 you're saying that we shouldn't feel worried about where the various items
00:01:06 have come from is that right? I wanted to take a position which is artifacts on
00:01:12 the whole should remain where they are not fixed in stone but they shouldn't be
00:01:16 returned to their origins automatically which is the kind of the contemporary
00:01:23 feeling if you like but I also wanted to take a step back and say why it's very
00:01:27 easy in these debates to become really entrenched and to take position and then
00:01:33 just rant at each other you don't persuade anybody so I wanted to look at
00:01:37 why it was why it had come to be the case that in the last 30 years museums
00:01:42 which are you know they've always been a little bit political but they have
00:01:47 become intensely politicized and they become like the place where people are
00:01:51 advocating for social change the repatriation of artifacts should go back
00:01:56 because of the sense of colonization and because what it can do for communities
00:01:59 today and I wanted to ask why museums you know why not why not Parliament why
00:02:04 not the public square why museums what was it about them we'll see what was the
00:02:08 effect of your book I mean it has there been any kind of change or I mean I know
00:02:13 it's hard really to measure but do you think it's affected the way they think
00:02:17 about these things? I think for a small time it opened up a space of
00:02:21 conversation and I think that's really important so I don't know if I changed
00:02:26 anybody's mind who was in you know who was a repatriation advocate if you like
00:02:32 but I wanted to say this is why I think what I think this is where my thinking
00:02:38 came from and just to kind of unpick things and unlock things and I think
00:02:42 that's something we really need today particularly in culture where it's just
00:02:46 become so it's become a war yeah and I just you know let's get off the
00:02:50 battleground and get around a table and talk talk to each other right why we
00:02:54 think what we think but I mean most people I think would know all about the
00:02:57 Elgin marbles right it's been going on for years and they wouldn't even
00:03:00 necessarily think of it in terms of sort of cultural guilt or anything like that
00:03:05 it just seemed oh well maybe they should have them maybe they shouldn't can you
00:03:08 give us some other examples of I'm thinking maybe the begging
00:03:13 bronzes for example you know where this has been the basis of it that essentially you know guilt
00:03:21 about imperialism maybe what other examples have there been i think i'll talk about the
00:03:26 bell and bronzes in a minute but i first became interested in it when there was a big debate over
00:03:31 human remains the museum collection so lots of museums natural history museum for example has
00:03:36 an extensive collection of human remains mainly for research so it's not on display but places
00:03:41 like the Pitt Rivers Museum in Oxford does have Shrungan heads on display and they're
00:03:46 less for research, active research. But in the 90s and in early 2000 they became the
00:03:53 focus of claims making for the return to Aboriginal communities and Native American communities
00:04:00 in states, Australia and Canada and New Zealand. And then a little bit more recently in Britain.
00:04:07 And many did go back, and they went back to communities of origin, which are quite loosely
00:04:13 defined on the basis that the circumstances in which they were acquired were under settler
00:04:20 society.
00:04:21 In many cases, the legacy of those settler societies was that cultures were almost wiped
00:04:27 out.
00:04:28 So very serious events in history.
00:04:30 But what struck me about it was that sometimes the people who were calling for it most vociferously
00:04:36 were not communities outside the institution but they were within the institution so you
00:04:41 had museums that previously would not have let anything go you know everything was under lock
00:04:45 and key they many curators were officially called keepers you know because they were to keep this
00:04:51 stuff but they were very keen to repatriate and they were very keen and i was struck i thought
00:04:57 that was a significant departure in what museums used to stand for sort of enlightenment values
00:05:02 Benham bronzes are much more recently the focus of controversy,
00:05:07 and I think the last year you've seen President Macron call for items taken in that period,
00:05:15 so in Africa, under the kind of carve-up of Africa.
00:05:20 So the benham bronzes that are in the British Museum
00:05:22 were taken under a unitive expedition by the British in the late 19th century.
00:05:28 and they are very there are very few in Nigeria modern-day Nigeria so I think for me there would
00:05:35 be a case for returning some to Nigeria because there are very very few and there are many in
00:05:41 European collections but that is for me it's kind of the question is where does the object
00:05:46 where is best for the object not where is best for politics and I think politics is very much
00:05:53 I mean, it's very convenient for President Macron himself not doing so well at home
00:05:58 to prance about on the world stage an almost virtue signal, and this is his case.
00:06:04 And I think objects can kind of get lost in that.
00:06:08 They become kind of burdened by political expectations.
00:06:12 So this is an entirely Western thing, is it?
00:06:15 Does it affect purely Western museums and institutions?
00:06:20 In the form that I'm talking about.
00:06:23 So culture has always been taken and demanded back.
00:06:28 So the Romans, for example, were great looters.
00:06:32 And I don't mean that in an approving way.
00:06:33 They were extensive looters.
00:06:35 And it was a way to show off, you know, we not only have dominated you, we have got your culture.
00:06:41 And many leaders followed in those footsteps, including Napoleon.
00:06:46 There was a little ditty in Paris where they used to sing,
00:06:52 Rome is no longer in Rome, it's all in Paris.
00:06:55 So that was the path of the course.
00:06:57 I'm not saying it's a good thing, but that was the path of the course for centuries.
00:07:03 And so the 20th century, that began to change.
00:07:07 And what's interesting is that in the last sort of 30 to 40 years,
00:07:12 years the idea that museums could do something positive with this material
00:07:18 and could show the world to the world if you like has become something they're
00:07:22 more much more uncomfortable about and I think this is as much about Western
00:07:26 institutions feeling unsure of their purpose and trying to find something
00:07:31 positive in their view to do that they mean that means that they are then very
00:07:36 they are very very open to requests and arguments for return so they're as much
00:07:43 part of it as they are I mean you know in some cases in the States thinking
00:07:48 about the human remains example they had quite a difficult time interesting
00:07:54 making communities interested in receiving human remains for return yeah
00:07:58 there's a case of Ted Carpenter Smithsonian's anthropologist who's
00:08:02 really keen to repatriate um and this very much came i think from anthropology some of this
00:08:08 thinking very very keen to repatriate to an eskimo community and he goes and then he's very candid
00:08:14 about this they take he takes these bones and the community then says well yeah okay um if you want
00:08:23 but this is not something that is really of concern to us yes um it has become so for for
00:08:29 many but no it's certainly it's as much from about the institution trying to if you like
00:08:33 reposition itself well this is what reposition itself i mean you've written about uh the
00:08:39 politicization of museums you highlight particularly for example museums of migration
00:08:46 which have been popping up you know various different places um this really isn't surely the
00:08:52 point and function of a museum is it to make political points i mean you know i i i feel
00:08:58 feel just as a layman going quite often I and I sort of think no this is just because you know
00:09:03 it's at the forefront of my mind all the time but I often find that I'm being told things in a
00:09:08 particular way with the immigration museums what is I mean basically they are there are they not to
00:09:15 show why immigration has always been a very good thing is is that fair to say do you think in your
00:09:21 restoration? I think museums have, if you look at museums in their heyday, it was, they did give
00:09:28 expression to the nation state. There was a flurry of national museums as the nation state
00:09:35 rose, and even the British Museum, although it had nothing from Britain within it, it was very
00:09:42 much a kind of surveyor of other cultures. So museums have expressed the political currency
00:09:48 and values of the time.
00:09:51 I think today, though, they're being,
00:09:54 in a way, they expressed something,
00:09:57 whereas today they're almost being asked to cause something.
00:09:59 So the relationship has changed.
00:10:03 Also, just thinking about the Victorian period
00:10:05 when there was a flurry of museum building
00:10:07 with the express purpose to kind of uplift local people,
00:10:12 you know, White Chapel being built
00:10:14 in an extraordinarily poverty-stricken area of London
00:10:19 was the idea of the Barnetts was to uplift people.
00:10:25 So there is a kind of, there is a politics there,
00:10:27 but I think they sort of thought that people could be uplifted away
00:10:30 from their everyday life.
00:10:31 That's sort of surely a good ambition, isn't it?
00:10:34 I think so, yeah, whereas I think now it's much more reflect,
00:10:37 let's reflect your life rather than take you somewhere else.
00:10:40 So the idea that you could be transformed, I think,
00:10:43 has sort of vanished you mentioned migration museums I mean some museums can do things that
00:10:51 are interesting and explore interesting ideas I mean it's not necessarily political but the
00:10:56 welcome collection looks at the body and the heart looks at ideas as much as it does objects
00:11:00 I think the problem with some of the migration museums is that they are they only express what
00:11:07 they're opinion-led so migration is a very good thing is the idea and as the
00:11:14 only way they can sort of express it sometimes this is really banal so they
00:11:18 bring in fashion if you have migrants or they bring in good food and it's
00:11:24 something that's just a lot more complicated than that I think it there
00:11:29 is a danger of the cultural world in general just reflecting a small minority
00:11:35 elite opinion and not and that has become I think the art world and the
00:11:40 museum in general has become detached from the broader public I mean you know
00:11:45 without should it be crude making connections like this we we're hearing a
00:11:49 lot about this at the moment generally the idea that there is one set of
00:11:52 opinions which is not basically does not reflect the majority opinion whatever do
00:11:58 you think there is therefore great uniformity amongst our cultural
00:12:02 establishment in that way in what they believe um i think i think there is a there is on certain
00:12:09 issues very much so and i think what you have is a i see it as a dynamic between those that don't
00:12:16 express their opinions right and feel uncomfortable about doing so and i do think they're a little bit
00:12:21 cowardly for that i don't think i think you've written they don't have a backbone or something
00:12:24 yeah they need to get a backbone yeah and they need to begin to articulate why i mean
00:12:29 they need to be able to articulate why their vision of the institution and of art is is one
00:12:35 that other people should be involved in rather than sort of hope that either history will do it
00:12:41 or people will run out of enthusiasm so the ones with the passion I think the ones with the passion
00:12:47 and the energy in the cultural world are the ones that express in my view of minority opinion
00:12:54 and in a way looks down to the public
00:12:57 and to some degree no longer really trusts
00:13:02 the transformative power of art.
00:13:06 That's the point.
00:13:06 I mean, this is about, in a way, the collapse of confidence, is it not?
00:13:11 This is a much broader thing, in a way.
00:13:14 You could say that people who are in charge of our culture
00:13:17 want a better expression, whether they're curators or whatever.
00:13:20 if they no longer think that that thing they're meant to be curating is is any good or or if they
00:13:27 look at it in a very relative way then we've got a problem haven't we yes i think what it does is
00:13:33 that it privatizes art yeah and i'm really struck i was at a large a meeting with a run by a large
00:13:41 a senior member of a large cultural organization and in private they will tell you their cultural
00:13:47 judgments they will say I've read this book or you know they will have quite
00:13:51 high complicated conversations about whatever painter or a piece of music it
00:13:57 is but in public they won't do that I mean the institution in a way is
00:14:02 constantly our organization is a constantly say we really care what you
00:14:06 think we want to know what you think we want to reflect our communities but it's
00:14:10 very disingenuous I mean I think if they trusted the public as well as trusted
00:14:16 their own judgments yeah then they would be having this conversation that is much
00:14:20 more about aesthetics or much more about quality or much more about music but I
00:14:25 mean do you think that they don't trust or they do trust their adjustment maybe
00:14:31 but they're more frightened of appearing elitist for example I mean this is great
00:14:35 emphasis now on accessibility isn't there yes you know in a way you're talking
00:14:39 about the Victorians you know basically putting things there and some trying to
00:14:44 raise people up i know these are unfashionable statements right but somehow trying to transcend
00:14:48 you know the everyday life um but now it seems that that confidence is gone but also it's sort
00:14:55 of like a fear maybe that they are being elitist this particular word you know which is thrown
00:15:02 about would you say i mean um i think that they i think they no longer trust the public
00:15:09 are capable of understanding and appreciating art.
00:15:14 I think they're, in a way, despite all this democratization,
00:15:18 they are more disconnected from the public
00:15:21 than they have been in earlier times since the Victorians,
00:15:25 when I think they did.
00:15:26 They put, the National Gallery was,
00:15:29 now it's obviously an extraordinary,
00:15:30 London is just wealth after wealth after wealth.
00:15:33 But that was there between the poor and the rich district,
00:15:36 so people would come.
00:15:37 and you know the British Museum was free
00:15:41 the day it opened it was free
00:15:44 you had to have clean shoes
00:15:45 you had to write
00:15:47 so you know it's a relative idea of accessibility
00:15:51 but nonetheless it was
00:15:53 wanted to bring people to the best
00:15:56 I think although the cultural elite
00:15:59 if you like
00:16:00 I think they're perhaps a little bit more ambivalent
00:16:05 and if you look at art itself
00:16:07 If you look at the way art has changed over the last 30-40 years, it is imbued with either a kind of self-questioning, which can be quite creative and it can very much reflect the period.
00:16:20 Art has to reflect its own time.
00:16:22 You can't go back and recreate artwork from previous periods from now.
00:16:30 um but it art itself has become a little rarefied i think when when did that happen when did that
00:16:41 change in attitude occur you know this where you're sort of saying people don't want to appear
00:16:47 judgmental they they're less you know they're far less certain now when would you say that really
00:16:54 we've been talking about the victorians we're talking about a century ago 150 years ago now
00:16:58 so there are waves I suppose waves of uncertainty I mean I was just thinking
00:17:04 about the modernists which I think that there wasn't a tech there was a kind of
00:17:08 horror of mass society there reflected itself in modernist literature in
00:17:13 particular that was very as I said you know it's not always a terrible thing
00:17:18 that was quite creative but then I think there's been waves ever since both
00:17:23 within art and also academia which obviously train a lot of museum
00:17:27 directors and curators and probably the sort of 70s just to complicate it
00:17:35 slightly I think in the 70s what you had was a tert in the political sphere
00:17:40 turning away from politics as a kind of the vehicle for social change and
00:17:46 equality movements and far more towards identity movements and culture as a way so if you have it
00:17:55 if you like if you have a kind of culture in the arts slightly terrified of mass society then starts
00:18:02 to question the possibility of truth then becomes politicized with the decline of left-wing movements
00:18:09 and an identity movements and maybe that though those are the sort of you know for collecting
00:18:16 threads if you like that have taken us to the present a move away from if you like formal
00:18:20 political activity into cultural areas i mean when you talk about that fear of the modern world fear
00:18:26 of the math you see this in the bloomsbury group famously yeah horror of the crowd you read virginia
00:18:32 wharf appalled at these people celebrating i think it's the coronation of george the fifth or whatever
00:18:39 you know absolute horror of it's interesting that maybe the arts generally have become more
00:18:46 elite if you like or more uh you know as it were separate from people as we've become more
00:18:52 democratic supposedly this is one of the great paradoxes yeah supposedly i mean i think we
00:18:57 i think obviously in many ways we are much more democratic and that's a good thing but i think
00:19:01 think the language of democracy is everywhere and yet it feels like it just
00:19:08 feels really it feels disingenuous the language that the museum profession has
00:19:15 talked about accessibility may be well intentioned but it rings hollow it's
00:19:21 all I think what happens is it's almost like they give the public an easy jet
00:19:25 experience you know you stuff people in um you make it actually not a very pleasant experience
00:19:32 and then it's fine for you because you can have your private views and your corporate functions
00:19:37 where there isn't so many people in the gallery and i i think things are done in the name you
00:19:43 always have to ask when people are talking about access is access to what are people really getting
00:19:48 the cream i don't think they are you know we did a report here at the new college forum on the
00:19:53 natural history museum and you know that is for me one a great example you know it's just full of
00:19:59 cafes now it's full of cafes and what have you there's nothing wrong in a cafe you know don't
00:20:03 get me wrong whatever but you get this feeling of somehow or other this is being turned into
00:20:08 the natural history experience do you know what i mean far more than maybe in a rigorous way um
00:20:15 it's full of kids and i've taken many children there for very good reasons they love the dinosaurs
00:20:21 But I think the institution is no longer talking to us as adults.
00:20:26 One other thing that I've seen that you've written about,
00:20:29 and it can't be avoided now because it is massive,
00:20:31 and that is identity politics.
00:20:33 You mentioned this movement into identity politics.
00:20:36 And I just wonder, you know, we talk about this in terms of education,
00:20:41 in terms of all these different areas and government,
00:20:45 but in the arts, I mean, what has been the effect of identity politics
00:20:49 generally in the cultural sphere
00:20:51 I don't just mean museums
00:20:52 but by your observation it seems to me
00:20:55 that it's now
00:20:56 there is a particular
00:20:59 sort of obsession maybe with
00:21:01 identity politics
00:21:01 that can't be healthy for the arts surely
00:21:04 The most destructive examples
00:21:07 have occurred in the last few years
00:21:09 in the States
00:21:11 but also here in Paris
00:21:13 and those
00:21:15 are cases of where an artist has produced
00:21:17 to work something like i'll just rule a few names of brett bailey's exhibit b oh that was the slavery
00:21:23 one yeah yeah yeah at the barbican at the barbican this was the case i should explain where there was
00:21:28 a sort of an anti obviously anti-slavery uh exhibit but i think you've you've put it quite
00:21:35 well actually tiffany you said that there's a growing feeling that only particular stories
00:21:39 can be told by particular people right and that was the problem there wasn't it if you could
00:21:44 explain so he was a white South African male and he did a piece about how in
00:21:50 different periods of history black people have been objectified it's not
00:21:53 just slavery like there was one where at the beginning of the piece which I saw
00:21:58 in Edinburgh there's a couple exhibited as if they're in a museum as they were
00:22:03 once and this happened in the States so it's a historical it's very very
00:22:10 challenging piece actually and although it was didactic it was genuinely
00:22:16 provocative and challenging and interesting and there were protests
00:22:21 against it because he's white even though the actors who took play part in
00:22:26 it are black and wanted to take part in it but in these kind of in these kind of
00:22:31 controversies that doesn't count you know though that black voice is not you
00:22:36 know there's only one voice which is allowed which is those that are
00:22:39 protesting those that have wanted to take part in this are being paid it's
00:22:42 their job and they want to do it they don't count but it was shut down it
00:22:46 didn't it was on at the Barbican and they had to shut it down I mean in Paris
00:22:51 they had to have armed police and this is a bizarre thing because in a way
00:22:54 you've got people say you cannot put something on so it is literally
00:22:59 silencing artists for me sorry but for me the thing is about artists that it is
00:23:06 an act of empathy and communication and if I think about some of the great
00:23:11 pieces of work that I've seen I'm thinking I just the other evening I saw
00:23:15 Sajid Ray's Apu Chilogy so this is a Bengali filmmaker operating a sort of
00:23:20 1950s three-part series about this young boy who becomes a man and the you know
00:23:25 the troubles of life and that he is in many ways different to you or me is not
00:23:32 the point is that you find connection and and and you in a way he's holding your hand and showing
00:23:39 you his world so it opens up um and connects and as an act of sort of human empathy you think about
00:23:46 this young boy but this and i think that's what they're trying to shut down you know and i think
00:23:50 that's fundamentally what's being shut down here but this is a real danger surely isn't it i mean
00:23:54 to it's okay you say freedom of speech thing but it's not just that is it it actually undermines
00:24:00 the whole idea of creativity what it's essentially saying is like you cannot
00:24:07 write about experiences of a say like a man even right yeah me as a gay man can
00:24:15 only write about gay things I mean what basically you're wiping you would wipe
00:24:21 out the whole of our culture would you not I mean if you applied that what
00:24:24 about Shakespeare what about how far back do you want to go yeah but I mean
00:24:28 And the point is, this appears utterly ridiculous, but I feel that it has quite a grip.
00:24:34 Do you think?
00:24:36 I think it does.
00:24:37 The other thing about it that's so detrimental is that it sort of says we cannot relate to
00:24:44 somebody who's not immediately, obviously, like us.
00:24:47 So I think it's really bad for solidarity, actually, and fundamentally conservative in
00:24:51 that it just says, stay where you are, that's it.
00:24:55 are who you were when you were born you can't become something else it's really
00:25:01 conservative it's politically really really bad bad idea I think it has a I
00:25:08 think it's it's also politicized everyday life so food dress has become
00:25:14 subject to this kind of criticism and I think most people just want to do the
00:25:19 right thing yeah and they've the the times that I've become quite worried
00:25:25 about it is the way in which young people in particular say well maybe I
00:25:28 shouldn't maybe I shouldn't wear a sari or maybe I shouldn't eat that food
00:25:33 because it's somebody else's culture and you know that's against curiosity and
00:25:39 the fact that we learn from cultures we learn from each other and we're always
00:25:43 sort of you know eyeing eyeing something else up just to see because it's maybe
00:25:47 it's better than what we've got it's interesting though but this is it's got the seed of its own
00:25:53 destruction within it hasn't it i mean you're talking about their cultural appropriation what
00:25:58 is now called cultural appropriation which seems to go entirely against the whole idea of what
00:26:02 we've been actually that somehow how can you worry about the fact that you might be appropriating
00:26:08 and at the same time celebrate say diversity all of this it adds to an enormous confusion
00:26:15 So people, I guess, on the whole, decide to stay quiet, don't they,
00:26:18 rather than say the wrong thing, maybe?
00:26:20 Yeah, no, I think that's true.
00:26:22 I mean, I think we hear a lot about diversity,
00:26:25 but actually there's very little of it.
00:26:28 It's a word that masks a different reality,
00:26:32 which is, you know, if you take something like learning languages,
00:26:35 even European languages, it's down.
00:26:39 So if you want to know about other cultures,
00:26:40 you need to learn the language and go to museums
00:26:43 and look at the porcelain and the script and the abstract design, whatever.
00:26:49 I think we do live in fairly timid times,
00:26:52 and I think people are afraid of saying the wrong thing.
00:26:56 And so, because what happens is that they say,
00:26:59 so what you're saying is, it's like a classic marital argument.
00:27:03 Yes, exactly.
00:27:03 So what you're saying is that this, you say, no, it's not.
00:27:08 Yes.
00:27:09 Am I optimistic?
00:27:10 I'm optimistic because I think people are curious about each other because they do want things to change and they don't want to just be, you know, they want to be more than what they're born with, if you like.
00:27:24 They want to become something else.
00:27:25 Yes, exactly. You don't want to stay necessarily a prisoner, you know.
00:27:28 You know, if you're born in one social, you know, economic group or whatever, what does that mean that you can ever actually think outside of those terms?
00:27:37 it seems and some of the most exciting art has come from people who have left home left their
00:27:43 country and gone somewhere else i have to say it seems that you've talked about uniformity museums
00:27:50 or whatever it does appear to me that in the cultural world generally i mean i worked in it
00:27:55 for a long time as making programs and writing about it there's a sort of uh is extraordinary
00:28:02 uniformity of views, I think.
00:28:04 And we've seen this, for example, with Brexit.
00:28:07 You know, what was it?
00:28:10 97%.
00:28:11 97% or something like that.
00:28:14 You
00:28:15 are not one of the 97%, I understand,
00:28:18 when it comes to... I'm one of the 3%.
00:28:19 One of the 3%.
00:28:20 Is life hard, therefore?
00:28:26 It's one of those...
00:28:27 I go back and forth on this.
00:28:29 I mean, when the Brexit
00:28:31 vote first happened there was um a very negative reaction and to those that voted for brexit and i
00:28:42 think it just reflected the fact that so few people in the cultural world left london or left
00:28:48 their bubble um and that really threw up to me the kind of irony of the world which is constantly
00:28:53 talking about accessibility and democratization and the public and audiences had obviously never
00:29:00 spoken to anybody outside their own dinner parties. I mean, God knows where we are now
00:29:06 with Brexit.
00:29:08 To be continued, to be continued, I'm sure.
00:29:11 But I should say that, you know, when you turn off the microphone and when you close
00:29:18 up shop, I have found people are much more open than they appear to be. And they genuinely
00:29:24 want to know, why did you vote for Brexit? And there is a genuine, my husband voted for
00:29:30 voted to stay with the EU and so you know there are a lot of people who are just trying to have
00:29:36 that conversation out but it just you just you just wouldn't tell from the kind of the public
00:29:42 debate that's occurring. Tiffany look thanks very very much for coming this time I hope you come
00:29:47 back actually because we could talk about a hell of a lot of other things but thank you very much
00:29:52 for the meantime and that was so what you're saying is please if you've enjoyed it do subscribe
00:29:56 I think there's a marker coming up here on the screen
00:30:00 and you put it in there and subscribe.
00:30:03 Thanks very much for watching and see you next time.