New Culture Forum - March 31, 2019


13. Lionel Shriver: [Part 1] Populism & The Battle for Brexit

12. Richard Tice - Rallying For Brexit 14. Lionel Shriver [Part 2] : Identity Politics & ‘Cultural Appropriation’

Episode Stats


Length

29 minutes

Words per minute

134.44

Word count

3,911

Sentence count

207


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to So What You're Saying Is. I'm Peter Whittle. Now I've had the pleasure
00:00:11 of knowing for about 10 years my guest for this show. Lionel Shriver is probably one
00:00:16 of our most celebrated novelists. She is the author of such books as Big Brother and The
00:00:23 Mandibles, A Family and perhaps best known as the writer of We Need to Talk About Kevin
00:00:29 which was then made into a critically acclaimed film.
00:00:33 But she's also a columnist for The Spectator and for The Wall Street Journal,
00:00:37 and she's been increasingly appearing on our screens on political shows
00:00:41 such as Question Time and Newsnight.
00:00:44 She's with me now.
00:00:46 Thank you very much for coming in, Lionel.
00:00:48 Pleasure.
00:00:49 We're recording this on Friday the 29th of March.
00:00:55 I know how I feel.
00:00:56 Depressed.
00:00:57 How do you feel?
00:00:59 At least it's depressed.
00:01:01 Right.
00:01:01 Right.
00:01:04 It's funny.
00:01:05 On the way here, I went through Parliament Square,
00:01:07 and I'm kind of glad that you at least got me out of the house
00:01:11 because it was quite a spectacle.
00:01:15 And I gather from the telegraph that the Leave people
00:01:21 got there really early in the morning to take over.
00:01:26 It's kind of touching, however pointless.
00:01:29 you uh wrote this week in the spectator what i thought was an interesting sort of what you
00:01:36 might call counterfactual if the boot had been on the other foot can you tell us what
00:01:42 you were writing about
00:01:44 i was actually writing about a trio different stories but the i think the one that you're
00:01:51 zeroing in on uh has to do surprisingly with brexit yeah and i was it really struck me
00:01:59 when there was that enormous march to call for a second referendum
00:02:08 and we want to remain in the EU that was supposed to be a million strong.
00:02:14 I don't know whether that's a correct measure or not.
00:02:18 It wasn't last time, so, you know.
00:02:20 Yeah.
00:02:21 But fine.
00:02:22 Let's say it was a million people.
00:02:24 Let's just flip roles.
00:02:29 What if the original referendum had gone 52-48 for remain?
00:02:38 And yes, we're staying in the EU. That question is settled.
00:02:43 settled, but in this scenario, perhaps freakishly, three-quarters of Parliament is full of Leave
00:02:53 supporters, and there's this enormous march of disgruntled, sore losers who come out for
00:03:04 Leave anyway and insist that we must rerun the referendum, if not unilaterally withdraw
00:03:12 in defiance of the electorate.
00:03:15 Now, how would that be covered?
00:03:18 It would be frightening.
00:03:21 It would be labeled populist.
00:03:24 And all these people would be dismissed as thugs and hoodlums.
00:03:30 Whereas the Remainers are portrayed as crusaders
00:03:33 out to save their country.
00:03:37 Do you think, I mean, when you look at the situation now,
00:03:40 would you have imagined it would have been so blatant this what has happened over the past two
00:03:47 weeks i mean you know it was going to be a battle it was always going to be a battle
00:03:52 but really when you look and you you look at this this institution which we're actually not that far
00:03:59 from parliament and for that matter all the institutions around such as the media it has
00:04:05 been quite extraordinary hasn't it the effort to essentially fight back and thwart the vote
00:04:11 i told my husband before the referendum and i wish i'd gone on the public record on this
00:04:21 if only to say i told you so because that's so satisfying um i said you know even if leave wins
00:04:33 which, of course, nobody thought it would, and I didn't.
00:04:38 They won't leave.
00:04:40 There'll be some kind of chicanery whereby we're not in the single market anymore.
00:04:46 We're in the singular market.
00:04:48 Or we're not in the customs union anymore.
00:04:52 We're in the customary union.
00:04:54 It'll be one big fiddle, and nothing really will change.
00:04:57 And I've been consistently right that that's exactly what's happening.
00:05:03 In fact, I would have more respect for Parliament right now if they simply marched in there and rescinded Article 50, honestly, and once and for all,
00:05:16 and simply announced, I know that you voted to leave the EU, but we've decided not to.
00:05:23 Sorry.
00:05:24 Because that is what's happening.
00:05:28 And one of the things that would happen right away, immediately after the referendum result,
00:05:36 is that suddenly we had this coinage of the so-called hard and soft Brexit.
00:05:42 I remember you actually talking about it, because I wanted to actually ask you about it,
00:05:44 it was the way in which the language was captured, wasn't it?
00:05:48 Yes, and the media picked it up right away, as if it had been part of the argument all along.
00:05:53 So it's important to bear in mind that during the referendum campaigns, nobody was talking about a so-called soft Brexit, a medium course, a leaving the EU sort of but not really.
00:06:08 The Remainers were all catastrophizing about, you know, that means leaving the single market in the Customs Union.
00:06:17 You'll be sorry.
00:06:18 It's going to be an economic disaster.
00:06:20 So this new coinage actually was a brilliant piece of branding.
00:06:30 We've never got beyond it.
00:06:32 It sort of came out of nowhere, didn't it?
00:06:34 Suddenly there was a soft and hard Brexit.
00:06:36 But then that was followed by crashing out, for example.
00:06:39 Right.
00:06:40 Which the media picked up too.
00:06:42 Which is language that betrays where they're coming from.
00:06:46 Yes, exactly.
00:06:47 You mentioned there about populism.
00:06:53 People would be accused of populism and all the rest of it.
00:06:56 I know you talked quite recently about definitions.
00:06:59 Again, we're talking about language here.
00:07:02 This is becoming or is treated as an entirely negative thing, isn't it, being populist?
00:07:08 Ostensibly.
00:07:09 It's really an odd concept.
00:07:11 I did a little piece for Newsnight on populism, and in order to write that little, you know,
00:07:20 it's like a two-minute essay, I read and reread definitions of populism trying to digest what
00:07:27 exactly it means. I think if you put a gun to most politicians' heads, they wouldn't be able
00:07:34 to give you a cogent definition. Ultimately, the definition I came up with was, it's democracy
00:07:42 when you don't win. It's a demonization of people who represent some ideology that you
00:07:55 don't like and occasionally you have left-wing populists but increasingly you know like in Spain
00:08:05 and in Greece but for the most part it has been a label that has been used against right of center.
00:08:15 Well in French culture it is a completely negative term when it when it's even applied to artistic
00:08:22 things for example populist it's like vulgar it's like bad yes and the odd thing about the
00:08:28 term is that it's very anti-democratic yeah I mean it's it's it conjures this vision of the mob
00:08:34 you know unconstrained has has taken the reins of power and gone crazy um well then what is
00:08:44 democracy but I don't get it. The thing is it it strikes me now that one of the
00:08:53 things we're facing is that people not just the 17.4 million or whatever or
00:08:59 even maybe more than that now that they now know they've got no shadow of a
00:09:05 doubt they now know what the establishment think of them mm-hmm they
00:09:11 They now, oh, they think we're racist, they think we are uneducated.
00:09:15 They might have sort of had a slight feeling that maybe that's how they were regarded,
00:09:18 but now there's no doubt about it.
00:09:22 What do you see?
00:09:23 And by the way, if you look at the demographics of who voted what,
00:09:26 we're not talking about a bunch of skinheads.
00:09:29 We're talking about Middle England.
00:09:32 We're talking about people who make marmalade.
00:09:35 And yet the utter contempt in the rhetoric on the Remain camp has been consistent and almost hysterical.
00:09:47 I find it horrifying.
00:09:50 One of the things that I've followed in the New York Times is really a bizarre line of reasoning,
00:09:59 a way of characterizing what's going on on the Leave side,
00:10:03 which I don't think you could ever get away with publishing over here
00:10:05 because it just wouldn't make any sense.
00:10:08 Such as what? What do they say?
00:10:10 The theory is that the Leave vote is a hearkening back to the imperial past, right?
00:10:18 It's trying to bring back the empire, and it's all about an act of nostalgia.
00:10:25 Now, does this ring true?
00:10:27 Is that the rhetoric that we listen to on a daily basis?
00:10:31 I mean, like you, I'm sure.
00:10:33 I follow this every day.
00:10:35 I'm reading all these articles.
00:10:37 I'm reading all these comment pieces.
00:10:40 And I'm reading a lot of pro-leave comment pieces.
00:10:42 I'm sorry, I don't see any reference to the empire.
00:10:46 There's no imperial rhetoric.
00:10:49 There's no, in fact, there's no reference to the past.
00:10:53 At best, I mean, I myself have referred to the past in that I don't find it especially bizarre to go back to being a country, right?
00:11:05 Because England has been a country for almost 1,000 years.
00:11:11 The union with England and Scotland goes back 300 years.
00:11:16 We've only been a member of this supernational organization for 46 years.
00:11:23 why is that so strange but that's that okay fine that's a kind of nostalgia if you will
00:11:31 you know a hearkening back to the past but it's also a hearkening to the present of an awful lot
00:11:36 of countries that are still countries in the world today so how does the new york times manage to sell
00:11:44 to the American readership
00:11:46 this
00:11:47 actually very prejudiced
00:11:50 ugly and ignorant
00:11:54 version of events.
00:11:56 And they love it.
00:11:57 And they get
00:11:58 they publish
00:12:00 just the kind of
00:12:04 contemptuous piece
00:12:06 that you're talking about.
00:12:08 That probably wouldn't be published
00:12:10 over here.
00:12:11 It's extraordinary that they do that actually.
00:12:13 Because even here, when one was arguing, campaigning, whatever,
00:12:17 that charge, you know, the kind of empire, imperialistic thing,
00:12:20 used to come up very, very occasionally.
00:12:23 It had no legs.
00:12:24 No one was really arguing on that base at all.
00:12:27 What's interesting, though, is that when you look at those million people,
00:12:30 however many it was who went through London,
00:12:33 aren't they the people who are demonstrating for the establishment?
00:12:38 Aren't they the conservative ones, if you like,
00:12:40 if you want to put it in inverted commas?
00:12:42 Yes, absolutely.
00:12:43 And there is an element here that I don't entirely understand, that is, given we're
00:12:51 talking about only those 46 years, why is membership of the European Union so
00:13:01 emotionally important to these people? I can see getting a little stroppy about
00:13:09 being controlled by a large bureaucratic autocracy that that to me logically stimulates
00:13:21 annoyance if not anger but I don't understand why membership of a large bureaucratic autocracy
00:13:31 why is why is that so meaningful to these people individually I mean I can I can see
00:13:37 okay, some younger people want the opportunity to work in Europe without having to get a work visa.
00:13:44 I mean, that's a practical access that I'm actually pretty sympathetic with.
00:13:49 They won't all necessarily take advantage of it.
00:13:52 In fact, most of them won't, but I can understand that feeling of opportunity is enjoyable.
00:13:59 And that's the one point on which I'm most sympathetic with Remainers.
00:14:05 But that doesn't seem to be where the emotion is primarily coming from.
00:14:08 It is an identity thing.
00:14:10 And I don't understand identifying so fiercely with this behemoth.
00:14:18 I just don't get it.
00:14:19 Can you explain it to me?
00:14:20 Well, no, this is an interesting thing.
00:14:21 In the 70s, if you like, 70s, 80s, 90s, when people talked about Europe,
00:14:28 and they argued and debated, people who were pro-EU,
00:14:32 I think as you just said, their attitude was,
00:14:34 well you know it's got a bit of a democratic deficit it's usually bureaucratic and everything
00:14:39 but on balance you know we think it's all right to be in and you could kind of argue with that
00:14:44 but what this has shown this the campaign and what's happened since is that as you say there
00:14:50 is this absolute kind of uncritical allegiance they walk around you know with the things on
00:14:56 their on their face you know the insignia and all the rest of all i can think you ask about
00:15:01 explaining I just suggest maybe one thing is it maybe that it's all about how I see myself I'm a
00:15:08 citizen of the world that's what it is is that could that be it they're wrong that's some of it
00:15:14 but somehow the most the best I can identify the emotion is we're used to getting our way
00:15:21 how dare you yeah I think that's actually much more what it is right because it's one of the
00:15:27 great orthodoxies of the past 40 50 years suddenly someone has put their foot down said actually no
00:15:33 too far we don't want this anymore and they don't know how to handle it
00:15:38 uh i don't say the creative or artistic community but if you think of the literary one out of which
00:15:48 maybe i have been booted so quite no no the point is apparently uh lionel it's something like 90
00:15:56 percent of people are Remainers. Is that something you recognize or is that an exaggeration?
00:16:02 Oh, sure. I mean, I am a freak among my coterie. And friends of mine have different responses
00:16:12 to that. There might be a few people who are more prone to avoid me than they would have
00:16:19 been. There are other friends of mine who are willing to overlook it. The rare friend
00:16:26 has engaged in constructive conversation of a sort that hardly anyone has because we
00:16:31 surround ourselves with people we agree with. And most Remainers especially are used to
00:16:38 being around other Remainers. So in some ways I'm regarded as some kind of exotic zoo creature.
00:16:47 You see, isn't this extraordinary, you know, I'm sure that many people in that world would see themselves as being original thinkers, as being free thinkers, whatever it is, you know.
00:16:59 What's going on then?
00:17:02 I'm mystified.
00:17:03 I mean, I don't understand why I could come to the conclusion that, on balance, I think the UK might do better outside the EU.
00:17:15 I thought it was at least a worthy experiment.
00:17:17 I don't think it's that I'm American
00:17:22 I mean I've been here for over 30 years
00:17:26 You still spend some time in the States don't you?
00:17:28 Sure I do
00:17:29 I spend the summer in New York
00:17:32 but I've gone too native in many regards
00:17:37 for that to be the explanation
00:17:39 there's just this group think
00:17:44 and it's disappointing
00:17:46 especially in the in the arts where you and I would say especially amongst
00:17:53 writers who are supposed to have more of an intellectual bent whereas you know
00:18:00 if you paint pictures maybe you don't care I can see that well no but I mean
00:18:03 whether you're painting pictures or writing plays or novels it's not just the
00:18:08 EU actually I would say sort of like when did you last see anything for
00:18:11 example, that criticized multiculturalism? When would you ever see a play which, for example,
00:18:18 seriously questioned mass migration? It just doesn't happen. I mean, you know what you're
00:18:24 going to get, don't you? Yes, and we're talking about something larger than Brexit now because
00:18:29 it's going on all over the West. The arts and media have adopted a both consistent and extremely
00:18:41 narrow set of views. And then at the same time, however bizarrely, you've got Trump in the White
00:18:48 House and Leave, at least ostensibly, triumphs over here. So there's this strange disconnect
00:18:58 between the artistic and journalistic elite
00:19:04 and the rest of the country.
00:19:09 And if anything, the more the animals, the populists,
00:19:16 succeed in getting real political power,
00:19:20 the more extreme and uncompromising
00:19:25 the artistic and journalistic community becomes.
00:19:29 I mean, they drive each other apart.
00:19:32 Where do you stand?
00:19:34 Where would you put yourself politically, actually?
00:19:36 I think I've heard you describe yourself as a libertarian.
00:19:38 I have to say I don't quite even know what that means anymore
00:19:42 because it seems to have so many definitions.
00:19:43 How would you define libertarian, if that's what you think?
00:19:46 I've resorted to that way just because I don't know what else to call myself.
00:19:51 It's a somewhat dangerous way of the court, especially in the United States, because libertarians are considered complete kooks.
00:19:58 The irony of that being that the core principle of libertarianism is just that you should be able to do whatever you want as long as you're not hurting other people.
00:20:11 And that is, as far as I can tell, the core principle of the American Constitution.
00:20:17 Yes, yes.
00:20:19 And we've lost, of course, you know, the left has completely abandoned any such notion because it has become oriented toward control.
00:20:31 So it doesn't have to do with letting people do whatever they want.
00:20:38 They must behave in this way, and the left is not content even to tell you what to do, but you also have to think in this way.
00:20:48 It's very dictatorial, and the views that you are allowed are very rigid.
00:20:56 And, you know, part of my problem with that is, look, I was a rebellious teenager, and I still am, right?
00:21:03 I don't like being told what to do.
00:21:07 I'm inclined to do whatever you tell me not to, just because that's my nature.
00:21:12 I don't like being controlled.
00:21:14 I don't understand why other people do. There's a lot I don't understand. So when I'm dictated to,
00:21:26 my impulse is to question, at the very least to question. And I do find it mysterious
00:21:34 obvious, why young people are so consistently indoctrinated into this way of thinking. I
00:21:50 know that I'm a kind of late child of the 60s, so that may be part of it, but I don't
00:21:58 understand what happened to the kind of wild and crazy rebelliousness of the state of being
00:22:07 young. And this whole thing of getting into lockstep with this rigid ideology is completely
00:22:18 antithetical to me in relation to being young and alive and you know used to be
00:22:28 that you you questioned your elders and you wanted to overthrow the way things
00:22:35 are done and do something differently and I see it I see it occasionally like
00:22:44 I do meet occasional younger people who give me enormous hope.
00:22:49 Spiked Online, I think, has some great people in it.
00:22:54 Given the current environment, I have doubly much admiration for them
00:22:59 because I think it has become very difficult to have a dissenting voice in universities
00:23:05 or even now because people who have been through the universities are now in workplaces.
00:23:13 There are a lot of workplaces where, you know, there's only one way to think.
00:23:18 So if you depart from that, you can endanger your career.
00:23:23 I think it's gone across something that you might have thought was in the public sector only is now in the private sector.
00:23:31 There was a spectator column about that recently.
00:23:33 That's right, about human resource departments.
00:23:35 Yes.
00:23:36 And what they see as being their reason, their motive.
00:23:40 but also in bringing in these various courses that staff have to do,
00:23:44 unconscious bias courses, what have you.
00:23:46 Which they've documented make people more racist than they were when they went in,
00:23:53 if only because they resent wasting their time.
00:23:57 If you call yourself, think of yourself as being libertarian for the reasons you've just said,
00:24:05 this must inform what you write about maybe or what you choose to write about when you write
00:24:12 your novels i i was looking through interviews with you and um one interviewer said that you
00:24:20 your writing is characterized by a sympathy for the overdog i thought it was a good line i have to say
00:24:28 but is this is that something that you actually recognize a little bit yeah i sympathize with
00:24:34 anybody that other people don't sympathize with and that's my instinct yeah um so when i was
00:24:40 writing we need to talk about kevin i looked at the characters in this scenario the school shooting
00:24:46 scenario although that book doesn't actually have a school shooting in it
00:24:51 who who doesn't get any sympathy obviously the actually you know i was about to say obviously
00:25:00 the shooter but that's not true the shooter does generally get some sympathy that is there's been
00:25:07 this pouring over uh the the history of uh these uh kids and looking for signs of bullying and
00:25:17 you know uh what's going wrong in their family um are they have they been warped by video games or
00:25:25 you know there have been all kinds of explanations made for them as to how how this happened
00:25:29 i thought the the parents of the killers those people get no sympathy it's their fault they
00:25:39 should have been better parents they should have known what was going on with their own kids
00:25:42 and they are in some ways de facto murderers and of the two parents which one really gets it in
00:25:49 the neck the mother yeah okay so i wrote we need to talk about kevin from the perspective of the
00:25:55 mother of the killer. And obviously, because I have embraced that viewpoint, I experience
00:26:05 sympathy with that person. So, for example, I have some sympathy with people who have
00:26:15 been very successful in their careers and finally started making a decent living only to discover
00:26:26 that they get taxed within an inch of their lives. Now, you're not supposed to sympathize
00:26:32 with people who make any money, but it's emotionally a pretty grim experience. In fact,
00:26:39 I did a paper for, I think it was New Criterion in New York, all about what it feels like to lose all of your income to the state.
00:26:57 And one of the things that the state doesn't take seriously when it removes the proceeds of your labor is what it feels like.
00:27:06 that they're especially once you ever cross approach or cross the 50% point
00:27:12 you just wonder what what is the point why did why am i working for other
00:27:16 people and you feel had you know okay you feel as if somebody has tricked you
00:27:24 you feel taken advantage of it's almost like being mugged and one of the main
00:27:32 things that motivates people to figure out somehow to pay a somewhat lower level
00:27:40 of tax is because they don't like what it feels like to be fleeced yeah you know
00:27:46 and the experience is not of oh the great opportunity to make a contribution
00:27:50 to the larger social welfare and let's let's be honest when especially when
00:27:56 other people are donating, if you will, a much smaller percentage. So, you know, that's another
00:28:05 example of, that's a constituency that almost no one goes to bat for. If you have any money, then
00:28:14 nobody sympathizes with you. Nobody wants to hear about your whinging, about your high tax rate.
00:28:20 And for the most part, people do keep their mouths shut.
00:28:24 You don't see people publishing comment pieces or going on TV.
00:28:34 The wealthy are very subdued on this point.
00:28:42 You certainly don't hear writers talking about it.
00:28:45 No, no, no.
00:28:46 Almost not.
00:28:48 We're going to break that.
00:28:49 We're going to go on and talk, Lionel, thank you very much,
00:28:53 but a bit more about identity politics
00:28:55 and some of the things you found yourself in.
00:28:57 But for this programme, thank you very much, Lionel,
00:29:01 and she'll be back with me next time.
00:29:04 Thank you very much. Bye.