New Culture Forum - April 07, 2019


14. Lionel Shriver [Part 2] : Identity Politics & ‘Cultural Appropriation’

13. Lionel Shriver: [Part 1] Populism & The Battle for Brexit 15. Julia Hartley-Brewer: Bringing Common Sense To The Culture Wars

Episode Stats


Length

24 minutes

Words per minute

129.12

Word count

3,138

Sentence count

216


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 hello and welcome to so what you're saying is I'm Peter Whittle now I'm very pleased to be
00:00:09 carrying on my conversation with the novelist Lionel Shriver last week we were talking about
00:00:16 brexit and populism what these things meant and we're just going to be carrying on from that now
00:00:22 Now, Lionel, we talked about the different tribes, if you like, of Brexit, but as well as the, as it were, the somewheres and the anywheres, as David Goodhart has called them there,
00:00:35 there seemed to be this body of people now, which I would characterize as being nowheres, people who just simply appear to be against the nation and want to traduce the nation.
00:00:46 Is that something you recognize in this current situation?
00:00:49 I recognize it because I grew up with it in the United States.
00:00:54 The liberals in the U.S. have for decades and decades prided themselves on how much they hate their country.
00:01:05 Or if they express any kind of patriotism, it's always kind of backdoor patriotism.
00:01:11 So it's always, you know, I love my country, but.
00:01:16 Emphasis on but.
00:01:17 But, yeah.
00:01:17 obsessed with all the evil things that the country has done in the past.
00:01:22 And when they travel, they travel in a state of apology.
00:01:27 They feel ashamed of being American.
00:01:30 But here's the thing, and you can easily transfer this to Britain.
00:01:36 They don't really feel ashamed because they don't think they're American.
00:01:40 Explain.
00:01:41 This whole posing and the posturing about how terrible your country is
00:01:50 and how disgusting your compatriots are is a way of opting out of the country.
00:01:55 It's a way of making yourself better than your fellow Americans
00:01:59 and putting yourself above them because it's only from a great height
00:02:05 that you can make these contemptuous judgments.
00:02:08 It's an opt-out.
00:02:10 And it's saying, I know everything that's wrong with us,
00:02:16 and therefore it is not wrong with me, right?
00:02:20 And the intention is to distance and to disown.
00:02:28 And therefore, all of these mean things that you're saying
00:02:32 about those disgusting other people do not pertain to you.
00:02:37 So it's very narcissistic, really.
00:02:39 It is entirely narcissistic. It's a kind of showing off. It's a performance of virtue and conscience. And it's showing off your awareness of the big issues. And you're not partisan. You may have been born into a country, but you're not trapped by it. You're greater than that country. Yeah, it's total narcissism.
00:03:08 I mean, I think citizen of the world must be the most self-aggrandizing label that anyone gives to themselves.
00:03:16 And, in fact, people who call themselves that, do they give themselves that label?
00:03:21 No one else does.
00:03:22 I am a citizen of the world, as it were.
00:03:24 I am not just of this place, as it were.
00:03:27 Well, also claiming that for yourself is peculiar when, if there is such a thing as citizen of the world, then that applies to everybody.
00:03:35 Yes, exactly, exactly.
00:03:38 When do you think, I mean, you grew up in the United States,
00:03:42 I grew up with it here, this kind of level of basic,
00:03:46 you know, there's a sort of cultural self-hatred, really.
00:03:50 And here, a lot of the time, people would say,
00:03:52 oh, well, this is the British being reticent about their pastures.
00:03:55 No.
00:03:56 I'd say there's a difference between being reticent, you know,
00:03:58 and kind of being understated and all of that stuff.
00:04:03 But what I think you see increasingly is this kind of desire
00:04:07 to actually dismantle, this desire to actually annihilate, actually, in a way, the past or your
00:04:15 country or whatever? Yeah, it is a strange impulse. Ultimately, it's rather anarchic.
00:04:25 But where do you think, if we both know what we're talking about, how did this originate?
00:04:31 you know, it wasn't the case presumably for our parents' generation?
00:04:35 No, World War II brought out something in most people in relation to their country.
00:04:44 Right.
00:04:45 Countries mattered in World War II, and countries saved other countries.
00:04:52 And so it's definitely a post-war phenomenon.
00:04:58 I'm not a good enough historian to explain the forces of it, I just can only respond
00:05:08 to it in relation to its psychology, and it is definitely a claiming of superiority in
00:05:19 writhing pretend hair shurdery you know all of this stuff about about how guilty
00:05:35 the West feels these people who promote Western guilt they don't feel personally
00:05:43 guilty. They don't feel guilty. They feel smug. Because they know all the evils that the West
00:05:50 has been guilty of and that makes them superior. I often find these big public apologies that
00:06:04 Western leaders have sometimes made for slavery or, you know, oh, it's just, they don't feel
00:06:11 sorry. They didn't do anything. And they know they didn't do anything. And these people who
00:06:18 claim to feel guilty know they didn't do anything. They didn't enslave anybody personally. They're
00:06:24 not, they're not responsible for slavery. They didn't kill any Indians, you know, it's fake.
00:06:33 It's emotionally fake.
00:06:35 And that's, I mean, as a person and as a novelist,
00:06:38 I have to say I have a real sensitivity to emotional falsity.
00:06:46 And that's what really puts me off about the hard left.
00:06:51 They're fake.
00:06:52 And all the emotions they claim for themselves are stand-ins for something else.
00:06:56 You could actually put together a little set of equations.
00:06:59 on a couple of occasions you was it you've taken them on even if maybe not intentionally you say
00:07:07 the hard left or whatever but this institutionalized approach right right if you're talking about
00:07:13 identity politics for example which we all apparently seem to have to now um i would say
00:07:19 they spring from the same kind of impulse don't they that they they're all about they're about
00:07:23 your position in the pantheon of victimhood in a way, aren't they?
00:07:29 Well, of course, this has been much discussed.
00:07:33 For some reason, no matter how much we despair of this way of thinking,
00:07:39 it doesn't go away.
00:07:41 You know, and we're raising whole generations now
00:07:49 to believe that you have to be able to feel sorry for yourself to have any power.
00:07:55 You have to have some terrible disadvantage.
00:08:00 Honestly, I think one of the things that the Me Too movement has been about
00:08:03 is a bunch of white women discovering their disadvantage
00:08:07 and glorying in their victimhood
00:08:12 because hitherto white women have been only this far from the bottom
00:08:18 on the victimhood totem pole.
00:08:21 So it's been really exhilarating
00:08:23 to be able to feel sorry for yourself
00:08:26 and to celebrate how badly you've been treated.
00:08:32 You made a speech, it was a few years ago,
00:08:35 at the Brisbane Literary Festival, I think it was.
00:08:39 Yes.
00:08:40 And it was about an aspect of this,
00:08:42 which is something we're hearing about cultural appropriation.
00:08:46 this idea is somehow that
00:08:49 I guess we've got to keep in our own silos
00:08:52 or whatever it was
00:08:53 but can you tell us about that
00:08:54 because a lot of people were very angry
00:08:56 at what you said
00:08:59 Yeah, to my astonishment
00:09:01 I mean, this concept has taken off since then
00:09:06 and I even worry that I may have helped it along
00:09:09 just by opposing it
00:09:11 When I first wrote that speech, I was worried that it would be basically setting up a straw man
00:09:24 because it was such a stupid concept that I was opposing that its illegitimacy seemed self-evident.
00:09:33 Basically, I worried that the speech was going to be boring.
00:09:36 Right, okay.
00:09:37 And I guess in the end, it was anything but.
00:09:39 No, no, quite.
00:09:40 But, you know, I think that, alas, the concept has spread enough that it doesn't need a lot of explaining.
00:09:49 But the idea is that you may not borrow from other cultures without, you know, you look up the definition,
00:09:58 without permission, anything to do with that culture and how one seeks that permission is utterly mystifying.
00:10:07 And this comes, doesn't it, from the idea...
00:10:10 Well it actually originated hilariously
00:10:12 in the fashion industry.
00:10:14 Right.
00:10:15 Whether or not white people can wear dreadlocks
00:10:18 or can designers borrow fashions from Japan or India
00:10:27 and play with those concepts in their clothes?
00:10:30 And of course my answer is yes, why not?
00:10:33 But isn't this...
00:10:33 Whom are they hurting?
00:10:34 Isn't this meant to be the whole point
00:10:36 in a way of multiculturalism
00:10:39 Or, you know, we're meant to celebrate diversity.
00:10:43 You would think.
00:10:44 And the thing is, is that what is one of the things that is used most to talk about this whole area?
00:10:50 It is food, isn't it?
00:10:51 It's cuisine.
00:10:52 Right.
00:10:52 So I think you've made this point.
00:10:54 What about, therefore, London is full of different ethnic restaurants, different cuisine?
00:11:02 Is that appropriation?
00:11:04 Oh, obviously.
00:11:04 I mean, if you take the concept seriously, basically you just have to stay home because anything you do or say or imitate or buy is a kind of stealing.
00:11:19 It's a dysfunctional idea on every level.
00:11:23 First of all, how do you define a culture?
00:11:26 What is a culture?
00:11:28 Most people have no idea.
00:11:29 I kind of had no idea what a culture is.
00:11:32 It doesn't have any boundaries.
00:11:33 It's a very mushy concept, and insofar as there is any such thing as a coherent culture,
00:11:41 you know, American black culture or Indian culture or Pakistani culture, fine.
00:11:48 Let's presume there is something to it.
00:11:51 They're constantly interacting.
00:11:53 We constantly borrow from each other, and I would also argue that basically the whole world belongs to you during the time you are alive.
00:12:11 These other cultures, these other people out there doing different things and saying different things and having different traditions are part of your experience, and therefore they belong to you.
00:12:22 We're not alive for very long and while we're here, we own the world.
00:12:27 We own all our own, all our experience and all our perceptions of others.
00:12:33 So and besides which, you know, I'm big on the concept of play.
00:12:39 My career is all built on play.
00:12:42 Why can't we play with each other's toys?
00:12:46 But it seems that at the basis of this, something which is extremely important, which I would have thought as a writer is probably one of the most important things facing you, is the idea that only particular people can tell particular stories, isn't it?
00:13:03 That's what is behind the whole cultural appropriation.
00:13:05 Interestingly, when I gave that speech,
00:13:07 virtually no one was claiming that fiction writers
00:13:10 couldn't tell stories from the point of view of characters
00:13:16 that were very different from themselves,
00:13:17 including of a different race or religion.
00:13:22 And within short order,
00:13:25 because I was basically just trying to head that off,
00:13:28 because if you applied it to fiction,
00:13:30 then that would be the case,
00:13:32 that you wouldn't be allowed to write from the perspective of other people.
00:13:39 And in short, yes, indeed, that's exactly what happened,
00:13:42 that suddenly we had this notion in the literary world
00:13:49 that it was a very dangerous thing to do
00:13:52 to write from the perspective of another group of people.
00:13:57 And then they even fashioned this creepy expression,
00:14:00 stay in your lane stay in your lane but this negates virtually our entire culture doesn't it
00:14:10 I mean it doesn't mean well it negates whole careers it negates fiction it means it's the
00:14:14 end of fiction it you know one of the things you're not supposed someone like me is no longer
00:14:19 allowed to use
00:14:22 A-A-V-E
00:14:24 African American Vernacular English.
00:14:29 So how would that actually
00:14:30 in practice? In my work. So that means that if I have
00:14:33 black, say black American characters
00:14:37 who have a kind of street way of talking
00:14:41 they have to have perfectly correct English because
00:14:44 I'm not allowed to avail myself of how they actually talk.
00:14:47 and basically I have to write bad fiction
00:14:50 and I have to write bad dialogue
00:14:51 and it cannot have any sense of verisimilitude about it.
00:14:58 This is no way to be.
00:14:59 This is no way to read.
00:15:01 I mean, it's no fun.
00:15:07 And most importantly, you know, who says?
00:15:10 This is, I think, what's most important
00:15:13 and this goes beyond cultural appropriation
00:15:16 and it has to do with all these different new little rules that seem to be coming down the pipeline,
00:15:23 applying to not just to writers, but basically to everyone.
00:15:27 Who says? Who says? Who's handing down these rules?
00:15:32 And what bothers me is the way in which we're empowering, I don't know,
00:15:40 some 19-year-old in a bedroom with a Twitter account to tell us what to do.
00:15:45 And little by little, some of these shrill opinions about what you're allowed, they're filtering into schools and places of employment and publishers, and suddenly these rules achieve institutional reality.
00:16:07 Are people scared? I mean, are publishers scared? Are people who would write, are they kind of therefore nervous about what they're going to write?
00:16:14 Yeah, I think right now they are.
00:16:17 I'm a little nervous.
00:16:20 You also had a bit of a run, did you not, with a publisher with Penguin.
00:16:26 It was something about they wanted to, it was promote diversity in their authors or something,
00:16:32 but almost in a kind of arbitrary way, wasn't that right?
00:16:35 It wasn't arbitrary, it was mathematical.
00:16:37 Right, okay.
00:16:38 And I got into big trouble for this, but I was sent this posy email that went to the agents of all of their authors.
00:16:52 and it was proclaiming that it was their intention by 2025 to achieve a perfect reflection of the UK population mathematically
00:17:09 in relation to gender, sexual preference, race, ethnicity, disability, and class, right, and class.
00:17:20 So, for example, they were no longer going to have any educational requirements whatsoever of the staff they hired,
00:17:30 which I wasn't sure was an indictment of publishing or English education.
00:17:36 But this just doesn't make, this is just crazy. It doesn't make any sense.
00:17:40 The complexity boggled the mind. It seemed completely impractical.
00:17:46 And furthermore, it did not seem remotely in the interest of publishing good books.
00:17:50 Right? And so I made fun of it. But there were a couple lines taken out of context and because there's a certain cabal out there that's, you know, hungry for new enemies, what I said was twisted around to be anti-diversity.
00:18:10 And, you know, I thought I wanted to preserve publishing for white people, and I was, the ridicule, which was very specifically aimed at the publishing company and its dopey new policy, was twisted around to be aimed at diverse writers.
00:18:33 So, you know, I was making fun of diverse writers.
00:18:37 It was, but, you know, in some ways it was interesting
00:18:41 because I think this is happening to a lot of people.
00:18:45 That's, in some ways, the nature of social media.
00:18:48 It's a forum that is very good at taking things out of context
00:18:53 and little snippets.
00:18:55 It's oriented towards little snippets.
00:18:57 and it was probably importantly informative to discover
00:19:05 how people are now eager to project on what you write
00:19:13 whatever they want to, the better to deplore it, right?
00:19:18 So it didn't matter what I had really written,
00:19:21 it mattered what they said I had written
00:19:24 And that was a discouraging revelation, because you cannot defend yourself against what you didn't say.
00:19:39 And for me, I did a second column on this and addressed the fact that, especially for a professional writer,
00:19:47 This was the ultimate hell because it means language doesn't function.
00:19:57 It means words just don't mean anything.
00:20:00 If people can twist what you write enough, then there is no point in writing anything
00:20:07 because someone else is really writing it for you.
00:20:11 They're going to project onto you what they wish to read and what they wish to see.
00:20:17 And in that case, the whole exercise is out the window.
00:20:20 I mean, you might as well just watch TV.
00:20:24 Again, what it also means is that you, you know,
00:20:28 you can't give your characters things to say.
00:20:30 Isn't that right?
00:20:31 I mean, you know, the...
00:20:33 Oh, that's another issue.
00:20:34 Yeah.
00:20:35 One of the things that I use in novels,
00:20:38 because I do sometimes take on larger social issues,
00:20:41 is having characters disagree with each other
00:20:46 or having a character take an extreme view,
00:20:50 which may be the kind of logical end point
00:20:53 of a certain direction.
00:20:55 And you can get a sense of dimension and energy
00:21:00 by having people represent views
00:21:04 that are not necessarily the authors.
00:21:06 The trouble is that lately literary criticism, insofar as there is any, has become so crude
00:21:16 that now people just interpret everything in the book as the voice of the author.
00:21:25 Yes, exactly. Yes, exactly.
00:21:28 Just describing something or stating something immediately is seen as a position, isn't it?
00:21:32 Yes.
00:21:33 even by just describing.
00:21:34 I know that happened with Michel Houlebecq in France,
00:21:37 definitely, very, very much so.
00:21:40 I suppose that what this means, really,
00:21:43 is that you are seen as an anomaly, surely,
00:21:47 in literary circles.
00:21:50 I mean, I think they see you as being the person
00:21:53 to talk to about, as it were,
00:21:58 politically incorrect things in that crude way.
00:22:01 Isn't that right?
00:22:02 I mean, no other writer does.
00:22:06 I mean, no other, I don't know any artist who does.
00:22:10 I mean, I really ask you, why not?
00:22:12 I do feel kind of lonely in the political position that I end up occupying,
00:22:18 and I don't understand why, out of sheer self-interest,
00:22:22 other writers, especially other fiction writers,
00:22:25 don't voice many of the same viewpoints.
00:22:29 I mean, freedom, ultimately, we're still talking about the broader issue of freedom of speech.
00:22:37 And it's really important for people who express themselves for a living to be given maximum latitude.
00:22:46 And I just get the impression that an awful lot of my colleagues have traded in the liberty of their profession for a cozy group membership.
00:23:05 Well, I worked in the arts for quite a long time as a journalist and program maker, and there certainly was a group thing even then.
00:23:13 I mean, there's no question about it.
00:23:16 Thank you, Lana, very much.
00:23:18 I think very shortly, or in May, I think it's May 22nd,
00:23:22 I think you're going to be discussing in London,
00:23:25 you're going to be part of a panel talking about identity politics, I think.
00:23:29 Isn't that right?
00:23:30 Yeah, it's actually a formal debate for Intelligence Squared,
00:23:35 and the proposition is something like identity politics is tearing society apart.
00:23:41 Right, okay.
00:23:42 Of course, the answer is yes, and then everyone can go home.
00:23:45 Okay, right.
00:23:46 I agree. Intelligence Squared in May 22nd.
00:23:50 Lionel, thank you very, very much again for coming on.
00:23:54 Great conversation.
00:23:56 Thanks very much for watching.
00:23:57 So what you're saying is, please do subscribe, won't you?
00:24:01 That would be our lifeblood.
00:24:03 It's absolutely free.
00:24:05 And see you next time.
00:24:07 Thank you.
00:24:16 You