New Culture Forum - April 16, 2019


15. Julia Hartley-Brewer: Bringing Common Sense To The Culture Wars

14. Lionel Shriver [Part 2] : Identity Politics & ‘Cultural Appropriation’ 16. Deadly silence: The unreported persecution of Christians

Episode Stats


Length

37 minutes

Words per minute

199.75

Word count

7,531

Sentence count

331


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 hello and welcome to so what you're saying is i'm peter whittle now my guest today is one of
00:00:11 britain's best-known commentators and broadcasters julia hartley brewer started as a reporter on the
00:00:17 east london advertiser in bethinal green then went on to write about politics for the standard
00:00:23 for the sunday express and for the guardian she's now host of the breakfast show on talk radio
00:00:29 She's very well known to us from her appearances on Question Time and throughout the media.
00:00:34 And she also features on those lists they regularly produce of the most influential right-wing people in Britain.
00:00:42 Thank you very much for coming. That's a bit of a starter, isn't it, Julia?
00:00:45 Absolutely. I didn't know I'd been so busy.
00:00:48 When you appear on, say, a list of the most prominent right-wing, what actually to you is right-wing?
00:00:56 Well, this is a funny thing. I don't think of myself as right-wing. I always say I'm not right-wing, I'm just right.
00:01:01 A lot of my views, actually, people on the right would say, you know, pinko lefty.
00:01:06 I'd rather like the NHS and things like that.
00:01:08 But I came from a Labour background.
00:01:11 My parents were involved in the Callaghan government, God rest their souls, and still alive, and an NHS GP mother.
00:01:19 So my background was very much on the left and very much supported to parties like the SDP, my teens.
00:01:25 and then I voted Lib Dem, I voted Labour,
00:01:28 I voted Conservative, I voted UKIP,
00:01:30 European elections in the past.
00:01:32 So I consider myself to be a floating voter.
00:01:34 So, you know, I think people should be locked up
00:01:36 if they commit crimes.
00:01:38 I think people need benefits if they're disabled.
00:01:40 I think my views are actually remarkably mainstream.
00:01:43 But for the media, because the media class,
00:01:46 their views aren't mainstream,
00:01:48 they're actually much to the left.
00:01:49 They think everybody who thinks, for instance,
00:01:51 a prison sentence might be appropriate
00:01:53 for someone who's burgled someone else,
00:01:54 They think you're right wing or, you know, God forbid, having a limit on the number of people who can walk into the country and make their homes here.
00:02:00 These aren't, I don't think these are remotely right wing issues or left wing issues.
00:02:05 I think these are just sensible political views.
00:02:08 Well, you mentioned that. I mean, you're from Birmingham, aren't you?
00:02:11 Born in Birmingham, yes.
00:02:14 Were you always politically interested?
00:02:16 Always. Yeah. So parents are always involved in politics.
00:02:19 Yeah, I went to school in 1979 at the age of 11
00:02:24 with a Win with Jim t-shirt, Jim Callahan t-shirt.
00:02:27 So I've been on the losing side many times.
00:02:29 Yeah, always, always politically interested.
00:02:31 Thought for quite a long time I would go into politics
00:02:34 and then realised actually it was going to be a better life
00:02:37 as a journalist commenting on it.
00:02:38 I've also got a 12-year-old daughter now who's still and distant.
00:02:41 I'm not allowed to go into politics until she's left home.
00:02:44 But what, you know, you've just brought forward what you believe.
00:02:49 The fact is, you know, being called right-wing now...
00:02:53 Yeah, it's an insult.
00:02:54 It's a sort of insult.
00:02:54 Even your average Tory, I think, would consider it an insult now,
00:02:58 wouldn't you say?
00:02:58 Yeah.
00:02:59 When, I mean, if you go back to, say, like 1979,
00:03:02 when you went to school or throughout the 80s,
00:03:05 was it the case then, do you think,
00:03:06 or has this got worse in your lifetime?
00:03:08 I think there's always been a little bit from the left and the right
00:03:11 where the left, you know, the right may be competent
00:03:13 and get the job done, but the left are good people
00:03:15 and they mean well.
00:03:17 And there's always been this thing,
00:03:18 but it's got worse and worse and worse now
00:03:20 that we're the good people on the left,
00:03:22 you're the baddies.
00:03:23 This whole trope about never kissed a Tory
00:03:28 and things like that,
00:03:30 which I think is really, really weird.
00:03:32 And you just don't see the same level of vitriol
00:03:34 from the mainstream right.
00:03:36 They'll immediately point to, say,
00:03:38 Toby Robinson and talk about the far right.
00:03:41 These people aren't in the mainstream political arena.
00:03:44 But in terms of attitudes towards people
00:03:46 and debating people on the basis of
00:03:48 look, we both want the country to be a good place.
00:03:51 We want people to have productive, happy lives
00:03:53 and make choices for themselves
00:03:55 and children to get good education,
00:03:57 people to get good health,
00:03:57 get all these, the trains to run.
00:04:00 Now, it's no longer a debate about
00:04:02 how is, what's the best way of doing this?
00:04:05 How would we best go about getting the outcome we want?
00:04:08 Now, Conservatives, Labour, Lib Dems
00:04:10 will all come with different perspectives on that.
00:04:12 But the argument between left and right now is
00:04:14 we're good people on the left.
00:04:16 We want the right things.
00:04:17 Whatever you want,
00:04:18 even if it works you wanted it for the wrong reasons and and this idea that your motivations
00:04:22 are somehow evil if you're considered to be right-wing is a very new and i think very disturbing
00:04:28 development you see uh you peppered your sentences there with we want this to work well with the
00:04:35 country and we all want this but that sort of presupposes you feel that there's a country and
00:04:40 you're part of it isn't this the crucial thing yeah i mean you would call yourself a somewhere
00:04:45 or would you as opposed to an anywhere?
00:04:47 You know this David Goodhart thing?
00:04:48 Oh, this whole citizen of the world nonsense.
00:04:52 Yes, what is that?
00:04:53 I genuinely find that utterly bizarre.
00:04:55 It is totally normal and natural and desirable
00:04:59 that we should care more about what happens to our immediate families
00:05:03 and then our immediate neighbours, our colleagues, our friends,
00:05:06 people we know through school or something, and workplace.
00:05:09 And you widen this out and widen this out to people from your local area.
00:05:13 Oh, did you hear about that terrible crime?
00:05:14 it's a lady down my street that it happened to oh that man do you know what happened to him he's
00:05:19 from my hometown we feel this affinity with people because we have a connection to them
00:05:24 and the idea that I shouldn't care more about what happens to people who live in my own country
00:05:29 more than people who live in another country I find quite bizarre um yeah I mean so much about
00:05:33 what is considered to be right-wing now is is patriotism a belief in the nation state a belief
00:05:38 that we have an affinity with each other,
00:05:42 a culture, not just a past, but a future with each other.
00:05:46 And this is somehow dirty and nasty and evil and wrong.
00:05:50 And I think the vast majority of people in this country
00:05:54 look at those debates and just think, frankly,
00:05:56 the political and media class have gone stock, staring mad.
00:05:59 This political and media class that...
00:06:02 Of which I am a fully paid-up member.
00:06:03 Of which you move in, and I do too.
00:06:06 frankly it seems to me that they don't even understand what you're talking about when you
00:06:11 talk about these things it's not just they disagree they just don't get it i mean we saw
00:06:16 this to be not with the you know brexit campaign or the remain campaign yeah it was all economics
00:06:22 yes because everyone everyone's going to vote only on economics and they never understood that
00:06:26 well people didn't vote to be poor or well they didn't they didn't believe project fear but also
00:06:30 they did in that vote in that choice as people often do in their voting and as they do in their
00:06:35 daily lives they made choices about what matters to them and actually yeah living in a local
00:06:41 community where you can get your kid into the local school and where you're sitting in the
00:06:45 doctor's surgery and some people might actually speak English no one does in my local surgery
00:06:49 in London where you you actually know people on the street who've lived there for years
00:06:55 that this the sense of community is actually more important to people than earning an extra
00:07:00 grand a year and these are people who earning an extra grand a year will make a big difference to
00:07:04 They're not earning that, you know, for 10 minutes work like Tony Blair does for a speech.
00:07:09 And it's about, I suppose it is about what you value.
00:07:12 And I suppose it's about what you believe in.
00:07:14 And it's got very little to do with money.
00:07:18 And which is why that remain argument on money was never going to work.
00:07:21 And it won't work if there's a second referendum.
00:07:23 But the thing is, is that they haven't changed their tune, have they?
00:07:26 Wouldn't you say that over the past two years, all the arguments seem to have been entirely economic and they still are?
00:07:31 Yeah, absolutely.
00:07:32 But it's almost like, is money the only thing that motivates these people who, of course, are better than us because they voted Remain?
00:07:39 I had my very first falling out almost three years after the referendum.
00:07:43 I had my first falling out with a friend over Brexit the other day.
00:07:46 And it was really quite upsetting.
00:07:48 And she said, oh, no, we'll just agree never to speak about it.
00:07:50 And I said, how can we be friends if we can't have a debate about this?
00:07:54 I said, I completely respect you for voting Remain and I'd like you to respect me for voting Leave.
00:07:58 but fundamentally you think that I'm neither as clever nor as nice as you thought I was
00:08:06 because I voted Leave.
00:08:07 There must be something slightly wrong with me to have voted Leave.
00:08:12 Well, there's something slightly wrong with 17.4 million of us
00:08:15 and I, for one, am just fed up of being told we're ignorant, we're stupid,
00:08:19 we didn't know what we were voting for, we were conned, we were lied to
00:08:23 and we're xenophobic and racist and little England.
00:08:26 Uneducated.
00:08:27 Yeah, I must remember to tell that to my tutor at Oxford.
00:08:29 Yes, well, this is the point.
00:08:30 He probably would think that.
00:08:32 The interesting thing as well is that when David Goodhart
00:08:34 was talking about anywheres and somewheres,
00:08:36 this was a big thing, that if you were educated,
00:08:38 you're more likely to be, well, a Remainer, but also in anywhere.
00:08:43 But what about those of us who are educated to the gills or what have you?
00:08:47 Well, I would consider myself a somewhere.
00:08:48 You know, I care about, I feel, you know, for my country,
00:08:52 I'm patriotic and I'm in London, all those sorts of things.
00:08:55 I feel those affinities.
00:08:56 Again, I think somehow the Remainers who feel that way,
00:09:00 there'll be plenty of Remainers who don't feel like they're citizens of Europe,
00:09:04 but I think they just think there's something rather tacky and nasty about nationalism.
00:09:08 For them, like Emily Thornberry, when I see an England flag, that just means someone's racist.
00:09:14 They don't understand why we're so excited about World Cups and European Cups
00:09:18 because we're allowed to fly our national flag with pride
00:09:21 and you're not instantly sort of, hello, hello, dodgy.
00:09:25 I can't believe there's any other country in the world
00:09:28 that the flag for our country of England is,
00:09:31 that their flag would be seen as a symbol of negativity
00:09:33 or something to be ashamed of.
00:09:35 I think that says an awful lot about our country.
00:09:37 You fly the Welsh flag in Wales, that's fine.
00:09:39 You fly the St Andrews flag in Scotland, oh, that's wonderful.
00:09:43 That's all about patriotism.
00:09:45 You fly it in England and you're a nasty racist.
00:09:49 What does that say about the attitude that has driven that?
00:09:52 Well, you know, there's that famous quote from Orwell.
00:09:56 He said that the English intelligentsia are unique in the world
00:09:59 in having a distaste for their own nationality.
00:10:02 Anything to do with English things, English taste, what have you.
00:10:05 Well, it's all wrapped up with this colonial guilt, white guilt.
00:10:09 I mean, Jon Snow on Channel 4 the other day.
00:10:11 Oh, that was important.
00:10:12 Talking about, you know, at the end of the Leave Means Leave rally,
00:10:14 I've never seen so many white people in one place.
00:10:17 What, didn't you cover the Remain rally last week?
00:10:19 which was you know
00:10:20 white
00:10:21 but you know what
00:10:22 I think you tweeted
00:10:23 the Hayes Festival
00:10:24 he was at the Hayes Literary Festival
00:10:25 I said he must have been
00:10:26 really shocked at the Hayes
00:10:27 and you know
00:10:28 and the Glastonbury Festival
00:10:29 where he'd attended
00:10:30 a couple of years ago
00:10:31 when he was shouting
00:10:31 you know
00:10:32 F the Tories
00:10:32 look at the pictures
00:10:35 of that crowd
00:10:35 but the idea
00:10:36 that in some way
00:10:37 this is worth
00:10:38 A. pointing out
00:10:39 and B. with the
00:10:41 again the nudge nudge
00:10:42 of isn't this ghastly
00:10:43 they're all white
00:10:44 90% of the country
00:10:46 is white
00:10:47 it's irrelevant
00:10:48 actually I was at
00:10:48 the Leave Means Leave
00:10:49 rally there were plenty of people of colour in the in the audience but but even if they weren't
00:10:53 it's irrelevant because this is interesting i'm not judging the whether a cause is good or bad
00:10:58 by the colour of the people the skin of the people talking about it actually the you're talking about
00:11:04 the rally last week which was uh the you know to uh the brexit rally in parliament square you spoke
00:11:10 at that i did terrifying never never done a speech at a political rally i mean you said you you didn't
00:11:15 want to be active in politics but i mean what what does that feel like well again i i was very
00:11:20 careful to ascertain that it was a cross-party uh issue and again so i mean i i'm i have a radio
00:11:25 show national radio we we have ofcom rules i can't be seen to be as affiliated with any political
00:11:30 party and and i'm not i genuinely am a floating voter but um i felt it was just something i felt
00:11:35 so so important and it transcends politics this this isn't about oh i think one party is better
00:11:40 than another party this is about I think democracy is better than not having democracy and I am so
00:11:46 angry and so horrified by what our MPs are doing and unelected lords right now are doing and the
00:11:53 arrogance with which they are telling the country well we made a terrible mistake we thought we
00:12:00 could trust you to do what we told you to do in the referendum and you didn't you silly stupid
00:12:04 people so we're going to have to take it back from you and make things better because you're not
00:12:08 trusted and i think that the damage that's going to be done to our country for decades as a result
00:12:14 of that is going to be huge i don't think they understand what they have done what do you think
00:12:21 how do you see it working out in that way because this is to me is this a fundamental my attitude
00:12:26 now to to my country or should i say its institutions has fundamentally changed
00:12:31 my trust in the democratic
00:12:35 principles of this country
00:12:37 has fundamentally changed
00:12:38 I worked in the Commons for years
00:12:40 we've both been around lots of politicians
00:12:42 I'm actually someone who will defend politicians
00:12:44 I think they do a tough job
00:12:45 it's not that well paid compared to lots of other jobs they could get
00:12:47 it's long hours, it's a difficult job
00:12:49 it never occurred to me
00:12:52 during 2016
00:12:53 it never occurred to me for one minute
00:12:55 that they wouldn't accept the outcome of the referendum
00:12:57 this is the equivalent of say
00:12:59 Jeremy Corbyn getting in at the next general
00:13:01 election perfectly possible it could happen and and all the MPs basically say no no no just because
00:13:07 he's got a majority no no no we're not going to let him move into number 10 we're just not going
00:13:10 to let it happen we're going to have to get everyone to vote again now that's inconceivable
00:13:14 yeah well well is it now is it we they're willing to overturn a referendum itself we've had Yvette
00:13:20 Cooper sponsoring a bill going through the House of Commons in a day and now through the Lords
00:13:23 saying you know basically trying to stop Brexit openly blatantly stopping Brexit extending
00:13:28 extending stopping a no-deal Brexit she stood at the election the last election not only on a
00:13:34 manifesto commitment from Labour which said they would deliver Brexit a different slightly different
00:13:38 version but nevertheless less a recognisable Brexit and put out her own election leaflet
00:13:43 saying in exact words I will not block Brexit yes and then she brings in a bill and and instead of
00:13:50 her being castigated in the media and and and being treated as the prior she should be for this
00:13:56 In any other way, I've actually been very admiring of her as a politician.
00:13:59 She's treated as sort of the saviour.
00:14:01 Oh, well, thank goodness, in fact, Cooper's doing this.
00:14:04 And again, I think that the media class are in on it,
00:14:06 the establishment are in on it, the civil service,
00:14:09 the politicians, they're all in on it.
00:14:10 And it's basically a saving the British people from themselves attitude.
00:14:15 You reported on politics for a long time.
00:14:18 You were a political correspondent.
00:14:20 A political editor for 10 years, yeah.
00:14:21 I mean would you
00:14:23 you don't miss that part
00:14:26 of reporting, I mean if you were reporting
00:14:28 this, it's what I'm saying, it would
00:14:30 be tough wouldn't it, isn't it better to
00:14:32 be a commentator? I much prefer being a commentator
00:14:33 yeah I moved into that
00:14:34 deliberately actually, but
00:14:37 again there are an awful lot of people
00:14:39 on the TV now, BBC, Sky
00:14:42 and others who, I've got
00:14:44 a pretty good idea how they voted
00:14:46 when it came to the referendum
00:14:47 I mean some of them I know how they voted
00:14:49 because they've told me and I'm amazed at how many senior people in the media
00:14:54 are like, I can't believe you voted for Brexit, you're insane, why would you do that?
00:14:58 That is the general view of people working in the media
00:15:01 and I think the reporting, the coverage of this issue has been so unbelievably biased
00:15:07 and I think people are waking up to it and I think the BBC are not going to come out of this well.
00:15:13 Do you think, I mean when people call into your show...
00:15:16 We don't do many phone-ins on a breakfast show.
00:15:18 It's far less of a phone-in, but we have lots and lots of guests.
00:15:21 Do you think, though, that from the feedback you get from the public,
00:15:25 that the penny has dropped about the media?
00:15:27 I mean, my feeling is that it was in the past,
00:15:30 it was Tory MPs usually saying,
00:15:32 the Today programme doesn't give us as much time as Labour MPs.
00:15:35 But it's not quite, it's much bigger than that now, isn't it?
00:15:38 It's much bigger.
00:15:39 But I find it amazing there are still so many people who think,
00:15:41 for instance, the BBC is biased against Remain.
00:15:43 I mean, I don't know what stations they've been listening to.
00:15:46 Look, I love the BBC.
00:15:47 I watch these and listen to their output.
00:15:50 But I tell you what it is, they don't hear it themselves.
00:15:54 They don't know it.
00:15:55 They live in such a bubble.
00:15:56 I know this because I've sat there in production meetings
00:15:59 and they don't know anybody who voted Leave.
00:16:03 They think they don't know anyone who voted Leave.
00:16:05 You could see their faces when the referendum result was announced.
00:16:07 The BBC, they were sitting there in shock.
00:16:09 Who are all these ghastly people?
00:16:11 Wasn't anyone they met?
00:16:13 It must be a fix.
00:16:14 They live in a complete bubble of Ramona.
00:16:17 I mean, I live in Ramona Central in North London.
00:16:19 They live in a complete bubble.
00:16:21 They don't know anybody who would admit to them they voted Leave.
00:16:24 They will know people.
00:16:25 They just are too afraid to say it because they don't want to be accused of being a racist or stupid.
00:16:29 But I don't even think, when they say we're not biased, they genuinely believe they're not.
00:16:34 They have no idea that their perspective is constantly going from,
00:16:38 they treat Eurosceptics like they're idiots, everything the EU says,
00:16:42 Anything Donald Tusk or Hofstadt or John Paul Juncker says
00:16:46 is treated as the word of God,
00:16:49 as engraved on a tablet and brought down from the mountain.
00:16:52 And they don't even hear it and see it themselves.
00:16:56 There was this, actually, again, I think you tweeted it, I certainly did.
00:17:00 The Romanists put a big sort of flag on the white cliffs of Dover or something,
00:17:06 and it was replied to by Hofstadt.
00:17:07 Saying it was SOS.
00:17:09 Yes, something like that.
00:17:10 I mean, I tweeted out someone as S-O-Z, Zos, we're leaving.
00:17:16 I don't know, I don't know how these people can live themselves.
00:17:20 The utter, the sort of, the self-degradation, the self-flagellation.
00:17:27 Self-flagellation.
00:17:27 I mean, it's embarrassing.
00:17:29 I want to give these people a hug.
00:17:32 I don't want to even angry at them.
00:17:33 It's the fact that they don't think that our country, uniquely in the world,
00:17:39 Fifth biggest trading nation in the world.
00:17:41 The idea that we can't rule ourselves,
00:17:44 that we can't possibly, possibly survive
00:17:46 without Liechtenstein and Belgium having a say
00:17:49 in how we run our country.
00:17:53 That's absolutely perplexing to me.
00:17:55 And yet these are the same people who say,
00:17:56 before 2016, we don't need to leave the EU.
00:17:59 It barely has any impact on our lives.
00:18:01 And now they're telling us, we can't leave the EU.
00:18:04 They're in control of everything.
00:18:06 Well, which is it?
00:18:06 The thing is that it used to be that when you had arguments with people who were pro-EU back in the old days,
00:18:13 essentially their attitude was, well, look, we see there are real problems with it.
00:18:17 We want to reform.
00:18:18 We want to reform.
00:18:18 We see there are real problems, democratic, deficit, etc., etc.,
00:18:21 but basically on balance, we want to stay in.
00:18:23 It was kind of, you could argue with it.
00:18:25 It's a perfectly reasonable position.
00:18:27 You could argue with it, but there are people now who seem to have an emotional attachment to this thing.
00:18:33 To Jean-Claude Juncker's drinks cabinet.
00:18:34 Yeah, it's quite, it's like the EU is this god, it's this saviour of our nation.
00:18:40 And it's what stands between us and sort of living like cavemen,
00:18:44 where we're, you know, we're going to be burning sort of immigrants at the stake
00:18:47 and living like, you know, post-Holocaust world.
00:18:52 It's utterly bizarre.
00:18:54 I mean, I think this, you know, the main reason why Ramoners,
00:18:57 and it's not Remainers, most people who voted Remain have perfectly good reasons to do so
00:19:00 and accept the democratic result.
00:19:02 Yeah, I agree with that.
00:19:03 That's why I use the term Ramonis, it's very different.
00:19:05 But most Ramonis, I think, are terrified of a no-deal Brexit
00:19:08 more than anything else in the world,
00:19:09 not because it would be a disaster,
00:19:11 because they secretly fear that the next day
00:19:14 would be exactly the same as the day before.
00:19:17 And they would be absolutely terrified that everything they have said
00:19:20 and everything that they believe,
00:19:22 and they've almost taught themselves to believe,
00:19:26 would turn out to be a lie.
00:19:28 And that England and Britain would just go on and do very, very well
00:19:31 and we'd have economic growth and we'd survive
00:19:33 and then we'd get a perfectly good free trade deal with Europe.
00:19:36 It's almost like they are terrified that that might actually happen
00:19:40 because then their EU god will fall before them.
00:19:44 But also all the other bricks in their pantheon of beliefs
00:19:46 would then start to look a bit shaky, wouldn't they?
00:19:49 I mean, this is the whole point.
00:19:50 It's almost like a religion.
00:19:52 It is.
00:19:53 You are on question time a lot.
00:19:55 Yes.
00:19:56 You, in some ways, you come right up against this imbalance
00:20:00 because you're on panels where
00:20:02 it's like, you know, like one Remainer
00:20:04 or maybe, sorry, one Brexit
00:20:06 or three Remainers or whatever, the audience
00:20:08 which nine times out of ten, I do
00:20:10 not know how they've been, I've done it myself, I've been on
00:20:12 Question Time, what have you
00:20:13 do you think with the BBC
00:20:16 because look, in a way Sky is
00:20:18 also, to me, has been a revelation in
00:20:20 how biased it's been, but with
00:20:22 the BBC, what do you see as being
00:20:24 like in the ten years time, the situation
00:20:26 with the BBC, do you think that
00:20:28 But would you be in favour of abolishing the licence fee?
00:20:31 Well, this is it.
00:20:32 Again, I mean, I think we should just be honest and just call it a tax,
00:20:34 which is what it is.
00:20:36 I've always been in favour of, you know, we should keep the BBC.
00:20:38 You know, I think it's done some wonderful work.
00:20:39 But now, to be honest with you, now people are getting their subscriptions,
00:20:43 whether it's to Sky or Amazon Prime or Netflix or, you know,
00:20:45 everyone else who's creating these.
00:20:48 I think there's going to be more and more people saying,
00:20:50 oh, hold on a minute, I'm not prepared to do this.
00:20:53 And certainly younger generations, my brother and sister,
00:20:55 in their 30s, they don't watch television from one year to the next.
00:21:00 And I think it is becoming more and more something of the older generation.
00:21:04 And eventually we're all going to be over 75
00:21:05 and there's going to be no one playing it anyway.
00:21:07 I have a funny feeling that it's going to fall by the wayside
00:21:10 more because of the pressures of online streaming and Netflix
00:21:14 than actually as a result of political action.
00:21:18 Because I think the BBC is such a strong sort of defender of the establishment.
00:21:23 Now, it used to be the Tory establishment.
00:21:25 and now it's a strong defender of the sort of liberal elite establishment,
00:21:28 they ain't going to let go of that quickly.
00:21:31 In this kind of environment, you know, where there is this, I would say, kind of group thing,
00:21:35 you mentioned civil service, the media, particularly in the media we're talking about,
00:21:40 and you have your voice.
00:21:44 When people go for you, you know, when they attack you, what's it like?
00:21:49 I mean, how do you handle that?
00:21:51 I mean, you know, I don't mean to make you sound infantile or anything, but how do you...
00:21:55 I've never been very good at playing a victim ever.
00:21:57 But every now and then, if you do, say, a question time,
00:22:00 very high profile, you get thousands of tweets,
00:22:02 every now and then you sort of, wow, oh, the victory.
00:22:04 If they decide to go for you, and especially when it's people you know,
00:22:07 people perhaps you've worked with in the past,
00:22:09 who you know you get on perfect, well, you see them at a party,
00:22:12 and then will gun for you on Twitter to please,
00:22:15 to get their likes on Twitter.
00:22:17 It can be a little bit sort of, well,
00:22:21 you find yourself taken aback by it, because it is overwhelming.
00:22:25 And there are some insults in particular that you have to stand up to.
00:22:29 I've had someone tweet, Julia's racist, pass it on to their 40,000 followers.
00:22:33 I called in lawyers.
00:22:34 In fact, I didn't have to call in lawyers.
00:22:35 Three QCs got in touch and said, would you like us to bring this case for you?
00:22:39 No, and I do know.
00:22:39 I said, you've got until 6pm to withdraw that.
00:22:42 I'm not going to have it stand.
00:22:43 I'm not racist.
00:22:44 You've got no basis on which to call me racist.
00:22:47 And, you know, I suggest you seek legal advice, which he clearly did.
00:22:50 But there are things I won't understand.
00:22:51 But if someone wants to call me, you know, vile, the B word, the C word, all versions of the C word,
00:22:57 frankly, I just, how I react normally is I normally just retweet it to my followers
00:23:03 and take the mick out of them about how good the Wi-Fi is in their mum's basement and things like that.
00:23:07 Because it is utterly ridiculous.
00:23:09 A few people have said, you know, feel free to come and say that to my face
00:23:13 because I have a funny feeling you won't be that brave.
00:23:15 But if people want to disagree and say, I think you're wrong, this is why you're wrong,
00:23:19 that's fine, and then I'll have the debate.
00:23:21 But, you know, every now and then it can be quite overwhelming.
00:23:25 But I genuinely take the view that, actually,
00:23:28 if you're upsetting them that much, you're probably doing a good job.
00:23:30 Do you ever, do you sort of come off Twitter ever?
00:23:33 Do you ever say to yourself, because you're a pretty prodigious Twitterer, aren't you?
00:23:37 I'm just, I'm a very fast hyper.
00:23:39 Oh, I see, OK.
00:23:40 And I can be on air interviewing someone and consult tweet.
00:23:42 I'm a big one on the multitasking, working mum and all that.
00:23:46 But I, generally on holiday, I do come off Twitter.
00:23:49 I certainly won't tweet about politics, but the amount of times I go away
00:23:52 and then something major happens.
00:23:54 But because politics and the news is my love and my hobby as well,
00:23:59 and my family are very into the news as well.
00:24:01 We all discuss politics around the dinner table.
00:24:04 My poor 12-year-old.
00:24:06 But she'll have therapy for years.
00:24:07 Is she interested in politics?
00:24:09 She is interested in politics, but she'll sometimes say to me things like,
00:24:12 you know, what do we think?
00:24:12 And I go, I think this, your dad thinks that.
00:24:15 You go away and read up and find out what you think.
00:24:17 I don't ever want her to think how I think.
00:24:21 That's not how I'm raising her.
00:24:23 So she'll probably have her,
00:24:24 I should probably become a sort of climate change activist
00:24:26 or something like that just to upset me.
00:24:29 But yeah, no, but it's, I think, no,
00:24:30 I think I do, I do just turn off.
00:24:33 You know, if I'm going out for dinner with my husband,
00:24:34 we don't, I don't sit on Twitter.
00:24:35 Phone goes, damn, have a lovely evening.
00:24:38 I think you do need to learn to switch off.
00:24:41 Absolutely.
00:24:41 Do you know, you obviously, you know,
00:24:43 know how to handle these people who come on,
00:24:45 you know, whatever, on Twitter or attack,
00:24:47 you say these things but quite recently there was a very very serious situation actually when we had
00:24:52 that appalling atrocity in New Zealand what was astonishing was they almost left no time at all
00:25:00 but the left I would say broadly speaking then started to lay the blame at conservative or
00:25:07 perceived conservative commentators and journalists and your name was up there wasn't it
00:25:11 that's not funny is it I mean oh no that was just well over the line and I certainly reacted
00:25:17 that and took that on on twitter this idea that because you've spoken out about immigration
00:25:23 because you have criticized aspects of the religion of islam some of the tenants and the
00:25:28 clothing for instance i'm opposed to the burqa and the niqab and would certainly have them banned
00:25:32 in this country along with i don't want to sit next to someone wearing a balaclava in a restaurant
00:25:35 either um because i could because it's subjugation of women um because i've spoken out about those
00:25:41 tenants somehow i have encouraged a complete lunatic murderous man on the other side of the
00:25:47 world to kill 50 innocent people in a mosque i mean you know that's absurd i know that's absurd
00:25:54 um and yes it is beyond a joke because when someone is saying you know i spent three and
00:26:00 a half hours on air talking about this horrific murder uh mass massacre and then have people say
00:26:06 well well it's people some people on the left who wanted to stir it up and what i find extraordinary
00:26:13 is that a just no sense of decency in trying to have the politics of this um but also the fact
00:26:21 that they genuinely seem to think that that that people criticizing a religion is the same as
00:26:29 someone i criticize the catholic religion i haven't encouraged any catholics to go and
00:26:33 or people who hope Catholics to go and massacre each other.
00:26:38 The thing in that in the same way is a reasonable response to that
00:26:42 would be someone picking up a weapon
00:26:43 and murdering 50 innocent men, women and children in a mosque.
00:26:46 These things are so separate.
00:26:48 They're like the Joe Cox murder, horrific murder by a neo-Nazi lunatic
00:26:52 who had been a neo-Nazi lunatic for years.
00:26:56 And the idea that because we were having a campaign
00:26:58 to become a democratically ruled sovereign nation state through Brexit,
00:27:01 that somehow had motivated this man
00:27:04 and was the reason why this man took the life of Joe Cox.
00:27:08 I think it's obscene that people should make those links.
00:27:11 I think even in that case, it was pretty shameless the way they did it.
00:27:14 And the British people knew it was, and that's one of the reasons why.
00:27:17 They just went, no, the polling show they thought that the Remain campaign
00:27:21 tried to use the murder to boost their vote,
00:27:25 which is a disgusting thing to do.
00:27:28 Do you think, though, that when they kind of make these,
00:27:31 when the left go, like they did in this particular case,
00:27:34 or indeed with Joe Cox,
00:27:36 isn't it also sort of a way they have
00:27:38 of trying to curtail and shut down general debate?
00:27:42 Oh, absolutely.
00:27:43 I mean, there is a problem, is there not,
00:27:44 with free speech increasingly in this country?
00:27:46 A huge problem.
00:27:47 And we brought a blasphemy law by default now,
00:27:50 only involving one religion.
00:27:52 This constant victimhood idea is ridiculous.
00:27:56 The idea that you can't say a single thing about anybody who...
00:27:59 you can criticise anyone who's white
00:28:02 a white male
00:28:03 if you're white and you're middle class
00:28:06 frankly you should probably just go
00:28:08 and kill yourself now, you're such a bad person
00:28:10 this identitarian
00:28:11 politics that we've got
00:28:13 people are representing
00:28:14 women or gay people
00:28:17 or Muslims or black people
00:28:19 I was raised
00:28:21 in a very liberal left family
00:28:23 to treat people as individuals
00:28:25 to judge people by how they
00:28:27 act and what they say
00:28:28 that's it that's it what's in the you know the character of your heart is more you know marjorie
00:28:33 the king said um now that the fact that we're supposed to judge everybody based on their skin
00:28:38 color or their religion goes or gender or gender fluidity or whatever it is goes against every one
00:28:44 of the liberal values i was raised with uh and i think it's it is very very dangerous and and the
00:28:50 idea that that people shouldn't be allowed to comment on something because they don't have the
00:28:54 correct skin colour, sexuality, gender, or whatever it is,
00:28:58 I think is really quite bizarre.
00:29:01 And I think the phrase Orwellian comes up an awful lot these days.
00:29:03 I don't think it does justice to what is going on right now
00:29:07 in terms of the de facto censorship of free speech.
00:29:12 Julie, you mentioned there being against the burka a bit earlier.
00:29:17 It seems to me that it's one of those issues,
00:29:22 a bit like FGM or whatever,
00:29:23 that your average guardianist or feminist
00:29:26 should be absolutely on the front line about.
00:29:29 Absolutely.
00:29:29 But they seem to be absent, don't they?
00:29:32 Yeah, I find it extraordinary.
00:29:33 Well, it's a woman's right to choose what she wears,
00:29:35 except that women don't get to choose to wear it
00:29:37 in most of the countries.
00:29:38 The fact that the vast majority of women
00:29:41 who are Muslim in this world
00:29:42 don't choose to wear the burqa or the niqab
00:29:45 and actually many huge, huge swathes
00:29:48 of the Muslim population around the world
00:29:49 don't choose to wear even the headscarf,
00:29:51 none of which are remotely required
00:29:53 in Islam, certainly not the face
00:29:55 coverings, I find it extraordinary that
00:29:57 there are women who consider themselves feminists
00:29:59 who will justify that
00:30:01 and it is an act, it's a
00:30:03 political ideology, the wearing
00:30:05 of the burqa, it's got nothing to do with Islam
00:30:07 it's not in the
00:30:09 Quran and it's
00:30:10 not in the Hadith in any
00:30:13 open or honest way, there are plenty
00:30:15 of Islamic scholars who
00:30:17 will say it's got nothing to do with Islam, I don't
00:30:19 like Boris Johnson referring to letterboxes
00:30:21 and I think that's not helpful
00:30:24 although our defence is right to use
00:30:25 whatever language he chooses
00:30:27 but no, I think that it is, I would absolutely
00:30:29 go down the same route that France has
00:30:31 and just say no, no, I don't want religious clothing
00:30:33 in schools, I don't want in the workplace and certainly
00:30:36 in Western culture, certainly
00:30:38 in British culture, when you're walking down
00:30:40 the street, unless there's a really good reason because it's
00:30:41 unbelievably cold and you're putting a scarf up over your face
00:30:44 to protect yourself from the ice and the snow
00:30:45 you show your face in public
00:30:48 and I don't think there's anything controversial
00:30:50 about that and we know the polling shows yes there's nothing controversial about that in fact
00:30:53 we're actually quite behind the curve these wonderful liberal eu countries yes exactly
00:30:58 all of which are bringing in these bands but they're doing that to protect their own culture
00:31:01 and this is what it comes down to is this idea that in some way criticizing aspects of islam is
00:31:06 is anti-muslim no it's not actually a lot of those aspects of islam are imposed on muslim
00:31:12 interestingly always muslim women who were treated in pretty much every majority muslim
00:31:18 country in the world are second-class citizens and you see these amazing videos of women in
00:31:22 Syria and Iraq and indeed in Iran showing they're having to take off the burqas they've been forced
00:31:27 to wear taking off their headscarves in Iran and being arrested for it and and yet and yet over
00:31:33 here we're saying it's a proud act of feminism for a woman to choose to cover her face it's bizarre
00:31:39 do you think I mean this is all part of the kind of identity politics that you just mentioned
00:31:43 earlier. It's a, I'm separate, I'm other, I'm different. Exactly. This is, it seems
00:31:48 to me, is the dominating theme of our politics now. Frankly, it seems to me that it cuts
00:31:55 society vertically, you know, into all these, it used to be class maybe, it used to be class.
00:32:01 What would you say is the way out of that? I think the way out of it is for people like
00:32:07 you, like me, and basically the sane majority to say, no, no, we're not going to put up
00:32:12 with this lunacy, for instance, saying
00:32:14 every child is gender fluid, not all
00:32:16 trans, we want people to live a happy
00:32:18 life, be your best self, but no
00:32:19 not every child isn't born
00:32:22 both male and female
00:32:24 no they're not, I have to accept the fact
00:32:26 that actually there are sometimes
00:32:28 competing rights
00:32:30 between our liberal western
00:32:32 values about freedom
00:32:34 of speech, against blasphemy
00:32:36 laws and against
00:32:37 women's rights and gay rights
00:32:40 and the like, mixed-race, mixed-faith marriages,
00:32:43 all these other things,
00:32:44 and that they come up against some values in some religions,
00:32:47 including Catholicism as well, where they compete.
00:32:50 And that's when we need to assert ourselves,
00:32:52 and we need to stop being guilty.
00:32:54 I think this, Douglas Murray has written about this
00:32:55 brilliantly in his book about the strange death of Europe,
00:32:59 this bizarrely unique sort of white European,
00:33:03 particularly British guilt about our culture,
00:33:06 about our history, about our values.
00:33:08 And we need to assert that, no,
00:33:09 our values are the best in the world believing that people are equal regardless of their faith
00:33:13 their gender their sexuality their their race what's to be ashamed of that and i think we need
00:33:20 to shout loudly about these values and and be willing to assert them and rather than feeling
00:33:25 oh well well he or she feels very strongly and i you know i'm british so i'll keep quiet and allow
00:33:32 our values to be trampled on because we do have a really strong history and a really strong tradition
00:33:38 and our values are in the liberal tradition
00:33:41 that will be, I think, the future.
00:33:42 But I think we need to fight for them
00:33:44 and there's nothing rude or wrong or bad or evil
00:33:48 about fighting for the liberal values of freedom of speech
00:33:53 and a freedom of religion
00:33:54 and freedom to be with who you want to be.
00:33:58 These are things worth fighting for
00:34:00 and I don't know why people are so embarrassed and shamed.
00:34:03 I think Rod Little we had on recently,
00:34:05 He said that the transgender issue was the turning point.
00:34:11 I think that's when the British public went, that's it, I'm out.
00:34:15 Well, I'm going to say, 12 years old, she's going off shopping, Topshop,
00:34:19 has, well, we have, you know, trans people can come into our changing rooms,
00:34:22 which is absolutely fine if someone's genuinely trans,
00:34:25 but if a man just wants to call on a dress and say, I'm trans,
00:34:28 and walk in, you know, completely intact, and walk into my daughter's changing room,
00:34:32 sorry, I've got a problem with that.
00:34:34 And actually most trans people would completely understand that.
00:34:38 Yes, I completely understand why you wouldn't be happy
00:34:40 with your 12-year-old daughter
00:34:41 and with a grown man with his genitals intact
00:34:44 who is in there for nefarious reasons.
00:34:48 This is just common sense stuff.
00:34:51 And this isn't about people not wanting trans people
00:34:54 to be free and be treated with equality and respect
00:34:59 and have rights.
00:35:00 It's just about, hold on.
00:35:02 hold on
00:35:04 but the thing is with these ideologies
00:35:06 is that they end up eating themselves in a way
00:35:08 because women's sport
00:35:11 is in serious trouble now
00:35:12 the array of pictures
00:35:14 I've been campaigning on this now for about a year
00:35:16 but the array of sports where
00:35:18 you see these women on the podiums in second and third place
00:35:21 and they're five foot tall
00:35:23 and then there's a six foot six
00:35:24 man pretending to be a woman
00:35:27 they haven't undergone
00:35:29 medical transformation even
00:35:31 sometimes not even any any drugs certainly not surgery and they they they have basically been
00:35:36 at a low level in men's sport they then say i'm a woman and they're able to compete yes women's
00:35:41 sport is over if this carries on and the women who've spoken out about it martina navratilova
00:35:46 i mean one of the strongest feminist and gay rights activists in the world of sport being
00:35:51 accused of being transphobic for simply saying um is this right i mean she basically is is this a
00:35:59 good idea. Yes, or people like Julie Bindor being no-platformed, have you ever been no-platformed?
00:36:06 I'm not aware of it, maybe I haven't been invited to things which I would have otherwise, but
00:36:09 I'd rather enjoy it, I mean I'd just turn up anyway, you know me, I always lack a bit
00:36:14 of trouble. But that's the thing, people shouldn't put up with it. I mean, but Germaine Greer
00:36:17 pointing out, you know. Oh, that's astonishing. She did it beautifully though, I have to say,
00:36:22 I can't quite remember the phrase. You know, a man who comes off his cork isn't a woman,
00:36:26 and he's a man without a cock.
00:36:27 I mean, it's crude, but...
00:36:31 To the point.
00:36:32 But it's true.
00:36:33 Yes, it's true.
00:36:34 It's true.
00:36:34 And I had a guest on my show the other day
00:36:36 who said, you know,
00:36:37 I introduced her as a trans woman.
00:36:39 Again, always would want to be polite
00:36:40 and say, if she prefers to be called she,
00:36:43 absolutely, it's a matter of just good manners
00:36:45 and respect.
00:36:47 And then she said, I'm a woman.
00:36:48 I said, you're not, you're a trans woman.
00:36:50 And I'm very happy to call you her
00:36:52 and she is a matter of respect
00:36:53 out of your choice of your life.
00:36:54 but she's had the surgery
00:36:57 but you're a trans woman
00:36:58 you're not a woman
00:36:59 I mean you're not
00:37:01 I'm not a coffee table
00:37:04 and you're not a woman
00:37:05 there are words that have meanings
00:37:09 and I think again
00:37:10 we've got to fight for words
00:37:12 to continue to have the same meaning
00:37:14 as they did when you got into the dictionary
00:37:17 I think the language has been sort of
00:37:18 captured in a way
00:37:19 I'm not a cis woman, I'm a woman
00:37:21 there you go, on that note
00:37:24 Julia thank you very very much
00:37:26 it's been great to have you
00:37:28 and I hope you come back as well
00:37:30 that's it for
00:37:32 what you're saying is this week
00:37:33 please do join our ever
00:37:36 growing list of subscribers
00:37:37 thank you to all those who already have
00:37:39 and we'll see you next time so thanks