New Culture Forum - April 21, 2019


16. Deadly silence: The unreported persecution of Christians

15. Julia Hartley-Brewer: Bringing Common Sense To The Culture Wars 17. Claire Fox - Brexit & Left

Episode Stats


Length

25 minutes

Words per minute

138.75

Word count

3,482

Sentence count

140


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to So What You're Saying Is. I'm Peter Whittle.
00:00:09 Now recently the New Culture Forum co-hosted a conference in London called Invisible Victims.
00:00:15 It was about the growing persecution of religious minorities around the world and indeed why we hear so little about it.
00:00:24 Now, with me to talk about this issue today is somebody who spoke very eloquently at the conference,
00:00:29 and that's Damien Thompson, who is Editor-in-Chief of the Catholic Herald.
00:00:35 Damien, this is going out around Easter time, it's kind of very appropriate, really,
00:00:40 but I think a lot of people won't even be aware of the problem of persecution of religious minorities.
00:00:49 Who, first of all, who are we talking about?
00:00:52 We're talking about people all over the world.
00:00:57 I think the first thing to say is that a tremendous number of Christians
00:01:00 aren't aware of the scale and the intensity and the unrelenting harassment
00:01:06 of the persecution of Christians.
00:01:10 They hear the phrase, the persecution of Christians,
00:01:13 they're vaguely aware it's going on, but until, for example,
00:01:18 they have seen the shocking photographs of Baroness Cox,
00:01:21 showed us at your brilliant conference.
00:01:25 It doesn't really hit home.
00:01:26 Perhaps it didn't hit home to me
00:01:28 until I attended that conference.
00:01:31 She showed us a picture, a lorry load
00:01:34 of the remains of slaughtered Christian women.
00:01:38 It's not until you learn something like the fact
00:01:42 that the Fulani herdsmen, herdsmen they're called,
00:01:47 Herdsmen, they're called, they're actually herdsmen who've become vicious Islamists in Nigeria,
00:01:53 have the habit of killing pregnant Christian women, disemboweling them, and then mutilating the fetus.
00:02:01 And that this is standard practice.
00:02:04 It's not until you learn these things that you realise the horrific intensity of the problem.
00:02:13 As for the scale of the problem, you'll forgive me, I'm going to have to read from a list.
00:02:19 Open Doors, the charity, produces a list in which there's countries in which there's extreme persecution of Christians,
00:02:32 very high and high.
00:02:35 So, extreme number one is North Korea, Afghanistan, Somalia, Libya, Pakistan, Sudan, Eritrea, Yemen, Iran, India, and Syria.
00:02:51 These are very different sorts of countries.
00:02:55 They're very different sorts of countries.
00:02:56 Most of them are Islamic countries.
00:02:59 They're also, with the exception of North Korea and one or two exceptions, perhaps India, they are genuinely war-torn.
00:03:12 Then if you move down to the list of places where Christian persecution is very high, you find Nigeria, Iraq, the Maldives,
00:03:22 favorite holiday destination of people who I'm sure are completely unaware that Christians are persecuted there,
00:03:28 Saudi Arabia, Egypt, Uzbekistan, Myanmar, Laos, Vietnam, Central African Republic, Algeria, Turkmenistan, Mali, Mauritania, Turkey, China, Ethiopia, Tajikistan, Indonesia, Jordan, Nepal, Bhutan, Kazakhstan, Morocco, Brunei, Tunisia, Qatar, Mexico, and Kenya.
00:03:54 Now, that's the very high category, and I won't bother going through the high persecution category.
00:04:02 But what is, first of all, have we got any idea of the numbers we're talking about?
00:04:08 No, we don't.
00:04:09 No, we know that they're very large.
00:04:13 It's difficult, because what is persecution of Christians?
00:04:17 Yes, exactly.
00:04:18 Clearly, the unimaginable slaughter of mostly Christians in Nigeria by these so-called herdsmen is...
00:04:31 We are talking hundreds, sir. I think there are hundreds, aren't there?
00:04:35 Over a period of a year, the past year, for example.
00:04:37 Oh, we're talking thousands.
00:04:38 Thousands.
00:04:40 And over a period of a couple of years.
00:04:44 They are worse than Boko Haram.
00:04:47 Remember when we used to hear that there were people who were worse than Al-Qaeda,
00:04:53 and we didn't really believe it, and then ISIS emerged?
00:04:56 Well, these people are worse than Boko Haram, worse than ISIS.
00:05:01 So, as I understand it, it's basically four out of five people who are persecuted for religion in the world are Christians.
00:05:13 We're talking mostly a Christian thing, isn't it?
00:05:15 Yes, it is mostly a Christian thing.
00:05:17 It's not exclusively. Religious minorities, including representatives of major faiths such as Islam, are persecuted in certain countries.
00:05:25 There's no getting away from it. Muslims are persecuted in Burma, for example, it's well known.
00:05:32 And the Yazidis are a rather unusual small religious sect.
00:05:39 We've heard of them because they're being ruthlessly persecuted, perhaps with even more vigor than the Christians.
00:05:45 but by and large we're talking about something that is happening to Christians
00:05:50 and on a scale that defies belief
00:05:56 so we have to ask ourselves the question
00:05:58 why don't we know about this
00:06:01 and why hasn't it made the visceral impact
00:06:03 that I know it made on both of us
00:06:05 when we attended that conference
00:06:06 You mentioned North Korea
00:06:10 North Korea is at the top of the list for prosecution
00:06:14 But obviously it's not an Islamic country.
00:06:17 What is the motivation behind the persecution there?
00:06:21 Well, all religion is banned in North Korea.
00:06:26 And any religious activity of any sort, Christian particularly perhaps,
00:06:34 will result in immediate detention, immediate disappearances.
00:06:39 There's zero religious freedom.
00:06:41 so it's it's not just a question is it of there's appalling descriptions you
00:06:46 gave at the beginning the program also persecution can be as it were I don't
00:06:54 know social persecution even can't it we're talking we're talking wide range
00:06:59 of persecution absolutely I mean you'll find that in India Christians are
00:07:05 persecuted you know as if they were low down on the caste system yeah some
00:07:12 Christians are persecuted certainly in Pakistan the situation is dreadful and
00:07:19 it's particularly dreadful as we shovel enormous amounts of money to the
00:07:25 government of Pakistan every day without really knowing how it's being spent or
00:07:33 certainly without holding them to account.
00:07:35 And this is a country in which the persecution of Christians
00:07:38 is really enshrined in law.
00:07:42 I understand that China is going up the league of persecutors, isn't it?
00:07:49 China's going up the league of persecutors.
00:07:50 Ask anybody who's seen their church demolished
00:07:53 by the Chinese state, Catholics and Protestants.
00:08:00 Catholics have seen their church as demolished
00:08:01 But since the Vatican signed an accord with Beijing, which was supposed to ease relations, if you like, solve the problem of China's relationship with the Catholics, well, it certainly hasn't.
00:08:19 And it points to the naivety and the ineffectiveness of Vatican diplomatic service, its inability, if you like, to protect Christians.
00:08:28 But apparently with China, the Christian population is flowering, it's growing, isn't it?
00:08:39 I mean, it's whether Protestant or Catholic.
00:08:42 Absolutely, and the congregations that are growing fastest are Pentecostal Christian populations.
00:08:49 How come, and why is that?
00:08:50 Well, that's because Pentecostal Christianity has always had a foothold in Southeast Asia.
00:08:55 It didn't get anywhere in Japan, never has, because Japan seems totally resistant to Christianity.
00:09:03 It didn't get anywhere in China for obvious reasons, but it did get somewhere in Hong Kong.
00:09:09 It certainly got somewhere on a very big scale in South Korea,
00:09:15 because I've been there to what at the time may still be the world's largest church.
00:09:20 so there's vigorous Pentecostal Christian activity throughout Southeast Asia
00:09:28 and that is spreading to the Chinese mainland from the south as it were
00:09:35 and the present regime in Beijing which is exceptionally unfriendly to religion
00:09:43 probably the most unfriendly since the days of Chairman Mao
00:09:46 perceives that as a threat.
00:09:48 Anything which, any authority which does not emanate directly
00:09:53 from the President himself is perceived as a threat.
00:09:56 And therefore, these Pentecostal Christians are harassed.
00:09:59 In parts of China, crosses have been removed from every single church.
00:10:06 Catholics, unless they've signed up to the official church,
00:10:11 are automatically persecuted.
00:10:13 But even those Catholics who sign up to the official church with the approval of the Pope,
00:10:18 who disgracefully, in my opinion, has made several fairly obvious Chinese spies, bishops,
00:10:26 or he's recognised them as bishops.
00:10:28 I was going to ask you, what the reaction, what has this Pope been like on this subject?
00:10:35 Well, if you were to ask Cardinal Zen, who used to be the head of the church in Hong Kong,
00:10:42 He's utterly horrified. He regards it as a betrayal.
00:10:45 Of course, any dealing with China is going to be complicated.
00:10:50 An immensely complicated situation arose there
00:10:52 where there was an official Catholic Church and an unofficial Catholic Church,
00:10:55 but the distinctions between the two began to be blurred,
00:10:58 and it wasn't clear whether a bishop belonged to one or the other.
00:11:02 So it was a difficult situation for Cardinal Parolin,
00:11:06 the Secretary of State, who's sort of Prime Minister and Foreign Secretary,
00:11:09 rolled into one, and the Pope to sort out.
00:11:12 But nonetheless, the way they've sorted it out looks very much, certainly to Cardinal's end, like simple capitulation.
00:11:19 When it comes to our own government, there are two, as I understand it, there are two, if you like, people who've been appointed.
00:11:27 I mean, Jeremy Hunt has appointed a kind of inquiry, didn't he, into persecution abroad.
00:11:37 I think that's being led by the Bishop of Truro, if I'm over my head.
00:11:40 but there's also the government also appointed somebody else to look at this how much faith do
00:11:45 you have in you know what they might come up with none none i can answer that before you finish
00:11:51 asking the question why why do you have none why because i think we were both very struck by the
00:11:57 exceptionally powerful speech given by lord alton yeah david alton who's been campaigning for
00:12:05 persecuted Christians, he and Lady Cox, when almost nobody else has in Parliament for 40 years.
00:12:13 And what we learned from him is that the Department for International Development
00:12:17 isn't really playing ball, and that they're not keeping track of this.
00:12:22 They're the people responsible for giving large amounts of money to the persecutors of Christians.
00:12:29 And they're just not interested.
00:12:31 And that doesn't surprise me at all, because DFID is part of what Michael Goe calls the blob.
00:12:38 It's part of a, sorry for the clichés, but liberal bien-pensant élite.
00:12:43 There are a few causes less fashionable than the defense of persecuted Christians,
00:12:47 because Christians, to the sort of smug liberals, are part of the problem.
00:12:54 Christianity is part of the problem.
00:12:56 Christianity is an intolerant religion.
00:12:58 they turn a blind eye to the intolerance of Islam
00:13:01 far greater intolerance of Islam
00:13:04 and therefore persecuted Christians
00:13:07 are really low down
00:13:09 well I don't think they're even on DFID's list
00:13:11 and without cooperation between DFID and this inquiry
00:13:15 the things aren't going to get very far
00:13:17 you know these things, these appointments were made
00:13:21 if I remember after
00:13:23 quite a well known case of Isaiah Bibi
00:13:28 You know, the Pakistani Christian woman who was denied, wasn't she, sanctuary in Britain.
00:13:35 Yeah.
00:13:36 I mean, I think I want to go back.
00:13:38 You said there about the Christians being part of the problem.
00:13:41 So we must talk about why this is not known about, why this is not covered.
00:13:47 It seems to me that, could it be that, you know, Christianity to the liberal mindset
00:13:53 is, if you like, seen as the religion of the oppressor.
00:13:58 Yes, not only could it be, it is very much the case as it is.
00:14:03 And you mentioned S.O.B.B. not being granted refuge.
00:14:08 Well, in fact, virtually no Christian refugees have been granted refuge.
00:14:15 I think it's like 0.2% of Syrian refugees are Christian.
00:14:19 It's a very, very small amount as well.
00:14:21 those those refugees who've made it yes yes I mean that you know the the
00:14:27 Christian population of that part of the world has dropped by something like 40
00:14:31 percent and in the last decade which is shocking also tragedy because it's a
00:14:35 it's it means there's a sort of enormous cultural impoverishment not just that
00:14:45 but the demolition, actual literal demolition of thousands of years of
00:14:52 heritage. But to go back to your question, you know, the government's not
00:14:58 interested in letting in Christians. When the Pope welcomed refugees, none of them
00:15:04 were Christians. The Pope himself seems to cast himself as a defender of
00:15:08 humanitarian causes rather than a defender of Christians. He mentions the
00:15:12 subject from time to time but it made no great impact on it but the mindset to
00:15:17 which you're referring with which both of us are very very familiar and have
00:15:21 been for many years the mindset is set in stone that is the general liberal
00:15:29 mindset so obviously you know this goes for the media I guess the the most
00:15:37 certainly you are at the heart of this damon have been you know you're one of
00:15:41 the best-known religious writers, I'd say, in the country now. What is your experience
00:15:48 of, you know, how this is regarded by broadsheet newspapers, tabloid newspapers, the broadcast
00:15:57 media?
00:15:57 Well, my experience is very disillusioning. When I was, years ago, a religion correspondent
00:16:03 for the Daily Telegraph, I was one of four or five full-time journalists covering this
00:16:08 field. Now, I'm not sure how many full-time journalists cover this field, maybe one or
00:16:14 two, but by and large, religion gets just added to somebody's portfolio. You do social
00:16:23 photos, you do religion as well? Yeah, okay, I'll do religion. That's how it goes. And
00:16:27 I've seen it, because I've worked in Fleet Street in recent years, and I've seen how
00:16:30 questions involving Christians, or opinion pieces involving Christians, they just go
00:16:33 to the bottom of the list. Editors aren't interested, and I could name a number of editors
00:16:38 who are not interested at or actively resistant to any comment pieces or news stories addressing
00:16:48 this topic. So there's been a general lack of interest or diminishing of interest in
00:16:53 religion, not just what's happening to Christians or members of other faiths, but interest in
00:17:00 what religion actually is and what it means throughout the media and indeed throughout
00:17:07 government and this at a time when religion as a social force as a shaper of
00:17:15 foreign policy as a as if you like a driver of world affairs has never been so potent at least
00:17:25 in modern times.
00:17:27 It would have seemed inconceivable in the 1970s
00:17:30 that religion would be such an enormous factor
00:17:33 in disputes in virtually every country in the world.
00:17:39 So I suppose really what it is is that people, if you like,
00:17:42 are establishment here.
00:17:44 They think we're living in a post-religious country,
00:17:48 post-religious age.
00:17:49 This is basically, no one cares about religion.
00:17:52 they are entirely at odds with actually one of the biggest issues globally aren't they not only
00:17:58 globally but in Britain so for example when we're the same age when you and I were growing up
00:18:03 people talked about the Asian community or the Pakistani community and now it's the Muslim
00:18:10 community and parts of our cities that were you know majority Pakistani and no problem with that
00:18:19 But no one thinks of them. In some cities, they have effectively become Muslim ghettos.
00:18:25 Sorry to use the word, but effectively the religious authorities wield civil power there.
00:18:31 And we're fine with that, because there's an alliance between the secular left
00:18:36 and rapidly reactionary religious authorities, which is a strange thing.
00:18:42 But my enemy's enemy is my friend, and Christianity is the oppressor.
00:18:46 so actually would you say that there's not just a lack of interest you talk about with editors
00:18:53 and what have you there's actually hostility to Christianity would you say is that pushing it too
00:19:01 I think it's pushing it a little bit too hard and I think the indifference is more deadly than the
00:19:04 hostility just as I think that in some respects persecution of Christians is an awful thing to
00:19:15 say, but is almost better for the survival of Christianity than the sort of yawning boredom
00:19:24 that it induces in the West. But having said that, the acts being committed against Christians
00:19:31 in these countries, and I'm especially thinking of Nigeria, having seen that evidence, are
00:19:38 an abominable outrage in some respects unprecedented it should be on the front pages
00:19:46 virtually every day and it never is i think uh that when there has been polling done admittedly
00:19:54 there was polling done um it was quoted by open doors which is the that's right association that
00:20:00 you talked about at the beginning of the program it said that amongst christians there is a growing
00:20:05 worry growing concern about the severity of this problem but that's amongst Christians particularly
00:20:10 amongst Catholics in this poll I would say that your average person walking along on the street
00:20:15 outside this building probably isn't even aware well I think there are polls also showing that
00:20:21 you know among American Catholics it's dropped down the list of priorities of subjects and I'm
00:20:27 not surprised because their bishops let our bishops say nothing of any interest on any subject so
00:20:34 I mean, that's an Anglican and Catholic, nothing memorable, but in America, many of their bishops, not all by any means,
00:20:41 are paralyzed with anxiety that they might be slipping behind the times,
00:20:48 or that they might have failed to jump on the right bandwagon, climate change, LGBT, you name it.
00:20:55 And therefore, you don't hear much about the persecution of Christians from them.
00:20:59 And you don't read enough about it in the religious media, which is why, since I became, took over again, as it happens, the role of editor-in-chief of the Cafe Carol last year, where we have launched as a magazine, well, a few years ago we turned ourselves into a wonderful magazine, and now, last November, we launched in the United States, where we're making waves.
00:21:29 And from now on, the persecution of Christians will be a fundamental concern of the Catholic Herald,
00:21:36 which is why I've asked Father Benedict Keeley of Nazarene.org,
00:21:40 who is a heroic defender and a very influential defender of persecuted Christians,
00:21:47 to become a consulting editor and, in effect, to oversee and guide our coverage of it
00:21:53 so that we don't forget and our readers don't forget.
00:21:57 and the Catholic Church doesn't forget
00:22:00 because the Catholic Church is in danger of forgetting too.
00:22:04 Are there any countries that you can think of
00:22:06 who've got a good record on trying to help persecuted Christians?
00:22:12 I mean, Hungary was mentioned a lot.
00:22:14 Well, Hungary is certainly the country that comes to mind
00:22:18 which actually has a government minister, a department for looking at this.
00:22:26 now that the hungarian government is is is controversial um but in this area they've been
00:22:35 magnificent and we just have to accept you know we just have to accept they've been brilliant in
00:22:41 this area yeah but what do you think i mean i know that you catholic herald you say this is
00:22:48 going to be one of your missions particularly in america now you're going to well here as well
00:22:52 and you did carry a great
00:22:55 front cover story by John O'Sullivan
00:22:57 by John O'Sullivan, former editor of National Review
00:22:59 who's one of our contributing editors
00:23:01 John wrote
00:23:03 very very powerfully
00:23:05 but in a spirit of despair
00:23:07 saying the problem has never
00:23:09 been worse and they have nobody
00:23:11 these people, you're talking about other religious
00:23:13 minorities as well, they have nobody
00:23:15 to speak for them because they're not
00:23:17 trendy and if you're not trendy
00:23:19 nobody's going to listen to you
00:23:20 trans is trendy now I oppose discrimination against trans people of
00:23:28 course I do but it is a trendy cause there's no doubt about it other causes
00:23:34 are trendy and people are attracted to them they're not attracted to this now
00:23:39 can we make this cause fashionable well I don't know you can make a bloody
00:23:44 nuisance of ourselves by reminding people what's going on that's what we
00:23:47 can do yeah but you've got to somehow as well get the media or try to bring the media around
00:23:53 yes we have yes we have and that's why new culture forums conference was so important
00:24:03 because you had heavy hitters at that conference i had people you know from all over the world
00:24:09 contacting me afterwards and saying wow you know when i went to that conference i didn't expect to
00:24:13 see such influential people and i hope that they will carry the message so thank you peter well it
00:24:18 was a close you know you and the danube institute together have done something really important i
00:24:23 feel that after that conference something changed well i hope it's not just something that will
00:24:30 go away i i i do hope the governments governments have got to take more notice
00:24:36 it's not going to go away the two of us will not let it go away and you know this is this is not
00:24:42 an issue for christians it is an issue for human beings on that note damien a wonderful way to end
00:24:50 it thank you very much coming in great and thank you very much for watching so what you're saying
00:24:57 is please don't forget to subscribe and it costs nothing and we'll look forward to seeing you on
00:25:04 the next show thank you very much