New Culture Forum - April 28, 2019


17. Claire Fox - Brexit & Left

16. Deadly silence: The unreported persecution of Christians 18. Dr. David Starkey - Uncut: Assaults On Brexit, British Identity & History

Episode Stats


Length

30 minutes

Words per minute

179.09

Word count

5,400

Sentence count

74


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to So What You're Saying Is. I'm Peter Whittle. Now my guest for this show
00:00:11 is somebody who's been in the news a bit recently. Claire Fox is the founder and director of the
00:00:19 Academy of Ideas. She's also convener of the Battle of Ideas which is a festival that happens
00:00:24 every year in london and it's a kind of a fixture now on the debating circuit but she's become
00:00:30 maybe better known to a wider public over the past week because she was recently announced as
00:00:37 a candidate for the brexit party for the upcoming european elections hello claire hello to see you
00:00:45 what's it been like over the past few days it's had a very different feel to my normal
00:00:50 political life because people want to treat you differently because you're standing for
00:00:55 election and that's fair enough so it's been something of a whirlwind I've been trying to
00:01:01 negotiate the variety of hostile hit jobs the various attacks on social media but I think it's
00:01:10 been exciting as well because I just on the way here was stopped in the street by someone who
00:01:14 said thank you so much for standing and so you know for every time you kind of look at Twitter
00:01:19 and think, oh, what have I done?
00:01:22 It's also been gratifying to meet, dare I say, ordinary voters
00:01:26 who are much more enthusiastic and excited, I suppose.
00:01:30 Have you actually ever stood electorally before for anything?
00:01:34 I stood many years ago for the Revolutionary Communist Party
00:01:39 when I was very young in an election.
00:01:43 I got barely a few votes.
00:01:45 I did stand in student union elections
00:01:48 and I was elected as a full-time student union officer for a couple of years.
00:01:53 But nothing like this.
00:01:55 And I never aspired to.
00:01:57 I had no intentions of ever getting involved in mainstream politics in this way.
00:02:02 But thereby hangs a tale,
00:02:04 because you were very clear about it at the launch when you were announced.
00:02:07 But I wonder if you could just, for viewers, explain what brought you to this.
00:02:12 This is a big thing, because you come from an entirely different political tradition
00:02:17 to many of the people who will be standing for the Brexit Party,
00:02:20 although I think it's a mixture.
00:02:22 But what brought you to it?
00:02:23 I mean, this was a real decision, wasn't it, that you made?
00:02:28 I increasingly felt that democracy was at a watershed
00:02:32 and I kept meeting people who were in despair, furious despair,
00:02:38 about the fact that they would never vote again.
00:02:40 They could not get over what had happened in terms of the sell-out of Brexit.
00:02:45 it. I mean, you can imagine that people, you know, all their lives have believed in the
00:02:51 democratic process. They thought if you won in a referendum, that that would mean that
00:02:56 you'd win and that then it would be implemented. And having watched three years of politicians
00:03:01 doing everything to water down or ultimately overturn that democratic vote, the palpable
00:03:08 sense of people feeling that's it now, I'm never ever voting again, made me realise that
00:03:14 we were a turning point in politics and especially i think if you imagine for those you know five
00:03:21 million labor voters or people who kind of saw themselves as left of center you know the brexit
00:03:26 wasn't a left-right thing it's it's caricatured and characterized as far right by those who wish
00:03:33 to discredit it so i'm not having a go at right-wing ideas i mean there's right-wing ideas
00:03:38 i'm left wing so be it but to try and kind of say to those people who are on the left
00:03:45 labour voters that they are right wing because they supported brexit
00:03:51 to feel abandoned in that way i felt that somebody on the left maybe i needed to throw my hat in the
00:03:56 ring did you actually get involved in the original referendum campaign in any way i did not not in
00:04:02 any of the formal campaigns i was endlessly invited to speak either on the media or at
00:04:08 universities or schools about brexit and i did do that and i certainly was in my own small way
00:04:16 a campaigner for it you mentioned there about people saying i'll never vote again what have you
00:04:22 i mean from your political perspective were you still are you still shocked at the way this has
00:04:30 been you know basically treated by the political class we or you could say well some people say
00:04:37 well you know it's to be expected they'll never let it happen but i frankly have been amazed at
00:04:43 quite how blatant it's been i you know what i feel so naive i mean straight after the referenda
00:04:50 random happened so many people said to me they won't let it happen they'll stop it and i thought
00:04:55 thought they would be like kind of mad conspiracy theorists. I could see that there was a concerted
00:05:01 effort at demonising Brexit voters. The speed and rapidity with which there was attempts
00:05:08 to delegitimise the vote, you know, blaming Russian bots or, you know, everyone was brainwashed
00:05:13 or saying that people were stupid and not educated, all that happened. But I still
00:05:18 thought in the end they had to see it through I think the the revelations that
00:05:25 came out in the checkers deal or the checkers discussion when I looked at
00:05:30 what they had been actually negotiating I then it dawned on me finally my god
00:05:37 they have spent all this time trying to avoid leaving they have sat with EU
00:05:43 bureaucrats to come up with the worst possible kind of a fudge not even a fudge of a deal not
00:05:49 a compromise deal an attempt to keep the united kingdom completely entangled in all the institutions
00:05:56 of the eu and that revelation uh frankly as you say it shocked me and i thought oh i thought i
00:06:03 thought somehow somewhere they must be trying to act in good faith and i don't believe that now
00:06:08 no no exactly what about your what about your colleagues and people that you
00:06:16 in in the kind of you like your environment what is the reaction been have you you mentioned at
00:06:22 the launch that you know here it goes we're going to get the trolling we're going to get this and
00:06:26 that on twitter but what has the reaction been to your your standing so there's two reactions i mean
00:06:32 it's been very gratifying that quite a lot of people who've
00:06:36 congratulated me
00:06:38 possibly secretly, lots of direct messages from people I would not expect
00:06:44 at all, you know, remain supporters who've said well at least you put your money where
00:06:48 your mouth is and it takes, you know, that's fine. I think
00:06:52 that however for a lot of people it's, people keep saying it's a step
00:06:56 too far, whatever that means. And I think what they
00:07:00 trying to do and which happens all the time in politics today in a kind of
00:07:05 culture wars of politics it's a kind of do a guilt by association you know you
00:07:09 know I can't now these I have to stress or not ordinary voters this is amongst
00:07:15 my liberal peers right and but I think that there's been a genuine and shock
00:07:22 waves even amongst people who voted remain who were quite established in
00:07:27 media circles or in liberal circles even they've been shocked by the fact that
00:07:32 this referendum result is being attempted to be overturned I mean there
00:07:36 are obviously a group of people who are actively doing that I mean the hardcore
00:07:40 you know they call themselves Romaniacs I don't use that word but I think that
00:07:47 for other people they just assumed somehow that it would happen so I think
00:07:51 that they even they themselves understand why I'm doing it but on the
00:07:56 the hand I'm not exactly on the dinner party circuit but I'm tolerated amongst
00:08:01 those who are I think I will get even you know I won't even be invited to the
00:08:06 kind of drinks that's the story but I can live what about your what about your
00:08:12 family are they remainers are they brexit people or they mixture so my
00:08:17 family was split and many people voted leave I'm from I'm from Wales originally
00:08:23 but I'm also from an Irish background so my Irish family are going along with a lot of what the
00:08:30 discussion is in Ireland are very hostile to Brexit although I kind of visited them recently
00:08:37 for a family holiday and when I was talking to them you could see that some of them were thinking
00:08:42 oh maybe she's got a point I hadn't heard that side of the story. In my most immediate family
00:08:48 and in-laws and people like that a lot of them voted leave and in fact they had a big impact on
00:08:55 me because you know you know family visits at Christmas and they were really saying things like
00:09:01 you go back to London and you tell them as though somehow because I was going to have the opportunity
00:09:06 to come back and tell anyone but they are rightly incandescent about what's happened and by the way
00:09:13 you know like all of the caricatures are so misplaced a wide range of different
00:09:20 socio-economic backgrounds and professions and jobs represented and to be described as stupid
00:09:27 and ignorant has really galled them I think the greatest insult that they found is the idea that
00:09:32 they're racist I mean these are tolerant decent people now some of my family voted remain and
00:09:39 And to my surprise, to my surprise, their attitude was, well, the good guys, we lost,
00:09:48 the good guys lost, right?
00:09:50 They're still enthusiastic about being in the EU.
00:09:53 I wouldn't say madly enthusiastic, but they thought it was the right thing to do.
00:09:57 But they have admitted to me that they did assume that after a few months it would calm
00:10:02 down and then we'd all really sort of sit down as a country and say, right, now we're
00:10:08 leaving the EU. Now let's have a discussion about what we're going to do about our industrial
00:10:12 strategy or what we're going to do about kind of building new policies when we've got a democratic
00:10:20 mandate to do it. And so it kind of had a potential excitement there. So they, funnily enough,
00:10:26 have become quite sympathetic to the leave cause because they can't understand why this backlash
00:10:34 has occurred in other words it's very kind of westminster bubble central oh yeah this idea that
00:10:41 everybody he voted remain uh wants us to uh to stay in that um everybody he voted leave is having
00:10:50 second thoughts i mean they are talking to themselves yeah one thing that has surprised
00:10:56 me interested me about the referendum campaign i don't know you you first discussed it with
00:11:01 lionel shriver when she was on recently was um that there used to be this thing there were people
00:11:06 who wanted to come out you're skeptics going back now and there were people who basically thought
00:11:10 on balance is kind of a good thing to be in but what there seems to be this group now who are
00:11:15 emotionally attached to the eu you know with all the they painted faces and everything what do you
00:11:21 make of that well i think that there is uh some kind of a crisis politically anywhere we way in
00:11:28 in which we've seen that a meaningful commitment
00:11:33 to principles and ideas have been undermined
00:11:36 by kind of years of technocracy.
00:11:37 And in the course of that,
00:11:41 we've seen the emergence of identity politics,
00:11:43 people searching for a way of understanding themselves
00:11:46 and finding an identity.
00:11:48 And I think that the kind of lever-remainer
00:11:53 kind of identities have kind of consolidated
00:11:55 in a way that you wouldn't have thought.
00:11:57 people kind of see themselves through those titles I mean I have been bemused
00:12:03 by the sudden enthusiasm for the European Union which was never witnessed
00:12:08 I mean there is now it is true that the UK probably they boast of this and I
00:12:12 think this is true that there probably is now a more active zealot you know
00:12:19 kind of almost religious kind of fervor of an attachment to the European Union
00:12:25 this country than any other country in the rest of europe but i still can't untangle what exactly
00:12:31 it is they're being enthusiastic about it's sort of the thing is it's entirely uncritical it seems
00:12:36 to me it's that it's not about you know they used to be the argument we'll stay in and reform it but
00:12:42 these people are not even saying that it's like they are attached to this thing yes and and there's
00:12:47 it in that sense it really is an identity it's it's i mean you know it kind of mirrors some of
00:12:52 of those ideas about like virtue signaling you know it's like sort of by this this means that
00:12:58 we believe in peace as though everybody else wants war yeah and by this um i am showing that i'm
00:13:05 interested in other countries and i'm an internationalist and i said well i am a proud
00:13:09 european and they look at me and they can't understand it i said i love europe i'm passionate
00:13:13 about european culture i you know all of these things my objection is to the european union
00:13:19 They cannot untangle these two concepts.
00:13:22 They've got no sense that the European Union is an entirely modern, relatively recent, artificial, top-down construct
00:13:30 that has been set up to ring-fence national sovereignty in a range of different countries
00:13:38 and to gather the power to itself and so on and so forth.
00:13:40 I hardly need rehearsals.
00:13:42 They seem to think that, you know, if you are a Leave voter, that you therefore hate Beethoven.
00:13:49 She had that argument, I think, actually.
00:13:53 I'm pointing out that Beethoven might have been pre-EU, possibly.
00:13:57 And, you know, that when I say, you know, I talk about, you know,
00:14:03 whether it's kind of like the European Enlightenment ideals that have inspired me,
00:14:07 you can see them kind of looking at me like I just cannot get their heads around it.
00:14:11 And that indicates to me that it's not, you know, it's a pretty two-dimensional kind of adherence to this notion of the EU.
00:14:24 The EU, of course, sell it that way.
00:14:26 I mean, it really is presented as this kind of all-loving family.
00:14:31 When I try and point out things like what's happening in France,
00:14:34 you know and you don't have to be a supporter of the gilets jaunes movement that goes on the
00:14:41 streets every weekend and demonstrates and i'm not trying to pretend that they are all
00:14:45 demanding to leave the european union but i try and point out well you know france with kind of
00:14:51 led by saint macron the liberal eu leader who you know is heralded by us in this country is somehow
00:14:59 the kind of leader we want is at war with his own people and sending in brutal police
00:15:05 riot teams that are actually injuring people not getting very much publicity in this country
00:15:10 ordinary french people being treated like dirt but when i sort of say that i'm not i i'm simply
00:15:16 saying what do you think about that i mean that must make you have an anxiety moment in relation
00:15:21 to the eu and it's utterly it's like as though they're in denial so it's an interesting thing
00:15:28 because they very often the people who are most zealous about the European Union think that
00:15:34 people who want to leave it know nothing and I think that we were something of an insurgency
00:15:40 in the build-up to that referendum so what I found was that people didn't know which way to vote
00:15:47 I mean there was a hard core of people who'd already decided to leave the European Union
00:15:51 millions of not 17.4 million people didn't think that they however took their responsibility very
00:15:58 seriously they started reading up they started thinking about it they started talking to their
00:16:03 friends about it they did not read the side of a bus they actually went and looked up details i mean
00:16:09 i went one one woman rather i told the story before but i loved it when she said well claire
00:16:15 we've got a family conference this weekend and i've got jim has gone to the library yeah judy's
00:16:22 googling yeah we're looking at things like tariff controls we're looking at you know and i said oh
00:16:28 yeah no i have no idea which way they voted but they were the kind of people who the media would
00:16:35 have presented as you know no qualifications stupid people who believed some soundbite no they
00:16:42 weren't they thought this mattered and they went off and as they were from north wales where i'm
00:16:47 from and north wales voted to leave they might well have been to their family conference decided
00:16:53 but the point i'm making is if you're kind of going against project fear and the whole establishment
00:16:58 giving you their version you have to find out yourself so in some ways i think the people who
00:17:03 voted leave had thought about the european union rather more than some of the people who nodded
00:17:08 through a vote to stay and also those people who nodded through the vote stays you as you put it
00:17:12 or people there was a there has been a sense as well that you know they've had it their own way
00:17:18 for a long time and then they were suddenly challenged and i think that this this kind of
00:17:23 anger vitriol must be as a result of that and i think people often underestimate the fact that i
00:17:30 really meant that point about technocracy you know the political classes over the last couple of
00:17:36 decades have basically gutted their own parties of any kind of meaningful social base of any
00:17:42 principle of any ideals and have increasingly ring fenced off decision making from the vast
00:17:49 majority of people by saying oh no don't you worry your little heads we make these decisions on your
00:17:54 behalf and i've also talked down to people huge amount you know it's not people think it's to do
00:17:59 with austerity it's not as simple as that it's not like a poverty point but it is a poverty of
00:18:05 aspiration if you're kind of treated as though you're poor people who need looking after yeah
00:18:10 and actually need lecturing because you're no good at rearing your children you drink rather too much
00:18:15 you break the units rules you you kind of you you know your kids go to mcdonald's you know all of
00:18:19 these kind of nanny state things i think being treated as though you're slightly less than full
00:18:26 citizens has grated over the years and here was a chance for people to take themselves seriously
00:18:32 a very important part of this is
00:18:34 I think we all discovered their agency
00:18:35 you know, take back control
00:18:38 became more than just take back
00:18:40 our national sovereignty
00:18:42 that people popularly said
00:18:44 we want to decide on
00:18:46 politics and the future
00:18:48 future
00:18:50 orientation of the country
00:18:51 I think they saw it as themselves saying
00:18:53 I want control over my life
00:18:55 this means my vote will count
00:18:57 but it was a reaction against
00:18:59 as you say
00:18:59 the absolute grinding down
00:19:03 of people's sense of pride
00:19:06 in themselves, in their communities
00:19:08 being constantly told that they had the wrong attitude
00:19:11 being constantly treated as though they were
00:19:14 not up to decision making
00:19:16 and I think that's not historically the way
00:19:20 ordinary people in this country view themselves
00:19:23 and I think this was a chance to go
00:19:24 oh we're back, we're back
00:19:26 do you remember us?
00:19:28 and I was impressed by the way
00:19:31 I was very impressed by how brave people were
00:19:36 I mean I was at one event
00:19:38 I mean I was just in the audience
00:19:40 and it had all of the usual suspects
00:19:42 you know CBI and CEOs of multinationals
00:19:46 and they were getting a bit panicky about the polls
00:19:49 this was in the build up
00:19:51 and a CEO of a multinational stood up
00:19:54 and he said you know
00:19:55 I want you to go back to your workplace tomorrow
00:19:58 you tell people there will be no jobs no jobs if they vote leave you know we will be closing down
00:20:05 and i said well you know they're not serfs you don't own them you can't but i remember going
00:20:12 home and saying to to my my partner or you know if they do that i mean people are going to panic
00:20:20 aren't they they're going to not they're going to be terrified well i was wrong i underestimated
00:20:25 people i mean they did go back they gave those lectures to their workforces as though they were
00:20:30 somehow beneath them threatened them people said right we've heard you thank you and then won't
00:20:36 vote leave i mean it's fabulous you said that at the beginning why the beginning kind of it's not
00:20:41 a left-right thing um and i see it but you know you you are from the left you were in the rcp the
00:20:50 the revolution party which i i guess you would call yourself a trotsky or something um there's
00:20:57 this saying now you know left and right is no longer helpful you hear this would you say that
00:21:02 would you say you agree with that do you think it's not where do you what i'm trying to where
00:21:06 would you put yourself now it's very difficult isn't it because those labels sound and feel like
00:21:12 real risk restrictions i've only kind of started doing the um the emphasis on the left because i
00:21:18 consider myself to be on the left but I also know how unhelpful it is you know
00:21:22 if I say oh I was the publisher of LN magazine which was living Marxism
00:21:26 you know people say to me oh yes but don't Marxists believe that the state
00:21:30 should run everything and I say no and then I feel like I'm in some sort of
00:21:32 undergraduate politics lesson and we're going to misunderstand each other is
00:21:37 what I'm saying but I've thought for a long time that left and right have
00:21:41 become unhelpful there are serious problems in left-wing politics I hardly
00:21:45 when you say this to you but you know I you know people will describe as the regressive left that
00:21:49 you know the left of fully embraced identity politics have fully gone down a very censorious
00:21:55 route in terms of banning ideas they don't like you know what do you do you know I'm an anti-racist
00:22:00 who fought for women's liberation but I know that when somebody says you know as an anti-racist I
00:22:06 find that offensive that means they're going to close it down I have to come in though that's the
00:22:09 title of your book that is the title of my book very well done I find that offensive but I mean
00:22:14 that's where the cycle comes from is it i heard it so often yes and it was often my as to our
00:22:19 peers on the left you know who he was in leading the charge on these things who were i thought it
00:22:24 also developed a rather to relate to that previous point developed a rather kind of almost like a
00:22:30 social work paternalism when it came to uh working class people which is they kind of talked about
00:22:36 them as though they were kind of poor and needy and needed looking after and saving some kind of
00:22:40 like victorian missionary work was going on and i thought this was very different to the kind of
00:22:45 you know standing up for oneself and and and and and self-organization that i was associating with
00:22:51 the left i don't always understood it because a uh old friend of mine was in the rcp at kent
00:22:56 university when i was there um it was this sort of sense of potential that the the modern left
00:23:02 is all about making you a victim and weak uh whereas the if you like the the harder left for
00:23:08 want of a better expression you know the marxist belief was that you know there's nothing we can't
00:23:12 do if we do it together um i suppose the interesting thing with you obviously you've
00:23:18 been on more maze you're on question time is that so many people who would consider themselves on
00:23:22 the right or conservatives or whatever would find themselves agreeing with you entirely but these
00:23:27 are usually about what you would call cultural issues are they not i mean this book of yours
00:23:31 uh what is it um i find that offensive or i think it's i still find that offensive they've just
00:23:36 brought a second edition out yes that is about isn't it identity it's about the snowflake
00:23:42 generation i think you coined that didn't you or did you no all right but i'll come back to that
00:23:48 i think on the on the on the but i'll explain i mean i i i use a phrase because i'm actually
00:23:54 looking at the culture wars in america and when i wrote the books maybe some of the the more
00:24:00 regressive trends in relation to
00:24:02 censoriousness on campus
00:24:03 were not as widely felt in this country
00:24:06 and I was almost writing a book
00:24:08 as a warning call, I could see that it was happening
00:24:10 and the phrase that was being used
00:24:12 in American politics at the time was
00:24:14 Generation Snowflake
00:24:15 and so I kind of wrote the book
00:24:18 both about
00:24:20 but to Generation Snowflake
00:24:22 to try and explain this idea of a kind of
00:24:24 rather oversensitive
00:24:26 thin-skinned, bannet
00:24:28 kind of generational mood that I detected and but Wikipedia now say that I popularized the phrase
00:24:35 and I'm responsible for the phrase and actually it's a rather derogatory phrase and it's a bit
00:24:39 like you know I actually don't like the phrase so I just used it in the book and so that's what's
00:24:44 happened but on your point it's very important isn't it I think you've you spotted this in a
00:24:48 lot of the work that you've done you know in the culture wars the left right thing doesn't work
00:24:54 anymore i mean to be frank with you there's far too many people on the right by the way who go
00:24:59 along with victim politics you know there are there are all sorts of people who are in the
00:25:05 culture wars settling in different areas i agree that the traditional left led the charge in in
00:25:12 terms of some of the things that i most despise in today's culture wars in terms of the the victim
00:25:19 politics the identity politics and also there's the kind of risk-averse element of society now
00:25:26 you make this point in the book and it's a very good one about uh the way that kids are molly
00:25:30 coddled now that this might actually be uh you know one of the the if you like the genesis of
00:25:36 a lot of this thing is that they're just simply not used to being exposed to different ideas not
00:25:42 just hard ideas but different ideas different ideas i think that the the sort of kernel of the
00:25:49 book was how have we got to a situation where 18 year olds go to university and demand safe spaces
00:25:57 safety and they always use this word about you know they demand of the authorities that they're
00:26:03 protected and are comfortable i thought how extraordinary i mean you're 18 you're going
00:26:10 out into the world the one thing that you didn't want to do was to feel safe and comfortable i
00:26:14 mean it's like the most peculiar i mean this is a moment when you should be saying yeah i'm going
00:26:20 to take on the world you know risky behavior challenges how exciting the last thing you want
00:26:26 to say is can i feel safe and comfortable so trying to work out what had happened i think that
00:26:31 i recognized and i've i'm from i used to teach i've always taken a great interest in education
00:26:37 I could see all of this kind of socialising of the young
00:26:41 into a risk-averse, safety-first culture our generation had done
00:26:46 meant that young people were not only being protected from different ideas
00:26:49 but just had an expectation that they would be looked after
00:26:53 and mollycoddled and infantilised ever later
00:26:56 and also have lost their independence.
00:27:00 We now oversee practically every activity that any young person does at all.
00:27:07 You know, you used to kind of have, you know, go out and play in the playground and, you know, be a teacher supervising you barely.
00:27:15 But now there's kind of CCTV cameras and monitors everywhere to make sure you're not bullying each other.
00:27:19 But also, isn't it like in the education system where kids are sort of told that they are all, you know, that they're all Mozart, as it were, or rather, you know.
00:27:28 Exactly. That's the other side of it.
00:27:29 So when they say to make sure they're not bullying people, to just make it clear, it's not that I want everybody to be bullying each other.
00:27:36 but bullying has become a very wide term
00:27:39 so it's like are you being nasty to somebody
00:27:41 are you not talking to somebody who's now considered to be bullying
00:27:44 and on the other hand as you say
00:27:46 they're put centre stage and told how wonderful they are
00:27:50 just by being young
00:27:51 and that creates a kind of sense of entitlement
00:27:54 a sense of expectation that my views are the most important views
00:27:59 actually the very opposite of what an education system should do
00:28:03 I mean every young person is narcissistic
00:28:05 Everybody thinks that they're the centre of the universe
00:28:07 when you're, you know, from the age of 10.
00:28:09 I mean, you think you count more than anyone else.
00:28:12 Part of the learning experience of growing up
00:28:14 is to realise that possibly your views are not correct
00:28:17 and that you maybe ought to read the odd book,
00:28:19 that you might change,
00:28:20 that you maybe have to listen, not just speak.
00:28:24 Whereas we've developed a culture
00:28:25 where that is actually seen to be good educational practice.
00:28:28 I think the thing is, maybe you'll find,
00:28:30 is that when you are commentating or discussing these things,
00:28:33 you can discuss them and leave them open-ended.
00:28:35 when you become a politician, people then say,
00:28:37 well, what are you going to do about it then?
00:28:38 What are you going to do?
00:28:41 That's true.
00:28:42 Although I'm standing for the European Parliament on the Brexit party
00:28:44 and I don't necessarily know that playground policy and education will be it.
00:28:49 But, you know, your show's called What You're Saying Is.
00:28:54 And so what you're saying is,
00:28:56 and one of the things that I do realise about political life
00:29:00 that's different than just being a commentator is,
00:29:02 part of my shtick
00:29:05 at the Academy of Ideas
00:29:06 at the Battle of Ideas Festival is to say
00:29:08 look behind the headline and the soundbite
00:29:10 you know
00:29:11 because people will always say so what you're saying is this
00:29:14 you know I've just said that so they'll say
00:29:16 so what you're saying is you think it's really
00:29:18 good that children are bullied
00:29:20 and I'll say no that's not what I'm saying
00:29:22 and it's fine as a commentator
00:29:24 to have and also my mission
00:29:26 has been to say that politics is complicated
00:29:29 let's go the layers
00:29:30 and let's talk about this with a bit more nuance
00:29:32 and not caricature each other
00:29:34 or try and delegitimize each other
00:29:35 through labelling people.
00:29:38 You can say all of that,
00:29:40 but when you're a politician,
00:29:41 I realise that if you say the one line,
00:29:44 taken out of context,
00:29:46 they'll be saying,
00:29:47 so what you're saying is you support this,
00:29:48 and I'm like, no.
00:29:50 And I realise I'm more at risk of that.
00:29:52 I reckon you'll be fine.
00:29:54 Claire, thanks very, very much for coming in.
00:29:56 Thank you for watching So What You're Saying Is.
00:29:59 we'll see you next time in the meantime please do subscribe you'll see a button
00:30:03 emerging on the screen and it's free so please do thanks very much for watching