New Culture Forum - May 14, 2019


18. Dr. David Starkey - Uncut: Assaults On Brexit, British Identity & History

17. Claire Fox - Brexit & Left Episode 19 - Brendan O'Neill: Anti-Woke: A Duty to Offend

Episode Stats


Length

49 minutes

Words per minute

156.33

Word count

7,794

Sentence count

395


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to So What You're Saying Is, I'm Peter Whittle. Now I'm delighted today that my
00:00:11 guest is probably Britain's best-known historian, Dr David Starkey. He's well known to us for the
00:00:19 numerous books that he's written about British history, about the monarchy and particularly
00:00:23 about the Tudors and to a wider audience through the various series and documentaries he's made
00:00:29 for television. He's also well known, I think it's a period of about three decades now for
00:00:35 his various appearances on Question Time and Any Questions. I'm delighted he's with us
00:00:39 today. Thank you very much David for coming. You're on tour at the moment, aren't you?
00:00:43 That's putting it very strongly. I am suffering from the fate of every B or C list celebrity
00:00:50 as you try to monetize the ashes of your fame and I troll myself around various obscure
00:00:57 theatres talking to very agreeable audiences and earning a pittance it's it's a really it's a
00:01:03 modest modest activity well I came to see you when you were doing it recently and it didn't seem
00:01:08 like it was a packed house and I mean I wonder whether you could tell us a little bit about this
00:01:13 without giving away too much of your lecture but this is a fascinating subject you're talking on
00:01:19 which is essentially Britain's other Brexit its first Brexit that's one of the subjects I do
00:01:25 several yeah I have lots of things up my sleeve including one that I think is in some ways even
00:01:31 more apposite to our present catastrophe than that which is on why Churchill was great and what I
00:01:38 argue is Churchill is great because of writing a very important history book really writing on his
00:01:44 ancestor the Duke of Marlborough and what he does he looks at the relationship between again it's
00:01:51 very much this question of the relationship between England-Britain and Europe and he looks
00:01:56 at the relationship between England-Britain because Britain is just a formal political entity
00:02:01 at this point from 1707 and the France of Louis XIV and what he does he looks at Louis XIV
00:02:08 and he's not quite sure what the modern analogy is. He's writing this after the rise of Stalin
00:02:15 but before the rise of Hitler. It's in this middle period and what he's doing in that is saying
00:02:21 I know why Louis XIV is wicked
00:02:23 on the one hand
00:02:25 he is aiming for external hegemony
00:02:28 dominance of Europe
00:02:29 on the other hand
00:02:30 he is an internal persecutor
00:02:32 the persecution of the Huguenot
00:02:34 and he sees this
00:02:35 the relation of internal persecution
00:02:38 and the external pursuit of hegemony
00:02:40 as the authentic mark
00:02:42 of totalitarian tyranny
00:02:44 now you can see
00:02:45 it's like Pirandello
00:02:48 six characters in search of an author
00:02:49 He's looking for a modern analogy, and this is why he understood Hitler,
00:02:55 in a way which nobody else did, and as quickly as he did,
00:02:59 because he'd already worked out the lineaments.
00:03:02 So it's a jolly good lecture.
00:03:03 The other Brexit, well, of course it's a good lecture.
00:03:06 The other one is when the boot is on the other foot,
00:03:09 and we're dealing with a quasi, but it's very quasi, totalitarian ruler in Britain,
00:03:15 which is Henry VIII, and the lecture you heard is Henry VIII and the first Brexit.
00:03:19 And what I argue there, of course, is that the break with the Roman Church is absolutely analogous to our separating ourselves from the EU.
00:03:30 It's even fought over the same territory.
00:03:32 It's fought over jurisdiction.
00:03:34 Why does Henry have to break with Rome to get his divorce?
00:03:37 Because England is subordinate to a European court.
00:03:42 What is the other ground of the conflict?
00:03:44 The amount of money you pay.
00:03:46 Quite extraordinary.
00:03:47 And it goes into absolute detail.
00:03:52 The way Henry does it is by the doctrine of parliamentary sovereignty.
00:03:57 In other words, the idea which is being pursued hotly by the legion of Remainers headed by Centurion Bercow
00:04:05 is that parliamentary sovereignty can be used to deny national sovereignty.
00:04:11 It's an absurd contradiction.
00:04:13 parliamentary sovereignty only makes sense within the notion of a sovereign independent state
00:04:20 otherwise it's meaningless verbiage and again of course it highlights the fact that the doctrine
00:04:25 of parliamentary sovereignty long predates democracy and that the great crisis in Britain
00:04:32 is that we've never worked out what the relationship between an idea of popular sovereignty
00:04:38 and parliamentary subtlety is, which was, of course, exposed with brutal effectiveness by the Brexit referendum.
00:04:45 So that really is the nub of it, actually, isn't it?
00:04:48 It really is the nub. But I think there are several nubs.
00:04:51 Again, you've got to ask why the various bits of the British Isles voted the way they do.
00:04:59 Why is Brexit a specifically English phenomenon with Wales?
00:05:04 The answer is, of course, Henry VIII. From the 16th century onwards, the notion of self-determination, of self-government, of separation from any external form of subordination has been absolutely the central thread of English identity.
00:05:23 It's why the British-English Empire is the only empire in the world that spawns a series of self-governing entities.
00:05:32 First the American colonies, then Canada, Australia, South Africa, New Zealand, and so on.
00:05:39 With the Henry VIII analogy, I mean, we're talking about a different set of people entirely, aren't we?
00:05:46 Oh, you'd noticed, had you?
00:05:50 I think so.
00:05:51 I think this is a level of sublime perception.
00:05:53 You'd notice the difference between, say,
00:05:55 Henry VIII and Theresa May.
00:05:57 Yes.
00:05:57 Yes.
00:05:59 There are some very interesting parallels, actually,
00:06:02 in how badly Henry got it wrong to begin with.
00:06:05 To begin with, Henry does exactly what Theresa May has been doing,
00:06:10 and he does it for two years.
00:06:11 He negotiates with Rome on Rome's terms.
00:06:14 he uses a principal minister
00:06:17 Cardinal Wolsey
00:06:18 who by the way was also fond of wearing red
00:06:21 and had very large beads
00:06:22 and didn't believe in the divorce
00:06:25 hated Anne Boleyn
00:06:27 and really wanted to keep England in hock to Rome
00:06:29 so he makes exactly the same mistake
00:06:32 except of course
00:06:33 when the catastrophe of Wolsey's approach
00:06:37 with the divorce is brought home
00:06:38 with the papal
00:06:40 the suspension of the papal court
00:06:42 that had been sitting in England with the cardinal legate Campeggio,
00:06:49 when that's brought home to Henry, of course he is not a 1922 committee.
00:06:53 It doesn't take him an eternity to decide that Wolsey's got to go.
00:06:58 And at that point, this is where the stories diverge so radically,
00:07:02 Henry stops, thinks, commissions research,
00:07:07 works out a series of rational grounds for what he's doing.
00:07:13 But of course in doing it, in pushing the argument for the self-sufficiency of England,
00:07:19 he really reinvents England.
00:07:23 And I think that the great impetus that lay behind the vote
00:07:29 is that sense of an England that is different,
00:07:34 an England that is separate
00:07:37 that has its own
00:07:39 powerful identity
00:07:41 over and against
00:07:42 I mean some of it's terribly, terribly crude
00:07:45 let me give you an example
00:07:47 of the final culmination
00:07:48 of all of this propaganda
00:07:50 from my own life story
00:07:51 I was the son of
00:07:54 working class parents of the north of England
00:07:56 very unusual in one sense
00:07:59 in that they were Quaker
00:08:00 which is very unusual for working class people
00:08:02 Normally it's very much the middle class at prayer, reading The Guardian, of course.
00:08:07 But my mother was a slightly different variety.
00:08:10 She was really just a northern working class Puritan.
00:08:13 And when I first, this was my first school trip as a newly anointed grammar school boy wearing my green blaze and my little cap,
00:08:20 my first school trip was to Rome.
00:08:23 The look of horror on her face when this is explained.
00:08:29 I mean, because suddenly all of these visions of the whore of Rome, the whore of Babylon, the wickedness of Rome, its corruption.
00:08:37 She couldn't explain those. She thought she couldn't to an 11-year-old child.
00:08:40 So I can still remember the moment.
00:08:44 Wash your hands.
00:08:46 They've got very funny toilet habits.
00:08:50 Absolutely, David, that was quite unusual at the age of 11 then to be going on a school trip to Rome.
00:08:56 No, it wasn't. It was a little grad school.
00:08:59 I was probably 13. It would be the second year.
00:09:02 But I remember vividly the trip, the trip across the Channel,
00:09:07 wearing a plastic mat because of the only thing that protected yourself from the vomit.
00:09:11 Just unspeakable.
00:09:13 And roughly 36 hours crossing Europe by train.
00:09:18 I can still remember the stop in Basel Station,
00:09:22 eating for the first time black cherry jam, which was totally good,
00:09:25 and the journey through North Italy
00:09:27 and the stink of the hard-boiled eggs in the packed lunches.
00:09:31 Have you ever written about this, by the way?
00:09:34 No.
00:09:34 Never?
00:09:35 That would be wonderful.
00:09:36 The way you're describing it there, it's beautiful.
00:09:38 My agent constantly says,
00:09:40 you should forget the Tudors and write your autobiography.
00:09:43 We can't forget the Tudors for a minute.
00:09:45 No.
00:09:46 Two things I want to ask you.
00:09:48 You mentioned there this sense of England being different.
00:09:52 Henry VIII, certainly to me as a kid,
00:09:55 And now, seems to kind of, doesn't he, he's part of the kind of English folklore, he seems to, somehow, he's mythical, somehow seems to absolutely be the essence of Englishness to some people.
00:10:08 What is that then?
00:10:10 Well, my great teacher at Cambridge,
00:10:12 this is moving on to the next stage of my life,
00:10:14 maybe the next chapter, but two of the autobiography,
00:10:17 my great teacher at Cambridge, Geoffrey Hilton,
00:10:19 the only thing I can remember of sitting at his feet in umpteen lectures
00:10:23 was his comment on the great Holbein portrait of Henry, you know, this one,
00:10:28 in which he pointed out that Henry VIII is the only king whose shape you remember.
00:10:34 But it's true, isn't it?
00:10:35 It's brilliant. Henry VIII is subliminal.
00:10:37 The Holbein portrait underneath all the frou-frou of the the velvet and the
00:10:43 cloth of gold and the ruching and the ostrich feathers and whatever is cubist
00:10:47 geometry. Bodies of trapezium, legs displayed, columns, arms of triangles,
00:10:54 attached triangles. Because he's a rugby player, jousting being rugby on
00:10:58 horseback, the head and the neck are a continuous cylinder. You know what the
00:11:03 rugby player neck looks like and the little hat is the angle. So that goes
00:11:07 into the mind and of course what Henry VIII did the six wives it beats Bluebeard
00:11:13 Bluebeard's a bore with Henry VIII and also ran in comparison with Henry so I
00:11:20 think it really it the Tudors are the English Greek myths they're the Greek
00:11:25 myths of the of the English world Elizabeth comes quite close yes she does
00:11:29 she's the English Virgin Mary yes although I always say it's very important
00:11:34 you understand she's a born-again virgin my clever lady friends tell me this is entirely possible
00:11:40 do you do you ever bother with the various film adaptations that there are do you never
00:11:47 i can't ask you which in elizabeth you thought was best no no no and not that i particularly
00:11:53 disapprove no but i and nor nor you know nor do i read the hillary mantel's of this world
00:11:58 not because of disapproving but i just don't see the point yes i i just remember
00:12:03 But in the Cate Blanchett Elizabeth film, this point is entirely made.
00:12:08 She says, they don't have a mother anymore.
00:12:12 I will virtually, I will become the Virgin Mary.
00:12:15 Hence the white makeup, hence all of this.
00:12:17 Well, and Roy Strong, I mean, who is brilliant on this subject,
00:12:21 he points out that there are surviving engravings of Elizabeth I
00:12:25 that have been turned into votive objects.
00:12:28 They're bordered in paper lace.
00:12:30 They're stained with wax.
00:12:32 I mean, clearly, candles have been put on either side of them.
00:12:36 And, I mean, Elizabeth is the moment at which the relationship with the monarch
00:12:41 really sublimates itself into some sort of notion of submerging in a larger national identity.
00:12:48 If you look under Henry VIII and you look at royal emblems, for example,
00:12:53 the use of the Tudor coat of arms or the Tudor badges,
00:12:56 if you find those in a country house that's redecorated under Henry VIII,
00:13:01 the best known example
00:13:04 of the two of them
00:13:05 one is Itam Moat
00:13:07 a National Clust house
00:13:09 and the other is not open to the public
00:13:10 it's Compton Wignett
00:13:11 of the house of the Marquessies of Northampton
00:13:14 that's built by Henry VIII's Peter Mandelson
00:13:17 that's built by the groom of the stool
00:13:18 who wiped Henry's bottom
00:13:20 I think is exactly the role that one envisages
00:13:23 Peter Mandelson as having played
00:13:25 if you look at both of those houses
00:13:27 they're heavily decorated
00:13:28 with portcullises, roses
00:13:31 and whatever because the people involved are intimate royal servants and attendants yes by
00:13:37 the time you've got to Elizabeth everybody's house yes yes it's become a statement of national
00:13:43 identity the monarchy has kind of nationalized itself before here recording this you've just
00:13:50 come from the portrait gallery haven't you you know when I was growing up this was somewhere
00:13:56 meant a huge amount to me, simply because, you know, this amazing Tudor gallery.
00:14:01 That top Tudor gallery, which is Roy Strong, we were talking about.
00:14:04 It's his great achievement.
00:14:06 And, again, it takes you into, I think, so much of the heart of being English.
00:14:12 Why do we care about the Tudors?
00:14:14 Well, there's yet another reason.
00:14:15 Because of the first people that we know what they look like.
00:14:18 Yes, exactly.
00:14:20 Why you can't get too excited about the Plantagenets.
00:14:24 amazing though they are
00:14:26 is because we don't really know what they look like
00:14:29 whereas with the Tudors
00:14:30 you saw Henry
00:14:32 God would you recognise him
00:14:34 Elizabeth would you recognise him
00:14:36 and I think that's
00:14:37 a central point and it's also
00:14:40 the dynasty which again
00:14:42 it is this question of the definition
00:14:45 of England
00:14:46 the only other medieval king who has
00:14:48 anything like that effect is
00:14:50 Henry V and what is striking
00:14:52 is when you look at Churchill
00:14:54 when you look at the use that he makes of history
00:14:58 of course one of the uses is Henry V
00:15:02 and Agincourt and whatever
00:15:03 but above all it's the few
00:15:07 it's as it were the rerun of the myth of the Spanish Armada
00:15:10 and very strikingly the great American historian
00:15:14 Garrett Mattingly was inspired
00:15:17 by the Battle of Britain to write what I think is one of the very greatest
00:15:22 history books of the 16th century his account of the spanish armada um and and it's these myths
00:15:29 yes that come back time and when we want to talk about the summit conscience it's the field of
00:15:34 cloth of gold yes there is this it's as though the tudors who again remember have a totally
00:15:41 modern appetite for fame a totally modern flair for publicity are also living and using and
00:15:49 manipulating a media revolution the bigger media revolution than even this
00:15:54 stuff you know the revolution of print yes so there are these wonderful echoes
00:15:58 that go across 500 years but what for for a young kid right that got me
00:16:05 interested in history it's simple as that seeing the ditchley portrait of
00:16:08 Elizabeth and this the theatricality of it got me interested what was it for you
00:16:15 that started you on the journey of being interested in history?
00:16:18 Oh, it's much more prosaic.
00:16:19 You obviously had a much more romantic upbringing than I did.
00:16:23 I was... I'm not really... I'm not just teasing you.
00:16:28 I did history as second best.
00:16:30 What was first?
00:16:31 My first best was physics and chemistry.
00:16:33 Really?
00:16:34 I was the star in my little northern grammar school at physics and chemistry.
00:16:39 I did better, actually, or at least as well as,
00:16:42 as somebody who got an open scholarship in the natural sciences
00:16:45 at the same time that I got one in history.
00:16:48 But I wasn't a natural mathematician.
00:16:50 And I had the wit to realise that.
00:16:52 And for me, history is the subject which, with its use of evidence,
00:16:57 with the trawling of sources, with the criticism of sources,
00:17:02 has something like the same foundations as the natural sciences.
00:17:06 which is why I become furious
00:17:10 at the modern attack on the notion
00:17:12 of truth, at the insistence
00:17:13 that everything is just a matter of opinion
00:17:15 no it's not
00:17:17 when did that happen then?
00:17:19 when did you realise that actually you were going to go
00:17:21 the historical way instead of
00:17:23 oh it was after doing
00:17:24 it was literally the decision on the eve
00:17:27 of going into the sixth form
00:17:29 as late as that
00:17:30 because the thing is
00:17:33 I don't know
00:17:34 the thing is, you've sort of become
00:17:36 in a way
00:17:37 you're one of those voices
00:17:40 that is so distinct that it almost
00:17:43 actually moulds the history
00:17:44 in a way. I know that
00:17:47 sounds terribly kind of, you know
00:17:48 Falling. Falling, I'm falling
00:17:51 that's what I'm doing
00:17:52 but I think that this is what is
00:17:55 often lost now, I mean
00:17:56 these things have to be brought to life
00:17:58 and you have to convey without
00:18:00 being condescending to people
00:18:03 Now that's a really interesting point.
00:18:05 I mean, I am passionately of the belief that there is nothing so complicated
00:18:09 that if you actually understand it, you cannot communicate it in straightforward language.
00:18:16 And the great problem, of course, with so many subjects in the arts and social sciences
00:18:21 is that obfuscation is part of the package.
00:18:24 The most obvious example is sociology, which is like medieval theology.
00:18:29 It can only be taught in Latin.
00:18:30 At the moment you translate it, it becomes an absurdity.
00:18:34 And I mean, I am so deeply opposed to that.
00:18:39 I also have the great luck, I suppose, in that I've always been a dissenter.
00:18:45 Well, I was Quaker parents.
00:18:47 I was the only boy in my class, this was literally,
00:18:50 you were saying when you were questioning me at age 11.
00:18:53 I was, my first year at grammar school was the year of Suez.
00:18:58 I was the only boy in the class who supported NASA.
00:19:01 Right, I see.
00:19:02 And that kind of person.
00:19:03 A very popular position, I imagine, at the time.
00:19:05 Really, really popular.
00:19:06 Fortunately, I was more or less the same size then that I am now.
00:19:10 So any attempt at bullying was fairly vigorously resisted.
00:19:14 I remember one of my masters said, you really should take up boxing.
00:19:18 But it never really appealed very much.
00:19:20 Later on, I might have quite enjoyed it.
00:19:22 But what I felt and what I became as a historian
00:19:27 was consciously going against the consensus of the 60s when I was taught.
00:19:33 And when I was taught, it was believed that the Russian Revolution
00:19:36 was the most important event in human history
00:19:39 rather than one of the periodic spasms of horror
00:19:44 that the Slavic people inflict on themselves roughly once every 50 years,
00:19:47 which is clearly what it is now, with Putin merely being yet another Tsar.
00:19:53 And so I went against that.
00:19:55 And I rejected the notion that history is essentially about the mass and comes up from the bottom.
00:20:02 It seemed to me always obvious that, in this sense, I'm a very good Bolshevik, history comes from the top.
00:20:08 History is determined by small groups.
00:20:11 The English Reformation being an absolutely prime example.
00:20:15 I went against, I've already paid tribute to my teacher, Geoffrey Elton, but I fought him every inch of the way.
00:20:21 Here was this man who claimed that government became bureaucratized or depersonalized under Henry VIII, for God's sake.
00:20:31 I can still remember teasing him, and he did not like being, he was very German, the real name, Gottfried Rudolf Ehrenberg, he did not like being teased.
00:20:38 So asking him what was the moment at which he thought Thomas Cromwell, his hero, of course, and Hilary Mantel's hero, explained to Henry VIII that the king was now redundant.
00:20:48 I reckon it was about three hours before he was executed
00:20:52 with a deliberately rusty axe and an inexperienced executioner.
00:20:57 But what that led me to do, this is a serious point,
00:21:01 what that led me to do was an interest in all the unfashionable subjects.
00:21:07 Monarchy, the court, aristocracy.
00:21:11 But of course doing that forces you into a very different sort of history
00:21:16 from the usual political or social history.
00:21:18 You're inevitably driven into the history of things.
00:21:22 I'm a huge believer in two key historical devices.
00:21:27 One is the device of the narrative,
00:21:29 which is also deeply unfashionable
00:21:33 in the teaching and presentation of history.
00:21:36 In other words, history is story.
00:21:37 And I believe that it is actually the only way of understanding things.
00:21:42 Until you know what happened,
00:21:43 How on earth can you possibly understand it?
00:21:46 And 90% of the time, when you look at so-called analyses of the past,
00:21:51 they're based on false narratives.
00:21:53 So all my best books are extraordinarily dense engagements with the source.
00:21:59 They don't read as though they're dense, I hope not,
00:22:01 but they are dense engagements with the sources,
00:22:04 really teasing out what happened,
00:22:06 and then in passages of what's fashionably called thickened narrative,
00:22:10 you then debate it, but within the narration.
00:22:13 so there is that belief in narrative my other commitment as a historian is the belief that
00:22:19 these are real people doing real things in real places in real time that means you need to know
00:22:27 about architecture it means you need to know about geography it means you need to know about dress
00:22:33 it means you need to know about people's toilet habits how they had sex how they went how they
00:22:38 slept how they ate it it's the french of course have a word for it they call it histoire total
00:22:45 total history yes and it's very demanding but i also think it was again this time falling over
00:22:53 myself i think it's why in some ways i was a television natural apart from the ebullience of
00:22:58 personality and the drama no but but also apart from those things it's a bit it's actually you
00:23:05 you've got to have a voice this is the point and i also have a very peculiar voice there was no
00:23:10 but a particular point of view indeed yes absolutely and the but i think it is this
00:23:18 i call it thinginess i mean i've just written now something i don't do very often though i'm doing
00:23:23 more of going back to my roots as a clever research student i've written a research paper
00:23:29 on the royal finances of henry the seventh and i've revolutionized them because i asked the simple
00:23:34 question what actually lies behind these account books where was it done who was there what do
00:23:42 these beautifully flourished pages represent and you realize well at least I've been able to show
00:23:48 that they represent actual specific accounts how did Henry VII control his finances by summoning
00:23:55 his treasurer but the treasurer of the chamber to court every quarter day just like a modern
00:24:01 the business he's summoned there every quarter day and you go through the entire book and you
00:24:06 know what how did the king make sure that those figures were accurate and that the treasurer
00:24:11 wasn't just doing like a modern fraud producing an elegantly balanced fiction because the
00:24:18 treasurer then had to hand over the amount of cash that he said he had all right okay brilliant yes
00:24:25 With those two devices, he is the only king ever completely, before modern times, to control the financial machine.
00:24:35 David, I'm going back to when you said that you've always dissented.
00:24:41 In the academic world, you were a teacher, weren't you, at the LSE?
00:24:48 I mean, I would have thought that you would have certainly kicked against what I see as being like an orthodoxy there.
00:24:54 I don't just mean in the academic sense, but actually even in the political sense, surely.
00:24:59 I mean, yes, I mean, I think going back then, politically probably less.
00:25:05 I mean, I pulled out of full-time academic life 20-odd years ago, a very long time.
00:25:11 I think, again, I'm honest, for much of that period I was rejoicing in the newly developed gay activities of London
00:25:18 and having a jolly good time.
00:25:20 And because I am a natural extemporary lecturer, I could be out enjoying myself till four in the morning
00:25:26 and still do a sort of 10 and 11 o'clock lecture and still be absolutely fine.
00:25:31 So, I mean, how did I kick against the pricks?
00:25:35 I believed passionately in teaching.
00:25:37 I taught the wrong subjects.
00:25:39 I also believed that everybody should be a serious teacher, which many of my...
00:25:45 I've just been having lunch with my former director.
00:25:47 and he was describing his absolute failure
00:25:50 to get my promotion through the academic board
00:25:53 because they all hated me
00:25:54 as I invariably became top of the student appreciation list, you see.
00:25:58 And this was regarded as being a bad thing.
00:26:01 And one of the catastrophes with the universities
00:26:03 is that we have falsely prioritised research.
00:26:07 Now, I think research is very, very important.
00:26:09 But the prime purpose of a teaching university
00:26:13 has to be to teach.
00:26:16 Yes, yes, yes.
00:26:17 But most academics aren't interested.
00:26:20 They're regarded as an unworthy diversion of their time
00:26:23 from thinking great thoughts and getting huge research grants.
00:26:28 David, you mentioned about being a dissenter
00:26:31 and taking on subjects that weren't particularly fashionable,
00:26:35 like the monarchy.
00:26:38 I wonder, we've just had a royal birth.
00:26:42 If you believe it.
00:26:45 I've seen it.
00:26:45 Yeah, there's been...
00:26:46 Oh, apparently it's been on display today.
00:26:48 I just wondered what you're...
00:26:50 As I understand it, as I've picked up,
00:26:52 you don't have that much of a high regard for the House of Windsor, do you?
00:26:55 Or is that unfair, sir?
00:26:57 I think it's rather unfair.
00:26:59 I mean, I think various sovereigns have played their cards
00:27:03 with various degrees of effectiveness.
00:27:05 I have an enormously high regard
00:27:06 for the first sovereign of the House of Windsor, George V.
00:27:10 I think the reinvention of the monarchy in 1917
00:27:13 is one of the great marketing exercises of all time.
00:27:16 They actually market test the name Windsor.
00:27:19 The transformation of a German dynasty into an English family,
00:27:23 the way you turn an aristocratic institution that was held in widespread doubt
00:27:31 into a symbol of sort of bourgeois earnestness and the best of British is genius.
00:27:38 It's genius.
00:27:39 On the other hand, I do have, and it's very unfashionable to say so, I am not entirely persuaded that the present Queen is the greatest that we've ever had, which is the fashionable position.
00:27:54 I think that she has tended to pursue a policy of the quiet life, save in the Commonwealth, about which she has been passionate.
00:28:03 And I think it's no accident that Harry and Meghan have been wheeled into participating in that.
00:28:08 But I think the great problem is that the Queen has left the monarchy as merely symbolic.
00:28:15 Now, the problem with that is it's rather too big an institution merely to be a symbol.
00:28:21 And I think our current political crisis illustrates the fact that the older role of the monarchy,
00:28:29 the role, for example, that her grandfather, when the Queen came to the throne,
00:28:33 she says quite explicitly, I want to do as my father and grandfather did.
00:28:37 well she hasn't they both were the ultimate well especially her grandfather the ultimate
00:28:44 political referee so when it came to the great crisis of 31 you know that long flowing crisis
00:28:50 from the general strike and whatever the second labor government and whatever it is george the
00:28:55 fifth who acts as the political referee who is directly instrumental in putting together the
00:29:02 national government if you look across the channel uh now no longer saying england unique and
00:29:07 whatever but you look at the other surviving monarchies in Europe they all have the role of
00:29:13 political arbiter and of course it's a role which is very alive in many of those countries because
00:29:18 they also have proportional representation which means that each formation of a government is a
00:29:23 work of negotiation and in almost all of them under their essentially 1830s constitutions
00:29:29 the monarch is the referee and um I've seen it with people like Juan Carlos absolutely absolutely
00:29:37 You see it with Queen Margaret of Denmark and so on.
00:29:43 You see it with the sovereigns of the Netherlands.
00:29:46 And the British monarchy is bigger than them.
00:29:50 It's the only sacerdotal monarchy that's left.
00:29:53 It's the only monarchy that practices full coronation.
00:29:56 The continental monarchies don't practice proper coronation.
00:29:59 They simply have oath-takings touching the crown.
00:30:02 They don't have anointing.
00:30:03 I mean, we are the last of the great medieval sacerdotal monarchies of which a shadow survives.
00:30:10 That's too big just to be a symbol.
00:30:12 But equally, I am very aware, and it's obvious why she did it,
00:30:18 because political intervention in an age when there is a lack of deference,
00:30:24 when there is an aggressive contempt for one's social betters,
00:30:27 a sort of levelling, levelling democracy, is difficult and dangerous.
00:30:34 I remember going, what, 22 years ago now,
00:30:37 I remember seeing you on TV after Diana had been killed.
00:30:42 I remember you being, in fact, I think you were on the very morning.
00:30:44 I was indeed. I was the only person, let me finish this story,
00:30:47 I was the only person in London with trousers appearing on television
00:30:51 because everybody had been dragged out of their bed.
00:30:53 At that time, the monarchy looked distinctly mortal.
00:30:56 Oh, I mean, collapsing.
00:30:58 I mean, but in fact, sort of general anti-monichism was actually the kind of order of the day.
00:31:04 Things have been...
00:31:04 Tony Blair's patronage, you know, putting his arm round the Queen.
00:31:09 And Alastair Campbell, for God's sake, sort of gently telling them how to survive.
00:31:16 Yes.
00:31:16 But now, I would say it appears stronger than...
00:31:21 Anything else.
00:31:22 Anything else.
00:31:22 I mean, do you think it has a future?
00:31:26 I mean, I can't help but feel that there is some, in some of its functions,
00:31:34 it's sort of almost actually possibly increased in importance.
00:31:38 If we're becoming more and more fragmented and all the rest of it,
00:31:41 there are very few things actually basically holding the thing together.
00:31:46 But isn't it just, oh come on, aren't you being very highfalutin?
00:31:49 doesn't it just provide terrific material for Twitter
00:31:54 and the right-hand column of the Daily Mail?
00:31:58 It does provide huge quantities.
00:32:01 But I think the reason that the monarchy looks stable
00:32:04 is nothing particularly to do with the monarchy itself.
00:32:06 It's just that everything else has collapsed.
00:32:09 If you look at the division in which Parliament is held,
00:32:13 I mean, first the expenses scandal,
00:32:15 Then the scandal of the deliberate deducing of the verdict of the referendum, the behaviour of the Speaker, the clownishness of the Speaker, who looks like au bourgeois wearing a black gown, the performance of easily the most incompetent Premier we've ever had and the most undesirable leader of the opposition.
00:32:36 And again, the questions over the behaviour of the courts, the collapse of respect for the metropolitan police, you know, you go on, area after area after area.
00:32:49 Yes, I mean, I find that...
00:32:50 So the monarchy, I think, the monarchy is sort of last man standing, or last woman standing.
00:32:55 Yes. I think, for me, you've gone through those institutions there, the civil service, all the rest of them, but since Brexit, it seems to me...
00:33:06 be held in my head as it were because of all of these things which once one did basically believe
00:33:11 it i mean i can also i've asked other people when for example we had this referendum
00:33:17 you know despite all the hyperbole i think most people thought ultimately they will kind of like
00:33:22 pass it through and i think people have been utterly shocked by the sheer level of betrayal
00:33:30 actually i would say is that how you see it i think it is absolutely true but i think what
00:33:35 What you've then got to do, you have to ask yourself, how has this come about?
00:33:39 Why is it that one act, as it were, brought the pillars of the temple tumbling down?
00:33:47 And I think my answer would be that the structure was already fundamentally rotten.
00:33:52 Both political parties, first Blair with Labour, New Labour,
00:33:57 and then the Conservatives under Cameron, were completely hollowed out structures
00:34:03 with minuscule memberships
00:34:05 in which they had been taken over
00:34:07 by a particular faction
00:34:08 and it was a particular faction
00:34:11 espousing a set of universal
00:34:13 neoliberal values
00:34:15 and of course
00:34:17 Cameron, catastrophically
00:34:19 Cameron Clegg
00:34:20 saw Blair as the master politician
00:34:23 I don't know whether you realise this
00:34:25 Blair's book was passed around
00:34:28 as gospel
00:34:28 Blair was referred to
00:34:32 as the master. And it's also very important to understand just how deliberately destructive
00:34:37 new labour was. I mean, fashionable people like Linda Colley's demolition of the notion
00:34:45 of Britishness, that bizarre account by a historian of Poland of the British Isles
00:34:52 and so on, were held up within the civil service as required reading. So you had a
00:35:02 deliberate demolition of the notion of nationhood,
00:35:05 what we know about, again, about, as it were,
00:35:08 rubbing people's noses in it,
00:35:10 either with open-ended immigration on the one hand
00:35:13 or within the Tory party,
00:35:15 the enforcement of gay marriage on the other.
00:35:17 These were all deliberate elite devices
00:35:20 to say, we're in command.
00:35:23 You lot don't matter.
00:35:25 You will do as you were told and you will shut up.
00:35:27 Yes, yes.
00:35:28 And I think that what Brexit has done
00:35:31 has torn the veil from people's faces.
00:35:33 In other words, I think there were absolutely fundamental changes there before,
00:35:38 which we sort of didn't really notice.
00:35:42 I mean, do you think...
00:35:44 How would, therefore, you characterise...
00:35:46 I mean, I know that you...
00:35:47 As a historian, you know, I know you don't like maybe looking at the future
00:35:50 and saying, oh, this will happen, that will happen.
00:35:53 I don't at all.
00:35:54 No, but this, therefore, is an extraordinary time of our history, surely.
00:35:59 Absolutely. I think it's the moment at which two things have happened. I think the constitution
00:36:07 as it emerged from the glorious revolution is manifestly finished. It's stopped working.
00:36:14 You could argue equally that that notion of constitutional development from Magna Carta
00:36:19 itself has also come to an end. I mean, you've got to ask the question, how is it that broadly
00:36:26 we've avoided revolution why have we avoided revolution because in england and we really
00:36:31 should talk it's the english parliament that's just got a few bells and whistles stuck onto it
00:36:37 in england the position of uh those wanting a place in the sun wanting admission to the
00:36:43 political elite you know first the the the entrepreneur and the and and the the the rich
00:36:49 outside the charm circle of the aristocracy and the gentry then the skilled worker then women
00:36:54 and the whole thing. Every one of them didn't want to do what was the case in France or continental
00:37:00 Europe. You didn't want to tear down the existing structures, you wanted a place in them. So
00:37:06 radicalism in England was a campaign for parliamentary representation. You didn't want
00:37:11 to destroy parliament, you wanted a place in it. And I think that what's happened with the referendum
00:37:16 is the first time that parliament as consciously and deliberately and led by its speaker and by
00:37:24 its leading MPs consciously reverse the notion of representation. And it seems to me to be
00:37:32 an act of unprecedented folly. And you look at some of those involved, they're supposedly
00:37:39 quite serious people. I don't think Burkos. I used to think Dominic Grieve was. But it's
00:37:47 a sort of act of institutional suicide and it as i said it calls it calls the home and again
00:37:55 burko's behavior it calls the whole notion of unwritten constitution into question but therefore
00:38:01 i mean this and even the call for a second referendum if there is which won't be a second
00:38:05 referendum it'll be a third or fourth referendum you know we've had two about europe uh we've had
00:38:10 one about scotland we've had one about the electoral system at that point i'm afraid you
00:38:15 then do have to define the status of referenda oh this isn't basically leading us into a position
00:38:22 where you know brexit maybe it's just lit a fuse you know essentially it's a much bigger deal i
00:38:29 think it is i think it's much bigger much bigger and i think that uh the re again the reason for
00:38:35 the vote i mean there is there is now this and this is deeply unoriginal it's not an original
00:38:41 observation at all there is clearly an enormous gulf between a particular liberal elite in which
00:38:49 certain things are totally unsayable that actually most people believe and much of the rest of the
00:38:56 population not all the population but a very significant slice of it it's partly generational
00:39:02 it's partly regional it's all sorts of things but brexit brexit has acted as a kind of acid bath
00:39:10 or a burning lens.
00:39:13 The thing is about the liberal elite
00:39:15 is that there is a feeling still
00:39:18 that they not only haven't learnt any lessons from any of this,
00:39:22 but they're doubling down almost.
00:39:25 Of course, of course.
00:39:26 I mean, I think, again, you see,
00:39:28 one of the things that I think is extraordinary
00:39:30 is with the loss of belief,
00:39:33 with the loss of religious belief,
00:39:35 certainly on the left,
00:39:37 political positions have become religious.
00:39:40 They're not arguments about human society.
00:39:43 They're statements about absolute values.
00:39:46 This means, of course, if you disagree with them,
00:39:48 you are not simply disagreeing.
00:39:50 This is not a debate in which evidence is adduced.
00:39:54 You are fundamentally wicked.
00:39:57 We are now treating political opinions
00:39:59 as though they were creedal formulations,
00:40:02 which means to dissent from them is heresy.
00:40:05 And the only way that you treat a heretic
00:40:07 is the way Roger Scruton has been treated.
00:40:09 I mean, it was extraordinary looking at the Times editorial.
00:40:13 Roger was accused, and in one sense it made some concessions to him,
00:40:17 but then if you recall, it also said he owed contrition.
00:40:21 What a word. That's a religious word.
00:40:24 And what was it that he had to become trite about?
00:40:26 First of all, he had described the Islamic masses threatening Hungary as tribes.
00:40:32 Well, I think they actually are.
00:40:33 if you actually look at how their societies are organized so that's a question of fact
00:40:40 an even more evident question of fact is the second thing he was accused of saying he was
00:40:44 accused of saying and i have no idea whether this statement is true or not he was accused of saying
00:40:50 that one of the reasons why social housing council housing has become contentious in britain is
00:40:56 because it is largely lived in by foreign asylum seekers
00:41:02 whose social habits are radically different
00:41:04 from those of the rest of the population.
00:41:06 Now, that's a statement of fact.
00:41:09 It is testable as to whether it is true or not.
00:41:12 The Times didn't say that.
00:41:14 It said merely saying that sins, let me finish,
00:41:19 against social cohesion.
00:41:21 Now, I'm a believer, going right back
00:41:24 to the beginnings of this conversation on history,
00:41:26 So politics is partly about emotion, but finally it has to be about evidence.
00:41:34 In fact, if we do not have a politics that takes account and is based upon the actual realities of human behaviour and our situation now, we head for disaster.
00:41:47 We head for the world of a false fact and Plato's cave.
00:41:52 And the terrifying thing about this world of the liberal elite, I think it's actually Plato's cave.
00:41:58 I think it's a false world. It's a world of illusion, passionately held illusion.
00:42:05 As a conservative, I believe in fact.
00:42:07 Do you think now, as opposed to maybe when you started your academic life, for example,
00:42:15 do you think that the young people that you come across, that you talk to or whatever,
00:42:20 do they have a far more tenuous grasp of our of our story of the most of them have no grasp at
00:42:29 all unless they unless they happen to be I mean the ones that I really meet have a very good grasp
00:42:34 because they're fans and they love the sort of things that I do but the general impression that
00:42:39 I get is that the teaching of history as dare I say the teaching of virtually every other subject
00:42:47 now seems to be fact-free.
00:42:50 They're inculcated with opinions, received opinion.
00:42:54 Isn't it this kind of experience thing, like,
00:42:55 I am a peasant in feudal, what do I feel?
00:42:59 Empathy, empathy, empathy, empathy.
00:43:02 Empathy, empathy, empathy.
00:43:03 As opposed to infamy, infamy, they've all got it infamy.
00:43:08 If only Keith Williams were the teacher of the nation's history.
00:43:13 It has deteriorated, teaching of history, in, what, 30, 40 years?
00:43:17 I think all subjects have. Partly it's how teachers are taught. The terrible notion that
00:43:24 you need a certificate of education, and I know lots and lots of people who think that
00:43:30 the way to improve education is to close all departments of education. They're disasters.
00:43:35 What you want are teachers who are passionate about their subjects and can communicate them.
00:43:40 And also, again, there has been, certainly in subjects like history, there has been deliberate subversion, what I regard as a proper way of teaching history.
00:43:52 There has been, again, the influence of postmodernism, the attack on fact, the claim that everything is a matter of opinion.
00:44:01 No, it's not.
00:44:03 Again, students are encouraged, children really, pupils, are encouraged to write opinionated essays when they don't know anything.
00:44:12 Isn't this happening really now with science too, in a way?
00:44:15 I don't know.
00:44:15 It's sort of creeping in, isn't it, this sort of whole idea?
00:44:18 I mean, certainly in things like climate change.
00:44:21 I mean, there again, it is terrifying.
00:44:23 You listen to allegedly significant scientists, and they're making totally non-scientific statements,
00:44:30 because it's become a creedal belief.
00:44:33 And it's when what should be a hard science becomes really a campaign for funding,
00:44:41 a campaign for specific forms of political action that contaminates.
00:44:46 It is no longer a scientific discipline.
00:44:49 It's yet another piece of political posturing.
00:44:55 Do you, just to finish off, what do you feel about Britain now?
00:45:02 I mean, do you feel more optimistic,
00:45:07 given that we are talking about these changes
00:45:09 that have been wrought by Brexit?
00:45:11 Do you think this is something that will replenish and revive this country?
00:45:15 Or do you think this is actually something that's going to make it happen?
00:45:18 A final spasm.
00:45:20 Do you know what?
00:45:20 I don't know, because I'm not a prophet.
00:45:22 I mean, I think there are very different outcomes possible.
00:45:27 I think that the conscious attack on the idea of nationhood,
00:45:33 the deliberate denigration of British history,
00:45:37 which is very interesting, this whole attempt at moving slavery to the centre of the story.
00:45:42 What this is an attempt to do is to say that British history is as corrupt as German history.
00:45:48 Of course, the Holocaust has ceased to be useful now to the left as a moral reference point
00:45:54 because they dislike Israel.
00:45:56 And there's now this very powerful flavor
00:45:58 of pro-Palestinianism, pro-Islam, and anti-Zionism.
00:46:03 But also, it's useless because it doesn't attack Britishness.
00:46:08 The Britishness is really the last uncontaminated nationalism
00:46:12 to survive the Second World War
00:46:15 because we didn't suffer the crisis of defeat.
00:46:18 And therefore, the great enterprise of the left is to destroy it.
00:46:22 And the attempt is using slavery to say that British history is fundamentally corrupt.
00:46:30 It's, of course, an absurdity because, A, every other civilization and every other empire practiced it,
00:46:36 many of them on a much larger scale.
00:46:38 But the uniqueness of the British Empire is it destroyed it.
00:46:42 And it's fascinating that my own university, Cambridge, has jumped on this,
00:46:46 led, of course, by a Canadian who rejoices in the name of Toop.
00:46:50 I say it should be Stoop.
00:46:52 bending the knee before these people.
00:46:54 The absurdity of it is, of course,
00:46:56 Cambridge is the pioneer abolitionist university.
00:46:59 It's actually a vice-chancellor's essay
00:47:01 that Lee, in the 1790s,
00:47:04 that leads to the first formulation of abolition
00:47:07 in intellectual terms.
00:47:08 And then it's picked up by William Wilberforce,
00:47:10 of course, who is a Tory.
00:47:12 But this doesn't fit the narrative.
00:47:15 No, it is...
00:47:16 You want a self-flagellating narrative.
00:47:19 But I think this is profoundly dangerous.
00:47:21 And we are peculiarly vulnerable to it, as we are to Brexit, because British identity and nationalism is a very peculiar one.
00:47:29 It's not about national dress. We don't have one. It's not about national music. It's not about Burns and all that sort of boring stuff.
00:47:37 It was always about institutions, about the sense of political continuity, of the excellence of our politics, of the quality of our law, of the strength of our society.
00:47:49 And once you start attacking all of these, you're actually destroying the fabric of social order.
00:47:56 It's not simply a political attack.
00:47:58 You are tearing apart the very fabric of a nation.
00:48:01 Now, it could be, in the best of all possible worlds, Brexit, if there was somebody who could lead, and I don't think Farage is the man,
00:48:11 if there was somebody who could produce a generous, open, welcoming,
00:48:17 as Britain always used to be.
00:48:19 It's still outstanding in its record of the absorption of minorities
00:48:23 and the prevalence of interracial marriage.
00:48:27 All of these things.
00:48:29 London's the most welcoming, open society in the world.
00:48:34 But there needs to be a formulation.
00:48:36 I mean, if Brexit happens, which I think is now very unlikely, if it actually happens, there needs to be a politician who can do a Churchill on it.
00:48:47 In other words, we need a politician who understands it, who can formulate it in a language which touches, which is comprehensible, which embraces, which involves.
00:48:58 And we have nobody, nobody at all, there's this deafening silence or the stutter or the flicker of, you know, shallow eyes going over an auto-view.
00:49:13 On that note, I mean, it's a rather depressing one, but nevertheless a truthful one.
00:49:19 Where can people come and see you, by the way, doing the tour?
00:49:22 Where can they find out about?
00:49:24 Oh, I'm terrible. I'm not even sure I've got a web page.
00:49:28 I'm a political knife thank you very very much like giving us so much time
00:49:35 David and thank you very much watching us so what you're saying is please do
00:49:41 subscribe it's totally free you can just subscribe by pinging on that button
00:49:46 there okay see you next time thank you very much