New Culture Forum - May 19, 2019


Episode 19 - Brendan O'Neill: Anti-Woke: A Duty to Offend

18. Dr. David Starkey - Uncut: Assaults On Brexit, British Identity & History 21: Ben Cobley: How & why identity politics dominates our culture

Episode Stats


Length

45 minutes

Words per minute

175.54

Word count

8,044

Sentence count

235


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to So What You're Saying Is. I'm Peter Whittle. Now my guest today has been
00:00:10 called the funniest and the fiercest opponent of groupthink. He's also been called the most hated
00:00:16 man on UK campuses. Brendan O'Neill is the editor of Spiked Online but he's also written for The
00:00:23 Sun, for The Australian, for The Spectator and many others and he's known to maybe a wider
00:00:28 audience by his many TV appearances, particularly on Sky Press Preview. And his writing has
00:00:34 been put into two books, two collections of essays, one called The Duty to Offend and
00:00:41 the other one called Anti-Woke. Welcome very much Brendan, it's great to see you. I want
00:00:47 to start by Anti-Woke. What actually, where did woke originate originally, the actual
00:00:56 word originate that's a good question it's been around for a long time and it has had different
00:01:02 meanings I think but at the moment I think what it means is a woke person is someone who has
00:01:06 all the correct opinions on identity politics left-wing issues or supposedly left-wing issues
00:01:14 it's someone who in my mind is identitarian quite censorious they always want to crush people who
00:01:22 are offensive or who say the wrong things or who are insufficiently PC. It's a woke person is kind
00:01:29 of in my mind a pretty um censorious authoritarian culture. A puritan. A puritan a puritan a puritanical
00:01:38 culture warrior who cannot abide the fact that there are people in the world who disagree with
00:01:44 him or her. Yeah so I mean interesting things about this because it's it's like a sort of like
00:01:50 the second phase is it not of political correctness yes it is it is the second phase it might be well
00:01:55 who knows i lose track of phases it could be three or four or five but yes it follows on from
00:02:01 political correctness and in my mind it's a more vicious form of political correctness because
00:02:05 you know political correctness has been around for a long time it's this expectation that everyone
00:02:10 must speak in the right way behave in the right way but what wokeness does is take that to the
00:02:16 next level. And the thing I find most obnoxious about wokeness is that, and I say this as someone
00:02:21 who traditionally comes from a left-wing perspective and a left-wing background, is the way in which it
00:02:26 kind of encourages you, in fact it demands that you think racially all the time. It really rehabilitates
00:02:34 racial thinking. So everyone must always go through life thinking that's a black person, that's a white
00:02:40 person that's a black trans person you must always categorize people according to their
00:02:46 inherited traits or their sexuality or their biology or whatever else it might be which that's
00:02:52 the thing about wokeness i dislike most of all which is it kind of it utterly betrays the struggles
00:02:58 the more progressive struggles of the 50s and 60s and 70s which were all aimed at saying look what
00:03:06 we have in common is more important than what divides us and then you have wokeness coming in
00:03:10 this kind of new generation who think they're carrying on the battles of the past but in my
00:03:15 mind they're actually undermining the battles of the past by reinventing the racial imagination
00:03:20 and the censorious imagination and the demand that we treat everyone differently rather than
00:03:25 the same. It is basically regressive isn't it I mean it's like it's keeping people in prisons
00:03:31 isn't it in a way? Yes it is it's entirely regressive I think it forces people back into
00:03:36 the kind of biological boxes that they spent so long escaping from and you know you see it in the
00:03:42 way in which people stand up in meetings and discussions and they will say as a white woman
00:03:47 or as a black woman or as a gay man or as a trans person they're always announcing their identity
00:03:52 before they say their point because in the woke era your identity is more important than what you
00:03:59 think your identity is more important than your character your color is more important than your
00:04:04 character now that obviously runs entirely counter to someone like Martin Luther King
00:04:09 who dreamt of a world in which character would be more important than colour so I find these
00:04:13 kind of declarations of identity incredibly interesting and very worrying because what
00:04:19 they're effectively saying is how I was born how I look what my racial or sexual makeup is is the
00:04:27 most important thing about me and I don't think woke people realise how regressive that is
00:04:33 Because every single positive campaign of the past 100 years, I would say, has in some way been devoted to saying, let's look at the humanist sense of what we share in common, rather than obsessing over our differences.
00:04:49 Exactly.
00:04:50 Interesting thing about the woke thing, though, a bit like PC.
00:04:54 It was once said about PC, is that everyone laughs at it and says, oh God, you know, political quaintness, but they all abide by it.
00:05:01 Yes.
00:05:01 You know, and this is my fear as well about the whole woke thing, is that somehow or other, even though people sort of feel uneasy about it and all the rest of it, it's like it seems to have such a strange power over people that they actually don't want to put a foot wrong, wouldn't you say?
00:05:17 I think that's really, that's a really good point. And that's a really important point about wokeness and about political correctness before that. You know, there's all this obsession over political correctness gone mad, which is not a phrase I've ever used as it happens. And it is a bit of a Daily Mail phrase.
00:05:31 but what that kind of phraseology allowed was it allowed people to think that there were this kind
00:05:38 of there was this extreme thing called political correctness which was kind of out there on the
00:05:43 loony left and so on and in real society things were still pretty normal but in fact what was
00:05:49 happening is that throughout that whole period political correct politically correct thinking
00:05:53 was being mainstreamed more and more and you know people obsessed over the crazy examples like
00:06:01 children being forbidden from singing bar bar black sheep or or Christmas being renamed or
00:06:06 whatever else it might be these kind of extreme examples people obsessed over those while losing
00:06:11 sight of the fact that the fundamentals of political correctness which is that there is
00:06:16 a correct way to speak if you don't speak in the correct way you will be punished there's a correct
00:06:21 way to think race is the most important thing in society and you must think racially all the time
00:06:27 all those kind of central features of political correctness through that period were becoming
00:06:32 mainstream and what you've ended up now you know most woke people tend to be relatively young
00:06:38 you end up with a new generation who have been completely socialized and educated in the pc way
00:06:43 of thinking and so when i speak on campuses or when i speak to young audiences i'm always really
00:06:49 shocked and depressed by how authoritarian they are how entitled they seem and they they have
00:06:57 this sense that they are absolutely right about everything and anyone who disagrees with them
00:07:02 must be silenced they have this incredibly strange um intolerance of the existence of
00:07:09 alternative points of view and they don't realize quite how unusual that is in in human history
00:07:15 Didn't you, there was a piece you wrote in the spectator some time ago now, but I think it was the Stepford Students, isn't that right?
00:07:22 Yes, the Stepford Students.
00:07:23 Stepford being an allusion, of course, to the movie.
00:07:26 Yeah.
00:07:27 So these are the people you're talking about, basically.
00:07:29 Yeah, Stepford Students.
00:07:30 So it's the kind of, it's this new generation.
00:07:32 And the first thing, the most important thing to say is that this is not all young people.
00:07:36 No.
00:07:36 By any stretch of the imagination, I actually think there's an incredibly interesting class divide.
00:07:40 So if you go to the red brick universities, the newish universities, which tend to have a predominantly working class student base, they don't have the same problems of censorship or the same problems of Stepford students as Oxford and Cambridge and Durham and some of these kind of older universities do.
00:08:00 So I think there are many interesting divides.
00:08:03 There are many interesting questions as to where this stuff is powerful and where it's less powerful.
00:08:07 But in the round, I think what's happening on campuses is that the whole point of campus life, which is to allow a space in which all opinions can be expressed, all ideas can be explored, all orthodoxies can be challenged.
00:08:24 That great ideal of the university is falling apart. And it's falling apart partly because the teachers at universities are increasingly intolerant of un-PC thinking.
00:08:36 And also because there is this new intake of largely kind of upper middle class, Stepford style, authoritarian millennials who want to know platform offensive speakers, hound trans sceptical feminists off campus, forbid any open discussion about mass immigration, absolutely forbid any kind of critical discussion about Islam.
00:09:00 they have all they have this powerful sense there are certain opinions you're not allowed to hold
00:09:06 and the thing that worries me about that generation is that they will soon be graduating from these
00:09:12 often quite prestigious universities and going into politics and going into the media and going
00:09:17 into social activism and so those ideas which are already quite pronounced in society itself
00:09:23 will become more pronounced and that's a real worry you you have been no platformed have you
00:09:28 not a university what was that about that was at oxford in 2014 i was due to speak at christ
00:09:34 church college um with timothy stanley and it was on the question of abortion and it was a debate
00:09:41 and timothy stanley was going to put the pro-life case and i was going to put the pro-choice case
00:09:46 and it was advertised as a uh it was going to be a very serious moral discussion between two people
00:09:52 who have very different views on the issue of abortion but feminists at Christchurch and
00:10:00 throughout Oxford University decided that it's unacceptable for men to talk about the issue of
00:10:05 abortion and so they refer to us as people without uteruses no that's how they refer to us in in the
00:10:11 things that they wrote how can how dare these people without uteruses come to our campus and
00:10:15 they said that our presence on their campus would make them feel unsafe and then Christchurch
00:10:21 management kowtowed to their demands and banned the discussion and I thought that was a really
00:10:27 good example firstly of the divisiveness of identity politics so the idea that you can only
00:10:33 speak about an issue if you directly experience it or if you are the right sex or if you are the
00:10:39 right race so that very kind of compartmentalizing dynamic that is unleashed by identity politics
00:10:44 that was the first problem and the second was just the sheer censoriousness the willingness
00:10:50 of students and university authorities to shut down discussions that they thought would make them
00:10:56 unsafe to use their language. So the Oxford no-platforming, I thought, was a good snapshot
00:11:04 of how difficult it can be to have serious moral discussions, important discussions, I would say,
00:11:12 on campuses these days, the one place you would expect it to be very feasible and perfectly
00:11:18 desirable to have those kind of discussions i mean the idea that you can't talk about abortion
00:11:24 because you're a bloke and all the rest of it is you know obviously absurd and completely and
00:11:30 utterly aggressive yeah no question about but we had lionel shriver on a while ago and she was
00:11:35 talking about publishing and the way publishers are going now and it is this is phrase called
00:11:40 stay in your lane yeah and this is going through for example the arts and culture yeah i mean
00:11:47 This is really worrying stuff, isn't it, Brandon?
00:11:51 I mean, you're talking about basically culture as we have known it
00:11:54 more or less actually kind of disappearing.
00:11:57 If you can't speak it except for in terms of very stringent
00:12:01 and very, very particular terms, how can you ever write about anything?
00:12:05 How can you ever paint anything, whatever?
00:12:08 Absolutely. It's the end of literature. It's the end of art.
00:12:11 If you can only speak to and depict and talk about your own experience,
00:12:17 That's the end of literature as we have known it.
00:12:19 The very noble enterprise of literature and acting and playwriting and art
00:12:25 and all these other pursuits, the noble enterprise was the sense of human empathy,
00:12:32 that you could empathise with people, you could tell their stories,
00:12:35 you could feel their stories, you could inhabit them and present them to the world.
00:12:41 That was the idea. It was a very humanist endeavour in many ways.
00:12:46 What you have now is this kind of woke backlash against that idea
00:12:50 and this notion that novelists should only write about their own narrow experiences.
00:12:55 If you're a white woman, in the case of Lionel Shriver,
00:12:58 who's made some excellent arguments on this problem,
00:13:00 then you should write about white womanhood.
00:13:03 If you're a white man, you should never try to create a black character.
00:13:07 You have no right to do that.
00:13:09 Utterly, utterly regressive.
00:13:10 And, you know, the notion of cultural appropriation, which is one of the worst aspects of woke culture, is this, what it essentially is, is a demand for cultural purity.
00:13:21 So white people should stick with white culture, whatever that is.
00:13:24 Black people should stick with black culture.
00:13:27 Gay people should stick with gay culture.
00:13:28 Straight people should stick with straight culture.
00:13:30 And what you realize is that what presents itself as a progressive, liberal, left-wing idea is actually incredibly regressive and more indicative of the kind of far right or the old far right.
00:13:46 You know, the notions of racial purity, cultural purity.
00:13:50 A white person could never possibly understand a black person or a Jewish, a Gentile could never possibly understand a Jew.
00:13:56 That is an incredibly destructive, divisive, highly racialized view of the world.
00:14:03 And what woke culture has done to art, I think, is a very good insight into what it intends to do to society more broadly,
00:14:13 which is this kind of compartmentalization of people according to race, according to sex, according to narrow personal experience,
00:14:21 rather than the traditional, more positive approach of saying,
00:14:25 look, we're human beings, let's understand each other.
00:14:29 This is so an entirely Western thing, isn't it?
00:14:32 Yes, I think so.
00:14:34 I think to the extent that it expresses itself in other parts of the world,
00:14:38 it would be, I think, more explicitly traditionalist.
00:14:42 So, for example, in parts of the Middle East,
00:14:45 it's undoubtedly the case that women are told
00:14:49 that there are certain things they can do
00:14:51 and certain things they can't do.
00:14:53 Men and women are seen as being very different
00:14:55 and never the twain shall meet
00:14:57 apart from full narrow purposes.
00:15:01 So to the extent that there is that kind of racialisation,
00:15:04 sexualisation, that kind of separation of groups
00:15:07 according to their inherited traits,
00:15:10 I think in other parts of the world
00:15:11 it would express itself in a more religious form
00:15:13 or a more traditionalist form
00:15:14 or an explicitly more conservative form.
00:15:19 Whereas what we have in the West is this very intense, this is what's unique about it to the West,
00:15:25 it's this incredibly intense, pseudo-progressive, quite new, historically speaking, campaign
00:15:33 to undermine all the gains that have been made over the past 30 or 40 or 50 years
00:15:40 in relation to racial equality and sexual equality and gender equality.
00:15:44 it really kind of shoots down all of that by saying well actually we're not as similar as
00:15:54 we thought and maybe we should all creep back into those kind of little boxes that we used to
00:15:59 be in in the past so someone like Lionel Shriver makes that point incredibly well which is you
00:16:05 know she is one of those people who sees herself who would have seen herself as very much being
00:16:09 part of the counterculture of the 1960s and the 1970s when you were ripping up you know the old
00:16:16 scripts and saying I'm a woman and I can do whatever I want or I'm a white person and I
00:16:21 will write black stories all those kind of developments took place so someone like her
00:16:25 would see the current woke culture as actually an attack on the counterculture so I think
00:16:32 what we're witnessing is
00:16:34 political correctness
00:16:37 presents itself as
00:16:39 an extension or a continuation
00:16:41 of the struggles of the 50s and 60s
00:16:43 whereas in my mind it is
00:16:44 the complete opposite of that
00:16:46 also another part of this you've already alluded
00:16:49 to as well is that amongst
00:16:51 the people who would call themselves woke
00:16:52 and you mention them as being say like
00:16:54 middle to up middle class and what have you
00:16:56 or many of them anyway
00:16:58 there is also a good old fashioned
00:17:00 social condescension
00:17:02 isn't there oh yes I mean in class terms almost yes that's a key aspect of it you know I've often
00:17:09 thought that identity politics is essentially a way for upper middle class or middle class people
00:17:16 to look down upon the masses but in a way that seems more politically correct than it would have
00:17:20 done in the past you know one of the key aspects of identity politics is it allows people who are
00:17:27 actually have had a very comfortable life and a very nice life to play the victim so if you look
00:17:32 at for example the Rhodes scholars at Oxford who go around saying that these statues of Cecil Rhodes
00:17:37 are deeply offensive and cause them to feel the wounds of history and all this other nonsense that
00:17:42 they talk about and you think to yourself hold on you are in one of the most prestigious universities
00:17:47 in the world there are millions of people who would you know sell their grandmothers to be in
00:17:53 that position but who never will be because they haven't had the opportunities that you guys have
00:17:58 had, and yet you're playing the victim. So it allows them to assume this sense of victimhood
00:18:03 as a way, in essence, of lecturing the masses of society who they see as unenlightened and
00:18:09 racially unenlightened and sexually unenlightened and stupid and feckless and hoodwinked by the
00:18:14 Daily Mail and hoodwinked by Nigel Farage. They really do look upon those people with utter
00:18:19 contempt. And I've heard them expressing that contempt. I have actually heard it when I've
00:18:24 had debates with some of these people and they will openly say things like people don't understand
00:18:31 politics they didn't know what they were voting for in the eu referendum they are easily brainwashed
00:18:36 they're easily led they're gullible they're fickle all those kind of old almost neo-victorian
00:18:42 arguments about the idiotic throng in society you know the kind of thing that john carey wrote about
00:18:49 very well in his book the intellectuals and the masses which was about the kind of literary set
00:18:54 in particular in the early the late if you if you go back to the bloomsbury group yeah and people
00:18:59 like virginia wharf the horror of the crowd that's right she you know she's she sees these crowds
00:19:04 going i think it's to george v's coronation or something and she sort of said oh these appalling
00:19:08 ugly masses of people and all the rest of it this is very is it very very strong isn't it yes and
00:19:14 and and that's coming back i mean maybe it didn't ever go away fully but it's now coming back
00:19:20 explicitly and i hear echoes of that kind of virginia wolf style contempt or you know and
00:19:26 there were other writers too of course um i hear echoes of that now in a lot of the kind of woke
00:19:32 discussion yes um and this sense that there is this swathe of people out there who are
00:19:38 not very well educated not really in tune with the right way of thinking um too right wing
00:19:45 too anti-EU, too much enamored with the tabloid newspapers, all these things.
00:19:51 And I hear exactly the same kind of snobbery that existed in the early 20th century,
00:19:55 which, of course, there was a lot of anti-tabloid sentiment in the early 20th century.
00:19:59 A lot of these people were very worried about the rise of mass education,
00:20:04 mass publishing, mass tourism, all those things which really started to emerge in the early 20th century.
00:20:10 they use those things to express the contempt for the masses themselves
00:20:16 and I think that's coming back with a vengeance
00:20:19 You mentioned Brexit and the role that this has played
00:20:25 I have been surprised by the level of snobbery
00:20:31 that was revealed by the referendum
00:20:36 which has been ongoing
00:20:38 As you say, the implication is these people didn't know what they were voting for.
00:20:42 We, on the other hand, we knew exactly what we voted for.
00:20:45 When it comes to Brexit, Spikes has just endorsed the Brexit party, hasn't it?
00:20:52 Yes.
00:20:52 And you've not endorsed a party ever before, have you?
00:20:56 Yes, so this is the first time we've ever endorsed a political party.
00:20:59 We've endorsed the Brexit party in the Euro elections, which are happening soon.
00:21:04 And we hope they do incredibly well, because it will be another statement of people's intent to leave the European Union.
00:21:11 I sometimes find myself thinking, you know, how many times do we have to say this?
00:21:15 You know, UKIP, when it was run by Nigel Farage, as you will know, won the euro elections in 2014.
00:21:22 And then in 2015, UKIP did incredibly well in the general election.
00:21:27 and then David Cameron did very well because I would say largely because he promised to have an
00:21:33 EU referendum then of course we won the EU referendum and 17.4 million people voted to
00:21:39 leave the EU and then in 2017 80% of voters voted for the Conservatives and the Labour
00:21:45 and Labour on the basis of manifestos that promised to respect the referendum result you know we have
00:21:50 spent years and years and years voting to have a referendum or to respect the referendum so
00:21:57 there is this incredibly strong democratic public desire to leave the European Union
00:22:03 and spite is a very pro-democracy publication we think democracy is one of the well the most
00:22:11 important political value and so the thing that worries us about the kind of Brexit phobia that
00:22:16 exists in British society now, amongst the chattering classes and the political class
00:22:20 and the media class, is that it is going to, or could potentially, undermine the largest
00:22:27 democratic vote in the history of this country.
00:22:29 Without question.
00:22:30 And you're absolutely right that one of the key drivers of that sentiment is blind, unquestionable
00:22:38 snobbery.
00:22:39 I would go so far as to say it's class hatred.
00:22:42 I mean, I never thought I would see class hatred come back in the way that it has.
00:22:47 And the things that I hear people say or read them say about the low information electorate,
00:22:54 you know, which is another way of saying they're thick as idiots, you know, they were hoodwinked by a bus.
00:23:01 You know, apparently the NHS promise on the side of a bus is the reason people voted to leave the EU.
00:23:06 You know, they were won over by demagogues.
00:23:09 you know these demagogues kind of invaded their brains and and basically controlled them like
00:23:14 manchurian candidates to vote for leave that's really how the political elite views ordinary
00:23:20 people and what i find interesting about that and terrifying about that is that the exact same
00:23:26 arguments were made against the chartists when they were arguing for the right of working class
00:23:31 men to vote in in the 1840s and against the suffragettes in the 1910s when they were arguing
00:23:36 I mean, for women's right to vote, the same arguments, which is that the working classes are too visceral,
00:23:41 they don't really understand, they're not rational, or women are, you know, they're way too emotional,
00:23:46 they couldn't possibly understand big, important issues like constitutional matters or legal matters.
00:23:51 Those same arguments are now coming back against Brexit voters.
00:23:56 It's interesting because, you see, what it tends to suggest is that something I always thought was the case,
00:24:01 that basically
00:24:03 that kind of snobbery was sort of
00:24:05 essentially not really there anymore
00:24:07 was a complete illusion
00:24:09 because we have a different establishment now
00:24:11 I mean
00:24:13 you've had a long political journey yourself
00:24:16 when you were
00:24:18 writing in the
00:24:20 1990s or whatever
00:24:21 did you think that that
00:24:24 kind of establishment was no longer there
00:24:26 I mean I grew up at a time
00:24:28 which was quite meritocratic
00:24:29 That was the idea.
00:24:31 What I'm asking you in a way is, was it actually ever meritocratic, do you think?
00:24:35 I think there was definitely a period of that, particularly in the 60s and 70s,
00:24:41 maybe even for some of the 80s, possibly.
00:24:44 I was thinking this, in fact, when Albert Finney died recently,
00:24:48 and I was thinking about, because he came from actually a lower middle class background,
00:24:53 lots of people think it was a working class background,
00:24:55 went to RADA, became the toast of Hollywood, became the toast of British cinema and so on
00:25:00 and his experience is the kind of experience that doesn't really exist anymore so he went
00:25:06 through the grammar school system he was pushed by his grammar school teachers to go to RADA
00:25:10 which working class people never went to RADA and there was this sense of opportunity and
00:25:16 possibility and that ordinary people were as good as the sons and daughters of lords and ladies and
00:25:24 and bureaucrats and everyone else that has definitely slipped away but what i think is
00:25:28 interesting is that um the people who are now promoting the notion that ordinary people are
00:25:35 kind of inferior politically inferior morally inferior intellectually inferior it's no longer
00:25:40 the kind of top-hatted tough tory kind of person who who will absolutely have made those kind of
00:25:47 arguments 60 70 80 years ago it's not those people who are making those arguments now it's the trendy
00:25:54 supposedly marxist very overly educated i would say um leftist types that kind of new establishment
00:26:04 the new establishment and they don't even think they're establishment because oh no they're in a
00:26:08 perpetual state of counter countercultural no they really do think they're the rebellious force
00:26:13 in society and you want to say like you know momentum and corbynistas and everything and you
00:26:17 want to say no you are the emerging establishment and that's just something you have to accept
00:26:22 but the snobbery now which I do think echoes that snobbery of the past which was the idea that
00:26:29 there's this scary terrifying throng of people who don't know what to think and don't know how
00:26:35 to behave and don't know who to vote for that idea has come back but what I find really worrying
00:26:40 about the new snobbery is that that idea is now expressed by people who claim to be progressive
00:26:46 who claim to be liberal, who claim to be anti-Toff.
00:26:49 So there's been a real shift in terms of
00:26:52 who is motoring and promoting snobbery.
00:26:55 Yes.
00:26:56 Your own political journey,
00:26:58 to use that terrible cliché, you know, journey,
00:27:02 has been interesting.
00:27:05 I mean, you were originally writing for Living Marxism,
00:27:08 when you were in the RCP, the Revolutionary Communist Party.
00:27:11 A bit like Claire, who was on, Claire Fox.
00:27:13 Yes.
00:27:16 Where would you, how would you define yourself now?
00:27:20 I mean, I've heard you call yourself an atheist libertarian.
00:27:24 Is that right? Does that cover it?
00:27:27 I'm an atheist. That's a fact of life.
00:27:30 Although I do think I'm not a new atheist.
00:27:33 I'm not one of those people who goes around all the time saying,
00:27:35 I'm an atheist.
00:27:35 I think it's the least interesting thing about someone
00:27:38 because all it tells you is what they don't believe in.
00:27:40 Yes, exactly.
00:27:41 I want to know what you do believe in.
00:27:42 So those people who go around saying, oh, I'm an atheist,
00:27:44 it's like people who go around saying, I'm a vegan.
00:27:46 you're like okay give it a rest but they'll always tell you they'll always tell you the first thing
00:27:50 they'll say so i'm an atheist um i'm a libertarian in the sense that i believe very strongly in
00:27:56 liberty particularly freedom of speech and individual liberty and i'm pretty much off the
00:28:02 mind that people should be allowed to say and do whatever they want so long as they don't hurt
00:28:06 anyone else so that's the extent to which i'm a libertarian but the most important word i would
00:28:11 use to describe myself today is Democrat. I think democracy is an incredibly threatened
00:28:18 political ideal. And I'm a Democrat, not because I think people always get it right. People often
00:28:25 elect governments and I'm thinking, why the hell did you elect that government? But because I
00:28:29 really genuinely believe that the best way to do politics is to engage as many people in the
00:28:34 discussion as possible. And, you know, it's a point the Chartists made. The Chartists made a
00:28:39 point in one of their newspapers, they said, look, we're not saying that working people are just as
00:28:44 good as lords and ladies and bureaucrats are doing politics. We're saying that they're very often
00:28:49 better. And they're better because they live in society, really in society, in a way that those
00:28:55 people often don't. And that's an argument that often gets lost these days. And the point I want
00:29:00 to make in relation to Brexit and other democratic issues is that, you know, the former factory
00:29:05 workers in Stoke, or the girls in Essex, or the coal miners in Wales who voted for Brexit,
00:29:13 perhaps they understand what Britain needs better than the people who live in the Westminster
00:29:18 bubble and never leave it. And that's the argument we've got to push now, I think.
00:29:22 So, Brenda, you were born in London, like me. What about your family? Are they Brexiteers too?
00:29:29 or you know yes or um pretty much not all of them but most of them are um i was born in london my
00:29:36 parents are from ireland the west of ireland they came here in 1970 and um for work to you know to
00:29:43 find work and to have a family and everything else um they had a large family as irish catholics
00:29:47 tended to do um so there i there are six of us six siblings and where are you in the where are
00:29:54 I'm in the middle, two older, three younger.
00:29:58 And off those six siblings, five are pro-Brexit and one is anti-Brexit.
00:30:04 But we're very sympathetic to him.
00:30:06 We don't treat him badly or anything like that.
00:30:08 But I think that's fairly typical for...
00:30:13 Because, you know, the thing that people forget about London,
00:30:15 and this really, really irritates me,
00:30:17 people forget that one and a half million Londoners voted for Brexit.
00:30:21 London is seen as the Remainer city.
00:30:24 More people voted to leave in London, 41%, than voted for Sadiq Khan.
00:30:30 That's absolutely right. 200,000 more voted for Brexit than Sadiq.
00:30:34 So when Sadiq swans around saying this is the Remainer capital,
00:30:38 you want to just remind him, hold on, Brexit is more popular here than you are,
00:30:42 democratically speaking.
00:30:44 But, you know, what's fascinating to me, and this fascinates me about Brexit in general,
00:30:48 But even in the context of London, I think that the divide, there's a class element to the divide.
00:30:57 And so there are working class pockets in London where there will be very strong pro-Brexit sentiment.
00:31:03 And then there are other parts of London which are middle class or working class and middle class, where there will be very strong pro-Remain sentiment.
00:31:10 So even in London, I find the patchwork of differences incredibly interesting.
00:31:14 Are your families still in London?
00:31:16 Yes, they still live here.
00:31:18 yeah yeah well i mean we when i was growing up we as a family used to talk a hell of a lot about
00:31:25 the news and stuff i mean were your were they politically interested your family they were
00:31:29 yeah we talked about the news we watched the news we read the newspapers um you know the news was
00:31:36 seen as something you ought to be interested in you really should have have a stake in what's
00:31:41 going on you should have a sense of what's going on um and it was seen as something that it was you
00:31:47 know you couldn't just go through life without understanding your surroundings I think some of
00:31:53 that might be lost these days or certainly I think people have a more confused and difficult
00:31:59 and strange relationship with the news now partly because of the rise of the internet and social
00:32:04 media and the fact that you have to kind of almost make your own news or find your own news
00:32:08 so I think it's more difficult but back then there was a very strong sense you had to buy a newspaper
00:32:13 every single day. You should read it. You should talk about it. You should watch the news at nine
00:32:17 o'clock, which is when you found out what had happened. There was no other way of finding out
00:32:21 what had happened in the day. So I think like most families, there was this sense that you
00:32:26 had to keep in touch with the world beyond your own house. When were you first interested in
00:32:31 politics? I mean, I said you were in the Revolutionary Communist Party. Were you from the start or were
00:32:37 you political before that? I mean, when did you become interested?
00:32:42 So, really, in the kind of early to mid-1990s, in my late teens, I kind of started getting
00:32:50 a sense that I was thinking I'm quite left-wing. But none of the left-wing parties were attractive
00:32:56 at all, you know, like the SWP and all the... They all struck me as quite bovine, you know,
00:33:02 they were not very intellectual. They were almost proud of the fact that they were not
00:33:07 very intellectual. They all used to put on these kind of very whiny, pseudo working-class
00:33:13 accents. I call it the Ken Livingstone accent, this kind of attempt to ape what they think
00:33:20 is the way ordinary people speak, and that used to always really put me off. So I looked
00:33:26 at radical left-wing parties and thought, none of them are for me. But then the Revolutionary
00:33:30 Communist Party, which I eventually joined, and then it disbanded a year later, so I was
00:33:36 for an incredibly short period of time,
00:33:39 just looked like a more attractive proposition.
00:33:42 It was very smart.
00:33:43 It was very intellectual.
00:33:44 As you say, it had people like Claire Fox.
00:33:47 It also had Mick Hume, who was the editor of Spiked before me.
00:33:50 These were very smart people, very engaged people.
00:33:52 And Frank Faraday was here.
00:33:54 And Frank Faraday.
00:33:55 So it was very different to the other parties.
00:33:59 It was much more switched on.
00:34:00 The people looked...
00:34:02 They dressed better than the other parties,
00:34:05 which seems quite important.
00:34:06 They were more engaged in ideas. They were more willing to talk about the world as it was, rather than this kind of fantasy version that some on the left have.
00:34:15 So that party looked to me to be more interesting. I think even when I was in it, I was aware of the fact that this was the end of an era.
00:34:23 You know, communism, Marxism, I mean, those things, in my mind, this is my own personal view, they're dead and gone, right?
00:34:30 that was a very interesting experiment
00:34:32 it was a very interesting moment in political history
00:34:34 it won a lot of allegiance
00:34:36 from a lot of people
00:34:37 but I do think those things are
00:34:40 history and what I'm interested
00:34:42 in now is not so much left
00:34:44 versus right or Marxism versus capitalism
00:34:46 and those kind of old arguments
00:34:48 I'm much more interested in where the new divides are
00:34:50 emerging, where the new politics is coming from
00:34:52 and I think some really important
00:34:55 political divides are emerging
00:34:56 right now and those are the ones
00:34:58 I think it's worth thinking about.
00:35:01 It's very interesting you say, actually,
00:35:03 that you say those ideas are dead and gone
00:35:05 because for quite a long time,
00:35:09 what Claire might say, what you might say,
00:35:11 people who have been in the Revolutionary Communist Party,
00:35:14 there's been a real kind of sense of similarity
00:35:18 with people on the right.
00:35:21 We very much agree about, well, free speech,
00:35:24 we very much agree about the risk aversion culture,
00:35:27 all of these things,
00:35:28 But they were always cultural aspects.
00:35:30 I often wondered where, therefore, people who were formerly of the RCP
00:35:34 stood economically now.
00:35:36 It's one area.
00:35:38 Do you actually think, therefore, that capitalism is not going to deconstruct
00:35:46 because of its own internal contradictions?
00:35:48 Do you not believe that anymore?
00:35:50 Well, my issue with capitalism at the moment,
00:35:52 and I wrote about this in The Spectator a few years ago,
00:35:55 I wrote a piece and I think the headline was something like,
00:35:57 help I'm a Marxist who stands up for capitalism because my issue with capitalism at the moment
00:36:02 is that is its lack of daring its lack of ambition and so the problem of risk aversion is a very
00:36:09 serious problem um you know the the fact that so much of the modern economy is devoted to financial
00:36:17 questions and financialization and the loss of any sense of the importance of creating new
00:36:25 opportunities new jobs new work new ways of doing things new ways of transporting things it strikes
00:36:33 me that capitalism has lost its own sense of itself and its own sense of ambition and its own
00:36:38 project of transforming the world so when I look at capitalism now I don't think
00:36:43 when the left looks at capitalism they think oh it's it's gone too far yeah it's doing too much
00:36:49 It's too global. What I want to say is that it's not done enough and it's not ambitious enough and it is constantly beating itself up over the fact that it, I don't know, causes pollution or causes inequality and all these other things, which is undoubtedly true.
00:37:06 So I come at this from a slightly strange perspective,
00:37:09 which is that I actually want to encourage capitalism to go further and further
00:37:13 because I think the creation of wealth and the creation of opportunity
00:37:17 and the creation of work is so important.
00:37:19 You know, when I see environmentalists marching through the streets,
00:37:23 as Extinction Rebellion did recently, calling for an end to economic growth,
00:37:28 calling for a shift away from the question of economic growth,
00:37:31 I find that incredibly inhumane, right?
00:37:34 Because we live in a world in which 3 billion people exist on less than $10 a day and live in dire conditions and extreme poverty.
00:37:45 And I find it extraordinary that in a time like that, people could march through the streets calling for an end to economic growth.
00:37:53 So I think the contemporary anti-capitalism is not the kind of thing you would have had 50 or 100 years ago among leftists,
00:38:03 which was always about how can we create more stuff,
00:38:06 how can we have more production, how can we have more consumption.
00:38:09 The problem with contemporary anti-capitalism is about
00:38:12 how can we have less production, how can we have less consumption.
00:38:15 It's about reining in, and I find that really worrying.
00:38:18 What's quite interesting about the way that capitalism is behaving now,
00:38:22 or at least on the surface, surely,
00:38:25 is that it's adopted, to go back to our first subject,
00:38:28 the whole woke agenda, is it not?
00:38:30 Yes.
00:38:30 This is the extraordinary thing.
00:38:31 This is not a public sector thing anymore, is it?
00:38:34 Yeah. Capitalism is incredibly woke.
00:38:36 It's very PC. It's very green as well.
00:38:40 But is it entirely cynical, do you think?
00:38:42 Or, you know, is it pure sort of shop window dressing?
00:38:46 You know, if you look at all the sort of boxes you have to tick in the public sector,
00:38:51 you know, your average human resource department now in any corporation would be exactly the same.
00:38:56 I think there's an element of window dressing.
00:38:58 But I think the scary thing, which is the thing that it's far more difficult to grapple with, is that I think a lot of them really mean it.
00:39:06 They really have bought into the woke agenda and the green agenda and the kind of PC agenda.
00:39:12 And I think it's an expression of capitalism's loss of drive.
00:39:19 And they disguise, if you like, they disguise that loss of drive by adopting all these new ideas and phrases and terms
00:39:26 to make it look like they're being progressive and nice,
00:39:30 you know, caring capitalism, as they call it.
00:39:32 But in fact, actually, if you scrape all that stuff away,
00:39:35 what you really will find is an economic system
00:39:37 which is no longer driven by any sense of ambition
00:39:41 or any sense of growth
00:39:45 and is constantly wanting to rein in and be more meek.
00:39:50 So I do think their embrace of the woke agenda
00:39:52 is partly a way of saying we're nice guys don't beat us up so much yeah but also more significantly
00:39:59 i think it does speak to the fact that they actually buy into that stuff this is what i find
00:40:05 you know anti-capitalism i think is now the core ideology of capitalism itself so when you have
00:40:12 anti-capitalists kind of in europe outside these kind of at davos or the g8 meetings or whatever
00:40:18 else it might be screaming about how evil capitalism is i always think hold on the people
00:40:23 inside those conferences probably agree with you more than you realize so um capitalism itself
00:40:29 is in serious danger of becoming anti-capitalist and the problem with that is that we could see a
00:40:34 down even more of a downturn in relation to production and consumption you mentioned again
00:40:41 there woke which is a part of the whole coin of the whole free speech and
00:40:45 offense subjects that we've actually touched on today just wanted to ask you
00:40:54 Brandon when it comes to these issues such as what seems to be a constriction
00:41:00 of free speech as imposed by world people you know and the culture of
00:41:05 offence isn't the problem that essentially people have now you know
00:41:11 internalize these things so much that you actually don't have to worry in a
00:41:16 way about making sure they go they abide by it they sort of internalizing they
00:41:22 don't they sort of I feel now amongst people there's a great confusion about
00:41:26 what actually they can and cannot say anymore and so therefore you know in a
00:41:32 way um it's almost like job done if you know what i mean i think that's absolutely how do we actually
00:41:38 move away from that if that's yes that's the big question and i sometimes think to myself that if
00:41:44 it was just old-fashioned boot on the face state censorship it would be easier because you'd know
00:41:51 where the problem of censorship was coming from and you'd know what needed to be done to challenge
00:41:55 it you'd need to dismantle those laws you need to put the state back in its box exactly it would be
00:42:00 much more straightforward but I think you're absolutely right the problem we have now is the
00:42:03 internalization of the censorious dynamic yeah and the new culture forum has done lots of work
00:42:08 on this yeah yeah well we did stuff on uh on uh free speech and what people felt they could say
00:42:14 around about the same time as you I think were doing stuff on about campuses yes that's right
00:42:19 you're talking about three or four years ago now that's right but the thing is that what it comes
00:42:23 down to it is okay so how do we get you know if you've got to a position where basically free
00:42:28 speeches become quite constrictive how does it then become unrestrained again it's the million
00:42:35 dollar question and i think you know the point people will often say things like oh it's only
00:42:40 censorship of the state does it the you know i i encounter this argument all the time i encounter
00:42:45 it from the left and the right in fact i leftists will say you know are no platforming of people
00:42:50 it's not censorship because it's just a kind of voluntary group demanding the censorship of this
00:42:56 person but and it's but it's only censorship of the state does it i hear it from the right too
00:42:59 who will often be quite cavalier about censorship on social media by twitter and facebook because
00:43:07 they will say well these are private companies it's not the state so it's okay we shouldn't
00:43:10 worry about it and the point i make to both of those groups of people is that they need to go
00:43:15 back and read john stuart mill on liberty because in that book he articulates incredibly well that
00:43:21 often the biggest problem in relation to censorship is not the state and not law but is the tyranny of
00:43:28 custom the tyranny of wisdom the tyranny of um the accepted way of understanding the world
00:43:35 and that's a very informal social pressure to conform and to say the right thing and to think
00:43:41 the right thing and to silence your opinion if it's the wrong opinion so mill talked about that
00:43:47 huge enormous informal pressure to conform to the the accepted way of thinking and i think we have
00:43:55 a real serious problem with that now where people have internalized uh this it's like this stasi in
00:44:01 your head you know you don't need the stasi up in your attic anymore spying on you because you have
00:44:06 your own stasi in your brain telling you well you shouldn't say that because you'll become you'll be
00:44:11 very unpopular if you say that you might lose your job you might be banned from the social media
00:44:15 so just suppress that opinion and it gives rise to there was a there's a european sociologist i
00:44:21 can't remember who it was but they talked about the spiral of silence and it gives rise to this
00:44:26 spiral of silence where more and more people simply do not express themselves the reason
00:44:31 that's a problem is because public discussion becomes increasingly dishonest and partial
00:44:36 and all opinions don't find expression there as to how we should challenge it i really do think
00:44:43 the owner should be on encouraging people to be braver to take risks and I think people who are
00:44:49 already in the public sphere for good or ill can lead that by saying the unsayable by expressing
00:44:58 the opinions you're apparently not allowed to express to really give a bit of a lead to others
00:45:03 and say look you can say these things and that's why I think something like Brexit and ensuring
00:45:10 that Brexit happens is so important because that's a way of saying the establishment doesn't want us
00:45:17 to have this opinion about the European Union, but we're still going to have it and we're still
00:45:21 going to make sure that it actually happens. And that in itself would be a good signal to people
00:45:26 that it's okay to have unfashionable opinions. Brendan, thank you. Keep on expressing yourself,
00:45:34 please. Thanks very, very much for coming in. It was great. We could have gone on for a lot longer.
00:45:38 um thanks very very much for watching please do subscribe this little thing will come up shortly
00:45:43 and you can click on it and then subscribe so see you next time and thank you very much for watching
00:45:49 Goodbye.