New Culture Forum - June 02, 2019


21: Ben Cobley: How & why identity politics dominates our culture

Episode 19 - Brendan O'Neill: Anti-Woke: A Duty to Offend 22. Simon Richards: The State of Freedom & The Nation

Episode Stats


Length

29 minutes

Words per minute

160.44

Word count

4,747

Sentence count

100


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to So What You're Saying Is, I'm Peter Whittle.
00:00:09 Now, identity politics appear to have an increasing grip on British politics and indeed our culture.
00:00:16 But who is behind identity politics and how do they maintain its extraordinary and growing influence?
00:00:23 Ben Cobley is the author of this book, which is called The Tribe, The Liberal Left and
00:00:29 The System of Diversity. He is a journalist, he's also a former Labour activist, and he
00:00:35 is the author of a blog called A Free Left Blog, and he's with me now. Ben, thank you
00:00:41 very, very much for coming in.
00:00:42 Thanks for having me.
00:00:44 The book is called The Tribe, so let's start at the beginning. Who, what is The Tribe?
00:00:51 Well, the tribe is, I mean, it's in the subtitle, the liberal left, as I call it, or you could say in its full title, getting very wordy, the progressive liberal left.
00:01:01 Now, I think of this as an identifiable group.
00:01:06 but on the other hand I think the way that we can identify it
00:01:11 means that we can all sort of fall in and out of it
00:01:16 almost as we like by picking up its idioms
00:01:19 which for me are based around identity politics
00:01:22 and about favouring certain groups and protecting certain groups
00:01:27 and more generally indirectly sort of unfavouring the other groups
00:01:33 because it's a sort of zero-sum game.
00:01:35 Yeah. You said the subtitle is the system of diversity. So what is this system? I mean, that tends to imply a kind of practical, a very practical system.
00:01:46 Yeah, that's quite an interesting question. I think it's, I call it like a system of relations.
00:01:52 Yeah.
00:01:52 so you can say like in a
00:01:55 you know in a call or response
00:01:57 sort of situation say the
00:01:59 liberal left someone who's of a liberal left
00:02:01 disposition will make a call
00:02:03 and then you can get a predictable
00:02:05 response say if you're on Twitter
00:02:07 and I mean recently
00:02:09 we've had John Cleese getting into trouble
00:02:11 with him talking about
00:02:13 London not feeling very English anymore
00:02:15 if you say that's racist
00:02:17 immediately you'll get a
00:02:19 positive response from the rest
00:02:21 of the gang so in terms of that that's how i see it in terms of being systemic right in a way that
00:02:28 it's predictable um but also um that there are there are relations not just between say people
00:02:36 on the liberal left side of politics but then to like the representatives of the favored identity
00:02:42 groups and there's also i would say like a call and response that goes on between those two um
00:02:49 those two groups and um it it kind of it again it makes it kind of systemic in character and
00:02:57 sorry if i'm waffling with this um but it kind of makes it systemic in character because those
00:03:02 representatives tend to act in a certain way right in order for those for those relations to work in
00:03:09 a predictable fashion they have to represent their groups as being victims you know almost
00:03:16 universal victims of society and of the of the unfavored groups of the system and if they do that
00:03:23 then just everything sort of sort of fits in they can claim maximum victimhood and the liberal left
00:03:30 who is overseeing and supporting them you know has a justification for doing that. So I think we
00:03:36 sort of know but for clarity's sake who would the favored groups be then? So we're looking at
00:03:43 Firstly, women, non-white people, gay people.
00:03:50 I think immigrants is an interesting category.
00:03:52 It's more, I would say, sort of people who appear to be immigrants.
00:03:56 So in contrast to sort of, you might say, native English or British people.
00:04:02 Also Muslims is an important category, I guess, within the non-white grouping.
00:04:08 Right. And so the unfavoured groups would be what? Straight white males?
00:04:11 Well it's us lot, it's mostly straight white males.
00:04:15 Well no, actually I've got favoured characteristics
00:04:17 being gay, apparently.
00:04:19 Right, yes, yes.
00:04:20 I've got protected characteristics, apparently.
00:04:21 So yeah, if you don't, I mean, looking at the system,
00:04:25 if someone like you doesn't play up to that gay identity
00:04:29 as being a victim of society,
00:04:31 then you don't fit into the system.
00:04:33 Right, yes, yes.
00:04:34 And in a way you're a traitor to the system.
00:04:35 Yes, exactly, I think it's particularly right,
00:04:37 because particular vitriol is actually reserved,
00:04:41 you know, if you're not going to type, as it were.
00:04:44 But, so you have the groups, but, so what happens then, for example,
00:04:49 if the demands of one group or the rights of whatever one group are essentially met?
00:04:55 You know, what happens there?
00:04:57 If it appears that, you know, equality, you know, is enshrined or whatever,
00:05:02 what happens? Do they stop being a favoured group?
00:05:05 It doesn't appear to be that way.
00:05:06 Oh, not at all.
00:05:07 No, I mean, that's the thing, it's a system of politics.
00:05:10 And whatever happens in society, the system must keep going for people to continue in their roles.
00:05:18 You know, if you're a liberal left person who, you know, takes a stance overseeing society.
00:05:26 You know, if there's a situation where, as we have in our country, I think, you know, in a lot of ways,
00:05:31 where, you know, women are doing very well, especially young women, non-white people are doing well,
00:05:37 especially certain groups like indians and chinese you know doing very well in society
00:05:42 but that doesn't fit the narrative so if if you're part of this system of diversity as i call it
00:05:50 you can't play up to that or or maybe if you do you can you can do it in terms of favoring those
00:05:56 groups and saying aren't those those groups um doing well and to be praised it can never be
00:06:04 praising the you know say british society or english society yeah or western society you could
00:06:10 say yes exactly what this is an entirely western thing isn't it pretty much although you know with
00:06:19 a globalized culture it has it has sort of got tentacles into everywhere i mean i guess i
00:06:27 immediately thought of south africa but you could say that's in a way part of the western world but
00:06:32 i guess you know the whole world to an extent is westernized now but places like you know japan
00:06:38 and china they kind of find this sort of stuff incomprehensible really thing is is that uh you
00:06:43 know i mentioned at the top there that is increasing influence uh this seems to be going
00:06:50 you know exponentially throughout all institutions i mean you know right you know now into charities
00:06:57 into what have you you know i wonder you know how does that actually happen i mean you know
00:07:04 one doesn't it's not a conspiracy theorist or whatever but you know how is this actually how
00:07:08 we arrived at the situation where apparently now even corporations you know hr departments
00:07:15 all the rest of it now basically practice this particular approach don't they i think i think
00:07:21 it's largely that and obviously there's so many different angles things going into it but it's
00:07:28 it's that point about um you know it's it's almost a tautology that um this stuff has become
00:07:34 completely dominant in society and there's very little counter narratives yeah which are prevailing
00:07:42 and you know in that sense say if you're looking at uh businesses they they tend to follow what's
00:07:49 popular you know right you say it's purely window dressing in their case to an extent I think that
00:07:57 you know the the the the huge influence of these forms of politics as such that you know they are
00:08:05 they are serious about it and they're doing more than you might expect if they were just
00:08:11 window dressing but in terms of charities I think if if you look at charities or civil society in
00:08:19 general it's overwhelmingly progressive and liberal left in character I think you know if you
00:08:26 look at perhaps other versions of the left or you know conservatives so largely sort of abandoned
00:08:33 civil society for me and and it's allowed the progressive liberal left to basically prevail
00:08:39 and I think during the labor years labor government years new labor
00:08:44 this sort of expanded a hell of a lot
00:08:49 and through outsourcing especially
00:08:50 What do you mean by that?
00:08:52 So a lot of charities now
00:08:54 but also businesses
00:08:56 government outsourcing services
00:08:59 into the charity sector
00:09:02 and into the business sector
00:09:03 and that means that there's more
00:09:07 basically political patronage on offer
00:09:09 while if you're working just through government
00:09:12 then you've got to rely on the civil service.
00:09:15 Although, of course, the civil services have largely been taken over by this stuff as well.
00:09:20 But through outsourcing to charities and handing out public money to charities,
00:09:25 that meant that political activists could get more involved and get hold of public money and use it.
00:09:32 And I think if you look at the charity sector now, at least that's kind of around politics,
00:09:37 you can see that so many of the people involved are
00:09:43 especially former Labour activists
00:09:45 or at least are visibly politically connected from their past
00:09:49 and I wouldn't say, I mean like you
00:09:53 to talk about it as some sort of conspiracy
00:09:55 I don't see it like that
00:09:57 I kind of see it as almost happening by accident
00:10:01 and in politics the Labour Party being in government
00:10:05 being very active in government and doing a lot of things.
00:10:08 I mean, you used to be a Labour Party activist.
00:10:10 You used to be, that's right, isn't it?
00:10:11 Yes, that's right, yeah.
00:10:12 But, you know, I think you mentioned in the book
00:10:14 that the Labour Party has become entirely controlled,
00:10:18 if you like, now by identity politics, really.
00:10:20 I mean, to the point where, you know, it wasn't...
00:10:23 Presumably they just got, what, impatient of waiting
00:10:25 for working-class people to maybe rebel
00:10:28 or whatever it is, or what?
00:10:31 I think largely through time, you know,
00:10:34 So if you look at the traditional Marxist view of history, where the proletariat, the
00:10:40 working class, is the agent of history which is going to overthrow capitalism and bring
00:10:45 about utopia on earth, obviously that didn't happen and there were no signs of it happening.
00:10:51 And even just on a more prosaic level, the working class were never aligned to the conventional
00:11:02 forms of politics that you know progressive intellectuals tended to have
00:11:06 so identity politics as we see it now as a it's kind of offered alternative
00:11:12 groups to kind of put into that role yeah you know in a quite informal way
00:11:17 but you you often see in the way that these people talk you know the
00:11:21 politicians and activists that they do have sort of transcendental so utopian
00:11:26 hopes for for example Britain becoming more and more diverse and multicultural
00:11:31 yeah and for women you know rising up in power um that this is a good by definition um and uh
00:11:40 like i say there's there's some real sort of truly utopian sort of hopes behind it is it sort of
00:11:47 maybe a naive question but is it a sincere desire on their part or is it entirely
00:11:53 to break down what they see as power structures
00:11:55 um you know because on the face of it you could say well what's wrong in having more women in
00:12:02 power exactly yeah there's some good aspects to it of course and there's some good will
00:12:07 and um i tend to see that it's it's a mixture of so much stuff going on there's you know there's
00:12:15 naivety in one sense there are some genuine sort of philosophical ideological sort of quite harsh
00:12:23 beliefs about transforming the country and getting rid of you know Englishness or even
00:12:29 Britishness but especially Englishness and destroying like white male culture but I think
00:12:38 generally it's you know on the everyday level most politicians and activists really don't feel
00:12:43 like that it's it's more a matter of just fitting in and and not causing trouble and aligning to
00:12:51 the affiliations you know with with the right groups because i just seem to remember i'd say
00:12:56 around about the 1980s with you know ken livingstone that this kind of the rainbow coalition
00:13:01 of minorities that's when i first became aware of it really taking shape and it was sort of up to
00:13:07 that point the left was very much about you know trying to further the condition looking after if
00:13:14 you're working class people or whatever it was around about then would you agree with that that
00:13:18 it sort of pretty much changed well funny enough this isn't something i've really looked into
00:13:24 in my book right i mean really in my book i've deliberately didn't look to write history right
00:13:30 i look to write about how how it works now on an everyday level sort of you know like i said
00:13:37 before like how the call and response sort of works you know what the cues are and what the
00:13:42 consequences of this are so really with that type of thing i'm i'm really not you're probably more
00:13:47 of an expert than I am. Have you got any examples you can give us from the book of the way that the
00:13:53 system stays in place or an instance that comes to mind maybe? Oh sorry of the the system yes in
00:14:00 the way that yes exactly or for example you know how I mean because I think look the main point
00:14:05 is really is that when you talk about the liberal left basically people and I think they're right
00:14:11 think that this is a relatively small number of people, right?
00:14:15 How come that a relatively small number of people
00:14:19 can have such a massive effect, actually, on the culture of a country?
00:14:23 I wouldn't say it's a small number of people at all.
00:14:26 Really?
00:14:26 And if we're looking at charities, if we're looking at public service,
00:14:30 civil service, teaching profession, obviously into universities,
00:14:34 we're talking about very large numbers of people,
00:14:39 and especially through the education system,
00:14:41 through indoctrination for younger people coming out of university you know largely being aligned
00:14:48 to those sorts of ways of thinking so I'm I don't think it's a small number of people at all it's
00:14:54 it's huge and if you look on social media Twitter it's very it's very clear to see that it's it's
00:15:01 huge there's a piece in the spectator by Toby Young this week he's talking about this is really
00:15:08 going strong in America isn't it what we're talking about the whole diversity yes he's talking about
00:15:13 it coming gradually here and he mentions for example a statistic the 4,700 employees for the
00:15:20 department of education here now all have to have unconscious bias training would this be a part
00:15:26 this is a part of the system in a way isn't it yes an unconscious bias training is quite
00:15:32 it's quite common now and is spreading not just through our public services but you know through
00:15:37 the charity sector and then in the charity sector into, you know, charities going in
00:15:43 and indoctrinating, well, maybe that's a bit of a strong word, but, well, perhaps attempting
00:15:49 to indoctrinate businesses and business employees. So, yeah, I think that's quite a good point.
00:15:56 A lot of it does arise in America, whereas, you know, with so many things, it's a lot
00:16:01 stronger a lot sort of more assertive and aggressive in america although we can see over
00:16:07 here we are following pretty pretty heavily and pretty successfully in that sense did it did you
00:16:13 find it hard to get your book published i mean it's a it's a very you know it's a the publishing
00:16:20 industry i would say on the whole is pretty left um very left in fact and i think that what's
00:16:26 happened over the past but certainly since the referendum is that they've kind of doubled down
00:16:31 they haven't opened they've kind of got they've really sort of like battened down the hatches on
00:16:35 that would you didn't you didn't have any trouble getting published well I I did and I you know for
00:16:43 a while I I tried to get an agent and completely failed at getting an agent um I didn't I didn't
00:16:49 go direct to many publishers I was quite lucky in that I you know in that an opportunity came up
00:16:54 with a very small publisher, but I knew, I mean I'd been writing on this stuff for years.
00:17:01 I'd written 100 plus articles mostly on identity politics and it got reasonably well known
00:17:07 and I got no interest at all from, especially from liberal left publishers, relentless sort
00:17:13 of ignoring and rejection and you've just got to accept that.
00:17:18 But I do think of myself as quite lucky to have got through that and to have got it published
00:17:23 even, like I say, with a very small publisher.
00:17:25 You had some help from Claire Fox, didn't you?
00:17:28 That's right, yeah.
00:17:28 What happened there? She just championed the project?
00:17:31 Well, she read, I think, an article or two I'd written about Brexit and the arts.
00:17:37 And the arts?
00:17:38 And the arts, yes.
00:17:40 And she responded well to those, and we met.
00:17:45 And she said, yeah, she would try and help me with the book, get it published.
00:17:48 And, you know, a few weeks later, she wrote to a publisher,
00:17:52 and then I was lucky enough to get a contract.
00:17:55 So I owe a lot to her and she's one of my heroes anyway,
00:17:59 but even more so with that.
00:18:01 Interestingly, you were writing there about Brexit in the arts.
00:18:03 I don't know what the particular thrust of your article was,
00:18:06 but what certainly became clear is that the arts were like 90% pro-Remain
00:18:12 and what have you.
00:18:14 I worked in the arts for a long time as a journalist and TV programme maker.
00:18:18 and again you you know you had an extraordinary kind of uniformity of views and I think that
00:18:27 the identity politics and the system of diversity that you talk about in your book
00:18:31 is very strong is it in the creative field very much so it's almost like they're the kind of
00:18:38 visual display unit for it in a way yes it's in a sense you know the arts have become subject to
00:18:47 politics yeah and that's you know there's always been a close relationship and I wouldn't say that
00:18:52 you know artists shouldn't be political I mean the reverse but when there's such a uniformity
00:18:59 of sameness and and where actual messaging itself has become artistic in a sense all gets sold as
00:19:08 art you know just sort of ranting about Nigel Farage or Boris Johnson you'll you'll find sort
00:19:15 of exhibits doing that in in our galleries and things so I think there's
00:19:23 an extraordinary extent to which that has that has spread because like like I
00:19:29 say it's always been around and you know sort of with with modernistic art as
00:19:36 well you know it's always it's always been quite political but um yeah it's
00:19:40 gone a lot further certainly do you think there's anything as why in the in
00:19:44 the view that for example you know the gay lobby achieved many of the things
00:19:53 they wanted you know civil partnerships marriage and what have you fine but then
00:19:59 sort of suddenly almost out of the blue comes transgenderism it's almost like we
00:20:05 have to quickly replace you know one group with another I I wouldn't say it
00:20:13 like that again i'd i'd see it you know looking at the the transgender lobby itself seeing how
00:20:21 other groups have been very successful using a certain model of maximizing their victimhood
00:20:27 relentless hammering away political activism um you know contributing very actively to political
00:20:35 consultations you know for example one on the gender issue in government to the extent that
00:20:41 you've had a conservative government almost sort of repeating their mantras.
00:20:46 I think it's more than, like I say, copying that sort of approach.
00:20:54 And again, like I say, with the system of relations,
00:20:56 the liberal left or the liberal left way of relating to the world
00:21:00 and relating to identity, going,
00:21:02 oh, here's another example of what we support and what we protect.
00:21:06 and you you remain victims regardless of your economic circumstance or whatever
00:21:12 that's the point with identity politics isn't it i think i mean i it's it's all very superficial
00:21:17 this stuff it's surface level once you get into the reality of it i mean it it kind of it does
00:21:23 fall apart a lot of the you know the truth of it the reality of it so if you're if that's your
00:21:29 your backup you can't you can't be going into the detail of it you've just got to sort of discuss it
00:21:34 on a superficial sort of surface level.
00:21:38 And if enough people do that around you
00:21:41 and relate in the right ways, like I say,
00:21:45 then, you know, it doesn't really matter if it's nonsense.
00:21:48 Yeah.
00:21:49 You mentioned at the beginning there John Cleese,
00:21:52 who's quite a recent example.
00:21:55 But, you know, what happens if you fall foul of this?
00:22:00 I mean, that was a Twitter storm.
00:22:01 OK, you can sort of almost discount, well, not discount, but, you know, it's Twitter, right?
00:22:06 That happens on Twitter.
00:22:07 But what happens if you, in a work situation or in an institution,
00:22:13 if you had qualms about this sort of thing, what would happen?
00:22:17 Presumably, you know, you'd be put beyond the pale, wouldn't you?
00:22:20 Well, there's cases happening all the time, you know, of people complaining about discrimination
00:22:28 and taking to tribunals and making complaints
00:22:31 and people losing their jobs over it.
00:22:33 And obviously some of those are going to be real instances of racism,
00:22:39 et cetera, of nastiness, but a lot of it isn't.
00:22:42 A lot of it is just sort of casual remarks
00:22:45 that don't completely align to the apparent consensus
00:22:50 which is about the favoured groups must appear as victims
00:22:54 and in need of protection.
00:22:56 so whenever someone from a favoured group
00:22:59 I mean I give the obvious example
00:23:01 in the introduction to my book
00:23:03 of the Rotherham child abuse
00:23:06 you know mass child abuse cases
00:23:09 and in that you had a lot of people in Rotherham
00:23:14 who knew what was going on
00:23:15 and in public services who knew what was going on
00:23:17 but they were so afraid of the denunciations
00:23:20 that were coming for being racist
00:23:22 that they wouldn't do anything
00:23:23 yes so you see one form of protection triumphing over another so the form of protection of of the
00:23:32 men who were committing these crimes prevailing over the protection of children and you know you
00:23:38 could say largely another favored group girls but they didn't have in that circumstance anyone
00:23:44 really on their side exactly so so and then when actually that's a good example because when
00:23:51 people might have pointed out things after like the mp did didn't she or wrote an article her
00:23:58 name is it was sarah what is her name now the mp sarah champion sarah champion she wrote a piece
00:24:03 and you've not really heard from her since have you it's extraordinary it's remarkable how it
00:24:09 happens of of suddenly people who don't align you know i said earlier to the consensus but it's more
00:24:18 just aligned to the you know the favored unfavored distinctions and if you come out and and and don't
00:24:26 conform to that then you're going to be get put outside the system well you you have already put
00:24:31 yourself outside the system of diversity i would say um so so like you say with sarah champion now
00:24:37 she just doesn't really appear in public life she was a junior minister for the government at the
00:24:43 time sorry for the um the labor partner that's right junior shadow minister and uh she she lost
00:24:49 her position very quickly and we've barely heard of her since and and this is this is the way it
00:24:56 works but it's also the way it kind of has to work you know because otherwise this system of
00:25:01 relations like i talk about it kind of falls apart what is the prognosis what if you look to the
00:25:10 future how can this system if you like and be challenged or can't it do you think it's a very
00:25:21 good question and a very difficult question to engage with an answer and i tried to in my book
00:25:27 because you know we are talking about a dominant system of of politics which is excluding other
00:25:37 other way just basic other ways of doing politics in all corners of public life and even to a large
00:25:45 extent in private life so combating it I mean a lot of us do already for example by writing
00:25:55 articles but you're always responding to what's being put out there and there's so much being
00:26:03 put out there at all times that you just can't keep up no I mean I think
00:26:08 sometimes you could easily write a daily newspaper of what's going on with in
00:26:14 relation to progressive identity politics and also the backlash but the
00:26:19 crucial thing is organization because if you like they are organized yeah yeah
00:26:26 and that's a large measure of the success that they they have institutions
00:26:31 which are are well-funded and continually are producing reports who have people who are you
00:26:39 know spokespeople in public life who are available to to turn up so we find with that that like we
00:26:47 said before i think the progressive liberal left is kind of just appears to be dominant it's always
00:26:51 there it's always appearing in public life and alternative views are always kind of appearing
00:26:57 almost as a response um and never sort of so much putting their own sort of standpoint out so
00:27:06 i mean one thing i'm i'm really interested in is is the way that identity politics uh
00:27:11 reduces standards in all areas i mean we've talked we talked about art you know the politicization
00:27:17 of art um we could say democracy as well with brexit as well um i i think uh identity politics
00:27:26 is is wrapped up in the in the whole brexit affair and it's a reason why so many left people turned
00:27:32 against brexit because there was a politicization along those system of diversity lines from the
00:27:39 beginning the roman campaign was doing that um so we've got art um democracy uh i think just
00:27:48 just on a wider notion truth yes just the idea of truth um and we talked about rotherham but with
00:27:56 so many of these these affairs these these media storms which come out and for example with john
00:28:01 cleese the people commenting on it were were not commenting on what he said at all they were
00:28:06 commenting on associations that they had made with him mentioning englishness and you know not
00:28:13 feeling that london is english anymore um and interpreting that straight away of him being a
00:28:20 racist you know and like i said before if enough people support that and go along with that it
00:28:27 doesn't really matter if it's a lie or maybe lie is too strong a word i would say it's more bullshit
00:28:33 because they're not they're not really concerned with the truth they're not really engaging with
00:28:38 what is said and what is done um so in terms of combating it i think you're looking at
00:28:46 maybe that's a bit abstract and vague but you are looking at institutions which
00:28:51 are looking to tell the truth and which are looking to promote you know promote
00:28:56 the pursuit of truth and of protection of democracy and the promotion of
00:29:03 beauty you know through art for example and indeed books like yours which are
00:29:09 very very important Ben thank you very very much for coming on it is called by
00:29:15 the way again the tribe the liberal left and the system of diversity you can get it on amazon is
00:29:21 that right yes it's on amazon uh also on the publisher's website if you if you search for it
00:29:26 it's a very very important book thank you very much very much and uh look forward to seeing you
00:29:31 next time on so what you're saying is thank you oh and by the way please do subscribe