New Culture Forum - December 04, 2019


2.11 Simon Heffer: From The Great War to Brexit: A Traditionalist View of Britain

S2.10 Theodore Dalrymple: Britain's Vanishing Culture & Character 2.13 Prof. Frank Furedi: The Culture of Fear in the 21st Century

Episode Stats


Length

35 minutes

Words per minute

169.73

Word count

5,949

Sentence count

160


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to So What You're Saying Is, I'm Peter Whittle. Now my guest this week is
00:00:21 Professor Simon Heffer, perhaps best known to you as one of our most prominent political
00:00:26 commentators and journalists. He's also the author of numerous books, including
00:00:33 critically acclaimed biography of Enoch Powell, Like the Roman. His latest book
00:00:38 is this, Staring at God, Britain in the Great War. It's the third volume in a
00:00:45 series he's writing which takes British history from the Victorian age up to the
00:00:50 Second World War. He currently teaches modern British history at the University
00:00:54 of Buckingham. Thank you very much for joining us. Thank you for asking me. Thank you. Why this title
00:01:00 Staring at God? I was in the Bodleian Library at Oxford about three years ago reading Mrs Asquith's
00:01:05 diaries which are a brilliant account of what went on in Cabinet in an era before Cabinet minutes were
00:01:12 kept. We're very lucky in regards to this because Asquith told his wife everything. He also told
00:01:17 his would-be mistress Phoenicia Stanley everything until May 1915. So up until then we've got
00:01:23 double accounts of what went on at cabinet meetings. So we can see the political process
00:01:29 in the conversion of our country from a liberal democracy into a state that was equipped for
00:01:34 total war. But when the war broke out in August 1914, Mrs. Asquith asked Kitchener whether it
00:01:43 would be over by Christmas. She believed it would. And Kitchener said, no, it's going to last three
00:01:48 years and she didn't believe him and by the end of October she's had a number of
00:01:53 her friends sons who've been killed or wounded on the Western Front and she's
00:01:59 been beginning to despair she sees she hears about the two armies entrenching
00:02:03 on the Western Front which they are after the Battle of the Marne and she
00:02:07 realizes it's going on for a long time and that Kitchener was right and on the
00:02:11 26th of October 1914 she writes in her diary that Britain had been going
00:02:16 through a terrible period before the war with massive industrial unrest unrest over suffragettes
00:02:23 unrest over ireland and a constitutional crisis in the house of lords that had divided london
00:02:29 society and she says in that regard this war has caught us at our worst yeah and then she goes on
00:02:34 to say and now all our finest young men are being blown to pieces by shrapnel in flanders and we are
00:02:41 left here staring at god and when i read that phrase i thought well that's the title of my book
00:02:46 because it conveys that sense of almost unprecedented hopelessness
00:02:52 and a sort of foreboding of an apocalypse
00:02:54 that I think had descended on British society by the late autumn of 1914.
00:03:01 This isn't a military history, is it?
00:03:03 No. It's a history about what it was like for us,
00:03:07 what it was like for the people at home,
00:03:09 and how society was transformed by this four and a bit years of war,
00:03:14 particularly about how it affected women who of course came into the labour force in vast
00:03:20 quantities we wouldn't have won the war without them they went into munitions factories notably
00:03:24 they went on to the land the women's land army which we all think of as a second world war
00:03:29 creation started in the first war and they also started to replace men in jobs all over society
00:03:36 they became bus conductresses they they worked on the railways and every job apart from actually
00:03:40 driving trains which I'm sure they could have done perfectly well if they'd been given the chance
00:03:44 and they were given the vote as a result of this massive contribution they made to the war effort
00:03:51 but it's the end of the deferential society as well it's a lot of those women who go into
00:03:56 factories come out of domestic service and the idea of the class system starts to become more
00:04:01 flexible and politics changes the old victorian um idea of political service changes and lloyd
00:04:10 george when he becomes prime minister at the end of 1916 brings in what were called um men of push
00:04:16 and go who are basically spivs but they're spivs who know how to run a business and he brings them
00:04:21 in to get government run more efficiently there's a very fundamental uh point you make and i think
00:04:27 is I found very interesting which is that you said you said that during this period there was
00:04:33 a transformation but that it was actually one wherein the state became hugely dominant in
00:04:41 people's lives I think most people would probably think that was the second world war where that
00:04:45 happened well the second world war was modeled on the first in that respect and everything that
00:04:50 happened in 19 the winter of 1939-40 was was based more or less on how the government in a
00:04:56 slightly slower way, had adapted from being a liberal society to being a society equipped
00:05:02 for total war between about 1914 and 1916. And the first emanation of this is the Defence
00:05:09 of the Realm Acts, which are passed on the 6th of August 1914. And this controls what
00:05:14 people can say, what can be written in the newspapers, where some people can go. If you
00:05:20 are deemed to be an enemy alien, you can't go within so many miles of the coast in case
00:05:26 signal to a submarine or so many miles of an army camp and the defense of the realm act is amended
00:05:33 a number of times until 1918 and it puts more and more restrictions on on what people can do
00:05:39 you know we have the licensing laws in in pubs for the first time because many working class people
00:05:45 are having to work 80 hours a week in factories to keep up the supply of munitions and other
00:05:50 materials needed for war they've suddenly got lots of money in their pockets and they're spending it
00:05:54 on drink and I mean a team from the Royal Navy go up to Glasgow to the shipyards in the spring of
00:06:01 1915 and find that some shipbuilders at a time when the Royal Navy desperately needs more ships
00:06:06 are drunk two days of the week they're only working three days a week because they are so
00:06:11 paralifically drunk and overhung by the amount they're drinking and so the government brings in
00:06:17 restrictions not only on when pubs can open but it becomes for example illegal to buy somebody
00:06:22 else to drink it's the law against what they call treating so the state does start to intervene
00:06:29 but the most profound way in which it intervenes is it tells men of a certain age that they must
00:06:34 serve their country and it presses women doesn't compel them but it presses women also to go into
00:06:40 the service of their country so that would bring about a psychological would it would it also mean
00:06:47 that people started to see the government as a thing that should do things for them perhaps in
00:06:53 a way they didn't before i think there was an element of that before the war because don't
00:06:57 forget from 1910 or so churchill who's then president of the board of trade um introduces
00:07:03 labor exchanges and in 1911 lloyd george introduces the national insurance principle
00:07:09 so there is a sense already before the war that the state is starting to provide for individuals
00:07:18 who can't provide for themselves the old age pension has come in in 1909 it's very ungenerous
00:07:24 it's five shillings a week which even in those days was a pittance and you don't qualify for
00:07:28 it until you're 70 now when you bear in mind that the average age of a man with death was 48
00:07:34 in 1909. The government's not spending very much money on this. But the principle has been
00:07:41 established by this same liberal government that being that we are a rich and advanced society,
00:07:48 we will no longer tolerate the extremes of poverty that were seen, say, in Victorian England.
00:07:53 But yes, once the state starts getting more and more involved, there is inevitably a section of
00:07:58 society that is very happy to have its life more and more run by the state.
00:08:03 the the volume before this called the age of decadence isn't it that's right it takes up to
00:08:08 1914 do you do you agree with the the idea i remember i was taught at university when i did
00:08:15 history um that in an odd way the first world war sort of prevented what could have been quite a
00:08:22 social revolution happening in britain you know there was this idea that things were trade union
00:08:27 activity what was happening at that time on a social level things were becoming rather dangerous
00:08:35 as it were there was certainly a rise of the labor movement and what ramsey mcdonald called
00:08:39 the great unrest which lasted from 1910 to 1913 certainly made certainly an emanation of trade
00:08:47 union power however trade unions didn't seem to gain very much by it it was an era of very long
00:08:54 strikes with people being starved back to work. So when you start starving people back
00:08:58 to work, eventually perhaps what might have happened is what happened in Russia, and there
00:09:02 would have been some form of revolution. And I think that possibly a revolution was prevented
00:09:08 by the war, not least because the governing class, and I'm thinking of everyone from the
00:09:13 king downwards in the upper echelons of society, was seen to be playing a very full part in
00:09:18 saving the country. So there wasn't a revolutionary mood, didn't get up. I wonder how quickly women
00:09:26 would have been emancipated without the war. Asquith, who was, although a prime minister who
00:09:31 was very interested in women, in that he spent a lot of his time with them, and liked intelligent
00:09:37 women, peculiarly was deeply opposed to women's suffrage. Yet he must have seen that most women
00:09:43 that he knew were easily intelligent enough
00:09:46 to exercise a vote as much as any man was.
00:09:50 And yet he gets up in the House of Commons
00:09:51 in October 1916 and says,
00:09:55 I've now realised,
00:09:57 given the contribution women have made to the war,
00:09:59 given that they are staffing our munitions factories,
00:10:01 they're bringing our harvest in,
00:10:04 that without them we wouldn't have been able
00:10:06 to fight the war this long,
00:10:08 or as well as we have,
00:10:10 and therefore they must have the vote.
00:10:12 and I just wonder whether they would have got the vote by 1916
00:10:15 if there hadn't been a war.
00:10:17 The other unknown is Ireland.
00:10:18 Ireland was due to get Home Rule in the autumn of 1914.
00:10:26 There was a huge row about whether Ulster should be included or not
00:10:29 and for the first four weeks after the assassination of Archduke Franz Ferdinand
00:10:34 there's no mention in the House of Commons about the situation in Europe.
00:10:37 There's an enormous obsession with the fact that
00:10:39 because the Home Rule Act is about to go on the statute, that there might be a civil war in
00:10:48 Ireland and a civil war that spills over here because of the big Irish communities in places
00:10:53 like Glasgow, Liverpool, Birmingham and London. And it's only when it becomes absolutely obvious
00:11:01 that the war is about to break out on the continent that we stop obsessing with Ireland
00:11:04 and start obsessing with Europe. But then, of course, we have the Easter Rising,
00:11:08 of which we make a complete mess
00:11:10 in terms of how we handle it
00:11:12 and as soon as the war is over
00:11:14 with Germany we have a war with the Irish
00:11:16 until the end of 1921
00:11:18 There was something
00:11:20 that really rather
00:11:22 came out of me when I was looking
00:11:24 at the book
00:11:25 just a quote you say
00:11:28 about
00:11:30 if you're looking at the transformation of Britain
00:11:32 in this book
00:11:33 you say it went from
00:11:35 an almost arrogant certainty
00:11:38 to a wounded insecurity.
00:11:41 And I just wondered, Simon,
00:11:43 do you think that that wounded insecurity,
00:11:47 notwithstanding the Second World War,
00:11:49 do you think that's something that's persisted?
00:11:51 I mean, did basically the First World War start it
00:11:56 and have we come out of it ever?
00:11:59 I think it's roots line the Boer War,
00:12:02 which we thought we were going to win again in a few months.
00:12:05 And it took us two and three quarter years.
00:12:08 I mean, we were a proper army, allegedly, fighting against a bunch of Dutch farmers armed with shotguns.
00:12:13 And they held us up from October 1899 to May 1902.
00:12:20 And we were so concerned by our performance in the Boer War that we had a major inquiry into the army led by Lord Escher.
00:12:27 And it was decided, for example, that many of our young men were so grotesquely undernourished and unfit that they'd had to be turned down for the army.
00:12:35 And if we faced a challenge nearer to home, we had to have a fitter and healthier population.
00:12:41 And so that's when in the 1902 Education Act, physical education is put on the syllabus.
00:12:47 And a primitive form of welfarism begins to ensure that children are being properly fed.
00:12:53 And allowances start to be paid in Edwardian England to families who say they can't afford to feed their children.
00:12:59 So we begin to realise that the great sense of invulnerability that pervaded the Victorian sense of empire was an illusion.
00:13:09 By the end of the Great War, we realised that, or those who are honest with themselves realised,
00:13:17 that we only won it partly because two million Americans turned up in the summer of 1918
00:13:24 and continued the fight that we'd almost exhausted ourselves having.
00:13:28 and we won it because of the success of our naval blockade of Germany
00:13:32 that had starved Germany more or less into submission
00:13:34 and it's why when the Americans arrive and start driving the Germans back
00:13:38 rather than just retreat they surrender in their droves
00:13:42 because their morale is collapsed
00:13:44 and so we realise that this wasn't a war that we managed to win on our own
00:13:47 it was a war that we won because of the late intervention of a major associate
00:13:52 the Americans didn't call themselves allies
00:13:54 Has this lasted you through until today?
00:13:56 I think what has lasted through until today is a sense of self-flagellation about our country
00:14:02 and about our values. And you see this in the Brexit debate. The number of people who say,
00:14:09 well, we're not capable of ruling ourselves. We can't survive without Europe helping us.
00:14:13 And there is this instinct that we're just not up to it. I mean, Jeremy Corbyn's entire political
00:14:20 philosophy seems to be based on the fact that we are a loathsome country that has all the wrong
00:14:24 values and can't possibly maintain itself which is why he finds it so easy i think to associate
00:14:29 with this country's natural enemies as i was going about to ask you actually about what brexit has
00:14:38 coming right up today what it's kind of revealed about changes in british society you you've
00:14:44 actually mentioned something there which is actually a continuum really isn't it it's
00:14:47 it's basically this distaste for one's own nationality that you get on the left yes and
00:14:53 I think the other thing about Brexit, and I've thought this since the campaign of 2016,
00:14:58 which I was very active on the Brexit side,
00:15:01 is that there was a large number of people in this country
00:15:05 whose voices had been ignored for decades.
00:15:10 And on the European question, no choice had been offered by any serious party
00:15:16 at a general election really since 1983
00:15:19 when Michael Foote still campaigned on a programme of taking us out
00:15:25 and no one in his or her right mind would have voted for Michael Foote in 1983
00:15:29 purely because he wanted to take Britain out of the European community as it then was.
00:15:34 But I feel what Brexit has shown is that in a representative democracy
00:15:42 people become very alert quite quickly to when they're not being represented
00:15:47 and that's why the idea of a referendum was embraced so wholeheartedly
00:15:51 why it was such a massively large turnout
00:15:53 the biggest vote of any sort in our country ever
00:15:56 and why it has been so difficult for some of us to accept
00:16:00 or to tolerate I should say
00:16:05 the determination of a few people on the Remain side
00:16:08 to ignore the result and to carry on as if nothing had happened
00:16:12 I mean you said you campaigned and you've been a Eurosceptic for years
00:16:16 it's my perception really that when one had debates about Europe
00:16:22 the opposition people who were pro-EU
00:16:25 what tends to be kind of reasonable
00:16:27 there are real problems with it
00:16:29 but on balance we want to be in
00:16:30 what it seemed to be the case with this referendum campaign
00:16:36 and after that
00:16:36 is there seemed to be a new group of people
00:16:39 who were quite zealous about the EU
00:16:41 they they're not asking for reform they don't see anything wrong with it at all
00:16:45 that seemed to be to be quite new to me yes I mean I remember realizing just
00:16:53 after the vote I went to high table at my college at Cambridge and there was a
00:17:00 very senior retarded civil servant there who was just happily telling everybody
00:17:05 don't worry this won't happen we'll ensure it doesn't happen and it seemed
00:17:11 to come for nothing with him that 17.4 million people that just said look actually we don't
00:17:16 think it works we don't think it's benefiting our country and I mean to me I slightly deplored
00:17:24 the 350 million thing on the side of the bus I didn't campaign for vote leave I campaigned for
00:17:28 leave.eu because to me it wasn't about saving money even if that happens incidentally to me
00:17:35 it was simply getting back control of my country and being able to vote when I voted in an election
00:17:40 to be able to vote for people who could actually change things
00:17:43 that profoundly affected my country.
00:17:46 And it wasn't all about immigration,
00:17:49 but when you've got a position where someone who is a very serious criminal
00:17:53 but who has no outstanding warrants against him
00:17:56 but who has a record of criminality
00:17:57 can turn up at Dover and say,
00:18:00 I'm coming in whether you like it or not.
00:18:02 Whereas if you try and get into America,
00:18:04 even with a minor drugs conviction, they will kick you out.
00:18:07 Never mind if you're a rapist or an armed robber or a murderer.
00:18:10 or run anything really vile like that,
00:18:14 I thought, well, we are taking leave of our senses to allow this.
00:18:18 I'm very much in favour of immigration.
00:18:19 I'm very much in favour of anybody who can do something useful for our country coming here.
00:18:25 But what I'm also in favour of is regulating the people who do come in.
00:18:30 And we must retain the right to do that.
00:18:33 And it's an obvious manifestation of sovereignty.
00:18:36 But when things happen in our country, particularly of an economic nature,
00:18:39 that you can't change by changing the government it seems to me that's a fundamental failure of
00:18:45 democracy and we had had that again and again with the european union over the last 30 years
00:18:49 and i just felt the time had come to stop that have you been surprised by the resistance
00:18:57 to brexit over the past three and a half years uh you know there is this sort of view now that
00:19:04 actually you know Britain was slightly different it would sort of carry through
00:19:09 with the result and then but a lot of people saying actually maybe aren't we
00:19:12 so different the way things going you know everyone is doing everything to
00:19:16 thwart it what were you surprised by the level of resistance or not I was
00:19:22 surprised by its level I was surprised by its promiscuity if you like I was
00:19:28 surprised there were so many people who were prepared to stick up two fingers to
00:19:32 democracy. You know, you either believe in democracy or you don't. It was not a howlingly
00:19:39 right-wing Prime Minister who introduced this referendum. It was David Cameron. And it had the
00:19:45 support of almost everyone in the House of Commons. More than 500 MPs voted to have this
00:19:50 referendum. So if you're going to have that level of parliamentary support, then I think it is
00:19:57 incumbent, particularly on the parliamentarians who voted to have the referendum, that its
00:20:03 result is respected. And I was horrified. I know that if we had lost, I had this conversation
00:20:09 with my children, both of my sons, despite having gone to very good universities and
00:20:15 very good schools, are Brexiteers. I know the popular perception is that only very stupid
00:20:21 working class people are Brexiteers, which is an offensive and highly wrong assumption
00:20:27 to make both about them and about everybody else but they said to me well what do we do dad if we've
00:20:35 lost and I said well I don't do anything but in 30 years time you might want to ask the question
00:20:40 again actually on the reflection I don't think that the EU will exist in 30 years time not in
00:20:45 its present form anyway and so I thought that you know we all understood that once the answer was
00:20:52 given that was the answer and we just carried on and waited for another opportunity many years
00:20:57 hence to say effectively as the liberal democrats are doing in this campaign yeah well you know let's
00:21:02 let it never happen let's revoke article 50 and stick up two fingers to 17.4 million people
00:21:07 i think is an outrageous affront to democracy and how a liberal democrat can call him or herself a
00:21:15 liberal democrat either a liberal or a democrat with that level of contempt for the democratic
00:21:21 process is beyond me and it's a question that is not being sufficiently asked in this election
00:21:25 campaign yeah i agree it's extraordinary but it's got the feeling of something that
00:21:30 they will look back and seriously regret you know not that i care what happens to them but
00:21:35 yeah i hope you're right i hope you're right i worry about that though i think that some of these
00:21:40 people are so brainwashed themselves and you know it's it's like you you you come across people in
00:21:48 the 1950s and 60s who were members of the most appalling regimes in the 30s and 40s whether the
00:21:56 communist regime of Stalin or the fascist regime of Hitler and they just pine for the old days and
00:22:01 I'm afraid that there'll be some people who will continue to pine for the old days in the Liberal
00:22:06 Party because they think they're absolutely right to ignore democracy they can't see
00:22:09 how contemptible it is to treat people in that way. You said quite recently Simon that you thought
00:22:15 we would end up with um possibly a minority government um is that how you think things are
00:22:22 going to pan out now as of today what are we four weeks away from the election uh yes i do i know
00:22:29 that things are allegedly going to change because faraj has stood down 317 candidates but he's only
00:22:35 stood down candidates in seats of the conservatives already held or technically already held um he
00:22:43 hasn't stood them down unless things change at the last minute in seats that they've got to win
00:22:48 and that will make it very difficult for them to win. I'm also not convinced that they'll hold
00:22:53 every seat that they've won in 2017. I think the Liberal Democrats, despite their pernicious views
00:23:00 on democracy, will attract Remainers. I mean they are clearly the lead Remainer party and if you're
00:23:06 in a Lib Dem Conservative marginal of which there are I think several dozen and you are a Remainer
00:23:13 you're going to vote for the Lib Dems, and that could well change things, even without a Brexit
00:23:17 candidate. So yes, I think the Conservatives will be the largest party, and they will probably get
00:23:23 very close to having enough to form a government, but of course they won't have a DUP to rely on.
00:23:29 I just can't see where the 326 seats are that they're going to win to get an absolute majority.
00:23:35 I may be wrong, but just looking at the lists now, I think they're just going to fall short.
00:23:41 I expect the Liberal Democrats to do well.
00:23:43 I expect the SNP to do well and Corbyn to lose seats that he held last time.
00:23:49 What's your impression been of Boris Johnson as Prime Minister?
00:23:53 I'm very sorry that he is Prime Minister.
00:23:55 I don't think he's morally fit to be Prime Minister.
00:23:57 Right.
00:23:58 I don't think he has the character to do it.
00:24:02 And I would have preferred almost anybody else to be able to do it.
00:24:06 Based on what, Simon?
00:24:07 Well, I used to work with him.
00:24:09 He worked for me, actually, at the Telegraph in the 1990s.
00:24:13 And I wasn't impressed with his lack of professionalism there,
00:24:19 which I also saw when I was back at the Telegraph as an executive in the 2000s.
00:24:24 I used to edit the paper on Sundays and he'd filed his column at 8 o'clock at night,
00:24:29 irrespective of the inconvenience it caused almost everybody there
00:24:32 trying to produce a newspaper for the next day.
00:24:34 He was deeply unprofessional.
00:24:36 I wasn't impressed by the fact he had, I think, eight deputies,
00:24:38 and he was mayor of London. I'm not remotely censorious of his private life, that's a matter
00:24:43 for him, but I think he has to bear in mind that many people in this country will be censorious
00:24:48 of his private life, and particularly women I talk to, who feel that the way he treats
00:24:52 women is, shall we say, slightly less than gallant and honourable. I just don't think
00:25:00 he has the character, I use that, it's a very old-fashioned word, but I think it's the best
00:25:06 word i don't think he has the character to be a successful leader and as far as i'm concerned
00:25:13 the sooner the conservative party comes to its senses on that uh point and find somebody with a
00:25:18 little bit more integrity to be the leader the better have you never considered actually being
00:25:24 active in politics actually standing yourself for anything i did in my 20s but um i you know
00:25:31 mrs thatcher was prime minister this is back in the 1980s and i realized first of all that
00:25:38 i admired her almost unreservedly and i realized that she wasn't going on forever
00:25:45 i wasn't sure what would follow her and i very quickly realized when she did leave
00:25:51 that i would have found it impossible to tow a party line under john major or indeed probably
00:25:57 under anybody who's led the Conservative Party since. I don't know that I'm a Conservative
00:26:02 actually. I think if somebody asked me to specify my politics, I'd say I was a Gladstonian
00:26:09 liberal. And I don't think that the basic tenets of Gladstonian liberalism, which Mrs
00:26:15 Thatcher actually adhered to, and actually also Enoch Powell, who as you mentioned I
00:26:19 wrote a book on, I don't think that either of them was a Conservative in the strict sense
00:26:25 of the word, even though Enoch always said that he was born a Tory. I think Enoch, like
00:26:30 Mrs Thatcher, was born a Gladstonian Liberal. And I think I was too. And there are elements
00:26:37 of what the Conservative Party has done under every other leader since Mrs Thatcher went
00:26:43 that I would have found very hard to put up with. And I mean, certainly when you get to
00:26:48 the Cameron years, I felt that his own connection with conservatism was pretty nebulous.
00:26:53 generally you've been writing about 35 years now about politics would you say that politics
00:27:03 politicians should we say are less interesting now than maybe when you started i think there's
00:27:12 a lot more lobby fodder now i think there are a lot more people who will simply do as they're told
00:27:17 and vote for anything the conservative party wants them to vote for um and i think that was
00:27:23 slightly different in the 1980s of course the the first uh well all three uh elections that
00:27:30 mrs thatcher won left her with pretty hefty majorities and so there was room for if you like
00:27:36 safe dissent um in a way that there perhaps hasn't been in in later conservative administrations
00:27:42 or conservative led administrations but uh i think there are more people now who will put
00:27:48 their career before their principles.
00:27:51 They've always been there, of course,
00:27:53 but I think there's probably a higher proportion of them now
00:27:55 than there were 30 years ago.
00:27:57 I think if you take, say, Enoch Powell,
00:28:00 whatever one's views on his beliefs and views,
00:28:04 there's no question of his academic calibre.
00:28:09 But I suspect people of that calibre
00:28:11 would not be attracted to be politicians anymore, maybe.
00:28:14 I mean, there are some very bright people in Parliament. Equally, there are a lot of
00:28:23 people in Parliament who are there because they don't seem to be able to get another
00:28:27 job anywhere else. What Powell also had, and Mrs Thatcher had it too, was a genuine ethic
00:28:36 of public service. I mean, many people have called Enoch Powell the Tribune of the People,
00:28:41 and mrs thatcher was to an extent as well and i think we lack that sort of person in politics
00:28:47 today there are interesting people in politics on both sides i mean in the last parliament
00:28:53 um frank field uh john redwood uh jesse norman um i mean there are people in the last tory party
00:29:02 i didn't agree with in that they took a very different view from me on brexit but they were
00:29:08 serious, high-minded people. And I mean, Dominic Grieve is one, David Gork actually is another.
00:29:16 I don't blame David Gork for telling people not to vote for Boris Johnson. He's actually
00:29:20 sticking up for his principles, and he resigned in a very principled way. And I can see why
00:29:25 he's doing it. I mean, that's the other thing that I find so regrettable about politics
00:29:30 today, is it's become so unpleasant. We can't have open and reasonable disagreements with
00:29:37 people. This I blame on social media. You've got so many MPs have said to me in the last
00:29:41 couple of years, well I'm getting out of politics, I can't stand the abuse anymore. And people
00:29:46 hiding behind Twitter handles, sending abuse to politicians. I know that people in my trade
00:29:52 are often accused of being rude about politicians, but at least it's in the public prints and
00:29:56 my name is on it. And if anybody wants to disagree with me, they know with whom to come
00:30:00 and disagree. If you make up a pseudonym and you send it off on Twitter, then it's a cowardly
00:30:06 way to attack anybody and I so deplore the degeneration of argument and debate. I've
00:30:12 got many friends who are remainers, I've got many friends in other political parties
00:30:17 than the ones I might vote for and we've always managed to have entirely cordial relations.
00:30:23 I've always respected their point of view even if I don't agree with it, although I
00:30:28 struggle to respect a point of view that says we should override the referendum result.
00:30:33 just wish we could get back to an honourable sense of being able to disagree with each other without
00:30:38 coming to blows. Do you partake in any social media yourself? No, none whatsoever. I haven't
00:30:46 got time. I have the fortune to write for the Telegraph newspapers. If anybody doesn't like
00:30:52 what I write there they can email me and I will almost always, unless I'm completely overwhelmed
00:30:57 with work do them the courtesy of a reply and i'm always glad when people do write to me but
00:31:06 i just can't see the point of social media really i think it's a terribly self-regarding thing to do
00:31:12 uh why should people care what i think about anything why should they have that inflicted
00:31:18 on them if they want to buy the newspaper i write for and read me in there they've made a decision
00:31:22 to part with their money, and that's a decision I entirely applaud.
00:31:27 But just to have me turning up on their mobile phone uninvited, as it were,
00:31:30 I think is the highest form of vanity.
00:31:35 Just to finish, Simon, it's wonderful to talk to you.
00:31:39 The book, again, Staring at God.
00:31:43 I just wanted to ask you one thing, given that it's about the Great War.
00:31:46 We've just had Remembrance.
00:31:48 We recently had David Starkey on the programme,
00:31:51 but he recently deplored what remembrance has now come he said it was a i think a crazy religious
00:31:58 ritual do you agree with that or not i don't want to compel anybody to wear a poppy or go to a war
00:32:07 memorial or to the cenotaph on the day of remembrance but i hope before they do decide
00:32:13 not to do that they look at their own families and they look back at the members of their own family
00:32:19 who almost certainly took a part in both world wars and wonder whether it was something of
00:32:26 such significance that their ancestors did or their forebears did that it doesn't it is
00:32:33 unbecoming of them not to recognize it in some way i had a number of members of my family who
00:32:42 fought in both world wars, some of whom died in those wars. And when I wear my poppy and
00:32:51 I fall silent for two minutes on Remembrance Sunday and indeed on the 11th of November,
00:32:55 if it's not the same day, I am thinking of them. I've got two sons of military age and
00:33:03 I think, aren't I fortunate? Isn't my wife fortunate that our children are not in a position
00:33:09 where they've got to go and fight for our country and possibly get killed in the way
00:33:14 that some members of our family did. My wife had a great uncle killed in the Great War
00:33:19 on the Western Front, on the Battle of the Somme, and on the exact centenary of his death.
00:33:24 Luckily he has a marked grave. We went to his grave and paid our respects. And although
00:33:30 he was no blood relation of mine, I was intensely moved. My wife and son, who are related to
00:33:35 my blood were deeply moved by this and I respect David Starkey enormously he's a very fine historian
00:33:41 and he's also a controversialist I suppose I am too in a way I think you've got to pick your
00:33:46 controversies I don't feel that I'm under any fascist obligation to wear a poppy I do it because
00:33:52 I've thought about the past I've thought about why you and I are not sitting here speaking German
00:33:58 when a member of the government's in the room to ensure that we don't veer off anything that
00:34:02 or onto anything that might be a bit difficult and so I'm incredibly grateful to those who
00:34:08 made that sacrifice both over 100 years ago and 80 years ago to fight that we could grow
00:34:16 up in a free country and I'll never forget that.
00:34:20 Thank you very much for coming Simon, it was great, thank you for watching again, please
00:34:25 remember to subscribe won't you and we'll see you next time, thank you very much.
00:34:32 Thank you.