New Culture Forum - January 25, 2020


2.13 Prof. Frank Furedi: The Culture of Fear in the 21st Century

2.11 Simon Heffer: From The Great War to Brexit: A Traditionalist View of Britain 2.15 Zuby: How To Be a Rebel in the 2020s

Episode Stats


Length

35 minutes

Words per minute

161.22

Word count

5,729

Sentence count

225


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to So What You're Saying Is. I'm Peter Whittle. A very Happy New Year to you,
00:00:19 by the way. Now, I'm delighted that my guest this week has been called the most quoted
00:00:24 sociologist in the UK. Frank Ferretti is Emeritus Professor at the University of Kent in Sociology.
00:00:32 He's written numerous books, the themes of which have ranged from the risk aversion culture in our
00:00:40 society today through to the cult of fear. Indeed, his most recent book is this, How Fear Works,
00:00:47 the culture of fear in the 21st century. I'm delighted to be with me now. Hello there, Frank.
00:00:54 Hiya.
00:00:54 Happy New Year to you too.
00:00:56 Happy New Year.
00:00:56 And can I start by asking something which, when I was reading through the book, came out,
00:01:03 which was that you say that now fear is sort of something in our society which exists almost entirely alone.
00:01:12 It's got, as you put it, a commanding moral position.
00:01:16 Can you explain that?
00:01:17 Yeah, I think what's happened in the last 20 years is that as the basic kind of moral values and beliefs have lost their significance to people's lives,
00:01:28 as ideologies unraveled so increasingly in public life, people use fear as a way of making statements, as a way of legitimating their cause.
00:01:39 So people tell us that unless we eat this particular vitamin, we're all going to be ill.
00:01:46 We have to go vegan because eating meat is going to destroy the planet, but also will destroy our way of life.
00:01:54 And virtually every cause, whether it's political or economic, is justified in terms of scaremongering.
00:02:00 And that's something that transcends the ideological divide because both the left and the right very often,
00:02:06 instead of putting forward a message of hope you know very often put forward a
00:02:12 message of fear and that's what in fact the main reason why I wrote this book
00:02:16 because the thing that I was really concerned with was that as children were
00:02:20 growing up as we were socializing them instead of telling them about good
00:02:25 positive values like prudence or courage or loyalty or duty we basically teach
00:02:32 them psychological tricks about how to avoid dealing with your fears. Such as how? How does
00:02:39 this translate for example when it comes to our treatment of children? For example, if you look
00:02:44 at the way that children are educated, especially in schools but also by parents, we tell them that
00:02:51 they need constant validations. We're not allowed to criticize them. Just a couple of days ago,
00:02:56 for example we were told on Radio 4 that we must stop isolating children in
00:03:03 schools when they misbehave because it's will traumatize them the best for
00:03:07 their emotional health and virtually every form of discipline that was used
00:03:11 in the past now comes with a health warning and therefore instead of
00:03:15 questioning or criticizing them what we tend to do is we basically give them
00:03:20 smiley faces we tell them that they have to raise their self-esteem we kind of
00:03:25 create an environment where they never have to deal with the distresses and the problems
00:03:30 of everyday life.
00:03:31 And therefore they become very one-sidedly nervous and anxious about engaging with uncertainty.
00:03:38 I think that's the reason why you have a young generation of people in their 20s who
00:03:44 find it very difficult to deal with what I call existential problems.
00:03:49 Because these days what we call existential problems, which are the problems of everyday
00:03:53 life are increasingly seen as medical ones. Stress all of a sudden becomes a
00:04:00 huge problem. When I was young, stress was abuzz, seen as being an essential
00:04:06 ingredient for creating something, for making something happen. Now stress is
00:04:10 seen as a marker for some kind of medical disease. You know, if you and I
00:04:15 go to a party these days and we're a little bit shy and we're looking at our shoelaces,
00:04:19 we don't know how to mix, we're diagnosed as having social phobia. So
00:04:23 So every personal problem that you and I can possibly have or imagine is now diagnosed
00:04:29 by some kind of medical expert.
00:04:32 And when we do that, then what we do is we shield ourselves from human experience.
00:04:36 We shield ourselves from each other and become less and less able to deal with the difficulties
00:04:41 that will inevitably face us in our lives.
00:04:45 So we're basically pathologizing ordinary human experience?
00:04:50 We are, it's almost as if we think that we should be spared the burden of having to deal
00:04:56 with challenges.
00:04:59 And indeed, the way we use the word challenges these days is by trivializing it.
00:05:03 So if you ever listen to some professional person or a public sector advocate, they talk
00:05:10 about this is a very challenging experience.
00:05:13 And what they really mean by it is that it's a little bit difficult.
00:05:16 So we don't speak in plain English in the language of everyday life, we've got these
00:05:22 euphemisms that we use.
00:05:24 I think one of the most troublesome features of British public life are these use of euphemisms
00:05:32 that avoid being clear.
00:05:33 So we don't talk about problems, we say this is problematic, whatever that means.
00:05:39 Or if you misbehave, for example, I don't say, Peter, you were bad, I would say that
00:05:45 was inappropriate. I mean I can give you a long list of these you know weasel words that avoid
00:05:51 you know sort of being clear about what we're doing and saying. You mentioned challenge there
00:05:55 to me it seems that that one has replaced problem you know people say this is the main challenge
00:06:00 we face it's it almost has to be put into a positive framework. Exactly because you know
00:06:05 there was a time when I was young when a challenge meant you know you know I don't walking up the
00:06:10 or something or or running the mile under four minutes I mean that's what a challenge
00:06:15 whereas not a challenge is crossing the street on your own as a 12 year old a challenge is you know
00:06:21 sort of being able to tie your shoelaces at the age of nine I mean this is how we've kind of
00:06:26 trivialized it we're talking about domestic and educational situations there what do you think
00:06:32 the overall effect to this cultural affair is on our whole psychology as a culture I think
00:06:40 the most important dimension of our fear culture today is we tend to turn almost every what I
00:06:50 would call the theological or a philosophical or a moral problem into a medical one and we kind of
00:06:56 sidestep having to deal with it. So gradually we're losing a language that makes it very very
00:07:03 clear about what is right and what is wrong. So for example one of the biggest casualties of this
00:07:09 kind of culture that i'm describing is the act of judgment i mean there used to be a time
00:07:17 when in christianity in judaism in in the enlightenment secular philosophies judgment
00:07:23 was seen as a medium through which we make sense of the world through judgment we come closer to
00:07:28 each other because i judge you and you judge me and through judging each other we create a public
00:07:33 world where we're having conversations and dialogues. These days, the virtue in our world
00:07:40 is no longer judgment. That's seen as being really bad. And we have a new word for it
00:07:44 called judgmentalism or judgy, which I love. It's a big American word. Oh, dad, you're being so
00:07:52 judgy. And what we have is a situation where the virtue is non-judgmentalism. So we teach
00:08:01 children in schools that it's important to be non-judgmental. And very often you will
00:08:06 find celebrities on television saying, you know, we don't have to be judgmental. I'm
00:08:11 non-judgmental, as if somehow that's a signature of saintlyhood. But actually, judging each
00:08:18 other, being judgmental, is the essential element of human communication. If I don't
00:08:24 judge you, then what I'm really saying is, Peter, I don't take you seriously. I don't
00:08:27 particularly care what you think. That's what non-judging means. Judging means that I'm looking
00:08:32 into you and making kind of conclusions about whether you're right or wrong or good or bad.
00:08:38 But it's also phony, isn't it? Because people are all the time making judgments.
00:08:44 Absolutely. But this is exactly the case, yes. Because I don't know anybody, you know,
00:08:50 who's genuinely non-judgmental. You've got to be a complete airhead not to judge people. And in fact,
00:08:56 We find that the same people who in one breath say, I'm nonjudgmental, at the same time will call you a Brexiteer because you're a Brexiteer.
00:09:05 You must be xenophobic, and because you're xenophobic, you must be a lower moral human being than I am.
00:09:12 And you'll find that they're very, very kind of casual and promiscuous with judging people that they don't even know,
00:09:19 just because they assume that if you vote on this particular issue in this way,
00:09:24 that it must follow, that all these horrible sort of associations will kick in.
00:09:30 Do you think this is something that is really a thing of the West?
00:09:36 I mean, I don't see these trends necessarily in other parts of the world.
00:09:40 Well, there's a problem, and the problem is that America, for all its sins,
00:09:46 for all its weaknesses, the fact that it's not keeping up with China, is nevertheless
00:09:51 still the dominant sort of hegemonic power in terms of soft power.
00:09:58 And I think that the influence of Netflix, the influence of MTV, the influence of popular
00:10:03 culture, Hollywood, all these things percolate throughout the world.
00:10:07 And I know, for example, I spend a lot of time in East Europe, and most East Europeans,
00:10:13 except for a very small minority of people, are not influenced by this kind of approach.
00:10:20 But then you can sense that gradually, as young people hear these songs, where they
00:10:25 hear that being judgmental is horrible, it's a sin, where they begin to watch Netflix where
00:10:30 everybody sort of adopts this form of thought, those things do begin to influence.
00:10:37 And I noticed I was very recently in Asia, and even amongst the Asian middle class, you
00:10:44 kind of get this kind of, what I see as the imitating of this kind of behavior, because
00:10:49 it's seen as the virtuous way of being.
00:10:52 Just imagine you watch the BAFTA awards, just imagine you watch the Oscars.
00:10:58 What are you going to hear?
00:10:59 All you're going to hear is people talking about those judgy people, or those people
00:11:04 talking about you know sort of people who are you know who are inappropriate and and it's very easy
00:11:09 then to kind of internalize this kind of stuff. The irony of course of that is that they are doing
00:11:14 it at ceremonies which are built on the whole idea of saying this is the best and this is not.
00:11:19 Absolutely yes. You're actually from Hungary aren't you? Yeah. You're from Budapest but you're
00:11:25 saying you're seeing this seeping into the culture of Eastern Central Europe. I mean the way I say it
00:11:31 is that amongst the younger generations who are digitally savvy, who are always on the
00:11:38 internet, who listen to the latest music, who watch the films, this influence inevitably
00:11:45 has an impact because even though they might see themselves as Hungarian, they're proud
00:11:50 to be Hungarian or Polish or Czech, nevertheless there's this overwhelming influence that's
00:11:57 quite global, and we feel that in England, in France, everywhere else.
00:12:01 I mean, if the French cannot resist it, and they're continually complaining about the
00:12:05 influence of American music, the East European societies, who have far less economic resources
00:12:14 to deal with these things, are less able to do it.
00:12:16 In fact, one of the things that I've been doing very recently is I've been doing some
00:12:19 lectures around Europe, both in the East and the West, and what I've been doing is talking
00:12:25 to the younger generation mainly between kids between 16 and 19 because they're
00:12:31 still idealistic at that point they haven't become cynical and they haven't
00:12:35 been too conformist to this kind of new ethos and trying to appeal to their
00:12:42 natural risk-taking impulses their desire for being idealistic their desire
00:12:50 to know what is right and what is wrong and and trying to encourage them to have the courage of
00:12:56 their conviction rather than just simply to conform what is the dominant cultural ethos of our time
00:13:03 and also presumably to to help them understand that there are such things as good risks to take
00:13:10 as opposed to every risk being essentially fraught with danger absolutely i mean i always remember my
00:13:16 dad, you know, at the age of nine, explaining to me that there are good risks and there
00:13:20 are bad risks. And I grew up on that. And sometimes I heard about, you know, we don't
00:13:27 know, it might be good or it might be bad. Well, these days, to talk about a good risk
00:13:31 is to court the accusation of being irresponsible, because a risk is by definition irresponsible.
00:13:38 It's got negative connotations to it. And I think that kind of sense of, it's a very
00:13:43 kind of defensive, you know, sense of not believing in your human potential is
00:13:49 something that we need to be really worried about because that kicks in at
00:13:54 the economic level, the political, the cultural level all the time and we've
00:13:58 become these people who are almost closing in on ourselves and instead of
00:14:02 being open to new experiences we kind of find 101 excuses as to why not now, you
00:14:09 know why not me and why not in this situation which seems to be the main
00:14:14 kind of ethos that is being taught in schools and in universities I did
00:14:22 sociology at least for a level and I remember reading a lot and being taught
00:14:27 a lot about moral panics yeah how is the kind of current cult fear different to
00:14:33 good old-fashioned moral panic well I've been arguing that moral panics
00:14:39 only do occur and there are many examples but they only occur when there
00:14:45 is a consensus about what is what is moral so I remember when I moved to
00:14:51 England you know there was a very clear understanding that this is good and this
00:14:55 is bad and there was no big debates about it the question was whether you
00:14:59 could live up to the good or not and and young people would know that this is
00:15:04 these are the values that they had to live by they might not like them but
00:15:08 But they knew that sooner or later they would have to match up to them in some shape or
00:15:13 form.
00:15:14 Now, I think in our world today, there's a total absence of moral consensus.
00:15:20 In other words, if you go down the street and ask people questions about what is right
00:15:24 and what is wrong, what are the values that you live by, it's an alien language now.
00:15:30 Because in our world, we don't teach children about what is good and what is bad.
00:15:37 We teach them to have emotional skills.
00:15:40 We teach them relationship skills.
00:15:45 We teach them to negotiate difficult problems, but we don't tell them that in our world this
00:15:53 is virtuous and this is not, in fact, the word virtue doesn't exist anymore.
00:15:59 So under those circumstances, when there's no moral consensus to panic about, it presupposes
00:16:06 that there was a certain moral consensus that had to be defended, that's why there was a
00:16:10 panic. If that doesn't really exist, and if there are different moral spheres pretty much
00:16:16 ghettoized in our society, then the panics that do occur or the overreactions that do
00:16:21 occur have a distinctly non-moral character. And what's happened more and more is that
00:16:27 what we used to call moral panics have become increasingly medicalized, they become medical
00:16:30 problems. I mean, every time I open a newspaper, we hear about the stress in offices, you know,
00:16:38 people are not able to work because they've been harassed and they've been traumatised by it. It's
00:16:43 always a medical language we use rather than a moral language. Where do you think the current,
00:16:49 I would say it's a form of panic, fear over environmentalism, do you think, would you
00:16:56 characterize that as being part of the cult of fear at the moment this kind of
00:17:00 sense of impending doom you know how much time have we got yes I think there
00:17:07 is a there's a fundamental element in our culture of fear which is that we're
00:17:12 we're detached from the future we regard the future as a alien destructive
00:17:18 territory and it's very rare these days to read a novel or see a film where the
00:17:23 future is portrayed in a positive way almost never well exactly almost and
00:17:28 never in fact and what you have instead is a very dystopic view of what the
00:17:33 future is like and I think what we've done with the environment is we
00:17:37 projected our own personal and communal insecurities into the environment we
00:17:43 can naturalize them and and once you do that it you know and once the once the
00:17:49 issues to do with the environment become pollution, global warming, which are all
00:17:55 of them are invisible in the first instance because you cannot see global
00:17:59 warming. Even when they try to show on TV they have to speed up the cameras. You
00:18:03 cannot see pollution. You can see the effects of pollution. Once you have this
00:18:07 invisible threat existing on a global scale then it becomes an unbounded fear.
00:18:13 There is no end to it. You can project any fantasy onto that and
00:18:18 And that's why we find that you have people almost talking like religious nutters from the Middle Ages,
00:18:25 talking about extinction next year or the year after, and really believing that.
00:18:29 I mean, they really do believe, just like those young children that went on the children's crusade in the early Middle Ages,
00:18:38 that unless you do something now, this is the end of the world.
00:18:44 Where does that leave us with Greta Thornburg?
00:18:46 I think you recently described her as being symptomatic of a societal crisis, actually.
00:18:53 I mean, is that what?
00:18:55 Because we're listening to young people, what?
00:18:57 Well, I mean, I listen to everybody, but I think there's something very sad
00:19:01 when the adult world hides behind children,
00:19:05 and we kind of put the children in the front line,
00:19:08 and in a sense kind of cultivate it.
00:19:12 It really does remind me of the old children's crusade,
00:19:16 when people hid behind, you know, nine, ten-year-olds as a way of promoting their cause
00:19:21 because they didn't have the courage of their own conviction.
00:19:24 And so I think that's a problem.
00:19:25 The other problem, of course, which is more fundamental in the long run,
00:19:29 is that the adult world, particularly in the Anglo-American sphere,
00:19:33 has given up on its authority.
00:19:36 Given up on its authority.
00:19:37 Yeah, it doesn't believe that it's right to give that direction to children.
00:19:42 It no longer gives leadership or inspires them.
00:19:45 And we are in the middle of a process that I call in my own other writings, socialization
00:19:51 in reverse, which basically means that we're getting the children to tell us how to behave
00:19:56 rather than the other way around.
00:19:57 So when I was young, when you were young, presumably parents guarded you and told you
00:20:03 what is right and wrong, how to behave.
00:20:06 Now parents look to their children very often.
00:20:09 So you have English mums going into a shop and it's their daughter who tells them what
00:20:16 to wear rather than the other way around.
00:20:18 And I think that kind of socialisation in reverse, the giving up of adult authority,
00:20:23 to me represents a real cultural regression where essentially you give up on your role
00:20:30 as a responsible adult to take responsibility for the future generations.
00:20:36 even down some of that to the kind of cult of youth i.e that youth has inherent wisdom that
00:20:42 once we used to attribute to older people by its very nature age that's right yeah i i it's very
00:20:49 very interesting that the idea that old people have something to teach us yeah is not seen as
00:20:56 a joke you know sort of and i've written about how professionals experts write about tell parents
00:21:03 not to allow the grandparents to tell the children how to behave or allow
00:21:09 children to spend too much time with the grandparents because their child
00:21:13 reading techniques is very outdated and is likely to make them you know sort of
00:21:17 the worst so in Finland they did this study which basically proved that
00:21:22 children become obese when they spend too much time with their grandparents
00:21:26 because apparently grandmas just shoves sweets down their throats and no mine
00:21:31 did. Yeah, well, so did mine. And, you know, I'm still here. Frank, a lot of your positions
00:21:39 and a lot of the themes that you take up and explain to people, these would find favour.
00:21:47 You mentioned earlier that these are not a left-right thing, but many of them would find
00:21:51 favour on quite a traditional conservative side of an argument. But I wonder where you
00:21:59 are politically now. I mean you quite famously founded the Revolutionary
00:22:04 Communist Party in the 1970s. That's late 70s. That's right and and I was at Kent
00:22:09 in the early 80s and the RCP was a real force actually on campus. I wonder I mean
00:22:16 are you still a Marxist? I find it very difficult to describe what I am. I can
00:22:23 only tell you if you give me a bit of time to indicate how I've come to where
00:22:30 I've been. I think that what has happened with me is that I had certain
00:22:34 experiences in my life which had a profound effect on my outlook. One such
00:22:42 experience was, it sounds very trivial, but it was late 70s, even when the RCP
00:22:47 was in existence. I remember students at the university and elsewhere adopted this policy
00:22:55 of no platform. And I remember saying to myself, well, if we believe in democracy, if we have
00:23:02 confidence in our arguments, why do you want to deny the National Front or any other organization
00:23:08 the right to argue and debate with you? And I actually wrote a little pamphlet on that,
00:23:12 and I got into a lot of trouble, because everybody on the left was saying that Furedi is a
00:23:17 appeasing the fascists by being prepared to argue with them.
00:23:21 And at that point, I realized that, you know, whatever I was, I wasn't like them.
00:23:25 I wasn't like the left was.
00:23:28 The second experience I had, which completely shook me up, I mean, had a really big impact on me,
00:23:33 was when, I don't know if you recall, in the 80s, you had these major trials occurring about child abuse of North.
00:23:42 and many of them were entirely based upon false accusations and I remember
00:23:49 talking to somebody who was actually quite close to me on the left and he
00:23:54 was saying you know Frankie what you don't realize is that in England one out
00:23:58 of four working-class men is a child abuser and when he said that I knew
00:24:03 that either he was an idiot or I was an idiot because in my mind that couldn't
00:24:08 take place but then I really then I began to realize a lot of people began
00:24:11 to believe this, that child abuse was so rough that every man was a potential child abuser.
00:24:18 That really did shake me up because if people had such a debased view of humanity on the
00:24:23 left, then what was their politics like?
00:24:27 And then the last thing that happened to me which had a big impact was the miners' strike
00:24:31 where we supported the miners' strike totally, but we argued that if there was going to be
00:24:36 a strike, there had to be a balance.
00:24:38 I don't know if you remember the big debate about it, the miners in Nottingham, for example,
00:24:44 said that we're not going to go on strike unless we have a ballot.
00:24:48 And the argument was that there's no time for a ballot and, you know, there's no point in doing that.
00:24:53 And I felt that from a basic democratic point of view, if you are going to have a serious action like that,
00:25:00 you do need to, you know, sort of have democratic forms of decision-making.
00:25:06 And I think that was the final thing that kind of pushed me in a different direction.
00:25:12 So my politics, I would say, is a mixture of three different things.
00:25:18 When it comes to family values, when it comes to personal relationships, when it comes to
00:25:24 things like community, loyalties, things of that sort, I think I'm fairly conservative.
00:25:31 I would see myself as a conservative with a small c.
00:25:34 I think those are particularly important now when there's so much being isolated and ghettoized.
00:25:46 I think it's quite important to stand up for those sensibilities.
00:25:50 When it comes to free speech, freedom, any kind of form of free expression,
00:25:56 I would say I'm libertarian, totally liberal.
00:26:01 I think that anybody should be able to express whatever they want
00:26:05 as long as they're prepared to live with the consequences.
00:26:08 So I'm totally committed to a certain sense of freedom.
00:26:15 And when it comes to economics, I change my mind on a regular basis
00:26:19 between understanding the importance of the free market
00:26:24 whilst at the same time recognizing that it's very important
00:26:28 that people have a safety net you know that in a civilized society we do provide people
00:26:36 with benefits so the education and health the thing that i'm i'm really against in the world
00:26:45 i'm not against welfare as such what i am against is the way that welfare is used to make people
00:26:51 dependent on welfare and the way in which welfare has become a medium of political control rather
00:26:57 than using it selectively for the right people. So it's a mixture of three different things that
00:27:02 often seem to conflict but in my mind they correspond to my experiences so that's how
00:27:08 I would describe myself. So it was nothing for example to do with the fall of the Eastern Bloc,
00:27:14 nothing like that? I always knew they would fall, in fact that was one of the arguments,
00:27:18 because I'm Hungarian I never had the slightest positive association with Soviet Union or China
00:27:26 or East Europe, and I could tell that it would fall, and people would argue with me saying
00:27:31 that you're crazy.
00:27:32 How could this formidable Soviet Union and this formidable Eastern Bloc just fall?
00:27:38 I said, look, talk to people in Poland, Hungary, Russia, you'll find that nobody believes in
00:27:42 the system at all.
00:27:43 So that had nothing to do with it.
00:27:45 It had to do with things within Britain itself, and in particular with our experiences.
00:27:50 And the good thing was that everybody I was involved with in politics on the left, in
00:27:54 the RCP more or less drew a similar conclusion. We had a lot of arguments and discussions
00:27:59 about it.
00:28:00 This would have been in the 90s maybe this happened?
00:28:02 Yeah, 90s. And we basically said it would be far better that we all end our party life
00:28:10 and go off as individuals and learn from our experiences and make our own way. And that's
00:28:16 what we did, which I think worked quite well because it meant that people had to live with
00:28:24 the consequences of their action. They had to take responsibility for what they were
00:28:28 doing and they were able to use their old experience in a positive way. So I'm very
00:28:33 proud of what I did in the 70s because they gave me a vantage point from which to see
00:28:39 both the right and the left.
00:28:41 You're actually writing a book, in fact you've written a book, haven't you? One's coming
00:28:45 out in a few months' time, which is about borders, isn't it? The need for borders. Now
00:28:49 that would seem to be entirely opposite to an RCP position which would have been borderless
00:28:55 internationalism, wouldn't it? So basically we live in a world where every single boundary that
00:29:03 gives meaning to life is being called into question, not just national borders. So if you
00:29:09 look around, people are saying that the boundary between men and women is unnatural. I mean, who
00:29:16 invented this. There are millions of genders. There's no point in simply sticking with the
00:29:22 old-school idea that there are men and women, only two sexes. That boundary has got to go.
00:29:29 The boundary between adults and children is being increasingly called into question. And
00:29:35 you have a situation where people no longer know when a child becomes an adult. It's no
00:29:40 longer 18, is it 24, 30, 31, total lack of clarity about it. The boundary between animals
00:29:48 and human beings, which was fairly clear in the past, there's a lot of books being written
00:29:52 about the fact that that's quite artificial, and there's no reason why we might not change
00:29:57 our minds about this boundary. Very importantly, the boundary between the private and the public
00:30:04 sphere, something I feel very strongly about, is being eroded, and people say we don't
00:30:09 like the private sphere. It's a place where you have domestic abuse, you talk about the
00:30:14 dark side of the family. So all in all what happens is that this important boundary between
00:30:21 the private and the public is being called into question. So in the book what I try to
00:30:25 do is to explain why this is happening and why we need to resist it, why culturally it's
00:30:32 important that we deal with this problem.
00:30:35 You could say this is all about the infantilization of society, isn't it, really?
00:30:39 I mean, just simply trying to turn things on the head just almost for the sake of it.
00:30:44 I mean, surely, saying animals, humans, there's no difference, whatever.
00:30:49 I think it's that, but it's also more profound.
00:30:52 I think we've kind of lost the meaning of life.
00:30:56 And we are very scared of dealing with the language of meaning.
00:31:00 It's seen as being too moral.
00:31:01 And it's also interesting that the very word moral now has got negative connotations.
00:31:09 So when somebody talks about virtues or talks about good and evil, they're described as
00:31:16 being moralistic.
00:31:18 And morality itself is often seen as something people hide behind, as a way of obscuring
00:31:24 their real intent.
00:31:26 So when morality itself has got this very negative, minimalist connotations, then under
00:31:32 those circumstances people just lose their way and fall upon themselves and begin to
00:31:40 react against everything that gave meaning to experience in the past.
00:31:44 And to me, this is something again that transcends left and right.
00:31:50 Because it was a conservative government, for example, in Britain that institutionalized
00:31:57 trans culture.
00:31:58 I mean, they very casually decided that to insist upon the fact that there are only men
00:32:03 and only women is somehow a cultural sin.
00:32:06 These are conservatives.
00:32:07 These weren't radical feminists or radicals of any sort.
00:32:13 So you can see that all sections of the political spectrum, to some extent, have lost their
00:32:19 own moral clarity and their own moral sensibility is conspicuous by its weakness. And you can
00:32:27 count on your hand the number of intellectuals or the number of public figures who are able
00:32:34 to speak convincingly in a language of moral norms.
00:32:39 We've just had a good example of that, I think, in the two judgments you probably know. One
00:32:44 where it was judged that a woman could not say at work
00:32:48 that there is such a thing as two sexes, a man and a woman,
00:32:52 that that was absolutist.
00:32:53 This is what the judge said, absolutist.
00:32:55 So she was fired, and so she lost that.
00:32:58 But at the same time, we've got the legal system saying
00:33:01 that veganism should be treated in the same way
00:33:04 as a belief system, a religion.
00:33:06 This is serious moral confusion and chaos, isn't it?
00:33:10 It is, and I think it speaks to the fact
00:33:13 that these moral confusions that you describe are legitimated by a judicial system where
00:33:21 the members of the judiciary themselves have more or less been educated into the values
00:33:27 that open the gates to anything that challenges tradition.
00:33:34 In English language, we talk about judicial independence, and I'm a big fan of judicial
00:33:41 independence but what we often forget is you know who are the people who are you
00:33:46 know working in the courts and these are people that went to the legal scholars
00:33:51 their lawyers who've been educated in different universities and the ideas that
00:33:57 they picked up in the universities invariably without exception inspired
00:34:03 them and drive them towards conclusions which in a sense is consistent with the
00:34:08 zeitgeist of our time so it's not surprising and I actually wrote an
00:34:14 article predicting this that in today's courts a judge would rule veganism to be
00:34:20 a religion you know having the same authority as Judaism or Christianity or
00:34:26 or Hinduism I mean that kind of outlook is not what you would expect from people
00:34:31 and it's not that they even think twice about it they think that they are being
00:34:35 you know sort of extremely you know sort of considered in making these
00:34:41 judgments at the same time the same judges you know will slap somebody down
00:34:45 who says that you know I think that you know biologically speaking there are two
00:34:51 sexes we've been thinking that for thousands of years you know why can't I
00:34:56 be allowed to say that in the 21st century you guys slap down for that what
00:35:01 is the book called actually the new book the new book is your book is called why borders matter
00:35:08 and why humanity has to relearn the art of drawing boundaries well that's a labor of love yes
00:35:15 thank you very very much for joining sir it's fascinating thank you very much thank
00:35:20 that's it for so what you're saying is this week do join us again next time in the meantime as a
00:35:27 present to yourself for the new year please do subscribe won't you thank you very much bye