New Culture Forum - January 25, 2020


2.14 James Oliver: Re-Platforming Speakers

2.11 Simon Heffer: From The Great War to Brexit: A Traditionalist View of Britain 2.15 Zuby: How To Be a Rebel in the 2020s

Episode Stats


Length

30 minutes

Words per minute

155.96

Word count

4,728

Sentence count

140


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to So What You're Saying Is, I'm Peter Whittle. Now we're hearing an awful lot at
00:00:22 the moment about the threat to free speech on our university campuses, the very places in fact which
00:00:29 should be open to free thought and new ideas. But there are signs of a fight back. With
00:00:35 me today is James Oliver. He's a PhD student at the University of Buckingham and last year
00:00:41 he started a free speech society there. Welcome James, good to meet you. Why did you start
00:00:48 the society?
00:00:51 Well I suppose there's more than one reason, but the main catalyst I would have to say
00:00:56 was early last year when the journalist and author Peter Hitchens found himself de-platformed,
00:01:04 disinvited, whatever you want to call it, from the University of Portsmouth.
00:01:09 And I've been a long-time fan of his work, and I've admired his stance on free speech
00:01:15 all the way through that as well.
00:01:17 And I just felt like it was maybe somewhat symbolic.
00:01:22 I wouldn't want to elevate it too much, but that somebody who's been so outspoken
00:01:25 and so committed to free expression, free thought,
00:01:31 that he found himself in this position.
00:01:34 What's the reason given?
00:01:35 Because I think a lot of people watching won't quite know what happened.
00:01:38 With Peter?
00:01:38 Yeah.
00:01:39 As far as I could tell, there was some concern on the part of the Students' Union
00:01:44 that views that he has uttered in the past about transgenderism,
00:01:49 I think this is right,
00:01:50 had the potential to make some people upset
00:01:55 and I think it may well have coincided with some sort of anniversary
00:02:00 LGBT anniversary of some kind
00:02:05 but the strange thing was
00:02:09 it was, as far as I remember, not what he was there to speak on
00:02:12 this was a tangential thing, essentially unrelated
00:02:16 and they basically said you can't come at this time
00:02:20 and I believe when there was a backlash in the media
00:02:24 they tried to backtrack quickly
00:02:28 and suggested that he could come at a later date
00:02:31 but of course at that point Peter Hitchens was done with them
00:02:35 he's not interested in being cowed
00:02:39 who are they as it were
00:02:42 who were the people who complained
00:02:44 who managed to get it stopped
00:02:46 I don't know how many students were bothered by his potential appearance but I'm pretty sure that
00:02:55 the people who had the kind of final say were the Students' Union. I don't know a turn about that
00:03:00 specific case but I just when it hit the when it hit the papers I just found it to be just really
00:03:07 rather sad um um somewhat infuriating but really just a bit depressing um and i happened to discuss
00:03:16 this with a friend of mine from the university who's the co-founder of the society daria uh
00:03:20 malenko yeah and we were just we're just talking about it she's a fan of his work as well
00:03:26 and later that night i said well why don't we start a society that could
00:03:33 have Miss Hitchens come and speak and in a sense try to right the wrong of
00:03:41 Portsmouth and then then we came up with the idea that we could seek to invite
00:03:49 more people who'd been disinvited and that's when we came up with this slogan
00:03:54 that we would re-platform the de-platformed. Re-platform the de-platformed, this is
00:03:59 your logo? That's kind of our mission it's not the only thing we're concerned
00:04:02 with we're happy to invite anybody who has interesting ideas surrounding free
00:04:06 speech well to be honest interesting ideas of any kind yeah but that's
00:04:11 certainly a big component of sort of our mission statement I suppose that we want
00:04:16 to try to give those people of which there are many now who found themselves
00:04:21 in trouble at other the other universities a home if you like has he
00:04:27 been up so far oh yeah he was our inaugural speaker oh and that was
00:04:32 wonderful he was fantastic he came to speak on the as he refers to it the so
00:04:38 called war on drugs had a really lively discussion some heated debate from the
00:04:43 audience because it's quite a hot topic but yeah it was it was it was fantastic
00:04:48 to have him and he did it all completely free of charge as well he wouldn't even
00:04:55 take travel expenses so just just shows the character of the man it was it was wonderful
00:04:59 to have him i'd gladly have him back anytime well we had him on this show yes and uh you know it's
00:05:05 one of our most popular shows people seem to seem to love him um one thing is that with
00:05:11 your particular society is it it's at the university of buckingham where you are
00:05:16 uh you know i think a lot of people maybe might not know but the university of buckingham's got
00:05:21 a particular kind of niche, hasn't it? It is the only private university still in Britain, isn't it?
00:05:26 I'm not 100% sure if it's the only one, but it's certainly the first one.
00:05:29 Right. I think other people have maybe tried. I'm not 100%, but...
00:05:35 But it's not actually a university that would necessarily seem to have a problem with free speech, isn't that right?
00:05:40 Well, in a sense, there's a bit of an irony here in that we've set up a free speech society in arguably the place with the fewest problems with free speech.
00:05:49 basically no issue with free speech we we've found ourselves we've never had any bannings
00:05:56 as far as i am aware and when the free speech university rankings existed for about four or
00:06:04 five years bucking was consistently at the very top of the pile they were set up by tom slater
00:06:09 and brendan o'neill over at spiked online and we we qualified for what they they had a traffic light
00:06:16 ranking system green amber red and we got green lights every year that they existed and what that
00:06:22 what you had to achieve in order to receive a green light award was no suppression of free
00:06:30 speech whatsoever right and just as a kind of just a marker for how bad it's got in this country
00:06:36 in the final year of the rankings there were only there was only one university in england i believe
00:06:43 that met the criteria for a green light
00:06:47 and also a university in Wales, I think.
00:06:50 Really?
00:06:51 Out of how many are we talking, actually?
00:06:53 Hundreds.
00:06:54 Hundreds now, isn't it?
00:06:56 That's extraordinary.
00:06:58 What other instances can you describe to us
00:07:02 that you know about at other universities?
00:07:04 You mentioned Peter Hitchens at Portsmouth, right?
00:07:07 But, you know, we hear about deep platforming.
00:07:10 There are a number of big cases, aren't there?
00:07:13 I mean, I'm thinking of Julie Bindall, for example, and Jermaine Greer.
00:07:17 I mean, can you tell us what happened with Claire Fox?
00:07:22 The specifics, again, I'm somewhat hazy on,
00:07:25 but she was going to speak, I think, at a university in Manchester.
00:07:31 And she was eventually told she couldn't come.
00:07:35 I wouldn't want to misspeak, but I think this was something to do with her,
00:07:40 again ironically her prior defense of free speech in public and she's she's
00:07:46 fallen into some hot water for for her real strong commitment essentially to an
00:07:52 absolutist view she would say or very close to yeah depends how you want to
00:07:58 define absolutism but she she I think was going to be a guest of the free
00:08:06 speech society there i'm not again not 100 but but i've certainly seen that in other cases where
00:08:11 free speech societies have been set up and then haven't actually been able to kind of
00:08:15 follow through or i think more often students unions will just simply not approve the founding
00:08:23 of a free speech society and that's one of the things that was fantastic about setting up a
00:08:27 buckingham we we came up with the idea and really very swiftly did all the paperwork and we were
00:08:33 approved with pretty much no resistance. Obviously we had to go through the usual checks that any
00:08:37 society would have to go through but there were no problems for us and we found incredibly strong
00:08:43 backing from the SU all the way through. We've had the presidents of, we've gone through two
00:08:49 presidents now at the SU, two terms and both of them have attended our events and we've also,
00:08:57 So Daria, my co-founder, she's the vice president of the SU and we essentially buck the trend
00:09:05 where at other universities you find the SUs to be the least forgiving on any of this
00:09:12 and we seem to have the opposite experience.
00:09:16 Student unions are really quite powerful now, aren't they?
00:09:19 I think they're more powerful than in my day.
00:09:21 Possibly.
00:09:21 Which was like 40 years ago at university.
00:09:24 Yeah, I think they've always been very politically minded.
00:09:28 I guess it's student politics, isn't it?
00:09:30 So the sorts of people that you are likely to get committing to those positions
00:09:36 perhaps will have stronger views.
00:09:38 But it does seem that a lot of the problems that other universities have had
00:09:43 have been located in the students' unions.
00:09:46 And I think, I don't want to downplay the issue nationwide or even worldwide,
00:09:52 or at least in the west but i do get the feeling and certainly through my experience running this
00:09:57 this organization the problem is found in pockets and it's not it's not spread particularly thickly
00:10:07 but the the minority can have a real big effect and if there are enough people who aren't
00:10:14 too fussed about standing up for arguably the supreme value of our culture then it can quite
00:10:23 quickly find itself dying away and that's going back to your first question that's another reason
00:10:28 i think that i wanted to do something like this i i've never been particularly interested in getting
00:10:36 even joining societies never mind setting one up but you hear all the time that if there's
00:10:41 something that's kind of worth fighting for or even dying for i think back to the the charlie
00:10:47 hebdo massacre and you got all of this all the all of these cartoons talking about the pens my
00:10:56 tooth and sword and a lot of a lot of verbal commitment to the idea without necessarily any
00:11:05 strong action to follow through yeah and maybe there was a sense that I'd been one of those
00:11:16 people a little bit as well I've been interested in this for a long time but had never really
00:11:20 done anything meaningful other than rant a little bit to my friends or what have you and so perhaps
00:11:28 that irked me and I thought well if you have the idea you might as well see what you can do yes
00:11:35 And I don't want to elevate this society way above its station.
00:11:39 Well, no, wait a minute. You were reported in The Times.
00:11:42 Oh, that's true. Sunday Times.
00:11:43 Sunday Times, right.
00:11:46 Maybe it was The Times, I can't remember.
00:11:48 That's good going.
00:11:50 I'm very interested in what you say there,
00:11:51 because about this thing of no follow-through.
00:11:55 You mentioned Charlie Hebdo, and I think after Charlie Hebdo,
00:11:59 there was this huge demonstration through Paris,
00:12:01 and all the leaders, world leaders, political leaders,
00:12:04 joining arms all joining us move along where we are just with Charlie Hebdo
00:12:07 and then nothing you know after that there's also this phenomenon isn't there
00:12:13 of I'm in favor of free speech but you know this has become the cliche I'm in
00:12:17 favor and then you think oh here comes the but you know what I mean that it's
00:12:21 the but is almost always guaranteed yes I just I think it's something that
00:12:28 people say without really thinking what it even means. You can't come out
00:12:34 really and say, I'm not in favor of free speech. So you pay lip service to the
00:12:40 principal without having any idea what it really means. And perhaps more
00:12:47 saliently, without any idea of what it means to lose it or what a failure to
00:12:54 commit to the principle can lead to in a society when you started this as well I
00:13:03 mean you know was it is your particular approach a political one I mean are you
00:13:12 are you a political animal you know have were you interested in politics before
00:13:18 you say you were interested in in free speech and you want to do something and
00:13:22 you thought strongly about that were you political at all I wouldn't say I've had any particularly
00:13:28 strong affiliation certainly party politics hasn't been hasn't been something that's gripped me um
00:13:33 not to say that that wouldn't be something that I could get interested in with the with the right
00:13:38 party if you want but um no for me it's it's a it's I think it's above all of that in a way this
00:13:45 this transcends politics uh and you can see that if you look at the range of people that have found
00:13:51 themselves on the wrong end of this um well just as an example our first two speakers peter hitchens
00:13:58 everybody will acknowledge his conservative writer speaker and our second was claire fox
00:14:03 who's most certainly of the left and both of these people have found themselves in the same position
00:14:09 and ironically found himself now on on the same side and i think if you if you forget that this
00:14:17 this is something that's beyond all of this,
00:14:19 you'll fall into the trap,
00:14:21 which I think a lot of the media has,
00:14:22 of associating free speech with a particular political wing.
00:14:25 And now it's seen, strangely, to be a right-wing phenomenon somehow.
00:14:32 I was going to ask you that very thing.
00:14:34 It's sort of like people who are sort of standing up for it,
00:14:37 or for that matter, I mean, there's something else, for example,
00:14:40 Toby Young, for example, is about to start something called the Free Speech Union.
00:14:44 He's going to be coming on this show.
00:14:46 But there is therefore this perception that these are broadly centre-right people who
00:14:52 are making fuss about free speech, you say that's not justified, that view.
00:15:00 Perhaps most of the people speaking out on this are from that side of the political spectrum,
00:15:08 but that doesn't mean that if you took, I don't know, a scan of the country, that the
00:15:12 only people who or the most people who care about this suffer are the right and of course historically
00:15:18 most of these battles that were fought were from the left yes kind of anti-establishment
00:15:24 i'm thinking of berkeley california that kind of thing um everything shifted this is where this
00:15:30 this is where this clown world meme you may have heard of has come as arisen from this idea that
00:15:36 We're living now in a universe which is just flipped upside down
00:15:40 and everything that we used to think is no longer true
00:15:45 and almost anything goes.
00:15:47 But I think it's concerning that people are branding this right-wing,
00:15:53 partly because right-wing has, in our culture, negative connotations,
00:16:01 which I don't think it should, but that's where we're at.
00:16:04 and so positioning it in this way
00:16:09 immediately gets people's backs up I think
00:16:13 But there is, you know, you could make the point surely
00:16:16 that so much of the incentive of basically no platforming people
00:16:21 and actually trying to stop people talking
00:16:24 has actually come from the left
00:16:25 I mean this is the reality of it
00:16:27 you know that it's actually broadly conservative
00:16:30 or centre-right views, call it what you want
00:16:32 But those are the ones that they disagree with and they want to get shut down.
00:16:37 I mean, that's the reality of it.
00:16:38 Well, that's what's happening.
00:16:39 Certainly in universities you have predominantly left-wing students' unions,
00:16:44 left-wing protests that are usually more often than not affecting right-wing speakers.
00:16:52 But Jermaine Greer was disinvited.
00:16:55 She's not right-wing.
00:16:56 No, no.
00:16:58 Julie Bindle again.
00:16:59 Julie Bindle.
00:16:59 it's difficult to pinpoint exactly
00:17:04 what the master values are in all of this
00:17:06 Douglas Murray's recent book
00:17:08 tries to tease some of this apart
00:17:10 I think he does a really good job
00:17:11 and certainly if anybody's interested in
00:17:13 having a look at the history of a lot of this
00:17:17 he exposes much of that
00:17:19 and shows the origins are very much political
00:17:22 but yeah I think it's
00:17:28 I think it would be risky to, in the same way that it's risky to associate commitment to free speech with purely right-wing thought,
00:17:39 I think it would also be risky to put suppression of free speech purely on the left.
00:17:44 I think it's probably got to be assessed on a more individual basis, and that's where we have to look at it.
00:17:54 you mentioned something about this a bit earlier but what worries me actually james really is that
00:18:01 you know you get the uh i believe in free speech but people right you got those um and we know
00:18:07 where they're coming from but it it worries me that actually there is now a group of people
00:18:14 significant group of people who actually do not believe in free speech i mean that not that they
00:18:19 you said they will say I think they don't they might not actually say it that way but but they
00:18:25 do not believe in it as a principle you know you're saying this is something which finally made you
00:18:30 want to do something because it's so important do you think that's true well I did I did mention
00:18:35 earlier that it's very unusual to hear anyone publicly say I don't believe in free speech but
00:18:40 I have actually come across people in the course of my running the society who've come
00:18:46 one person springs to mind who actually came to the society's fair and said oh I don't I don't
00:18:55 no I don't agree with free speech and I said oh brilliant come come to our events and we can have
00:19:00 a discussion and he said something like I'm entitled to my opinion I said hang on me that
00:19:06 that's free speech right there you're missing the point but sometimes people don't want to
00:19:13 be reasoned with. And in that moment we don't want to get into an argument with the fella.
00:19:18 But it's awfully odd to see how the cogs fit together in that line of thinking. Somewhere
00:19:28 down the line you're going to find yourself struggling.
00:19:31 Yeah, but what do you think is the basis for what they're saying? How would they explain
00:19:37 their position?
00:19:38 Right, that's a massive question.
00:19:42 And I think there are lots of answers,
00:19:44 but more often than not,
00:19:46 I think it's actually perversely well-meaning.
00:19:50 Right.
00:19:51 Bear with me, perhaps.
00:19:53 But I think you hear it a lot,
00:19:55 the road to hell is paved with gun intentions.
00:19:58 And I think people want to be nice.
00:20:03 They don't want people's feelings hurt.
00:20:06 they don't want certainly don't want to be seen as somebody who is defending people's feelings
00:20:13 being hurt and if they have for whatever reason managed to associate a commitment to free speech
00:20:19 with a commitment to that i can totally see how you might find yourself being averse to it
00:20:27 but it's more for me as so many things are an issue around a written issue centered on just
00:20:35 a lack of understanding of what somebody means by free speech and as it happens i think even the
00:20:41 people who claim to be very committed to that philosophically when they're actually pushed
00:20:50 to define what they mean by free speech that's a difficult thing and i would say that i fall into
00:20:55 that category myself in that the but in a way sometimes always follows because unless you
00:21:04 really are calling yourself an absolutist free speech advocate in which anything goes.
00:21:10 And this brings us back to Claire Fox because she got in the hot water I mentioned was due
00:21:15 to mentioning on, I believe, a radio program that she may well be in favor of child pornography.
00:21:25 Now, that's not to say that she's pro-child pornography, for goodness sake.
00:21:28 What she's saying is that if you're going to say, I'm pro-free speech and I'm an absolutist,
00:21:33 you're going to have to follow through
00:21:35 and commit to that
00:21:36 I'm sure she'll hate the fact that I've mentioned that
00:21:40 but it's just a really good touchstone
00:21:42 to see how very quickly
00:21:44 if you hold on to this strongly
00:21:46 you're going to find yourself
00:21:48 defending things you maybe
00:21:50 wish you weren't defending
00:21:51 on the basis that it's free speech
00:21:54 not that you agree with it
00:21:55 exactly, which is of course, is it the
00:21:57 Voltaire? I'd defend
00:22:00 to the death. Or even more recently
00:22:02 Christopher Hitchens
00:22:03 you know yeah you're going to have free speech it means you know people saying
00:22:08 things you don't want to hear yeah but I mean the interesting thing is when you
00:22:11 talk about the fellow who came along to your society or the people we're talking
00:22:15 about broadly who don't believe in it it's larger on the basis of offense
00:22:22 being given isn't it which is not quite the same as not but not agreeing with
00:22:27 something you're saying they don't want to be if they don't want to be offended
00:22:30 or rather they're taking offence on behalf of groups who are not even there.
00:22:35 This is the point.
00:22:36 Often.
00:22:36 You know, isn't this the point that really it's about the giving of offence
00:22:41 as opposed to I don't agree with you on this point so I'm going to stop you talking.
00:22:46 Yeah.
00:22:46 The psychologist Jonathan Haidt, whose work I'm sure you're familiar with.
00:22:50 Oh, right, yeah.
00:22:52 Jonathan Haidt did The Righteous Mind, the book The Righteous Mind.
00:22:55 Yeah, that's right.
00:22:56 And also the coddling of the American mind, I believe, after that.
00:23:00 He works out of a university in New York.
00:23:03 He's actually in the business school there.
00:23:06 But his thesis, narrowed down I suppose,
00:23:10 is that a lot of this comes from parenting in the early years,
00:23:17 which has become overbearing.
00:23:18 Again, from a position of, it's a well-intended position.
00:23:25 They don't want their children to find themselves hurt.
00:23:30 whether that's physically or mentally.
00:23:35 But what he has, in the course of his research,
00:23:38 what he's discovered is that children are less and less
00:23:44 often these days left on their own to reason with each other.
00:23:51 And that sort of thing is crucial for your development
00:23:54 and your understanding of how to simply deal with disagreement.
00:23:56 if you're always able to call upon an authority figure in this case a parent in in university
00:24:05 the students union or the the dean or whatever if you're always able to do that and you you're
00:24:12 that's your first port of call you'll never learn to deal with offense because there's always
00:24:18 somebody who can come and tell the other person not to do it and again i wouldn't want to
00:24:23 we want to put all of this on that one factor but I certainly think that's playing a role
00:24:29 that that children aren't growing up to be as independent as they used to be
00:24:36 and therefore maybe more rigid you know mentally more rigid I mean do you think that
00:24:45 students people around student age young people around the student age do you think that they are
00:24:52 basically more intolerant now generally I mean do you what's the entire that they
00:24:58 would say them see themselves as being hugely tolerant of course but I would
00:25:02 say just intolerant of anyone who deviates from a particular kind of
00:25:08 approach you know if you think the whole woke culture right that is you know
00:25:14 intolerance writ large isn't it you know the new name for those people what's
00:25:18 what is it the members of woko haram woko haram yeah i love that one that's a good one
00:25:23 yeah that's a good um woko haram yeah good yeah i uh i think
00:25:30 very often these people would say they're tolerant of everything other than intolerance
00:25:36 yes and i mean maybe that's true but
00:25:42 often I think people just haven't been exposed enough to people that are a bit different to them
00:25:51 in the way that they think and my experience running this group one of the things we do
00:25:57 perhaps the main focus of the society is to have discussion evenings so of course we have
00:26:05 the external speakers but they're less frequent than our more regular discussion evenings
00:26:12 We model those essentially, I suppose, on a tutorial,
00:26:16 but it's an informal extended one.
00:26:18 It can run beyond two hours of some times
00:26:21 where everyone just gets around a table,
00:26:26 often a very large table,
00:26:27 and we have a focus
00:26:33 and we'll just hash out an issue over the course of that time.
00:26:37 Often I'll start by just paring things down a little bit,
00:26:40 maybe offer a definition. For example, we've discussed hate speech as a concept, discussed
00:26:46 absolute free speech, political correctness. Just trying to pare these things down, tease
00:26:52 them apart, get a feel for what people's intuitions are. And very often you see people, you see
00:27:02 people, I don't want to say change their minds, but maybe just open their eyes a little bit.
00:27:06 having their eyes opened by everybody in the group and that's really good to see
00:27:15 so perhaps people are coming with preconceptions that would clash with my
00:27:20 own but then over time we perhaps find a consensus and then they come back and
00:27:27 we do it all again in a couple weeks time how big is your society now by the
00:27:31 way I mean how many people you know do you have membership yeah so we actually
00:27:36 Actually when we started we thought the best thing, it seemed perhaps right to make it
00:27:46 free.
00:27:49 We ended up then taking more sign-ups than anybody ever has at the societies fair at
00:27:56 the university.
00:27:57 So we were inundated with people signing up, so that was a really good sign.
00:28:04 And our first event was very successful, and since then we've kind of maintained that pretty solidly.
00:28:12 The discussion evening seemed to be just as popular as the public events, which is a really good sign.
00:28:16 That may be something to do with the fact we provide Krispy Kreme donuts, just to lure them in.
00:28:22 Works every time.
00:28:23 Yeah, it does. I'm surprised they're not.
00:28:25 But yeah, I think we've been maybe surprised that we've had such a positive reaction, both from the students and from the staff.
00:28:40 And I'd really just like to mention the support we've had from Sir Anthony Seldon, the Vice-Chancellor, who's really been fantastic on all of this.
00:28:48 I've met with him alongside Daria to discuss just the plans for everything.
00:28:51 I mean, he's congratulated us on the success we've had in the early stages,
00:28:57 but he's also mentioned us in the Sunday Times a couple of Sundays ago
00:29:01 in an article in which he discussed this problem more broadly.
00:29:05 And again, we're bucking the trend at this university,
00:29:10 standing up for free speech in a way that really I don't see any other universities doing,
00:29:17 not at least from top to bottom.
00:29:19 you have
00:29:20 as I said
00:29:20 you have other
00:29:21 free speech societies
00:29:21 in other places
00:29:22 perhaps you have
00:29:23 other pro-free
00:29:23 speech vice chancellors
00:29:25 and pro-free speech
00:29:26 student union
00:29:27 although I'm not
00:29:28 I'm seeing less
00:29:29 evidence of that
00:29:29 but to have it
00:29:31 at every stage
00:29:31 at Buckingham
00:29:32 I think is
00:29:32 that's just really
00:29:33 refreshing
00:29:34 well
00:29:35 all the very best
00:29:37 for it James
00:29:38 you know
00:29:38 going forward
00:29:39 and I think
00:29:40 you know
00:29:40 this is crucial
00:29:41 what you're doing
00:29:42 and I hope a lot of people
00:29:44 emulate you
00:29:44 yeah that's
00:29:45 that's what I'd like to see
00:29:46 actually
00:29:46 look
00:29:47 I
00:29:47 I'd like it to be the case
00:29:50 that there's no need for a free speech society
00:29:51 anywhere
00:29:52 and maybe 10 years, 20 years ago
00:29:55 there was no need
00:29:56 but at the moment I think
00:29:59 it's just a really
00:30:01 good idea and at the very least
00:30:03 you have a good time
00:30:04 discussing things with people
00:30:06 Thanks very much indeed James
00:30:09 That's it for what you're saying is this week
00:30:12 please remember to subscribe
00:30:13 if it's totally free
00:30:15 if you haven't done so already
00:30:16 and we will see you next week.
00:30:18 Thank you.