New Culture Forum - March 02, 2020


2.16 Toby Young: The Free Speech Fightback

2.15 Zuby: How To Be a Rebel in the 2020s 2.19 Charles Coulombe: A Conservative Author Examines the Culture Wars in Trad. Institutions

Episode Stats


Length

44 minutes

Words per minute

174.85

Word count

7,807

Sentence count

222


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to So What You're Saying Is, I'm Peter Wittrell. Now I'm delighted that my
00:00:19 guest today is one of Britain's best-known journalists. Toby Young is currently a columnist
00:00:24 for The Spectator, but in his career he's done a huge number of things. He founded a magazine
00:00:28 called the modern review back in the 90s he wrote for vanity fair he also wrote the best-selling
00:00:34 book how to lose friends and alienate people which was then made into a film now since then
00:00:41 he's also become a champion for free schools he's founded four of them and now he is about to launch
00:00:47 a new organization which is called the free speech union thanks very much for joining us
00:00:53 Thank you, Toby. First of all, can you tell us what is the Free Speech Union?
00:00:58 So the Free Speech Union will be a mass membership organisation that stands up for the speech rights of its members.
00:01:06 So if a member ends up being targeted by an outrage mob on social media because they've dissented from the prevailing orthodoxy
00:01:17 or inadvertently used a taboo word or something along those lines,
00:01:21 we will defend them on social media.
00:01:24 We'll mobilise our members to come to their defence and praise them on social media.
00:01:29 If they've been accused of something, we'll pass the evidence.
00:01:32 We'll try and make sure that they're put through some kind of due process
00:01:36 and not just presumed guilty and immediately cast out in the way Roger Scruton was
00:01:41 when George Eaton, I think it was, the spectator plucked various things he'd said out of context,
00:01:49 put them on social media and immediately whipped up a kind of blood-crazed feeding frenzy
00:01:55 which ended with him losing his job as a government advisor.
00:01:59 In addition, if people start circulating petitions or open letters, we'll start counter-petitions.
00:02:05 If they start writing letters or emails to the person's employer, we'll start a letter writing or email campaign to urge their employer not to fire them.
00:02:17 If they're put through some sort of disciplinary process or if they're fired, we will, I think, in most cases, provide them with legal assistance.
00:02:26 And if they do go to law, we'll help them crowdfund so they can fight their case.
00:02:31 We're in the midst of a really censorious moment, not just here, but across the Anglosphere,
00:02:38 a kind of new climate of Maoist intolerance in which any dissent from the prevailing orthodoxy,
00:02:44 any opinion which falls outside the increasingly narrowing confines of the Overton window,
00:02:52 anyone responsible for challenging the prevailing orthodoxy, even if they're on the left.
00:02:58 So, you know, we see it with Selina Todd, professor of modern history at Oxford, currently has to have a security guard to accompany her from her rooms to the lecture theatre because she has had the temerity to challenge some of the more outlandish claims of the trans Taliban.
00:03:15 So we want to create a more tolerant atmosphere. We want to protect people from being punished, from being singled out in this way by these twitchful mobs.
00:03:27 And I hope that we can give people a bit of courage and also give the mobsters, you know, pause for thought before they come after people like Selina Todd in future.
00:03:37 So would it be right to say that, say, for example, to take a recent example of Alison Stewart's, that's a perfect example, is it not?
00:03:45 Alison Stewart is a perfect example. Here is a distinguished, much-loved broadcaster employed by ITV for 40 years.
00:03:57 One careless tweet, and even describing it as careless is putting it quite strongly.
00:04:03 Yes, I think, you know, he quotes Shakespeare and and, you know, to make a technical point in the Shakespearean quote in question, the individual, the quote in Measure for Measure is aimed at is not being compared to an ape.
00:04:23 It's a simile, not a metaphor. And nonetheless, because of this one tweet, which which the person he didn't even include this person in the Twitter exchange.
00:04:36 But nonetheless, because he was using this passage from measure to measure, measure for measure to describe this individual in some sense,
00:04:45 the individual took offence, accused him of being racist and he was, you know, thrown under a bus.
00:04:50 I mean, yes, he resigned. But, you know, ITN left you in no doubt that they had acted to kind of force his resignation.
00:04:59 You know, had he been a member of the Free Speech Union, we would have urged him to sit tight.
00:05:05 If he'd been put through some sort of disciplinary process, we would have, I think, tried to make sure a solicitor was with him during those meetings.
00:05:15 if they'd gone on to fire him.
00:05:17 I'm not sure they would, but if they had done,
00:05:19 we would have urged him to sue them for constructive dismissal
00:05:22 and we would have crowdfunded to help him pay his legal costs.
00:05:26 So I hope that had he been a member of the Free Speech Union,
00:05:29 this wouldn't have happened and he'd still have his job.
00:05:32 The funny thing about things such as with Alice Stewart,
00:05:35 or with many of these things,
00:05:36 is that it seems to be a lot of it entirely phony
00:05:39 in the sense that no one seriously thinks Alice Stewart is a racist.
00:05:42 you know this is what almost the people who are accusing him I'm sure they don't even believe it
00:05:47 either it's just seems to be something which is about maybe virtue signaling or do you not find
00:05:53 it is it is odd that that someone like Alistair Stewart whom you know everybody I think has a
00:06:01 view of they they know him they trust him he's been reading the news for you know 40 years
00:06:06 for him to be accused of racism on the basis of a single tweet and you know it takes quite a lot
00:06:16 of kind of you know interpretive license to deem that tweet racist you know and set against that
00:06:24 you know his 40-year track record never been accused of anything like that before
00:06:27 and when he when he resigned quote unquote lots of his colleagues some of them women of color
00:06:33 testified to the fact that he's not a racist so the fact that someone can be deemed racist and
00:06:40 the fact that you know their employer can take that accusation that really serious allegation
00:06:47 at face value and not think well if someone's made that accusation let's put them through some
00:06:52 sort of due process let's weigh that one tweet against everything else we know about this person
00:06:58 against his entire career that would be the fair way to go about it not just to assume
00:07:03 oh you know guilty until proven innocent and by the way we're not going to even give you a chance
00:07:08 to prove your innocence we're just going to toss you to the wolves it really is disgraceful this
00:07:12 sort of thing cannot continue but was there something which actually basically made you
00:07:18 think to yourself right enough is enough i mean you know because we complain about this growing
00:07:24 sense of restriction on free speech was there something that happened or was there one
00:07:29 particularly interesting which made you think actually I've got to do something well yes there
00:07:32 was at the beginning of 2018 I was appointed to the board of the office for students a new
00:07:40 higher education regulator by Theresa May I was one of 15 non-executive directors it was an unpaid
00:07:47 job I wasn't Theresa May's new university's czar which is how it was described I mean curiously
00:07:55 over the course of the kind of week in which in which I was monstered by first social media and
00:08:02 then the mainstream media I was elevated so originally I started out as one of 50 non-executive
00:08:07 directors then I became you know a key universities advisor then a government advisor then a university
00:08:14 czar I mean you know if I'd have held on I would have become more important than the prime minister
00:08:17 but because I think in part because I'm you know I'm a I'm a white middle-aged cisgendered
00:08:27 heterosexual cishet I think is the term Brexit supporting Tory middle-aged balding outspoken
00:08:34 male you know the university sector didn't take very kindly to my appointment didn't like the
00:08:41 idea of me being a regulator overseeing their activities so immediately the offence archaeologists
00:08:47 went to work, sifting through everything I'd said or written. Dating back to 1987,
00:08:53 Paul Mason dug up a passage from an essay I wrote in a book edited by Rachel Johnson,
00:09:01 Boris's sister, in 1987. And the essay was about class at Oxford. And I described grammar school
00:09:07 boys in a slightly unflattering way, but it was self-deprecating because I myself was a grammar
00:09:12 school boy at oxford of course he left that out portrayed me as a as a knob and a toff um and uh
00:09:18 and you know suddenly i was this ghastly snob and had no place uh sitting on this uh uh as
00:09:25 being a university's czar you know when the big problem is had to persuade more working class
00:09:29 children to go to university not to keep them out you know as if you know i need telling that
00:09:33 thank you paul what what have you done to help the working class apart from backing jeremy corbyn
00:09:38 which inadvertently did help the working class because it meant labour became completely unelectable
00:09:42 Anyway, putting that to one side, another example, Peter.
00:09:46 I wrote a piece for The Spectator in 2001
00:09:50 in which I praised this obscure satellite channel,
00:09:56 now long defunct, called Men and Motors.
00:09:59 And there was one particular...
00:10:00 I remember it.
00:10:00 You remember Men and Motors?
00:10:01 Granada, Granada, Men and Motors.
00:10:01 There you are.
00:10:03 Fantastic, fantastic channel.
00:10:05 And if you're a bit of a, you know, if you're into cars.
00:10:08 Anyway, they had this one program which featured kind of topless girls draping themselves over kind of fast cars.
00:10:17 And I praised this show in this piece.
00:10:21 And the sub-editor of The Spectator at the time put the headline on it,
00:10:25 Confessions of a Porn Addict, as a sort of gag.
00:10:28 And, you know, I thought it was quite funny too until, you know, I think it was 17 years later,
00:10:33 some little online metal detectorist kind of found this in the spectator's digital archive
00:10:40 took a screen grab put the screen grab on twitter and then you know literally within half an hour
00:10:44 the evening standard ran a piece on i think page three with the headline pressure mounts on theresa
00:10:50 may as new university czar confesses to being porn addict and it was as though you know the
00:10:56 the kind of gestapo had had me under the hot lights the night before and i just you know
00:11:00 reluctantly confessed to being a kind of complete sexual deviant I mean it was you know and thank
00:11:06 you George Osborne you know I thought you were a Tory anyway anyway there was just a deluge of
00:11:12 kind of nonsense like this yet some silly things I'd said on Twitter late at night after a couple
00:11:17 of glasses of wine were brought up and this was like 10 years ago and and at the end of seven
00:11:23 days you know there'd been an urgent question in Parliament in which you know various virtue
00:11:29 signaling MPs including some conservatives not conservatives anymore I'm glad to say but
00:11:33 people like Sarah Williston kind of lined up to condemn me. Thanks John Bercow for granting that
00:11:40 and then there was there was a petition a change.org petition which had over 220,000 signatures
00:11:48 urging Theresa May to sack me. There was a there was a Guardian journalist permanently stationed
00:11:53 at the end of my driveway yeah would have brought him a cup of tea Michael Govstar but I'd run out
00:11:57 of almond milk and in the end I resigned partly to protect the other charities I was involved with
00:12:05 didn't want the kind of the mob to start turning their attention to them and saying what are you
00:12:12 doing employing Toby Young you know charities have to remain squeaky clean for a variety of
00:12:16 reasons are dependent on government funding and private donations and so forth so I stepped down
00:12:22 from the office for students hoping naively that that would draw a line under the whole affair this
00:12:27 was after one week of you know leading the news um and um but that was naive that was like throwing
00:12:33 a hunk of raw meat to a shoal of piranha fish you know once they think you've shown some weakness
00:12:38 and they can see blood in the water they go completely nuts you know the the blood crazed
00:12:43 feeding frenzy really gets going so i then had to step down uh as um from from the from the um
00:12:50 board of trustees of the charity I'd set up to house the four schools I'd co-founded.
00:12:56 I had to step down as a Fulbright commissioner. I had to step down as an honorary fellow of
00:13:01 Buckingham. And I had to resign from my full-time job running an education charity, which worked
00:13:06 with people wanting to set up free schools. So in total, I lost five positions as a result of
00:13:11 this being targeted by this outrage mob. And so I was, you know, well and truly cancelled,
00:13:19 You know, cast out, put beyond the pale, told I had no place any longer in kind of polite society.
00:13:26 So I know what it's like. I mean, and it can be, you know, I don't want to sound like a snowflake, but when you experience something like that, it can be really psychologically traumatic.
00:13:39 Well, I was going to ask you, because I mean, you're being very, very amusing about it now. But I mean, what actually was it like? I mean, if you've got someone at the end of the driveway and you've got, you're losing positions, you're losing a job. I mean, from every point of view, surely, sense of injustice and all of these things.
00:13:58 I'll tell you, the thing which really surprised me about it, and this was brought home to me when I spoke to someone else who'd been cancelled, who was a psychologist, one of the nice things, I mean there aren't many, but one of the nice things about being cancelled is you get to meet lots of other people who've been cancelled because they inevitably contact you or you meet, I mean I work for this Australian publication called Quillette, we had this party in Toronto beginning of 2019 and there were lots of people at that party who themselves had been cancelled and it was wonderful.
00:14:28 to meet these you know for the most part kind of really interesting mavericks and dissenters from
00:14:34 all different areas of all political views but who had ended up kind of uh you know um
00:14:40 inadvertently often kind of triggering some tripwire and their careers their lives were
00:14:46 were in tatters but anyway one of the people i met said that the hardest thing he'd found
00:14:50 about being cancelled was having to abandon the just world hypothesis so the just world
00:14:59 hypothesis is the belief that we live in a fundamentally just universe the laws of karma
00:15:04 apply and if you're basically a decent person and you observe the social contract then bad things
00:15:10 you know gross injustices are not going to befall you and when they do you know it's one of the one
00:15:17 of the forms i think your sense of injustice takes the reason it feels so acute is because
00:15:22 you hadn't realized it but you had been laboring under this illusion that you lived in a just
00:15:28 universe i mean a typical tip this like this psychologist said you know typically a pious
00:15:33 christian um whose uh young child gets cancer that's a real test of their faith because they
00:15:40 think i've been an observant christian all my life why is god turning on me in this way um and
00:15:47 you know sometimes they abandon their faith sometimes they find a way of rationalizing
00:15:51 what's happened um and keeping their faith but you know that's a really extreme example but for
00:15:56 someone like me an atheist i don't believe in the laws of karma um it was a shock to discover
00:16:01 that i did actually think that if i behaved well if i was a decent human being if i observed the
00:16:06 social contract that these the bad things wouldn't happen to me i mean horribly naive but nonetheless
00:16:12 having to abandon this having to kind of reconcile myself in the most kind of uh brutal way uh to to
00:16:20 the to the kind of randomness of the universe was was was pretty tough it reminds me rather of that
00:16:26 great woody allen movie crimes and misdemeanors you know where this is the whole crux of it that
00:16:31 he realizes in fact the universe is not what he thought it was all all the way along but what does
00:16:36 that actually do to you, Toby? I mean, has it changed? Do you think you are a different
00:16:41 man now as a result of that? Well, I was able to survive it, I think, for a variety of reasons.
00:16:48 And just to say, not everyone does. So there was a department chair at the University of
00:16:56 Dartmouth who was written about in the New York Times towards the end of last year. He
00:17:01 was caught up in a me too case and quite unfairly treated. I mean he had a group of women graduate
00:17:10 students in his department had complained about some of the professors in his department. They
00:17:17 hadn't accused them of rape or sexual assault but of behaving in various inappropriate ways and he
00:17:23 had done what was expected of him. He'd referred it to the Title IX committee at Dartmouth and it
00:17:29 was duly investigated by the authorities so he felt he discharged his responsibilities as department
00:17:34 chair but the women then brought a lawsuit a year later against Dartmouth for you know tens of
00:17:39 millions of dollars and what part of the lawsuit was that Dartmouth hadn't done enough when they'd
00:17:44 first brought it to this man's attention and in the lawsuit they then accused these professors of
00:17:48 much more serious misdemeanors crimes like rape and sexual assault but different to what they'd
00:17:56 originally accused them of anyway this man was then found you know he found his colleagues turning
00:18:01 on him a hashtag on twitter like something like sort of do better dartmouth started trending a
00:18:08 woman in the supermarket his local supermarket told him he should be ashamed of himself and he
00:18:12 was a disgusting human being he had a wife he had two young children he felt kind of ostracized by
00:18:18 his community and he hadn't done anything wrong but he was just swept up in the kind of me too
00:18:23 moral panic and and he'd had some mental health difficulties 20 years earlier it all came flooding
00:18:29 back he had electroconvulsive therapy to try and treat his depression that didn't work he ended up
00:18:36 taking his own life towards the end of last year and he's not the only one there are sort of a
00:18:40 think of at least half a dozen people who as a result of being cancelled of being targeted
00:18:45 particularly on social media have ended up taking their own lives nothing like that you know i never
00:18:51 came close to anything like that, partly because I have a stable and loving marriage. I'm a reasonably
00:18:59 psychologically robust person. I've never had mental health issues. Lots of my friends stood by
00:19:04 me. Even, you know, some people defended me in the press. Fraser Nelson, for instance, wrote a really
00:19:09 staunch, robust defense of me. Rod Little. I mean, my spectator colleagues were. Andrew Neil, they were
00:19:14 fantastic um so for all those reasons um you know i got through it um and um am i am i a different
00:19:21 person well i think i'm i'm sort of i i think um before it happened i sort of thought that um uh
00:19:30 i thought probably that that that that there was some merit in trying to remain sort of on the
00:19:37 right side of kind of mainstream liberal good opinion uh james delingpole who i do a kind of
00:19:43 weekly podcast called London Calling he would always kind of take the mickey out of me for not
00:19:49 being prepared to say the more outlandish provocative things that he said because I was
00:19:55 sort of scared about falling out with you know my mates on the Guardian or whatever it might be
00:20:00 and I realise now that he was probably right that that was a bit cuckish of me to use his phrase
00:20:05 And that actually, you know, we imagine that that our friends on the liberal left will stick up for us when we are accused of something like what I was accused of, when you're branded a homophobe or, you know, a transphobe or a misogynist.
00:20:26 You know, people, you know, and you've worked with for many years, colleagues, you know, on papers like The Guardian will stick up for you.
00:20:34 But no, in my case, they really didn't.
00:20:37 And so now I've become kind of, well, I'll just call it as I see it and speak my mind and not worry about, you know, the likely PR ramifications because, you know, you're never going to get that stuff right under any circumstances.
00:20:48 But it certainly has inspired me to set up the Free Speech Union.
00:20:53 I talked about it at the time.
00:20:55 I thought well if one good thing could come out of this I can start an organisation that can offer
00:21:00 some kind of protection to people who find themselves in the position I find myself in
00:21:04 because you know you don't know who to turn to for legal advice for PR advice you feel really
00:21:10 isolated even if your friends are sticking by you you know most of the time you feel quite isolated
00:21:15 and so if you can I really wanted to create an organisation that can provide people with all the
00:21:20 help both professionally and personally and psychologically that they will need if they
00:21:25 find themselves you know in the eye of a storm like this when they're being assailed on every
00:21:31 side by by this kind of by these mobs i wanted i wanted to provide a kind of safe haven for them
00:21:37 some kind of and a union seems like the perfect perfect organization the perfect kind of entity
00:21:42 to provide that kind of protection once upon a time unions used to provide that sort of protection
00:21:47 to their members one of the reasons unions were set up in the 19th century was to enable you know
00:21:52 workers to challenge the political views of their bosses without risking being fired you know not
00:21:58 really anymore um you know organizations like liberty and amnesty international pen they used
00:22:04 to stick up for people uh writers anyway intellectuals academics who found themselves
00:22:09 under fire because they'd said something controversial because they challenged an
00:22:14 orthodoxy or a dogma not anymore not for the most part index on censorship is still pretty good but
00:22:19 for the most part you know there's no one to turn to if you find yourself in that kind of position
00:22:24 we just had this case i think paul embury who was fired yeah i think it's because he shared a
00:22:28 platform with certain other brexiteers that are at a brexit rally and which i think um you know
00:22:34 he's now been in the battle with his own union the firefighters union it's extraordinary i mean
00:22:38 So the treatment of people who were pro-Brexit during, you know, the past three and a half years by some organisations, you know, treating them as though they were beyond the pale.
00:22:54 The position they were advocating was really indistinguishable from racism, xenophobia, calling them Little Englands.
00:23:02 I mean, you know, it's like you would expect you'd expect universities at least, you know, trade unions at least, which supposedly uphold the free speech of people within their organisations.
00:23:15 You'd expect them to have been a little more tolerant of some viewpoint diversity.
00:23:20 But no, this is actually going to be one area short of universities where you're going to have maybe your work cut out, really, because this is where free speech is really being suppressed, isn't it?
00:23:30 I mean, you wrote recently in The Critic about an incident where you were speaking at a debate,
00:23:35 but there was some poor guy you met afterwards who was virtually, you know, like, ostracised for being quite a mainstream,
00:23:43 well, just a mainstream Tory, I guess.
00:23:45 Yeah, I had a pretty tough time.
00:23:47 It was a debate during the general election, and I was sticking up for Boris Johnson,
00:23:51 And I was, you know, insulted in the chamber, called a paedophile by the co-president of the Durham Labour Club, called a nonce by the lead speaker on the other side.
00:24:06 And this was in a fairly respectable, you know, debating society in one of the oldest universities in England.
00:24:12 So I was pretty shocked. And in the bar afterwards, this young man came up and introduced himself and told me his story.
00:24:20 He was a small-c conservative.
00:24:23 In his first year, he'd contributed to this forum that had been created,
00:24:27 this online forum for students that were due to come to the university.
00:24:32 He was the first person in his family to go to university, incidentally.
00:24:34 He was from a Catholic background.
00:24:37 And he had expressed his view, his religiously informed view,
00:24:41 that he didn't think that Catholic priests should be forced to marry gay couples.
00:24:48 He thought that that should be their choice, and he challenged the idea that trans women are women
00:24:56 and indistinguishable from people who are born as women.
00:25:03 He'd said some pro-Israeli things in this forum.
00:25:06 Anyway, because he'd effectively outed himself, as you say, as having fairly mainstream conservative views.
00:25:13 I mean, maybe the view about gay marriage isn't as mainstream as all that,
00:25:17 But, you know, not certainly doesn't make him a homophobe, you know, and I think he was accused of being in favour of ethnic cleansing because he'd made these sort of mildly supportive comments about the state of Israel.
00:25:29 I mean, it was extraordinary. And he was targeted by a kind of energetic group of left wing activists on the Durham campus in his college.
00:25:38 So he someone slapped him in the face in the bar. Another person threw a plate at him in the dining hall and wrestled him to the ground.
00:25:47 The woman, the second or third year student whom Durham had assigned to him as his mother, quote unquote,
00:25:53 and her pastoral role to kind of look after freshers who are a little bit at sea.
00:25:59 She encouraged a gay friend of hers to make a pass at him in some sort of cack handed attempt to expose his bigotry.
00:26:06 You know, I mean, it's all horrible, all ghastly.
00:26:09 I mean, this is like it's a kind of soft and not so soft totalitarianism.
00:26:13 The intolerance for people with conservative views.
00:26:16 And I said, you know, the strange thing is that at Durham, you know, about 20 percent of the student body is conservative in most universities.
00:26:25 It's about 10 percent. So if anything, you know, what happened to him was unusually mild compared to the treatment that other out conservatives get at universities.
00:26:35 I don't know if you saw that policy exchange report last year, and it revealed that 60% of students who are pro-Brexit were uncomfortable airing their pro-Brexit views in front of their classmates for fear of the repercussions, and quite rightly, we now realise.
00:26:53 Didn't it also reveal something which is a bit of a wider concern, which is that there now are people, there's a significant group of people who actually don't believe in free speech?
00:27:04 I mean, they sort of feel it's something that should come second or third in the priorities.
00:27:09 Yeah, I think one of the reasons that free speech is under assault in universities is because the regressive left, the intersectional social justice left, has succeeded, I think, in embedding this narrative that there is a fundamental conflict between the rights of minorities, of marginalised groups, of women, and the right to free speech.
00:27:34 that the two are in conflict and if you side with free speech you're siding against those
00:27:41 historically victimized groups it's complete nonsense those historically victimized groups
00:27:47 have been you know the main one of the main beneficiaries of free speech over the years you
00:27:52 know the civil rights movement couldn't have taken place if america didn't have the first amendment
00:27:57 we wouldn't have rights for women if people hadn't stood up for free speech for women when these
00:28:03 suffragettes were clamouring for universal suffrage the idea that there is this conflict
00:28:08 and that free speech isn't for everyone it's just an opportunity it's just really an excuse for
00:28:15 male pale and stale conservatives to kind of flex their muscles and shout down their opponents i
00:28:22 mean it's just complete nonsense and i think to really one of one of the things i hope the free
00:28:27 speech union can do is to challenge this idea that there is a conflict between you know viewpoint
00:28:32 diversity on the one hand and all these other kinds of diversity on the other uh you know if
00:28:36 we want to live in a more open um uh uh humane compassionate society um the way to get there
00:28:46 is not to uh suppress free speech it's to defend everyone's right to free speech these these things
00:28:53 you know these are pretty serious sort of issues to be and as i mentioned in in the introduction
00:28:58 You know, you've sort of moved, it seems to me, in terms of your preoccupations.
00:29:02 You've moved from, you were basically working, say, for Vanity Fair.
00:29:06 Your book was a sort of a self-mocking account of that.
00:29:11 But you've become basically more political, have you not?
00:29:15 I mean, when did that sort of happen?
00:29:18 Or were you always bubbling under the surface political?
00:29:21 Well, I think I was always small c conservative.
00:29:25 I mean, I'd gone through periods of being...
00:29:27 Because your father was a very famous Labour man.
00:29:29 My father was a lifelong socialist, even though at one stage he left the Labour Party and joined the STP.
00:29:34 They went back to the Labour Party.
00:29:36 Yes, and my mother was fairly left-wing too.
00:29:40 And people often sort of bring that up as if...
00:29:44 It's odd that if you have left-wing parents, but you yourself are a Conservative, people think that's a bit suspect.
00:29:50 You must be engaged in some sort of Oedipal drama in which you're constantly battling against your father.
00:29:56 This is one of the kind of memes that was used when I was mobbed at the beginning of 2018.
00:30:02 He's obsessed with his dad. He's got this kind of huge psychological issue.
00:30:06 He's constantly tilting against the kind of imposing figure of his father.
00:30:10 And that's how to explain his politics.
00:30:12 And people say sometimes the same things about Hilary Benn, who isn't quite as left-wing as Tony Benn.
00:30:18 And so he must therefore be engaged in some sort of Oedipal drama.
00:30:22 I mean, you know, people don't say the same about if you if you have right wing parents and you and you're a left winger, then you're enlightened.
00:30:28 You know, then you've emerged from the darkness, the bigotry of your of the kind of the fog you were enveloped in as a child in this horribly closed household.
00:30:38 You've emerged into the light and become a kind of psychologically healthy person.
00:30:42 I mean, it's just complete nonsense. Anyway, you're right.
00:30:46 I've certainly become kind of more political over the course of my career.
00:30:51 I mean, I guess I used to write much more about culture in a non-political way.
00:30:57 And then I started writing, when I got involved in the free schools movement,
00:31:00 I started writing more about politics.
00:31:02 And now the border between culture and politics has become much more porous.
00:31:08 I mean, we are engaged in and have been engaged in for some time now a culture war.
00:31:12 And that means that I can write about both politics and culture in a way that comes quite naturally, having written about both for sort of, you know, 35 years.
00:31:21 But there is a sort of sense as well that these are really compelling things, aren't they?
00:31:25 These cultural issues, they are really compelling issues.
00:31:29 And so almost one can't ignore them.
00:31:33 What's interesting is that I mentioned the Modern Review in the introduction, which I remember reading.
00:31:38 Really, I loved it.
00:31:40 I should explain to people that this was a it was like a paper actually wasn't it was a magazine
00:31:45 yeah but the whole point was that you were actually writing about as it were the popular
00:31:51 arts but in a highbrow way I think that was the point but that was hugely influential wasn't it
00:31:57 with I mean that's the way the Sunday Times covers them now isn't it yes yeah Andrew Neil
00:32:03 once confessed to me that he'd based the culture the Sunday Times arts and culture section
00:32:10 on the Modern Review.
00:32:12 It was a magazine that Julie Birchall and Cosmo Landersman
00:32:16 and I set up in 1991 in my sort of bedsit in Shepherd's Bush.
00:32:20 I think I had Jan Wenner, the founder of Rolling Stone.
00:32:24 He created the first issue of Rolling Stone on his kitchen table.
00:32:27 And I had fantasies of, you know,
00:32:28 becoming this kind of multi-millionaire magazine publisher
00:32:32 flying around in private jets.
00:32:35 But actually, we never graduated out of my kitchen
00:32:38 in my bedsit in Shepherd's Bush.
00:32:39 it was there for four years it was born there and it died there um but it was a great experience as
00:32:44 you say it was um i think the motto was low culture for highbrows and we employed kind of
00:32:50 intellectuals and academics and kind of smart journalists to write long scholarly uh pieces
00:32:57 about things like arnold schwarzenegger and madonna and many many the magazine was at that time you
00:33:03 know now we think what's radical about that but back then that was quite a radical approach you
00:33:07 Most people employed kind of slightly snotty critics to write about pop culture to review airport novels and did it in this kind of disdainful, kind of snobbish way.
00:33:19 And so we wanted to turn the tables on them and actually celebrate what we really loved about popular culture, but not in a kind of slumming it way as a sort of reaction to high culture,
00:33:30 but just saying actually some of this stuff is so good, it deserves to be put alongside some of the best stuff in high culture.
00:33:37 And so that was the kind of motif.
00:33:40 But very quickly, I think the broadsheets, particularly the Sunday Times,
00:33:43 recognised that this was the kind of direction of travel.
00:33:47 And they immediately started changing the way they covered mass culture
00:33:50 and poached quite a few of our writers.
00:33:52 So Tom Schoen, who was the literary editor of the Modern Review,
00:33:56 was poached by the culture to become the Sunday Times film critic.
00:33:59 Not that I minded, it was great to kind of be...
00:34:01 He's still there now, isn't he, I think?
00:34:03 He's back there. He's now doing that again.
00:34:05 Yeah, he's actually a great critic.
00:34:07 And therefore, if you were writing about culture at that point and obviously have done since, I wonder, Toby, with Brexit, has your own cultural life, this is something I've been thinking about a lot, has your own cultural life altered and changed in any way?
00:34:21 I mean, I'm thinking, for example, you wrote for Vanity Fair, didn't you? I used to read Vanity Fair and I enjoyed it. Now I can't really take it anymore because it seems to be just one long Trump bashing thing.
00:34:35 And I wonder, is what you read and what you watch and listen to, has that been altered by Brexit?
00:34:44 Have you found that sort of like, I can't watch the actor anymore or I can't do it, you know, I can't read.
00:34:50 I know what I'm going to get.
00:34:51 i'd say um i'd say i haven't been um that that that i'm not so wrapped up in the brexit drama
00:35:02 that it's completely poisoned me against the kind of ultra remainers when i see them pop up
00:35:09 on tv or on the stage and so forth so you know i can still enjoy you know hugh grant in uh four
00:35:17 weddings and a funeral even though you know he he tried to muzzle the press in hacked off and he
00:35:22 campaigned for um i think chaka amuna and various i think all the candidates he campaigned for in
00:35:28 in december all lost um as we know um but i think i i can kind of separate i think the man that
00:35:34 his performances from his kind of public persona um i think it's uh i mean you're right about
00:35:41 But it's extraordinary the extent to which so many fairly mainstream liberal with a small L magazines and newspapers that used to have lots of readable stuff in them back in the day, back in the not too distant day, you know, 10, 15 years ago.
00:35:59 Magazines like Vanity Fair employed some really good writers, not the least of which was Christopher Hitchens, who used his column in part as a platform to make the case for the Iraq War and was anti-woke before his time.
00:36:19 But now you don't see that diversity, that range of views in publications like Vanity Fair, The New Yorker, The New York Times.
00:36:27 The Washington Post may be slightly less guilty of this, but pretty much going in the same direction.
00:36:31 It's as though they've all been captured by the woke left.
00:36:35 It's like the left took this kind of regressive turn.
00:36:38 And not everyone on the left kind of went along for the ride, but they've become the kind of dominant voice.
00:36:44 And they've cowed the kind of much more reasonable, progressive members of the left.
00:36:52 They've cowed them.
00:36:53 And some of them are kind of being forced over to our side.
00:36:57 Someone like Andrew Doyle, for instance, the creator of Titania McGrath.
00:37:00 I mean, you know, describes himself as a socialist.
00:37:02 But he's almost kind of, he's so unwelcome in the woke church.
00:37:06 And he's effectively, you know, an apostate.
00:37:09 And of course, we know the left hates apostates even more than heretics.
00:37:13 So he's kind of been forced to kind of join people like you and I in our kind of, you know, along with the other deplorables.
00:37:21 But I hope one of the things that the free speech union can achieve is to provide some protection to the more reasonable members of the left from being turned on and ostracised by their woke colleagues.
00:37:36 What we see with the way in which gender critical feminists are being treated.
00:37:41 I mean, the extraordinary thing about that is that the kind of the trans Taliban who make life so difficult for gender critical feminists like Kathleen Stock, professor of philosophy at Sussex University, is on the advisory council of the free speech union.
00:37:58 You know, she receives death threats, has things thrown at her.
00:38:02 People set off fire alarms when she tries to speak so she can't be heard.
00:38:06 You know, she's a member of she's a she's a member, a longstanding member of the left.
00:38:10 and you know in the the trans Taliban are allowed to get away with it because you know the kind of
00:38:17 the Politburo within the kind of you know the woke Kremlin have kind of decreed that if you're
00:38:24 you need to be a good ally of these kind of trans militant advocates and if you criticize them if
00:38:33 you dissent from their orthodoxy even in the smallest way then you're you're an enemy and it's
00:38:39 You know, we have to try and reduce the power of that Politburo and make and create more space in our society for people to discuss issues like whether you should be able to self-identify more easily if you think you're transgender.
00:38:53 I mean, that's a really critical issue that affects lots of people.
00:38:56 Should we have gender neutral toilets? Should trans women be allowed into women's changing rooms or women's refuges?
00:39:03 Or should they be allowed to transfer from men's prisons to women's prisons?
00:39:06 it's all happened uh because of the you know it's as though we haven't had a chance to to have a
00:39:12 public conversation about it because everybody's too scared to say what they really think it seems
00:39:16 to me that the trans issue is sort of maybe a bridge too far maybe this is where things are
00:39:21 turning i remember we had rod little on and he said this he thought this was going to be he had
00:39:26 a wonderful phrase he called it peak wank basically this was going to be the the ridiculousness of
00:39:31 this issue was actually going to be the turning point well interesting you say that peter i mean
00:39:35 i would love to think that we had reached you know peak wank but every time you think we have
00:39:43 um it then gets worse i thought i thought you know people thought ricky gervais you know he
00:39:49 gets away with um his opening monologue at the golden globes which is a kind of fantastic kind
00:39:55 of exhilarating kind of full-throated assault on the kind of uh censorious high priests high
00:40:03 priests of the woke church marvellous stuff you think everyone thought this is a turning point
00:40:08 you know uh he's been able to he's he's attacked them and he hasn't been cancelled you know he's
00:40:13 still with us he'll probably be doing the opening monologue next year if the golden do the hollywood
00:40:17 foreign press association give him enough money uh but then you know two weeks later alastair
00:40:22 stewart tossed to the walls for one careless tweet uh you know you think that there's you think that
00:40:27 the tide has turned and then and then it just starts coming in again uh so i think we really
00:40:32 need more organisations, I hope the Free Speech Union isn't the only one, but I hope it's a start,
00:40:37 more organisations like this that can stand up for dissenters, for non-conformists, for mavericks,
00:40:45 so they can speak out without risking their livelihoods, say what they think, challenge
00:40:50 some of the prevailing orthodoxies, which need to be challenged, have, engage in conversations
00:40:56 about important issues that affect so many people without feeling they have to censor what they
00:41:00 really think i think uh obviously it's a fantastic initiative and and one that is utterly vital i
00:41:08 mean i know we're ending now but i know that this week you um highlighted a situation in canada
00:41:15 where the government's talking about uh you have to have a license for the internet to do shows
00:41:21 like this even you know or podcasts i think you tweeted about yes um that might not seem like what
00:41:27 you're talking about but it is an area of free speech you know these are the areas we're going
00:41:31 to have to look at aren't we? Well the the the danger of what's happening in Canada and of the
00:41:39 regulation the regulations that our government is proposing to create and which they outlined in
00:41:45 the online harms white paper which proposed you know creating a new internet regulator it's the
00:41:51 same problem we faced with uh the the hacked off wanting to create a state approved regulator of
00:41:58 the press the problem is that the people who want to become regulators are inevitably um the kind of
00:42:05 purse-lipped finger-wagging left-wing scolds you know the puritans the sort of people that
00:42:11 that um george orwell described as the boiled rabbits of the left they're the people who will
00:42:18 essentially decide what people can and can't read what they can and can't see on twitter on
00:42:24 facebook what they what they can see on youtube you know it'll be it'll be a further narrowing
00:42:30 of the overton window and so you know everyone should oppose any attempt to try and replicate
00:42:36 what's happening in canada over here and i hope that the free speech union can can can lend its
00:42:41 weight to the campaign against the creation of internet regulation greater internet regulation
00:42:48 in this country i should just say peter i hope by the time this is broadcast yeah that the free
00:42:53 speech union's website is live we're kind of frantically trying to get it ready it'll be at
00:42:58 freespeechunion.org right and if you're interested in joining hopefully go to the website it'll tell
00:43:04 you how to do that but if it's not if it's for some reason we're still you know it's still in
00:43:08 beta and we're still road testing it then just email me at uh info at freespeechunion.org info
00:43:15 at freespeechunion.org and um and i can process your membership application and make sure you get
00:43:21 your card and everything else uh you know in a couple of weeks so that goes for everyone who's
00:43:25 watching who wants to do that wants to join yeah absolutely yeah anyone can join and and also will
00:43:31 you be having any form of events to be i mean yes something like that i think one of the one of the
00:43:36 really important things that we hope to do is to create public spaces where people can have
00:43:44 difficult conversations, speakeasies in bars, public debates in institutions like the Emanuel
00:43:51 Centre, Conway Hall, debates at universities in conjunction with free speech societies at
00:43:58 universities, where people with passionately opposing views can model how to have courteous,
00:44:05 good-humoured, well-mannered conversations and to show people that it's possible to disagree
00:44:11 but to remain on civil terms and that merely challenging the prevailing orthodoxy doesn't
00:44:19 actually risk anyone's safety. It's not a form of violence. It's not going to send people into
00:44:25 a spiral of psychological trauma. Actually, it's just a conversation.
00:44:30 This has been a great one. So thank you very much indeed, Toby. Thank you.
00:44:34 thank you Peter thanks for watching so what you're saying is so we will see you next time thank you