New Culture Forum - March 11, 2020


2.19 Charles Coulombe: A Conservative Author Examines the Culture Wars in Trad. Institutions

2.16 Toby Young: The Free Speech Fightback Counterculture 1.07: Does Conservatism Have a Future?

Episode Stats


Length

34 minutes

Words per minute

165.7

Word count

5,745

Sentence count

258


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to So What You're Saying Is, I'm Peter Whittle. Now, seven years ago this month,
00:00:23 Pope Benedict XVI abdicated and he was followed by Pope Francis II. You might be aware of a film
00:00:32 that's been out recently called The Two Popes, which features a fictitious meeting between these
00:00:37 two men and in some ways they do represent two wings, if you like, of the Catholic Church.
00:00:43 One thing is for certain and that is the Catholic Church has faced what is now known as an
00:00:48 existential crisis for a long time and I'm very pleased therefore that my guest today is someone
00:00:53 who's going to talk to us about that and many other things. Charles Coulon is from Los Angeles
00:00:59 originally and he's now living in Austria. He has toured the world speaking about the papacy
00:01:06 and Catholicism. He's written numerous books on the subject and indeed on another possibly
00:01:11 besieged institution, the monarchy. Thank you very much for coming, Charles. It's great to see you
00:01:17 here um i mentioned that film at the beginning but i understand you haven't seen it sort of on
00:01:22 principle pretty much yeah although i have to say that as soon as francis was elected my first
00:01:28 thought was price has to play him in the biopic because he looks just like yes he does so that
00:01:33 was that was a given but uh no i'm not really keen on seeing it partly because i really like
00:01:38 Anthony Hopkins. And I know from people who've seen it that the, how do I put it, the popular
00:01:49 press mind idea of Benedict as this terrible, evil dictatorial fellow who scammed his way
00:01:56 into becoming Pope versus this wonderful, free, humble, holy person who came in, doubtless
00:02:05 brought in by the Holy Ghost directly.
00:02:08 That was the point of view.
00:02:10 Well, it's like certain historical films.
00:02:17 I won't see them simply because I know they're so biased,
00:02:22 so twisted, it annoys you.
00:02:24 Yes, it's just going to kind of wind you up, isn't it?
00:02:26 Yeah.
00:02:26 Basically.
00:02:27 I've got so many things to do that already, I don't need more.
00:02:29 Yes.
00:02:30 Now, it's true to say, isn't it, Charles,
00:02:33 that you are a traditionalist when it comes to Catholicism.
00:02:37 I mean, it's interesting because we start off this week, actually.
00:02:41 There's been this decision, hasn't there, by Francis II
00:02:44 not to allow married priests in the Amazon region.
00:02:49 Now, that would appear to be a victory for the conservative part of the church, is it?
00:02:53 Well, yes and no, no and yes.
00:02:55 I mean, it is in the sense that it shows that the Holy Father does give himself certain limits.
00:03:08 And what I've been hoping for throughout this pontificate is that he would have his Humanae Vitae moment.
00:03:15 And this may be it.
00:03:17 Paul VI, who dominated my childhood and early youth, delighted in change.
00:03:24 hear that that generation of clerics and their immediate disciples which
00:03:30 generation the current Holy Father is one love change for changes sake you know
00:03:34 if it's not alive if it doesn't change yeah so change it as an end now the
00:03:42 thing was that he came to a point beyond which he could not go and then he dug in
00:03:48 his heels and he paid the price horribly because after humana Vitae the last 10
00:03:53 years of his pontificate were held. You know, his life, from being popular, he became scorned.
00:04:00 All right, well, during the course of this pontificate, which I have to say is gone pretty
00:04:05 much the way I was afraid it would, during the course of it, I've kept hoping that he
00:04:11 would find a Humanae Vitae moment where his basic faith would kick in and say, no, I don't
00:04:17 think, I don't think we're going to go that way. I'm hoping this is it. Not simply because
00:04:25 of the issue involved, which is true enough on its own, but for his sake, you see, as
00:04:31 a man, as the Holy Father, as the Pope. Because, you know, we're obligated to, at the very
00:04:37 least, try to respect him and to try to have some sort of affection for him.
00:04:41 Isn't this sort of the case that people who like this Pope are the sort of people who
00:04:44 don't like popes generally well that's exactly people who don't like the church yes exactly
00:04:50 you know i mean let's put it this way uh i was a comedian as you know years and years ago
00:04:56 no you should explain this was uh when you were a younger man in los angeles right on the sunset
00:05:01 strip indeed and had brown hair okay right but way back then uh i mean if i had been you know
00:05:08 the sort of comedian people who don't like to laugh like what sort of a comedian would i have
00:05:13 bit. He'll confirm you in every dreadful feeling you've got and you'll be suicidal by the time
00:05:19 you're done with him. Well, you wouldn't want to deal with a comedian like that. Well, similarly,
00:05:24 you look at a politician. If a person in power makes you doubt your country,
00:05:31 makes you unpatriotic or contrary-wise, if the enemies of your country love your leader,
00:05:36 yeah you got a problem
00:05:39 well it's the same here
00:05:41 we wouldn't say for instance
00:05:43 that the Dalai Lama
00:05:45 was a great Tibetan Buddhist if he said
00:05:47 you know what we should be eating meat
00:05:48 I've changed my mind
00:05:51 now mind you I'm a meat eater
00:05:53 I love meat
00:05:54 but I don't think it would be a good thing
00:05:57 for the Dalai Lama to come out for meat
00:05:59 and continue to be
00:06:01 Dalai Lama
00:06:02 now if he said I'm resigning because I want to eat meat
00:06:04 that's different. That's a matter of principle
00:06:07 and that I can respect
00:06:09 but if he were to get up there and say
00:06:11 well, I'm the Dalai Lama and I would be
00:06:13 having steak every night. Catch me at Simpsons
00:06:15 Yeah, yeah. Exactly
00:06:17 There's this thing as well with
00:06:19 this Pope as well that there was this image of him
00:06:21 being, wasn't there, very much
00:06:23 an informal Pope
00:06:25 one that cared about people
00:06:27 and then I remember, I think it was just before Christmas
00:06:29 this footage emerged of him
00:06:31 you know, sort of pulling his
00:06:33 hand away this woman i think it's a chinese lady and she was trying to touch him and he pulled his
00:06:38 hand away and then as a result he looked very petulant and as a result uh a lot of people went
00:06:43 and did a bit of archaeology on the internet and there were quite a few instances like this i mean
00:06:47 in other words is the reality of the man different to the image very much so i mean
00:06:52 they called it at the time the slap heard around the world and i have to say that uh i wrote about
00:06:59 it in crisis magazine there i have a column i'm sorry was that a plug but uh the thing is that
00:07:07 looking at the footage this is before i knew what had gone on looking at the way she crossed
00:07:13 herself stared at him and then grabbed his arm i figured that she was probably trying to say
00:07:19 something about the way he dealt with the church in china right um the truth is that the holy see
00:07:26 I mean if words mean anything
00:07:29 the Holy See betrayed the underground church
00:07:31 in China. Can you actually explain
00:07:33 a bit more about this because there has been this
00:07:35 a lot of people watching won't know
00:07:36 there was an agreement
00:07:39 wasn't there with the Chinese but it's not
00:07:41 worked out the way has it?
00:07:42 It's worked out precisely the way anybody
00:07:45 who knew anything thought it would work out
00:07:47 you see if
00:07:49 now maybe Justin Trudeau
00:07:51 had a different idea he doesn't know a lot
00:07:53 but that was an egregious
00:07:55 swipe yes you know we like those don't worry well i i just it's too easy to bag out i'm sorry but
00:08:02 the the the thing is honestly that uh after the communists took over china in 1949
00:08:10 they separated the church in china there was a seismatic national church the chinese patriotic
00:08:15 association bishops appointed by the chinese communist government um and the the pope basically
00:08:23 deprived of any control over it and then there was the underground church bishops and so forth
00:08:27 remaining loyal to rome and they were and continue to be persecuted horribly from murder to imprisonment
00:08:34 to you name it and notice no one ever talks about this you see we always talk about china we never
00:08:39 mention about what's going on you say that's i don't want to say we're a bunch of hypocrites
00:08:44 but it's tempting anyway what should happen but that he gets it into his head our holy father
00:08:52 does apparently with some uh pushing from uncle ted mccarrick carl mccarrick the famous scandal
00:09:00 person uh to come to an agreement with beijing and to recognize the patriotic church as the catholic
00:09:09 church in china which he did and this ended up with far more persecutions of what had been the
00:09:16 the underground church uh more and even true even persecutions of the patriotic church
00:09:22 you see because now there's nothing to hold over their heads there's no whip hand and they do
00:09:27 whatever they want but the holy father being the soda man he is of the of the generation of clerics
00:09:33 he is i think on some level is incapable of ever saying he's wrong even if he feels yeah yeah he
00:09:40 just if he did it he did it well i thought at the time when i watched that lady go off on him
00:09:46 I thought, you know, I'll bet anything she's going on about China.
00:09:51 Yes.
00:09:51 And that's exactly what it was.
00:09:52 Right.
00:09:53 And that's, now mind you, later he met with her, which is nice, you know.
00:09:58 It was certainly a good PR move.
00:10:00 But he's not, the problem with him, I would say, is fivefold.
00:10:08 Number one, I do believe at the bottom of it all,
00:10:11 he has the faith of an Argentine immigrant kid, which is what he is.
00:10:14 But he hasn't been back there, has he?
00:10:15 he hasn't been back to his own country well they know i'm there right okay there's but it still
00:10:20 shaped him yeah you know the second uh thing about him though is that he's a product of the
00:10:26 jesuit educational system at the time that it was being dismantled people forget this but in the
00:10:32 60s it was very willfully dismantled the jesuits the time of vatican ii were brilliant they knew
00:10:37 tons of languages and so on and so forth and they might have been horrible as people but they were
00:10:42 very well educated that's all gone and so you could see this when he uses big
00:10:48 words then he doesn't know what they mean yeah especially he tries to be
00:10:52 insulting you know if I were he and I said you you know what Peter you're a
00:10:56 trilobite you look at me said a trilobite you're telling me that I'm a
00:10:59 fossilized crustacean oh that's not what trilobite means okay you say something
00:11:05 That is the position he calls people Neopelagians and so forth.
00:11:13 You know he doesn't know what the word means.
00:11:15 It just doesn't work.
00:11:17 Anyway, the third thing I would say about him is that he is very, very much representative, as I said earlier, of his generation of priests.
00:11:25 The reason why I have not been surprised by him, as so many of my friends and colleagues have, especially the younger ones,
00:11:31 is that when I was a kid,
00:11:35 it seemed like every parish
00:11:36 had what we called the Vatican II priest.
00:11:40 And he was going to come in
00:11:41 and break up everything,
00:11:42 throw out the statues,
00:11:43 break up the altar rails,
00:11:45 do this, do that,
00:11:46 and on and on and on.
00:11:47 If you questioned him in any way,
00:11:50 he'd attack.
00:11:52 It was often very brutal, very nasty,
00:11:55 but at the same time,
00:11:56 it was all for freedom and love
00:11:58 and peace and truth and so on.
00:12:00 Well, a lot of him left the priesthood.
00:12:04 Unfortunately, a lot of him stayed and became the bishops of the 80s and 90s.
00:12:08 Not all of them, of course.
00:12:10 And then one of them, sooner or later, had to be pope.
00:12:14 And here he is.
00:12:15 The fourth point I would make is that it's not really just about him or about the church
00:12:21 because that generation in leadership roles is always about self and not about the office.
00:12:27 You can see this in government.
00:12:29 You can see this in industry.
00:12:34 It's the sort of thing where if I were a city councilman,
00:12:36 and I'd say, Peter, being a city councilman
00:12:39 is like the summation of my whole life.
00:12:42 It's my life's journey's completion.
00:12:43 I'm going on and on and on.
00:12:45 And finally you say, councilman, cool on, that's great.
00:12:48 You ever get to fill the potholes,
00:12:49 maybe get the trash picked up?
00:12:51 Oh, Peter, that's the old city councilman.
00:12:54 We don't do that anymore.
00:12:56 And we don't wear jackets and ties at council meetings.
00:13:00 It is quite right.
00:13:02 It's sort of like, in this country,
00:13:04 it seemed to come about very much with the Blair government.
00:13:07 Yes.
00:13:07 That kind of approach, that sort of, as you say,
00:13:10 the self being far more important than the office.
00:13:12 Yep.
00:13:13 You know, and this is, I admit,
00:13:14 there was a great line in the movie,
00:13:16 The Iron Lady, about Thatcher.
00:13:18 I saw that.
00:13:18 She says, you know, in my day, we wanted to do something.
00:13:22 Now people just want to be something.
00:13:24 And I think that that's the point.
00:13:25 The point really, Charles, about this is,
00:13:27 where does this leave the church?
00:13:28 But if you've got someone in it who is more concerned about the self, as it were,
00:13:33 could he destroy the church, therefore?
00:13:35 No, no.
00:13:36 I mean, you know, there's the old joke of a cardinal when he was asked that question.
00:13:42 He said, we've been trying for 2,000 years and we haven't succeeded.
00:13:46 And it's quite true.
00:13:49 I was very fortunate in that I had as a confessor James Francis Cardinal McIntyre,
00:13:54 who had been the Archbishop of LA and was retired when he took on the odious job
00:13:58 of monitoring my conscience okay I don't wish on anyone but the Cardinal was a
00:14:04 very funny man he had a great sense of humor but he'd had a real life before he
00:14:08 became a priest he'd been a runner on Wall Street and risen up to be off of
00:14:13 the partnership of a firm and then he became a priest so very practical but
00:14:19 also had a ton of faith you know it which is the combination I've always
00:14:22 light tough as nails but a complete believer so he uh he used to say that uh the the biggest
00:14:31 problem in hierarchical church will always be the clergy and at the top is the top we've had popes
00:14:38 i wrote a history of vickers of christ uh which i touch on francis just as i mentioned it uh another
00:14:44 plug a uh we don't mind parks really well that's that's rely on them when i was a kid in the 60s
00:14:53 on every talk show you'd always have so i oh and i'll be appearing at the palladium oh i'm sorry
00:14:57 was that a plug yes it's it's a plug trust me but seriously um the thing is that uh we have had
00:15:08 some really awful leadership in the 2000 years of the church's history we had a whole century
00:15:14 the so-called pornocracy the iron age in the 900s when popes were basically chosen by
00:15:21 noble roman sluts i mean literally there's there's no other way i can put it uh the last
00:15:28 really bad pope i would say i mean as in nobody defends him is julius iii in the 1550s but you
00:15:38 You see, without him, the reform of Trent had already gotten underway, had begun.
00:15:43 But a lot of the cardinals at the time were not happy with the way reform was going,
00:15:48 so they said, all right, we'll put in someone who will calm it down.
00:15:52 Well, they did all right, Julius III.
00:15:55 The stench he left in everyone's nostrils was so great that they elected Paul IV after,
00:16:01 and that was the beginning of the Tridentine reform really taking hold.
00:16:03 So they all, I mean, that's one of the things that hit me about writing about every single one of these popes
00:16:09 Is how they all played their role
00:16:12 They all, even despite themselves, against themselves
00:16:16 Which, if you think about it in a sense, is true of all of us
00:16:19 But John XII, another one of my favorite bad popes
00:16:23 Tried to sell the papacy three times
00:16:26 Died of the wounds his mistress's lover inflicted on him in her arms
00:16:32 It was very romantic, you know, dying in her arms like that.
00:16:35 I've always wondered if the husband went to hell for killing the Pope
00:16:39 or heaven for defending the marriage bomb.
00:16:41 I don't know.
00:16:41 But whichever it was, he was also the one who confirmed the Charter of Cluny
00:16:46 and thus unwittingly set forth a period of reform in the church.
00:16:53 So what I would say is that no single man can destroy the church, much as we try.
00:17:01 No, it can look down, it can be persecuted, it can be corrupt, it can be this, it can be that, but it always bounces back.
00:17:11 There's a famous Boccaccio story set during the Renaissance, oddly enough, when he was writing about a Frenchman in Paris who had a Jewish friend who was always trying to convert to Catholicism.
00:17:23 The Jewish friend wouldn't do it.
00:17:25 Finally, he says, you know what, I'm going to go to Rome and I'll see your Pope and Cardinals.
00:17:30 And if your religion's true, I'll find out, and I'll convert.
00:17:33 Oh, no, don't go to Rome.
00:17:34 Whatever you do, don't do that.
00:17:36 No, no, I'm going.
00:17:37 So off he goes.
00:17:39 And the fellow thinks, well, that's it.
00:17:40 He'll never come in now.
00:17:42 A year and a half go by.
00:17:44 He's walking down the street.
00:17:45 There's his friend.
00:17:46 He says, well, I'm back from Rome.
00:17:48 I've converted.
00:17:49 Let's go to Mass.
00:17:50 I said, you've been to Rome?
00:17:53 He says, yes.
00:17:54 And you've converted there.
00:17:55 Yes.
00:17:56 Well, wasn't it corrupt?
00:18:00 Oh, horrible.
00:18:01 The Cardinals? Disgusting.
00:18:03 The Pope? Wouldn't trust him as far as I could throw him.
00:18:06 And yet you converted?
00:18:08 He says, absolutely.
00:18:09 I realize that any organization that could be run by people like that this long
00:18:14 and still survive had to be divine.
00:18:17 Well, actually, there's an echo of that at the moment,
00:18:20 in the past 10, 20 years,
00:18:24 in the various sexual scandals
00:18:25 that have gone on in the church.
00:18:27 You know, again, there is this sense,
00:18:29 I think, that Francis was kind of
00:18:31 going to be a new pair of hands on this.
00:18:33 It's not worked out that way, has it?
00:18:34 It's the opposite.
00:18:36 He's been, I mean, and again,
00:18:39 I can't say why,
00:18:40 I can't pretend to read his mind,
00:18:42 but he's surrounded himself
00:18:43 with some of the most bizarre criminals
00:18:47 and pervs you can imagine.
00:18:48 and nobody says anything
00:18:51 because the press love him, you know.
00:18:54 But every time you turn around,
00:18:57 somebody is close to him
00:18:58 as being indicted for something.
00:19:02 And people, again,
00:19:03 don't realize how effective
00:19:05 Benedict had been
00:19:06 in bringing the thing to bay.
00:19:10 And mind you, I say this is one
00:19:11 who was writing about the scandals
00:19:13 when no one else was back in the 80s.
00:19:16 I was quite aware of them.
00:19:17 Well, I mean, I was aware of them growing up.
00:19:19 But you see, in those days,
00:19:21 and I'm speaking specifically of the American situation,
00:19:25 but I wouldn't be surprised if it was married elsewhere,
00:19:26 one of the reasons why nobody talked about it in the press
00:19:31 was that, how do I put this nicely?
00:19:36 So many of the major either offenders or enablers
00:19:39 were darlings of the press.
00:19:42 The Archbishop of Milwaukee, Rembrandt Weakland, for instance,
00:19:45 This man was, I remember when the scandals broke,
00:19:50 he wrote in his diocesan paper that many priests were being seduced
00:19:56 by streetwise and sexually aggressive altar boys.
00:20:00 And other than giving me the vision of this priest going into a bar
00:20:03 filled with altar boys sitting around,
00:20:05 Hey, Father, you want a drink?
00:20:07 I just came in to get out of the rain.
00:20:09 Of course you did, Father. We all do.
00:20:12 Yeah, okay.
00:20:13 Apart from that, Weakland was just horrendous in every sense.
00:20:20 However, they loved him in the press because he always said what they wanted to hear.
00:20:25 So what happens?
00:20:26 His former lover comes out of retirement to demand money very publicly
00:20:34 about four months before he's supposed to resign anyway, retire.
00:20:38 And there's a big hullabaloo and things jump up and down.
00:20:41 Well, the Los Angeles Times, that great beacon of something or other,
00:20:46 they reported it because they'd always loved Weakland.
00:20:51 They called it, how do they describe it?
00:20:55 Robert Weakland was a man who tried to move his church's sexual views
00:21:01 into the 20th century, but fell victim to his own moral complexity.
00:21:07 Oh, right.
00:21:08 And I thought, you know, the next time I go to confession,
00:21:10 I'm going to say, bless me, Father, for I've been morally complex.
00:21:14 That's great.
00:21:16 Okay.
00:21:18 Where's Francis again, Francis II?
00:21:20 He's taken various positions.
00:21:21 Obviously, you're an American.
00:21:24 Although, actually, I should mention as well that you have Canadian-French heritage, do you not, Charles?
00:21:28 Indeed.
00:21:29 But you're an American.
00:21:31 He's been, he's given veiled, isn't it, veiled criticism of Trump, for example.
00:21:37 He said about, we don't build wars, do we?
00:21:39 We're not in the business of building walls.
00:21:42 That's not what the church is about.
00:21:44 So, I mean, obviously that's the criticism of Trump, isn't it?
00:21:47 Who's to say?
00:21:48 I mean, one of the things he loves doing is giving these oracular pronouncements
00:21:53 that could mean this or not.
00:21:56 In an interview he did with La Nacion in Buenos Aires,
00:21:59 he made a comment.
00:22:01 He said that God has given me the gift of unawareness.
00:22:06 And I read that and I thought, well, he did the same thing for me,
00:22:08 but I try to hide it so people don't quite
00:22:11 catch on
00:22:11 I think he likes being opaque
00:22:15 now I'm sure he doesn't
00:22:17 like Trump because he's very much like him
00:22:19 he's very much like Blair
00:22:20 interesting point
00:22:22 you know
00:22:24 they're going to do things their way
00:22:26 and if you don't like it, my way or the highway
00:22:29 pal, regardless of anything else
00:22:31 now
00:22:32 this is not
00:22:34 a comparison of the relative merits
00:22:36 of Blair or Trump or the Pope,
00:22:39 but it's a generational thing.
00:22:42 You know, it's all about me.
00:22:44 I'm wonderful, love me.
00:22:46 You know, no.
00:22:48 Your office I respect,
00:22:49 your office I may have to follow,
00:22:51 but please, don't pretend
00:22:53 you have any importance other than that.
00:22:54 I mean, it's one reason I think
00:22:56 that the Holy Father decided to live
00:22:57 in the Hotel Santa Marta
00:22:59 rather than the Apostolic Palace
00:23:01 because the palace,
00:23:04 I mean, the Hotel Santa Marta
00:23:05 is all about him.
00:23:07 But the Apostolic Palace, you walk around and you hear the wall saying,
00:23:11 Oh, hello, little holy father.
00:23:13 It's wonderful to see you.
00:23:15 You know, soon you're going to be just like Leo XI.
00:23:18 Oh, you don't remember him.
00:23:20 No, neither does anyone else.
00:23:22 And they won't remember you.
00:23:24 Well, who wants to hear that, especially if you have a generation based upon self?
00:23:29 And again, I'm drawing with a very wide brush.
00:23:31 but you look at these characters
00:23:34 place after place
00:23:36 time after time
00:23:37 your comparison with Blair was spot on
00:23:39 I mean imagine a man
00:23:41 who comes riding into Downing Street
00:23:43 and he's going to get rid of the Lord Chancellor
00:23:45 and he's going to change the House of Lords
00:23:47 and he's going to have cool Britannia
00:23:49 full Britannia maybe
00:23:51 I think the thing is
00:23:53 this leads us in a beautiful segue
00:23:56 into something else that's happened
00:23:57 but it would be fantastic to hear your perspective
00:24:00 on this Charles
00:24:01 You're talking about self versus institution.
00:24:03 Yeah.
00:24:04 We've just had a situation, obviously, as you know,
00:24:06 where Prince Harry and Meghan Markle have moved to Canada.
00:24:13 You could say that this is a case of basically self-growth
00:24:16 and the need to be true to oneself has sort of overcome
00:24:20 what was called duty, maybe, if you like,
00:24:24 or a belief in the institution.
00:24:26 Do you see it in that way?
00:24:28 And I mean, where do you see them going in Canada?
00:24:34 Not far.
00:24:35 Not far.
00:24:36 I mean, look, Megan Markle and I have something in common.
00:24:41 We were taught by the same nuns.
00:24:43 Right.
00:24:44 And they were crazy.
00:24:45 I mean that in a bad way.
00:24:47 Crazy as in...
00:24:49 And I'm not saying that simply out of anecdotal thing.
00:24:54 They were mad.
00:24:55 They were absolutely mad.
00:24:58 and she became an actress and you speak of woke well the best comparison of the two of them that
00:25:08 i can come up with is actually believe it or not brad pitt and angelina jolie now brad pitt
00:25:13 way back when he did a film called seven years in tibet oh i remember remember that
00:25:18 seven years seven years in the cinema that's that's for sure well i mean it's not by any of
00:25:23 a good time. But in those days, any actor that had anything to do with Tibet, from actually
00:25:29 going there to watching a couple of tapes of the Dalai Lama, was considered to be brilliant
00:25:34 and have all sorts of important insights. So he's being interviewed. He won my respect
00:25:41 that day. He's being interviewed, and the lady says, well, now that you've done this
00:25:45 film about Tibet, do you have any deep spiritual or political insights to share? And he looks
00:25:51 that and says, man, I'm an actor. All I know is acting. I have political and religious views,
00:25:58 but they're not really very important because I don't know a lot. And I sat there. I was like,
00:26:04 yeah, Brad, you show him. Well, what happens? He takes up with Angelina Jolie, who never saw a
00:26:10 crazy cause she couldn't get behind. And he embraces the whole thing. So, with Titus Mutandis,
00:26:18 I looked at Prince Harry, who, prior to taking up with her,
00:26:24 seemed like a fairly decent fellow, a bit harum-scarum, as we say,
00:26:28 but, you know, amiable, willing to do his bit.
00:26:33 I mean, you wouldn't expect him to be a nuclear physicist,
00:26:37 but for what he was, he was fine.
00:26:40 Then she comes along, and suddenly he's embracing everything mad that she embraces.
00:26:46 now there is I think
00:26:48 and again this is just me thinking
00:26:50 and I don't claim any infallibility
00:26:52 but my parents are actors and I've grown up
00:26:54 around the industry my whole life
00:26:56 a lot of actors suffer from
00:27:00 a feeling of unimportance
00:27:02 of irrelevance
00:27:03 you know
00:27:04 I get paid money for doing what
00:27:08 and unfortunately
00:27:10 and I say unfortunately because I happen to feel that
00:27:12 acting craft
00:27:14 is a very important one
00:27:15 and a worthwhile one, and there should be no reason to think that way.
00:27:20 But they do, some of them.
00:27:22 And so what do they do?
00:27:23 They try to fill up with their need to feel useful or relevant or whatever
00:27:29 with these crusades.
00:27:32 And they do.
00:27:35 But again, because their backgrounds, even as Brad Pitt said in the long ago,
00:27:40 usually don't lend them to having useful opinions.
00:27:44 they're taken for a ride by anything that comes along
00:27:47 and because of their visibility
00:27:51 their views get a respectability they wouldn't have
00:27:54 if you heard them from the waitress in the cafe
00:27:56 so she gets him on this particular gravy train
00:28:00 and I am
00:28:02 as to what will happen
00:28:04 I'm not surprised at what did happen frankly
00:28:06 my suspicion is that it won't last
00:28:11 and that he'll end up coming back
00:28:13 I hope for their children's sake
00:28:17 he comes back with the kids in tow
00:28:18 the thing is Charles with this
00:28:20 this really does
00:28:22 sort of bleed into what we're saying
00:28:25 really that when
00:28:27 Meghan Markle talks about you know compassion
00:28:29 and wanting to be involved in all of these things
00:28:30 it looks fine but you sort of
00:28:33 you can't help thinking
00:28:34 why just you
00:28:37 you know it's like
00:28:39 the implication is that I'm not compassionate
00:28:40 or that I need to be told
00:28:42 This is the thing that actually, I think, gets under people's skin.
00:28:46 And with good reason.
00:28:47 I mean, the fact of the matter is she went into a system,
00:28:54 into a situation that is what it is, all right?
00:28:59 If you don't like that, you shouldn't go into it.
00:29:02 And she knew what she was getting into.
00:29:04 I mean, she's not stupid.
00:29:05 She may be a little nuts, but she's not stupid.
00:29:09 And to go into a system like that and say,
00:29:11 I'm gonna change it which again is a pattern we see over and over and over
00:29:15 again it's wrong if you don't like it don't do it honestly and you'll never
00:29:25 hear this from anyone else but frankly I think that if Wallace Simpson had been
00:29:31 made princess consort for Edward the eighth I think she would have done a
00:29:35 much better job than this one yeah because she admired the system I mean
00:29:40 She had her problems. I'm not saying she was a great one, but she admired the system
00:29:45 She wanted to be a part of it, and she probably would have done
00:29:49 You know
00:29:51 So she would have been the Queen mother that's for sure but she would have done as decent a job as she could I
00:29:57 think this lady from the very beginning
00:29:59 wanted to do what she wanted to do and
00:30:02 What I heard when I heard that she'd forbidden her husband from hunting, you know, which is
00:30:08 Royals hunt you don't like it well you know what boxers box so don't go to the
00:30:15 boxing match then when the when they named their son Archie really how about
00:30:24 Bobo or bubbles Tiffany why not Tiffany because what's the next thing they are
00:30:30 not directly but from their friends now they're gonna arrange the raid raise the
00:30:34 get gender neutral no it is incredibly sort of it just it just really as I say
00:30:42 gets under people's skin did get under people's skin he was hugely popular
00:30:46 before actually him but it's a very interesting point you are a great
00:30:53 promoter of the idea of monarchy I don't just mean the British money I mean
00:30:56 monarchy in the abstract and you in fact you go further than that you believe
00:31:01 for an absolute monarchy aren't you and and well proper monarchy is what you
00:31:05 would maybe call it yes let me let me make a point here absolute monarchy in
00:31:10 the sense that people think of it doesn't exist right we live in an absolute
00:31:14 state where our masters can alter the nature of humanity they can alter the
00:31:20 nature of marriage henry the eighth couldn't do that he had to go through
00:31:24 all sorts of hoops to pretend what he was doing was legal but he had to
00:31:27 pretend somehow to abide by the law but our lords and masters in the judiciary
00:31:32 and the legislatures across the West they do whatever they want and will
00:31:35 bark like dogs and they tell us so immediately when you say monarchy
00:31:40 people begin to oh we'll stop you've already accepted a government wilder
00:31:45 than any monarch had ever had so that's the first thing we have to bear in mind
00:31:49 having said that my ideal is not really what we're called the absolute monarchies
00:31:57 of the 17th and 18th centuries,
00:32:01 because in a real sense,
00:32:02 it did pave the way for the revolutions that followed
00:32:04 through centralizing, through creating
00:32:06 what has become the modern state apparatus.
00:32:10 And eventually that modern state realized
00:32:11 it didn't need them anymore, and poof, off they went.
00:32:14 Or they got tamed as, well, the Netherlands.
00:32:19 Anyway.
00:32:20 But I would say that, you know, whether, you know,
00:32:23 okay, monarchy and obviously traditional Catholic,
00:32:27 These things might have marked you.
00:32:29 I mean, you have really, in some ways, ploughed a lonely far in choosing these things.
00:32:35 I mean, if you grew up in Los Angeles, I wonder how those passions, if you like, were founded for you.
00:32:48 I mean, how did they come about?
00:32:50 They're not immediate ones for an American teenager.
00:32:53 That is a fair question.
00:32:55 I think part of it, well, there were two things.
00:32:59 One, my family, not in the sense that they were monarchists,
00:33:03 but they were certainly very traditional Catholics.
00:33:06 They didn't have the prejudice against monarchy that many Americans have.
00:33:12 My dad, being French-Canadian, was very much aware that the House of Bourbon sent us to Canada.
00:33:18 And he had a good bit of Scots blood, and so he was something of a Jacobite supporter.
00:33:23 My mother was very fond of the Habsburgs and the Romanovs.
00:33:28 So, and of course, disliking the French Revolution intensely
00:33:34 is part of the old French-Canadian ethos.
00:33:37 So those things were all dancing around.
00:33:41 And there were other things.
00:33:41 My mother's, the English side of my mother's family were loyal.
00:33:47 Having said all of that, I could see in the world around me,
00:33:51 the world of the 60s and 70s how the opposite principles had triumphed and what they had
00:33:58 produced it's as simple as that you know if you look at what the commentators shall we say and
00:34:07 these are the french revolution or whatever you like what the the conclusions they drew
00:34:12 we have incarnated we are nasty and we are cruel we're bloodthirsty we have no no real care for
00:34:21 customer human life we're all about ourselves and that's exactly what was
00:34:26 predicted would happen thank you very very much for coming in Charles thank
00:34:30 you very much that's it for so what you're saying is this week and we'll
00:34:34 see you next time thank you for watching and do subscribe please thank you