New Culture Forum - March 12, 2020


Counterculture 1.07: Does Conservatism Have a Future?

2.19 Charles Coulombe: A Conservative Author Examines the Culture Wars in Trad. Institutions 2.20 Darren Grimes: I fought the liberal elite and won

Episode Stats


Length

49 minutes

Words per minute

184.84

Word count

9,153

Sentence count

209


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 hello and welcome to counterculture I'm Peter Whittle now there's an old saying you might have
00:00:13 heard which is that if you're a young person and you are not left-wing or liberal then you have
00:00:18 no heart but if you get to 35 and you're still left and liberal and you have no head what that
00:00:25 really means is that in Britain at the moment we seem to have a lot of young people who are just
00:00:29 all heart because there was a survey done just after the last general election in December
00:00:35 which showed that if only 18 to 24 year olds were voting then basically Jeremy Corbyn would have had
00:00:43 a majority of over 500 seats and indeed Boris Johnson would have been left with something like
00:00:49 four seats so that shows you a massive divide. What does this actually mean? Are young people
00:00:55 more left-wing than they've ever been if so what is the outlook for conservatism right-wing politics
00:01:03 going into the future is it a bleak outlook now i've got four great guests to talk about this
00:01:08 today first of all we have dominique samuels dominique used to be of turning point uk she's
00:01:14 now president of a new group called the orthodox conservatives we have jake scott who is indeed
00:01:21 head of philosophy and ideology for the new conservative orthodox and also emily hewitson
00:01:29 who you might remember made a real splash last year when she was on question time in the origins
00:01:34 has since become a bit of a social media star she is a member of the conservative party she briefly
00:01:40 went to the brexit party or voted for the brexit party she's now back with the conservative party
00:01:44 and the NCF's resident guest, historian,
00:01:49 incommodator and old Conservative, Rafe Hadel-Mancou.
00:01:53 Not quite as old as me, but anyway.
00:01:55 Thank you very much for coming.
00:01:56 I want to start by asking you a very fundamental question.
00:02:00 If someone says to you, are you right-wing,
00:02:05 what is your reaction, Dominique?
00:02:08 I'd just say yeah.
00:02:09 Yeah?
00:02:09 Yeah, basically.
00:02:10 I think that maybe when I was a bit younger and like getting more into conservatism and what it kind of meant for me
00:02:18 I think I'd be kind of hesitant to say whether or not I was
00:02:22 because being right-wing is often associated with negative attributes such as, you know, racism, xenophobia, homophobia
00:02:29 all of those phobias
00:02:32 but now I think it's important to just be honest with people
00:02:36 and not let other people kind of control your narrative for you
00:02:40 so if I'm asked I'll just say yeah yeah so you don't recall from it what about
00:02:44 you I'd say yes I'm a proud right winger and I think it's important that other
00:02:48 young people have that kind of pride I mean the amount of young people that I
00:02:52 have in my DMs saying that they are a conservative but they're just too scared
00:02:56 to say it and I think it's so important that people like us are given a platform
00:03:00 to say yes I am a young person and I'm right wing and I'm proud of it and so
00:03:04 should you be so basically right so but you use right wing and conservative interchangeably there
00:03:10 do you think there's a difference or my answer's changed i'd say over the last few years right when
00:03:17 people used to ask me if i was right wing i was very much the same um now i think my answer is is
00:03:23 a question in return which is what do you mean by right wing um mostly because as dominique's
00:03:29 pointed out there's this old stigma surrounding it of racism xenophobia homophobia which probably
00:03:36 is there still an element of or residual but i think the other point is that i'm probably right
00:03:43 wing on a lot of issues and probably left wing on a few um economically i'd say i'm i'm probably
00:03:49 less right wing than a lot of my peers i don't know if i'm necessarily on the left yeah but my
00:03:55 The attitude towards capitalism and markets has become very sceptical and very cautious.
00:04:02 I believe that if you look at the history of capitalism in the UK, it's gone from being
00:04:07 something of a resistance to feudalism and a resistance to mercantilism to one of corrosiveness,
00:04:15 especially following the neoliberal revolution of the 1980s.
00:04:18 Right, I see, it's interesting, because you're quite frank about it, you know, Dominique, you're saying you're right wing, Emily, but it seems to me that generally culturally, this has become a term that people will do anything but identify themselves by, wouldn't you say, Ralph?
00:04:38 That's right. Just right wing.
00:04:40 The great victory of the last 20 years has been the ability of the left
00:04:44 to stigmatise anyone who called themselves right wing as being beyond the pale,
00:04:48 whereas the left wing was to essentially be a person who's concerned with society,
00:04:52 despite the fact that high Toryism is all about conserving society,
00:04:57 conserving all levels of society, looking out for people,
00:04:59 noblesse oblige if you want to look at it from the traditional sense,
00:05:03 in the old Tory sense.
00:05:04 But certainly the new generation of conservatives we're seeing in the Generation Z, those born after 1996, are conservative when it comes to values.
00:05:14 And in terms of their economic conservatism, it's about personal responsibility, in terms of their sexual lives as well.
00:05:19 So it's not so much a party political affiliation as much more a concern for looking after themselves and for the planet.
00:05:25 There are a lot of woke issues where they are actually also still very left wing.
00:05:29 so the conservatives of the future are going to be economically more liberal more liberal on a lot
00:05:35 of work issues whereas a lot of the intrinsic values are going to be conservative but you see
00:05:40 okay i can see that that's quite a i said that's quite an optimistic analysis therefore you know
00:05:45 but then when you look at the survey i quoted like 500 seat majority how come i mean you know
00:05:53 What about your friends? I mean, are you unusual?
00:05:57 I'd say I am, generally. I mean, a lot of my friends do vote Labour or vote Green Party.
00:06:03 Why do they vote for them? Why?
00:06:05 I think that how they see society is that fundamentally our services need investment,
00:06:13 and they see the Conservative Party as being intrinsically against that kind of issue,
00:06:18 and that's just not the case. I think a lot of it comes from marketing.
00:06:21 obviously social media is a massive thing for young people and if you go onto twitter a lot of
00:06:27 the posts that get hundreds of impressions are from left-wingers they have got really good the
00:06:33 social media trend we saw it a bit more with boris this time he's starting to kind of pick up on that
00:06:38 on that lead but i think when you see on twitter i mean on election day i think the three top
00:06:44 trends were basically around hashtag vote labor and it's very easy to kind of jump on that bandwagon
00:06:50 and join in, because you don't want to be an outsider
00:06:52 at the end of the day, and I think social media
00:06:54 has a massive part to play in that.
00:06:56 Do you think so? I mean, social media?
00:06:58 I think social media is important, but just like
00:07:01 with regards to why
00:07:02 young people seem to veer
00:07:04 more to the left, I'd say it's
00:07:07 like what Emily said about
00:07:09 the kind of economics that the Tories pursue
00:07:11 when it comes to public services,
00:07:14 and also the fact that
00:07:15 there is still a lot of
00:07:17 stigma attached with being conservative
00:07:19 and social issues with regards to racism with regards to homophobia and all of those kinds of
00:07:25 things and i think that i don't think the conservatives have made that much of an effort
00:07:31 to kind of appeal to the groups that labor targets and i think that we could target those culturally
00:07:39 conservative ethnic minority communities for example which i don't think we've done because
00:07:45 we just think that, you know, they're lost to Labour forever.
00:07:48 And I just personally don't think that's the case.
00:07:51 Dominic's absolutely correct here.
00:07:52 And I'm a bit worried about the complacency that may set in with the Tory party
00:07:56 winning such a large majority, because they do need to remember
00:07:59 that coming up is a huge demographic, a very large demographic.
00:08:03 Generation Z is going to be a very large demographic
00:08:05 and future trends are going with each subsequent generation
00:08:09 of being completely alienated from the Conservative Party.
00:08:12 And it's basically, that's why I've said in previous episodes,
00:08:15 there needs to be a reverse of this long march to institutions because the department of education
00:08:19 the university situation we have both in secondary schools and in higher education is so dominated
00:08:26 by the left now it's gone in 20 years from having a majority of two liberals for every one conservative
00:08:31 to having an eight or nine majority for every liberal to conservative that it's completely
00:08:37 impossible now to have a balanced view of conservative and right-wing politics or right-wing
00:08:42 ideology within an academic setting and so that's why you're seeing the rise of the environment and
00:08:48 racism and homophobia as being seen in an era when actually homophobia and racism are at the
00:08:53 lowest levels ever they're being they're being seen to be the most you know acute problems in
00:08:59 the country and that's because of the ideology that's being fermented within the education
00:09:04 system you're all at college aren't you you're at york you're at birmingham and you're at king's
00:09:08 in London, aren't you? I mean, what is it like, I mean, do you feel this in the university
00:09:14 campuses? You know, we've covered on the programmes, you know, about the incredible restriction
00:09:19 that there is increasingly. I went to a very left-wing university, Kent, back in the 1980s,
00:09:25 and, you know, it was very left-wing. I mean, you got up as a Tory, as I then was, and you,
00:09:29 and, you know, you took your life in your hands a bit, but, I mean, it seems to be more acute now,
00:09:35 wouldn't you say? I think
00:09:37 you're right, there's certainly
00:09:39 an almost recoiling
00:09:42 moment when you say that you're a conservative
00:09:44 in class, when I was an undergraduate
00:09:45 You say it in class though, you do say it
00:09:47 I never, as Dominique
00:09:49 and as Emily
00:09:52 both rightly say, you should not be ashamed
00:09:54 of it, and I do, I was quite
00:09:55 strident in saying it, and there
00:09:58 is this moment of almost
00:09:59 as Rafe says, beyond the pale
00:10:01 how could you be?
00:10:02 and I think it largely comes down to
00:10:05 like Dominique said, there's the stigma
00:10:06 but I also think there's a caricature
00:10:08 one of the enduring quotes of Lenin
00:10:11 is that fascism is capitalism and decay
00:10:13 which in itself is an awful
00:10:15 diagnosis of what capitalism actually is
00:10:17 but the other side of it
00:10:19 is that I think capitalism has dominated
00:10:21 the Conservative Party for so long now
00:10:22 that there are certain things we see
00:10:25 as inherently right wing
00:10:27 that aren't necessarily right wing
00:10:29 like disregard for ecology
00:10:31 and the environment and these sorts of things.
00:10:34 So to return to the question of university,
00:10:36 when I was an undergraduate, when I was in class,
00:10:37 I was very strident and said, yes, I am.
00:10:40 And now when I teach, because I'm a doctoral researcher,
00:10:43 I introduce myself at the start and say, I am a conservative,
00:10:46 and I'm a conservative of the Scrutonian tradition
00:10:48 and the Burkean tradition.
00:10:50 And I have a few students come up to me at the end of the class
00:10:52 and say, I'm really glad that you said that.
00:10:54 See, the thing is, when I listen to you,
00:10:58 and also after what Ray just said
00:11:01 I can't have a feeling
00:11:02 you've slipped through the net
00:11:04 by being conservative
00:11:06 I mean the fact is
00:11:08 I think Ray pointed it out
00:11:10 when you talk about homophobia
00:11:12 that was never a reason
00:11:14 not to be a conservative
00:11:15 those weren't the problems with being conservative
00:11:18 I think it was about that you were considered
00:11:20 authoritarian for example
00:11:22 you were considered like you liked the queen
00:11:24 and the army and that was what made you
00:11:27 conservative, these things though
00:11:28 isn't this surely about what people
00:11:31 I was about to say, you know, like your age
00:11:33 have been taught all the way along
00:11:34 isn't this the point, from school onwards
00:11:37 Personally I massively agree
00:11:39 like I say, this caricature
00:11:41 of the right, in my opinion
00:11:42 I studied history and politics when I was
00:11:45 at secondary school in sixth form
00:11:46 and when you discuss history
00:11:48 anyone who's mildly considered
00:11:51 evil is implied to be
00:11:53 on the right, regardless
00:11:54 and it's not the other way around it's not that if they're on the right they're evil it's that if
00:11:57 they're evil they're on the right and I just wanted to say for example I remember I think I
00:12:02 was about 14 in my English class I don't know what this has to do with English but it was just after
00:12:09 UKIP had won the European elections I think in 2014 and we were actually shown the different
00:12:15 political broadcasts of UKIP and Labour and our teacher stood there and dictated how UKIP was
00:12:22 racist party and she can't believe that the UK has become so racist it would vote for them and
00:12:27 then she contrasted it with Labour being this you know lovely warm welcoming inclusive party
00:12:33 and I remember that so distinctly and looking back I was absolutely shocked if I knew what I
00:12:39 knew now I wish that I kind of stood up to that and kind of challenged that because I don't really
00:12:44 think there's a place for that in the classroom. So you were 14? Yes I was 14. To me that's
00:12:48 outright indoctrination yeah outright indoctrination I mean if you ever had
00:12:52 anything like that happen me personally when I went to college and it was
00:12:56 dominated by left-wing students and my teacher was admittedly left-wing but
00:13:02 when we were actually learning about philosophical conservatism which is
00:13:06 what brought me to the conservative party eventually she actually got a one
00:13:10 nation conservative teacher that was in the college and worked in the politics
00:13:15 department to actually teach us it so it wasn't biased and it was actually her teaching which
00:13:20 was you know she didn't present the ideas in a biased way that actually got me interested
00:13:24 in conservatism but there was an incident at university actually I worked as a student
00:13:29 ambassador for first year and we were with all of these students that were in college
00:13:34 and Brexit came up and there was a PhD student who was you know doing the presentation and Brexit
00:13:40 it came up and he was basically presenting all of these doomsday forecasts to all of these kids
00:13:46 that don't know any better and it really annoyed me to be honest and I actually started debating
00:13:51 with him like actually this but this and people came up to me afterwards and they were actually
00:13:56 really grateful for it because if I didn't say something they would have had the idea that the
00:14:01 UK is going to run out of food and everyone's going to be starving and it's going to be a
00:14:04 virtual apocalypse if we dare to leave the European Union so yeah I've experienced that before
00:14:10 I think it's more prevalent in university
00:14:12 because there's a lot more freedom for lecturers
00:14:15 and people that are responsible for educating people
00:14:17 to kind of reveal their views more so.
00:14:20 There's always been a left-wing bias.
00:14:21 I mean, I was at university for nine years in total,
00:14:24 so I saw this transformation through the 90s.
00:14:26 1992, I was 14, and I was one of the first
00:14:29 to jump onto the Leave the EU Brigade, along with Nigel.
00:14:32 And as a 14-year-old, I began my role,
00:14:35 commentating in career at 19,
00:14:36 advocating for the monarchy during the Annus Horribilis period.
00:14:40 and you know i was you know far beyond the pale as a monarchist brexiteer in the 90s so and it's
00:14:46 quite appealing actually in a way to be contrarian like that but in those days you could study
00:14:51 military history diplomatic history universities all those courses are gone now because you have
00:14:55 superstar historians like now ferguson who was unable to get tenure at any university he has to
00:15:00 be employed by a think tank the hoover institution in america because universities weren't taken
00:15:05 because he wrote a book saying that the british empire wasn't all bad you know there was good
00:15:08 side of the British Empire as well as a less good side and yet these superstar
00:15:12 historians cannot get a higher despite being mainstream by the standards of the
00:15:16 90 today they're deemed to be far too extreme yeah it is it is quite
00:15:21 extraordinary what's happened in that way I think I everything has I think
00:15:24 compressed and become far more constricted
00:15:29 Rafe talked about generation Zed right so does that do you would you call
00:15:36 yourself Generation Z? I mean, what is even Generation Z? Technically I am, but I just
00:15:41 feel that there's a lot of connotations that come with Generation Z. What is it? I think
00:15:46 it's a very woke culture. I'd argue that, you know, yeah, there's a certain wokeness
00:15:53 that kind of surrounds the label. So technically I am Generation Z, but I'm not sure I really
00:15:58 like what you called it. But I thought it was millennials who were the most woke. I don't
00:16:03 know when the the gen z generation starts me rave said 96 i've heard 90 i'm born in 95 so i don't
00:16:10 know where this leaves me i think it's 2000 of the years that i've heard most quoted right okay
00:16:15 so basically as generation z you would be being taught by millennials is that right to say yes
00:16:23 actually i think that's true because teachers are becoming younger and younger they're going
00:16:27 from being maybe like 30 to 40 to being fresh graduates because you see what i've heard as
00:16:32 well is that and this is anecdotal right is that the like generation zed or 1920
00:16:38 years are rebelling against the huge wokeness of the ones just above does
00:16:44 that resonate with you do you think that's true there are some inklings of
00:16:48 that there's like this it's more prevalent in America though I think
00:16:52 there are some like kind of fringe ones that call themselves zoomers and they're
00:16:58 like zoomers and they're like very very kind of like fringe on the right and
00:17:05 they like completely rejects the kind of hegemony of like ideology that we see
00:17:11 right now when it comes to you know the woke generation and kind of the
00:17:15 millennial generation I don't know I don't if I identify with it I just call
00:17:20 myself I think one of the big things you're seeing basically is generation
00:17:25 zed and millennials do share the same woke ideology as a whole so it's not no surprise
00:17:30 because they're being taught by the same and the success of the left has been to get themselves
00:17:33 onto the administration departments onto onto the onto the administration of universities into the
00:17:39 chancellor's office but also onto committees the hiring now the committees within universities
00:17:45 departments to do the hiring so they've been very effective and so over the next 10 years we have
00:17:49 10 years of tory government there needs to be a move to shift the things back on onto a more even
00:17:55 keel no one's asking for a tory majority but just to have a natural balance i mean professor
00:17:59 jonathan height who has written about this and said that you know all societies need to have
00:18:04 an equal balance of opinion that's what people want to have how do we go about like implementing
00:18:09 that though you know that was going to be my last question today you put no no no you brought it up
00:18:14 no how do we actually yes how do we do how do we get to that point i wonder you know it's a very
00:18:19 important point if you want to try to adjust the balance balance how have you got any answers for
00:18:26 this how would you do it i think practically i think it's by making all day all ideologies very
00:18:32 broad church um so i guess it's just about accepting different viewpoints within the
00:18:39 same ideology and not not focusing too much on labels it is a hard one because uh in when you
00:18:45 put it in practice it's uh like gaining that balance is tricky but i guess the easiest way
00:18:52 is just open debate tolerance all of those big issues but it is it's going to be tricky it's not
00:18:58 going to be an easy feat it's not but you see but when you talk about like committees and
00:19:02 people coming in i think you're talking about basically getting people who are going to have
00:19:07 about there's be more of a political balance on these very things is that not right yeah i think
00:19:13 that the government could play a role especially as soon as we do have a
00:19:17 conservative government right now that has a sizable majority there should be
00:19:20 way more focus on the suppression of free speech at universities you know
00:19:25 when it comes to the things that university lecturers do the kind of
00:19:29 ideas that they push on to students I do think that there needs to be a bit more
00:19:34 of a crackdown specifically when it comes to banning certain speakers that
00:19:39 you don't like from campuses or you know banning certain academics that you don't
00:19:43 like I do think that the government needs to say to these universities you
00:19:47 either facilitate free speech and facilitate a diversity of ideas or the
00:19:53 certain things that you receive from us that you will get no longer and you know
00:19:57 in these Mickey Mouse courses gender studies women's studies which were
00:20:01 created by in the 60s you know there was a desire to create these departments and
00:20:06 and they were created by female faculty
00:20:09 who were brought over essentially from departments of English
00:20:11 because there weren't that many female faculty in universities,
00:20:14 so there was no science component to these,
00:20:16 there was no biologists brought over,
00:20:18 and so you have these theories with no actual evidence
00:20:22 sustaining the arguments put forward by these departments,
00:20:25 and so the government just needs to say,
00:20:27 look, unless you up your game
00:20:28 and you actually have proper peer review
00:20:30 by recommending and recognising authorities
00:20:33 and departments of psychology and
00:20:35 genetics and so forth, we're going to
00:20:37 defund you. There needs to be wide-scale defunding
00:20:39 of all of these Mickey Mouse courses
00:20:41 and that's where I think you'll hopefully get
00:20:43 some redress of this if they don't
00:20:45 change. No one's doing a
00:20:47 Mickey Mouse course here, are there?
00:20:49 I think I am.
00:20:51 I don't
00:20:54 necessarily disagree, but I would
00:20:55 be cautious over
00:20:57 any
00:20:58 zealous overpowering
00:21:01 of the state in that
00:21:03 there's always got to be some concern for what if the people we don't agree with come into power
00:21:10 um i don't necessarily disagree as i say i think that there's got to be a certain degree of
00:21:14 oversight and maybe that needs to be done now but the issue i've always found with any of these
00:21:19 measures is that it's very easy for this to then go the other way and i think that's what we need
00:21:24 to be concerned with it's it's it's it's fine for us to sit here and say we're looking at 10 years
00:21:28 of a Tory majority, but what if that didn't
00:21:29 happen? What if the 2024
00:21:32 election was a huge
00:21:33 upset? Well we should be calling
00:21:36 for balance in the departments of history
00:21:38 and politics and sociology and so forth
00:21:39 balance there, but in terms of these other
00:21:41 courses, gender studies and women
00:21:43 there needs to be actual scientific
00:21:46 rigour applied
00:21:47 to these courses and
00:21:49 theories need to be called out when
00:21:51 the evidence doesn't support the theories because
00:21:53 you get the BBC and others touting
00:21:56 this evidence as being
00:21:57 peer-reviewed scientific quality evidence
00:22:00 when it's clearly not?
00:22:01 If I may, speaking as someone
00:22:04 who's in academia and wrestling with this
00:22:06 movement towards the Teaching Excellence
00:22:08 Framework and the Research
00:22:10 Excellence Framework, the TEF and the REF
00:22:11 was an idea to reintroduce
00:22:14 this rigour into publication
00:22:16 but what it's
00:22:18 done is the counter, it's
00:22:20 forced this rush of publications
00:22:21 this publish or perish attitude
00:22:23 that was there in the 80s and 90s and has
00:22:26 just accentuated itself now so rather than actual good research you just get this this avalanche of
00:22:33 of tosh and just for the sake of it so it does the opposite of what it's intended to do and you've
00:22:38 got the huge scandal that recently when you had three of three academics bogosian lindsey and
00:22:43 another person who essentially fabricated as a test fabricated all the evidence and published
00:22:49 completely satirical articles about you know lesbianism in dogs i think was one of one of the
00:22:54 one of the articles they fabricated all the evidence and a number of these articles got
00:22:58 published by the leading journals in these fields because there was absolutely no peer review that
00:23:03 was done and people were just willingly you know confirmation bias on their part and then they
00:23:08 were exposed as being fraudulent articles and yet they've been cited by other experts in these
00:23:12 fields but they're just going to show what these courses are really like but don't underestimate
00:23:16 to the the the part that money plays you know funding you know that you actually if you want
00:23:21 to get your various thesis done and everything you if you just take a few
00:23:24 things I'll be looking at this when in a diverse you know sort of framework you
00:23:29 get the money or whatever okay you said your you don't mind being called right
00:23:34 wing conservative right wing but what what does that mean actually what does
00:23:42 it mean are we on the same page or not now I know that you know you've been a
00:23:47 a member of the Conservative Party, haven't you, since you were 16?
00:23:50 Yes, since I was 16.
00:23:51 But you have started this new group called the Orthodox Conservatives,
00:23:55 as I mentioned.
00:23:56 You've got 10 tenants, which people can see on your website
00:23:59 if they go to it.
00:24:01 I would broadly say, if you don't mind,
00:24:04 that they are more cultural ones than economic, right?
00:24:08 So, for example, you say that family is terribly important
00:24:14 and nation and things.
00:24:16 I mean how does that sort of
00:24:18 first of all how does that
00:24:20 go down with your peers
00:24:23 as it was
00:24:24 we were jumped on
00:24:27 almost immediately
00:24:28 for saying that we supported the family
00:24:31 I mean you received a hell of a lot
00:24:33 of abuse
00:24:33 they were like oh I come from a single
00:24:37 parent household
00:24:38 I come from a single parent household
00:24:40 you demonise single parents
00:24:43 you demonise single mothers
00:24:44 I was raised by a single mother who's absolutely amazing what we're saying is that it's desirable
00:24:50 to be raised by two parents some people were linking that to homophobia and you know hatred
00:24:59 of gay people it's got nothing to do with that it's about promoting the family unit which I
00:25:04 think we can all agree is essential for us to grow into productive and healthy people in society
00:25:11 You only need to look at the statistics, both in this country and in America, at the effect that single parenthood for both women and men, when there's not a father in the home and when there's not a mother in the home, that impacts children greatly later on in life.
00:25:26 So what we're basically saying is we think it's time to focus more on this and kind of demonstrate the positives of it rather than attacking or demonising, you know, anyone as, you know, those people have kind of been accusing us of.
00:25:42 So does this mean, for example, we all like families, I love my family, and we can also see that actually part of the attack on it is because it's seen as the bedrock of capitalism, and that is why they attack it.
00:25:58 But for example, would you therefore agree, as I would call traditional orthodox conservatives, with gay marriage?
00:26:04 Personally, yes.
00:26:05 Personally, I don't have an opinion.
00:26:13 That usually means something else, Dominic.
00:26:16 It usually means something else.
00:26:18 It's kind of difficult, OK, because there are some people that are religious
00:26:22 that don't agree with gay marriage for perfectly understandable reasons
00:26:26 because it's literally what their religious book says.
00:26:30 And I think that some people can be really intolerant,
00:26:34 which is really ironic, towards religious people and the way that they choose to follow
00:26:39 their religious scripture. So some people might not agree with gay marriage for those
00:26:45 reasons. Personally, for me, I think gay marriage is fine. I just don't really think it makes
00:26:51 sense for it to happen in a religious institution or that religious institutions should be forced
00:26:58 to perform gay marriages because it is essentially against their religion. But in terms of
00:27:04 me actively campaigning against gay marriage and telling someone that they
00:27:08 can't get married because of their sexuality no that's not really me the
00:27:12 reason I bring this up obviously is actually because this is a bit of a test
00:27:17 case you know like Cameron it was his big one of his big sort of policies is
00:27:21 in fact the only one he would be remembered for actually which was gay
00:27:24 marriage and it's kind of used a bit rather like abortion in America we
00:27:29 haven't arrived here yet but that is this big symbol of where you stand. I assume you've
00:27:37 got no problem with gay marriage? Yeah I take quite a liberal approach on these issues.
00:27:41 I don't have a problem with gay marriage but again I don't think that institutions should
00:27:45 necessarily be forced. I think they should have the choice but then again I think anyone
00:27:50 should have the right to get married regardless of their sexuality. But do you think, I mean
00:27:54 do you think that as i said orthodox conservatives appear to be more cultural is that how you see
00:28:02 how many conservatism now because i think this this election has made a big difference has it
00:28:06 not um i think i see it as a combination of obviously economics plays a big part in it as
00:28:12 well um i think orthodox conservatism should have a voice within the ideology but i think it is
00:28:17 important that it remains broad church and the only issue that i have potentially with
00:28:22 the ideology or the Conservative Party becoming dominated by this rant is that it could put
00:28:28 young people that we're trying to attract really off just because of the connotations that it
00:28:34 might lead to. For example, anti-gay marriage, it's not a particularly popular policy amongst
00:28:39 young people. So that's just my... That wouldn't be a policy. No, but it's kind of like a connotation.
00:28:46 Yeah, it is a connotation. But I think a lot of the time they often choose to associate that with
00:28:51 I think the problem with the overly zealous, you know, appeal to young people is that we often forego the values that form, you know, the foundation of the party in the first place.
00:29:05 And I think that whilst the Conservative Party is known for its economics, if we look at this election, a lot of the areas that we attracted are more so culturally conservative than rampant neoliberals who want no regulation on anything at all.
00:29:22 Exactly. And your finger is on the zeitgeist. I mean, this is the future of conservatism that we're seeing right here.
00:29:28 Every 40 years or so, we have a major realignment election in British politics. It's happened for over a century now, every 40 years.
00:29:34 1979 was the last time when we had an economic revolution.
00:29:38 But that wasn't true conservatism.
00:29:39 That was a neoliberal agenda that was being pushed for the last 40 years.
00:29:43 And now actually we're returning to proper conservatism, high Toryism,
00:29:47 which is more economically left-leaning, economically concerned with society,
00:29:51 concerned with one nation, lifting up parts of the nation that require it.
00:29:54 But actually focusing on the issues which, as I said before,
00:29:57 unite the former Labour voter in Bolsover with the Tory voter in Kensington and Chelsea,
00:30:02 far more than they are united to the Labour vote in Islington.
00:30:06 It's culture now, which is the common bond
00:30:08 that unites Conservatives, small-c Conservatives across the nation,
00:30:12 and Generation Z, those people who are in the Conservative wing
00:30:16 on Generation Z, espouse those same views.
00:30:19 And gay marriage is a dead issue now.
00:30:21 It's not going to change.
00:30:23 That's an unnecessary divergence,
00:30:25 because nothing's going to go on that issue any longer.
00:30:27 Sorry, go ahead.
00:30:29 I think the other thing when it comes to homosexual issues
00:30:32 is that you are forced to take a black-and-white approach.
00:30:37 The marriage thing is one thing.
00:30:38 As Rafe says, it's dead, frankly.
00:30:41 The law is the law. No one wants to change the law.
00:30:43 Even in our group, I don't know a single person that thinks the law should be changed.
00:30:47 But then there's the issue of, say, Drag Queen Story Hour
00:30:52 or this LGBT education in primary schools.
00:30:56 I mean, I live in Birmingham, and I live down the road
00:30:59 from where these protests were happening
00:31:01 by religious minority
00:31:03 parents and I
00:31:05 had all my friends saying can you believe this
00:31:07 they were protesting and I was saying
00:31:09 well yes I agree because I don't
00:31:11 think that you should be teaching sex education
00:31:13 of any kind to anyone below the age of
00:31:15 12 frankly
00:31:16 actually you've hit on the fault line
00:31:19 or not a fault line but I think this is
00:31:21 to use the left's language
00:31:23 this is all intersectionalism
00:31:25 I think we've got here
00:31:26 you said you'd agree with them
00:31:28 Here you've got, situation, LGBT teaching in school in Birmingham.
00:31:36 You've got groups outside, mostly, I think they are mostly Muslim groups.
00:31:41 Let's be honest about this, for goodness sake, we're not in the mainstream media.
00:31:45 It's a fact.
00:31:46 I mean, basically, and they are protesting against it.
00:31:50 So, right.
00:31:52 Okay, so you've got one of the conflicts of multiculturalism here coming up.
00:31:56 Where do you stand? You've already said you stand with the parents, right? How about you?
00:32:02 I believe that sex education does need to be started younger. It's just a fact of life that, obviously, whatever age a child is, eventually they are going to be confronted with these issues.
00:32:16 so I think to kind of and also I think part of it is tolerance kind of teaching tolerance from
00:32:21 a young age because if they are coming from communities who believe that being gay is a
00:32:27 sin for example I think it's important to open up their mind to a different way of thinking
00:32:31 and also if their peers who aren't from a religious background decide that or realise
00:32:38 that they are gay then they need to be supported as well so I think I think it's more of an issue
00:32:42 of tolerance um and the younger you start the better i believe but obviously it's sensitive i
00:32:48 think it's important to realize that these young people aren't you know being told the most explicit
00:32:52 information it's it's very tailored to a certain age group i think it's easy it's relationship
00:32:56 education there's no sex component to the education that they're receiving it's about
00:33:00 relationships with there's no so you think it's good i'm a militant defender of liberal values
00:33:06 and so that's why i'm actually quite strong on this point my in my view is identity politics is
00:33:11 now a terribly tarnished thing but in the 1980s and 70s you know look at women's lip you look at
00:33:16 the civil rights movement in america those rights were hard won by and hard fought and should be
00:33:21 defended and i'm very concerned that there is a move by immigrants coming into this country who
00:33:26 come from traditions when none of these battles were fought and they'd be so easy to do away with
00:33:31 if you have a population coming in here who don't treat them as sacred as we treat them and so i
00:33:36 think things like the gay rights movement and the women's rights movement and the civil rights
00:33:39 movement up through the 1990s
00:33:41 to the early part of the 2000s
00:33:43 were very noble things. They've gone
00:33:45 woefully off track in the last
00:33:47 15 to 20 years, but what we achieved
00:33:49 in those years should be defended
00:33:51 against people who are coming here who are
00:33:53 less liberal on those things, and quite frankly
00:33:55 they're sort of medieval
00:33:57 quite often. Well, this is the
00:33:59 odd thing, isn't it, that in fact
00:34:01 with multiculturalism, obviously
00:34:03 you've often got socially conservative
00:34:05 groups, you know, actually from
00:34:07 completely different places, I mean from parts of
00:34:09 europe you know and catholic and whatever not just muslim um i haven't asked you some minute
00:34:14 where do you stand because this is this is this is important i didn't quite get do you think that
00:34:18 the school should teach this then this is as far as i'm aware this is purely about relationships
00:34:24 it's not about sex so it's okay right okay so we've got a disagreement going i don't think it
00:34:29 needs to be taught to five and six year olds i just don't think it's needed i think in year six
00:34:34 which I think I was when I was in year six
00:34:36 talk about sex education
00:34:38 and relationships
00:34:39 what sexual relationships
00:34:41 are five and six year olds
00:34:46 going to have
00:34:46 I don't see the need to bring sex into everything
00:34:49 and I know that you said it's not specifically
00:34:51 about sex or explicitly mentioning sex
00:34:54 but those are the connotations
00:34:55 that that kind of thing has
00:34:57 I think that I do agree with you
00:35:00 about people from immigrant backgrounds
00:35:02 that have very extreme views when it comes to things like homosexuality women's rights and
00:35:08 things like that but I think that there's an opportunity to do that when kids are a bit older
00:35:15 and have the agency to think for themselves I think at the age of five and six there's a fine
00:35:20 line between education and tolerance and indoctrination I think that when you're at such a tender age
00:35:26 those kinds of things don't need to be addressed just yet maybe when you're a bit older
00:35:30 I sort of
00:35:32 I mean I think for what it's worth
00:35:34 on the one hand
00:35:36 I sort of can see what you're saying about the school
00:35:38 but on the other hand I look at the
00:35:39 protesters and I also hear
00:35:42 some of the things they've said
00:35:43 and also I think you know what
00:35:46 these people they just don't like gay people
00:35:47 let's be honest about this
00:35:49 a lot of it is anti-LGBTQ
00:35:51 and essentially
00:35:54 am I going to line up with you lot
00:35:56 or am I going to line up with you lot
00:35:58 it's a problem
00:35:59 I think this comes back to what I was saying
00:36:01 about things being black and white
00:36:03 there's this erasure of nuance
00:36:05 you can't stand
00:36:06 the nuance I think comes from Rafe's perspective
00:36:09 of saying well as Dominique says
00:36:11 maybe it's a bit too young
00:36:13 but at the same time you need to be able to turn around
00:36:15 to the other side and say but you are being unreasonable
00:36:17 and no one seems to
00:36:19 want to stand in the middle
00:36:20 because I feel like then they think they're being attacked
00:36:23 from both sides whereas in reality
00:36:24 frankly you need these people
00:36:27 to stand up and say well maybe we need to take a step
00:36:29 back here look at what's actually being discussed why it's being discussed the
00:36:33 way it is and whether that's productive and the answer is no frankly
00:36:36 doctor there should be a principle if you are coming to a country as if you're
00:36:40 joining a club you subscribe to the principles and rules of that club yes
00:36:43 we don't come to that club yeah but why but at the same time why is it that we
00:36:47 you would say to people who are coming to this country right you need to change
00:36:50 entirely but then we change the rules once they're here that's that's a
00:36:55 difficult thing to say because if these if these parents are coming here when
00:36:58 they're 17, 18 years old
00:37:00 and education in school is very much
00:37:02 concerned with practical knowledge, technical knowledge
00:37:04 and then when you get to about 15
00:37:05 there is sex education
00:37:07 and for them that's acceptable
00:37:09 but then 20 years down the line they have their own children
00:37:12 and in that time things change
00:37:14 and things have changed irrevocably so
00:37:16 so how on earth
00:37:18 can you then reasonably say to these people
00:37:20 you are in the wrong
00:37:21 because if the rug's been pulled out from under them
00:37:23 there are established channels for effecting change
00:37:26 in civilised societies
00:37:27 and they aren't the tactics that are employed by these groups.
00:37:30 No, I completely agree, but how could they?
00:37:33 Because if, in theory, we've had a Conservative government
00:37:35 for the last five years, in theory, ten, why doesn't this happen?
00:37:40 Yeah, but the thing is with this, it's the age-old thing we've covered before,
00:37:43 but, you know, you have a Conservative government,
00:37:46 but the general drift of society is leftward
00:37:49 and the reasons that we've already sort of covered today,
00:37:51 i.e. the people who are in control of the culture, in a way,
00:37:55 and people who can decide things carry on this leftward,
00:38:00 so-called progressive kind of ideology regardless of the government.
00:38:05 Speaking of which, what about Boris? Do you like Boris?
00:38:10 Yeah, so I really liked Boris during the campaign.
00:38:13 He's a brilliant campaigner.
00:38:14 I mean, we saw that during the London mayoral elections.
00:38:17 And I do believe that he was the right prime minister for the time.
00:38:20 Is he the most conservative we have ever had? No.
00:38:23 but I think
00:38:24 where would you like him to be more conservative
00:38:26 I think that obviously there's some big
00:38:28 spending pledges but I did understand that
00:38:30 that was needed in many ways to kind of
00:38:32 counter what Jeremy Corbyn was doing
00:38:34 so I guess it was
00:38:36 right for the time but I disagree with him
00:38:38 on HS2 and 5G
00:38:40 so obviously
00:38:41 if I could I'd change those decisions
00:38:44 right right okay what about
00:38:46 Dominique what about Boris what do you think of him
00:38:48 impressed not impressed
00:38:50 I initially actually didn't like
00:38:52 Boris. First I backed Dominic Raab and then I backed Jeremy Hunt, which a lot of people were
00:38:58 actually surprised by. With regards to Boris, like Emily said, he's a brilliant campaigner and
00:39:03 he's done really, really well in the election. Is he the most conservative Prime Minister? No,
00:39:10 like obviously not. And there are some issues that I just don't agree with, such as HS2,
00:39:16 such as 5G and our buddy-buddy approach to China
00:39:20 and the fact that we seem to be kind of
00:39:26 turning our nose up, really, at America,
00:39:28 which a lot of people didn't really expect him to do.
00:39:32 I know Boris has been very critical of Trump,
00:39:34 but in times of Brexit, I think that, you know,
00:39:38 more of a warmer approach to America would be helpful.
00:39:41 But overall, I'm not a massive fan,
00:39:44 but I think he's right for the time
00:39:47 and I want him to visit flood victims as well
00:39:49 I've got a feeling that
00:39:51 the whole American thing might just be
00:39:53 a bit of showboating
00:39:54 I think he probably is very much on side
00:39:57 with America
00:39:57 what about you then Jake?
00:40:02 I'm very
00:40:03 conflicted on Boris
00:40:04 for many reasons Emily's pointed out
00:40:07 the spending plans are
00:40:09 I think that's
00:40:13 playing the left's game too much
00:40:16 whether
00:40:18 strategically it was successful in the election
00:40:20 so you can't really criticise them on that
00:40:22 but now they're in government
00:40:23 they are obviously torn between a rock and a hard place of
00:40:26 how realistic are these things but at the same time
00:40:28 we need to make sure we hold on to these northern seats
00:40:29 that have now been won
00:40:30 so I think if you're going to spend the money
00:40:33 that he's planning to you should get rid of
00:40:35 HS2 and get rid of 5G
00:40:37 and instead focus on investing in local
00:40:39 communities, rebuilding certain
00:40:41 I mean, some person was saying to me a couple of weeks ago about how HS2 isn't just for commuting, it's for the transport of goods.
00:40:49 I said, well, you know, if you read, say, Robert Winder's The Last Wolf or any history books of the 15th to the 17th century,
00:40:56 most freight was travelled by canal and by coast.
00:41:00 So why do we not reinvest in coastal towns and rebuild shipbuilding in that respect?
00:41:05 You know, why are we not doing something a little bit more long-term, a little bit more practical when it comes to these left-behind communities?
00:41:10 Right.
00:41:10 but basically you kind of like him
00:41:13 but I mean do you think he's really conservative
00:41:15 Rafe I mean
00:41:16 for example I just think I can't think of
00:41:18 I think of his attitude towards immigration
00:41:20 which is one of the big issues for people
00:41:23 with Brexit there's no question about that
00:41:25 he's come up with the idea for
00:41:27 amnesties for illegal immigrants
00:41:29 terrible idea I think
00:41:30 I'm very sceptical about the new
00:41:33 immigration policy that's come out
00:41:35 which actually I think could have the opposite effects
00:41:37 of what he's meant to have
00:41:38 there's a huge problem here in that the model that they seem to be going on
00:41:42 migration is one whereby they're guaranteed success at the ballot box by
00:41:47 being seen to be tough on migration whereas the reality is
00:41:50 they're not being tough at all in practice and that message is very
00:41:53 difficult to convey to the electorate who
00:41:55 will see the numbers and won't actually have the information at their disposal
00:41:59 to realize that this is merely theatrics that's being portrayed
00:42:03 and I'm worried that this may be seen in other areas of government policy going
00:42:07 forward. Huawei worries me greatly, but I do have a lot of faith that he is the man for
00:42:12 the times. I used to deride Cameron and Blair by citing Churchill's old adage that it's
00:42:17 very hard for a nation to look up to a person who always has his ear to the ground, but
00:42:21 actually that is the success of Boris Johnson and Dominic Cummings. We used to have the
00:42:25 listening bank, we now have the listening prime minister, who understands, even though
00:42:30 he's not necessarily conservative, he understands the needs and the issues that concern the
00:42:35 former Red Wall Labour, who are culturally conservative,
00:42:38 and so he goes where the votes is, much like Trump goes where the votes is,
00:42:41 you know, an old Democrat from New York, now a Republican.
00:42:44 He understands where his concern is being re-elected,
00:42:48 and that means you need to cater to the needs of the Red Wall.
00:42:50 And so the infrastructure investment, I want to see Northern England
00:42:54 actually rise up from its current low, and if he can do that,
00:42:59 then that will be a success in my view as a person who believes in one-nation Toryism.
00:43:05 Speaking of One Nation tourism going forward, because we're just ending now really, but this is obviously an extremely important thing, but personally, you personally, you know this sort of thing I said at the beginning about having no heart when you're, if you're not lefty when you're young, then it means you have no heart and everything.
00:43:23 Obviously, you know, it's just absurd, you know,
00:43:26 you're well-rounded people, for goodness sake, with emotions.
00:43:30 Oh, thanks.
00:43:31 Not quite hollowed out yet.
00:43:33 But I wonder, therefore, you know, if you could just briefly say,
00:43:39 why would you say, at 16, join the Tory party or something,
00:43:45 what was, why?
00:43:47 Why did you become conservative?
00:43:49 for me um it was essentially the philosophy and it just made more sense to me so for example when
00:43:59 you had to seek it out yeah I did like I had to learn about it because initially I didn't really
00:44:03 know anything about politics and then I started learning about ideology and then I knew that I
00:44:09 didn't know I wasn't really interested or passionate about socialism so I was kind of like hmm but then
00:44:15 with liberalism I looked at liberalism and then I was looking at philosophical conservatism and
00:44:21 just for me when I looked at conservatism and you know kind of learned about its tenets it just made
00:44:27 more practical and logical sense to me so for example the organic society that's normally
00:44:33 associated with one nation conservatism and how we're all of value to one another and we're not
00:44:39 just individuals in a state you know we're all connected and community is absolutely vital and
00:44:47 a kind of cohesion in community is vital in order for society to operate healthily and also i'd say
00:44:55 our view of humanity that you know we are imperfect and i think liberals attribute too too much to us
00:45:03 as humans, they automatically assume we're rational, whereas conservatives accept that
00:45:10 we're not, we're imperfect, and that's where our kind of more hardline paternalistic kind
00:45:16 of policies come from with regards to law and order, for example. So that's what made
00:45:21 me join the Conservative Party. I would say that I'm less a party political conservative
00:45:27 though. I identify with the party and I will vote for them if needs be, but I'm more of
00:45:32 philosophical conservative. How about you Emily? Well it's actually quite funny I grew up with my
00:45:37 dad kind of channelling down the strong labour rhetoric yeah so my dad works for the NHS he's
00:45:45 a doctor in the NHS and um yeah he's always been a strong labour so he's my granddad I remember
00:45:50 them saying that anyone's a conservative is a fascist obviously joking around really
00:45:54 and as a 16 year old rebel I thought I'd see what's on the other side and obviously at the
00:46:00 time it was it was david cameron and i actually as a 16 year old i actually um identified a lot
00:46:05 with him i saw that he was quite a more liberal conservative um whether you can actually be a
00:46:12 liberal conservative is a whole nother debate but he he kind of channeled more kind of uh liberal
00:46:16 views and um it kind of made me see a different side to what my dad was saying um so i decided
00:46:23 that i was that i wanted to join the conservative because i think the other thing as well about
00:46:28 Labour is they're very prone to
00:46:30 kind of knee-jerk reactions
00:46:31 and I really believe in a pragmatic
00:46:34 approach to things like the economy
00:46:35 and that's something the Conservatives could really offer
00:46:37 So it was actually sort of a
00:46:40 rebellion, a bit of a rebellion
00:46:42 I did my research but
00:46:43 I have to say that the research was
00:46:45 led a little bit by a rebellion side
00:46:48 How about you, Jake?
00:46:51 Well
00:46:51 growing up, my dad's a farmer
00:46:54 and so was his dad
00:46:55 but my grandad's father was
00:46:57 was a Labour Party member in Yorkshire and in factories.
00:47:02 And when I was growing up, they always told me about the strikes in the 70s
00:47:05 and the three-day working week and all these sorts of things.
00:47:08 And they said, you know, we never want to go back to that and all the rest.
00:47:11 And as a result, when I was about 12, 13,
00:47:14 and Cameron was talking about, you know, the need for compassionate conservatism,
00:47:19 I remember thinking, well, that seems a bit strange, compassionate conservatism,
00:47:23 because we do have this caricature of conservatism as being quite hard,
00:47:26 It's quite authoritarian, as you say.
00:47:27 I did my research into it, and the thing that struck me
00:47:31 and always took out to me, and I know that it's a bit of a toxic name in politics,
00:47:35 but there was a really, really interesting thing said by Enoch Powell
00:47:38 on obligation and duty, which was he was talking about
00:47:41 the Good Samaritan parable in the Bible.
00:47:42 And I'm a Christian myself, and he said that the parable of the Good Samaritan
00:47:48 is very much about willingness and feeling of obligation
00:47:51 that comes from internally.
00:47:53 You see someone on the side of the road, you want to help.
00:47:55 If there had been a Roman soldier standing there forcing the Good Samaritan to help, he wouldn't have been the Good Samaritan.
00:48:00 He would have been a civilian.
00:48:01 Now, that then led me back to compassionate conservatism.
00:48:04 And I saw, whether this was Cameron's intention or not, that when conservatism rose back the state and says to people,
00:48:12 you be moral and be helpful and dutiful to other people, but how you see fit, it's a much richer understanding of compassion.
00:48:21 It's a freer compassion.
00:48:22 It's more moral compassion.
00:48:23 is one that you cultivate as you grow up.
00:48:25 So that was what led me to the philosophical conservatism
00:48:28 that Dominique talked about.
00:48:29 I have nothing but respect for the three of you for doing that
00:48:32 because, rightly or wrongly, I've always had more respect for people
00:48:35 who have changed horses of their families' political leanings.
00:48:41 I have also people like Hilary Benn on one side,
00:48:43 the son of Tony Benn or Nicholas Soames from Churchill's grandson.
00:48:47 You're born into your class and into your world view
00:48:50 and you've gone along with the view of your fathers and forefathers.
00:48:53 but to actually change that view, to think for yourself,
00:48:55 to take off those right or left-leaning blinkers
00:48:58 and to determine your own path in life,
00:49:00 I think is very much kudos to you on that front.
00:49:03 Well, I think it shows great strength of mind, actually.
00:49:07 You know, I'd agree with you on there.
00:49:10 And also, all the very best to you, you know, for the future.
00:49:13 Well, we're going to kind of cross paths again, I think, on this show, aren't we?
00:49:18 Dominic, Jake, Emily, and of course we have.
00:49:20 Thanks very much indeed.
00:49:21 Thank you very much for watching.
00:49:22 Great show, I think you'll agree
00:49:24 And we look forward to seeing you next time
00:49:27 In the meantime, please remember to subscribe to CounterCulture, won't you?
00:49:30 Thank you, bye