New Culture Forum - March 02, 2020


2.17 Harry Miller: My Free Speech High Court Victory

2.15 Zuby: How To Be a Rebel in the 2020s 2.19 Charles Coulombe: A Conservative Author Examines the Culture Wars in Trad. Institutions

Episode Stats


Length

51 minutes

Words per minute

164.13

Word count

8,456

Sentence count

87


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to So What You're Saying Is. I'm Peter Whittle. Now if you've watched many of the
00:00:22 interviews we've done over the past year you'll know that one of the themes that comes up time
00:00:26 and time again is free speech and indeed the increasing attacks and restrictions on it.
00:00:34 You might remember that last week there was a very well publicised case. I've got this
00:00:39 headline here from the Times, Hate Speech Policing is Orwellian, warns Judge. Now this
00:00:45 was a very, very important case and I'm very pleased to say that the man at the very centre
00:00:50 of it, who was in the High Court, is with me today and that's Harry Miller. Hello Harry.
00:00:56 very much for coming thanks for having me and i also you're mentioned as well in the times leader
00:01:01 today uh which is about free speech and free expression um this is an incredibly important
00:01:07 moment um there will be a lot of people you know who are watching the show who are not in britain
00:01:13 i mean in american places won't necessarily know what we are actually talking about i wonder if you
00:01:18 could just give us an overview a brief overview of how you ended up in the high courts january
00:01:24 2019 i was in tesco's car park and um it was middle of the afternoon and i got a phone call
00:01:31 from my managing director now i own the company um so and my managing director is my partner
00:01:39 so it's not the traditional hierarchy where the managing director rings and you sort of panic
00:01:45 like crazy uh but he said really weird harry we've just had a policeman um turn up at work at the
00:01:51 officers i've not given him your telephone number but he's given me his telephone number and if you
00:01:57 want to ring him give him a buzz so i said did he did he say what he wanted he said no not at all
00:02:03 but he he turned up in plain clothes like well sounds a bit serious so i i rang him and um
00:02:10 this officer answered and he introduced himself as pc gull from humberside police i said all right
00:02:16 yeah hi peace eagle um what is it you want and he said well we've had a complaint from down south
00:02:23 and i live in immingham which is up north he says we've had a complaint from down south um
00:02:29 apparently your twitter activity um the concern is that your workplace is not safe for trans people
00:02:39 i just went you what what are you on about my workplace isn't safe for trans people
00:02:44 he says well the the person from down south the victim says that um that your workplace might be
00:02:50 unsafe i said well as far as i'm concerned i'm not even sure we have any trans people at my
00:02:55 workplace and he says ah yeah that might be because you're a transphobe and i went is this
00:03:00 some kind of wind up is this what what you want about he says oh no no this is very serious we've
00:03:04 had a had a report in and um i'm ringing you up to have a word with you about it yeah i said but
00:03:09 this makes no sense at all.
00:03:12 I said, look, let's cut to the chase.
00:03:15 He says, is there anything that I've tweeted?
00:03:17 Is there anything that I've tweeted criminal?
00:03:18 Anything at all?
00:03:19 He said, oh, no.
00:03:21 Nothing criminal.
00:03:22 No suggestion of criminality whatsoever.
00:03:25 I said, so, why are you ringing me then?
00:03:29 He said, well, I need to check your thinking.
00:03:31 Check your thinking?
00:03:32 Yeah.
00:03:32 He said, I need to check your thinking.
00:03:34 Which made me kind of smile inside.
00:03:36 And I said, all right, okie dokie.
00:03:38 I said, so, let me get it straight.
00:03:39 you're a police officer yeah and you're ringing me to check my thinking yeah i said have you any
00:03:46 idea what that makes you and he's went no i said george orwell thought police i said 1984
00:03:54 it's a dystopian novel not a police operating manual yeah and the reference was like boom
00:04:00 straight over he had no idea what the hell i was talking about
00:04:02 so we had a bit of a discussion about george orwell and dystopia etc etc
00:04:08 and I said right we've established that I've not committed any crime I said
00:04:15 what's your evidence this is well we've got 30 tweets I said all right any of
00:04:20 them criminal said no no no suggestion of criminality I said right okay so which
00:04:25 one in your opinion because you've got 30 tweets which one in your opinion comes
00:04:29 closest to the mark of being criminal the one that if I'd just gone a little bit
00:04:33 further yeah that would have been it it would have been incredible give me a
00:04:36 give me your worst one give me a very worst one out of them 30. and he said right okie dokie
00:04:42 so there's this one here there's a limerick i said a limerick i said i've not i've not written
00:04:48 any limericks he said oh no you didn't write it you retweeted it i said what limerick they said
00:04:55 oh it's this limerick i said well you're gonna have to remind me because i have no idea what
00:04:58 you're talking about um and he said if i remember rightly it said um your breasts are made of
00:05:05 of silicon your vagina goes nowhere um and we can tell the difference even when you're not there
00:05:12 your hormones are synthetic now let's just cross this bridge what you have you stupid man is male
00:05:18 privilege bubble um for one i said that's not even a limerick mate that's not a limerick you
00:05:23 need to look up the definition of limerick um he says well it's it's offensive i said how is it
00:05:29 offensive he said well it's offensive but you're not telling me how it's
00:05:34 offensive so well it's anti-trans I said but I don't even know what you mean by
00:05:39 anti-trans and I didn't even write it yes but by retweeting it or the people
00:05:43 will have seen it yeah I said that is just absolutely that's absolutely nuts
00:05:47 mate he says yeah but it's not is it because you know the victim is very
00:05:51 upset I said let's just stop right there you keep talking about the victim
00:05:56 there is no victim because I've committed no crime so how could there be a victim and he said well
00:06:01 that's just what we have to call him we have to call him the victim I said why well we call them
00:06:05 the victim because there might have been a crime I said but before you even contacted me you decided
00:06:10 there was no crime so please stop using the term victim because I find that insulting and he said
00:06:16 well that's just the term we have to use I said but that's absolutely ridiculous have you not heard
00:06:21 of free speech have you not heard of evidential inquiry i'm an ex-police myself this is just
00:06:27 nonsense and he went on in this vein for about 23 well actually 34 minutes 34 minutes he went
00:06:35 on but he finished off by saying this what you've got to understand mr miller i can barely say it
00:06:42 without laughing so what you've got to understand mr miller is that sometimes in the womb
00:06:46 a female brain accidentally pushes out the wrong body parts and that's what being trans is
00:06:53 i went seriously i says you cannot believe that you cannot believe that he says yeah i kind of
00:07:01 went on the course i went on the course i went on the course yeah i went on the course oh well
00:07:05 there you go then if you've been on the course that that explains it done it right yeah i said
00:07:09 i just cannot believe that the police are ringing me up to give me some psycho babble biology that
00:07:16 makes no sense whatsoever um i said i'll tell you what mate you need to just go wash your socks and
00:07:24 we're into this conversation now so that was 34 minute conversation 34 minutes out of my life
00:07:29 being told about wrong think and lady brains um i mean you're being you're being very good
00:07:36 humored about it and we're laughing but this is really serious stuff isn't it well it is serious
00:07:42 stuff and it's so i went home and i said so i said to my missus i had a phone call from the cops
00:07:51 her immediate reaction was oh god what is it something to do with twitter and i went actually
00:07:57 it is yeah now what's interesting is that my wife was on twitter as well or had been on twitter
00:08:04 and she voluntarily came off twitter once a couple of police officers started following her on twitter
00:08:10 um and at the time i'd said this is just ridiculous you know why would you come off twitter
00:08:17 that you're being paranoid you're being ridiculous we had a row about it um and she says no no i'm
00:08:23 not it's i don't like it i feel really unsafe with the police following me i said but that's
00:08:27 just that's just nonsense the police in britain aren't like that you know chill take a chill pill
00:08:32 i've never looked good in a tinfoil hat i don't believe in conspiracy theories
00:08:36 um but who was the flaming mug now yeah because it turns out that the police were following us
00:08:44 it turns out the police are monitoring what we're saying and even when we're committing no crime
00:08:49 um they're dispatching an officer to check my thinking so as usual my wife was right this is
00:08:57 uh so he was actually this ended up being what is called a hate incident that's what they were
00:09:02 saying isn't that right yeah the college of police guidelines which were issued by in 2014
00:09:07 now the college of policing is a quasi-government body where the responsibility for policing
00:09:17 and setting down the standards of policing has been subcontracted out by the home office
00:09:23 to a private company and the college of policing is a it's a private company interestingly somebody
00:09:29 from the college of policing wrote to me and said please win this case because we it's filled with
00:09:35 failed inspectors and academics who know nothing right that was from somebody who shall remain
00:09:40 anonymous in the college of policing but that is the college of policing and they set these they
00:09:44 set these guidance these guidelines on on hate crime so the hate crime operational guidance or
00:09:51 or HCOG, was issued in 2014.
00:09:54 And it addresses two things.
00:09:56 It addresses hate crime, and it addresses hate incidents.
00:10:01 Now, the difference is this.
00:10:03 A hate crime, for a hate crime to be a hate crime,
00:10:06 you have to have met the threshold of a crime.
00:10:10 And then the hate bit is where the motivation for committing the crime
00:10:14 is perceived, or adjudged, to have been due to a hatred
00:10:19 against a protected characteristic a hate incident is where you haven't met the threshold for a crime
00:10:29 but the police consider it worth logging and registering etc because it may lead to crime
00:10:37 it may lead to crime now my understanding is that um the justification for the hate instant hate
00:10:44 crime thing was the Stephen
00:10:46 Lawrence case. Now Stephen Lawrence
00:10:48 in the 90s
00:10:50 was a young black lad
00:10:54 who was brutally
00:10:56 murdered at a bus stop by being
00:10:58 stabbed by some
00:11:00 white racist thugs.
00:11:04 The police
00:11:04 were utterly incompetent in their
00:11:06 investigation about it.
00:11:09 It eventually became the subject
00:11:10 of a report by Lord
00:11:12 Macpherson and in the report
00:11:14 a very long report he slammed the what he called the institutional racism of the police he slammed
00:11:22 the idea that black people if they ever came um onto the police radar at all he was only ever as
00:11:29 a suspect very rarely as a victim um it utterly slammed the police and what in a sense what it
00:11:36 said was you have to take the perceptions of people who complain seriously and that's a noble thought
00:11:43 actually if you if you report to me that you've been the the victim of a racist attack it's no
00:11:49 good for me as a police officer to say well show me your hard evidence yeah well i didn't tape it
00:11:54 i didn't i haven't got well forget it then and and that's why that's what that's what the hcog
00:11:58 was addressing okay you you you should take victims seriously even if they can't bring
00:12:04 hard evidence to the table all very noble but of course what's happened is we've taken this
00:12:11 no evidence required thing to an absolute illogical extreme where rather than having
00:12:18 no concrete evidence it now means no evidence whatsoever at all not at all so if somebody
00:12:25 perceives an action to be hateful it is hateful no there is no excuse there is no defense you
00:12:35 can't give a reason and say well actually i was i was engaging in this or i was engaging that
00:12:40 so that's what i said um we we complained to the police and i said look i was engaged in a
00:12:48 political debate okay those tweets were from part and parcel of the rough and tumble of political
00:12:54 debate and um the context is the government has called it called in 2018 for um discussion about
00:13:02 reform to the gender recognition act now at the moment if you are a trans if you are a trans person
00:13:11 you get protection if you have or intend to hold a gender recognition certificate that's what the
00:13:18 the 2010 equalities act says now there's a move to reform the 2004 gra gender recognition act
00:13:27 to one of self-identification where I don't need to get a GRC,
00:13:32 I don't need to go through any medical process,
00:13:34 I don't need to go through any psychological assessment.
00:13:36 All I need to do is say, yesterday I was a man, today I'm a woman.
00:13:42 That's it.
00:13:44 And the government rightly saw some of the bear traps
00:13:46 that were clearly implicit in such a move
00:13:51 and called for a discussion.
00:13:54 So I was engaged in the discussion.
00:13:58 Now, of course, Twitter is a fairly unsubtle and fairly brutal medium
00:14:04 because you don't get the chance to write long essays or anything.
00:14:08 It's basically the market square.
00:14:10 It's the social pub.
00:14:11 It's the back and forth of debate,
00:14:14 and it involves a little bit of insult and a little bit of coarse language.
00:14:18 It's the marketplace.
00:14:18 place so this is the context that i was i was tweeting in and i explained this to the police
00:14:26 via you know official channels i put in a formal letter um and they weren't having any of it they
00:14:32 they just stuck to the line well somebody's complained therefore it's transphobic so i i put
00:14:39 in a complaint and a formal complaint to the assistant chief constable no against the assistant
00:14:43 chief constable of humberside acc scott young because he'd done a press announcement where he
00:14:49 said um we are in possession of 30 transphobic tweets not 30 tweets that were reported to us
00:14:55 as transphobic 30 transphobic tweets now that that has already given a judgment analysis
00:15:01 quantitative analysis exactly that the tweets are transphobic so i said you've got to take that down
00:15:06 it's just not true and they said no and i said while we're at it you need to remove the hate
00:15:11 incident against my name and they said no it's mandatory recording it's going to stay there
00:15:17 and we said no you will remove it where would it actually be recorded can you uh where where
00:15:22 where would it be recorded it would be it would be recorded on whatever the police database is
00:15:27 recording um hate incidents now initially i wanted it removing as a matter of as a matter of principle
00:15:36 i didn't for one second think he would have any effect on me or anybody else but as a statistic
00:15:43 simply as a statistic alone i felt that it was wrong that there should be a statistic
00:15:49 supporting this notion of hate yeah and that to have my instance included on it was giving a
00:15:55 entirely false impression to everybody about the rates of hate incidents absolutely so so from that
00:16:03 level i just knew it was wrong if we're going to have statistics and we're going to have statistics
00:16:08 that mean something and that inform something and that inform action then the statistics need to be
00:16:14 accurate and so it was at that level that i initially began to challenge it because it
00:16:19 struck me as being entirely wrong and these just these are these statistics or if there's a
00:16:26 notification they can presumably be looked at for future by future employers things like well
00:16:31 initially what i thought was it becomes simply a statistic no name nothing it's just hate instant
00:16:37 you know i've notched i've ratcheted up by one number and for me that was enough i even though
00:16:43 i didn't imagine my name was attached to it the simple ratcheting up of a hate incident
00:16:49 i felt was wrong so it was on that basis that i began my appeal now the interesting thing is you
00:16:57 have you have one go at appeal um with the police and it's the police who are judging themselves
00:17:05 which is which is not really great is it so the police have done this i say the police have done
00:17:10 this i think it's wrong they investigate themselves and go boom we've done nothing wrong
00:17:15 and you go well you have done something wrong well we've decided we haven't done anything wrong
00:17:19 unfortunately in this in this case the the next stop on the way of appeal is the high court right
00:17:28 via judicial review and that costs you need to put up around about 150 000 pounds that's what
00:17:35 you need to budget for a high court appeal now who can do that exactly who can who can do that
00:17:41 so of course most people the vast majority of people are just going to take it on the chin
00:17:46 in fact i had a radio interviewer months ago said to me um harry why don't you just take it on the
00:17:52 chin like most people and i said because that's the point most people do just take it on the chin
00:17:57 i'm not most people and the police shouldn't be giving it on the chin in the first place
00:18:02 that's why i'm not taking it on the chin now we thought that this was simply about
00:18:09 notching up a statistic
00:18:11 which was bad enough
00:18:12 but then it turned out
00:18:14 we asked a few
00:18:17 inquiring
00:18:19 questions
00:18:20 can this
00:18:22 well initially
00:18:24 let's just roll it back a minute
00:18:25 remember I said that
00:18:28 they told me that there was this
00:18:31 one limerick
00:18:31 but this one limerick represented
00:18:34 30 other tweets
00:18:36 I wrote to the police and said
00:18:38 can i see the other 30 tweets and they said no and i said well how am i supposed to learn
00:18:45 and how am i supposed to modify my behavior if i don't even know what it is i've said
00:18:52 they said well you know what you've said because you wrote the tweets i said but i've written
00:18:57 hundreds thousands of tweets which one which ones are they and they said well we're not going to
00:19:02 tell you i thought that's just nonsense so i put in a what's called a subject access request
00:19:08 to the police where i said give me all data on myself all data everything including the tweets
00:19:15 it took me three months to get a copy of the tweets i didn't get a hold of the tweets until
00:19:20 june june now two things here one when i read the tweets i was frankly stunned just stunned
00:19:32 because over that period of time my mind had started playing tricks with me had i got drunk
00:19:39 one night and tweeted punch a tranny or something like that you know my wife who'd had shown great
00:19:46 support of me said what what did he tweet what did he tweet and you know i'd search back through my
00:19:52 my stuff well and i think well it might be on a deleted thread i might have answered somebody
00:19:58 on a thread that's now deleted or unblocked I don't know I just don't know but it's a long
00:20:02 time for it to mess with your mind and think I wonder I wonder because I've set the ball rolling
00:20:07 with the judicial review etc etc I wonder if there's something in those tweets that I'm going
00:20:13 to be really really embarrassed about then when they finally came through as a result of a subject
00:20:19 access request I read I read through them and I did not sleep that night I was so I was so angry
00:20:26 I don't think
00:20:28 I can't remember ever being as angry
00:20:31 because there was nothing
00:20:33 there was nothing
00:20:34 this is a sample of some of the tweets
00:20:36 Sheffield women
00:20:39 know the difference between lads and lasses
00:20:41 that's one
00:20:42 another one was
00:20:44 I retweeted an article by Andrew Gilligan
00:20:47 from the Sunday Times
00:20:48 another one
00:20:50 was simply
00:20:52 my son's at Oxford
00:20:54 and
00:20:56 he rang me up about
00:21:00 protesters at a Steve
00:21:03 Bannon
00:21:03 speech at the
00:21:07 union and I'd simply tweeted
00:21:08 just had the sun on from
00:21:10 Oxford, apparently the anti-Jenny
00:21:12 Murray crowd are out baying
00:21:14 and spitting at students going to see
00:21:16 Steve Bannon
00:21:17 how is that
00:21:20 I mean it doesn't even touch
00:21:22 the subject of trans except it
00:21:24 does yeah because i mentioned jenny murray and the mere mention of jenny murray dame jenny murray
00:21:31 who is a long-established bbc woman's hour presenter was bullied out of going to speak at
00:21:39 oxford because she dare write a piece that simply suggested that trans women were not the same as
00:21:46 biological women that was it yeah so she was bullied from from going to speak at the oxford
00:21:52 union and simply mentioning jenny murray was enough for it to be considered hate speech
00:22:00 of course there were some other more ripe um tweets in there i'd said uh which i think has
00:22:06 been quoted quite a lot that um i'd said um i i was i was assigned mammal at birth
00:22:13 but I identify as fish
00:22:15 don't misspecies me
00:22:17 fuckers
00:22:18 and
00:22:21 okay it's
00:22:23 choice language but actually
00:22:25 it does make a serious
00:22:27 point I was using
00:22:29 existential humour I suppose
00:22:31 to make a point
00:22:33 because if it's possible
00:22:34 to simply
00:22:36 identify yourself
00:22:39 out of your sex and cross
00:22:41 the boundary between male and female why is it not possible to cross the boundary between mammal
00:22:47 and fish why it doesn't make any sense if we can if we are in the process of being able to
00:22:53 identify identify out of a biological fact why does it have to finish between male and female
00:23:00 and so for me i was actually addressing what i consider to be a serious serious point albeit with
00:23:07 sardonic fairly unsophisticated humor but that was considered hate now when they talk about hate
00:23:15 they say it's hate that is likely to escalate to crime and the crime they have in mind is the
00:23:22 stabbing of somebody to bus stop i find that to be just just ludicrous so we've got these 30 tweets
00:23:30 They came back, I was fuming about that, but also in the subject access request came my report, the incident log.
00:23:41 And what was interesting is this, it says crime report on it.
00:23:45 Crime report?
00:23:46 Yeah, it's headed, crime report, big letters, crime report.
00:23:50 And then below that it says offence, trans hate, and then below that it says suspect, Harry Miller.
00:23:57 and then somewhere way down in the terms and conditions box you know right down the bottom
00:24:03 it says category crime non-crime crime non-crime non-crime yeah yeah yeah crime non-crime yeah yeah
00:24:09 so if you're at all familiar with orwell you instantly start thinking about double speak
00:24:17 duck speak it's just absolute nonsense so now i've got my name attached to a crime report
00:24:24 where I am named as the suspect
00:24:26 for an offence
00:24:28 that is a crime non-crime
00:24:30 so this is beginning to feel
00:24:32 a little bit serious now
00:24:33 so then we said
00:24:34 who else has got access to this report
00:24:37 well it depends
00:24:40 alright so some other people
00:24:42 do have access to this report
00:24:43 then who
00:24:44 well it's in the gift of the chief constable
00:24:47 but it can appear on an enhanced DBS check
00:24:50 a DBS check is basically
00:24:52 a crime records check so well under what circumstances would that be released as an
00:24:59 enhanced dbs check well if you applied for certain jobs well what jobs well if i applied for to a
00:25:07 school or a college or a university or anything that worked with vulnerable people at all then
00:25:14 that would be flagged up and it would appear on the pre-employment check and i said well what do
00:25:20 you think it's going to happen when my application goes in and they pick up this bit of paper that's
00:25:27 headed crime report what do you think they're going to do I'll tell you what I'm going to do
00:25:31 if I see that I'm going to tear up the application just throw it in the bin I'm not going to wait
00:25:36 I'm not going to read through it and make a judgment and then hope that I spot the nine
00:25:40 crime non-crime bit and then just dismiss it I'm going to make a value judgment on whether to
00:25:47 employ this person based on this and what i see there is crime report so actually this has gone
00:25:53 from being simply about notching up a statistic to having a very real world impact so then you
00:26:01 ask the question right is this just me am i just that one unlucky one izzy lyons at the telegraph
00:26:06 did a bit of digging and um she came up there have been 89 i think 87 or 89 000 of these crime
00:26:12 on crimes in the last four years 87 000 there's been another report by another report i can't
00:26:17 remember who it's gone up to 120 000 i think it's 120 since 2014 or something like that yeah yes
00:26:24 in 2014 120 000 people now in that 120 000 people i am sure there are some thoroughly nasty people
00:26:31 whose details actually ought to be recorded somewhere because it may well be that they are
00:26:37 the next stabbers of somebody to bus stop it may be that but in in this country in a civilized
00:26:44 society we don't capture everybody on the off chance that we're going to capture the right
00:26:49 one somewhere we don't do that that is that is simply wrong that is the kind of behavior that
00:26:55 you expect from i don't know um cold war yeah cold war police forces in fact this is what the
00:27:03 judge said you know this is what the headline was here um the judge implied didn't he that
00:27:09 or in fact said that we don't do this kind of thing in this country this is Orwellian we don't
00:27:13 have a Stasi you don't have a Gestapo any of that stuff well he said he said we've never had a Stasi
00:27:19 a Gestapo or a Cheka if he'd have picked one of those three it would have been bad enough but he
00:27:28 picked three because the judge mr justice knowles who quite frankly is now the poster boy the poster
00:27:37 judge of rad fems absolutely everywhere because he spoke the truth he spoke the truth were you
00:27:44 surprised i was surprised at the i wasn't surprised at the judgment against humberside no i thought
00:27:53 that was, by any test of reasonableness, they had to be found to have broken, to have trampled
00:28:02 all over our human rights. I could not see how they could possibly have gotten away with
00:28:08 that at all. What surprised me was the weight of the judgment upon them. I mean, he, out
00:28:18 of all the words, out of all the images he could have picked, he picked Orwell, he quoted
00:28:25 On Liberty by Mill, and then he referenced the Stasi, the Chequette, and the Gestapo.
00:28:30 I mean, it's a stunning, stunning judgment. He said that the witness that Humberside had
00:28:39 presented, and whose details were all redacted, simply known as Mrs B, that they were operating
00:28:46 on the outer edges of rationality right it was it was it was a scathing scathing judgment now
00:28:53 what's interesting is just imagine for a second you're you're the police you're the chief constable
00:28:59 you're the pcc you're you're an officer senior officer in humberside and you've had a high court
00:29:04 judge call you that what what what would the rational response be do you think what you wouldn't
00:29:09 expect is a traffic update about roadworks in gull followed by a statement that says we've read the
00:29:18 judgment and we're going to have a learning moment moving forward we're going to have a learning
00:29:23 moment a learning a learning moment yeah yeah a learning moment they they've basically done
00:29:27 the management two-step which is reflect two three move forward two three and that's it that's it
00:29:35 They've been called the Gestapo, the stars in the checker.
00:29:38 They've been likened to an Orwellian police force.
00:29:41 And they think that the appropriate response is to have,
00:29:45 moving forward, have a learning moment.
00:29:47 Absolute nonsense.
00:29:50 Absolute nonsense.
00:29:51 They've treated it as though they've been found guilty
00:29:54 of trampling on somebody's daffodils in pursuit of a missing cat.
00:29:58 The thing is, I can't help feeling that, you know, you took it.
00:30:03 you weren't going to let this lie so you took it right to where it should go high court but
00:30:11 there'll be a lot of people you know i'd say almost maybe even the majority who will be so
00:30:16 intimidated they you know you're switched on enough to know when you look at the statement
00:30:20 it says crime non-crime and heck a lot of people will just start to get frightened and they'll just
00:30:27 sort of like just back away just to let them get on with it i mean this is the worrying thing is it
00:30:31 not it's usually worrying it's worrying but that is that is precisely um what they're wanting to do
00:30:39 yeah they don't give you they don't give you the law they can't say what law you've broken
00:30:44 they don't even give you the evidence in my case they just say back off because if you don't back
00:30:50 off you are in danger of becoming a criminal so the reasonable person backs off but i think it
00:31:00 george bernard shaw who said that all hope rests with the unreasonable person in such circumstances
00:31:07 and i am the unreasonable person i am i'm just bullheaded one i knew i knew that i'd not tweeted
00:31:14 anything awful because i'm not awful i don't hate trans people i'm just not i'm not that
00:31:19 sort of person i'm just simply not um secondly i'm an ex-police officer from humberside so
00:31:26 So the whole mystique of the police don't really watch with me.
00:31:31 Actually, as a former policeman, when you look at the police,
00:31:34 you're dealing with the police now, do you recognise what you see?
00:31:38 No, I don't recognise it at all.
00:31:40 I mean, it's absolute nonsense.
00:31:42 Now, the vast majority of the police are doing a form of policing
00:31:46 which is entirely recognisable to me.
00:31:49 They're at the sharp end.
00:31:52 They're doing a fantastic job.
00:31:54 My issue is not with the police.
00:31:56 it is with the thought police
00:31:58 who are a division
00:32:00 of the actual police
00:32:02 this is what worries me
00:32:03 only this week I found
00:32:06 that the same PC
00:32:08 who rang me up
00:32:11 do you know what he was doing earlier this month?
00:32:14 what?
00:32:15 he was at a bakery
00:32:17 in Humberside
00:32:19 teaching the bakers about hate crime
00:32:22 oh dear
00:32:23 why would you do that?
00:32:25 I mean, there's only two possibilities.
00:32:27 Either bakers are very likely to go stab somebody,
00:32:32 and I can't see that,
00:32:34 or hit him with a hard flipping bread roll or something,
00:32:37 I don't know.
00:32:38 Or, more likely, this is what I think,
00:32:41 he's teaching them to be victims.
00:32:43 He's teaching them to recognise victimhood.
00:32:45 Why?
00:32:47 Because the HCOG also says
00:32:49 that a reduction in statistics
00:32:52 is not an acceptable target so they have to the hcog says they have to keep their statistics up
00:33:02 and it says it doesn't matter whether hate crime is going down the statistics have to go up yeah
00:33:09 so there's the motivation yeah they're going around teaching people to be offended yes exactly
00:33:14 also in the case of the bakers maybe is it you know just in case they don't want to do a cake
00:33:19 for somebody or something like that you know those sort of cases as well it could well be that
00:33:23 it might be that it might well be that yeah it might be that thing is um you so basically the
00:33:28 you won this part of the case the judicial review harry but the the college of policing was upheld
00:33:38 wasn't it in other words they misapplied their guidelines isn't that right no in no no no we
00:33:45 We took the College of Police to do judicial review and Humberside Police for this reason.
00:33:54 Humberside's defence was we followed the guidance.
00:33:57 We followed the national guidance.
00:33:59 So we go, okay, well, who issued the national guidance?
00:34:01 The College of Police.
00:34:03 Okey-dokey.
00:34:04 In that case, we will take them to court as well for issuing the guidance,
00:34:08 which Humberside followed.
00:34:11 Now, what I would have expected was that the College of Policing,
00:34:14 in order to protect their guidance
00:34:16 would have put some distance
00:34:18 between their guidance and the actions
00:34:20 of Humberside. They would have said
00:34:22 our guidance is correct
00:34:24 but you, Humberside police
00:34:26 you didn't follow the guidance
00:34:28 that way we protect our
00:34:30 guidance whilst throwing you
00:34:32 to the dogs. But that's not what
00:34:34 happened.
00:34:36 The College of Police defended
00:34:38 to the hilt the actions
00:34:40 of Humberside. Point
00:34:42 to point you couldn't blow a breath of wind between the two defendants at all
00:34:50 so we have this peculiar situation where humbersides say we followed the guidance
00:34:59 the college says we agree you followed the guidance the judge says yes you followed the
00:35:06 guidance the guidance is legal but you homicide police are thoroughly illegal yeah which leaves
00:35:15 us in this quite strange and peculiar and almost well very illogical position because
00:35:22 one plus one equals three in this instance so i think the college of police know that there's
00:35:31 a problem though because um they waved through our request to go direct to the supreme court
00:35:40 they didn't object they've supported the application to go to the supreme court
00:35:45 because we think that they know there is a severe problem with the guidance now of course
00:35:52 they're defending it but i think they know there's an issue i think this is a case of they want
00:35:59 somebody higher up the supreme court to make the decision for them that's what i think so what are
00:36:05 you doing now what is your what is your next course of action then our next course of action
00:36:09 is to um is to present well appeal to the supreme court the judge mr justice knowles has given us
00:36:16 license to a certificate to appeal to the supreme court now the supreme court only take what 11 12
00:36:23 cases a year i think so they don't have to take our case if they choose not to take our case
00:36:28 immediately then we'd take a step back and go to the court of appeal and then the court of appeal
00:36:34 may then say go to the supreme court but we're hoping to leapfrog and go direct because it's of
00:36:40 it's not only of national importance actually it's of international importance because
00:36:44 other countries around the world take the lead in terms of law from the uk and i think everybody
00:36:50 knows that i mean the the judgment hadn't been out for half a day before there was a statement from
00:36:54 on number 10 yeah everybody everybody knows the needs looking at everybody we
00:37:02 talked a bit earlier about the definition which is at the root of all of this
00:37:05 really I mean the way the guidelines are applied does one thing but the actual
00:37:10 definition that you've already have referred to of hate incident or a hate
00:37:15 crime is this thing where there's all sorts of problems wrong with it are
00:37:18 they not and first of all victim is used immediately the word victim as you said
00:37:23 you should at least be just a complainant shouldn't you yeah but a victim it's already
00:37:27 there it's already kind of like loaded yeah it's all very loaded but it's in the perception of the
00:37:33 victim that there is hostility or or anything or anybody else or anybody else now that means
00:37:40 in legal terms anybody yeah someone watching this now can decide that this is some form of
00:37:45 hate incident or something exactly and they can report it and that would be then on the statistics
00:37:50 wouldn't it yes yes it would be almost distinct in fact you talk about irony um mrs b who is the
00:38:00 the the the complainant in my case um published a statement anonymously two days ago in which they
00:38:08 accused the judge of a hate incident really yeah well you see by their own logic i guess
00:38:16 you know by their own skewed logic i guess you can see it can't you because because the guidance
00:38:22 says there is mandatory recording elsewhere it says use common sense but elsewhere it says
00:38:31 mandatory recording so which is it is it common sense or is it mandatory because it can't be both
00:38:38 words mean something and mandatory means mandatory that's what it that's what it says and also the
00:38:45 definition of hate if you look at the definition of hate it includes a dislike of that's right
00:38:52 this is in the this is in the CPS yeah sort of definition is it with hostility kami as you say
00:38:59 just simple dislike what what what does that mean I've no idea but one of the things it does mean
00:39:05 is this that momentum is a hate group yes because the momentum make no apology at all for hating on
00:39:12 tories so why is that not a hate why is that not why are they not a hate group you said before we
00:39:19 started recording that this was a kind of like a form of psychosis I mean it does seem to me to
00:39:28 be that there's a kind of madness going on isn't there well Douglas Murray writes about it doesn't
00:39:32 he yeah he talks about the madness of crowds and that's exactly what we've got here we've got a
00:39:35 we've got a form of utter utter madness where black is white up is down right is wrong
00:39:41 everything is evidence can be no evidence yeah how can that's what the guidance says no evidence of
00:39:49 the hate element is required for a hate incident or a hate crime how can that be how can the b
00:39:54 how can it say no evidence is required that's just nonsense it's a heckless charter it's a lunatics
00:40:03 charter quite frankly and mrs b in my case the judge was kind by saying that they were operating
00:40:11 on the outer edges of rationality i'd say they were just plain flipping nuts yeah um and you know
00:40:19 nutters are gonna nutter but what is really worrying is that the the police thought it was
00:40:26 a good idea to use the testimony of a raging lunatic that's because they've been on a course
00:40:33 yeah exactly but the you read you read through this the official victim statement the the evidence
00:40:41 that humberside presented and it says harry miller is a bigot he any ransom it says um that i'm in a
00:40:52 conspiracy with james kirkup of the spectator uh and um and joanie walsh from the telegraph i mean
00:40:58 i'm running a hate group with them and then it says quite bizarrely that 80 years ago i would
00:41:04 have been persecuting the jews 40 years ago i would have been persecuting the blacks 30 years ago
00:41:11 i would have been persecuting homosexuals well one i wasn't alive 80 years ago it may come as a
00:41:18 surprise to you and 30 years ago i was living with two homosexuals and i don't recall persecuting
00:41:27 either of them so it's just patent nonsense and what is worrying is the police with an entirely
00:41:35 straight face presented this as evidence now there is what is known in rad femme circles and
00:41:43 free speech circles as the mr justice knowles eye roll now my understanding is that high court
00:41:49 judges aren't supposed to roll their eyes but but the provocation in this instance was such
00:41:55 that even he with his steely judgy self could not but help himself and his eyes almost rolled
00:42:03 into eternity uh at that what was the reaction what has the reaction been on the whole
00:42:10 uh harry of the media to your case i don't know i mean i know that we've got the press on the one
00:42:17 hand but say the broadcast media people who've had your are they broadly sympathetic or have
00:42:23 you found yourself being exasperated by it i've been exasperated um i was exasperated by my local
00:42:32 bbc who who you know you go and give an interview to them and then they cut the interview right down
00:42:40 so you're basically saying very little and then they would have a local trans person on who would
00:42:46 be going on about how jokes can be so cruel all right well i don't recall writing i'm thinking
00:42:51 i didn't do any jokes i was part of a discussion but hey that's local that's local news for you
00:42:56 but then the press by and large
00:42:58 has been incredibly sympathetic
00:43:00 last week I was on
00:43:02 PM
00:43:03 I think I was the top story on PM
00:43:06 straight after the judgement
00:43:08 and what stunned me
00:43:10 is that the interviewer
00:43:12 I can't remember his name
00:43:13 all he wanted to talk about
00:43:16 was why I wasn't more kind
00:43:18 why I wasn't kinder
00:43:19 the story is not about kindness here
00:43:22 the story is about a police force
00:43:24 those would be called the Gestapo
00:43:25 the stasi and the checker and you want to talk about why can't we all be kind that's part that's
00:43:32 why i say there's a collective madness yes there is a collective madness and the bbc um in certain
00:43:38 instances are part and parcel of that madness oh without question what has been the kind of effect
00:43:45 on of this on you i mean have you had you know has it been sort of like a few long dark no nights
00:43:54 as it were of the soul you talk about a long night of the soul i did i had one i had one
00:43:59 very long dark night of the soul which was in october and it was it occurred when the
00:44:07 the witness statements from humberside came in up until that point i'd i knew i was in a fight
00:44:15 of a little man the against a very large organization humberside and then an even
00:44:20 larger organization the college of policing but still in my naivety i thought that we were fighting
00:44:27 fairly okay it was a flyweight against a heavyweight but still we were going to be fighting
00:44:33 fairly then i read the then i read the the statements and my heart dropped out my ass
00:44:44 the truth was told because they lied just plain straightforward lie lie number one was that um
00:44:53 pc gull statement said i did not say i need to check your thinking well he did he did
00:45:00 absolutely he did you know strike me down strike my family down he said it we had a full discussion
00:45:07 about 1984 no doubt about it second lie he didn't say about fetuses growing the wrong body parts and
00:45:16 that's what being trans is again 100% lie absolute lie third lie was that it was a phone call which
00:45:27 lasted no more than 20 minutes except i rang him remember and it was a 34 minute phone call
00:45:33 so another lie verifiable lie but even if it was only a 20 minute phone call what he said he said
00:45:42 in that phone call wouldn't last two minutes let alone 20 what else did we what did we discuss did
00:45:48 we discuss the football did we plan a family holiday together did we ask about each other's
00:45:53 kids what did we talk about for 20 minutes even if even if your 20 minutes was right you can't
00:45:58 fill it my account you can fill all 34 and some so at that point i realized oh my god
00:46:06 not only are they heavyweights but they've got a knife down the trouser pocket and a horseshoe
00:46:12 in the glove and um i was very nearly very nearly broken very very nearly broken well it sort of
00:46:21 shakes one's whole confidence in you know what we've grown up believing in a way about our
00:46:27 institutions doesn't it well like i said to you earlier i'm not a i don't look good in a tinfoil
00:46:32 hat i'm not a conspiracy theorist i will back the police absolutely 100 to the hilt um i think by
00:46:39 and large police officers are good i think our four police force is good i'm pro i am absolutely
00:46:46 prime pro police and to see absolute lies being presented for the high court stunned me i had a
00:46:56 very near breakdown it was october um i i just lost it i took my car to um the humber bridge
00:47:09 i got out of my car and i started walking across the humber bridge
00:47:13 and i looked over and thought god that would be tempting just just stop it all now i don't think
00:47:21 i really i don't think i i think it would be wrong to say that i i was on the point of jumping
00:47:28 but i knew i was in a really bad place really bad place so what i did was i just kept walking i
00:47:37 decided my rational brain said just keep walking get as far away from that bridge as is possible
00:47:42 and i walked and i walked and i walked i was wearing a pair of gardening shoes and an old
00:47:47 jumper and a gillet I walked and walked and I was still walking at half past 12
00:47:54 at night I'd walked 30 miles 30 miles and eventually I got picked up by by my
00:48:02 wife found me and the police found me and I was frozen solid yeah absolutely
00:48:07 frozen solid and I didn't know what I was doing I was just I was just out of
00:48:12 it my wife took me home I eventually got warm and then I woke up the following
00:48:17 morning and my wife said do you want to give up and I said we can't do can we do
00:48:23 we just can't and she's in you're right we can't give up we've come this far
00:48:27 we've got to keep going and we did what but you talk about the long night of the
00:48:31 soul I had that was that was a long night that was a really long night because you
00:48:36 i'm a tough guy yeah right i'm not i'm not i'm a tough fella but they're the police and the home
00:48:44 at the humberside police and the college of policing and humberside lying straight forward
00:48:51 lying it absolutely ripped my world apart it really really did i was i was not expecting that
00:48:58 when you stood outside the high court last last week uh i hope you had a different feeling
00:49:06 i loved it yeah it was it was a superb feeling because there was the personal vindication
00:49:15 of course which is good for which is good for my family um because you know you don't want
00:49:22 they don't want a family member to be associated with hate and this that the other even if they
00:49:28 know there's nothing in it it's really nice to have a high court judge of course um authenticate
00:49:34 that but more more i think for my organization fair cop the support i've had from the fair cop
00:49:43 members which includes serving police officers and a whole bunch of really really good people
00:49:50 who've got to remain anonymous obviously um and the public and for the public yeah because i knew
00:49:56 I knew that this was a watershed
00:49:58 moment and I knew
00:50:00 that the language
00:50:02 that Mr Justice Knowles
00:50:04 had used
00:50:06 was going to send shockwaves through
00:50:08 absolutely everything
00:50:10 to have a high court judge
00:50:12 say what he said
00:50:13 the judgement is 65
00:50:16 pages long, there are something like
00:50:18 290 paragraphs in it
00:50:20 the paragraph he chose, I think it's paragraph 279
00:50:23 that's the bit that he read out
00:50:24 Gestapo, Stasi, Czechoslovakia
00:50:26 i'm like get in there justice knowles and this is uh this is the first case of its kind isn't it i
00:50:35 mean this is a this is a landmark absolutely landmark case yeah you say it and even even now
00:50:43 saying i'm thinking yeah i'm looking at myself thinking how did i end up here you know my life
00:50:49 is about walking the dogs and doing a bit with the business and playing candy crush and watching
00:50:54 netflix it's not about it's not about changing the world but um that's what we're doing that's
00:51:00 what we're doing well no harry thank you so much for telling us chapter and verse on that i mean
00:51:05 uh you know i think it's a remarkable story and congratulations and also all the very best what
00:51:11 you do next you know yeah absolutely we've got we've got a lot going on we've got a lot going
00:51:15 we've got the supreme court and the little teaser this this story with humberside mine
00:51:20 i'll be over yet all right okay thank you very much thank you very much indeed harry um thanks
00:51:25 for watching um please do subscribe won't you and uh we'll see you next time thank you bye