New Culture Forum - March 02, 2020


2.18 Robin Aitken: BBC Bias - Distorting the truth

2.15 Zuby: How To Be a Rebel in the 2020s 2.19 Charles Coulombe: A Conservative Author Examines the Culture Wars in Trad. Institutions

Episode Stats


Length

40 minutes

Words per minute

141.0

Word count

5,749

Sentence count

194


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to So What You're Saying Is. I'm Peter Whittle. Now just over a year ago we
00:00:22 started this show and our very first guest is indeed my guest today I'm very pleased to say
00:00:28 Robin Aitken came on to our show to talk about the BBC.
00:00:33 He was at the BBC as a reporter over almost the whole spectrum of the BBC for 25 years.
00:00:40 And he wrote a book called Can We Trust the BBC?
00:00:43 And more recently, The Noble Liar.
00:00:47 Now, the BBC is pretty much at the top of our agenda at the moment on the news.
00:00:52 So I'm very, very grateful for you coming back, Robin.
00:00:54 Thank you very much.
00:00:56 I wanted to ask, when we spoke before, which was a year ago,
00:01:01 we were talking in quite general terms about the BBC,
00:01:04 but something seems to have changed.
00:01:06 And I wonder, what do you think it is that's actually changed?
00:01:10 Well, I suppose the obvious answer to that is that the general election turned out as it did.
00:01:15 And I think that that changed the game completely,
00:01:19 politically, as far as the BBC was concerned.
00:01:22 The problem for the BBC is that over a period of many years it has made enemies, and the BBC has been oblivious to its critics.
00:01:36 They've not engaged with their critics, and consequently the things which people on the right particularly find objectionable about the BBC have simply got worse.
00:01:51 and there's a sort of sense of reckoning now
00:01:55 because I think there are people in government
00:01:58 influential people in government
00:01:59 who believe that the BBC has become in certain ways the enemy
00:02:03 and that's not a healthy place for an organisation like the BBC to find itself
00:02:09 When you say the enemy, do you mean the enemy of the government
00:02:14 or do you mean actually the enemy of the country?
00:02:19 Well, let's put it this way
00:02:20 The BBC has a large body of support in the country
00:02:26 But the support that it has is fairly cohesive culturally
00:02:32 There is a cultural elite which very much likes what the BBC does
00:02:38 And approves of it very strongly
00:02:40 And they are a very influential and powerful group
00:02:44 So they're supporters of the BBC
00:02:47 But on the other side, you've got also a substantial minority of people who feel the BBC distorts the news in a way which is not to their liking.
00:03:04 That people feel the BBC doesn't speak for them, doesn't speak to them, doesn't allow them to speak to us.
00:03:13 BBC, you know, is fairly, it has become a bit of a bubble, in a way, a cultural bubble.
00:03:22 You know that at one point, when you talk about the news,
00:03:25 it used to always be Tory MPs complaining about a lack of, as it were, balance on the Today programme.
00:03:34 But it seems that there has been a greater recognition amongst the general public
00:03:41 of general drift, political drift, in the BBC, would you say?
00:03:46 Well, I think so.
00:03:48 And I think the obvious reason for that, or one of the reasons,
00:03:50 is that the Brexit debate, of course,
00:03:54 made people hyper-alert to what they were hearing and seeing.
00:03:58 So the thing about the Brexit debate was
00:04:01 that it divided the country into two camps
00:04:03 and both camps knew what they believed.
00:04:08 And people in the Brexit camp,
00:04:10 those who were in favour of leaving the EU,
00:04:15 found that the BBC did not represent their views.
00:04:19 They weren't hearing the voices of people making the argument
00:04:22 for Britain to leave the EU in the same way they were hearing repeatedly
00:04:26 the argument for the country to stay.
00:04:30 There was a huge imbalance.
00:04:32 And it wasn't just a question of counting numbers,
00:04:36 it's also a question of tone.
00:04:38 And I think the BBC gave the impression throughout that debate that it was firmly of the opinion that the country should stay in the EU and that further European integration was a good thing.
00:04:51 That was the tone of what they were saying.
00:04:54 And because of the imbalance also in the ratio of interviewees,
00:05:00 it was inevitable that leavers would feel a sense of chagrin about that.
00:05:10 So, you know, that's part of it.
00:05:13 I think when it comes to the way things have changed in people's attitudes to the BBC,
00:05:19 it seems to me that it's as i say it's not you mentioned brexit but also it is in the kind of
00:05:28 uh the woke progressive attitudes which increasingly unless i'm being paranoid
00:05:35 increasingly you see on the bbpc yeah i think that's absolutely true peter and i mean um so
00:05:41 as i said the the brexit debate was a contributory factor to what we're talking about which is this
00:05:47 sense of alienation that quite a lot of people feel towards the BBC now. So the Brexit debate
00:05:55 was one reason for that, but you put your finger on the other, which I think is an equally
00:06:00 important factor, and that is the, if you like, the cultural tone of the BBC. So what
00:06:07 cultures does the BBC extol? What cultures does it promote? And as you say, it's a very
00:06:15 woke culture. And so you get an imbalance because you get a lot of people campaigning
00:06:23 for and talking in favour of certain reforms, cultural reforms if you like, but these cover
00:06:32 the equality agenda, the inclusivity agenda, all these things. Now individually there's
00:06:41 nothing wrong with a lot of these campaigns but the problem is that they
00:06:46 hog the argument and that people feel they're being preached at by campaigning
00:06:54 groups with which they do not agree but never have their say and that's the
00:06:59 thing so you never hear the ordinary man in the streets argument against some of
00:07:05 this nonsense which is taught in the woke culture things which we all
00:07:09 understand and know about where the common sense view of the man or woman in
00:07:15 the street is quite different from that of the cultural elite that's the problem
00:07:19 it sort of comes through in things such as dramas and think you know non-news
00:07:25 things I mean I've jotted down a few things I remember Christmas time for
00:07:29 example I saw a Christmas Carol which had every issue sort of plugged into it
00:07:35 you know and elongated as a result uh totally unnecessary and also there's been a lot of fast
00:07:42 recently about this horrible histories yeah which is where it was that was classic stuff wasn't it
00:07:48 absolutely you know sort of basically everything you thought about Britain's not true it's basically
00:07:52 really terrible yes absolutely there's sort of cultural damage being done by that kind of thing
00:07:58 isn't there? It's the cultural sneer towards what one might call mainstream opinion. So
00:08:13 most people in the country, or I think, still feel pride in the country. And most people
00:08:22 feel patriotic to a certain extent.
00:08:26 Now, when the BBC portrays, as it very often does,
00:08:33 Britishness, British history, in a negative light,
00:08:39 people get their hackles up, you know?
00:08:44 Because I think it has become,
00:08:47 this is something which has become more and more pronounced.
00:08:49 That's the problem.
00:08:50 So, as you rightly say, these politically correct ideas are obtruding into all manner of output, drama output.
00:09:00 I mean, Doctor Who is the classic.
00:09:02 I don't watch Doctor Who, I might say.
00:09:04 But I know that there's been a lot of comment on the way that, you know, that when the doctor travels back in time, this anachronistic set of modern woke opinions is projected onto historical situations.
00:09:23 I mean, it's laughable, really. It's like a sort of, it really is quite Soviet in its intensity and in its ubiquity.
00:09:34 It's as though, you know, the BBC simply doesn't understand that it is out of step with a lot of people.
00:09:44 I mean, I think partly this is born out of almost a contempt for parts of British culture.
00:09:54 There are parts of British culture which the BBC actually does not approve of.
00:10:01 Such as?
00:10:02 Well, there are aspects of working class life, which involve things which the cultural elite
00:10:18 disapprove of. And so attitudes about gender relationships, about the way that men and
00:10:29 women live their lives in a more traditional way than is often portrayed, that the BBC
00:10:38 does not reflect and does not celebrate that kind of ordinary lifestyle. What it celebrates
00:10:43 is a transgressive lifestyle where we know what is approved of and we know what is disapproved
00:10:50 of. And I think that people are becoming increasingly aware of that fact, that actually
00:10:55 the BBC shuts them out of the conversation.
00:10:59 Is it just approval, or would you say that actually also the basis of it is a form of attack?
00:11:06 I mean, without wishing to get all culturally Marxists all over you here,
00:11:13 but it would appear like that, that actually ultimately the aim is to question to death, almost.
00:11:21 Yeah, I mean, I think, you know, there has been a swift and now complete takeover of the BBC by people who are culturally liberal.
00:11:35 More than when you were there?
00:11:37 Well, I think the process has gone on since I left, and, you know, I still keep in touch with people in the BBC,
00:11:44 so I know quite a lot about what goes on one way or another.
00:11:48 and there are many people in the BBC quite senior people a lot of them who
00:11:59 have misgivings about what's happening it's difficult for individuals to speak
00:12:05 up in the BBC and it certainly doesn't burnish your career prospects but there
00:12:14 is a problem and some people recognize it there's a report out today actually um recording this
00:12:22 which is all about people who work in the arts i saw that you saw this i read it and yeah it's
00:12:28 fascinating it's nothing we don't know robin really but to see it in black and white nevertheless
00:12:33 and i sort of include in that television obviously because these are these are sort of if you like
00:12:38 these are arts programs, these are the performing arts, the visual arts, all of them, people
00:12:46 employed in those areas. And essentially the report is saying that you just simply can't
00:12:51 have a dissenting game.
00:12:52 Yeah, no, absolutely. I thought that was a fascinating report. I read it closely actually
00:12:57 with close attention because I just thought how interesting that was because it confirms
00:13:01 much of what you hear anecdotally.
00:13:04 And I had an anecdote of my own, actually.
00:13:10 So I recently appeared, I was asked to go on to the BBC
00:13:15 for the first time, actually, for a number of years.
00:13:18 They asked me on to one of their radio shows, The Moral Maze,
00:13:21 and I talked about it.
00:13:22 It was about the BBC, Future All.
00:13:24 And so I had my say, and I said...
00:13:27 You were a witness on it, were you?
00:13:28 Yeah, I was just a witness.
00:13:29 You get your seven minutes, so you just get your little input.
00:13:31 which is actually not long actually
00:13:35 and of course you have to be guided by the questions you're asked
00:13:39 so it's not a wholly satisfactory format as far as I was concerned
00:13:42 but anyway, I said my piece
00:13:45 and a day later I got an email from a very senior producer
00:13:52 of a very long-running and high-profile BBC drama series
00:13:57 series, which has been in with the brickwork, as it were, saying that she would like to
00:14:09 be more inclusive in her scriptwriting team, but could find no writers who were prepared
00:14:19 to articulate other than the liberal orthodoxy in scripts.
00:14:25 Right.
00:14:25 And she asked me if I'd go and talk to them about, yeah, interestingly, so this person, and full marks to her, thought that, because my shtick when I'm asked about the BBC, what I often say is that the BBC talks a lot about diversity.
00:14:49 And it talks a lot about diversity in terms of skin colour, sexual orientation, etc, etc, etc.
00:14:56 We know the categories.
00:14:58 The category that is not included is political.
00:15:02 Diversity of opinion.
00:15:03 There's no political diversity within the BBC.
00:15:08 And this is conveniently left out of the equation.
00:15:12 Although when you think about it, it is vital for the BBC to have political diversity within it.
00:15:18 because lacking that diversity it finds it very difficult to be objective about issues that matter
00:15:25 to us all and that is where the blind spot is and the bbc unfortunately will not engage with its
00:15:31 critics it has shown you know a degree of contempt for public opinion but it has also shown
00:15:39 very visibly i think a contempt for political opinion particularly that associated with boris
00:15:47 Johnson. I saw an interview that Laura Koonsberg did with Boris Johnson during the course of
00:15:57 the Brexit campaign. She treated him with contempt, and he was Prime Minister at the
00:16:06 time, but there was no sense that this was a man that the office deserves respect.
00:16:17 It's the office, not the man.
00:16:20 It was all too obvious from this example and others
00:16:24 that there was a contempt for many of the conservatives,
00:16:29 conservative ideas,
00:16:31 and these were ideas which were, as it was then proved,
00:16:35 were popular in the country.
00:16:37 The country may not love the Tory party,
00:16:40 and one couldn't blame them for that.
00:16:43 I find as an object of affection,
00:16:45 The Tory party leaves a lot to be desired, but still they had the pulse of the nation, didn't they?
00:16:55 Just to go back to, you know, you told us when you were on the moral mace you got this email.
00:17:00 Will you go in and talk to the scriptwriters, do you think?
00:17:03 Yeah, of course. Why not?
00:17:05 She was asking basically how they should maybe include more diversity of opinion in their scripts.
00:17:12 is that what it is?
00:17:13 Yeah, exactly.
00:17:14 So I don't know if I'm particularly well suited to do this job
00:17:21 because I'm not a scriptwriter
00:17:24 but what I've been thinking about it
00:17:26 and it seems to me that
00:17:27 if you are portraying the lives of so-called ordinary people
00:17:35 the script writer's job is to
00:17:39 is to portray all kinds of lives
00:17:43 with all kinds of opinions
00:17:45 and all kinds of outcomes
00:17:48 and you know there is a pattern in BBC drama
00:17:51 where you know that by and large
00:17:54 anyone who's portrayed as a Tory
00:17:56 will be a baddie of some sort
00:17:58 and there is a sort of
00:18:02 distinct animus
00:18:04 against the upper class
00:18:06 I'm not upper class, clearly
00:18:08 I'm not upper class, so
00:18:09 it's not my class, but I can see that
00:18:12 the upper class is always portrayed
00:18:14 in a particular way
00:18:15 It's interesting you mention that because
00:18:17 they seem to be obsessed as well with the
00:18:20 Profumo affair
00:18:21 I just feel that I've seen a hell
00:18:24 of a lot, I mean we've just had this long drama
00:18:26 and I thought, why would this be
00:18:28 and I just thought, well it's about
00:18:29 how rotten the establishment was
00:18:32 I mean, it might well have been at the time, but you sort of think, what is it about this relatively minor piece of history, which is absolutely fascinating to me.
00:18:40 I was going to ask, do you, I mean, you went on Moral Mays, but do you watch much BBC yourself these days?
00:18:47 Not much, no.
00:18:52 I don't.
00:18:55 I listen to a lot of BBC.
00:18:57 and I
00:18:59 what I do use a lot
00:19:02 actually, the BBC
00:19:03 website, I use
00:19:06 that as a sort of
00:19:07 it's
00:19:11 it has a fairly decent coverage
00:19:14 I mean I also consume
00:19:16 every day
00:19:17 six or eight or ten
00:19:20 other news sites because I do it the whole time
00:19:22 and it's an obsessive thing
00:19:24 and sometimes
00:19:25 I regret the fact I spend so much time looking at this stuff, but I do, just to try to get
00:19:33 a sense of what is out there.
00:19:35 There are many things that, stories that interest me, which never appear on the BBC, for instance.
00:19:40 But on the other hand, if you go onto their news website, the world section, and you trawl
00:19:45 through the various sections, you'll usually find in there, you know, there are countries
00:19:50 I'm interested in like India a bit
00:19:52 and other parts of the world
00:19:54 America particularly
00:19:55 their American news has to be treated
00:19:58 with great circumspection
00:20:00 unfortunately
00:20:01 I think the BBC's coverage of Trump
00:20:06 and America this past four years
00:20:08 has been so bad
00:20:10 that I can
00:20:11 it astonishes me
00:20:13 that it is as partisan
00:20:16 as it is
00:20:17 I find it quite
00:20:19 startling really i think it's a it's almost there is a strange fascination with the american system
00:20:27 and american politics i think they've got something like 13 reporters or whatever
00:20:31 covering the american action and american politics is covered with a detail which is
00:20:36 actually quite extraordinary i know that america is a very important country but it is and and it
00:20:41 at the same time there is this horror of trump and i think that probably the people who are at the
00:20:46 BBC obviously don't really meet anyone who might actually have a good word to say about him
00:20:51 that's right I mean I've never heard anyone say a good word about Trump on the BBC it's like a
00:20:58 sort of I wonder whether what you think of this from that during the election obviously we had
00:21:06 this thing whereby Boris Johnson decided not to go on the Andrew Neil program yeah to be interviewed
00:21:12 and there was a huge kerfuffle
00:21:14 this was terrible for democracy etc
00:21:16 of course it just was entirely forgotten about
00:21:19 it made no difference at all to anybody
00:21:21 at the election
00:21:23 and then we had this thing
00:21:24 whereby senior ministers
00:21:26 were kind of boycotting the Today programme
00:21:29 not necessarily wanting to make a trend out of this
00:21:33 but it does appear that
00:21:35 there is now a more American approach actually
00:21:39 which is that we're not going to do this media
00:21:41 if we're constantly going to be treated in this way.
00:21:44 Absolutely.
00:21:45 Do you think that's a good thing?
00:21:49 Well, before I answer that, actually,
00:21:52 something that struck me has been a trend
00:21:55 which has quickened in recent years,
00:21:59 which is something which in...
00:22:04 You know, one talks like an old fart when you get to this point,
00:22:07 but, you know, in my day, right?
00:22:09 the idea of inviting a government minister on to the today program sitting him down asking
00:22:16 minister tell us what government policy is at the end of which you turn to your political editor
00:22:22 who's sitting in the same studio and you say well laura um what is this what do you make what is
00:22:32 your comment on what the minister has just said. And very often, that would be an oppositional
00:22:38 stance. So as it were, what the BBC did was, he invited a government minister in and then
00:22:44 sets up a rival authority alongside, who comments on what has just been said, with
00:22:49 no right of reply, of course, by the politician sitting there. Now, of course, part of the
00:22:56 job of senior bbc journalist is to explain the world to the audience but the way that was done
00:23:07 made it very often seem to me the bbc was saying you can't trust this guy whoever it is and whatever
00:23:13 they've said and we've got to interpret that for you right here and now with this person sitting
00:23:17 next year now that elevates the status of the journalist to that of pundit and she or he
00:23:26 becomes actually an influential person in their own right and I think there were times when the
00:23:32 BBC did that too often and very often the the comments which came immediately after the the
00:23:39 ministers interview were very negative and very oppositional and you know is
00:23:48 that the right thing for the BBC to do and I'm not surprised in fact I think I
00:23:53 think it's very smart actually because the today program with the input of
00:24:02 government ministers stripped out is definitely hollowed out to a certain
00:24:06 extent and um the you will know this if you've um i'm sure you do that one of the things which
00:24:13 current affairs shows like today care about is what we call pickup you know has this story been
00:24:19 picked up yeah now there was a time when because of its status and its position as the the bbc's
00:24:27 most important current affairs show that um someone appearing on the 810 slot there would
00:24:34 very often be picked up by the daily papers by everyone else it sets the agenda for the day you
00:24:39 know it often carries on into the next day and so those sorts of interviews are really the the
00:24:47 raison d'etre of such a program these are the these are the interviews the program wants to do
00:24:52 the program wants to have the environment minister on you know and you need that to talk about you
00:25:00 the green agenda
00:25:02 and all that. Stripped of that
00:25:04 it makes the Today
00:25:06 program much less
00:25:08 necessary listening I'm afraid
00:25:10 and I've certainly
00:25:12 although
00:25:13 it's not because I have any loyalty
00:25:16 to the Today program especially
00:25:18 although I loved working there
00:25:19 I worked under Rod Liddle
00:25:21 Oh wow
00:25:23 an esteemed guest of this show
00:25:26 and
00:25:27 so those were great days
00:25:29 and I loved working actually for today.
00:25:32 It was a great show to work for.
00:25:35 But they have brought this on themselves, not today alone,
00:25:40 but the BBC in general has got up the nose of the wrong people
00:25:45 because those people, very unluckily for it, have now arrived in government.
00:25:51 And there is, I think, the whiff of comeuppance in the air.
00:25:59 We start off by saying that there is something about the current sort of discussion,
00:26:06 particularly about the licence fee, which feels more serious than whatever that I can remember it.
00:26:12 It is now a discussion, it's on the agenda, and there is an assumption behind it.
00:26:17 It seems actually there's a growing consensus that this simply cannot go on, would you say?
00:26:22 Or am I being too optimistic about that?
00:26:24 I think there are two things to say about the licence fee.
00:26:27 One is that it is failing a technical test in the sense of, is this a justifiable tax as it once was, given that there are some and a growing number of people, apparently, who don't use the service?
00:26:49 so that's the sort of technical aspect of it
00:26:51 but there's another point
00:26:54 and this actually means
00:26:56 that in my view very little is going to happen about this
00:26:59 at least in the near future
00:27:01 is that
00:27:02 people talk about
00:27:06 okay if you get rid of the license fee
00:27:08 what comes next
00:27:09 and people are talking about a subscription model
00:27:12 the problem with that is
00:27:14 a technical problem also
00:27:16 which is that
00:27:17 BBC services are not currently set up
00:27:20 and the technology does not exist
00:27:22 to make the BBC into a subscription service.
00:27:25 And also what you would have to do,
00:27:27 I mean, one of the things that would have to happen
00:27:28 is that everyone would have to have a new kit in their homes
00:27:31 or the pensioners would have to have a new kit in their homes.
00:27:34 This is not a small undertaking.
00:27:36 And so you can't simply change the BBC into a subscription model.
00:27:41 So that's one thing.
00:27:42 On the other hand, you're right, it is now on the agenda.
00:27:45 And because of the first thing I mentioned, the fact that there is a growing number of people who don't use the service and yet still have to pay.
00:27:52 And it's the equity of that, I suppose, which is driving that particular argument.
00:27:58 And you've got to make a political decision about that in conjunction with the BBC about what can be done about that.
00:28:06 Because, you know, it is a problem.
00:28:08 What would you do, actually?
00:28:09 I mean, what would you like to see?
00:28:11 Would you like to see the licence fee gone entirely?
00:28:13 would you or some people want a bit of it kept don't they well what I mean you
00:28:20 know I constantly talk with friends and you know other journalists about this
00:28:26 sort of thing and and some of my friends and one man I'm thinking of me in
00:28:36 particular a senior commentator in the newspapers he has lost patience with the
00:28:42 BBC. He now thinks that the BBC cannot be reformed and therefore it's outlived its usefulness
00:28:54 as a concept. And I have always argued for reform for BBC. And it's a bit like being
00:29:11 You know, it's a bit like those people who were sceptical of the EU
00:29:15 and wanted to reform it but not leave it, you know.
00:29:18 It's that sort of stance I've taken.
00:29:22 But I'm not sure whether that is tenable.
00:29:25 If the BBC, we are at a, it feels as if we're at some sort of critical point for the BBC.
00:29:35 Well, isn't this also, because in seven years' time,
00:29:38 the charter comes up for renewal
00:29:40 so that's a kind of decent time
00:29:43 isn't it if you like for this to take
00:29:45 root or a different approach to take root
00:29:47 yes
00:29:48 yeah that's right
00:29:50 I wonder what the BBC
00:29:53 internally, can you speculate
00:29:54 what their attitude will be to what's
00:29:57 happening at the moment
00:29:58 this isn't just an obsession
00:30:01 of the likes of you and me
00:30:02 and think tanks and what have you
00:30:05 it is actually sort of
00:30:07 right out there, and it is being discussed.
00:30:10 Will they be circling the wagons,
00:30:12 or will they start to get aggressively defensive?
00:30:18 Will they start to put out their stool, or what?
00:30:22 I've heard things like Steve Coogan saying,
00:30:25 I'll be first at the barricades,
00:30:27 and defending the BBC.
00:30:30 Well, I mean, it's been interesting
00:30:34 seeing what has been said.
00:30:36 I mean, the BBC has taken quite a firm stance that it doesn't want to see the license fee system ended.
00:30:44 So it's very pro-maintaining the current.
00:30:46 The status quo is what it generally likes, and it's worried about the ending of any criminal sanction,
00:30:55 legal sanction rather than non-payment of the license.
00:30:58 So, you know, if that is decriminalized, then that would have an impact too.
00:31:02 So these are things that the BBC is against and which worry it.
00:31:06 So, in the more general sense of what the higher echelons of the BBC think about the current situation, well, my speculation would be worth no more than anyone else's because I don't move in those circles.
00:31:26 But I think that there will be some in the higher reaches of the corporation
00:31:34 who are thinking seriously about the current situation.
00:31:40 And if they have any sense, they'll be trying to formulate some sort of truce between the organization and the BBC.
00:31:54 It's essential for the BBC.
00:31:55 If the BBC wants to maintain the status quo, which I believe it does, maintaining the status quo is going to mean reaching an accommodation with the government.
00:32:06 And this means defanging the government's critics.
00:32:10 So how do you do that?
00:32:11 Well, there has to be, you know, we are waiting for some white smoke from the top of the Vatican.
00:32:17 that we want to
00:32:23 I was asked of all these stupid
00:32:27 one of these irritating
00:32:30 runners and riders thing
00:32:35 for a news outlet
00:32:37 so I was asked to do one
00:32:39 and so
00:32:41 that appointment
00:32:44 the successor to Tony Hall
00:32:46 will be an important appointment, not just in terms of the talents and inclinations of
00:32:52 the person who gets it, but as a visible sign that the BBC is prepared to treat with the
00:33:03 government. I mean, I don't see any, at the moment, I think probably the BBC, it must
00:33:13 still be working out what it's about you know i mean we you know we're in we we are in a new
00:33:20 a new a new a new situation here these are uncharted waters for the beep and they have to
00:33:25 tread carefully to make sure that the response they eventually do come up with um is going to
00:33:32 be a good defensive posture i think you say that on uncharted waters but i think it was a chairman
00:33:38 recently, I was talking in defence
00:33:40 of the BBC, and he
00:33:42 said, the thing I've heard
00:33:44 time immemorial
00:33:46 the BBC brings
00:33:48 the country together
00:33:49 and he used as the example
00:33:52 Gavin and Stacey doing
00:33:54 very well at Christmas
00:33:55 and Royal Weddings
00:33:58 Jubilees, sports event
00:34:00 but the truth is
00:34:02 if you take that apart, there was a rather
00:34:04 there was a rather careworn
00:34:06 feel actually about that
00:34:08 Gavin and Stacey got something like
00:34:11 11 million which is good in this day
00:34:13 and age but it's not 30 million
00:34:14 like it used to and there are all sorts of
00:34:17 reasons for that and also
00:34:18 does it actually bring the
00:34:20 country together anymore I mean
00:34:22 when it did the Jubilee it made an absolute
00:34:25 mess of it
00:34:25 this goes back to what I was
00:34:30 saying earlier about the tone of the BBC
00:34:32 I don't think the BBC
00:34:34 understands any longer
00:34:37 how to get on the nation's wavelength.
00:34:40 Yes.
00:34:41 You know, it really doesn't.
00:34:43 It doesn't have the pulse of the country.
00:34:49 And it's not only in its news
00:34:52 and current affairs output,
00:34:54 it's also in its drama output.
00:34:57 It's in every aspect of the output.
00:35:00 The BBC too often finds itself...
00:35:04 You know, I mean, sometimes it seems to me, certainly during the most sort of tensest and most agonizing parts of the Brexit debate, BBC sometimes sounded to me as if, I tune in, it was as if I was listening to a foreign broadcaster media.
00:35:24 There was so little identification with the country.
00:35:30 So it was as if, you know, what the Continentals, whatever, Barnier or any of them, you know,
00:35:37 that weary list of characters that we've all now shunted to the back of our minds, hopefully forever.
00:35:46 All those names that were the daily stuff of the today show, you know,
00:35:51 And the way in which all too often it seemed as if the implicit attitude of the program and the interviewers was that the E was in the right.
00:36:07 And whatever we were saying was either laughably implausible or wrong or stupid.
00:36:14 so it felt very much
00:36:17 at times to me
00:36:19 as if I was listening to
00:36:21 there was just a palpable
00:36:25 hostility
00:36:26 too much of a distance
00:36:28 yes exactly because
00:36:31 what the BBC
00:36:32 always proclaims
00:36:35 about its news is the Tittachee's
00:36:37 objectivity
00:36:38 and
00:36:40 that is a difficult
00:36:43 concept to define
00:36:46 in terms of journalism
00:36:48 and it's also
00:36:50 an even more difficult
00:36:52 quality to master
00:36:54 and employ
00:36:55 the truly objective journalists
00:36:58 I think are very few
00:37:01 and far between, they are masters of their trade
00:37:03 I'm not one of them
00:37:06 but there are
00:37:08 many men and women I've known over the years
00:37:11 who
00:37:11 have
00:37:13 striven to be objective
00:37:15 and some of them have attained that
00:37:17 these are largely BBC people
00:37:19 but not just BBC people, other people in other
00:37:22 aspects, you know
00:37:23 newspapers and so on, people who've
00:37:25 really
00:37:26 striven for a sort of
00:37:29 clear-sighted and honest view
00:37:33 of
00:37:34 British affairs
00:37:36 it's difficult, it's difficult because
00:37:39 Because none of us is, we all carry with us these, you know, our carrier bag of opinions
00:37:46 and prejudices and views, don't we?
00:37:49 And, you know, I do, I know.
00:37:51 And so if you ask me, could I be objective about Irish nationalism, for instance,
00:37:57 I would say no, I couldn't.
00:38:00 No, I completely see that.
00:38:02 But that was something that they majored on for a long time at BBC.
00:38:06 and I think that it's, particularly with the advent of social media
00:38:09 and people sounding off on Twitter, you know, reporters,
00:38:12 this is another thing, isn't it?
00:38:15 I think finally, I think what maybe is a bit of a wall shed at the moment,
00:38:19 you refer to it there, is the decriminalisation of the licence fee.
00:38:24 Yeah.
00:38:24 This will be the sort of, the real thin end of the wedge,
00:38:27 if there is that feeling about it.
00:38:29 Yeah, I think so.
00:38:30 And it almost, I would have thought that will happen, actually, won't it?
00:38:33 well I don't know if it will or not
00:38:37 I think that it
00:38:38 I can see it happening
00:38:40 I think it's conceivable that it will happen
00:38:43 and it's something that
00:38:45 you rightly say
00:38:46 the thing is that of course
00:38:49 it can be justified
00:38:51 that's the point
00:38:52 so
00:38:53 you can make a case for decriminalizing it
00:38:58 and it's a plausible case
00:38:59 especially as
00:39:00 that particular thing
00:39:03 bears hardest on that sector of the population which is very often the least able to pay yes
00:39:09 you know so what you're doing is you're taking poor people through a legal process
00:39:14 to screw 150 quid out of them on the bbc's part and um you know that there is a sort of
00:39:22 basic inequity about that in a way i think it's the poor which you know it's the poor who always
00:39:30 get, always get
00:39:31 the dirty end of the stick
00:39:33 and it's, in that
00:39:36 sense it's, of course
00:39:38 the BBC then, it is a difficult
00:39:40 argument for it because it will know this
00:39:42 as well, that actually
00:39:43 what I've just said
00:39:46 that a lot of people who do get
00:39:47 taken to court are those who are
00:39:50 the poorest and I don't
00:39:52 think that'll sit easily with the BBC
00:39:53 itself probably because there are a lot of good
00:39:55 hearted people in it who will think that's
00:39:57 wrong. So, you know
00:39:59 I think you're right actually, that could easily
00:40:02 happen, I don't know if it will
00:40:03 I think probably, yeah, you might be right
00:40:06 actually, it could well happen
00:40:07 Put it this way, the issue is
00:40:10 not going away this time, is it?
00:40:11 It's not going away. It's live
00:40:13 and it's out there. Well while it's not going
00:40:15 away, that means you're going to be on here
00:40:17 quite a few times, Robin, actually
00:40:19 just as a full warning
00:40:21 because your perspective is just
00:40:23 so invaluable to us
00:40:26 Thanks very much
00:40:27 coming back this time and I reckon that maybe in this time next year if not
00:40:31 before there might have been some big movement on this who knows yeah thank
00:40:37 you thank you very much for watching do subscribe to us won't you please and I
00:40:42 will see you next time thank you very much