New Culture Forum - June 19, 2019


23. Tim Montgomerie - The State Of Conservatism

22. Simon Richards: The State of Freedom & The Nation 24. Twitter phenomenon ‘Titania McGrath’ aka comedian Andrew Doyle

Episode Stats


Length

29 minutes

Words per minute

171.95

Word count

5,115

Sentence count

195


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to So What You're Saying Is. I'm Peter Whittle.
00:00:09 Now, my guest this week is one of Britain's best-known Conservative commentators.
00:00:14 Tim Montgomery was founder of the Conservative Home website.
00:00:18 Before that, he was co-founder of the Centre for Social Justice.
00:00:22 He has worked right at the very heart of the British political establishment.
00:00:26 he was columnist for the Times and most recently he was editor of the unheard
00:00:31 commentary site that is really some CV there Tim although I'm not sure given
00:00:36 the health and the status of the British political establishment to be
00:00:39 described someone has been at the heart of it I'm not sure that was a kind thing
00:00:42 to say Tim we first met each other it must be now about 12 years ago and there
00:00:50 was something eventually called 18 Doughty Street I mean can you explain a
00:00:53 bit what that was actually because you were that was your baby wasn't it I was certainly involved
00:00:58 in it and it was of course where we first really came across each other and I think it was an
00:01:02 issue ahead of its time really I think it was the idea behind it was that the mainstream media
00:01:09 conversation at that time had all the signs of the problems we're now all too familiar with and
00:01:15 we wanted to create something and you know we took the advantage of the fact that the number of the
00:01:21 house that we were based in was 18 and we called it politics for adults and we had the 18 sign as
00:01:27 it was another cinema certification and what we wanted was grown up extended conversation rather
00:01:34 than the soundbite narrow conversations that were too dominant then is still too dominant now but
00:01:40 you ran a fantastic culture program yeah I remember with the new culture forum but I think
00:01:46 internet speeds was too slow then people didn't have the bandwidth and so what we
00:01:51 were trying to broadcast was just hard for people to consume on a on a
00:01:54 technical level as much as anything in it it unfortunately didn't quite last but
00:01:58 it was actually before its time wasn't it really yeah I mean we didn't have
00:02:01 YouTube then if I if I know that was the big difference did we have YouTube there
00:02:05 I think it might have sort of been emerging but it wasn't sort of mainstream
00:02:08 but I can't quite remember but no I don't think it was a big thing but coming
00:02:12 right up to date here I mean we can't really get away from it obviously we're
00:02:15 recording this at the end of what the first really intense week if you like of the Tory leadership
00:02:20 campaign something that you would by by matter of course be commenting on um I wonder when you
00:02:28 view it are you viewing it as a commentator or do you have a dog in this fight as it were
00:02:33 well uh I love the Conservative Party that may sound an odd thing to say but I really some of
00:02:43 my most my first political memories were well actually it was a school teacher who told me at
00:02:50 school that military that nuclear weapons were horrible things and that we should be ashamed of
00:02:55 them and I went home to my dad who was a in the army and told him how ashamed I was of him and
00:03:02 he introduced me to the idea of nuclear deterrence and I went back to my teacher the next day hand up
00:03:08 And thereon, I saw this lady on the television with her big hair and a blue suit and a handbag,
00:03:15 and I sort of fell in love with her a bit.
00:03:16 And that, for me, was the Conservative Party at its best.
00:03:20 I thought the Conservative Party rescued Britain from a post-war malaise.
00:03:25 And I think throughout its history, whether you look at Churchill or other great leaders
00:03:30 and Wilberforce and Shaftesbury's Conservative politicians,
00:03:33 I think the Conservative Party has played an important role in the life of this nation.
00:03:37 And at the moment, it's a sick institution. It's failed to deliver Brexit. Theresa May has been a disastrous Prime Minister. And I'm just grateful that we have an opportunity for a new leader, start to get it right. And I hope that somehow that great decision that the British people took in June 2016 will finally be delivered properly by a new Prime Minister.
00:04:00 So I'm fascinated by it, I'm involved by it, I'm worried and hopeful in equal measure,
00:04:08 but it really matters.
00:04:10 And I think we probably know who's going to win now, Boris Johnson,
00:04:15 but there is a history of frontrunners not succeeding,
00:04:19 and so no chickens should be counted yet.
00:04:22 How many leadership contests have you actually, as it were,
00:04:25 commented on or been involved with in some way?
00:04:28 It's a lot, isn't it now?
00:04:29 Quite a few. And the website that you mentioned, Conservative Home, that really took off because of the leadership contest between David Cameron and David Davis.
00:04:40 We were the first sort of website to do the tracker of MPs at that time, which MPs were backing who and how many.
00:04:49 And we tried to, I think probably one of the things I'm most proud of in my time in politics and public life was, I don't know if you remember,
00:04:56 but Michael Howard tried to take the vote away from individual party members
00:05:01 and to make it a decision only of MPs.
00:05:04 And actually I thought, well, the people who day in, day out volunteer for the party
00:05:08 without hope of reward should continue to have a say in choosing who leads their party.
00:05:15 And so, yeah, I've got a fondness for leadership elections
00:05:19 because they were quite good for my career and earnings as well as everything else.
00:05:23 Because the Conservative Home website, it seemed to me at the time, sort of really in a way, well you might disagree with this, but sort of replaced in a way, or rather it was the voice, it was meant to be the voice of the grassroots of the Tory party, wasn't it?
00:05:36 And I just remember at that time, when I was getting re-involved in politics, that it was the time of the Notting Hill Tories, or maybe that was just a bit before, and I got the feeling that they were sort of rather ashamed of their own members.
00:05:50 So I remember having that feeling that they would rather they weren't there.
00:05:53 Do you think that that was justified, do you think?
00:05:56 Well, there is this view, and it's still alive today,
00:06:00 that Tory members are sort of right-wing bigots,
00:06:03 and the idea that these people, and they're all old, etc.,
00:06:06 one of the worst sins you can commit now, it seems to be old,
00:06:10 and that they shouldn't really have the say in the future of the country that they do.
00:06:14 But actually, if you look, Marcus Roberts, who is a Labour supporter, a pollster,
00:06:20 was saying to me recently he thinks that if you compare the record of Tory and Labour local
00:06:27 associations in the selection of candidates in open meetings Tory members are more likely to
00:06:34 select ethnic minority candidates and more likely to let openly gay people than the Labour Party
00:06:40 and you know these people aren't just old right-wing Tories they're grands they're granddads
00:06:47 They're military veterans, they're community volunteers.
00:06:50 These are people absolutely embedded in their society.
00:06:54 And they're in politics because of belief and principle and patriotism.
00:06:59 And most MPs, I think, are as well.
00:07:01 But MPs, of course, also have a job and a reward out of this.
00:07:05 And I think we have a nice balance now in the Conservative Party.
00:07:09 In our way, we choose our leader between MPs choosing the two that go to the country
00:07:15 and then the party in the country choosing between those two.
00:07:20 But Conservative Home and the internet,
00:07:22 well, the internet has lots of problems.
00:07:23 We're all familiar with them.
00:07:25 But what Conservative Home was part of and still part of
00:07:29 is a decentralisation of power from the centre.
00:07:32 No longer was it just journalists in Westminster
00:07:34 deciding what to present as the picture of the grassroots.
00:07:39 We now have our own place where we congregate and say what we want.
00:07:43 And we've been doing it now for 15 years.
00:07:45 and I'm very proud it's still going.
00:07:47 You mentioned there at the very beginning
00:07:49 that someone who inspired you
00:07:51 was this lady you saw on television
00:07:53 with blonde hair and blue dress,
00:07:54 whatever, and a handbag, presumably, as well.
00:07:57 What do you think she would make
00:07:59 of this contest at the moment?
00:08:01 Do you think she'd have a...
00:08:02 Who would she go for, do you think?
00:08:04 Oh, that's a question and a...
00:08:05 That's a question and a half.
00:08:08 Well, look, I'm biased, Peter,
00:08:12 and I think we're recording this conversation
00:08:14 on a Friday I think it's a couple of days before it goes out and so events may even take overtake
00:08:20 what I'm about to say but I was at university with Sajid Javid who's the British Home Secretary
00:08:25 and we've been friends for 30 years I after we left university we moved into a flat together
00:08:31 and I know him to be a man of enormous integrity and deep conservative conviction and I know he's
00:08:39 a conservative. I don't believe in identity politics. He's fundamentally, for me, a sound
00:08:45 conservative. But Mrs Thatcher, you know, she broke through the barrier of becoming Britain's
00:08:52 first female prime minister. The Tory party, for all of the accusations that the left throws at it
00:08:58 of somehow being a backward-looking party, had the first Jewish leader and prime minister,
00:09:02 the first female prime minister, the second female prime minister. Sajid Javid is the first
00:09:08 Asian Britain to hold one of the great offices of state and I think Mrs Thatcher might quite like
00:09:15 the story of this guy who's risen from nothing, son of a Pakistan bus driver and risen to the top
00:09:22 of society and he's of Muslim background but he's probably the staunchest defender of Israel
00:09:28 in the cabinet. I think he's a remarkable man and so I'd have to say Margaret Thatcher would
00:09:34 choose him because I'm choosing him, but whether she would or not, I don't know.
00:09:39 Do you think, what would she make of, you said the Conservative Party is a sick institution at the moment.
00:09:46 What do you think, would she despair, do you think, if she were around now?
00:09:51 I think she'd be furious, just as I think grassroots members are furious.
00:09:57 I left the Conservative Party briefly
00:10:03 when David Cameron came back with his deal from Brussels
00:10:08 when he said he'd renegotiated our relationship with Britain
00:10:12 in a fundamental way
00:10:14 and for me it was only a cosmetic renegotiated
00:10:17 I know you agree with that
00:10:19 and I resigned at that point
00:10:20 because I was so angry at the insult to intelligence
00:10:24 it was my protest
00:10:26 And then when Theresa May became leader and said Brexit means Brexit and said she was going to implement the referendum, I rejoined.
00:10:36 I'm still not to this day sure which is the worst decision, leaving or rejoining.
00:10:43 But it was the most important vote of British post-war history, in my view, the decision to leave the European Union.
00:10:50 And the fact that the Conservative Party has messed it up.
00:10:54 Theresa May definitely is an awful prime minister.
00:10:56 But the cabinet sat round that table, acquiescing in most of the bad decisions that she made,
00:11:03 and it was a contest for how many bad decisions she made.
00:11:06 She appointed a chancellor who is a do-nothing chancellor at a time when lots of people voted to leave the European Union,
00:11:12 but also a fundamental reset of public policy.
00:11:15 The Conservative Party has done very little.
00:11:17 She promised to tackle the injustice of her time.
00:11:21 When she stood on the steps of Downing Street on her first day in the office,
00:11:25 she hasn't done anything like, and really begun to do it.
00:11:29 And Mrs Thatcher was not, I think, the politician that some people remember.
00:11:34 She'd left the NHS untouched, she left much of the welfare state untouched.
00:11:37 She was quite pragmatic.
00:11:39 But the things that she said she would do, like tame the unions,
00:11:42 like control inflation, like station nuclear weapons in Britain
00:11:47 so that we would deter the Soviet Union, she did.
00:11:52 nobody really thought Mrs Thatcher
00:11:55 spun
00:11:55 and deviated
00:11:58 they knew she was a conviction politician
00:12:00 and I think she'd be
00:12:01 appalled really that the Conservative Party
00:12:05 has been so weak
00:12:06 in delivery over the last three years
00:12:08 Have you been
00:12:11 watching the programme about her, the BBC documentary?
00:12:13 Yeah, well I'm not sure
00:12:15 how often we're allowed to say good things
00:12:17 about the BBC
00:12:18 We've already said about this programme
00:12:21 I think it seems to be remarkably even-handed, actually.
00:12:23 Good.
00:12:24 I think it's a superb documentary,
00:12:26 with the archive material.
00:12:27 Have you been enjoying it?
00:12:29 I have indeed,
00:12:29 and I think it's beautifully done as well as anything.
00:12:32 But I think you mentioned that,
00:12:35 and we discussed this, I remember, a long time ago,
00:12:37 that Thatcher, you know, one of my stuff,
00:12:39 but it was largely an economic thing, wasn't it?
00:12:43 Thatcherism.
00:12:44 Yes.
00:12:44 That so much of what has, you know,
00:12:47 united people on the centre-right,
00:12:48 or the right, call it what you want,
00:12:50 have been cultural issues, I would say.
00:12:52 And I think that, wouldn't you say that
00:12:55 Thatcher, in a way, wasn't that interested in those particular areas?
00:12:59 I mean, or rather, maybe they weren't compelling areas at the time.
00:13:03 I think every Prime Minister has to be judged in the context of their times.
00:13:09 And in the end of the 1970s, before she came to power,
00:13:13 the question really wasn't so much how Britain should be governed,
00:13:17 but whether Britain could be governed at all.
00:13:19 the trade unions were largely in charge
00:13:21 there were three day weeks in the
00:13:23 1970s, there was a whole sense of
00:13:25 Britain being in decline
00:13:27 and ungovernable, strikes
00:13:29 industrial decline
00:13:32 we were a nation
00:13:33 really with a massive identity crisis
00:13:35 and a huge brain drain, some of the most
00:13:37 talented people
00:13:38 in our country were going abroad
00:13:41 because they were giving up on Britain
00:13:43 London was quite a grey
00:13:45 down at hill place
00:13:47 and Mrs Thatcher came in and she fundamentally changed that.
00:13:52 That was the great success of her time
00:13:54 and she did it by restoring the authority of government
00:13:57 and she did it by rewarding those people who made good decisions
00:14:02 and so suddenly talent and investment started flowing into the country again
00:14:07 and still we benefit today from the fact that Britain is the leading place for inward investment.
00:14:13 She took lots of brave decisions in that regard
00:14:17 but I think she would have probably had different emphases today
00:14:20 because we have different challenges today.
00:14:23 And I think it shouldn't be forgotten that she never cut the police.
00:14:27 She regarded law and order as a fundamental conservative responsibility.
00:14:32 And, of course, she retook the Falkland Islands.
00:14:36 She understood the importance of sovereignty.
00:14:39 And, of course, later on in her years, she made the famous Bruce speech
00:14:44 where I think she realised that some of the decisions
00:14:46 that she had been part of in Britain's relationship
00:14:49 with the European Union were wrong
00:14:51 and we'd stopped being part of a European economic community
00:14:55 and we're becoming part of the European Union
00:14:57 which was moving nation states
00:14:59 into ever closer relationship with each other.
00:15:02 So some of the people who call themselves Thatcherites today
00:15:06 I think have a narrower memory of her
00:15:08 and I'm not sure she would be one of today's Thatcherites.
00:15:12 right right you mean by that the absolute sort of evangelical free marketeers you know like the
00:15:17 people who that for that is all that it's about for them it's just entirely about the market
00:15:23 profit you're saying she wouldn't go for that yeah and i think there's an idea today of the
00:15:28 individual that i think exists in some more libertarian conservative circles where that
00:15:34 individual isn't really connected to the public services that supported them in early in their
00:15:40 life and still support them that's cut off from family church community i i'm i'm a christian and
00:15:48 for me catholic social teaching gets the idea of the individual right it's an idea of a person
00:15:54 deeply connected to other people they are in they are in charge of their own life
00:16:00 they are um they're free to uh choose uh key aspects of how they live but they are not cut
00:16:08 adrift from their nation's culture, its history, loved ones and then they
00:16:15 can't build things on their own whether it's a business or a good life. There is
00:16:19 certain things that government provides and history provides and culture
00:16:23 provides and I think there needs to be a recovery in conservatism of that broad
00:16:28 understanding of what it means to be an adult citizen in a civilized country. How
00:16:34 do we civilise young people so that they understand that Western civilisation
00:16:38 can't be taken for granted. This is a project which every generation needs to
00:16:42 reinvest in. I mean what you were describing now I would say is what David
00:16:47 Goodhart called the somewheres. Yeah. I mean we're somewheres, are we not him?
00:16:51 Both of us? Yeah, I hope so. No, no, but the thing is is that where I would
00:16:56 disagree, he's actually going to be coming on the show shortly, David Goodhart, he
00:17:00 talked very much about the uneducated being somewheres you know and all the rest of it and
00:17:04 this is this was one of the kind of criticisms during the brexit campaign but of course there
00:17:09 are people who are educated to the gills who were somewheres as well you know have a very strong
00:17:13 sense of that um you mentioned their law and order uh growing up i'm sure like you you know
00:17:21 the tory party almost to the point of being mockable was the party of law and order
00:17:25 Hang them and flog them, perhaps.
00:17:27 Hang them and flog them.
00:17:28 I would say that that perception, even publicly, has entirely gone.
00:17:32 Yeah.
00:17:33 You know, whether it's Theresa May cutting the police or whatever it is.
00:17:38 But just generally, I'd say, isn't it deeper than that, Tim?
00:17:41 I mean, in the sense that it's a very big question I'm asking you,
00:17:45 but in a way, how conservative at the moment is the Conservative Party, really?
00:17:50 well Esther McVeigh one of the leadership candidates already eliminated had the best
00:17:57 slogan I think of the campaign even she didn't have the best campaign and that was make the
00:18:00 Conservative Party conservative again and I think one of the downsides of the Theresa May period
00:18:08 was some of the candidates that she's allowed to be selected and have become MPs they strike me
00:18:15 as people who are largely in politics for career reasons yeah not with any great sense of belief
00:18:22 um the system of special advisors uh that exists around ministers these are people that allow the
00:18:30 ministers have some sort of political appointees around them to sort of ensure that the political
00:18:35 agenda is driven through a civil service that might not be so understanding or sympathetic
00:18:39 it. I think we've seen that, haven't we, recently? Yeah, we certainly have. But I meet lots of these
00:18:46 special advisors and none of them haven't got, most of them haven't got a first idea of what
00:18:51 Margaret Thatcher stood for. The vast majority, because I asked them deliberately, I go through
00:18:55 my little checklist of questions, I asked them how they voted in the referendum. They nearly all
00:18:59 voted for Remain. Yeah, yeah. And so you have this political class at the, which has far too
00:19:07 much control over the modern Conservative Party and frankly electing a new leader is only the
00:19:13 beginning of what needs to happen in the Conservative Party. We need a huge clear out of a lot of the
00:19:19 individuals that have power at the moment and a rediscovery of you know Reagan used to say you
00:19:27 know staff is policy yeah and if you don't have good people throughout an institution it's hard
00:19:33 to make it work properly and I think you see in public appointments a whole range
00:19:41 of public bodies when Labour in power they stuff these institutions with Labour
00:19:46 people when we're in power we stuff these people with Labour people you know
00:19:51 and well this I think is why the general drift of society often appears
00:19:55 leftward regardless of who's in you know you've got a Conservative government or
00:20:00 you've got to this or that.
00:20:01 Actually, no, it's all the quang.
00:20:03 It's the establishment that's been basically established,
00:20:07 which is essentially sort of left.
00:20:09 Which is why I hated your introduction.
00:20:11 Well, I worried about your introduction
00:20:13 to say I was at the heart of the political establishment
00:20:15 because the establishment in our country at the moment
00:20:18 is not one that I think is supportive of Conservative values.
00:20:24 I'm only teasing.
00:20:24 You have been at the heart in many different ways,
00:20:27 writing speeches and what have you.
00:20:28 No, I know, I'm only teasing, yeah.
00:20:30 But, what I say, has it never really occurred to you
00:20:34 to want to stand for office?
00:20:39 Well, one of the organisations I also used to run
00:20:44 was the Conservative Christian Fellowship.
00:20:45 Yes, I was going to ask you about that.
00:20:47 And I had people constantly coming to me
00:20:51 and saying they'd been called by God to be in Parliament.
00:20:55 Yeah.
00:20:56 as a lot of how Christians talk.
00:20:59 And I felt one of my principal jobs was to discourage them.
00:21:03 And if they still wanted to do it at the end of all the things
00:21:07 that I said to them, well, fair enough.
00:21:09 But I've seen the institution just over the road, Peter,
00:21:14 the House of Commons, probably has the worst divorce
00:21:18 and marriage breakup rate of almost any institution in the country.
00:21:24 People are separated from their families,
00:21:26 during the week lots of alcohol lots of young people it's a it's a family
00:21:31 wrecking lifestyle unless you your your relationship is really built on rock
00:21:36 lots of people expend enormous amounts of money trying to get a seat then they
00:21:42 don't win the seat then they get into Parliament and they find that they never
00:21:46 become the minister in the department of the area that they want I think I
00:21:50 applaud people who go into public life but I think it's important for people to
00:21:55 going with their eyes open and how hard it is to necessarily make progress in the way that they
00:22:00 perhaps would like and I've just felt that writing advocating policy work that I've been doing has
00:22:09 been a better use of my time and you can have actually more power can't you than being a
00:22:15 backbench MP actually sometimes I think I think you can and then I don't want to be to be negative
00:22:21 we need good people in public life
00:22:23 my goodness we need good people in public life
00:22:25 but I think there are many ways
00:22:27 to serve and I think people
00:22:29 need to go into politics
00:22:31 with their eyes open as to the
00:22:33 as to how difficult it is
00:22:35 to make progress
00:22:36 You mentioned there the
00:22:39 the Christian Association
00:22:41 Conservative Association
00:22:43 Fellowship
00:22:44 How much is
00:22:46 your faith, you're a man of strong faith
00:22:49 How much has that informed your political views, do you think?
00:22:55 A great deal.
00:22:56 And I became a Christian at 16 a few years after I became a conservative.
00:23:02 Why did you, why didn't you? What happened?
00:23:03 I went to an event with a Baptist minister
00:23:06 and they talked about Jesus Christ
00:23:09 and really used a line of C.S. Lewis
00:23:12 and said at some point everybody has to examine the claims that this man makes.
00:23:17 He said he was the son of God.
00:23:19 And he was either mad, bad, or he was who he said he was.
00:23:24 And I spent a lot of time reading and I came to the conclusion that he was the son of God.
00:23:29 And I think through most of my 20s and 30s, I had a very evangelical, some would say almost fundamentalist view of Scripture.
00:23:39 I think over the years, I've become more liberal on certain things.
00:23:44 I think more willing to accept that other people have perspectives on religion and faith and divinity
00:23:50 that I need to be more respectful of.
00:23:54 And I think in conversations you and I have had, Peter, over the years,
00:23:57 for example, I've changed on views on homosexuality.
00:24:00 I took a very traditionalist view on those issues, and I don't anymore.
00:24:05 I'm faced with all sorts of realities.
00:24:09 But initially, when I became a Christian, I thought I should walk away.
00:24:14 from politics and that i you know considered the ministry uh and and things but it was william
00:24:22 wilberforce who probably is if i had to name a great hero he really is he he's the guy obviously
00:24:27 well known for uh fighting slavery but he abolished the last lottery that britain had he formed the
00:24:34 rspca he was involved in so many good causes and he had that quality which i think is the most
00:24:40 important quality that anyone should bring to public life, which is perseverance. Any
00:24:46 good project is worth sticking at. And he stuck at trying to fight the slave trade for
00:24:51 over four decades. It was a life work. And it was John Newton, the author of Amazing
00:25:01 Grace, who convinced him, yes, you become a Christian, but don't walk away from public
00:25:06 life we need good people in public life and uh that's why i sort of have stayed in politics and
00:25:12 you decided but you got really quite near to maybe take taking holy orders as it were i don't think
00:25:17 i got near to it but it was a it was a thought at the front of my mind for a good number of years
00:25:23 that that one route i probably would have wanted to consider going down it's interesting uh you're
00:25:29 talking about your faith because um apparently the number of people who traditionally gone into
00:25:34 politics MPs well the number that would consider themselves to be religious
00:25:38 it's actually hugely disproportionate to the population I mean there are many
00:25:41 more people yeah there is this link isn't there between religion and and
00:25:46 public service still I think so and I think there is an attempt at the moment
00:25:51 to push Christians out of public life I think Tim Farron the former Liberal
00:25:58 Democrat leader, faced a lot of that. Here was someone who did think that homosexuality was
00:26:06 legal, should remain legal, that abortion was legal and should remain legal. But that wasn't
00:26:13 enough. People wanted to know what his private beliefs on these issues were. And if his private
00:26:20 beliefs didn't quite measure up to what people thought they should be, he shouldn't be in public
00:26:24 life and i think that's a dangerous view to start peering into people's souls and having to know
00:26:32 everything that they they think about everything because if you look over the years whether it's
00:26:37 the slave trade or martin luther king jr on the civil rights movement uh debt forgiveness in the
00:26:43 third world um in the in the run-up to the year 2000 again and again i think christians have been
00:26:49 a larger force for good
00:26:51 in public life and I think
00:26:53 our civilisation
00:26:55 is based on Judeo-Christian
00:26:57 ethics and I think we're poorer
00:27:00 without that
00:27:01 influence in our national
00:27:03 conversations. It certainly has
00:27:05 I think it's not just
00:27:07 you talk about Christianity but I think isn't there a general
00:27:10 narrowing as well of
00:27:11 actually what is acceptable
00:27:13 for a public figure
00:27:14 you hear this more and more
00:27:17 people of real quality
00:27:19 maybe won't want to go into public life or be MPs
00:27:22 because they're going to have everything that they've ever said
00:27:25 or ever thought.
00:27:27 There's no allowance for nuance.
00:27:29 There's no allowance for anything changing.
00:27:31 It's going to be examined and dragged up.
00:27:33 Why would you put yourself through it?
00:27:35 Why indeed.
00:27:37 And an intolerance for allowing people to evolve as well
00:27:43 and the entrenchment of people at the moment
00:27:46 in positions that they've held for years
00:27:49 is one of the most unsatisfying parts
00:27:51 of public policy at the moment.
00:27:54 We are living in a time when we're seeing
00:27:58 technological, cultural, economic and social change
00:28:01 at an extraordinary pace.
00:28:04 And I think it's Matt Ridley who talks about
00:28:05 ideas having sex with each other.
00:28:07 And I think these trends are having sex with each other.
00:28:10 The trends are influencing, accelerating each other.
00:28:13 And you have events like 2016 with the EU referendum, the election of Donald Trump, and three-year, unpredicted events.
00:28:24 And yet, the Financial Times, The Guardian, most politicians, central banks, as far as I can tell, they all seem to think exactly the same as they did before these events occurred.
00:28:35 or before these trends struck.
00:28:37 Now, I think there should be an encouragement in public life
00:28:39 for everyone to sit down in a conversation like this
00:28:43 and to say, tell us how your ideas have evolved.
00:28:48 And if someone like Jeremy Corbyn,
00:28:50 who seems to believe exactly what he did today
00:28:52 as he did in the early 80s before communism collapsed,
00:28:56 I think those sort of people should be ruled out from public office.
00:28:59 I want people who are open-minded and fresh thinking
00:29:03 and willing to admit mistakes.
00:29:05 Whether we can develop a culture that allows that, I don't know,
00:29:08 but it would be a huge improvement on the staleness we have now.
00:29:11 I think it's interesting that if you're left and you believe the same thing,
00:29:14 you're principled.
00:29:15 If you're on the right and you believe the same thing,
00:29:17 you're a bigot and a reactionary.
00:29:19 Tim, thank you so much for coming in and talking.
00:29:22 You're probably back off to Salisbury, are you not, this weekend?
00:29:24 Or staying up in London?
00:29:27 Well, actually, I'm at Windsor Castle.
00:29:28 Oh, really?
00:29:29 This weekend, not to see the Queen,
00:29:30 but actually on a conference on Christian responsibility and public affairs.
00:29:34 Well, look, thank you very much, Tim. It's great to talk to you.
00:29:37 That's it for what you're saying is.
00:29:39 So please remember to subscribe if you haven't already
00:29:42 and we'll see you next time. Thank you very much.