New Culture Forum - June 22, 2019


24. Twitter phenomenon ‘Titania McGrath’ aka comedian Andrew Doyle

23. Tim Montgomerie - The State Of Conservatism Sir Roger Scruton

Episode Stats


Length

28 minutes

Words per minute

205.46

Word count

5,910

Sentence count

220


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 hello and welcome to so what you're saying is I'm Peter Whittle now if you're on Twitter you
00:00:11 will be aware of somebody called Titania McGrath she is the social justice warrior extraordinaire
00:00:18 she is the self-proclaimed intersectionalist slam poet is many controversial tweets that
00:00:27 she's put out it's meant that she's been de-platformed a couple of times but she is now
00:00:31 in print in this book woke a guide to social justice right of course uh titania doesn't
00:00:39 really exist she's a fictional character she's the creation of my guest i'm pleased to say
00:00:44 today his name is andrew doyle he's a comedian and satirist and he's also the co-creator
00:00:50 of an equally fictitious TV reporter called Jonathan Pye.
00:00:55 Thanks very much for coming in, Andrew.
00:00:57 Thanks a lot.
00:00:57 Thank you.
00:00:58 Thank you.
00:01:00 We obviously know, Titania now, we know...
00:01:03 I would love to know why you decided, when you did,
00:01:07 to actually, as it were, reveal yourself.
00:01:10 I didn't. I was outed.
00:01:11 Oh, really? Who outed you?
00:01:13 Steve Bennett at Chortle.
00:01:15 Chortle's the comedy industry website.
00:01:16 Right.
00:01:17 And there had been some sort of mistake
00:01:19 where somebody at the publishers, the publishers are a little brown,
00:01:22 someone had accidentally put my name next to a reference to the book
00:01:25 in some catalogue at some book fair in Frankfurt.
00:01:29 And somehow, Steve Bennett at Chortle got hold of this book
00:01:32 and connected the dots, and that was that.
00:01:35 So I didn't want to.
00:01:37 I found it really much more liberating to be hiding behind a persona.
00:01:42 I didn't change the character once I was outed.
00:01:45 I carry on doing what I'm doing.
00:01:46 it's just that the difference now is that of course
00:01:49 if I put out a tweet that annoys people
00:01:51 now I get inundated with
00:01:53 very angry tweets from people
00:01:54 which I didn't before because they didn't know it was me
00:01:57 But your traffic
00:01:59 as it were, the followers for
00:02:01 Titiania basically grew
00:02:03 didn't they? I mean after
00:02:04 went up by 20,000 or something?
00:02:06 It went up by 20,000 when she was banned permanently
00:02:09 so there was a
00:02:10 Twitter ban, she'd been suspended a number of times
00:02:13 What over basically?
00:02:15 absolutely nothing i mean there were a few tweets which i mean they sent me twitter emailed me with
00:02:20 the tweets that they were nervous about shall we say and they were completely innocuous really i
00:02:24 think they just had a swear word in or something i think what it really boiled down to was that
00:02:28 uh they you know silicon valley is is packed to the rafters with these kind of very woke
00:02:32 intersectional types and they didn't like someone taking the piss that was it i think and so they
00:02:36 took it they took the opportunity to ban her when they could ultimately the permanent ban came when
00:02:41 And she attended a UKIP rally, and she said she was there to punch people in the name of tolerance.
00:02:47 And they got very annoyed.
00:02:49 I think they suggested it was inciting violence or something, which, of course, it wasn't.
00:02:53 And I had the email through saying, it's a permanent ban.
00:02:56 You won't be returning.
00:02:57 Don't try and set up alternative accounts and evade the ban, or it will get even worse.
00:03:02 And then there were lots of people, particularly in America, actually,
00:03:05 a lot of conservative figures who were complaining about it and saying,
00:03:09 you know, this is a sadirical account, Twitter, what are you doing?
00:03:13 And then within 24 hours she was back.
00:03:16 I had another email saying we've reviewed it
00:03:18 and you didn't violate our terms of service.
00:03:20 So has it sort of made any difference to the way you write it, surely,
00:03:24 that people now know that this is not actually a real person?
00:03:27 No, it hasn't. It really hasn't.
00:03:29 I still obviously annoy people.
00:03:33 Yeah, yeah.
00:03:35 But what I've just had to resign myself to
00:03:38 is that people are going to get annoyed at me
00:03:40 rather than the character.
00:03:42 So, I mean, I have been trolled endlessly
00:03:45 by some very angry people.
00:03:46 They're very upset about it.
00:03:48 But then if you write a satirical thing like this,
00:03:51 you know, it's there to entertain some people
00:03:54 and annoy others.
00:03:55 That's its purpose.
00:03:56 So, you know, I have to accept that.
00:03:58 I mean, when I first saw it, you know, on Twitter,
00:04:01 you know, you have me fooled, actually, I have to say.
00:04:04 Because, I mean, I've come across quite a lot of people
00:04:06 and argue with people.
00:04:08 with those views.
00:04:09 I mean, I wondered, you know, in your case,
00:04:12 did you know many Titanias?
00:04:14 Yeah, loads.
00:04:14 It's funny you say that, though,
00:04:15 because a lot of the critics of it,
00:04:17 the people who don't like it,
00:04:18 will say, well, it's nothing like real life.
00:04:20 Oh, no, it is.
00:04:21 This is a straw man.
00:04:22 You're satirising someone that doesn't exist.
00:04:24 I'm afraid that's not true.
00:04:26 And that's very much wishful thinking on their part.
00:04:29 But she's certainly at the extreme end.
00:04:32 Like, she's certainly saying the things
00:04:33 that most people wouldn't say.
00:04:36 But the whole woke movement is a minority.
00:04:38 It's a very vocal, powerful minority.
00:04:39 That's why it deserves to be satirised.
00:04:41 Yes, exactly.
00:04:42 At this point, I think you've made this point before,
00:04:44 that it's a question of punching up, isn't it?
00:04:47 These people, you know, give us a bit of an idea of her profile.
00:04:51 I mean, she's an upper middle class girl, isn't she, right?
00:04:54 So basically she's privileged.
00:04:55 Yes.
00:04:56 And yet thinks of herself as a victim.
00:04:57 Yeah.
00:04:57 That's right, isn't it?
00:04:58 Yeah, yeah.
00:04:59 That's exactly what it is.
00:04:59 And we all know who I'm talking about.
00:05:02 We all know those kinds of people.
00:05:04 It's so recognisable.
00:05:05 a lot of them are in the media or on twitter of course very vocal on twitter i got into an argument
00:05:10 someone got very angry with me a columnist from the guardian surprise surprise and she uh sent a
00:05:15 message saying well you're talking about people that don't exist i've worked at the guardian
00:05:18 there's no one like there's no wealthy feminists who constantly go on about being victims and i
00:05:23 said no there really there really are and if you work at the garden you probably should know
00:05:26 in fact i suspect she's one of them and then she came back to me saying no no unless you name who
00:05:31 they are and i didn't want to name who i was talking about because i deliberately didn't
00:05:35 want to make it personal but she kept pushing and so I said okay there's this person this person
00:05:39 this person this but I listed them and then she said well thank you for that list of the women you
00:05:43 hate you're clearly a misogynist and that in of itself is exactly why I created Titania that kind
00:05:49 of response I have no argument left I'm just going to call you a misogynist that's all I've got
00:05:54 all I've got is the ad hominem attacks yeah which is funny to me that's funny to me that was hilarious
00:05:58 That was, you know, she couldn't have proved my point better.
00:06:04 And I think, because I used to teach critical thinking,
00:06:06 and I think we have to get back,
00:06:08 that people don't understand that as soon as you throw an insult, you've lost.
00:06:11 That's it, game over, your argument's gone.
00:06:14 And I just wish we could get back to that.
00:06:16 But Titania's that sort.
00:06:17 So Titania will call anyone who disagrees with her a misogynist,
00:06:20 fascist often, Nazi, racist, anything, just anything,
00:06:25 because she knows that those epithets will stick.
00:06:28 I've actually got a couple here
00:06:30 I mean
00:06:30 this one here, I mean first of all
00:06:34 about comedy
00:06:34 I think she says in one
00:06:38 of her tweets, if you find
00:06:40 yourself laughing at comedy
00:06:41 it's probably not sufficiently progressive
00:06:43 well I mean that to me
00:06:46 is entirely true
00:06:47 in the sense that if you think now
00:06:49 a lot of comedy is made up of audiences
00:06:52 of people laughing to show their
00:06:53 own side politically, wouldn't you say
00:06:55 you're a comic, I mean you are in clubs
00:06:58 you do stand up don't you or yes yes absolutely would you say that that's correct i mean you know
00:07:02 that that is sort of that's exactly on the money that's that's exactly right because i think
00:07:06 this is something i really hate when i go and see comedy is if i get a sense that the audience are
00:07:11 laughing because they endorse the views that are being expressed rather than laughing because they
00:07:15 find it funny and i'm guilty of it myself i think all comedians if they're honest about this sometimes
00:07:19 when i've done a joke uh say i've mocked teresa may very easy target uh and then people have laughed
00:07:25 and particularly when I was touring on the Jonathan Pye tour
00:07:27 and I was doing the support slot
00:07:28 I had to think now, is that joke really good enough
00:07:31 or are they laughing because they just hate Theresa May
00:07:33 and if it's the latter then it's weak comedy
00:07:35 so you have to go back and rethink it
00:07:37 what I really loved though is on that tour
00:07:39 I was doing a pro-Brexit set
00:07:42 to a room full of people
00:07:43 often big rooms of 3,000 people
00:07:45 where virtually no one would have voted leave
00:07:47 or very few
00:07:48 and so therefore I had to make sure the material was good
00:07:52 because they won't laugh at someone who supports Brexit
00:07:55 it unless it's even better you know it has to be really really good so that in a sense is a good
00:08:00 thing but yes I always mistrust you see the people who criticize Bernard Manning and sort of old
00:08:04 school comics well the main criticism because actually he was a very good comic politically I
00:08:09 couldn't be more opposed to him and of course he was a racist he admitted to being a racist and I
00:08:12 I deplore that but as a in terms of the craft he was he was excellent but a lot of the people
00:08:19 laughing in those old clips you can see what they're doing is they're laughing because they
00:08:23 just agree with with the unpleasantness of the views but that to me is no
00:08:27 different than what we see today which is people from the left comedians from
00:08:31 the left yeah making people laugh and people are laughing because they agree
00:08:34 the material isn't necessarily particularly strong and doesn't need to
00:08:37 be but those two camps are the same so when these people on the left now
00:08:40 criticize the likes of Manning and the old working men's club comics but they
00:08:44 are guilty of exactly the same lack of artistry sometimes yes I've got one here
00:08:50 as well i'm not going to you know go on with loads of quotes for you because you must get tired of
00:08:55 it but but you know i think this one i loved if you only have sex with people you find attractive
00:09:02 you might want to ask yourself why you're such a superficial bigot now i just think but i just
00:09:08 think that i could imagine people saying that no but they they sort of have there's been a number
00:09:14 of articles where people have said you know if you're um you know if you're online tinder or
00:09:19 on Grindr or whatever those sort of dating apps and if you are eliminating
00:09:24 people based on certain characteristics if you don't sleep with people of color
00:09:27 you're racist. It's like you don't need to prove you're not racist by
00:09:30 having sex with people like that people are actually saying this stuff you know
00:09:35 we all have proclivities you know are you misogynist if you're gay a gay man are
00:09:39 gay men misogynist because they won't sleep with women you don't show something
00:09:42 you like someone and approve of someone by by having sex with them do you that
00:09:45 would be an odd world but the thing is it is so spot on i mean i it's slightly exaggerated isn't
00:09:53 it so it's slightly of course it's absurd but at the same time it's got that kernel of truth you
00:09:57 could think i could imagine that you know a time in the future where actually that might be the
00:10:01 case and in fact you are called this because for example you don't fancy this is the problem is
00:10:06 that i think unfortunately often i end up anticipating what people actually say and
00:10:11 that really scares me and it's happened a number of times i mean i remember before christmas i did
00:10:15 No, at Christmas it was. I did a thing about the Queen's speech and what she should have said.
00:10:20 And she should have said that Harry and Meghan will raise their child as gender neutral.
00:10:26 And then there was a story about Meghan floating the idea of raising her child as gender neutral.
00:10:29 And that was a couple of months later.
00:10:31 And then there was the tweet about Mary Poppins.
00:10:34 I did a screenshot from Mary Poppins where she's got the soot on her face.
00:10:37 And Titania said, this is blackface, this is racist.
00:10:39 But Mary Poppins is racist.
00:10:40 And then lo and behold, New York Times in February says he's got exactly the same thing.
00:10:44 four months later
00:10:45 comes out and says
00:10:46 I remember the story
00:10:47 I didn't know the tweet
00:10:48 really
00:10:48 I tweeted about it
00:10:49 four months before
00:10:50 saying exactly the same thing
00:10:51 right
00:10:52 and so that
00:10:52 I should be pleased about that
00:10:53 because it makes me
00:10:54 happy to be a kind of prophet
00:10:55 sort of a messiah
00:10:56 kind of figure
00:10:57 which is really good
00:10:57 for the ego
00:10:58 but actually it's really
00:10:59 worrying and scary
00:11:00 when you know
00:11:02 reality imitates
00:11:04 satire
00:11:05 now Titania's
00:11:07 going on stage
00:11:08 now isn't she
00:11:08 this is a one
00:11:09 woman show
00:11:10 now
00:11:11 so can you tell us about that
00:11:12 it's imminent isn't it
00:11:13 Pretty imminent, yeah, it's at the Edinburgh Fringe Festival, so that's in August.
00:11:16 So how will you do that?
00:11:19 So, you know, I've got a script that I've written and still putting finishing touches to it.
00:11:25 I like to leave things to the last minute.
00:11:27 And we're casting at the moment, so we'll see.
00:11:32 I just, I know that we need to get this right.
00:11:33 It has to be the right actor to play her.
00:11:36 So we're looking for that young, she's got to have the right look.
00:11:39 she's got to be very uh first and foremost a really strong actor because it's it'll be more
00:11:44 like a play you know yes um but she's got to be comedically on point you know she's got to have
00:11:49 excellent comedic timing so it will have it will have a story will it as it were it'll be more no
00:11:54 it's more like a lecture like a ted talk style lecture because that's exactly what she would do
00:11:57 yes it's her manifesto she's going out there to educate the masses yeah she believes that's her
00:12:01 sort of you know god-given duty not that she believes in god yeah um but you know but the
00:12:08 The thing is, with this creation of yours,
00:12:11 it seems to me that it's entirely in the tradition of satire.
00:12:16 Going right back to Jonathan Swift,
00:12:19 I think he created somebody, Isaac Bickerstaff.
00:12:23 Bickerstaff, yeah, yeah.
00:12:24 Somebody he created to make a point about some other issue or some other person.
00:12:29 Yeah.
00:12:29 But I would have thought, I mean, it's great to see it on social media
00:12:32 because I would have thought that satire is, on the whole,
00:12:35 a pretty low ebb in this country, would you say?
00:12:38 Yeah, I mean, there is that tradition, isn't there, of inventing characters too.
00:12:42 Joe Orton did it when he used to write letters of complaint about his own plays to the press
00:12:47 under the name Mrs. Edna Wellthorpe.
00:12:49 She used to get very upset, very angry.
00:12:52 And I think that's a really...
00:12:53 I'm always attracted to that kind of thing, that sort of fake persona.
00:12:57 There is a tradition of it.
00:12:59 I'm always wary of talking about that because I wouldn't for a second compare myself to Swift.
00:13:03 No, but I mean, it's a tradition.
00:13:05 Yeah, exactly.
00:13:06 I mean, when I say it's at a low ebb, I mean, if you take popular satire to be spitting image, maybe, or private eye as it once was, it seems to me now these things, well, there is no spitting image anymore, but there's nothing like it.
00:13:20 And I worry that somehow satire, real satire, is actually sort of very, very weak now, simply because of the culture, which actually you are now satirising.
00:13:28 Yeah, I think part of it is that a lot of people don't know what satire is. I think that's part of the problem.
00:13:33 How would you define it, then?
00:13:35 i would say that satire is i suppose it's when you're attacking or attempting to deflate
00:13:42 those in power yeah when you see something that is wrong in society and you're attempting to fix
00:13:46 it by by reflecting back at it yeah its own its own vices its own its own corruption um so uh
00:13:54 for instance uh i suppose the thick of it is a good example of very strong satire which does
00:13:59 uh reflect and exaggerate to an extent uh the the machinations of what goes on in westminster
00:14:03 right so um whereas comedy is very different you know comedy doesn't need to be satirical comedy
00:14:10 doesn't need to have levels of ironic detachment to it you know and and i think that's i think
00:14:15 that's the distinction um she's definitely satirical because of course she is embodying
00:14:21 a type of person uh that exists a very powerful uh type of person well that's the big difference
00:14:27 because the thick of it is about the process if you're you're not actually going after the people
00:14:32 Well, you are, but it's actually the process of Westminster, which is a kind of easier thing to take on.
00:14:40 You're taking on things, concepts, ideas, current things.
00:14:43 Yeah, but maybe that's where it needs to happen online.
00:14:47 Maybe it has to be, because that's where so much of the power resides at the moment, is through social media.
00:14:53 Do you think, I mean, so you said you wouldn't presume to call yourself a satirist, is that right?
00:14:58 No, I mean, I did.
00:14:58 No, I would presume to call myself a satirist.
00:15:00 I just wouldn't put myself in the ranks of Swift, that's all.
00:15:05 But I suppose in some ways the difference may be...
00:15:08 Obviously not, I should say.
00:15:10 Is satire a middle-class thing?
00:15:13 I mean, when you talk about comedy now
00:15:16 and how comedy is the state of comedy in Britain now,
00:15:19 I would say on the whole it appears to be
00:15:22 what was once called working-class comedy
00:15:25 or working-class comedians are no more.
00:15:27 comedy's become generally a very middle class thing.
00:15:30 Well comedy or satire
00:15:31 I mean Joe Orton wasn't
00:15:33 middle class.
00:15:36 Was Chris Morris middle class? I don't think he is.
00:15:37 Joe Orton was the 1960s now.
00:15:39 You're talking 50 years ago.
00:15:41 So you mean now in the present state
00:15:43 comedy's expensive.
00:15:45 If you go and see stand-up you have to have a
00:15:47 you have to be quite affluent
00:15:49 don't you I suppose. Maybe that's it.
00:15:51 Maybe that's why audiences are becoming more sensitive.
00:15:53 Because this whole sort of
00:15:55 offence culture tends to
00:15:57 it tends to come from the middle classes and it tends to come from people who are quite well off
00:16:01 um i don't know why i don't know a friend of mine did say that actually a stand-up comic said
00:16:05 because i said to him why why do you think it is that audiences are generally getting more sensitive
00:16:09 uh and he said he thinks it's because they're all rich and and that's part of their that's
00:16:12 part of their nature yes you know i don't know do you i mean do you find that um you know the
00:16:20 reaction to Titania is sort of, do people expect you to be a certain type of
00:16:28 person? Do they expect you to be politically a right-wing headbanger,
00:16:33 having a go at these people? They do? Virtually all of the arguments I have on
00:16:37 Twitter, which I shouldn't even engage with, I don't know why I do, are from
00:16:41 people who imagine what I am and they imagine wrong. So they have this sort of
00:16:46 phantom in their mind of me at this sort of rabid frothing at the mouth
00:16:50 gammon gammon brexity and i'm always angry apparently
00:16:54 um and uh which couldn't be further from my personality you know so
00:17:00 it's um and so you end up in arguments with someone who who isn't even arguing
00:17:04 in good faith you know they they're arguing against this spectre of
00:17:07 their imagination so it's actually completely futile
00:17:10 so i've started just ignoring them now um because i've realized this is you
00:17:14 You know, I'm trying to defend...
00:17:16 They're arguing with Andrew Doyle, this character they've invented,
00:17:19 and I'm actually the real person,
00:17:21 and those two things are not in any way similar, so there's no point.
00:17:24 But yeah, they do have an expectation,
00:17:25 and I think they bracket all these things together.
00:17:29 If you are seen to mock social justice
00:17:31 or the manifestation of social justice at the moment,
00:17:34 then of course you must be this Tommy Robinson-style EDL,
00:17:39 whatever they decide you are.
00:17:42 And because they're not rational people,
00:17:44 You can't talk to them and explain the difference because they will take it in bad faith and say, well, of course you'd say that.
00:17:51 Where are you on the general political spectrum then, Andrew, personally? Where do your views sit?
00:17:59 They happen to sit on the left, I suppose.
00:18:03 But most of my bedfellows now appear to be more right-wingers because I'm pro-free speech.
00:18:09 because I detect, I know when authoritarianism is on the rise.
00:18:16 It's at a very low level at the moment, of course, but it is creeping.
00:18:19 And for some reason at the moment,
00:18:23 the people who are most concerned about freedom of speech tend to be on the right.
00:18:27 I don't know why that was.
00:18:28 I mean, you know, the ones who are trying to curb people's speech
00:18:31 and the ones who complain and want things banned,
00:18:34 want people no-platformed at the moment tend to come from the left.
00:18:36 Whereas if you go back to the 80s and 90s,
00:18:38 they were almost all from the right
00:18:40 the Mary White House Daily Mail
00:18:42 complaining about the film Crash for instance
00:18:44 you know
00:18:45 anything, Last Temptation of Christ
00:18:47 all of these sort of works
00:18:49 it used to be the right that would rage and say
00:18:52 ban this filth is the phrase
00:18:54 but now Mary White House
00:18:56 has won because what Mary White House has done
00:18:58 is infected the left
00:18:59 and the left are now a troop
00:19:02 of Mary White House's. Well you've made this point though
00:19:04 in a wider sense that in fact
00:19:05 identity politics
00:19:07 as, you know, practised and promoted by Titania
00:19:13 are essentially kind of re-racialising society.
00:19:17 In fact, sort of going backwards.
00:19:19 I mean, Brendan O'Neill came in quite recently
00:19:21 and he made exactly this point.
00:19:23 It's all about seeing people through the prism
00:19:26 of one characteristic, isn't it now?
00:19:28 It's really depressing.
00:19:29 I mean, Brendan talks about that a lot
00:19:30 and he finds it genuinely depressing.
00:19:33 He describes it as the rehabilitation of racial thinking
00:19:35 and that's exactly what it is.
00:19:37 I mean, I always think about this, if I go back to when I was a kid, and if you watch old sort of Top of the Pops 2 programs and popular culture programs from when I was young, you know, for Top of the Pops, for instance, there were often times in the charts where it was predominantly black artists.
00:19:53 TV was quite diverse, you know, I mean, we watched, one of my favorite comedy programs was Red Dwarf with the predominantly black, you know, the two main characters are black.
00:20:02 but none of us noticed that as kids none of us registered it you know most of my
00:20:07 favorite comedians growing up were female but i never thought to myself oh what's the state of
00:20:13 women in comedy or i never noticed it you know and now people notice race and they notice gender
00:20:18 and sexuality and they'll watch a play and they'll see and they'll say oh it's interesting
00:20:23 they've got you know diversity they've fulfilled some diversity that's good but then you're
00:20:26 assessing someone in terms of their race or in terms of their and i think i think that's a real
00:20:31 shame i think i noticed something you wrote sorry that you read in wrote in spiked online recently
00:20:37 about critics and what they do now and how they become these kind of political arbiters yeah
00:20:42 that's exactly what they do more than you know hence criticism as a thing has gone downhill
00:20:47 yeah i mean you know you only have to look at the reviews of the book if you you know if you
00:20:53 are politically on side with me you might you'll find it funny and if you're not you won't uh but
00:20:58 what very few people are able to do is see beyond those political allegiances and assess something
00:21:03 on its own merit. And that's a real problem. Obviously, any critic is going to bring a
00:21:07 subjective view to anything that they do. And that's part of criticism, part of good criticism,
00:21:11 that's important. But if your politics blinds you to everything else, if you can only see something
00:21:17 in terms of how closely it matches your own political stance, you're not really in a position
00:21:23 to assess it critically. So I don't even consider those people critics. If all they can say is,
00:21:27 oh I don't agree with the politics of this film
00:21:29 therefore I don't like the film
00:21:31 I don't think you're qualified to talk about it
00:21:33 and unfortunately that's the case for a lot of critics
00:21:35 not all and I really need to emphasise this
00:21:37 there are some brilliant critics who don't fall into that trap
00:21:39 but if you're an activist first
00:21:42 and a critic second then I'm afraid your work is pretty useless
00:21:44 Who would you have admired
00:21:47 say like Grant
00:21:47 where did you grow up by the way Andrew
00:21:49 where were you from?
00:21:49 In the middle of Birmingham
00:21:50 In Birmingham right
00:21:51 so who would you have admired
00:21:53 you know I don't know
00:21:54 when you were watching on TV
00:21:55 or reading or whatever
00:21:57 when it came to satire and humour.
00:21:59 Who were the people that you liked?
00:22:00 Principally, Victoria Wood was my favourite,
00:22:02 without a doubt.
00:22:05 Almost to obsessive points, actually,
00:22:08 because I memorised her scripts.
00:22:10 I had copies of the scripts.
00:22:12 I recorded the shows and watched them endlessly,
00:22:14 so I can still recite those.
00:22:17 Who else did I really like?
00:22:18 It was a piece about, sorry,
00:22:19 I have to say that some of the details with Victoria Wood,
00:22:22 it was like a low camp, wasn't it?
00:22:24 Yeah.
00:22:24 the constant use of you know product names like not just this I could kill for a Huntley and
00:22:30 Palmer's yeah that kind of exactly it's the specificity yeah that's what she did really
00:22:34 really well and there's something quite northern about that as well um throwing in the detail that
00:22:38 you didn't need to have yes um which is great you know she she and that that and there was almost
00:22:44 I mean the way she wrote was literary actually and um her songs were brilliant and yeah just an
00:22:52 incredible influence but of course not hugely political although quite class
00:22:55 conscious people forget this a lot of what she's talking about is is mocking
00:22:59 she did a brilliant you know she she pioneered that sort of mockumentary
00:23:02 format oh yes which became really normal I mean she was she was doing that before
00:23:07 anyone else really she used to she had a series called as seen on TV and there
00:23:10 were these mockumentaries within it and there was one about a posh private
00:23:14 school girls school and it was really fun they had the you know they were doing
00:23:18 the the prize-giving day they had the Oswald Moseley award for whatever you
00:23:21 You know, these subtle kind of digs at that whole culture,
00:23:26 which is quite a political thing.
00:23:27 But people don't think of her as political,
00:23:28 but in a sense she was.
00:23:31 Who else?
00:23:31 I mean, what about the whole, you know,
00:23:34 if you think of like, that was a week, that was,
00:23:36 I know it's before your time, I'm sure,
00:23:37 but that kind of thing, would that have interested you?
00:23:40 Yeah, I loved the day-to-day.
00:23:41 I loved Brass Eye.
00:23:42 I think Brass Eye is incredible.
00:23:45 What else did I write?
00:23:46 But I also really liked mainstream things.
00:23:48 I really liked Friends.
00:23:49 I've written about that actually
00:23:51 because I think it's a really dark subversive
00:23:53 series which people don't give it
00:23:55 How? How come?
00:23:57 It's packaged to this kind of very
00:23:59 mainstream cuddly fun
00:24:01 show but then when you watch it
00:24:04 all of the characters degenerate
00:24:06 over the series so by the time you get to series 6
00:24:08 all of their funny little quirks
00:24:10 have turned into serious almost
00:24:11 psychopathy
00:24:12 I mean you have for instance Phoebe who's the quirky
00:24:16 hipster type
00:24:17 she ends up sort of confessing to stabbing a police officer
00:24:20 and she mugged Ross at one point.
00:24:24 She becomes mad.
00:24:26 You have Monica's OCD about cleanliness.
00:24:28 That becomes absolute insanity
00:24:29 where she has to go over to someone's house with a mop and bucket.
00:24:32 This is unhinged behaviour.
00:24:35 This passed me by, I'm afraid.
00:24:37 Also, from series six onwards, I hate to go on about it,
00:24:39 they all lie to each other all the time.
00:24:41 Their first instinct is always to lie, to get whatever they want.
00:24:44 The show is called Friends,
00:24:46 but they just
00:24:47 they can't tell the truth
00:24:48 to each other at all
00:24:49 as soon as Monika
00:24:50 and Chandler get married
00:24:51 the whole show
00:24:52 becomes a satire
00:24:54 on marriage
00:24:55 because they don't
00:24:55 really care about each other
00:24:56 you know
00:24:57 they just
00:24:58 they go on honeymoon
00:24:59 but all they want
00:24:59 is the free stuff
00:25:00 you know
00:25:01 and they used to
00:25:03 feed in these
00:25:03 very sort of
00:25:04 saccharine moments
00:25:06 of very highly
00:25:07 sentimental moments
00:25:08 and then they just
00:25:08 undercut it
00:25:09 and undermine it
00:25:10 and people don't
00:25:11 give it credit for that
00:25:12 part of its effect
00:25:13 is that it appealed
00:25:14 to such a mainstream audience
00:25:15 yes but it was feeding these all sorts of very sort of dark subversive ideas i know i'm the
00:25:21 only person who thinks i'm processing it at the moment but uh with with comedy now like perform
00:25:29 comedy on tv or whatever what what do you like at the moment um that's a really difficult question
00:25:35 because i know so many of the people involved so i don't okay so i don't want to mention really who
00:25:40 i uh because i'll leave someone out would you like to be i mean i know you do stand up yeah but
00:25:44 So, you know, you're known for this creation, you're known for Jonathan Pye, which you kind of co-created, didn't you?
00:25:50 No, I didn't co-create. I came on board a couple of months after it started.
00:25:53 Right.
00:25:53 And we wrote it together for three years.
00:25:55 Right, OK.
00:25:56 But, I mean, do you want to put yourself forward more, you know, you, as it were?
00:26:00 What, as a stand-up?
00:26:01 Yeah.
00:26:01 Well, I've been doing stand-up for so long.
00:26:02 I mean, I just, I like performing stand-up whenever I can.
00:26:06 I'm doing a week at the Edinburgh Fringe this year, but just one week.
00:26:09 Right.
00:26:09 Titania's doing the full run.
00:26:10 I think stand-up for me is sort of an outlet it's it's it's something I do you know vocationally
00:26:18 rather than anything else I think first and foremost I'm probably a writer I mean that's
00:26:22 where I make my money you know and I make money as a stand-up but but that's not my main so but
00:26:29 you know I don't see the two I can keep doing the pair the two of them I think would you create
00:26:34 another I mean have you got any other characters you're thinking of all the little brewing as it
00:26:39 in your mind I've got a few ideas yeah but I won't say for certain types for
00:26:43 certain just like yeah for certain well I'm always thinking you know I'm a
00:26:46 writer I create I write stories I create characters that's part of it that one of
00:26:50 the most amazing things I think to me is is the a lot of the vitriol against me
00:26:53 is is how dare I put words into a woman's mouth right you know this is a
00:26:58 sexist trope of the you know you're putting words in a woman but that's
00:27:01 called being an author yeah creating a character I'm surprised that people are
00:27:04 unfamiliar with this concept well no I'm afraid it's something we've discussed on
00:27:08 the show we had Lionel Shriver on and she was talking about actually this is
00:27:11 something that's really growing yeah writing generally in fiction novels
00:27:16 whatever you know that essentially it's stay in your lane yeah you you can't say
00:27:20 you can't tell anyone else's story I hate that phrase stay in your lane what
00:27:24 is it talk I mean it's nonsense I know it's very matey isn't it I hate it I
00:27:28 think it's you know do they want everything to be an autobiography I don't
00:27:32 understand this point I mean I can write a fit for one thing like for a lot of
00:27:36 time we get people complaining that male writers aren't creating enough strong female characters
00:27:40 strong roles well what i've just written a show which is going to be one woman so it's a major
00:27:46 role for one for one talented woman right what more and yet i'll be criticized for putting words
00:27:51 in a woman's mouth as though the actor has no autonomy whatsoever so she can she can't she
00:27:55 has no choice but to accept this job and it's incredibly patronizing um when is the show
00:28:00 actually on it's what are the dates i mean people can want a book and go and see it yeah
00:28:05 it's from the 31st of July
00:28:07 until the end of August
00:28:09 25th of August
00:28:09 so it's basically
00:28:10 you know
00:28:11 through the month
00:28:12 and it's at 9 o'clock
00:28:13 at the end of a fringe
00:28:14 every night
00:28:15 9 o'clock
00:28:15 you better kind of get
00:28:17 to and finish it
00:28:18 from what I can understand
00:28:19 yeah I better
00:28:20 otherwise it'll be
00:28:21 really embarrassing
00:28:22 thank you very very much
00:28:24 for coming in actually
00:28:25 Andrew
00:28:25 thanks very very much
00:28:26 thanks for having me
00:28:27 all the very best
00:28:27 with the show
00:28:28 cheers
00:28:28 I will say again
00:28:29 we've got the book here
00:28:30 Woke A Guide to Social Justice
00:28:32 it's very very funny
00:28:33 of course
00:28:34 no it's not
00:28:35 it's terribly serious i have to take it very very seriously thank you very very much and thank you
00:28:39 see you next time on so what you're saying is please do subscribe won't you as i say every week
00:28:45 thank you bye