New Culture Forum - June 30, 2019


Sir Roger Scruton

24. Twitter phenomenon ‘Titania McGrath’ aka comedian Andrew Doyle 26. Katharine Birbalsingh: Kids need knowledge & discipline

Episode Stats


Length

45 minutes

Words per minute

144.3

Word count

6,550

Sentence count

142


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to So What You're Saying Is, I'm Peter Whittrell.
00:00:09 Now, we started this programme in January. Since then I've interviewed about 25 people.
00:00:15 It's a very particular and very important time for us because we have just passed the 1 million views mark.
00:00:22 So I'd like to take this opportunity to say thank you very much to all those people who have watched.
00:00:26 hope you continue watching and also to those people who have subscribed to the
00:00:30 channel and indeed to those of you who've sent donations because they are
00:00:35 extremely important to us we really do appreciate it thank you very much
00:00:39 because this is a landmark it's particularly important that we have an
00:00:43 especially eminent distinguished guests I'm glad to say that today I'm joined
00:00:48 by the philosopher Sir Roger Scruton Sir Roger has been a dogged defender and
00:00:54 and promoter of conservatism and conservative ideas over 50 years.
00:00:59 He's the author of 50 books on philosophy, religion, art, politics, sexuality and music.
00:01:08 And he's with me now. Thank you very, very much for coming.
00:01:10 Thank you for inviting me.
00:01:12 I think that some congratulations are in order because you've just been awarded the Polish Order of Merit, if you not.
00:01:20 Yes, exactly.
00:01:21 Now, does this relate to the work you did in Eastern Europe?
00:01:25 Yes, this was, just a week or so ago, there was the 30th anniversary of the first free elections that took place in Poland,
00:01:38 first free elections after the communist collapse in Eastern Europe.
00:01:42 And so there was a big celebration for this, and they singled me out as someone who was symbolically important because I'd been involved.
00:01:50 But my involvement was not at all overt or well-known.
00:01:58 I spent a lot of time in those days making contacts among the underground in Poland, Czechoslovakia and Hungary
00:02:07 and putting people into relation with their Western colleagues, taking them materials, giving them talks as well
00:02:15 You know, because they were completely out of their depth when it came to trying to understand the geopolitical situation.
00:02:24 Nobody had ever explained to them that there was such a thing as conservatism or a liberal current of opinion within socialism and all that.
00:02:33 So we had a very, I and a lot of colleagues, had a very good time going around to the places where people had got together to educate themselves.
00:02:45 And that's something I've always believed in, that civil society consists of those little platoons that Burke recommends to us.
00:02:55 Those platoons had all been abolished in Eastern Europe, yet people were groping their way towards them again.
00:03:03 So it was very inspiring to visit the places where they were and help people to set themselves on their feet.
00:03:12 It wasn't safe, of course.
00:03:14 I was going to say, it must have been dangerous.
00:03:17 Well, it was. One was followed often.
00:03:21 And, you know, I went on getting a visa to go in to Poland right to the end,
00:03:27 not to Czechoslovakia. I was arrested there.
00:03:30 But, you know, as long as you were careful and prepared things properly,
00:03:35 we were always a step in advance of the secret police
00:03:40 because it was a time when everything was changing.
00:03:43 You know, we had computers. They had only just begun to envisage a computer.
00:03:48 We even had, among our underground contacts, somebody who produced the first software for the Czech language.
00:03:57 So we had that before the secret police had it.
00:04:00 So there was quite a difference in technological availability for us.
00:04:06 But it wasn't safe.
00:04:09 safe but for that very reason it was there was something inspiring because you knew that whoever
00:04:15 you were talking to was taking a risk yes so you're so talking to you was more important to him
00:04:21 than the possibility of you know six months in in jail isn't that really well like English
00:04:28 academia now I have to say I have been distressed to see the parallel when I first went to Czechoslovakia
00:04:38 In 1979 this was, after the Charter 77 movement, which had tried briefly to establish relations with the West of an open kind,
00:04:52 all my colleagues in the university who had signed the charter were either still in jail or anyway not allowed to teach.
00:05:01 They were doing menial jobs sweeping streets or stoking boilers.
00:05:05 and one of the most important procedures that had been used against them
00:05:11 was the denunciatory letter.
00:05:16 Their colleagues in their department would find a letter on their desk one morning
00:05:21 issued by the secret police denouncing a particular colleague
00:05:26 for having signed the charter or for having associated with people who did
00:05:30 and accusing him of subversion of the republic in collaboration with foreign powers
00:05:36 and all this sort of thing, and asking for a signature from the person on whose desk it was
00:05:43 to add his name to the call for this person to be dismissed.
00:05:48 And that's what we're seeing in universities here now.
00:05:52 Letters of denunciation formulated by totalitarian students
00:05:58 who've got no conception of recent history don't read books but are full of a kind of
00:06:05 undigested venom towards the world of culture into which they should be
00:06:11 longing to incorporate themselves but for some reason they can't do it and they see these
00:06:17 professors with old-fashioned views you know who who might not have the absolutely up-to-date
00:06:24 vision of whatever it is as the issue of the day, transgenderism or whatever it
00:06:29 might be and so he's ripe for denunciation and we've seen this with
00:06:34 several cases recently and the university, many of the universities, just
00:06:39 capitulate and say yeah well that's that's his fault. I think you've referred
00:06:44 to this recently but it's possibly the kind of death isn't it of the university?
00:06:48 Well if it if it's not stopped it will it will be the death certainly of
00:06:52 humanities departments I think in the sciences it will still you know people
00:06:57 will still go on but but science when as it were isolated from the rest of
00:07:02 culture becomes a very dreary thing and people become alienated from it you know
00:07:07 all the great scientists of our time if you look back at Einstein and you know
00:07:12 and Freud and Piaget and all those people they were highly cultivated people
00:07:16 and for them their intellectual development
00:07:22 could never have been confined to something like a laboratory.
00:07:26 It was a form of dialogue with civilization as a whole
00:07:32 and if that goes, I mean it hasn't gone
00:07:34 because I know some wonderfully cultivated scientists today
00:07:39 but if the humanities departments are taken out of universities
00:07:43 that's a very great loss to science as well you mentioned the Eastern Europe
00:07:49 there you said I think recently that you know Eastern European countries Hungary
00:07:56 Czech Republic are our natural friends yes more than maybe the others well
00:08:03 certainly the impression one had traveling then of course I was traveling
00:08:10 among dissidents and people had taken risks to stand up for something, but the impression
00:08:15 one had was that there was a great admiration for the British experience, and that we had
00:08:20 to some extent established ourselves as a role model for a stable government in a changing
00:08:26 world, and our Conservative Party was much admired, partly for Mrs Thatcher's strength
00:08:32 of character of course, but it was really quite inspiring for me to be able to associate
00:08:39 myself with this country's resilience and firmness against the whole Soviet expansion.
00:08:48 Whether that exists now is another question, but it did exist then in the late 1970s, and
00:08:55 I think had we worked harder than we have done, those countries would have been our
00:09:01 natural allies in our long-term conflict with the european union yeah exactly speaking of which to
00:09:10 come right up today you mentioned there that the conservative party maybe was quite resilient then
00:09:15 under that yes when you when you look at now we're recording this during the full throttle if you
00:09:22 like of the leadership campaign of the tribe party when you look at that now what do you
00:09:26 sort of take from from it when you look at the personalities involved and the issues and the way
00:09:32 they're expressed i mean what does it what does it say about the general state of conservatism
00:09:38 very good question you know i've always been worried about the general state of conservatism
00:09:44 because as an intellectual i think it ought to have proper philosophical foundations and i look
00:09:50 for those foundations and I don't really see them very clearly in practical politics of course in
00:09:57 the tradition and in in the history yes you have Burke and and Hegel and de Maistre and all those
00:10:03 people in the romantic period and what followed in the 19th century all that is very inspiring
00:10:09 but I don't think it has much impact on the conservative party I mean the conservative
00:10:16 party has always been suspicious of intellectuals anyway on the perfectly good ground that
00:10:22 intellectuals think and thinking is dangerous. You know you might come up with a wrong idea
00:10:27 so the conservative party has always been very demure about it but now I think it's that
00:10:36 that lack of a proper thought through basis to their worldview is beginning to show
00:10:44 because that's precisely what was needed in the whole Brexit thing,
00:10:48 a sense of what and who and where we are as a nation
00:10:53 in this confrontation with the global forces, which we can't avoid.
00:10:59 Where do we put our flag, so to speak, in what territory and how?
00:11:05 How do we respond to all the changes brought about by mass migration
00:11:11 and, of course, especially migration from Eastern Europe.
00:11:15 Anybody in his senses in Poland has his eye on coming here,
00:11:20 although I'm glad to say that the Polish economy is picking up
00:11:24 and there's beginnings of a movement the other way.
00:11:28 But all these things we know are hugely, hugely difficult,
00:11:32 and it's certainly a case where having some conception
00:11:37 of what our country is and where its values and its future come from was necessary.
00:11:45 You mentioned there, Mr. Satch, the battles seem to be largely economic.
00:11:51 I'm speaking very broadly here.
00:11:53 But you mentioned there too about what we are, who we are, where we are.
00:12:00 You would define conservatism, wouldn't you, as being,
00:12:04 that is the essence of it in a way, and a love of that.
00:12:07 and wanting to preserve it is that right the first principle of politics for a conservative in my
00:12:15 view is that politics is concerned with belonging we have a particular community which belongs in
00:12:23 a place but also in a in a tradition in a political framework and with it and belongs in expectations
00:12:33 and so on. All these are things which unite people in a first person plural as a we and unite us to
00:12:39 a place and we've always assumed that and if you don't assume that you have a real problem about
00:12:46 how you deal with people who don't agree with you. You know this is something that was very
00:12:52 clearly seen in the 20th century when the communists and the Nazis declared
00:13:00 that you know that there can be no opposition because you've now got the
00:13:06 right solution but and then they looked around for what the opposition where it
00:13:12 might be and of course it was then hidden it was then the enemy within and
00:13:16 had to be destroyed but but in a democracy if you recognize it that we
00:13:22 live among people who disagree with us but attached to the same place and the
00:13:28 same historical inheritance we can then all say you know let's agree to
00:13:33 disagree but we still have this which is more important than what we believe
00:13:38 this thing which is ours to which belongs to us and we belong to it that
00:13:42 to me is what the Conservative Party has always emphasized in the past and one
00:13:47 reason for its great electoral success and it sort of suddenly has ceased to do
00:13:52 so it's lost confidence partly because it's frightened of the left as soon as
00:13:56 you start saying these sort of things that I've just said to you which are in
00:14:00 my view quite harmless and also true you get accused of these thought crimes
00:14:07 that have suddenly become dominant you know because you're you're wanting to
00:14:11 You're wanting to exclude people, you're wanting to attach yourself to some kind of primitive supremacist vision of what your own community is, which of course is not true at all.
00:14:28 You know when you say, you're talking about the 80s, that there was this sense in which we could disagree or whatever but we all had this.
00:14:37 Kim. I think it's true to say, isn't it, that that was more intact then than now?
00:14:42 Of course it was more intact, and that's part of what we're going through, is a recognition
00:14:46 that the fabric that holds all that together has been torn. But again, I think there's
00:14:55 a lesson to be learned from the East European experience. If you ask yourself, why was it
00:15:01 communism finally collapsed there wasn't any external force causing it to do so it collapsed
00:15:10 largely because the poles woke up to their sense of national identity they they started saying we
00:15:17 are an entity other than the communist party and we're going to affirm that and thanks to the
00:15:24 election of john paul john paul ii you know to the papacy of course they had the added boost from
00:15:30 their religious inheritance and you know we all need that and it shouldn't be demonized but the
00:15:38 people but the left has had a real attempt at demonizing it so that we have the conservative
00:15:43 party is afraid to confess to what it knows to be true yes you uh come from a quite humble
00:15:53 background don't you originally it wasn't it didn't have sort of future eminent conservative
00:15:58 philosopher sort of printed all over it did it but was it a political family was it well my father
00:16:05 was very political he was a labour party member and a trade union member as well he belonged to
00:16:13 the national union of teachers and he was the local secretary of his branch and you know he
00:16:19 took it very seriously and he was a bit of a class warrior a product of the of the Manchester slums
00:16:30 who remained through all his life loyal to that deprived background and wanting on the best of
00:16:37 grounds for the situation of people in the industrial working class to be improved they
00:16:45 They should have their share of the beauty of this countryside, for instance, and the wealth that it produced.
00:16:53 And it was a very noble approach to things, very much that of the old Labour Party,
00:17:00 which was not about taking over the entire economy and turning it in a collectivist direction.
00:17:08 Although, unfortunately, after the war, you know, all the Clause 3 stuff came in, and it did move in that direction.
00:17:18 But he wasn't a collectivist of that kind, but he did want things to be distributed more fairly.
00:17:25 Yes.
00:17:26 And he had a visceral dislike of the upper class.
00:17:33 How did that manifest itself?
00:17:35 Just inability to tolerate their existence and just sneering at the radio whenever they were mentioned or anybody appeared on the radio speaking with what was then the correct BBC accent.
00:17:48 When people talked correctly, he would bang his fist on the table, anyway, that was not pleasant.
00:18:01 And I, at the time, his anger against the upper class really inspired me to investigate them.
00:18:13 You know, I thought, well, gosh, these people, they really sound interesting.
00:18:17 They're at that point, let's have a look.
00:18:21 Was there a particular point at which, or was it a gradual thing,
00:18:26 that you formulated your conservatism or your world view?
00:18:33 Did something happen, or did it just gradually emerge?
00:18:37 Well, everybody's in a state of flux, and I'm no different from everybody else,
00:18:43 but there was the crucial moment of 1968 in Paris where I was at the time.
00:18:50 I'd left university and been teaching in the Collège Universitaire in Pau,
00:18:56 and I was there in May in Paris, borrowed a flat from a friend,
00:19:01 and saw what was going on, and I was outraged by it,
00:19:07 You know, the smashing of things by these incredibly well-heeled students in their Maoist uniforms.
00:19:16 You know, it occurred to me, what on earth do they think they're going to put in the place of this wonderful city of Paris, of France, of the culture and history of France?
00:19:27 Where are they going to get it from?
00:19:30 And there was no answer to that.
00:19:31 And, of course, I started reading all the destructive literature that had influenced them,
00:19:36 in particular Foucault and Althusser and so on.
00:19:40 And that really turned me against the sort of Marxist orthodoxy
00:19:46 that was beginning to take over the student world in the late 60s.
00:19:51 And then I went back to Cambridge to do research,
00:19:54 you know there I met you know robust people who hadn't gone down the Marxist line and I thought
00:20:02 well in that case one doesn't have to and I started thinking things through and really got
00:20:07 interested in you know in the question what is the alternative what does it apply to the society in
00:20:16 which we are now and where are its intellectual roots so I became you know
00:20:23 sort of known in the academic world as someone prepared to defend conservatism
00:20:29 well if we think that's 1968 we're now 2019 so like 51 years you've been
00:20:37 defending conservatism during that whole time you have often you know ploughed a
00:20:44 lonely pharaoh it's true to say what and you've had lots of hostility what keeps
00:20:53 you going in the face of that as a man well you're right to ask that question
00:21:01 because I have gone through moments of depression and actually be but I've
00:21:08 always had the hope that there are others of thinking likewise and I've
00:21:12 always had the good fortune to meet them and for the most part the
00:21:18 hostility has been the kind that you can deal with as long as you have
00:21:25 another circle of your own. So I was very lonely at certain times but my
00:21:33 involvement in Eastern Europe cheered me up no end because I recognized then
00:21:40 that all those things I disliked in the academic Marxism that was emerging
00:21:45 around me had actually been put into practice and had shown how not how
00:21:53 inefficient they were but how evil they were you know entering that world where
00:21:59 everyone was in a state of fear nobody trusted anyone there was a sense of the
00:22:05 omnipresent eye observing you without knowing whose eye it was. All that was
00:22:11 very creepy and and it got into my soul to be quite honest and I thought
00:22:18 even if I'm hated for what I write I've got to write in such a way as to show
00:22:23 how destructive of the human norm that is of a human personality and I still
00:22:31 think that I still long for the great book which will pin it down and say this should
00:22:38 never happen again unfortunately but of course I got to know the literature and there's nobody
00:22:46 who's read Miłosz's Captive Mind or Solzhenitsyn of course can have any doubts about it but
00:22:57 unfortunately we're entering a period of illiteracy in which people don't read
00:23:01 those books. I mean one of the most recent you know hostilities you faced or
00:23:08 rather difficulties you faced was when they put an end to your position when
00:23:15 you had been appointed by the Conservative government to be head of
00:23:18 the beautiful building housing committee and because of an interview
00:23:25 which seems to have been a new low in outrageous distortion you were asked to
00:23:32 leave whatever what was that like well that was very disturbing because I
00:23:39 thought whatever the attacks on me the Conservative Party surely is my place of
00:23:50 refuge and they must see that I'm standing up for the things that they ought to be standing up for
00:23:58 and I was pleased that they appointed me to this commission. Unusual. Unusual yes and it was a
00:24:03 difficult commission to advocate for beauty in a world that's dominated by utilitarian architecture
00:24:10 you know that's tough and it required a lot of work and a lot of diplomacy but the interesting
00:24:19 thing is that when as you say I gave an interview at my publisher's request I didn't ask for it
00:24:26 to the to the new statesman I thought it was going to be about my philosophy and so on
00:24:32 and they sent this journalist of um obviously of
00:24:38 animated by a very strong hostility to me pretty mildly who who uh essentially fabricated the
00:24:45 interview from my discourse yes and by taking bits out of context adjusting other bits and all the
00:24:53 usual stuff but addressing it in effect to the social media mob asking them or inviting them to
00:25:04 join in in in character assassination and the effect of it of course was the whole press
00:25:11 came in on this because um it looked like a jolly good story and the conservative party joined in
00:25:17 instead of i wasn't even asked to um explain i learned as i was on a train at the time i learned
00:25:26 i'd been dismissed peremptorily by the minister concerned um and um that was it and it was so
00:25:35 You know, it was typical of this panic that the Conservatives feel at the witch hunting that goes on on the left.
00:25:45 They don't want to be the next one.
00:25:47 If someone is being scapegoated, you must pick up your own stone and throw it at him.
00:25:53 Otherwise, you'll be the next one.
00:25:55 It's exactly the same as what I talked about with letters of denunciation.
00:25:59 Yes, exactly, yes.
00:26:00 I remember with one particular
00:26:03 of the Tory MPs, I think there were about three
00:26:05 Tory MPs, won't name
00:26:07 them, but one of them
00:26:09 who went for you
00:26:11 and it seemed to me actually
00:26:13 what it really showed also was the level of
00:26:14 Philistinism actually because
00:26:17 I got the impression, and I mean this with a great
00:26:19 respect, I got the impression he didn't quite know
00:26:21 who you even were, I'm thinking particularly
00:26:23 of Johnny Mercer
00:26:24 and talking about intellectualism
00:26:27 so somehow this was a bad thing
00:26:29 No, I think he was out of his depth.
00:26:33 I didn't follow all the things that were said because it was all too upsetting.
00:26:38 But I had the great good fortune that Douglas Murray stepped in
00:26:44 and relentlessly interrogated the new statesman about it
00:26:48 until finally somebody managed to get hold of the tape of the interview,
00:26:54 send it to me anonymously,
00:26:55 and we recognised that I hadn't said any of these things
00:26:59 or if there were phrases that were phrases I'd used,
00:27:04 I'd used them in a completely different context.
00:27:06 And I think now, I think there will be an apology about it from the paper.
00:27:15 I know the editor was mortified by the whole thing and that's good.
00:27:22 Before we leave this particular topic,
00:27:25 um i suppose that you know this is an important part in what we call our culture wars i guess it
00:27:30 was an important in in instance of it um i suppose that you could say there would be a
00:27:37 would have been a some sort of victory in the culture wars if they had said actually we were
00:27:42 wrong please we would like you to take it back yeah if they did that would you have taken it back
00:27:47 um i think if it had come at the right time i would in order to help them over their embarrassment
00:27:53 I wouldn't have wanted it back
00:27:57 because the reason why I got these attacks
00:28:00 that happened already
00:28:02 is that the architectural establishment
00:28:05 is deeply hostile to my being in that position
00:28:09 because they know that I will say the things
00:28:12 that they don't want to hear
00:28:14 and they don't want the public to hear
00:28:15 namely that the kind of templates used
00:28:19 in our cities and in our countryside today
00:28:22 by the the average modern architect are deeply repugnant to the ordinary person and that's why
00:28:29 ordinary people fight their planning battles and prevent us from building and the architectural
00:28:35 schools need to wake up to this and we need to arm the public against them and i was going to say
00:28:41 that so they will always stop me saying that and they'll use any weapon because there's a this is
00:28:47 a huge vested interest with a great deal of money behind it and a great deal of political connection
00:28:53 especially with the Tory party and so were you you were surprised in some ways maybe
00:29:00 by your point which is anyone else absolutely I thought that I thought these the conservative
00:29:05 party had was now must be going through a crisis because it was insane enough to appoint someone
00:29:12 who believed what it ought to be believing you know on the whole the conservative party has
00:29:19 survived by aiming to be still in place at the next election and doing whatever is necessary
00:29:26 to be there you you're talking about it was called building beautiful yes you talked a lot about
00:29:32 beauty you've written about beauty there's a book on beauty and you did a tv program on beauty which
00:29:37 I loved I watched it it's required viewing I think but the upshot of what
00:29:42 you say in that it seems to me is that we are either afraid of beauty now or we
00:29:50 have sort of banished the whole idea of beauty so before I ask you I just ask
00:29:54 what would you call beauty in architecture or art I think what I would
00:30:05 to say is the most important aspect of beauty is that we are at home with it
00:30:11 right and that's even when it shocks us or challenges us you know some just go
00:30:22 back to you know the great challenging works of art like like Picasso's you
00:30:29 you know, early, well, middle period stuff,
00:30:35 or Stravinsky, the Stravinsky ballets,
00:30:39 especially the Rite of Spring,
00:30:40 or even some of the striking architecture
00:30:46 of people like Letherby and so on
00:30:48 at the turn of the century.
00:30:52 There, you know, whatever we think about it,
00:30:56 we stand back after a while and we think,
00:30:58 yes, I can bring this into my life, and it is part of me,
00:31:03 and it's inviting me to be part of it, and it's part of me.
00:31:08 That invitation is, I think, essential to our sense of beauty.
00:31:13 And in ordinary life, we're not aesthetes, most of us.
00:31:19 We don't go around the world looking for the sublime experience
00:31:23 that you can get from the Shakespeare sonnets or Tristan and Isolde or whatever.
00:31:28 We go around the world wanting to find the places where we could be,
00:31:36 places which don't repel us, which don't say go away,
00:31:40 which on the contrary open some kind of inner door.
00:31:44 And I think that's what everyday beauty is like,
00:31:47 and we're all able to produce it.
00:31:51 When we're given a room of our own and a bit of furniture,
00:31:54 we start arranging it so that it is like that,
00:31:56 so that we belong and it belongs.
00:31:58 And I think that is what the instinct for beauty is and why it's absolutely necessary for us and more necessary today
00:32:06 than it's ever been before
00:32:09 precisely because it's so rare and also because the
00:32:14 surrounding world is dominated by
00:32:16 utilitarian culture. Everything is conceived in functional terms as a means to an end. Certainly you see that in architecture, you know, it's all
00:32:25 straightforward simple
00:32:27 engineering devices to
00:32:29 to perform a particular function, but which don't have any ability to put the surrounding people at ease with them.
00:32:37 But you made the point, actually, an excellent point in the program, where you said that
00:32:42 buildings that have been built purely because they are useful, as it were, in the way that art is not necessarily useful,
00:32:48 end up being useless, they end up being empty, they end up having graffiti squalled all over them, no one wants to be near them.
00:32:55 exactly I think that that's where the first lesson that you learn when you
00:33:00 begin to study the philosophy of beauty is that there is a utility in the
00:33:05 useless and that you have we that's what we most need to cultivate in our own
00:33:12 lives as well we don't become lovable objects by being useful although we do
00:33:18 should lend our help to others and so on but we we we should we become lovable
00:33:23 through enjoying the world and radiating our appreciation of it and that is
00:33:29 something that we look for in beauty in buildings too and you know I always take
00:33:35 Paris as an example partly because it is so obviously you know a wonderful thing
00:33:43 but also because it's always under threat you know poor Notre Dame was
00:33:47 going to have some ghastly shell but designed by Norman Foster stuck on it I
00:33:52 imagine in the end but you know there there you see all around you that this sense that things
00:34:00 are there because because they are what people wanted to put yeah yeah just like in an arranged
00:34:08 room and the doors open into agreeable spaces the windows open onto the street properly and
00:34:15 you are there as though among friends even though those friends are made of stone
00:34:20 There is a sense surely if you look at the art world in particular or architecture
00:34:25 there's a sort of sense in which the belief is that truth is ugly
00:34:33 you know, ugliness is more truthful
00:34:35 this is the sort of thing you get told a lot
00:34:38 Yes, that was the idea being that you become truthful
00:34:47 by as it were repudiating things showing that that showing the world as it is and
00:34:57 the world as it is is a horrible world but that's what the artist should be
00:35:00 doing not finding something to love but finding something to you know just push
00:35:06 in your face and say this is part of you too now sometimes that that that can have
00:35:13 an important role in art. Obviously we all know that the Rite of Spring is about something
00:35:22 extremely ugly, the sacrificial death of a girl in the grip of the most appalling primitive
00:35:31 superstitions, but it is one of the most beautiful things ever composed. As I say it redeems
00:35:41 that death it isn't about saying that this the world is just as horrible as
00:35:45 this it's saying that no even in these horrible things there is a redemption
00:35:51 and here is the music that shows you that so I think that the true artist he
00:35:58 may he may mess around with these nasty things but it's in order to to show
00:36:06 that they are not intrinsically nasty that they contain the seeds of a real humanity
00:36:13 and you know a real artist will go to the edge of what is intolerable and still bring you back
00:36:21 some people like Dr Johnson thought that Shakespeare went to the edge in King Lear
00:36:29 and fell over it and so he rewrote the end to bring us back and you know there's some truth in
00:36:35 but I think we must recognize that the whole idea of tragedy is about the way in which art can redeem the human condition
00:36:46 by looking the most awful things in the face
00:36:49 I think sometimes when you look at the situation now in the art world for example
00:36:54 you can kind of lose hope but then something happens
00:36:58 for example I've went recently to the Portrait Gallery's Portrait Award
00:37:03 and it was full of people, some of the work was extraordinarily talented,
00:37:08 beautiful craftsmanship and you thought somehow these people must have slipped through the net.
00:37:13 Well, they have because remember the awful thing about works of visual art is you can own them
00:37:24 and then the Saatchi types come in and bid for them and then they're told by the critics
00:37:30 you must bid for this because it's really hideous and that that would be a prize procession so that
00:37:37 we're constantly bidding up ugliness and those old-fashioned portrait painters you know who
00:37:45 exhibit at the Royal Academy Summer's exhibition and so on they are pushed into the corner as you
00:37:51 know sort of you know they're sweet but they're but it's it's just bland yes and it doesn't
00:37:58 challenge doesn't it doesn't get to the the the mystery of the human condition and all those
00:38:04 things that those are things now my view is that actually it does often get to the mystery of the
00:38:11 human condition more effectively than say Andy Warhol I see you're looking at indeed I have got
00:38:17 that there yes you know who in my view was a totally trivial character who happened to make
00:38:23 a splash yes and this flash sold now in the case of music you know where you can't actually own
00:38:30 the result there's a countervailing force that says you know um since i can't possess this
00:38:37 the only way i can appreciate it is by listening to it and then of course critical judgment comes
00:38:42 in and gradually uh after a few horrible things uh clamoring in your ears you come around to
00:38:50 recognize that in music there has to be beauty too and we have emerging composers like James
00:38:58 McMillan and David Matthews and so on who are writing the sort of music that people actually
00:39:03 want to listen to and I think that there's the atelier movement in in representational painting
00:39:09 which is trying to do the same it's just that the art schools are full of people who are not capable
00:39:15 of actually teaching the techniques of representational painting. They can teach
00:39:21 you to make a splash and put your ego on display and therefore they invent all
00:39:26 kinds of curricula which are about putting your ego on display even if you
00:39:31 have no real ego that would fit the bill. It is all really about me isn't it?
00:39:37 Unfortunately that's our celebrity culture. That's one of the, we didn't
00:39:44 talk about this when talking about politics but that is one of the problems
00:39:47 with politics that because of the celebrity culture because you have to be
00:39:52 photogenic and appear on TV and everything the me concept begins to
00:39:59 dominate politics too and I think we are lucky that that it hasn't really
00:40:05 dominated this current attempt to find a leader of the Conservative Party which
00:40:10 is good but you know I think they'd be on to a hiding to nothing as well actually you mentioned
00:40:17 there about how the maybe the art world repudiated its traditional forms whatever maybe a bit of a
00:40:24 clunky segue here but I'm going back to 1968 when you were in Paris and I remember that the French
00:40:34 they tend to be much more open about talking about cultural issues and I remember I think
00:40:39 with Sarkozy, you were talking about we have got to, the 68th generation must not keep
00:40:46 apologising, it must not keep repudiating our greatness or whatever. You've called this
00:40:52 the culture of repudiation, I believe, which is where we essentially appear to want to
00:40:57 disown and indeed hate everything about ourselves. Do you think in the 50 years that you've been
00:41:04 writing and and everything that you've been doing that that it is the situation
00:41:11 there is better now or or worse because it seems to me that we are in one of the
00:41:17 peaks of sort of repudiation yes and no I think when I first began publishing as
00:41:27 a conscious conservative but the meaning of conservatism which I published I
00:41:32 I can't remember, 1969 or something, the, it was the case that all I got was incredible
00:41:45 attacks and then later I wrote Thinkers of the New Left, which was more or less the end
00:41:52 of my academic career, people just wouldn't, they just thought that I was completely on
00:41:58 the margin of everything, in attacking people like Foucault and Sartre and all that. But
00:42:05 now I get emails all the time saying, you know, thanking me for my writings and saying
00:42:13 that this is inspiring, I think we can all get together and do something about this.
00:42:18 So I think that there is certainly a kind of moment of awakening, like awakening against
00:42:25 the woke.
00:42:27 Do you think that is happening?
00:42:28 I think it is happening among serious people.
00:42:31 And not only middle-aged people, lots of young people write to me about things.
00:42:37 My little film on beauty, which you referred to,
00:42:40 that's had a million views before the BBC took it down in outrage.
00:42:46 You can still see it on Vimeo.
00:42:48 Yes, exactly, with Portuguese subtitles.
00:42:51 That's had about a million views, I think.
00:42:53 And I get a lot of stuff from young people about that,
00:42:57 saying thank you so you've helped me you've helped me get away from the cult of ugliness
00:43:02 and okay that's only my personal narrative but I think one mustn't lose faith in human nature
00:43:13 one must at the same time recognize that civilizations decline that we can lose things
00:43:21 and never get them back, as our ancestors did, you know, in the Dark Ages.
00:43:27 But there were those self-sacrificing monks who kept the lamp burning, and it did come back.
00:43:35 I suppose on an almost more prosaic level, I was thinking,
00:43:39 here are the sort of 68ers who, I would say on the whole, are in charge of the show now.
00:43:45 You know, they're the seniors now.
00:43:46 and the general drift of society regardless of the government appears leftward always
00:43:52 there's got to come a point where you know all of these people who are placed in all of these
00:43:57 positions for you briefly for a moment which was most unusual but how do we change that how do
00:44:04 what is the plan for changing that um one should never forget that one's greatest friend in this
00:44:11 life is death and you know they'll all go and you have to prepare what their
00:44:20 successor and they're all there are also moments of the repudiation of the
00:44:30 repudiation and I think we've seen this to a great extent in France a recovery
00:44:37 of the sense of the French cultural identity you don't find in France the
00:44:43 adulation of Foucault and Derrida and Lacan and all that you find in American
00:44:49 universities they most French intellectuals will say yeah that had its
00:44:54 day but you know it was pretty narcissistic wasn't it so and there's
00:45:00 always something new. You know, that's really given me some hope actually. Thank
00:45:08 you very much. Thank you so much for joining us actually Sir Roger. Thank you
00:45:11 for that time and for that very very optimistic ending. Thank you very very
00:45:16 much for watching So What You're Saying Is and I hope to see you next time. Thank
00:45:21 you very much.