New Culture Forum - July 12, 2019


26. Katharine Birbalsingh: Kids need knowledge & discipline

Sir Roger Scruton 27. David Goodhart: Somewheres and anywheres

Episode Stats


Length

43 minutes

Words per minute

213.63

Word count

9,263

Sentence count

172


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to So What You're Saying Is, I'm Peter Whittall. Now my guest this week has
00:00:11 just been awarded Contrarian of the Year Award 2019. Katherine Burblesing is a teacher but she's
00:00:20 also the founder and headmistress of the Michaela Free Community School in London which she founded
00:00:27 in 2014. But that's not really the whole picture because she has pretty much single-handedly
00:00:33 fought against educational orthodoxies and indeed the educational establishment as it's
00:00:38 been over the past decades. I'm thrilled that she's with me now, Catherine, welcome.
00:00:43 Thank you for having me.
00:00:44 First of all, I have to ask you, what's it like being contrarian of the year?
00:00:49 Yeah, well, you know, when I was first told that I was being shortlisted, I thought it
00:00:53 was all a bit funny. It's great. I mean, as I was telling the audience the other night
00:00:58 that I think contrarians tell the truth. And being a truth teller is something that's quite
00:01:07 difficult, I find. People are far more likely to take the easier road and just they don't
00:01:14 like difficult conversations. They don't want to say things that they think, especially
00:01:18 in this day and age and so I was really honored in that sense to be shortlisted
00:01:25 and then to to actually win the prize yeah I quite like being a contrarian
00:01:30 you're up against some pretty awesome yeah there was Douglas Murray and there
00:01:35 was David Goodhart and there was a woman called Helen Pluckrose people may not
00:01:38 know as well who would expose the academic establishment by getting essays
00:01:45 published so she created these ridiculous essays which were just absurd and got
00:01:49 them published in an academic journal which really was quite humiliating for
00:01:53 the journal because I know I remember this was the one wasn't it where they
00:01:58 came up with these amazing sort of subjects like studying dogs in school
00:02:01 playgrounds and things like this to make very sociological points it was all a
00:02:05 spoof wasn't it exactly and so she made fools out of them really and and then of
00:02:09 course David Goodhart is fighting for the somewheres against the anywheres and
00:02:13 and then as you know Douglas Murray is trying to save the West and so and then
00:02:18 there was Theresa May actually who was also one of the contenders bizarrely
00:02:21 because I sort of think she's not much of a contrarian she's very conformist I
00:02:25 would say but I don't know anyway she was one of them and and yeah so it was
00:02:30 it was great to win I mean you know I I think in anything you know in running my
00:02:38 school, I think all leaders need to be as kind of truthful as possible with
00:02:43 their staff, with themselves. I think often we are too dishonest with
00:02:47 ourselves to really make a difference. And I was just speaking to some new
00:02:54 staff of mine this morning who are coming to join the school in September
00:02:57 and they were talking about how in their schools one of them is saying that you
00:03:04 know you get feedback you people go and observe a lesson and you get feedback but at her school
00:03:08 they've decided to call it feed forward um because and there's no reason they just decided
00:03:14 it because it's more forward thinking and it sounds nicer and then they spend two hours
00:03:17 telling all the staff about this and they're wasting everyone's time and um it's like they
00:03:21 live in a different stratosphere in that um uh there's some people who are just uh going through
00:03:29 the motions instead of it being really real um and i think people find me a little bit you know
00:03:37 well i always say i'm like marmite and the school is like marmite either you love us or you hate us
00:03:41 and um same with me um and it's because of the the truth thing i really like the truth
00:03:49 um and and and and i think sadly uh too many people are quite happy uh to ignore the truth
00:03:55 because it's too difficult to deal with well it's interesting because just uh recently we
00:04:00 interviewed roger scrutin he was talking about the truth a lot and we're living in this time
00:04:04 of post-truth and all the rest of it yeah yeah exactly you came and spoke to the new culture
00:04:09 forum you might not remember but it was a good 10 years ago nearly i think right and that was
00:04:13 before you set up the school um how difficult was it setting up your school rich you did it in 2014
00:04:21 so that was you already a voice you know in on the scene you'd written a book which i'm going
00:04:27 to hold up now actually you can still get here we go to miss with love i think taken out of
00:04:32 to sew with love um the film and um this was based on a blog you did wasn't it that's right so the
00:04:39 blog was called to miss with love um and i was called miss snuffleupagus um because i on stephanie
00:04:44 sesame street uh for those of us who grew up in the 70s you know you'll all know sesame street
00:04:49 There was Big Bird and there was Snuffleupagus, who was the big elephant, this mammoth.
00:04:54 And nobody could see Snuffleupagus even though he was absolutely huge.
00:04:58 So Big Bird would talk to the other people on Sesame Street and say, oh my friend Snuffleupagus.
00:05:01 And when people would arrive, Snuffleupagus wouldn't be there because the elephant in
00:05:04 the room, you know?
00:05:05 And so that's why I called myself Miss Snuffleupagus, which eventually turned to Miss Snuffy.
00:05:09 So now I have the embarrassment of when I give my business cards to people, as the head
00:05:12 mistress of Michaela, it says Miss Snuffy on there from my Twitter.
00:05:16 And it looks a bit odd, but that's why.
00:05:18 And yeah, and so I had this blog, To Miss With Love,
00:05:22 and I used to write a few posts a week.
00:05:24 I didn't sort of realise that there were kind of big politicians and so on
00:05:27 reading my blog, like Michael Goh, for instance.
00:05:30 I didn't have any idea.
00:05:31 I was just a teacher doing my thing.
00:05:33 And then there was this woman from Penguin who was reading it as well,
00:05:36 and she wanted to make it into a book.
00:05:38 So the book is essentially what the blog was.
00:05:41 Right, I see.
00:05:42 And I was trying to explain anonymously what was going on in the school system
00:05:47 because I thought it was broken.
00:05:48 and when I then eventually said that out loud in 2010 at the Conservative Party conference
00:05:54 a lot of people didn't like me for it this is what I mean about the truth because I think
00:05:59 everybody knows what's going on oh you said quite recently is that the parents parents really some
00:06:05 parents really have very little idea of how bad things are in state schools okay I didn't mean
00:06:10 parents I mean everybody in teaching knows what's going on so teachers have a sense of it it's just
00:06:14 that I think too many people are in denial absolutely parents don't
00:06:18 necessarily realize and the reason they don't realize is because schools are not
00:06:22 really open to parents so in Brent alone where I am there are 15 secondary
00:06:28 schools there only seven of them offer an open day to parents to go and see what
00:06:34 the school is like if you're in year six and you want to choose your school for
00:06:37 or seven so that's fewer than half but then even then schools will open up for
00:06:43 a morning if you're lucky in October to go and see it what if you want to see it
00:06:49 in May what if you want to see it in June and then not only that but what if
00:06:53 you want to see it at break time or at lunchtime because they will take you
00:06:56 down certain corridors and they will show you certain classrooms but they
00:06:59 won't show you the whole school we Michaela however are open all the time
00:07:03 to visitors and we have visitors that come every single day from around the
00:07:06 world and I feel that every school should be open to visitors at all times
00:07:12 yeah I think sunlight is the best disinfectant and I think that if we could
00:07:17 all see what was going on in the schools whenever we wanted then there would be a
00:07:20 better sense of what's actually happening in education I don't I mean
00:07:24 this is interesting point actually because I don't you you've you've heard
00:07:27 but there's reports that I've just read it was out today actually which is
00:07:31 basically saying that there was a school in Birmingham which seemed to have had
00:07:36 at one point or another an outstanding grade from Austed but now the teachers
00:07:41 are on strike because of the level of violence I mean you you know you know
00:07:45 about this one yeah well I mean it got it outstanding in 2012 right so it has
00:07:50 been a few years and I know Amanda Spielman has been complaining about this
00:07:54 idea that if a school has been given outstanding then it should just be left
00:07:56 alone right because schools can change rapidly yeah and when they were given
00:08:00 their outstanding they only had primary children there and then they grew and
00:08:03 and now they have a secondary school and the secondary school often you find
00:08:06 people who deal with primaries they then think oh you know we're gonna set up a
00:08:11 secondary school well that'd be great and they don't realize that it really is
00:08:14 a completely different kettle of fish it's much more difficult to run a
00:08:16 successful secondary school than it is a primary school and that is not to do
00:08:19 you know not to say that primary schools don't aren't hard but it's just a
00:08:23 different thing you have one class with each teacher you don't have children
00:08:28 moving around the school going from class to class and also secondary
00:08:31 schools are just much much larger institutions yeah um how large is yours at the moment you
00:08:36 know how many kids do you have so we have 600 next year we'll have 700 and a bit uh and then
00:08:40 eventually we'll have 840 we've been growing every year since 2014 and so at full capacity in two
00:08:45 years we'll have 840 our sixth form opens in september which is really exciting and we get
00:08:50 our first gcse results in august uh so we're really at the beginning but um yeah i mean so
00:08:57 that the Ofsted point is that you know things, Ofsted visits a school for a day
00:09:03 and a half. I think people put far too much, they value Ofsted far too much
00:09:10 both the public and the teachers for that matter. Ofsted visits for a day and a
00:09:14 half, they make a snapshot, they get a snapshot, that's all they can do, right?
00:09:17 And I mean look we've got outstanding and I suppose I should be shouting it
00:09:22 from the rooftops and saying look we've got outstanding but you know what if
00:09:26 that's not the thing that I'm proud of you know the thing I'm proud of are the
00:09:29 kids inside it and the teachers inside it and if you want to see our school come
00:09:32 and see it because we're open at all times and we're open at all times because
00:09:36 I take great pride in the fact that I know with a hundred percent certainty if
00:09:39 you walk around the school at any time you will find all of the children
00:09:42 learning you will find excellent lessons throughout the school I don't have to
00:09:46 take you down corridor B and avoid corridor a because I'm worried about
00:09:50 what you're going to see there. Right. And I think that's really crucial. I think
00:09:56 also the public accept far too much you know bullying and and all sorts of
00:10:02 things that go on and so people say well it's just normal. It's normal for kids
00:10:04 to behave like that. It's not normal. We can make a difference. We can change
00:10:08 things. We can have higher standards for children and we do at Michaela and
00:10:13 because we've got high standards for those children they rise to it. I always
00:10:16 say if you keep your standards here the children will meet you there. If you keep
00:10:18 there the children will meet you there it's just a question of how high you want them i mean in a
00:10:24 nutshell really your approach is is is remarkably simple isn't it as i understand it is basically
00:10:31 teaching kids knowledge as opposed to learning skills whatever it might be knowledge and also
00:10:37 discipline i mean basically those are the two isn't that right the two columns of your approach
00:10:42 yeah that is right so when you say teaching knowledge what we mean is we value
00:10:46 you, you know, I suppose a kind of political way of thinking about this is that it's more
00:10:52 conservative to think about giving knowledge to the future generations. Roger Scruton would
00:10:59 think very much that that is the point of education, that it's our duty as educators
00:11:03 to pass on knowledge from our generation to the following generations so that the country
00:11:08 can do well. That's how Scruton would view it. And then there's the more left approach,
00:11:13 which is education is about creating revolutionaries
00:11:16 and getting them to overthrow typical thinking
00:11:20 and getting them to question.
00:11:23 And I'm all for questioning and being critical in your thinking.
00:11:28 My argument would be you can't do that without the knowledge, right?
00:11:31 So then there are a bunch of people in the middle who will say that,
00:11:33 who will say, well, wait a minute,
00:11:34 we want our children to be critical thinkers,
00:11:36 so we need to give them lots of knowledge.
00:11:37 And I suppose that's kind of where we're at.
00:11:39 Although, obviously, my teachers, they think a variety of different things.
00:11:42 But certainly that's where I'm at. You cannot get children to be critical and to be creative and to think outside the box and to think independently if they don't know very much.
00:11:56 And at secondary school, it is our duty to give them that. When they go on to the sixth form, when they go on to university, then they can use that knowledge to create.
00:12:04 But a 12-year-old can't create that much. And if they do create something, we are patronizing them and we say, isn't this the most extraordinary thing ever?
00:12:12 because actually it's not because they don't know very much to be able to do much with it
00:12:16 and sadly over the last 50 or 60 years we've sort of lost that in education
00:12:20 a teacher is more a facilitator of learning moving around the desks that are grouped together
00:12:27 while the children are leading the learning as opposed to the teacher leading the learning
00:12:31 I always say the teacher should be driving the bus the children get on the bus and it is for
00:12:35 the teacher to keep the children on the bus right and if one gets bored oh he's jumped off it's for
00:12:41 the teacher to make sure he gets back on um and that we do throughout the school
00:12:45 and so uh when visitors come they're always so impressed by the amount our
00:12:49 children know and just how clever they are at thinking and at being creative
00:12:53 because they've got the knowledge to do that with um and then the discipline i
00:12:58 mean there's lots of schools who also have you know uh high standards of
00:13:01 discipline um sadly there are many people out there campaigning to have poor
00:13:06 discipline and i know people think how that's ridiculous catherine how could
00:13:09 they be doing that they don't go around saying what we want is poor discipline what they say is
00:13:13 we don't want um uh punishments we think it's mean to punish children so we shouldn't do that
00:13:19 what you need is to have a restorative justice conversation with them where you talk about what's
00:13:24 gone wrong now of course you want to have a conversation with the child because you want
00:13:28 him to understand what he's done wrong but if there's no punishment that goes along with it
00:13:32 i can tell you they're going to ignore the conversation because yeah i mean i think kids
00:13:36 I remember we were we were exactly the same when I was in school you knew when a teacher was trying
00:13:41 to be down with you and everything and you would kind of exploit it in a way I think the point that
00:13:46 you're making is very interesting the idea for example that it almost amounts to sort of maybe
00:13:51 that knowledge is somehow going to imprison these kids but in fact knowledge sets you free doesn't
00:13:57 it I mean this is the point if you want to be free in thinking and you have to have structure and you
00:14:02 You have to have knowledge.
00:14:03 Well, I can tell you the thinking behind it,
00:14:05 which is that,
00:14:07 remember they want to reject the establishment, right?
00:14:10 This is the thing.
00:14:11 This is what you're saying.
00:14:12 That's the gut feeling there.
00:14:15 And so dead white men,
00:14:17 it makes them go,
00:14:18 ooh, I don't like that
00:14:19 because they don't like the power that comes with it.
00:14:21 The power structure is such that
00:14:23 these white men are on top
00:14:25 and they don't want that.
00:14:26 So they don't want to teach all that stuff.
00:14:28 It's about the content
00:14:29 that they really don't like, ultimately.
00:14:31 And they want to reject that.
00:14:32 So if you're teaching skills, then you don't have to decide which knowledge is more important,
00:14:36 because the problem with teaching knowledge is you've got to decide which bits of knowledge
00:14:39 you're going to teach. Right. And and then it becomes very political. You know, should you
00:14:45 read Shakespeare or should you read Benjamin Zephaniah? And then people say things like,
00:14:50 well, you just read both. But we all know there's only so much time in the in the school day.
00:14:54 The curriculum has to choose. Right. And so then you come to the point of, well, what is the point
00:14:59 of school and um again the divide between right and left i would say the right would see it more as
00:15:06 uh schools are there to help socialize children to help make them feel like they're part of a
00:15:10 country that they are british that they have they learn their british history that they read their
00:15:15 british literature that they that they are part of a certain a certain something uh the left would
00:15:21 see it more as no we want to reject all those things we don't want them to see themselves as
00:15:24 british actually being british is something we might feel a little bit ashamed about because
00:15:28 look at the terrible things that have happened in British history, you know, slavery and
00:15:32 so on. These are all awful. We might not think about the fact that Britain was a leading
00:15:37 light in abolishing slavery, but we want to ignore that, you know. And because of the
00:15:43 guilt, I think, that sits on people's shoulders for being British, they don't really want
00:15:48 to teach that. And so then it comes to this idea, well, actually what we want to do is
00:15:52 teach skills. Now that's my own philosophy on that, about why we've come to this point.
00:15:55 a lot of people wouldn't necessarily think that consciously you know now teachers are teaching
00:16:00 and they just they are told that the way in which um children come to really understand something
00:16:07 is by directing their own learning um but how is a 12 year old meant to direct their own learning i
00:16:13 mean take it down to a five-year-old how is a five-year-old meant to know the difference between
00:16:17 a triangle and a square unless you just tell him right he can't figure it out it's impossible now
00:16:21 this ultimately started with rousseau rousseau thought that you needed to draw it out of the
00:16:25 child as opposed to putting it in um you definitely have to put it into the child uh now that doesn't
00:16:31 mean that you can't then analyze it you can't toss it around in the classroom and do a bit of paired
00:16:35 work and and think about it of course you can yes that will help the child properly understand it
00:16:40 and properly retain it you know uh it's not a question of just the caricature of knowledge
00:16:44 teaching is it's just rote learning children just sit there like parrots and repeat after the teacher
00:16:49 and that's all that's going on that's not what's happening um not in a good classroom and if you
00:16:53 come to Michaela's classrooms you will see all sorts of energy and all sorts of
00:16:56 thinking and understanding going on but that's because in part we give them
00:17:00 knowledge and we also want them to learn it so that they know it memory is part
00:17:05 of what learning is you were a teacher for quite a long time before you set up
00:17:09 you've always been a teacher haven't you you're for a long line of teachers
00:17:12 aren't you or my father but you know have you always felt this way I mean or
00:17:21 did you has it been or did you have is it were more of the kind of orthodox view of education
00:17:28 at one time did you change i went through teacher training so sadly teacher training teaches
00:17:33 everyone how to teach the wrong way i mean that that's i that's a big statement but it's true
00:17:38 okay teacher training is all wrong and so i mean when teachers come to michaela for instance we
00:17:43 teach them how to teach differently they all have to go through a process of becoming a michaela
00:17:48 teacher um so I was I did went through teacher training like everybody else and
00:17:53 of course I did loads of games in fact in those days so we're looking at early
00:17:59 21st century you know in those days there was no talk of knowledge versus
00:18:05 skills I mean that that conversation didn't exist um all you ever did it was
00:18:10 just considered normal that you taught skills and that you wanted children to
00:18:13 get up out of the chairs in the classroom and move around and you wanted
00:18:16 to do brain gym and flap your arms around and learning styles and all of this stuff was just
00:18:23 standard in teaching. Since 2010, what is great is that there's much more of a conversation
00:18:27 around what works and what doesn't work. We're now looking at brain science. We're now looking
00:18:31 at research. We're now saying, hey, look, you know what? This doesn't work. Now, for me, it's always
00:18:36 been about the children in front of you. And so I learned quickly that that stuff just didn't work.
00:18:40 I think I taught French. So I used to just think, well, maybe it works for other subjects. It just
00:18:45 doesn't work for French because that was what I taught you know so I thought well
00:18:48 it just doesn't work for languages it's just different and so I did my verb we
00:18:52 did verb tables and we did the kind of more old-fashioned stuff and guess what
00:18:55 my kids did really well right Michaela the woman who we named the school after
00:19:00 she's originally from st. Lucia sadly she died of cancer in 2011 she was exactly
00:19:04 like that very old-fashioned she's to talk about rigor she said where is the
00:19:08 rigor Catherine you know and she was all about discipline all about the kids just
00:19:13 working hard and traditional teaching and she would stand in front of the classroom despite
00:19:17 all the fads and despite being told to do differently which is why we named the school
00:19:21 after her would you think actually i mean from what you're saying there i've got a business plan
00:19:27 for you um you're doing this new school in stevenage yes that will be a few years when
00:19:32 because you've got to get the school together and everything haven't you but what about a michaela
00:19:37 teacher training school yeah well isn't that the very root of what you're talking about yes but i
00:19:43 need to get a lot of teachers thinking that way in the first place you know
00:19:46 like um we're a really small institution so you know you can train people up but
00:19:51 then I mean you're talking about a much bigger thing eventually yes possibly um
00:19:56 you know there are some places Buckingham University that do things
00:19:59 slightly differently I mean I wouldn't want to say all teacher training but the
00:20:02 vast majority of it is is it's just is has fallen to this progressive way of
00:20:07 thinking and what makes me really sad is that there are people who I know
00:20:12 know personally who've dedicated their lives to teaching hard-working individuals who care about
00:20:17 the kids but because all of the philosophy is wrong around it the kids aren't benefiting and
00:20:23 people don't understand that holding kids to account and holding your standards high is is to
00:20:29 be on the kids side i don't get to school at 6 30 every morning because i hate kids right because i
00:20:34 love them i haven't been fighting the establishment all this time because i because i hate kids because
00:20:39 I love them and I want the establishment to do what's right by them sadly often the state gets
00:20:43 it wrong you know I'm very anti big state I'm really into the small state and why even though
00:20:49 I work for the state it's because I have worked for the state all my life yeah and I've seen the
00:20:53 damage it causes and just it just gets everything wrong um and so you know I'm not saying it
00:21:00 shouldn't exist obviously it needs to exist we depend on the state but um we do need to reduce
00:21:05 its influence and that's why I love free schools because they're still state
00:21:09 schools but it gives an ownership to the people who are who are running the
00:21:12 school and they're able to think outside the box one of the problems with the
00:21:17 state is that people working for the state tend to just keep doing the same
00:21:20 thing over and over again and they don't question when you're running a small
00:21:23 business you the bottom line matters right and if something isn't selling you
00:21:28 need to be thinking right well I'm gonna put that on sale and then I'm gonna sell
00:21:30 it like this I'm gonna do this and there's a dance that you do every day a
00:21:33 capitalist dance that you do when you're working in the state there is no
00:21:37 capitalist dance that happens and you could just clock in clock out every day
00:21:40 and you'd still earn your salary and nothing much changes now I'm not saying
00:21:44 teachers want to do that but it can happen you just kind of end up somebody
00:21:49 who's just kind of clocking in clocking out the thing about free schools is that
00:21:52 it just puts a bit more energy back into the system right people then own it you
00:21:57 know and I suppose the same is to be said of Academy Chains you know that's
00:22:00 the idea behind it now there are all sorts of problems that come with Academy
00:22:02 chains I'm not without my criticisms for Academy chains but the good thing about
00:22:07 them is that there's some sense of accountability right that that's the
00:22:10 thing it's accountability and kids need to be held to account teachers need to
00:22:14 be held to account head teachers need to be held to account and there's too
00:22:17 little of it in the system what I mean what going from before you set up
00:22:23 Michaela right through to now you we talk about the statement about the
00:22:28 educational establishment as well the state one you must have had you know a
00:22:34 fair amount of aggro from them and I wonder how you've handled that how do
00:22:41 you deal with that I mean because if you're going if you're swimming against
00:22:45 contrarian if you're swimming against the tide it's lonely isn't it yeah very
00:22:50 very lonely it is and I am hated by a lot of people but I remember those
00:22:56 children I just remember the children the thousands of children that I have
00:22:59 known in my lifetime and I remember the children that I have now in my hands and
00:23:03 I remember the fact that you know life is only worth living if you're doing
00:23:07 something where you're making a difference and I always say that I don't
00:23:10 imagine that the big changes in education will come in my lifetime you
00:23:13 know people who fought against slavery people who wanted the vote for women and
00:23:17 the Berlin Wall finally came down you know you you you work for something in
00:23:21 your life and at the end of your life you you pass the baton on and that's my plan is that i will
00:23:26 pass the baton on and i hope to have achieved something in my small lifetime you know because
00:23:31 what else is the point of living you know um i have this great quote by thomas soul and my who's
00:23:36 a great african-american i'd love to get him on this program yeah i mean it will be a sad day when
00:23:42 he goes i say that because he's 85 or something you know and um i love him anyway he he has this
00:23:48 quote where he says uh if you want to help yourself you tell people what they want to hear
00:23:52 if you want to help uh uh others you you you tell them the truth if you want to help other people
00:23:59 you tell them the truth and um that's what i mean about being a truth teller you want to
00:24:03 you telling the truth only the truth will set us free right and there's too too much in education
00:24:11 where people are just,
00:24:13 they're not looking at what's real.
00:24:17 And the number one thing,
00:24:18 I mean, you say about knowledge,
00:24:19 you're absolutely right,
00:24:19 we teach knowledge.
00:24:20 You're absolutely right about the discipline.
00:24:21 I also say things that distinguish us
00:24:23 is we teach gratitude.
00:24:24 We teach children to be grateful
00:24:25 for what they've got.
00:24:26 And no matter how hard their lives are,
00:24:28 and our children's lives,
00:24:29 some of them are awful.
00:24:30 We're in the inner city.
00:24:31 We're surrounded by gangs.
00:24:32 Children will turn up,
00:24:33 other children from other schools
00:24:35 will turn up,
00:24:36 I say children,
00:24:36 16-year-olds on bikes,
00:24:38 masked,
00:24:38 carrying knives,
00:24:39 waiting for our kids.
00:24:40 One of our kids left after his GCSE exam.
00:24:43 A whole bunch of kids from another school rushed him and got stabbed with a compass.
00:24:47 We are in the inner city and we've got a very tough intake.
00:24:51 So life is difficult for some of our kids.
00:24:54 However, they're still better off than some of those kids who don't have enough food to eat in some African countries.
00:25:00 We have all got to be grateful for what we've got in life.
00:25:03 Because if all you do is spend your time being miserable and saying life is unfair and there are all these obstacles in front of me.
00:25:09 this is my whole fight with the whole kind of race thing you know when people
00:25:12 I'm black and I'm poor and I grew up with a single mother so I can't possibly
00:25:17 make it in life that defeatist kind of victimhood mentality will never get you
00:25:21 anywhere and I'm not saying the world isn't racist I'm not saying life isn't
00:25:24 going to be difficult for you it may be very difficult doesn't matter you have
00:25:27 got to pick yourself up and you got to keep going there has to be a sense of
00:25:30 personal responsibility in here and there has to be a sense of gratitude for
00:25:33 what you've been given in life our kids at our school need to be grateful
00:25:36 because they're at a school called Michaela, right?
00:25:38 But the irony of this, of course,
00:25:41 is these claims are made on behalf often of kids,
00:25:44 you know, you meant the victimhood thing.
00:25:46 But in fact, amongst sort of like African parents
00:25:49 and Asian parents,
00:25:50 you have got the most aspirational people, haven't you,
00:25:54 who really want their kids to do really, really well.
00:25:56 Well, you say that.
00:25:57 Some of them are like that.
00:25:58 It depends on how long they've been in this country.
00:26:00 Right.
00:26:00 And I say that because I think the welfare state
00:26:03 and welfarism generally affects people
00:26:06 can affect people in a negative way
00:26:08 if you're around it too much
00:26:09 and there can be too much complacency
00:26:14 this sense that the state is going to sort it out
00:26:16 for you as opposed to you taking
00:26:18 personal responsibility
00:26:19 and that is something
00:26:22 that we're constantly pushing in school
00:26:23 is this idea of personal responsibility for you
00:26:25 you got the detention, well you did something wrong
00:26:27 don't go and blame it on somebody else
00:26:29 and maybe somebody else did something
00:26:31 but you should be interested in what you did
00:26:33 and we also have a sense of duty
00:26:35 duty to others and a sense of obligation what are you going to do with your life how are you going
00:26:40 to give back right um it's our duty as teachers to properly teach these children i was i was very
00:26:46 struck as well by you making a point about you know that britain is a kind of like a family and
00:26:52 we're going to celebrate you mentioned earlier british history but how else do you sort of
00:26:57 instill a feeling of community and national community in your schools i mean how well we
00:27:01 sing. You sing? What do you sing? I vow to thee my country. I was singing it this morning. God save
00:27:07 the Queen, Jerusalem. We also talk about these things. You know, we do assemblies. During the
00:27:14 World Cup, we had England flags everywhere. It was all about go England, go England. This is
00:27:18 particularly important for ethnic minorities who can often feel, well, you know, am I British?
00:27:23 Well, you know, what am I really, you know? It's so important because if you don't feel like you
00:27:26 belong in your country, you can never succeed, okay? You have to feel that. Now, some of these
00:27:31 kids may grow up and become revolutionaries well great I mean that's fine I've done my job as a
00:27:35 teacher it's my duty yes it's my duty to help socialize them I always talk about the family
00:27:39 of Michaela you've got your own nuclear family then you've got your larger community you've got
00:27:44 your school family and then we've got the larger family of the country yeah and we should all feel
00:27:50 like we are together especially in a multicultural community it's all the more important because
00:27:55 that's the thing that we share together otherwise we end up splitting right and then there's all
00:27:59 this discord if we are to get on together we have to share something and the one thing we share is
00:28:04 being British and isn't that a wonderful thing you know in some countries you get murdered if
00:28:09 you're gay you know the police will murder you in some countries in some countries you if you're a
00:28:14 woman you can't drive a car whatever you know the point is that we live in a wonderful country and
00:28:18 this is something we should be celebrating doesn't mean it doesn't have its problems I'm the number
00:28:21 one person to say that the education system in Britain has its problems right but that doesn't
00:28:26 mean i don't love it as my country right yeah and um and so should the children and shows we should
00:28:31 also we should all be grateful for this but too often we we don't recognize that and we don't
00:28:35 want to celebrate that and um and that's really that's that's really sad um you know i often joke
00:28:43 about how it's the end of the west and you know um and and that's because we've lost something you
00:28:47 know uh you talk about scrutin saying post truth you know um a lot of people i think know this in
00:28:55 their heart of hearts they know you know how many times like i tweet loads and then i go to an event
00:29:00 and i get so many people teachers who come up to me and whisper to me and they say i really like
00:29:04 what you're saying on twitter but they would never say it out loud because they're terrified yes and
00:29:09 this is crazy we can't have a situation where people can't say what they what they believe what
00:29:13 they think and let's have a conversation but that's because too many people want to shut the
00:29:18 conversation down and they say no you're not allowed to speak i have people on twitter getting
00:29:22 angry with me because I'm having conversations with people on Twitter who I disagree with
00:29:25 and they say you shouldn't speak to them and I say well what do you mean I disagree with them
00:29:30 so I want to talk to them and have a conversation they're saying no you know there's something wrong
00:29:36 with our our thinking if we just want to shut certain people out of the conversation
00:29:40 Kevin you you mentioned the Twitter I know that you do quite a lot of tweeting and everything but
00:29:45 one of the big changes that's happened maybe even since Michaela was founded was this intensity
00:29:52 of social media for young people.
00:29:54 Now, you recently talked about the fact
00:29:58 that parents you felt should be shamed
00:30:00 if they give toddlers smartphones.
00:30:04 I mean, they are giving toddlers smartphones, are they?
00:30:07 Well, you see it all the time on the tube,
00:30:09 in restaurants, you see it, it's normal,
00:30:11 and they don't realise.
00:30:12 I mean, I don't blame those parents right now
00:30:14 because they just don't know.
00:30:15 I think it's hilarious because for many, many months
00:30:18 I've been talking about the dangers of smartphones.
00:30:20 Nobody's taken any notice.
00:30:21 suddenly i talk about shaming parents and boom the sun the times t.s everybody's everybody's
00:30:27 saying look kathleen people saying said that parents should be shamed look i'm not saying
00:30:32 that in the tube you need to start shouting at the parent who's giving that the point is is that
00:30:36 if we have enough information about the dangers of uh phones then people would naturally feel a
00:30:43 sense of shame and they wouldn't do it yeah in the same way as right now you would be shocked if
00:30:47 you saw parents smoking in front of their toddler,
00:30:51 blowing smoke in front of, it would never happen.
00:30:53 Once upon a time it happened all the time.
00:30:55 And then we found out about the dangers of smoking
00:30:57 and because we're all much more informed now,
00:30:59 there's a sense of shame around smoking
00:31:01 and we go outside to do it
00:31:03 and we certainly wouldn't want to do it around children.
00:31:06 It's the same thing with smartphones.
00:31:08 If we were more informed,
00:31:10 there would be a natural sense of shame
00:31:11 that would develop in us and that is required.
00:31:15 The parents now don't know.
00:31:17 My parents, so the parents at school, I tell them about, I say, look,
00:31:22 you give a 13-year-old boy access to porn, he's going to look at it.
00:31:26 That's what the phone is doing.
00:31:28 Once upon a time, we used to put porn magazines up at the top, right?
00:31:30 Oh, yes, yes, I remember.
00:31:32 Nowadays, we say, here's a phone, honey.
00:31:34 Go and look at as much porn as you like.
00:31:36 And not just on a magazine form, but video form, right?
00:31:40 The girls, if the parents looked at the social media,
00:31:44 So Snapchat, Instagram, and the pictures that the girls make, they make themselves look
00:31:49 five years older, they're pouting their lips, they're sticking their bottoms out.
00:31:52 Their only understanding of being a woman is to be some little dolly bird that looks
00:31:58 a certain way as opposed to being a strong woman who can go out and do something with
00:32:01 their life, you know?
00:32:03 If parents understood, they saw the kind of conversations, the swearing, the bullying,
00:32:09 the undermining, how terrible it is on there, they would never let their children on there.
00:32:14 But they don't know, right?
00:32:15 But I mean, but when I said toddlers, I was thinking literally of kids, you know, really like preschool kids.
00:32:22 Yeah, that is what I meant.
00:32:22 And they are, oh, I see.
00:32:24 Do you not see them?
00:32:25 They're all the time.
00:32:26 You see them in the trains and so on.
00:32:27 You see parents giving their child a phone.
00:32:30 What I mean is the phone is, there are prams that you can buy now.
00:32:33 There are buggies that have a slot to put the iPad and the phone in so you can turn it and face it to the baby to entertain the child.
00:32:41 Okay?
00:32:42 like that is where we're at yeah and my point is those companies if it was the case that we had
00:32:48 the information on how damaging this is for children then they just wouldn't exist right
00:32:52 um parents are handing them because it's an easy babysitter you know here's the phone i'm going to
00:32:57 talk i'm in a restaurant going to give them a phone to the child i'm going to get on now there
00:33:01 are some great apps you can play chess you can learn maths there are all sorts of things that
00:33:06 you can do in a smartphone if you're with your parent and you're doing it together and you're
00:33:11 watching what they're up to because actually with many of these maths games and so on they can just
00:33:15 guess and then they win the prize you have to be watching to make sure you have to choose the app
00:33:20 carefully right um parents don't know they don't realize that a book cannot compete with a phone
00:33:26 it just can't and so you know the phone has colors and flashes and changes and so on a book is flat
00:33:32 now if you want your child to be able to read your listeners listen to me do not give your child a
00:33:38 phone bill gates steve jobs all the big tech ceos they do not give their children phones when steve
00:33:45 jobs was asked in 2010 what his children thought of the ipad he said my children don't have the
00:33:50 ipad why would i give them the ipad this is extraordinary though katherine isn't it i mean
00:33:53 you i've heard i've heard exactly the same they're very clear about it they won't let their own
00:33:56 children because they protect their own children while they're making billions out of us and our
00:34:01 ignorance right they're pumping millions into their advertising and whatsapp snapchat and so
00:34:06 they hire teams of addiction people they're addiction teams to make it so that the thing is
00:34:10 so addictive that the child can't put it down right these people are flying around in private jets
00:34:15 and we stupid us are going off buying these things and then i get people on twitter who say
00:34:19 oh but my i'm fine actually because i monitor my children and so if everybody should just monitor
00:34:25 their children it's just bad parenting look when you are a parent who's working two or three jobs
00:34:29 and you're not home in the evening there is nothing you can do right and it is unfair for
00:34:34 the rich to be oppressing the poor. This is what's going on. I'm telling you those smartphones are
00:34:39 exacerbating the divide between rich and poor. And in 25 years, people are going to be writing
00:34:43 reports and PhDs on this about how the poor have got even poorer and the divide has done that
00:34:48 because of those smartphones. And they all have the most expensive smartphones. So we have this
00:34:53 idea that the poor are too poor to buy smartphones. They're buying them and they're buying more than
00:34:56 one. And the children are glued to them. And look, a smartphone, you have a 20 second thing on
00:35:03 snapchat oh look look at that man with the bald head oh and then that's all that that's the little
00:35:08 ditty that they watch for 20 seconds a book has a narrative arc that does that you you learn you
00:35:15 get to know the characters there is depth in a book there is no depth in snapchat and instagram
00:35:20 and the children get used to no concentration span bam bam bam when they then have to do this
00:35:25 with a book it's just too much it's too difficult apparently there's a i read in the uh the time is
00:35:30 while ago there was a survey done of 600 head teachers i think and they were talking about
00:35:35 the anxiety levels now amongst their pupils yeah exactly brought on a hell of a lot of it by social
00:35:41 media addiction so apparently now there are things like kids getting um or rather parents
00:35:48 sending in letters saying can such and such be excused from learning languages because it's
00:35:52 too stressful yeah the stress level has gone up they're blaming the academic subjects that's
00:35:57 absolutely ridiculous take the smartphone away and i have parents who've done that right parents
00:36:03 who have listened to me they take the smartphone away from their child and at first all hell breaks
00:36:07 loose you have children going on hunger strikes and all sorts of craziness they refuse to come
00:36:11 into school because they're so addicted to the phone right it's like taking heroin away from a
00:36:15 heroin addict that's what it's like right now people will say oh that's an exaggeration i'm
00:36:18 telling you i've seen it right they are they are threatening to kill themselves because they don't
00:36:22 of their phone then they get over it right they get over it few weeks of hell and I always tell
00:36:28 the parents just dig deep just hold the line okay and the ones who listen to me and they hold the
00:36:34 line they say to me I film the parents and then I show the other parents to try and persuade them
00:36:39 the parents say I've got my boy back his personality had changed he was depressed he was anxious
00:36:46 i've got my girl back she was so terrified all the time being bullied and awful and she was so
00:36:53 unhappy and now i've got my child back the lovely innocent child that they once were is now back
00:36:58 what is it what is your policy then michaela what is no phones in the classroom what yes but that's
00:37:04 just look yes that's just obviously you shouldn't have phones at school if we see them over here
00:37:10 we take them until we never see them we never hear them because the children don't take them
00:37:13 presumably in a lot of state schools there's going to be there's going to be a teacher standing there
00:37:17 and the kids are going to openly be on their phones so that's terrible and that's awful and
00:37:21 and you're right but that for me is an obvious basic you shouldn't have phones in the school
00:37:25 i'm took i'm going beyond that now i'm saying i don't want them at home either um i'm saying
00:37:31 that if children are trying to revise for the gcse's and they can't because they are addicted
00:37:35 to the phone and people don't necessarily realize how how awful this is and other schools might not
00:37:40 realize it because they've got so many daily problems going on at Michaela things are so
00:37:44 smooth sailing you know there's great teaching going on the children are behaving everything's
00:37:49 lovely I have been able to isolate this as my main problem you want to ask me what my biggest
00:37:54 challenge is smartphones that's my biggest challenge and not in the school because we
00:37:58 don't have that as a problem the biggest problem I have is getting kids to do their work at home
00:38:03 because they won't work because they are so addicted to their phones they say it to me
00:38:07 themselves they say miss I want to I want to what can I do please help me we have a whole digital
00:38:12 detox system at school where they can actually drop their phones off to us for a night or two
00:38:16 and then it gives their brains a break there's all sorts of studies done on this about how it
00:38:20 actually breaks the brain what I mean by that is your memory chain gets broken you are no longer
00:38:25 able to concentrate I children look you're 11's mine who gave in their phones they gave in their
00:38:31 phones in September some of them so they had a whole run-up without their phones right and the
00:38:35 video games they gave in the the cables they have said to me they felt their brains get get smarter
00:38:42 yeah right they actually felt it now i don't have the data i can't i don't have the proof in black
00:38:46 and white but i've got the stories from the children and i tell you i know what i'm talking
00:38:50 about and i wish people would listen to me and i keep shouting about it and then all people say is
00:38:55 oh you're what your parents shamed oh for goodness sakes listen to the content of what i'm saying
00:39:00 i'm saying that if we knew more about this and a natural sense of shame would develop in all of us
00:39:05 and we simply wouldn't do it and unfortunately because it's a new technology right it's new so
00:39:10 we don't know it's only in the last few years that it's become so common to have a smartphone like
00:39:14 this um and those guys in california they know what they're doing right oh they know and we are
00:39:21 all idiots and we need to you know if i have to talk about shame i'll talk about it if it means
00:39:26 that people are going to start listening to me then i'll talk about it all they like do you know
00:39:29 i think one of the most uh sad things actually you know it's like just really old man talk here but
00:39:34 you know maybe in the 70s there's a new album out the new david bowie album people would go
00:39:40 and they would queue for it yeah and they'd go home and they'd and it would be you know have an
00:39:44 amazing picture on it the word now they queue for technology they queue for the new phone yeah you
00:39:52 know and you sort of think it's something so sterile about this you know okay it's all the
00:39:57 stuff they can do and all the rest of it but have you changed your own social smartphone usage do
00:40:03 think no well you know it's interesting I I really don't like Twitter and for
00:40:07 the first couple of years the school I wasn't on Twitter at all I didn't like
00:40:10 it and then I was on Twitter I never went on it the problem is is that if I'm
00:40:14 not speaking on social media to tell people what we're about that vacuum gets
00:40:18 filled by somebody else and then people start saying things about us and start
00:40:22 characterizing us in ways that are not correct so I've realized that actually
00:40:28 for my job it is really important that i'm out there in social media explaining what we're about
00:40:34 and saying what what i think because otherwise people then attribute all sorts of ideas to me
00:40:40 they still do but they do it less because i've i've filled that vacuum and i and i have a voice
00:40:45 now more so on twitter so that's why i do it but i mean you know i have a facebook account i never
00:40:50 go on it um i'm certainly not on snapchat or instagram i can't stand any of that stuff i mean
00:40:53 i hate all of that stuff frankly yeah yeah and you wouldn't believe it given that i'm caught i
00:40:57 regularly tweet but i'm tweeting for the movement right i i i'm i'm fighting the establishment and
00:41:04 in order to fight it i i'm doing it partly on twitter i think um when it comes to instagram
00:41:09 and and particularly instagram there are people on it who appear to be able to make this
00:41:16 extraordinary living with 200,000 followers or whatever sort of like on thin air almost or just
00:41:24 this product and you can see that apparently you know a lot of kids will ask what you want to be
00:41:28 when you when you grow up and the idea of even wanting to be an astronaut okay that's old old
00:41:32 stuff oh I want to be a celebrity or maybe even an Instagram star or what you know whatever it is
00:41:37 that that is kind of worrying isn't it really yeah well a lot of them say that I mean we do quite a
00:41:42 a job of Michaela to stop them from thinking in that way and to think in a
00:41:46 more traditional fashion yeah and some of it can be quite dangerous I mean we've
00:41:52 had a couple of kids who've posted videos that can involve gangs you know
00:41:56 there was a boy around the corner from our school not from our school but he
00:41:59 posted something on on YouTube that insulted a South London gang and they
00:42:06 came up and they killed him you know and and so we've had those kinds of issues
00:42:09 where some of our kids get involved in that we're trying to say to them and to
00:42:12 their parents your child's life is at risk here you know that's the other thing about a smartphone
00:42:16 you give a child a smartphone everybody out there has access to your child they know where they live
00:42:21 they know what school they go to they know who their friends are they know what they like to do
00:42:24 you know and children are vulnerable their brains are still growing so that's what i mean about
00:42:28 breaking the brain and also they're not they're naive they can easily get sucked in and i mean i
00:42:34 could tell you stories of children who have been murdered right and people you know people think
00:42:39 i'm exaggerating i am not exaggerating about the dangers and in particular even if you don't want
00:42:44 to worry about their safety just the business of wanting to do well at gcse wanting to to to be
00:42:50 able to read and the younger ones we haven't seen it yet right those two-year-olds who are on
00:42:54 smartphones from now they haven't come through the system yet oh god we are no we just wait and see
00:42:59 right well you will be there for them i will the other end and i will keep on fighting
00:43:04 Councillor, thank you so much for coming in
00:43:07 it's just wonderful
00:43:07 and all power to you
00:43:10 and also for the new
00:43:11 school when it comes up in Stephen
00:43:14 thank you, thank you very much
00:43:15 thanks very much for watching
00:43:18 so what you're saying is, see you next time
00:43:21 bye