New Culture Forum - July 13, 2019


27. David Goodhart: Somewheres and anywheres

26. Katharine Birbalsingh: Kids need knowledge & discipline 28. Konstantin Kisin - The Last Laugh

Episode Stats


Length

42 minutes

Words per minute

149.68

Word count

6,298

Sentence count

193


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to So What You're Saying Is, I'm Peter Whittle.
00:00:09 Now my guest this week is the author and journalist David Goodhart.
00:00:14 David was the founder of Prospect Magazine back in the 1990s.
00:00:19 He's now Head of Demography, Immigration and Integration at the Policy Exchange Think Tank.
00:00:25 But he's perhaps best known to a wider audience through two books.
00:00:29 two books. The first one called The British Dream, which was about the experience of immigration
00:00:35 in Britain in the post-war period. And the second one, this one here, The Road to Somewhere,
00:00:40 which came out a while ago, which is basically a description of the two tribes who exist now
00:00:47 quite uneasily maybe in Britain of anywheres and somewheres. He describes himself as post-liberal,
00:00:54 and he's with me now. Thank you very much David. Post-liberal that doesn't immediately equal
00:00:59 conservative does it? No it doesn't. I don't actually use the term very often because
00:01:08 because it is a bit confusing and requires lengthy explanation but I guess it is
00:01:13 It is partly saying that one can absorb many of the kind of fundamental truths and pronouncements
00:01:27 of modern liberalism, I mean the basics kind of rule of law, separation of powers, individual
00:01:32 rights, minority rights, etc.
00:01:37 One can accept much of that, all of that, and one can also see many of the kind of limits
00:01:48 of contemporary liberalism, or indeed the unintended consequences, the kind of overreach
00:01:55 of contemporary liberalism, liberalism in another sense, beyond that, those kind of
00:02:00 fundamental rules and principles of modern liberalism, you know, since the 18th century,
00:02:07 as it were. And I would certainly, and it's all, there's an element of sort of beyond left and
00:02:14 right about it as well, I think, and that is indeed, that's how I started writing The Road
00:02:19 to Somewhere. I was, I'd originally, sort of, the original plan was to write a book that was much
00:02:29 more philosophical, was much more about beyond left and right, and indeed about what actually
00:02:35 is post-liberalism. But then I was just in the foothills of writing it when the Brexit
00:02:40 vote happened, unexpectedly. And so I ended up writing something that was perhaps a little
00:02:47 bit more sort of political with a capital P, attempting to understand both the Brexit
00:02:55 vote and indeed the the writing of the book was sort of bookended by the these
00:03:01 two dramatic events of 2016 the Brexit vote and then Trump's election in
00:03:05 November which was just just when I was finishing writing so I ended up writing
00:03:10 something that was trying to get under the skin of those events and try and
00:03:15 understand through the value divides that have emerged to to to in some ways
00:03:23 sort of challenge the more the traditional socioeconomic divides or cut
00:03:27 across anyway but yes I so I suppose I mean post-liberalism is
00:03:34 post-liberalism is saying look you know you know I am we are still liberals in a
00:03:43 fundamental way we're not we're not conservatives but we also perhaps share
00:03:51 some of the reservations of conservatives about the direction of of contemporary
00:03:55 liberal society I mean I think it's it's a it's it's not a it's not a phrase
00:04:03 that's ever going to catch on really and and there are partly oh well partly
00:04:08 because there are so many different potential definitions of it too so it's
00:04:11 in some ways not you know I mean you know I haven't even I haven't really
00:04:15 explained it very clearly in you know in the last two or three minutes but but it
00:04:18 I mean, you know, it's one of those, I mean, there is a family resemblance between, you know, between the people that would call themselves post-liberal, I guess.
00:04:30 I suppose I took it maybe in a more crude sense, if you like.
00:04:34 You talked or you wrote an article, How I Left My London Liberal Tribe, for example.
00:04:41 And I think that's how most people understand it.
00:04:43 I mean, for those who maybe are not so aware, you wrote a famous article in Prospect, now famous, I'd say, called Too Diverse, did you not?
00:04:54 Question mark, yeah.
00:04:55 In 2004.
00:04:57 Yeah.
00:04:57 And this seemed to be a sort of break for you, possibly, from the position you might have had then and looking more critically at, for example, the effects of immigration when it came to welfare state, when it came to cohesion.
00:05:13 Yeah, yeah.
00:05:14 And you were therefore moving away maybe from your habitat, as it were.
00:05:17 No, indeed, yeah.
00:05:18 I mean, I was a sort of rather innocent, sort of unthinking...
00:05:24 I didn't think I was unthinking, I thought I was terribly thoughtful,
00:05:28 but I was basically a kind of innocent, unthinking centre,
00:05:31 liberal lefty.
00:05:35 When I set up Prospect in the mid-1990s,
00:05:38 we were generally seen as a pretty liberal magazine.
00:05:42 Although I think we always sort of had a, there was always quite a strong contrarian streak in it too,
00:05:48 you know, challenging some of the shibboleths of contemporary liberalism.
00:05:54 Yeah, and then I kind of stumbled by accident really into the whole area of race and immigration and multiculturalism
00:06:01 by writing this rather abstract essay, 5,000 or 6,000 word essay,
00:06:11 on the tension between diversity and solidarity,
00:06:14 which seemed to me one of the central issues for the modern centre-left,
00:06:20 which admires and wants to further both of these principles,
00:06:30 these two principles are kind of at the heart of the modern left you might even say and clearly
00:06:34 they are in tension with each other you know based on a common sense assumption that people
00:06:39 are more likely to share with people with whom they have something in common you know they don't
00:06:42 look the same or pray to the same god even but you have to have some shared experience trust
00:06:49 familiarity for high levels of sharing to be possible in a society and it's that just seemed
00:06:57 to be obvious and I sort of looked at some of the evidence for that in recent
00:07:00 history and now you know these these things are not inevitable and unavoidable
00:07:08 you can mitigate these tensions you've got to be aware of them and you've got
00:07:12 to talk about them and and the the essay was reprinted all 6,000 words of it was
00:07:22 reprinted in the Guardian I mean that's what drew it to a degree of national
00:07:26 attention uh and that caused that caused quite an outcry and you know i was accused of being a kind
00:07:32 of nice racist or um yeah you know all sorts of um all sorts of silly phrases were uh were thrown
00:07:42 around but weren't you sort of in a way considered a bit of an apostate therefore i mean yeah yeah
00:07:47 um no i think that's that was one of the reasons why yeah i mean you know if somebody had written
00:07:53 something like that in the spectator it would have you know no one would really have noticed
00:07:57 but yeah it was the fact that it was coming from a magazine that was considered very loosely part
00:08:03 of the sort of center leftish you know we'd supported Blair in 97 we've been quite critical
00:08:10 of him over quite a few things subsequently but we were generally considered you know I got invited
00:08:17 to those kinds of parties yes um did you stop getting invited to things not well there was a
00:08:26 not immediately i mean actually what was much more um memorable at the time i remember was lots of
00:08:34 um labor mps sort of saying quietly sort of keep up the good work you've got to keep talking about
00:08:40 these things but very sort of voce and and yeah in a way rather sort of
00:08:49 hypocritically but I guess it was you know even as recently as 2004 it was
00:08:58 quite difficult you know if you did question high levels of immigration you
00:09:05 You know, there was something slightly suspect, slightly sinister about you.
00:09:12 I mean, it really was that bad.
00:09:13 I mean, I think it's changed quite a lot since then.
00:09:15 I mean, partly because of the experience of free movement from the former communist countries.
00:09:21 You know, we've had much of the immigration since then has been from Central and Eastern Europe,
00:09:27 people who are white and Christian and so on.
00:09:29 And so it's been easier to sort of talk about the negative economic or indeed cultural impact of large-scale immigration without it being so attached to race.
00:09:42 I mean, obviously one of the reasons why immigration was so sensitive is because race is so sensitive.
00:09:50 and also one of the reasons why the left found it so hard to think clearly about immigration
00:09:57 is because one of the great achievements, you might say, of the modern left
00:10:04 is the anti-racist achievement, defending minorities against discrimination
00:10:12 and the left is on the whole in most countries has been responsible
00:10:15 for pioneering anti-discrimination legislation and so on.
00:10:19 and those are good things that the left can be proud of
00:10:23 but it's partly because these are such
00:10:28 because as a result of that the left thought that it owned the whole issue of race really
00:10:36 that they were the only people who thought decent thoughts about race
00:10:41 and therefore they were the only people who were entitled to a view on it
00:10:46 and the way that race got sort of entangled with immigration
00:10:51 obviously the two things are completely separate logically
00:10:53 but the way in which if you were in favour of slowing immigration
00:11:00 or restricting it in some way
00:11:02 then you were somehow someone who didn't like people from different races
00:11:07 it was as kind of silly as that
00:11:09 and it's taken the left I think a long
00:11:13 And even now, I mean, there's a sort of unthinking bias in favour of large-scale immigration,
00:11:18 which is so ridiculously and obviously in conflict with the economic interests of the left
00:11:25 or the people that the left has traditionally been there to defend.
00:11:30 I mean, the whole, you know, why is it called the Labour Party?
00:11:33 Because it was set up in order to defend the interests of organised labour.
00:11:37 What is against the interests of organised labour?
00:11:40 Vast numbers of people coming in from other countries, you know.
00:11:43 It was, you know, Marx talked about the reserve army of labour.
00:11:50 In Marx's day, the reserve army of labour came from Ireland.
00:11:53 Now it comes from Central and Eastern Europe.
00:11:57 You said that it was still considered slightly sinister
00:12:00 even to talk really very much about migration in 2004.
00:12:07 Problem is, though, my perception, I think perception of a lot of people,
00:12:11 is that now immigration as a subject has sort of gone again.
00:12:16 You say it's easier.
00:12:18 I'm not sure because, first of all, it's not talked about very much, I would say.
00:12:23 And then, secondly, on top of that, the mass immigration,
00:12:29 as opposed to just what you might call immigration, has become normalized.
00:12:33 So to the extent that, say, 200,000 to 300,000.
00:12:36 I think this was even pointed out when you were writing your book.
00:12:41 is that 200,000 to many on the left seems like quite normal.
00:12:45 I would say that's not normal, would you?
00:12:48 No, no, I agree.
00:12:51 And it's held a lot more.
00:12:52 I mean, I think it has, I think we do talk about immigration quite a lot now.
00:12:56 I mean, just actually in the last few months,
00:12:59 the whole sort of subject has died down, I think, partly because of Brexit,
00:13:02 partly because people think, well, you know,
00:13:04 at last we are going to be back in control of all forms of immigration.
00:13:10 I mean there remains a bit of a question mark over that
00:13:13 it's true
00:13:15 but I mean I think
00:13:18 aside from that recent lull
00:13:20 I mean in a sense a sort of justified lulling concern
00:13:24 I think we do talk about it quite a lot
00:13:28 and certainly
00:13:30 and we talk about it in quite sort of
00:13:35 gritty detail
00:13:37 But do politicians? Politicians don't.
00:13:41 I think they do.
00:13:42 I mean, we had a government white paper at the end of last year.
00:13:45 We have arguments about whether, should there be a kind of 30 grand a year limit?
00:13:51 How do we bear down on low-skilled immigration
00:13:53 but continue to have moderately high flows of skilled immigration?
00:13:58 Is that the right way to go?
00:13:59 We have the Migration Advisory Committee,
00:14:00 which I think has proved a great innovation, actually.
00:14:04 And they are often very, very critical of more kind of neoliberal and indeed leftish ways of thinking, I mean, laissez-faire ways of thinking about immigration.
00:14:18 They're very critical of employers and the way that employers have just reached for immigration as a way to sort of solve their skill shortages and so on.
00:14:30 I mean, it's astonishing.
00:14:33 One of the sort of social facts that is far less well-known than it should be
00:14:38 is just how there's a guy called Francis Green at UCL who tracks these things,
00:14:44 that there are lots of government surveys that support what he's saying,
00:14:49 that since the late 1990s, actually, and particularly since 2004-05,
00:14:57 The amount of money that employers spend on training has declined,
00:15:03 I think it's ending between 20% and 25%.
00:15:05 The amount of time that per head people spend being trained has declined by 50%,
00:15:16 I think it's an enormous figure.
00:15:19 And this should be more prominently discussed in the public debate.
00:15:26 I mean, I think employers have had, you know, a free lunch over free movement.
00:15:33 But in a way, there's been a strange sort of alliance, hasn't there,
00:15:36 between what employers want in terms of the cheap labour
00:15:39 and also what the left wanted in terms of pure, as it were,
00:15:43 you know, the whole rubbing their nose in diversity argument.
00:15:46 The two sort of came together almost, did they not?
00:15:49 Yeah, yeah.
00:15:49 You find them on the same platform almost.
00:15:52 Yeah, and it's the double liberalism, you know.
00:15:56 It's the double liberalism that in some ways the modern political discontents represented by Brexit and Trump have been in revolt against.
00:16:02 You know, the liberalism of free market economics and the belief that free trade must, you know, unconstrained free trade must always be a good thing.
00:16:13 and the social and cultural liberalism, one of the most prominent aspects of which has been high flows of people across borders
00:16:26 and general comfort with and sort of support for rapid social change and social fluidity,
00:16:36 which you know to use my language in the kind of language of anywheres and
00:16:39 somewheres I mean anywheres who completely dominate our society economy
00:16:43 culture politics despite only being 25 30% of the population possibly I mean
00:16:50 these are not hard and you know there are sort of fuzzy borders around these
00:16:53 things we're talking about worldviews you know not everybody you know signs up
00:16:57 to the full full kind of anywhere or somewhere worldview but but but anywhere
00:17:04 people tend to have what I call achieved identities. Their sense of themselves comes from the fact
00:17:10 they passed exams when they were young, they went to more or less good universities, they
00:17:14 had more or less successful professional careers, they're mobile, they're often very individualistic
00:17:18 even if they're on the left, and they're comfortable with social change. They tend to have weak
00:17:24 group attachments and relatively weak attachments to place. Even if they don't live where they
00:17:32 came from they will still you know as as many people who felt uncomfortable they didn't like
00:17:39 my book would say but you know I live in Stoke Newington I'm very attached to it and of course
00:17:43 they are I mean I don't contest that for one moment it isn't the places they originally came
00:17:48 from but they've you know they've ended up in somewhere that they that they feel a strong
00:17:52 community attachment to but that is sort of somewhat different I think to feeling an attachment
00:17:58 to the place you originally came from um in any case you know the the those attachments are much
00:18:05 weaker i think on the part of highly educated people partly because they have been they have
00:18:09 been mobile and they're um they're you know they're they're attached to kind of looser networks
00:18:15 of people with you know who have who with shared who share their views about things um and are you
00:18:24 are comfortable with social change and that's the point and and there are great
00:18:28 many people in our society who people who have more ascribed identities who
00:18:34 sense themselves comes from group attachment and attachment to place who
00:18:40 who don't feel that same comfort and if you have a if you have an identity that
00:18:46 is built around group and place then it is much more subject to being disrupted
00:18:52 or discomforted by social change.
00:18:55 I mean, these seem pretty obvious things.
00:18:59 And they should be what we talk about in our politics.
00:19:06 We're sort of talking about them now, I suppose,
00:19:08 anyways and somewheres, because of Brexit.
00:19:12 But how long have these, if you would call these groups,
00:19:16 these tribes, one much smaller than the other,
00:19:19 the anywheres, although much more influential,
00:19:22 How long had they been in existence before Brexit?
00:19:27 I mean, Brexit kind of revealed them.
00:19:29 I remember there was just an anecdote in one of your books,
00:19:31 in the British Dream book,
00:19:33 about people you were having dinner at some function
00:19:37 with, you know, pretty top brass civil servant, I believe, and an academic.
00:19:43 And there you relate how their whole approach to the world was entirely global.
00:19:48 It was that they felt they had an obligation to people
00:19:51 just as strong in other countries as to here,
00:19:54 that they would be, I suppose, classic anywheres, would they not?
00:19:59 Extreme anywheres, yes.
00:20:00 I mean, I actually named them.
00:20:02 I mean, I used the anecdote twice.
00:20:05 I used it in the British Dream,
00:20:06 but the civil servant in particular was still, I think,
00:20:12 head of the civil service at the time,
00:20:14 so I didn't actually name him.
00:20:15 I did name them both in the road to somewhere.
00:20:19 It was Gus O'Donnell.
00:20:20 I was sitting next to Gus O'Donnell
00:20:22 at a dinner at Nuffield College
00:20:24 and he
00:20:25 I said I was writing a book about
00:20:28 immigration and he said oh when I was at the
00:20:30 Treasury I was always in favour of
00:20:32 as much
00:20:34 immigration as possible
00:20:35 and we sort of talked a bit further
00:20:38 and he came out with what I thought was an absolutely
00:20:40 astonishing thing to say particularly if you're head of the
00:20:42 National Civil Service which is that
00:20:44 I believe in maximising
00:20:46 global welfare not national welfare
00:20:48 and I happened to be sitting
00:20:54 that the man to my left
00:20:56 these were probably the two most powerful
00:21:00 unelected people in Britain at the time
00:21:02 Gus O'Donnell and to my left was Mark Thompson
00:21:06 who was then head of the BBC and I said to Mark
00:21:08 did you just hear that? The head of the National Civil Service just said
00:21:11 that he thought it was his job to maximise global welfare
00:21:13 and Mark Thompson said
00:21:18 no, well, I agree with him, of course.
00:21:21 And that sort of, I think,
00:21:26 was one of the kind of inspirations
00:21:27 for writing both of my books, actually, in a way.
00:21:31 It is extraordinary because these people,
00:21:33 hugely high up,
00:21:35 very emblematic of that attitude.
00:21:40 In some ways, surely,
00:21:41 you know, Brexit was a revolt against that.
00:21:44 And the anger which has been now directed, I would say,
00:21:50 at Brexiteers comes from that sort of attitude
00:21:53 and people feeling, you know,
00:21:55 actually they've had their way for a very long time
00:21:57 and they're just angry that somehow it's being challenged in some way.
00:22:01 You mean the Remainers?
00:22:02 Yes.
00:22:03 Yeah, yeah.
00:22:04 You are a Remainer yourself, are you not?
00:22:06 I voted Remain, yeah.
00:22:07 I mean, I think we should respect the vote.
00:22:10 I think we should leave the European Union.
00:22:11 but yeah I mean I voted
00:22:14 largely for reasons of
00:22:17 small c conservatism in a way
00:22:18 I mean everybody was voting in a way
00:22:20 for reasons of small c conservatism
00:22:22 but yes I think
00:22:26 it is slightly depressing the way in which
00:22:28 the
00:22:30 political class has
00:22:32 sort of has
00:22:33 which is what sort of 70% remain
00:22:36 if not more
00:22:37 certainly parliament is
00:22:39 I do think it is very
00:22:42 I mean I think what has happened
00:22:44 obviously what has happened has been
00:22:46 partly determined by the fact that the government
00:22:48 has not had a majority
00:22:50 in Parliament
00:22:52 but there is a sort of deeper
00:22:55 there's something sort of more deeply depressing
00:22:58 about it I mean I think it really is
00:23:00 the sort of be careful what you wish for
00:23:02 that we have spent so much of the last
00:23:04 30 years or so
00:23:06 talking about expanding the boundaries
00:23:08 of individual freedom, about welcoming diversity, about feeling happy that we are in a way becoming
00:23:22 a more fragmented and pluralistic society that we pursue different faiths, we have different
00:23:31 values and yet still more or less managed to kind of live together more or less peacefully
00:23:40 and yet it has clearly taken its toll the fact that on something as important as this we have
00:23:45 not been able to you know that the different sort of factions in parliament have not been able to
00:23:52 submerge or suspend their differences for the greater common good the fact that we haven't
00:23:57 been able to work out what the common good is I think it shows that there's
00:24:01 there's been a sort of draining away of that both of the sort of almost the kind
00:24:07 of technical ability to come to compromises you know everyone has been
00:24:12 sort of head down pursuing their own narrow goal and not looking up and and
00:24:19 deciding what you know and fashioning fashioning a decent compromise that that
00:24:24 takes us out of the European Union, but in a way that is not, you know, so alienating
00:24:29 for the 48% of the population that voted to remain. And I think, yes, I think it is, it
00:24:38 is a rather pressing sign of the times that that sort of collective sort of intuition
00:24:45 almost to come together over and find a common good, you know, has just become weakened.
00:24:52 You know, the attitudes that you're describing amongst, I mean, those are very particular versions of it, of anywheres.
00:25:02 We have anywheres, you have somewheres, but isn't there also another tribe, maybe even smaller, what you might call nowheres?
00:25:11 These are people, it seems to me, who don't really care very much about the European Union.
00:25:16 Not really, but they just, they have a kind of strange nihilism about Britain and about the nation-state generally.
00:25:26 I sort of dislike, they would be happy to deduce it in any way, but they're not especially European.
00:25:36 They will say they are, but it's a kind of strange, it's this kind of self-hate that goes through much of European society now.
00:25:43 Yeah, I think it's true. I mean, I think there's been a, you know, in the modern academy, there is a very, very strong liberal left hegemony in many, many humanities and social science departments.
00:26:02 and I think that is partly to do with hostility to the domination of you know we come from a
00:26:19 country that has been dominant in global terms at least until a few decades ago you know was
00:26:26 was one of the leading countries if not the leading country in the world for for a couple
00:26:30 hundred years and you know and modern democratic egalitarian you know ideas of
00:26:40 equality both in social class in ethnic terms and so on look back on our recent
00:26:47 history and feel dismayed at that degree of domination you know the the
00:26:53 domination of one group over another is you know is is seen as a as a kind of
00:27:01 wound you know the Empire you know is is seen as a as a as a ghastly mistake and
00:27:10 obviously that is judging the past by the standards of the present but doesn't
00:27:14 it go further than that and since you know if you go back I know it's a very
00:27:18 hoary old quotation you know all well said about the English intelligentsia
00:27:23 having a kind of distaste for England for their nationality said it was almost
00:27:28 unique in that now that seems to be quite separate to guilt about empire
00:27:35 well there was always there was always a there was always a sort of small
00:27:42 segment often of the kind of educated classes who were in a sort of permanent
00:27:48 revolt against the empire, and actually I think one has to, you know, it's almost the
00:27:52 sort of, you know, families like Jeremy Corbyn's, you know, his parents famously met on a kind
00:27:57 of anti-Franco demonstration in the 1930s, you know, they were the people who sort of,
00:28:02 they were the liberal conscience of empire in a way, you know, those people going back
00:28:06 a couple of hundred years, and I think, you know, sort of good on them in some ways, you
00:28:11 know, they were responsible for some of the, you know, bringing some of the, you know,
00:28:15 for exposing some of the worst atrocities or brutalities of empire and I don't
00:28:21 think they they aren't the problem really I don't think I mean they were
00:28:27 they were partly trying to hold the Empire to a to a kind of higher liberal
00:28:32 standard now I mean yeah it's true I mean they're you know what Orwell was
00:28:37 talking about I mean he was probably talking about people who were kind of
00:28:41 members of the Communist Party in the 1930s or on the fringes of it right I
00:28:44 I mean, just to go back to Gus O'Donnell and Mark Thompson,
00:28:48 I mean, you know, there are lots of different kinds of anywheres,
00:28:53 as indeed there are lots of different kinds of somewheres.
00:28:55 There are huge gradations, and there's a big in-betweener group,
00:28:59 about 25% of the population.
00:29:01 When I say in-betweener, I mean people who sort of share almost equally
00:29:04 the sort of anywhere and somewhere world views.
00:29:08 I mean, I think there is a kind of more extreme anywhere end
00:29:12 represented by the sort of Gus O'Donnell and Mark Thompson
00:29:14 view, you know, sort of citizens of nowhere, you know, in Theresa May's famous speech,
00:29:21 people who are genuinely, you know, very, very globally minded, spend their lives in,
00:29:26 in, you know, airport lounges and, and probably have more sort of, you know, connections
00:29:33 internationally than they do, and feel really quite a weak attachment to their own countries
00:29:38 often um um but they're a very they're a pretty small number i mean you know most anywheres have
00:29:45 kind of normal moderate national feeling i would say i mean they're pretty you know they're not
00:29:50 perhaps as patriotic as many more rooted somewheres and also of course national social contracts
00:29:56 matter a lot more often to poorer people and people who feel they have relatively
00:30:02 less sort of sovereignty in their own in their own lives i think often are sort of comforted
00:30:07 by the fact that actually there are kind of levers you know there in London that can be pulled and
00:30:13 things happen. David the Anywhere that we're talking about they are to a great extent in charge
00:30:19 of the cultural direction we take. They I would say are tend to be characterized by basically
00:30:29 feeling this guilt that we discussed or not being particularly proud. Now the fact is if you're
00:30:36 getting or trying to get people to integrate into that how do you do it if those people who are in
00:30:43 charge of that don't even really believe in it themselves how can you convince people to integrate
00:30:49 this is the you you you're working in integration at the moment in politics yeah no i mean you're
00:30:54 right i mean i i go to lots of seminars where people essentially say well you know what is
00:31:00 there to integrate into you know this is the where it's in cultural and social
00:31:06 matters the left is often espousing a kind of Thatcherite there is no such
00:31:10 thing as society you know you you know you say you know that we know why can't
00:31:16 we have another you know 200,000 people from Afghanistan because you know we're
00:31:21 all just individuals aren't we you know they can just sort of you know so long
00:31:25 as we provide them with sufficient housing and education it'll all be fine
00:31:29 They are sort of a-culturalist, you might say.
00:31:32 They don't believe that societies have distinct flavours and characteristics and cultures.
00:31:41 And it is part of the sort of liberal individualism of the left
00:31:46 when it comes to these issues of integration and immigration and so on.
00:31:50 They remain collectivist often in economics,
00:31:53 but sort of individualist and liberal in cultural and social matters.
00:32:01 I mean, integration is an incredibly difficult and sort of slippery concept.
00:32:07 It's an extremely difficult thing to, you know, you can't enforce integration in a liberal society.
00:32:14 And indeed, you know, there is such a thing as, what's it called, the technical term is homophily,
00:32:20 You know, the people often do feel more comfortable amongst people like themselves, whether they're from the ethnic majority or ethnic minorities.
00:32:29 You know, this is this is very well known. I mean, you can observe it every day.
00:32:35 But a society which which, you know, fragmented into just lots and lots of separate groups would not be a very healthy one.
00:32:46 So we need to acknowledge both the kind of reality of people often feeling more comfortable amongst people like themselves
00:32:55 with the desire to cross these ethnic and class and other boundaries as much as possible,
00:33:02 to have a society, there's a very nice way of putting it, that a colleague of mine, Philip Wood, came up with,
00:33:09 which is a well-integrated society is one in which everybody is a potential friend.
00:33:14 I thought that's rather a nice vivid way of putting it and I think we're a very
00:33:20 very long way from that kind of society and integration becomes more difficult
00:33:27 when you have serious critical mass for different minorities particularly
00:33:33 minorities from more traditional countries with much more collectivist
00:33:40 and authoritarian instincts than the kind of liberal individualistic instincts
00:33:47 of the majority culture.
00:33:49 But also there's no need to integrate.
00:33:53 If you have, in such numbers, there's surely no need.
00:33:57 You have a ready-made community.
00:34:00 This is the problem, isn't it?
00:34:02 One thing follows another.
00:34:03 In order to have integration successfully,
00:34:06 you've got to surely have smaller numbers of migrants.
00:34:09 Well, I mean, this is, you know, one of the reasons for arguing for more moderate levels
00:34:16 of immigration, yes.
00:34:17 It's easier to absorb people, you know, if there aren't so many of them and you have
00:34:22 a longer time to do it.
00:34:24 That was often the case, you know, back in the sort of post-colonial immigration period.
00:34:32 It was often easier to integrate people then because the numbers were lower.
00:34:37 But you mentioned, by the way, earlier when we were talking, before we came on air, about the, is it the Danish, what they are doing?
00:34:46 Yeah, I mean, they represent the kind of the most draconian end of the spectrum, but I mean, I think quite a lot of what they're doing, we should certainly look at.
00:34:56 I mean, it's, you know, it's almost sort of Singaporean.
00:34:59 I mean, you know, Singapore does not allow, or rather it enforces integration in housing, particularly, you know, there are sort of quotas, you know, you cannot have more than a certain proportion of people from a certain background in a particular housing estate, for example.
00:35:17 The Danes, I think, are doing something similar in neighbourhoods.
00:35:23 They're enforcing very, very strict rules in schools.
00:35:28 So they are basically saying we are not going to have, as we have many schools where 90% of the children,
00:35:36 if you go to Tower Hamlets or wherever, 90% of the children will be Bangladeshi background.
00:35:42 you know you go you know a few miles away it'll be 95% will be will be white
00:35:49 British I mean the Danes are saying we're not having that you know we are
00:35:53 going to we're going to make sure that you know we spread out the minority kids
00:35:59 so that they're you know that there's never going to be more than a third I
00:36:03 think I'm not quite sure what the exact figure is but no more than a third in any
00:36:07 particular class. Now, I mean, that's, you know, given that minorities often
00:36:13 concentrate together, I mean, that probably requires, you know, quite a
00:36:17 logistical effort in moving people around. But they're prepared to invest in it.
00:36:22 You know, the Danes are very worried about these things, even though their
00:36:27 immigration numbers have come down a lot and are relatively low now,
00:36:32 they are they're being very very tough-minded about it and you know and
00:36:39 people who are saying they don't want to comply with these rules are saying right
00:36:43 well you're not getting any welfare benefits I mean they're very tough
00:36:47 minded in a way that probably relatively few other European societies would be at
00:36:53 the moment but how when it comes to integration that you're talking very
00:36:58 practical measures there are dispersing people when it actually comes to the
00:37:03 actual culture making people integrate into that the moral code the social code
00:37:09 all of these things how are they dealing with that in Denmark I mean I don't know
00:37:14 I mean I'm not an expert on the on the Danish story this is where the flash
00:37:19 points seem to be happening more and more here I mean yeah with the case in
00:37:22 Birmingham for example and the parents in Birmingham and this sort of these
00:37:25 areas yeah I agree I mean that that is a you know a fascinating example of you
00:37:31 know you know be careful what you wish for this is what this is what it's like
00:37:34 living in a multicultural society you know in a sense you have to allow
00:37:37 conservative Muslims to object homosexuality being taught in schools I
00:37:43 mean I mean that is you know that is their right in a liberal society I mean
00:37:49 they they shouldn't win the argument I do think we need to I mean the whole
00:37:54 British values thing I find a bit clunky. I would like there to perhaps be a bit more emphasis on
00:38:03 teaching British history. I mean that also raises difficult issues. I mean people you know coming
00:38:11 here from different countries often countries that have been on the wrong end of the British
00:38:14 Empire but none that you know we still have the British Empire in common and it's surely not
00:38:21 not beyond the wit of man, to teach the story of the British Empire relatively neutrally.
00:38:26 Yes, there were awful things about it.
00:38:28 There were good things about it.
00:38:32 We can teach these things, surely, in a relatively neutral and balanced way.
00:38:38 I mean, I think, so, you know, shared history,
00:38:42 wanting people, as it were, to kind of adopt British history as their own
00:38:47 when they come and live in a country, perhaps not the first generation,
00:38:50 but certainly by the second generation.
00:38:53 I mean, which doesn't mean to say, I mean, you know,
00:38:57 I'm not saying, you know, that we should all support the Tebbit test.
00:39:02 I do think that it's possible for people to identify with the country
00:39:07 in many different ways.
00:39:09 And I think, you know, people whose families have been here
00:39:12 for thousands of years might identify with Britain or England
00:39:16 And in a different way to somebody who's just come over a generation or a couple of generations ago,
00:39:24 they will identify perhaps more with the political freedoms, with the economic wealth.
00:39:30 But I think over time, you would hope that people become absorbed into the kind of invisible common norms
00:39:41 and sort of shared historical references, you know, turning a blind eye, you know, the Dunkirk spirit,
00:39:46 All of these things that are sort of in our vocabulary, that speak to our history.
00:39:53 It's a very nice idea, but I can't help feel a bit sceptical about it,
00:39:59 simply because, as I said, the sheer numbers involved mean that this becomes very, very difficult.
00:40:08 We have to finish now.
00:40:10 I mean, are you more optimistic now than maybe in 2004 on these issues or less?
00:40:20 No change.
00:40:22 I think we have a more open debate about it.
00:40:26 I think we have, I mean, I experienced in a sense how close the debate was in 2004 personally.
00:40:34 I think we do have a more open honest debate about these things.
00:40:37 whether things are moving in a better direction.
00:40:44 I mean, I think Brexit will have a kind of a break effect perhaps on,
00:40:51 I mean, the anywhere political classes have received a great shock
00:40:54 and I think they, I mean, despite the political petulance
00:41:00 that has been on display, you might say, in recent weeks and months,
00:41:04 I think there will be a recognition that actually they were too oblivious of their own cultural and political domination
00:41:12 and that there will be some adjustment of that.
00:41:16 I mean, I'm reasonably hopeful that that will take place, perhaps a little bit too hopeful.
00:41:22 Well, here's hoping anyway.
00:41:24 Thank you very, very much, David.
00:41:25 Thank you.
00:41:25 Thanks very much for watching us, and what you're saying is.
00:41:28 Please do subscribe, as I say every time.
00:41:32 And we'll see you next time.
00:41:33 Thank you very much.
00:41:34 Thank you.