New Culture Forum - May 09, 2022


Abortion, Blair's Legacy 25 Yrs On & Will Canada's Woke Gov't Ban Dying Soldiers Access To Priests

How To March BACK Through The Institutions & Regain Control The New Puritans: How Social Justice Captured the Western World

Episode Stats


Length

51 minutes

Words per minute

182.02

Word count

9,413

Sentence count

—


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to this week's Newspeak, the New Culture Forum's current affairs show with me
00:00:10 Emma Webb and I'm joined this week by senior fellow and historian and commentator Rafe
00:00:15 Hadel-Manku. We're going to be discussing this week's news stories all the way from abortion
00:00:19 to attacks on religious liberty in the United, not in the United States, in Canada even.
00:00:24 So let's get started by talking about this decision in the US. The US Supreme Court has
00:00:31 made the decision to overturn Roe versus Wade, which was an historic judgment that has been
00:00:36 portrayed as really a kind of cornerstone of abortion rights, not just in the United States,
00:00:43 women's rights to bodily autonomy in the United States, but also it's been portrayed as something
00:00:48 that was significant all across the globe. Do you want to start by giving us a sense and view
00:00:53 as a sense of um of what roe versus wade was as a judgment and the importance of that and why
00:01:00 there's such a hubbub now that this decision has been overturned yes so abortion in this country
00:01:06 is largely a settled issue it's still very contentious on on the extremes but in america
00:01:12 it's probably one of the most um hotly contested subjects uh the democrats and people on the left
00:01:18 have for 50 years assumed it was a completely settled matter there because of roe v wade
00:01:22 and what roe v wade did around 50 years ago was to establish a national right to access abortion
00:01:29 across the country any woman could do that and yes it is women who have abortions in case there's any
00:01:33 confusion about that subject the avoidance of doubt um and uh what's happened now is there's
00:01:39 been a leak so it hasn't actually been overturned yet there'll be a judgment in june and we don't
00:01:43 know the final details uh we've had access i believe probably from a disgruntled employee
00:01:49 outraged at this decision that the supreme court by majority of five to four is going to rule to
00:01:55 overturn roe v wade and this has obviously created a furore and what it would mean if it happens is
00:02:03 that rights over abortion will be devolved down to the states as it was originally and there are
00:02:08 around 26 states so basically 50 percent of whom would actually make abortion illegal and this is
00:02:15 an important point as well, that it's being portrayed as an attack on women's rights to
00:02:21 abortion. But actually, the overturning of that judgment doesn't mean that they're banning
00:02:26 abortion in the United States. It means that actually they're making a decision in favour of
00:02:31 more democratic control over abortion rights by state. And so those who have been angry saying
00:02:39 women are 50% of the population and women are against this, but actually women are 50%
00:02:45 probably in each state in the United States.
00:02:47 Maybe there are some states where there are more men than women.
00:02:51 But they will have a choice over their own state in terms of, you know,
00:02:58 they'll be able to remove people if they want to ban abortion and they don't agree with it.
00:03:06 So actually, in a way, this originally is almost using the narrative of rights
00:03:12 to try and circumvent the democratic control over abortion because you've seen like amnesty
00:03:18 international tweeting saying that abortion is a human right um so i guess what i'm saying is that
00:03:24 what's interesting about this is that the way that it is being portrayed in the media and all
00:03:29 of the hysteria surrounding it there's quite a contrast with the the reality of what this
00:03:34 means because it doesn't mean banning abortion in the united states it just means more democratic
00:03:39 control that's right it's taking it out of the hands of unelected justices who've become extremely
00:03:44 politicized now in a way that we don't see here in this country with judges who completely reflect
00:03:49 the views of whichever president put them into power and yes it does devolve this to states
00:03:54 and you know those states that uh are going to most likely ban abortion uh reflect particularly
00:04:01 well the entire cultural war that you see in america so both of the coast of america the
00:04:06 heartland of liberalism will have abortion still there and of course when it comes to the deep
00:04:10 south and parts of the uh parts of the midwest and so forth you won't have that but yes if people
00:04:16 want to travel to have an abortion that's not going to be outlawed although some states are
00:04:20 saying they may make it illegal to go to another state for an abortion it is something which is up
00:04:25 to the democratic will of the public in those states now the democrats could also try to put
00:04:30 forward legislation to overturn the supreme court ruling and enforce legislation to make abortion
00:04:36 legal across the country again. But whilst they have a majority in the House of Representatives,
00:04:42 you need to have a 60% majority in the Senate for such a law to pass. And that's not going to happen
00:04:47 because it's evenly split. And as we know, with the midterm elections coming up, the Republicans
00:04:53 are going to make inroads there again. So I think the Democrats are out of luck if they think there's
00:04:56 going to be any chance to do away with that. So my understanding of this judgment is that
00:05:02 they're essentially they're saying that and i know that this is something that had been disputed
00:05:07 since since this judgment was passed that the reasoning behind it was it was um disputed that
00:05:13 they're arguing essentially that it was wrong to to interpret abortion as being a constitutional
00:05:19 right that it isn't a constitutional right in the united states and that's what the sort of
00:05:23 the point of the law that they are discussing are correct and that's right in fact if you
00:05:28 if you read if you read the opinion of of the court or of judge alito he says that you know
00:05:33 unlike the right to bear arms the second amendment and the right to free speech there isn't a clear
00:05:38 right to have an abortion in the constitution uh and yes but it does go fundamentally to those
00:05:43 moral issues it's an ethical and moral issue who does a woman have exclusive right to her body
00:05:49 or is there the rights of the child to life and then if so at what point does life start
00:05:54 do you see this as firstly do you see this as kicking off uh new discussion around in the
00:06:03 within the culture wars because i know a lot of people have been worried that this is going to
00:06:06 have in the same way that they claim that roe versus wade had in the first place huge implications
00:06:11 for abortion laws around the world that this is going to have implications in other countries
00:06:16 outside of the united states and do you think that particularly in the united states how i
00:06:21 I mean, how do you see that fight playing out?
00:06:24 Because obviously this isn't going to be the last word.
00:06:26 This is something the Democrats are going to fight back on.
00:06:28 Look, most things that have come out of America in the last 50 years have not been good for the rest of the world.
00:06:33 We're all dealing with the after effects of George Floyd, for example,
00:06:36 a subject that has no relevance whatsoever to this country and yet has been taken up by BLM radical activists over here.
00:06:44 I'm not so sure that the abortion issue is going to make inroads in, say, Western Europe.
00:06:49 it's it's much more of a settled it's much more of a settled thing it is
00:06:52 however going to become a touch paper in American politics and I think things
00:06:56 are going to become even more incendiary and the divide between Democrats and
00:07:01 Republicans on the issue of abortion is wider now that any time in the last 20
00:07:05 or 30 years which is interesting around 80% of Democrats think that abortion
00:07:10 should be legal in most if not all cases and it's only around 39% of
00:07:15 republicans now as a nation around 60 percent of americans are actually in favor of abortions in
00:07:22 most if not all cases so i'm not actually sure that this ruling even though i may or may not be
00:07:27 in favor of it is actually going to help the republicans when it comes to the election because
00:07:32 i think if trump is going to be the candidate going forward given he appointed these justices
00:07:35 there if a decisive majority of the american population don't believe that this was the right
00:07:41 decision to be made and if trump is still going to be in debate saying that he won the election
00:07:47 and if the democrats can can stick on this january the sixth insurrection on him i think he's going
00:07:53 to have a very tough time and i think those are three issues which may actually become obstacles
00:07:58 to the white house you mentioned um before the the moral issues surrounding this what did you
00:08:04 think of the people holding up my body my choice uh posters in the in the protest they were
00:08:10 protesting outside of the white house i believe or were they protesting outside of the supreme court
00:08:14 either way um a lot of the people who are saying my body my choice will be people who were in favor
00:08:20 of vaccine mandates and this is something that's been pointed out as a sort of grave hypocrisy
00:08:25 the sheer hypocrisy of this these are the people who wanted to have forced vaccinations and yet
00:08:30 are now saying my body my choice i mean and why they can't see the irony there or the hypocrisy
00:08:36 about that but you know and it works the other ways too you know a lot of the people who are
00:08:41 opposed to abortion are in favor of the death penalty people who are in favor of abortion are
00:08:48 opposed to the death penalty so if life is sacred how do you actually balance those two competing
00:08:53 views now the catholic position is at least consistent on both points they're against
00:08:59 abortions and they're against the death penalty but lots of the other arguments whatever side
00:09:03 you're on there are glaring holes in the logic i think i think one thing that i i i've found
00:09:09 interesting over the discussions i've seen happening over the last couple of days particularly
00:09:13 because i think in this country it's very very difficult to have open conversations from a pro-life
00:09:21 position because most people it's become such a verboten subject that there are many people who
00:09:27 They'll have, you know, a variety of views on it, not necessarily being an anti-abortion absolutist.
00:09:36 They might believe that perhaps that the amount of the window of time should be shorter in which a woman can have an abortion or that it should only be allowed in circumstances of, say, rape or incest and so on.
00:09:47 But that side of the argument doesn't really get a hearing, even in the United Kingdom where we're less divided over this issue.
00:09:55 and one of the aspects of this as i mentioned amnesty international tweeting that abortion
00:10:02 is a human right is that the debate has become so almost facile and crass because there's no
00:10:09 recognition of the fact that the other side far from being monsters simply believe that the right
00:10:15 to life is an actual human right and that there is a human life involved because the other side
00:10:20 will say well it's just a clump of cells and so it's nothing like just you know throwing out a
00:10:25 bit of trash there's no moral difference there and so what I found really interesting is that
00:10:31 on the one hand you've seen people pointing out the hypocrisy of those and I think it is hypocrisy
00:10:38 of those who say my body my choice except when it comes to vaccine mandates but in the other
00:10:44 direction those who pointed out well you were against vaccine mandates but you're also pro-life
00:10:49 I think actually that position is less hypocritical because and it can only be viewed as hypocritical if you are failing to recognize that there is another human life involved.
00:11:01 So there's just a simple biological, straightforward biological fact that women and men are biologically different and that has ethical implications because a woman can have a life inside of her.
00:11:12 And so actually, you can make my body, my choice argument in relation to the bodily autonomy of the fetus.
00:11:19 Also, it's actually not that different from vaccine mandates, because the other side would presumably argue that the unborn child and the unborn child's life and right to life needs to be protected from the mother.
00:11:32 and we've seen cases recently people arguing for things like post-birth abortion that a mother
00:11:39 should have the right to terminate the life of her child for mental health reasons physical reasons
00:11:45 and so on and so for me I think that actually a lot of the confusion in this discussion is coming
00:11:53 from the fact that because we've not had that sort of fair-minded conversation for so long
00:11:59 the other side actually really don't understand the pro-life position you're absolutely right
00:12:04 there's far too much emotion in this without actually any reason discussion and any re-evaluation
00:12:10 of the science because a key point here is if you get a lot of the morality and ethics of this
00:12:15 is based upon scientific evidence but as time marches on the science changes hugely in terms
00:12:21 of when they believe life may be there and there's this huge disagreement on those issues
00:12:26 Now, unlike Peter Hitchens and Tim Stanley and others, I've always been consistently conservative.
00:12:32 I've never wavered in my conservatism since I was a teenager.
00:12:36 But when it came to abortion, I was always confused because I tried to study the subject very well.
00:12:42 And the science seemed out of kilter with the ethics and the morality of one side and on the other side.
00:12:49 and i think if people actually took time to actually look into the the various points at
00:12:54 which abortions have been stated as being acceptable they would get a far more nuanced
00:12:59 understanding of the arguments of both sides because there are merits in the actual logical
00:13:03 arguments but it's a question of of for me when life starts so of course if you're a catholic
00:13:09 it starts at the point of conception which is immediately with the fertilization of the egg
00:13:14 but then others would say it starts a week later with the implantation of the of the egg into the
00:13:21 womb after that about 16 or that takes about a week i believe now 16 17 weeks later you get what
00:13:27 used to be called the quickening and this was a a time when the baby would first kick for example
00:13:33 now this goes back to the time of aristotle and saint augustine where and it was actually part
00:13:38 of christian theology that the soul entered the embryo at that point of the first kick when henry
00:13:45 the eighth one of his one of his wives had the had a kick there were bonfires litter all over
00:13:50 and i think what a lot of people don't realize is that in britain from around the 13th century
00:13:55 to the 19th century abortions were legal up to the quickening so it wasn't until that baby kicked
00:14:01 that the abortions became illegal others would say it's when brain activity starts that's when life
00:14:07 starts others will say it's when the fetus becomes viable outside of the womb and that technology
00:14:13 changes of course the viability outside of the womb becomes much more early and of course it
00:14:18 depends upon what facilities are in a hospital ward for example as well and then you have those
00:14:23 who say that it's basically uh should be stopped just at the point of birth but for me a piece of
00:14:29 skin separating a baby from the outside world doesn't seem very good but those are all points
00:14:33 along the timeline and my view has always been to err on the side of caution because science always
00:14:38 suddenly revealed actually things are earlier things start early the heartbeat is earlier than
00:14:42 we thought there's brain activity earlier so i've tended to uh far more on on the side of caution
00:14:48 but if you look at these things in that sense of sense i think people can see that there are real
00:14:53 logical arguments and these aren't just uh frenzied hysterical points of view based upon
00:14:58 religion or dogma and of course it's very much a christian concept in the sense that
00:15:02 in judaism and islam the rights of the mother actually do supersede the rights of the baby
00:15:07 there's almost something um sort of vile and barbarous about the way that you you see people
00:15:14 discussing or debating at university campuses and loads of videos on youtube and the way that people
00:15:19 talk about the fetus is almost as if it is um i'm not sure how it should be described but it's
00:15:26 it's almost as if the the dehumanization of the fetus is forced like it's it's it's a point of
00:15:33 ideology that it that this is a bag of cells that can just be simply discarded even even to the
00:15:39 point and and um i was watching a video of this earlier of um a woman arguing that the abortion
00:15:45 should be allowed even while the woman is giving birth and like you say the difference between a
00:15:50 baby inside of a mother and a baby outside um particularly in those later stages is is almost
00:15:59 sort of besides the point and it's something that i found particularly um i was i was shocked and
00:16:04 disgusted by um when i discovered that through heidi krauter this um down syndrome activist
00:16:12 woman who has been campaigning against our abortion laws in the uk um because it turns out and i
00:16:19 didn't know this that you can have an abortion if the child has down syndrome all the way to
00:16:25 the point of birth and her argument is that this is discrimination within the womb because it
00:16:31 suggests that even outside of the womb that somehow people with down syndrome are lesser
00:16:36 people less less than fully human if they can be um sort of essentially killed just before birth
00:16:44 whereas a a normal fetus wouldn't be would be protected by the law um and so i there seems to
00:16:52 me to be a kind of like i said sort of barbarism in how we the public debate has come to talk about
00:17:01 the unborn child um and i was talking to somebody yesterday at the pub about this that um only
00:17:08 you know, maybe a decade ago, you would have had Labour MPs, Conservative MPs, religious
00:17:14 and not religious, standing up and arguing against abortion in the House. And now it
00:17:21 has become so sort of, as I say, verboten as a subject, that it's, I actually think
00:17:29 this dehumanising language about the foetus has become normalised.
00:17:33 It's entirely become normalised and is actually quite despicable to see some of these Vox
00:17:38 pops you've referred to where people are essentially treating a baby as if it were you
00:17:42 know an appendix or an intestine that can just be disregarded but of course as with everything
00:17:48 the abortion issue also becomes tied up in race politics because a disproportionate number of
00:17:53 ethnic minorities black people in particular have abortions compared to say white people
00:17:57 and therefore this is also being seen as uh tied up in all of those issues and you're denying the
00:18:02 rights of uh of black people so it's just a convoluted mess shall we um move on to discussing
00:18:10 neil parish the mp who's caught uh watching porn in parliament um but what i not not necessarily
00:18:18 whether the rights and wrongs of him doing that and then choosing to resign over it but what i
00:18:23 felt thought was particularly interesting was how how quickly same as with the sarah everard um
00:18:28 murder how quickly we went from an event so in this case an mp watching porn in parliament
00:18:36 to we need 50 50 men and women in parliament we need to deal with the the culture of misogyny and
00:18:43 so on and like i mentioned sarah everard we went very very quickly from the murder of an innocent
00:18:49 young woman to conversations about whether or not men should be curfewed and locked inside because
00:18:55 of systemic misogyny and toxic masculinity how how do you understand this leap because i can't
00:19:02 fathom it had they got from an mp watching porn to we need 50 50 men and women first of all i
00:19:08 have some breaking news for you that um neil parish's wife has just left him um he woke up
00:19:14 this morning to find that she had written him a john deere letter now that's probably lost on a
00:19:19 lot of people lost on me john deere is a dear john letter is what traditionally a wife writes
00:19:25 to her husband she's leaving but john deere is a famous tractor brand so yes but you have to
00:19:29 explain your joke it rather loses the whole thing but hopefully there are some older people out there
00:19:34 who are laughing i knew they were going to be tractor jokes but i didn't expect that that was
00:19:37 one of them but no yeah but you're absolutely right what i found absolutely appalling here
00:19:41 was this sort of almost consensus of opinion that there has never been a sleazier parliament than
00:19:46 this one that parliament has never been more unsafe for women women than it is now uh and
00:19:52 that drastic measures need to be taken to sort out uh the culture that exists in parliament excuse
00:19:58 me there has never been a better time to be a woman in parliament than now uh just because um
00:20:05 neil parish works on porn in parliament doesn't mean that this is the sleaziest parliament ever
00:20:09 it means that we have social media now that enables you to have these devices
00:20:13 i'm pretty sure that if we had these smartphones 30 40 years ago particularly before cameras came
00:20:20 in to show bbc parliament there would have been a hell of a lot more mps surfing some people may
00:20:26 have seen the the meme of jacob reese mogg looking at a victorian woman exposing her ankle but uh
00:20:33 i'm sure yeah and i'm sure every single male mp given by british standards has watched porn at
00:20:39 some point in their life um and similarly the idea that this is the sleaze that people have pointed
00:20:45 out you know the owen patterson scandal for example as another example of sleaze in modern
00:20:50 day politics well i'm sorry he's now the exception before that he would have been in the main
00:20:56 the number of people with outside interests was exponentially higher until it has been in recent
00:21:01 years uh and of course now women are far more vocal about things that happened to them we've
00:21:06 We've had Anne-Marie Trevelyan saying that she was pushed up against a wall.
00:21:10 Before, that would never have been told to anybody.
00:21:12 None of this would have been announced.
00:21:13 There are no mechanisms in place.
00:21:15 So I think that all of this is completely over the top.
00:21:18 And I'm so disappointed to see Andrea Leadsom and the Tory party advocating such a woke policy as 50% female MPs.
00:21:29 I mean, anybody who knows how these things work.
00:21:33 I forget who it was, Julia Hartley Brewer or someone said that every time they've met MPs, two women MPs, one from a shortlist and one who wasn't, they instinctively knew which woman had been from the shortlist because the gap in talent and skill between the one who was elected because of their own merits and the one who was there on a shortlist shows the reality of what quality of candidates you get.
00:21:56 And you just have to look at the House of Lords, particularly the Labour peers in the House of Lords, Baroness Udin, all of these social workers and party apparatchiks who get appointed to see that there's a complete dearth of talent there.
00:22:09 Don't you think it's peculiar, let's say, that the Conservative Party and particularly many conservative activists are not exactly illiberal when it comes to porn.
00:22:25 They're not Mary Whitehouses. These are people who have been normalising porn through their comments and through their activism for years.
00:22:36 They have claimed that that porn is something that is, you know, I know this from personal
00:22:43 conversations with people that they believe that porn is can be a liberal thing, that
00:22:49 it can it can liberate women.
00:22:51 It's something that is, you know, they don't they don't believe in banning pornography.
00:22:55 And then when you see an MP casually watching porn in Parliament, of course, this is something
00:23:01 that is inappropriate in the workplace.
00:23:03 the reaction to it seems so overblown given how how people seem to not take
00:23:10 porn as being such a terrible thing yeah no I agree with you completely I mean
00:23:15 what amazes me is that the two Tory MPs who spied this didn't just go to their
00:23:20 own chief whip and say to the chief whip look this chap is completely out of
00:23:24 order he needs to be brought in and given a severe dressing down not to do
00:23:28 it again rather than going through this whole um shaming which is again now put the tory party
00:23:34 again in under the spotlight and may risk it at the next local elections coming up next week so
00:23:39 i just i'm not maybe it's me that's out of out of keeping it out of touch but i just thought
00:23:43 the process by which this thing came to light and what he's been put through i think is completely
00:23:49 out of proportion i'm failing i'm failing to understand how in their minds um as i say
00:23:55 presuming that they are actually themselves quite liberal when it comes to pornography and don't
00:23:59 want to ban it. I'm struggling to see how they saw an MP watching porn and then thought this is an
00:24:04 issue to do with misogyny that we need to make into this huge issue to do with women and women's
00:24:09 rights. To me, it seems almost cynical. And I find it amusing, horrible, but amusing that they see
00:24:18 the solution to a culture of misogyny as they perceive it as being solved they see the solution
00:24:26 to that as being basically patronizing women by by insisting and having 50 50 shortlists and quotas
00:24:32 because in iceland they managed to achieve 50 50 on the basis of merit with no quotas
00:24:37 and for me the implication that oliver dowden made when he said that men will just put themselves
00:24:44 forward for these things and they'll believe that they'll be really good at the job but women need
00:24:48 a little bit of an extra push that they need women need someone to come out to us and say
00:24:53 you'll be very very good at this job and you should look into getting yourself on the candidates
00:24:57 list it's so patronizing that i actually think in a way ironically it's actually a little bit
00:25:03 misogynistic it is it is patronizing and misogynistic and of course what i never understand
00:25:08 with all of these things is why they're just um just keeping things to 50 women why not why don't
00:25:14 have a quota for gay people coming in why not have a quota for trans although i think you'd have to
00:25:18 half a person or a quarter of a person in if you're going to go by national percentages of
00:25:22 who's trans uh same thing for ethnic minorities why don't we actually have more chinese people
00:25:26 in parliament than are there you know surely that they they deserve a greater proportion
00:25:29 and disabilities i mean where are you going to end this now look i think there should be more plump
00:25:33 fat people in parliament personally you know so i can have a chance finally of getting in
00:25:39 uh but these you know and but it goes broader than that you just have to look for example at
00:25:43 advertising now right if you look at advertising black people make up three percent of the
00:25:47 population and yet they're around 80 percent of the people you see on television and yet asians
00:25:52 pakistanis and indians make up around eight percent of the population and you'll rarely ever
00:25:56 see one now if that's not racism i don't know what is but this is an attempt to be to be unracist but
00:26:02 actually it's enforcing racism in another sense by excluding a far larger portion of the population
00:26:07 let alone white people who are still you know 86 percent of the population is white so if you
00:26:11 wouldn't know that watching television um but yeah i agree with you and of course the falsehood at
00:26:16 the heart of that is the idea that someone represents you because they are physically
00:26:20 similar to you i don't like the implication that someone like diane abbott or um even even someone
00:26:27 like liz truss or anna soubry or um i mean kemi badenoch i very often agree with kemi on everything
00:26:35 but i don't i don't believe that i agree with her because we're women i don't feel represented by her
00:26:40 because she is another woman i feel represented because we share views whereas someone like
00:26:46 anna soubry or diane abbott or even liz truss i don't feel very represented because i i don't
00:26:52 i happen to disagree with them on more things possibly than i agree with them on in varying
00:26:56 degrees and what really gets me about all of this is the self-indulgence of this it's the narcissism
00:27:01 it's this naval gazing of the westminster bubble by which i mean not only politics but also the media
00:27:07 and the fact that we have a cost of living crisis we have energy crisis we've got a social house
00:27:12 social care crisis um we've got the ukraine crisis going on these are meaty subjects and
00:27:18 yet the majority of air time over the past two weeks has been on growler gate angela
00:27:25 rainer pulling a sharon stone basic instinct and on track tractor gates and how people can think
00:27:31 that that is a normal state of affairs i think is absolutely despicable and it shows the dearth
00:27:36 of talent amongst in parliament it shows the lack of ambition of motivation and the lack of real
00:27:41 concern i think with the real issues of the day and that extends to the the agenda setters in
00:27:47 the media do you think that this has something to do with this is part of the covid effect that
00:27:53 all of the news surrounding our politics now rather than it being about policies or being
00:27:57 about the actual politics has become a kind of pantomime about all of the individuals involved
00:28:02 that every week there seems to be a new scandal a new installment in the soap opera of what's
00:28:07 going on in parliament and it's become very very focused on the individuals is that something to
00:28:13 do with covid is that something to do with identity politics how how has that become the
00:28:18 sort of prevailing situation this all comes down to virtue signaling on both sides and it's a
00:28:24 question of pinning your colors to the mast and wanting to be seen to be on side on everything
00:28:30 because everybody now I think is conscious of social media. They want to have a soundbite,
00:28:35 they want to have a clippable thing that can go on to a tweet and so people are obsessed by the
00:28:40 superficial which will resonate as hollow things always sound louder after all rather than dealing
00:28:47 with more substantive issues which are less sexy. It's far less sexy to speak out about tax levels
00:28:54 than it is to make a comment about uh you know dominator tractors and i guess there's a lot of
00:28:59 these in the game of politics a lot of these uh actual policies things to do with tax and
00:29:07 yesterday there was so much news about tax that um these things sort of slip out into the night
00:29:14 underneath this enormous veil of drama to do with as you say you know how angela rayner chose to
00:29:20 across her legs and and that kind of thing that um maybe it's partly because i wonder whether
00:29:28 it's a sort of mixture of as you say the navel gazing the focus on self and identity whenever
00:29:34 somebody tells a story or makes a point they always need to have some kind of personal hook
00:29:40 to make it relevant as to why that person is so it's created a kind of cult of of individual
00:29:45 personalities and then at the same time we've also had two years of a non-stop barrage of wall-to-wall
00:29:53 coverage of covid and then that stopped and we got wall-to-wall coverage of ukraine and then that
00:29:58 stopped and we got wall-to-wall coverage of party gate rishigate and all of this stuff that it maybe
00:30:04 it's something to do with a kind of um public fatigue that that the the paper this is what the
00:30:10 papers are giving the people what people want yeah it is but it's also it's a wider societal
00:30:14 problem i mean you just have to look at things such as um for example comedy comedy used to be
00:30:19 about telling jokes you know an englishman an irishman and the scotsman or whatever now it's
00:30:24 about my personal journey through life all comedy is now focused on myself and it is the most
00:30:30 narcissistic sort of thing now that everyone's obsessing oh my dad gave me a tough life you know
00:30:35 oh growing up as an indian boy here you know when i just tell a funny joke rather than constantly
00:30:40 turn everything into a story about and it becomes it becomes obsessive and you see that in people's
00:30:45 tweets now and instagram all of the selfies everything in our culture is about me myself
00:30:50 and i the megan markalization of the public debate um so let's move on to blair's legacy
00:30:58 because this is this week we've had the 25th anniversary of um blair's election people have
00:31:04 been sharing on social media that that famous photograph of maybe we can put it up that famous
00:31:09 photograph of sherry blair um opening the door on the day after the election in her in her night
00:31:16 dress and and with a bunch of flowers um so what are your views of tony blair's legacy what
00:31:26 we spoke before about you know everything from the long march to mass migration do you think
00:31:32 that he is britain's worst prime minister i'm not sure what time this is going out whether it's
00:31:38 before the watershed or after the watershed you know what i can say what language i can use
00:31:42 do your worst for this man but he was without doubt in my view the most dangerous prime minister
00:31:47 i won't say worse because worse can be interpreted in many different ways does worse mean most
00:31:52 incompetent i would say boris is the most incompetent um teresa may was a terrible prime
00:31:57 minister um but in terms of danger in terms of lasting legacy and long-term damage perhaps
00:32:05 irrevocable damage caused to this nation nobody has more guilt than tony blair what he's done
00:32:11 has been more damaging to britain than the second world war in my view second world war crippled the
00:32:16 economy destroyed so much of the country but what he's done is much more insidious and it goes to
00:32:21 the core of britain britain and british identity and it is it's mass immigration uh it's the long
00:32:27 march its education and its constitutional and devolution look at mass immigration this is
00:32:35 unbelievable we all know now the famous article written by andrew neither in the evening standard
00:32:41 in which he admitted this was the chap who was the key speech writer in the labour government
00:32:45 under blair who wrote a key speech for the immigration minister and he revealed a few
00:32:49 years ago that mass immigration was a deliberate policy of the labour party to turn britain into
00:32:56 a truly multicultural society and there were two reasons for doing that one was to quote
00:33:02 rub the rights noses in diversity charming and secondly was to ensure that the labor party will
00:33:10 be easily elected in the future because ethnic minorities vote 80 of them vote labor and that
00:33:14 would ensure and guarantee and we're seeing that now in the cities in london and elsewhere
00:33:19 the tory party will never be seen again because of their strong ethnic and young populations
00:33:24 people often say britain was always a land of immigrants absolutely not true you know um the
00:33:31 people quote for example the ugandan refugees who came over very famously that was a huge number for
00:33:37 the time but that was 27 000 people that's the average immigration number that comes over every
00:33:43 two weeks now and this started under blair 25 years ago that we've had more immigrants to this
00:33:49 country since Blair came to power, so in the last 25 years, than in the last 2,000 years combined.
00:33:57 And no society can withstand such rapid seismic shifts in demography without having severe
00:34:05 repercussions. No one's opposed to immigration, but immigration needs to happen at a slow and steady
00:34:10 pace that enables the society to adapt to the new populations, and that enables the immigrants who
00:34:15 coming here who have to be the right sort of immigrants for a start highly skilled unlike the
00:34:20 unskilled labor that came in under blair but they need time to be able to be absorbed and assimilate
00:34:25 and if you have such vast numbers coming into the country they would naturally automatically form
00:34:30 ghettos and we now have unbelievable segregation in this country we have a rise in um acid attacks
00:34:37 honor killings public machete fights with groups of young black men in the streets which you would
00:34:41 never see before in broad daylight there's now a metropolitan police department focusing on
00:34:47 witchcraft if you can imagine because incidents of witchcraft have become so high with exorcisms
00:34:52 babies being and young children in many cases in some cases unfortunately losing their lives
00:34:58 in these despicable practices grooming gangs as we know or rape gangs as i would like to call them
00:35:05 correctly in the north of england deep culture of misogyny arise in anti-semitism and arise in
00:35:11 homophobia it's funny how on the bbc we're always told that there's a rise in anti-semitism and a
00:35:15 rise in homophobia and no one ever questions why is this the case could it be because we have a
00:35:19 larger muslim population for example none of this gets discussed this is all part of his legacy
00:35:25 britain now has from the last census i think 14 percent of the population was born abroad
00:35:32 the last thousand years we only had around 1.5 percent of the population born abroad even when
00:35:37 the romans and vikings were here it was between three and five percent we've never seen such a
00:35:42 shift and that is extremely damaging for our society because people are not having any exposure
00:35:48 to british culture british tradition and british sensitivities and when you have an education
00:35:55 system supported by tony blair's labor government which our current tories have done nothing about
00:36:01 they have an enforced policy that elevates minority cultures over the majority existing
00:36:06 british culture so when you have an enforced policy of multiculturalism combining with mass
00:36:11 immigration you get segregation and you have parts of this country now alas that actually think that
00:36:17 this is a muslim majority nation there are schools in the north of england who think that britain is
00:36:23 90 asian and muslim it's despicable that's the mass immigration side but then yes but then we
00:36:29 just have to look at the long march through the institutions and i think this goes really to the
00:36:32 heart of of what's wrong with tony blair people don't actually realize how many communists were
00:36:37 in tony blair's cabinet he was a confirmed trotskyist john reed was a member of the communist
00:36:44 party of great britain and a declared leninist and stalinist alan milburn used to run a marxist
00:36:51 bookshop peter mandelson was a member of the young communist league and used to candle copies of the
00:36:59 morning star outside kilburn tube station and alistair darling was a member of the international
00:37:06 some other communist marxist organization these were the people the key players in the country
00:37:11 holding the great offices of state they were at the heart of this government so and what they've
00:37:15 done is to refashion institutions in ways that were unrecognizable you know if you walk through
00:37:20 whitehall in london you see these wonderful edifices these grand structures which look
00:37:26 about which look to everyone that britain is a confident imperial sort of nation was grounded
00:37:31 in monarchy and tradition and so forth but the reality is the people that inhabit those buildings
00:37:36 today bear no resemblance to previous generations we have cuckoos in the nests you can have a
00:37:40 revolution without flying red flags from the rooftops there's been this silent cultural
00:37:45 revolution and unfortunately after 10 years now of tory government i've seen no efforts by this
00:37:51 government to try to redress that and it seems as if it may even be too late now the rot may have
00:37:56 set in because of again another Blair policy education education education we have far too
00:38:02 many people going to university who should be in apprenticeships and they're being indoctrinated
00:38:07 in this left-wing marxist ideology and we know full well that if only under 25s had had a vote
00:38:13 at the last election the tories wouldn't have gained one seat in parliament obviously when
00:38:19 Blair won he had this enormous historic landslide victory and so many people possibly even many
00:38:26 of the people watching will have voted for Blair because the the what you described there wasn't
00:38:33 the Blair that they thought that they were getting that that that isn't what they expected that
00:38:37 um he seems very very centre-left to the point that now actually um many conservatives are
00:38:44 are probably more similar to Blair than they are to the conservatives of old.
00:38:49 Do you think that people expected
00:38:52 that that was what they were what they were getting?
00:38:54 And also, I think with the long view now, because for me,
00:38:59 I don't really remember what the country was like before Blair,
00:39:01 because I was I was a young child when when Blair won.
00:39:05 So with that long view on Blair's legacy,
00:39:09 all of those things that you describe there, obviously,
00:39:12 there are elements that quite clearly you can attribute to Blair like increasing immigration
00:39:18 and so on but are there other explanations with that long view like successive governments
00:39:24 including successive conservative governments and failures there that explain things like
00:39:29 high crime rate because a lot of these people who are involved in crime and so on
00:39:33 won't necessarily be immigrants themselves they may be the children of immigrants there may be
00:39:38 other explanations for rising crime rates and so on so with that long view how much of that do you
00:39:45 think is fair to attribute to blair and how much of what occurred afterwards do you think could
00:39:52 have been predicted by those who chose to vote for him well i didn't say that crime was the rising
00:39:58 crime was due to blair i named specific types of incidents and crimes which are directly related
00:40:03 to his policies but yeah look tony blair understandably got elected at a time when
00:40:07 you had had the tory party in power from 1979 through to 1997 and it almost seemed as if
00:40:15 the labor party would be unelectable and it had to change and it occupied the ground
00:40:20 and britain of the 1990 you did have another sleaze era far more sleazy era than we have
00:40:26 we have now uh of uh sleep back to basics policies in john major's government and people were tired
00:40:32 of the tories and the 90s the communism had collapsed there was this feeling of francis
00:40:38 fukuyama that it was the end of history and there needed to be an awakening of a new society you had
00:40:44 bill clinton doing a similar policy in america so i can absolutely see why they would cleave to
00:40:51 blair because blair looked less left-wing than say michael foote and other labor leaders had before
00:40:58 him um but he was still a trotskyist this is the thing you know he was very much the wolf in sheep's
00:41:04 clothing people didn't really understand those who were inside did know and peter hitchens talks
00:41:09 about this how he said people were the people in the inner coterie were celebrating or waving red
00:41:14 flags and they said this is a new dawn because they really did see this as a time they thought
00:41:19 they might have one or two parliaments maximum and they wanted to inflict the most radical change
00:41:24 that they could so they went hell for leather in that parliament to try to change the country
00:41:30 and the british public had no idea about that because yes there was investment in infrastructure
00:41:34 there were investment in in transport and you know by the time of the millennium london alone
00:41:39 looked so much cleaner and better so that there were definitely good aspects of intent in terms
00:41:43 of investment but nobody was privy to this secret plan and it's not a real i'm not a conspiracy
00:41:49 theorists but there was a clear agenda at play here to radically transform and as i said credit
00:41:54 to them right i don't agree with them but they had a what they wanted to change the country and they
00:41:58 did it our government since 2010 has had a chance to reverse that long march through the institutions
00:42:05 boris has an 80 seat majority he can do what he wants and he's squandered this in the most
00:42:10 ridiculous way because we actually should have had with an 80 seat majority we should have had
00:42:14 at least 10 years so until 2029 if not beyond that for the tory party to actually reverse that
00:42:21 long is that is that because they lack vision they don't have the same vision for society that
00:42:25 blair had yeah or they don't have a vision for society in the way that bled it obviously not
00:42:30 the same one they lack dominic cummings boris was only ever a puppet everyone knows that he's
00:42:35 very much a wishy-washy liberal on on all issues particularly on immigration for example
00:42:41 but dominic cummings understood the pulse of the nation he understood what needed to be done
00:42:46 and the loss of dominic cummings and his replacement with carrie antoinette
00:42:52 who's now pulling his strings and you can see that from environmental policy onwards it's very much
00:42:56 a red tory uh party of um i wouldn't even say a green tory party of of his wife who's basically
00:43:04 the last person he listens to at night before he goes to bed and that's basically boris always
00:43:08 believes what the last person told him and she has his ear i really do think that there is no
00:43:13 vision at all they're very good at talking the talk the modern tori party so we hear about rwanda
00:43:18 policies we hear about pushing ships back in the boats back in the channel but these are all just
00:43:22 sound bites there's never any meaty substance behind these things and they're always soon
00:43:26 forgotten about and they're always being issued in order to divert attention away from other issues
00:43:31 what do you think of the calls within the labour party to return to blair um that they they
00:43:38 essentially want to replicate blair's legacy and that they think that that is the way that they
00:43:42 can search basic basically the way that they can salvage the labour party from complete oblivion
00:43:47 i think it's a very smart policy because he was the only person who gave the labour party three
00:43:52 consecutive electoral victories um he's a man who um because of the changes he brought into the
00:43:58 country has would have a strong following amongst the center of the country not blair standing
00:44:05 again but somebody in his mold he has changed the country and it's because over 25 years one
00:44:12 generation has now grown up that i think it would be a someone with charisma and with that sort of
00:44:17 agenda i think would do very well in parliament and what in terms of um so as i say you know
00:44:23 people wouldn't wouldn't necessarily have known what they were going to get when they voted for
00:44:27 Blair if there is a new Labour leader in the mould of Blair and people vote for them and they they
00:44:34 win at a general election what do you what would you expect that the implications of what that
00:44:40 would be in terms of that individual's legacy well Tony Blair I don't think anybody not even
00:44:46 Tony Blair could have imagined we would have the rapid transformation we've had in woke identity
00:44:51 politics of the last 10 years no one could have foreseen that and I think Blair has been shocked
00:44:56 by that too and you've seen him issue statements which uh show his concern with the woke identity
00:45:02 politics that has overtaken the labor party so i think anyone who's sensible note would know that
00:45:07 if you want to carry the nation you have to be more centrist on this and so i i think they would
00:45:12 understand that so let's finally um move on to this story that that you sent me um that had me
00:45:19 i was bawling with laughter at it i think it's hilarious um obviously it's quite serious but
00:45:24 some aspects of it are very funny. This Canadian government report that calls for a ban on Catholic,
00:45:31 Orthodox, Jewish and Muslim chaplains because essentially the fact that they only have
00:45:38 male clergy doesn't conform to Canada's theological judgment on tolerance. One of the things in this
00:45:46 that i i thought was particularly amusing um is that so this comes from a an orwellian sounding
00:45:55 panel called the minister's advisory panel on systemic racism and discrimination and trudeau
00:46:03 gave it this is a quote mandate a clear mandate to seek out policies processes and practices that
00:46:09 enable systemic racism and discrimination in the department of defense and that the panel was to
00:46:14 quote um to hunt out quote uh all forms of systemic racism and discrimination including
00:46:21 anti-indigenous and anti-black racism lgbtq2 plus prejudice gender bias right-wing extremism
00:46:28 and white supremacy and that according to this article each of these these weekly meetings of
00:46:37 the advisory panel would begin with members um doing this sort of prayer where they would turn
00:46:43 towards quote our grandfathers the thunder beings our grandmother moon and our creator however
00:46:49 imagined so um i just wanted to get your thoughts on this insane story thunder beings are go yes no
00:46:57 it's absolutely remarkable this document it's not government policy yet but it's a government body
00:47:03 that has issued these report recommendations interestingly that the terms of reference were to
00:47:08 root out systemic racism including anti-black racism i don't know why you need to specify that
00:47:13 surely racism is racism why would you need to specify that and also it's not anti-chinese
00:47:18 racism yeah exactly no yeah and uh and also uh right-wing extremism why do you need to say
00:47:23 right-wing can't you just say extremism because surely you know muslim extremism or left-wing
00:47:28 extremism is equally insidious it's it's it's very telling the bias apparent and just in those terms
00:47:35 of references is overwhelming but people have to understand what this this is a direct attack on
00:47:40 religious liberty what this report the government report is saying is that because women aren't
00:47:46 allowed to become catholic priests or orthodox jewish rabbis or imams in islam that these
00:47:53 religions should be banned from the canadian armed forces that these chaplains should not be
00:47:59 hired because of their sexist um policies which aren't in keeping with the the army's policies
00:48:06 this is state sanctioned control this is state sanctioned religion all i could think of when i
00:48:11 read this was of china the chinese government appointing catholic bishops rather than the pope
00:48:17 because the catholic bishops there that they appoint tow the party line and i don't see how
00:48:22 this is any different in principle uh and of course these uh the canadian government is now
00:48:28 saying through this report that monotheistic religions should be banned meaning these three
00:48:33 religions because they don't believe in paganism and they believe in converting polytheists
00:48:39 so basically what they're saying is if you believe in um jupiter and apollo and um you know achilles
00:48:46 and all the old roman gods that's that's more valid than believing in jesus christ it is
00:48:52 ultimately subversive isn't it that the and it it is a sin it's really the the uh canadian
00:48:59 government taking a stance on theology so they many people have compared uh woke ideology to
00:49:07 some kind of religion that it's a kind of religious thinking it does look as if it's
00:49:11 a kind it's becoming a sort of state sanctioned ideology in canada uh that they are now imposing
00:49:18 now on the armed forces but presumably this is something that is going to have implications
00:49:22 more widely that they may see in other um other parts of the civil service or the country as a
00:49:27 whole i mean think about about it right what they're saying is this is a country of 30 million
00:49:32 people out of a population of billions it's canada's about 150 years old but the trudo
00:49:39 government's only a few years old and it's a party that basically represents fewer than half of the
00:49:43 nation and they are going to tell the oldest grandest religions in the world that have existed
00:49:49 for millennia they represent billions of people what is correct and what's not correct and they're
00:49:53 doing it in the name of inclusive and they're doing it in the name of inclusivity but let there
00:49:57 be no mistake this is so insidious what this means if if a soldier is dying on his deathbed
00:50:03 and require and if he's a deeply committed christian and he calls for a catholic chaplain
00:50:09 they will say no to him that i think is absolutely remarkable state of affairs that we have
00:50:14 it's it's it's religious intolerance and it's state-sanctioned control of religion on that
00:50:20 hideous point we're going to wrap up so thank you very much raif and thank you for watching
00:50:25 please like and subscribe and let us know what you think down in the comments we will see you
00:50:29 next time on newspeak hello if you're enjoying the new culture forum channel and you believe in our
00:50:36 mission may i invite you to join our membership scheme at the link below or on our website
00:50:43 newcultureforum.org.uk our work is more important now than ever and we have great plans ahead for
00:50:51 the future but we can't do it without your support from as little as three pounds per month you can
00:50:56 help ensure that we continue on our mission as a member you'll receive a range of benefits
00:51:03 including access to exclusive content invitations to our private events including here at our
00:51:10 studios, free copies of our books and much much more, including of course our
00:51:16 famous NCF mug. If you aren't able to become a member then please help us by
00:51:22 clicking this button and subscribing to our channel. It's completely free, just
00:51:28 remember to also click the bell icon so that you can get notifications when we
00:51:34 post new videos. Thank you.
00:51:40 You