New Culture Forum - May 05, 2022


How To March BACK Through The Institutions & Regain Control

War on Words: "We Publish What Woke Publishers Won't" - New Publisher Challenges Cancel Culture Abortion, Blair's Legacy 25 Yrs On & Will Canada's Woke Gov't Ban Dying Soldiers Access To Priests

Episode Stats


Length

41 minutes

Words per minute

161.59

Word count

6,778

Sentence count

291


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Great. Thanks very much, Peter. Thanks for organizing such a stimulating event. I'm very
00:00:08 honored to be here. And so today, what I want to talk about is largely some of the measures
00:00:14 that can be taken to try and roll back this march of the cultural left through the institutions.
00:00:21 But I want to begin by talking about what I think is going on more broadly, which is
00:00:26 essentially a cold war, a battle for freedom, not the same battle that we fought in the
00:00:32 second half of the 20th century that many of us will remember, which was about economic
00:00:37 freedom, but this time it's about cultural freedom, and the adversary is cultural socialism.
00:00:45 The idea behind economic socialism, of course, was redistribution of wealth and equalizing
00:00:49 the condition, the material condition of people between the working class and the bourgeoisie.
00:00:56 Cultural socialism is the same idea except transposed onto cultural.
00:01:00 And that is equal outcomes for members of race, gender and sexual identity groups
00:01:06 across all valued positions in society
00:01:09 and protection from harm for these groups
00:01:13 including the most microscopic and imaginary psychological offenses and traumas.
00:01:19 So we have this new battle between cultural freedom and cultural socialism,
00:01:24 the new Cold War. Accompanying this cultural socialism is wokeness, which, as Emma alluded
00:01:30 to, the one-line definition of which is the sacralization of race, gender, and sexual
00:01:38 identities. And so these historically marginalized groups have been made sacred, and so anytime
00:01:43 you say anything that can be construed or manipulated as being in any way offensive
00:01:48 to the sensibilities of the most sensitive member of one of these groups, you have committed
00:01:53 blasphemy. And so we have this cultural socialism with its attendant religion of wokeness. And I
00:02:02 think what's important to understand is in this new Cold War, the cultural socialist side is
00:02:07 rising. You know, we have, yes, we have new groups. We have the Free Speech Union, the New Culture
00:02:12 Forum. We have Academics for Academic Freedom and so on. These new groups are very important.
00:02:19 Yes, we have editorials from The Economist,
00:02:22 The New York Times, Harper's, and so on,
00:02:25 criticizing cancel culture.
00:02:26 That's great, but the idea that somehow this is a blip
00:02:29 is a complete myth,
00:02:31 because that's not the way that culture changes.
00:02:36 If you can imagine being in 1965
00:02:38 and older generations saying,
00:02:40 oh, well, this trend toward people not going to church
00:02:43 or listening to rock music, it's just a blip.
00:02:46 It's just going to go away.
00:02:47 when people are older, they're going to be back in the pews.
00:02:50 Well, that's not the way it turned out
00:02:51 because a lot of change is generational.
00:02:54 People are very open to having their attitudes shifted
00:02:56 when they're in their late teens and early 20s.
00:02:59 Those attitudes, not totally, but largely solidify
00:03:03 and are carried with them as they get older.
00:03:06 And so we should expect to see the attitudes
00:03:08 that we see in today's 20-somethings
00:03:10 transmitted through the institutions as they get older.
00:03:14 And if that's the case, I have some bad news for you,
00:03:16 which is that cultural socialism is only just getting started.
00:03:21 Because these attitudes that would tend to prioritize equal outcomes
00:03:26 for different identity groups over free speech, over reason,
00:03:30 over science, due process, national tradition,
00:03:34 that outlook is much stronger amongst so-called Gen Z and millennials
00:03:39 than it is amongst older generations.
00:03:42 And so I want to show you, if I can get this thing to work.
00:03:45 So this is just an example.
00:03:46 And you can see this in question after question.
00:03:51 And this is sort of cut off, unfortunately, on the top,
00:03:53 but what this is essentially asking people
00:03:55 is whether they support Google's firing
00:03:58 of the computer engineer, James Damore, from his job
00:04:02 for questioning the firm's gender equity ideology
00:04:05 in an internal memo,
00:04:06 just raising questions and counter-arguments.
00:04:09 For that, Damore was fired.
00:04:11 Now, if you ask people under the age of...
00:04:14 in the 18 to 25 age bracket,
00:04:16 in the U.S. or in Britain, two-thirds of them support the decision by this big corporation
00:04:22 to fire James Damore. Two-thirds of 18 to 25-year-olds support Damore's firing, compared
00:04:29 to only about a third of the over 55s in Britain and the United States. So what we're looking
00:04:37 at is a generation that is substantially more amenable to cultural socialism and less amenable
00:04:43 to cultural freedom than older generations.
00:04:45 And they're going to be entering workplaces.
00:04:47 They're going to be emerging into positions of power
00:04:50 where they're going to have control over policy and decision-making.
00:04:53 I think this is a looming catastrophe,
00:04:56 and we should be very clear about the challenge that lies ahead of us.
00:05:00 Because if nothing is done,
00:05:02 our culture of liberty and national tradition
00:05:05 is in danger of being substantially deformed out of all recognition.
00:05:09 so in this talk what I want to do
00:05:12 is to try and talk about some things we may be able to do
00:05:15 to address this problem
00:05:16 because this problem has to become
00:05:18 the number one problem
00:05:20 for conservatives in particular
00:05:22 conservative media
00:05:24 and especially politicians
00:05:26 have got to elevate this cultural struggle
00:05:28 against cultural socialism
00:05:30 the way they did with the issue of
00:05:32 for example leaving the European Union
00:05:34 an issue which was relatively
00:05:36 low priority but which rose up
00:05:38 people's priority lists. This is already happening in the United States in a major way. If you look
00:05:44 at politicians like Glenn Youngkin in Virginia, Ron DeSantis in Florida, who may become the next
00:05:49 presidential, Republican presidential nominee, they have elevated these issues substantially
00:05:55 to the point where amongst Republican voters, culture war issues are now a leading issue for
00:06:02 voters. They're just below immigration and above religion. So they occupy now a very significant
00:06:07 in place, they're deciding elections.
00:06:09 And the important thing about culture war issues
00:06:11 is if you look at public opinion, the public generally
00:06:14 leans two to one in favor of cultural freedom
00:06:18 and against cultural socialism.
00:06:20 And I want to show you a couple of charts that
00:06:22 will reveal that.
00:06:23 Go ahead.
00:06:25 Next slide.
00:06:27 Ah, OK.
00:06:29 Anyway, these are not showing very well.
00:06:32 But what you can see is that the question that is asked here
00:06:36 essentially, is whether to teach children in class
00:06:40 that Britain is a racist society.
00:06:42 Should schoolchildren be taught that Britain is a racist society?
00:06:47 Now, amongst those who identify as on the right,
00:06:50 roughly 7 in 10 are strongly opposed
00:06:53 to teaching schoolchildren that Britain is a racist society.
00:06:57 Amongst those on the left,
00:06:58 only 9% are strongly in favor of teaching children
00:07:03 that Britain is a racist society.
00:07:05 There is a major difference here,
00:07:07 that right-wing voters are largely united
00:07:10 in opposition to critical race theory
00:07:12 and attacks on national heritage.
00:07:15 Left-wing voters are divided.
00:07:18 41% of them oppose teaching children
00:07:20 that Britain is a racist society, for example.
00:07:22 So these issues actually unite the right,
00:07:26 and they divide the left.
00:07:28 Another example.
00:07:29 Next slide, please, whether this will work or not.
00:07:32 So this question is really asking about
00:07:33 the vice chancellor of Sussex University who defended Kathleen Stock's right to free speech
00:07:39 against those who were mobbing her.
00:07:43 And what we see here is that there's a big, big difference between far-left voters,
00:07:50 people who identify as far-left and those who identify as moderate-left.
00:07:54 Amongst those who identify as far-left, 6 in 10 disagreed with the vice chancellor defending Stock,
00:08:00 And amongst those who are moderate left, barely two in ten disagreed with the vice chancellor.
00:08:06 So a much stronger support for freedom, free speech, amongst moderate left than amongst far left.
00:08:11 And again, we see a major division within the left between moderate left and far left,
00:08:17 whereas the right almost completely united.
00:08:20 So here we have a perfect wedge issue for politicians on the right to go after in a big way
00:08:24 because it splits the left and unites the right.
00:08:27 that's what's happening in the United States
00:08:29 and we can see
00:08:31 that that's been
00:08:31 we can see that that's been used very
00:08:35 successfully by politicians
00:08:36 such as Glenn Youngkin and I believe in the future
00:08:39 this will be a very important issue that is helping to
00:08:41 peel voters away from the Democrats
00:08:43 into the Republican fold
00:08:44 so the question really is well what is
00:08:47 the Tory party in Britain
00:08:49 doing? Why are they so timid
00:08:51 on these issues? Now of course there are some
00:08:53 people like Kemi Badnak
00:08:55 Munir Amirza, Oliver Dowden,
00:08:57 there are a few politicians who are willing to speak up on this issue
00:09:00 and to do something about it,
00:09:01 but most of them are running scared of the media,
00:09:04 and they're running scared of progressive institutions
00:09:08 that would accuse them of quote-unquote stoking the culture war,
00:09:11 when in fact actually the culture war is being waged primarily by the left
00:09:15 in elite institutions,
00:09:17 and these are defensive measures attempting to try and counteract
00:09:21 the overwhelming power of cultural socialism,
00:09:25 which is creeping through our elite institutions.
00:09:29 So what I want to talk about next
00:09:31 is what has to happen for this situation to change.
00:09:35 And I think the first thing that actually has to happen
00:09:37 is within the right of the political spectrum,
00:09:40 that the battle against cultural socialism,
00:09:44 these cultural issues have to become
00:09:46 the main reason for being a conservative,
00:09:48 Not reason number five or ten after markets and after foreign policy.
00:09:53 Reason number one.
00:09:55 That is increasingly happening in the United States.
00:09:58 It has to happen here as well.
00:09:59 Because only if that happens, only if conservative parties are actively campaigning on these issues,
00:10:05 are they going to get the profile that they deserve.
00:10:07 And then are we going to be able to take the action that we need to take to address the problem.
00:10:14 So next slide, if we would.
00:10:16 Yeah.
00:10:18 Okay.
00:10:18 So here's just a sort of laundry list of what I think we might be able to do
00:10:24 to try and counteract the influence of cultural socialism in our elite institutions,
00:10:29 which have a role then in shaping the consciousness of younger generations.
00:10:34 The first is we have to abandon this notion that governments shouldn't regulate.
00:10:40 We actually, elected government is the last institution
00:10:44 that reflects the views of the mainstream of the population.
00:10:49 So we need to use government intelligently
00:10:51 to try and reform the unelected and opaque intermediate institutions,
00:10:58 government bodies, monopoly corporations, for example,
00:11:03 that are not accountable and not scrutinized by the media
00:11:07 to anything like the same extent as governments are.
00:11:10 That means we need to have a program for regulating and auditing elite institutions,
00:11:16 beginning, for example, with protection for free speech.
00:11:21 The higher education freedom bill in this country is a good example of that,
00:11:25 where universities not only will be obliged to protect and promote free speech,
00:11:29 but they will be audited on their performance, liable to fines.
00:11:33 People are going to be able to appeal around their universities
00:11:36 in order to weaken the power of the universities,
00:11:38 their ability to enforce cultural socialism on faculty and students
00:11:42 is going to be greatly weakened by this bill.
00:11:45 But, of course, what this requires is that this be sort of sustained,
00:11:50 that the government follow through on its promise
00:11:53 to ensure that free speech is protected
00:11:57 and that the dictates of the Higher Education Freedom Bill
00:12:00 are actually enforced in real time.
00:12:03 It's not enough to make a high-sounding statement
00:12:05 because there are going to be all kinds of attempts
00:12:07 to defy free speech in favor of social justice, so-called.
00:12:11 And so what is very important is that there has now been an office,
00:12:15 the Directorate of Academic Freedom with 10 staff
00:12:18 that will proactively monitor all of the policies of universities
00:12:22 and the way they are implementing them.
00:12:24 In order for that to work, you have to have the right people
00:12:26 who are in these bureaucracies,
00:12:29 who believe in the mission of counteracting this ideological indoctrination,
00:12:33 indoctrination who believe in the mission of making sure these institutions
00:12:36 do not deviate from what they've signed up to and what is in the law so where I
00:12:42 think we have a long way to go our bodies such as the EHRC or Ofcom which
00:12:46 have yet refused to issue guidance telling us exactly when where free
00:12:52 speech is protected and where it is not in terms of so-called hate speech or so
00:12:59 So what we actually need is much clearer guidance on the idea that free speech comes first and
00:13:05 offended sensibilities come second.
00:13:07 That has to be clear across government.
00:13:09 The third thing is political neutrality.
00:13:12 We need to enforce political neutrality across all of these institutions.
00:13:17 And that means, for example, in schools we cannot have critical race theory being taught
00:13:21 to students.
00:13:22 We cannot have political indoctrination occurring in schools.
00:13:26 Now, I know that's the law on the books,
00:13:28 that schools aren't allowed to politically indoctrinate,
00:13:31 but we have a lot of evidence that, in fact,
00:13:32 many of them are doing precisely that.
00:13:34 And in Brighton, for example, when this was,
00:13:37 and some of you will have been involved
00:13:38 in exposing this critical race theory program
00:13:41 that was being pushed in Brighton schools,
00:13:43 Ofsted came in, investigated, and said,
00:13:46 oh, they're not actually politically indoctrinating,
00:13:49 despite the fact that what they were doing
00:13:51 was very much political indoctrination
00:13:52 on critical race theory grounds.
00:13:54 It was blatant.
00:13:55 and yet Ofsted comes in and doesn't enforce what's on the books already,
00:14:01 which says you're not allowed to politically indoctrinate.
00:14:03 So the only way that that chain is going to be maintained
00:14:07 is if we have pressure from the media on government
00:14:09 to enforce political neutrality in these institutions.
00:14:15 And this holds equally for big tech algorithms.
00:14:18 Those should be open to scrutiny from regulators
00:14:21 to ensure that they're not politically biased
00:14:22 and they're treating people equally on the grounds of political ideology.
00:14:25 We need to push for political beliefs to be a protected characteristic alongside race and gender.
00:14:31 What I think we also need is, if we want to talk about equity and diversity and protected characteristics,
00:14:37 I think there should be what's called equivalent action,
00:14:40 that any action an institution takes in terms of gender and race equity
00:14:44 must be matched by action on political and ideology, diversity and equity.
00:14:48 So in universities, if they're really worried about racial underrepresentation,
00:14:51 They've got to be doing equally as much on the under-representation of conservatives, for example, on university faculties, who are outnumbered around 9 to 1, by the way, in the social sciences and humanities.
00:15:06 So that's a much bigger issue than the very slight inequities on race and gender.
00:15:12 It's very important for people who are against cultural socialism to be placed in government positions on these regulatory bodies.
00:15:21 People who believe in the mission of fighting back against wokeness
00:15:24 need to be in these positions, on these bodies,
00:15:27 so that they can enforce freedom of speech, political neutrality,
00:15:31 and so that they can bring some balance, for example, to the school curriculum
00:15:34 so that kids learn as much about Stalin and the Cultural Revolution
00:15:39 as they do about Jim Crow and the Nazis.
00:15:42 It needs to be balanced, and it's not balanced right now,
00:15:45 and that's something that we very much need to see.
00:15:48 In order to get there, I'm afraid that the anti-woke conservative side
00:15:53 is dramatically underpowered.
00:15:54 It needs to get its people into elite institutions.
00:15:57 But in order to do that, it needs to develop talent
00:16:00 and develop a pipeline for getting people who are on board
00:16:03 with this fight against cultural socialism into those elite institutions.
00:16:08 In the U.S., with the Supreme Court,
00:16:11 there is an institution called the Federalist Society
00:16:13 that vets and nurtures conservative graduates of law schools
00:16:19 who will be selected to be judges in the United States
00:16:23 and ultimately selected to the Supreme Court.
00:16:25 We need that kind of organization in order to nurture talent
00:16:30 and get those people into the government bureaucracy,
00:16:33 into schools, into universities, and so forth.
00:16:37 So nurturing a policy network and nurturing talent
00:16:40 to enter the bureaucracy.
00:16:41 You also need to be able to hold conservative politicians, in particular, to account when they simply ignore cultural issues or, in fact, take the woke side on these issues.
00:16:53 Now, again, I don't agree with a lot of what the National Rifle Association does in the U.S.
00:16:58 I disagree with a lot of their stances.
00:17:00 But they are extremely effective.
00:17:02 And what they do is they rate members of Congress on their record on these issues.
00:17:08 And I actually think MPs should be rated, for example, on their record on cultural war issues.
00:17:12 And they should be held scrutinized and held to account if they are not doing anything about these issues.
00:17:21 And so I think greater scrutiny of conservative MPs to the point where we can see deselection of MPs
00:17:27 that are not on board with combating cultural socialism sufficiently,
00:17:32 I think that would be a very effective way of instilling some focus in the conservative party
00:17:37 and making it a little bit more attentive to this issue.
00:17:43 And then, of course, it's not just the conservatives.
00:17:46 If conservative parties can win on culture war issues,
00:17:50 that is going to throw parties of the left on the defensive,
00:17:53 and it's going to empower the more sensible liberal leftists.
00:17:57 And I'm thinking in the U.S. of commentators like Matthew Iglesias, for example,
00:18:01 or people like James Carville,
00:18:04 people who are telling the Democrats,
00:18:06 look, we're not going to win elections
00:18:07 if we keep pushing this woke garbage.
00:18:09 We've got to get back to a more sensible center.
00:18:12 We have to endorse patriotism.
00:18:14 Those are the kinds of people on the left
00:18:16 that we need to empower,
00:18:17 but they're not going to be empowered
00:18:18 unless the right starts winning elections
00:18:21 and forcing the left to change.
00:18:24 So again, these are just some ideas that I've had,
00:18:27 and then of course what Emma says,
00:18:28 this idea of everyday resistance,
00:18:30 you know, don't accept new buzzwords
00:18:32 and challenge new policies. I think that's
00:18:34 very important as well. But I also
00:18:36 think there's a lot we can do politically
00:18:37 to sort of change the
00:18:39 mood music that is
00:18:42 really setting the agenda in politics.
00:18:44 Okay.
00:18:44 Thank you very much.
00:19:00 Eric, before we turn to the audience, I just want to ask you, your very last point there,
00:19:06 and you said that the right have got to start winning elections.
00:19:10 Could I suggest that that seems to be such a difficult thing for them to do, to take on these issues.
00:19:17 And if you look back to Brexit, in fact, it was pressure from pressure groups.
00:19:23 Okay, UKIP was a political party, but it was a sort of pressure group to start with.
00:19:29 Don't you think that the pressure has got to come from outside now?
00:19:32 I mean, in other words, to fight the Tories.
00:19:35 When it comes to the Tories, it seems to me that being fearful of losing their electoral seats
00:19:41 is the thing that tends to bring them on board.
00:19:44 No?
00:19:45 Yes, you are right.
00:19:47 So I think there's certainly an opening for a third force, a similar type of third force,
00:19:52 that can raise these issues and sort of hold the government to account
00:19:56 or hold the Tories to account.
00:19:58 and might lead to a sort of reforming impulse within their ranks.
00:20:02 So, yeah, I think it's not incompatible with what I'm saying,
00:20:06 that there needs to be that kind of pressure to force people to sort of reform.
00:20:11 Okay. Oh, lots of questions.
00:20:13 Sorry.
00:20:14 Al-Mileth, Chairman of Migration Watch.
00:20:17 Eric, terrific, as usual.
00:20:20 Thanks.
00:20:20 Common sense of a right-wing academic.
00:20:24 You're a rare breed, my friend.
00:20:28 You haven't mentioned, and indeed in the course of this morning, terrific morning, Peter, thank you for arranging it.
00:20:38 It's about time that the right started getting its act together.
00:20:43 Thank you.
00:20:45 Migration, my area, hasn't really been mentioned.
00:20:51 And yet, a lot of the fodder, what is being fed into the whole debate about cultural socialism, the culture wars, stems from the mass immigration that we've experienced over the last 20 years in particular.
00:21:13 so that now ethnic minorities, the group that I'm in, form over 20% of the population in this country.
00:21:26 And this has happened in the space of 20 years, as I say, when it has actually doubled.
00:21:33 how do we um actually make the case for lower levels of immigration something that migration
00:21:45 watch has been um attempting to do for many many years and i believe has won the argument
00:21:51 on that all of a sudden we find that it's being pushed by the very people who not so long ago
00:22:01 were trying to reduce it.
00:22:04 The Prime Minister announced only a few days ago
00:22:07 that he was going to open up more routes
00:22:10 for people to come from India to work here.
00:22:16 My concern really is that migration
00:22:21 is actually feeding the war
00:22:25 and secondly that the government has managed to focus attention
00:22:33 on what is going on in the channel
00:22:35 while people are actually forgetting about almost the fact
00:22:42 that we are now at the levels of net migration
00:22:47 that we have seen at their highest really for some years.
00:22:55 I think you take that first.
00:22:57 Yeah, I mean, it's a really good question.
00:22:59 I think my own view is actually that migration per se
00:23:03 has not necessarily been a big driver for wokeness.
00:23:07 So what I think is, in fact, the relationship is that
00:23:09 wokeness has shut down the ability to have a discussion about migration, in a way.
00:23:14 Because, you know, if you talk about immigration,
00:23:18 then they can associate you with being a racist,
00:23:20 which means they don't have to discuss numbers, right?
00:23:23 So I think that's sort of the relationship.
00:23:25 Now, of course, what happens with migration is, you know, you have a population.
00:23:28 Some people want ethnic change.
00:23:31 A lot of people want it to be slower.
00:23:33 So you get a division, and the people who want it to be slower say,
00:23:36 hey, where's our political voice?
00:23:38 And when a political voice pops up to represent that view,
00:23:41 it's shouted down as racist, right?
00:23:43 So there is a sort of, to some degree, the diversity interacts
00:23:47 with what's already this rising wokeness to produce polarization.
00:23:51 That's, I think, the main result of what you're talking about.
00:23:54 Now, migration levels, from what I can tell, are at historic highs now in Britain.
00:23:59 So you're absolutely right that the government, which, I mean, migration was the main reason for voting Brexit.
00:24:06 The Tories came in on Brexit votes, and in fact what they are doing is enabling very high levels of migration.
00:24:13 But that's another example of what I'm talking about with regard to cultural socialism,
00:24:16 is that the more cultural socialism is dominant,
00:24:20 the more that any topic that touches on race or gender or sexuality is off-limits,
00:24:25 whether that's family, crime, migration, you name it.
00:24:29 All of these debates become very, very difficult,
00:24:32 and mainstream politicians don't want to touch them,
00:24:34 which is why only populist politicians are generally comfortable on this terrain.
00:24:38 So this is interacting very much with your concerns,
00:24:42 Because the stronger cultural socialism is, the more reluctant politicians are going to be to address concerns of the average person, and the less we're going to get on top of migration.
00:24:53 I hope I answered your question.
00:24:54 So, yeah, with regards to point six about getting conservatives into the bureaucracy, how do we do that when a lot of the institutions, the NHS, for example, asks that applicants actively promote diversity as a condition of getting those jobs?
00:25:11 And with regards to political neutrality, how do you suggest we sort of counter the counter-argument that, well, it's not political if it's not just in relation to a particular party?
00:25:24 Yeah, and I think this is where a committed conservative party or conservative movement that was really committed to fighting cultural socialism would push much harder and with much greater scrutiny on, for example, number three, political neutrality.
00:25:39 So if the NHS introduces equity and diversity statements, the government, it's one phone call, that's got to go right now.
00:25:49 That's what I'm talking about. Stonewall, out of every government institution.
00:25:53 Any government funded institution, please disaffiliate now.
00:25:57 That's what I'm talking about really, is that by setting the terrain on free speech,
00:26:01 so for example, forcing people to sign an EDI statement is a violation of freedom of conscience.
00:26:07 It's number two, free speech, freedom of expression, freedom of conscience.
00:26:12 So a government that was serious about this, that was developing talent,
00:26:16 and what the government would be doing is it's sort of placing people who shared this view into these government bodies
00:26:23 where they would essentially push reforms.
00:26:26 If they were resisted, the government would have to either replace more people
00:26:29 or simply increase the fines or issue guidance.
00:26:33 I mean, this is what I'm talking about with getting serious about regulating and intervening in these institutions in a much, much more purposeful way, covered by the media.
00:26:43 So celebrating or making very clear they wanted to resist us, we told them no, this has to be in the press, people have to become aware of it, and this has to become important for how they vote.
00:26:55 So all of these things have to happen, I think, because ultimately these institutions are just going to replicate themselves and push to the left.
00:27:02 it's sort of conquest law right
00:27:04 these institutions will always recruit their own
00:27:06 and drift in that cultural socialist
00:27:08 direction unless actively resisted
00:27:10 I think there is something
00:27:12 called Sullivan's Law
00:27:13 Sullivan's Law
00:27:15 something automatically becomes
00:27:17 left wing over time if it's not
00:27:20 explicitly right wing
00:27:21 this gentleman here sorry been very patient
00:27:24 thank you very much
00:27:28 Nicholas Beecroft founder of the
00:27:30 Future of Western Civilization Project
00:27:32 which I've started just after 9-11 to try and work out
00:27:37 how do we defend and rejuvenate our civilization
00:27:40 and as a psychiatrist my approach to that really was to
00:27:44 do what Emma's done, do what you've done
00:27:47 and really look into the toxic pathology of this
00:27:50 and try and work out how to turn it around
00:27:52 spent years doing that from within the elite
00:27:55 from within the institutions you're talking about
00:27:58 and in a sense it's simple, it's dehumanization
00:28:02 it's cultural Marxism, it's relativism, it's victim mentality and naivety as well.
00:28:10 But anyway, after years of trying to work out how to do that
00:28:13 and work out how do you persuade what I call the post-modern bigot
00:28:17 to see the errors of their ways, after years of banging my head,
00:28:22 I realize it's incredibly difficult and I probably only ever converted about two people.
00:28:27 But I wrote a couple of books on the subject
00:28:29 and probably after 15 years
00:28:32 I realized that there were two big things
00:28:34 that I missed
00:28:35 and I'm interested in what both of you think
00:28:39 one is the
00:28:40 confidence required
00:28:42 to push back
00:28:44 in other words
00:28:45 the core pillars of western civilization
00:28:48 of capitalism
00:28:50 of freedom
00:28:51 of science etc
00:28:54 actually requires
00:28:57 you to believe
00:28:58 at the very least in the sacredness of the human spirit if not god um and religion basically well
00:29:06 god really so in other words um that's the authority on sorry that's the foundation on
00:29:11 which our authority rests to actually say all these things and and so i'm interested in what
00:29:17 you think about that and the second part which i've only realized in the last couple of years
00:29:22 after 20 years of this is that i always try to understand how is it that all the big corporations
00:29:29 are behind what's obviously a marxist project whose goal is to destroy a civilization and when
00:29:36 you look at what just happened in the american election and when you look at what just happened
00:29:40 with covid and all of that i realized that um the big corporations funded by people like vanguard
00:29:47 Black Rock, etc., are actually doing it, funding it, because they make money out of it.
00:29:54 And so if we're going to push back, the punchline is we need God, or at least human spirit,
00:30:00 and we actually need to get right to the core of the people funding it.
00:30:04 If we don't do that, we won't win.
00:30:05 Thank you so much.
00:30:12 Well, I think there's a lot there, and a lot there I agree with.
00:30:17 I mean, one thing, however, I would say is I think that with Marxism, this is not really about money and economics as much as I think some people.
00:30:25 I mean, my own view, you can take a view that corporations are doing this to make money.
00:30:31 They're supporting wokeness to make money.
00:30:33 My own view is actually it probably costs them.
00:30:35 I mean, you just have to look at Disney, for example.
00:30:37 I think this is more, I think the model I would use is more like a mind virus, which is transmitted like COVID.
00:30:43 and it's seeped into a lot of these elite spaces
00:30:47 because these are graduates of elite universities
00:30:49 where the virus is most strong.
00:30:51 I don't actually think it's in the interests
00:30:53 of a lot of these companies
00:30:54 to do what they're doing, actually.
00:30:57 And in many cases, some of them have taken a bath
00:30:59 because of these stances,
00:31:01 but they can't resist their young staffers,
00:31:03 these Gen Z and millennials
00:31:04 who I've been showing you on these graphs
00:31:06 who have these different attitudes
00:31:07 coming into the workplace, pushing their activism.
00:31:11 And the leaders of these companies
00:31:13 don't know how to respond, so they cave in.
00:31:15 But the other thing I should say is that
00:31:17 I think they're also somewhat sympathetic.
00:31:19 Anything that is wrapped in a nice
00:31:21 candy wrapper that says equity, diversity,
00:31:23 anti-racism, they're going to
00:31:25 buy because they aren't willing to
00:31:27 unwrap the candy and see exactly
00:31:29 how toxic it is. And that's
00:31:31 part of the challenge is that
00:31:32 the cultural socialism trades
00:31:35 under different labels and it
00:31:36 wraps itself in nice-sounding
00:31:39 things that you can't begin. It's like being
00:31:41 against a puppy, you know?
00:31:42 Emma was talking earlier
00:31:47 about what we could do on a daily basis
00:31:49 with these corporations
00:31:50 one thing we can do is boycott
00:31:53 we just simply stop buying
00:31:55 Ben and Jerry's ice cream
00:31:56 eventually they'll get the message
00:31:59 eventually because it's the bottom line
00:32:00 I want to ask you before someone else comes in
00:32:03 the other
00:32:05 possible route
00:32:06 and this is one that's coming up more and more
00:32:09 and I believe is that we have to start
00:32:11 building our own institutions.
00:32:13 In other words, these
00:32:15 are beyond reform.
00:32:17 I mean, do you think that's why, in America
00:32:19 we now have colleges, don't we, like
00:32:21 Hillsdale College, and there's one in
00:32:23 Austin, you know, where Catherine Stock's going
00:32:25 to. Isn't this a
00:32:27 real option, you know, to actually
00:32:29 start doing something positive,
00:32:31 you know, rather than, as you say,
00:32:33 banging your head on the brick wall for years?
00:32:35 Yeah, I mean, I think
00:32:37 that it's very important to start
00:32:39 new institutions, but I'm
00:32:41 more skeptical about, I mean, I'm involved in the University of Austin, for example,
00:32:46 and I think it's a great venture.
00:32:48 Can you tell us a bit about that?
00:32:50 Yeah, yeah.
00:32:51 Well, this is sort of a new university in Austin, Texas,
00:32:56 which is intending to be a sort of free speech, open inquiry university.
00:33:00 It's not going to have equity and diversity.
00:33:02 It's not going to have all of the bureaucracy, and so it intends,
00:33:05 and it's going to be cheaper because it doesn't have these layers of bureaucracy.
00:33:09 And I think that's very important.
00:33:11 But I think the problem is that, you know, an institution with sort of 350 years behind it,
00:33:17 like Harvard or Oxford, or with the prestige and the alumni,
00:33:21 and it's just very, very, very difficult.
00:33:24 The university system is what we would call, it benefits from network effects,
00:33:30 so it's like Google or Facebook.
00:33:32 The more users, the more you have to use it, and so it sort of builds on itself.
00:33:37 And I think it's just very difficult for new entrants to reform these systems.
00:33:42 I actually think, now I think that's different when it comes to culture, media,
00:33:46 which is more of a free market, easier to enter.
00:33:49 Universities, very hard to enter and disrupt.
00:33:52 And so I think we have to rely on government regulation
00:33:55 rather than bottom-up disruption for a lot of these institutions.
00:33:59 I'd say the same about Facebook and Twitter,
00:34:01 which are essentially common carrier monopolies.
00:34:03 and common carrier monopoly there's not going to be another Facebook or Twitter anytime soon
00:34:08 and therefore we need to go for regulation rather than disruption from below
00:34:12 thank you I wanted to question the term cultural socialism and really question whether it's cultural
00:34:19 socialism or cultural liberalism because you know I'm skeptical of the idea that there's
00:34:25 these sort of like you know Gramsciites you know going through institutions and trying to create
00:34:31 the proletarian revolution and not
00:34:33 really what we're really seeing is a sort
00:34:35 of like liberal managerial
00:34:37 class you know seeping through the universities
00:34:39 and then infecting the
00:34:41 institutions that way because we need to
00:34:43 get the terms right
00:34:45 because I think this all cultural Marxist
00:34:47 cultural socialist terminology
00:34:49 is a bit outdated
00:34:51 it's not completely accurate
00:34:53 to the ideology of
00:34:55 the people who are infecting our institutions
00:34:57 because they're not really you know
00:34:59 Marxists or socialists in the traditional
00:35:01 sense, they're, you know, progressive liberals, you know, they're, you know, from leafy middle
00:35:05 class suburbs in London or the home counties, you know, that, you know, yes, they may have
00:35:11 these Gramsciite ideal of, like, you know, take over the institutions and so forth, but
00:35:17 whether, you know, they're cultural socialists and Marxists, I think that's really up for
00:35:21 debate.
00:35:22 Yeah, I just want to come back on that, and I think, here's the thing, is I think we're
00:35:28 so used to thinking about socialism in terms of unions and class and proletarian revolution
00:35:34 and all the Marxist things, the materialist socialism.
00:35:39 And I think what I'm talking, the reason I use the term socialism is I'm harking back
00:35:43 to sort of utopian socialism and Christian socialism, which is more cultural, more moralistic.
00:35:49 That is really more the ancestor of today's cultural socialism than Marxism.
00:35:55 And so it isn't a contradiction to be an economic capitalist, but a cultural socialist.
00:36:00 So economically, you kind of believe in free markets.
00:36:03 You believe in living well.
00:36:05 You want to get your kid into Harvard.
00:36:08 But culturally, what you believe is, well, no, there can't be any gaps between men and women or black and white in the boardroom, in wealth, in whatever.
00:36:17 So you are a socialist in the sense of wanting to see equality of outcome, of result.
00:36:22 wanting to protect from harm the oppressed.
00:36:26 And that's what I mean by socialism,
00:36:28 not material connotations about command and control
00:36:32 and instituting a workers' revolution.
00:36:35 And the reason I don't think cultural liberalism is what we're talking about
00:36:39 is, in fact, cultural socialism is very much anti-liberal.
00:36:43 It is anti-free speech, it is anti-due process,
00:36:46 it is anti-equal treatment, it is anti-science.
00:36:48 All the things which I think I would associate with classical liberalism
00:36:52 are in fact in opposition.
00:36:54 So that's why I would say cultural socialism
00:36:56 is, in my view, the clearest term
00:36:59 for identifying the problem that we're facing.
00:37:02 One of the things that I was aware of,
00:37:04 you get a constant diet every day
00:37:06 of in this institution, that institution.
00:37:10 I wonder whether it would be useful
00:37:11 to draw up some sort of map of woke institutions.
00:37:15 Who's in them? Who appoints them?
00:37:17 How are they funded? How often is it done?
00:37:20 What is it that they're producing?
00:37:21 what are the rules and regulations etc
00:37:23 and then for example
00:37:25 you've had the Save Our Statues
00:37:26 you could link them all together in a map
00:37:29 and different campaign groups
00:37:30 and start bagging some FOIs in
00:37:33 if you start asking the British
00:37:34 decolonise this
00:37:36 what about your Arab slave trade monuments
00:37:39 your Ottoman slave trade
00:37:40 your African slave trade
00:37:41 are you doing anything about that
00:37:42 or is it just the European slave trade
00:37:44 so that's the question
00:37:45 and just one very quick point on unconscious bias
00:37:48 we had that at my employer
00:37:50 keep that a little bit discreet, but what I went and did, I did some research on it,
00:37:54 found the studies on it, there was a great government link to the studies
00:37:58 and how they said it's not recommended for the public sector, the privates,
00:38:04 and it was failed, and I actually put that up on screen at the end of a presentation on it,
00:38:09 and the response? Silence.
00:38:11 There's no big woke horror story that comes for you.
00:38:14 You just sit and they are, the woke, many of them are absolute wusses,
00:38:18 And what you do find afterwards is that a lot of people say, oh, great, I'm glad you put it up.
00:38:26 So it's going to be a lot of small things going back to your organizations, politely, factually,
00:38:32 and then you just watch the silence and it tells you everything.
00:38:36 And just a very quick plug, James Lindsay's new Discourses website.
00:38:40 If you have a look on that, you know, the extent to which he's broken down in videos, in papers,
00:38:46 breaking down work at its origins is an absolute goldmine for anybody who's opposing this very
00:38:53 very helpful point thank you sir well well just just really quickly what i will say i mean i think
00:38:57 that map would be interesting i mean there is a sim there is a sort of loose group of activists
00:39:02 who are networked on twitter who know each other who are involved in a number of different
00:39:06 organizations but for the most part i think this is very much like covid it's like a bottom-up
00:39:10 virus, that once it captures your mind, you can convert other people. And these people
00:39:16 are in these organizations. They are twice as prevalent amongst Gen Z, at least twice
00:39:22 as prevalent. So the younger employees are going to be a lot more woke, and this is one
00:39:25 of the problems. But if you look at an institution like universities, which I've studied, but
00:39:30 even other institutions, you have maybe 10 or 20% that are true believers in this stuff.
00:39:37 And then you have sort of a 50% in the middle,
00:39:39 and then you have sort of 40% to 50% opponents.
00:39:42 And that's sort of the structure,
00:39:44 but that 10% to 20% true believers
00:39:46 really can leverage their small numbers
00:39:48 by essentially raising taboos around racism.
00:39:53 Oh, you're against what we're doing,
00:39:55 you must be a racist or a transphobe or a sexist or whatever.
00:39:58 So they're able to weaponize these taboos,
00:40:00 which essentially gives them sort of forced multiplication.
00:40:04 And they're also able to wrap their cultural socialism in these nice sounding labels like
00:40:08 equity and diversity, which a lot of the people in that middle 50 think, oh, well, what could
00:40:13 be wrong with a policy that's just trying to help people?
00:40:16 And so they'll fall in line because they kind of believe in, you know, protecting weak people,
00:40:22 fragile people from harm.
00:40:23 And so these are the dynamics we see in institution after institution.
00:40:27 There's only a small group of true believers, but their power is magnified hugely by these
00:40:33 processes eric thank you very very much
00:40:44 hello if you're enjoying the new culture forum channel
00:40:48 and you believe in our mission may i invite you to
00:40:52 join our membership scheme at the link below
00:40:55 or on our website newcultureforum.org.uk
00:41:00 Our work is more important now than ever and we have great plans ahead for the future but we
00:41:05 can't do it without your support. From as little as three pounds per month you can help ensure
00:41:11 that we continue on our mission. As a member you'll receive a range of benefits including
00:41:17 access to exclusive content, invitations to our private events including here at our studios,
00:41:24 free copies of our books and much much more including of course our famous NCF
00:41:31 mug. If you aren't able to become a member then please help us by clicking
00:41:37 this button and subscribing to our channel. It's completely free, just
00:41:42 remember to also click the bell icon so that you can get notifications when we
00:41:47 post new videos. Thank you.
00:41:54 You