New Culture Forum - May 03, 2022


War on Words: "We Publish What Woke Publishers Won't" - New Publisher Challenges Cancel Culture

The War On Whiteness & The West - Murray's Brave New Book Exposes How We're Taught To Hate Ourselves How To March BACK Through The Institutions & Regain Control

Episode Stats


Length

43 minutes

Words per minute

197.77

Word count

8,577

Sentence count

89


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to So What You're Saying Is, I'm Peter Whittle. Now as you know if you've been
00:00:24 watching the channel for a long time the New Culture Forum was based on the idea that we
00:00:29 should challenge orthodoxies wherever they are in the academic world, in the publishing world,
00:00:36 in the media and indeed in the political world. So I'm delighted to see a new publishing imprint
00:00:42 which is started called Forum whose sole aim in fact is to publish people who don't necessarily
00:00:50 fit into these orthodoxies and it's been the man behind it is with me now my guest this week
00:00:58 george owers uh george thank you very much for joining first of all i should say forum it's
00:01:03 called forum yeah uh it's just started no connection to new culture forum i might add
00:01:08 what is the aim well i think that we see um that i mean it's not just in publishing it's in all
00:01:14 kinds of areas as you kind of alluded to but publishing is as good an example as any that um
00:01:19 the views represented by the people who run it and therefore the things that they produce are
00:01:24 a very narrow range generally they tend to be restricted to people of broadly i don't know
00:01:29 what you'd call it kind of progressive left liberal left kind of um attitude and authors
00:01:35 that don't fit into this very easily on all kinds of grounds i mean not just people on the right but
00:01:40 people who are kind of awkward leftists who have kind of fallen foul of their own side what you
00:01:45 might call kind of enlightenment liberals who are rather aghast at some of the things that are going
00:01:49 on in terms of the kind of extremities of id politics and so on um are refusing finding that
00:01:55 they're you know if they have a publisher their publishers are getting a bit antsy about retaining
00:02:00 them um or you know often they've struggled to get published in the first place and you know
00:02:04 we're there to try to you know sign the people who are you know original voices who have something
00:02:09 genuinely interesting and rigorous to say but who you know are currently shut out from that culture
00:02:15 um you know where the publishing is dominated by a relatively small number of large companies
00:02:19 and you know i mean i would say that historically there has always been uh publishing has always
00:02:25 had a kind of liberal left bias for many decades it's not a new thing but what has changed or is
00:02:31 increasingly changing is that the big presses um used to you know they were liberals more emphasis
00:02:37 on the liberal part of that and they were quite willing to publish you know wider range of voices
00:02:42 conservatives right-wingers you know mavericks of all kinds and increasingly a culture that you only
00:02:49 put you you know certain areas quite large swathes of public debate are kind of out of
00:02:54 bounds and you get kind of for example a lot of younger people who work in publishing who are
00:03:00 very kind of censorious they don't like the idea of publishing people who you know basically they
00:03:05 don't agree with they strongly disagree with and so it's becoming the monoculture of publishing
00:03:09 is becoming more and more of a problem um yeah yeah i wonder why it is it does seem to be
00:03:16 particularly publishing actually i mean you know as you say it's always been what i would call
00:03:22 sort of traditionally hampstead left if you like uh whereas now it seems to be
00:03:30 one of the most restrictive areas i wonder why it attracts as you mentioned those young people
00:03:37 who particularly don't like publishing things they don't agree with?
00:03:41 That's a good question.
00:03:42 I mean, obviously, the people who go into publishing
00:03:45 are overwhelmingly arts, social science graduates from universities.
00:03:49 And I think you've seen a general trend
00:03:50 whereby younger people, graduates in those kind of areas,
00:03:54 partly it's kind of a problem for universities as much as anything,
00:03:58 if you trace it back, who are used to not being challenged to...
00:04:03 know academia is in many cases more of a kind of activist uh enterprise more than it is a you know
00:04:09 a kind of critical learning debate and so on kind of enterprises as it should be and i suppose i
00:04:14 mean i would say i suppose that the people i mean publishing is not renowned for its high wages
00:04:18 uh and it's you know it's it's the kind of thing that you the the quite clever people who've been
00:04:24 to university go to and they you know the the the immediate rewards are obviously quite limited and
00:04:29 And I think that breed of younger radicalised people who are kind of, I mean, you might
00:04:36 almost say that they're kind of the product of elite overproduction, they find themselves
00:04:44 quite, you know, not doing that well in the social economic structure, but they have very
00:04:48 big ambitions and they've been very well educated.
00:04:50 And those kind of people were the people who were like the most vocal Corbynites, for example.
00:04:58 the same kind of like social group age and demographic and educational group that that
00:05:04 fueled corbinism and you know younger people in publishing tend to be very much from that that
00:05:09 area um i mean that said i don't if the problem is not just young people in publishing um it's also
00:05:16 the fact that i think the bigger problem is the spine you know often the kind of relative
00:05:19 spinelessness of the more senior people who should know better really um who are afraid of you know
00:05:26 they're afraid of backlash on social media they're afraid i mean my personal theory is that a lot of
00:05:31 them is more about the fact that they they don't want to be kind of alienated amongst their peer
00:05:36 group they don't they you know it's kind of you know they don't want people um giving them funny
00:05:41 looks at dinner parties in islington and and so on um but you know that said i mean obviously this
00:05:46 is all this is the case and we want to provide a new outlet for this but you know i should i don't
00:05:52 of make it more more positive than just all the publishing industry is terrible you know the
00:05:56 publishing industry has good still has good people it still has good editors at other other other
00:06:00 firms though they're increasingly finding it difficult they're finding um you know i mean i
00:06:04 won't i don't think it's really good form to mention names but i know of a number of incidents
00:06:08 where people have good editors have been basically have had their projects stopped by senior
00:06:14 management who've got very uh kind of um because you know the the first sign of any backlash they
00:06:20 get very um nervous about it and they can't and then and then so then and this process is getting
00:06:25 worse and i think the good editors in some of the bigger presses are increasingly finding
00:06:29 uh the atmosphere constrained and difficult um um but yeah well i want to also i want to emphasize
00:06:35 that you know we want to be positive we want to publish original new thinkers you know really
00:06:40 important ideas in a positive way to contribute positively to the debate rather than just slagging
00:06:44 off the rest of the publishing industry you know i i remember actually simply i'm not mentioning
00:06:49 names blow i spoke to a publisher last year quite a quite a from a big publishing house and um he
00:06:56 very much wanted to try to span out and to to widen things but it was so timid and it was almost sort
00:07:03 of like it was almost been along the lines of we want to prove that you don't have to be bad to
00:07:09 write this you know if you've written a book says this or that it doesn't mean you're bad but it
00:07:14 It was terribly apologetic.
00:07:16 So consequently, I don't think anything's happened.
00:07:18 No.
00:07:19 I think it has a lot to do with status, personally.
00:07:22 I think that certain opinions and certain political viewpoints
00:07:25 are seen as very low status, as very kind of...
00:07:29 It's a sort of snobbery involved, I think.
00:07:31 Well, Brexit.
00:07:32 Brexit is the obvious example.
00:07:34 The tendency to categorise anybody who voted Leave
00:07:37 as some kind of idiot from the sticks
00:07:39 who probably has no education, is stupid,
00:07:44 or you know it's very patronizing um and therefore you know publishing anything which
00:07:49 you know deviates from the kind of normal polite consensus is seen as being you know terribly you
00:07:55 know declassé darling you know that kind of thing and um you know and i think it's it's silly it's
00:08:00 it's very similar silly attitude because you you know any culture which ends up so dominated by a
00:08:06 small number of opinions becomes you know infested with groupthink and that's never it's not a healthy
00:08:12 thing for a wider culture you need to um you know orthodoxies to be challenged so that you can
00:08:17 even if you know even if you want them to be strengthened you need them to be challenged i
00:08:21 mean you know what is it a cloistered and fugitive virtue you know as milton talked about is you
00:08:27 know it's not worth it's not worth anything it um so you know and i think it reveals a weird kind
00:08:32 of lack of security because if you're very confident in your ideas then you'd welcome
00:08:37 scrutiny and you'd welcome alternative voices um there's no reason to shy away from it um
00:08:43 so you know let's let's bring it on as well so with that with that in mind we're looking
00:08:49 to the future i mean you have how what have you what what have you already published i suppose
00:08:55 you haven't you haven't published anything yet have you or you sure you've been a short time
00:08:58 so the first book to publish in the forum imprint is um woke racism by john mcwater which is a book
00:09:04 that's the American we bought yeah we bought the rights from the UK rights for that and um so that's
00:09:09 not a book that we've actually commissioned from scratch but and that obviously addresses
00:09:13 the kind of the US um context but you know it's very relevant to those kind of racial debates
00:09:18 are very much becoming current in Britain but um I mean sorry what is the woke racism I know
00:09:23 John McWhirter in the book but just for people who necessarily haven't heard of it he's basically
00:09:28 what is his basic premise in that book well his basic argument is that actually the the kind of
00:09:34 premises of a lot of you know progressive left um attitudes towards race in america reveal i
00:09:40 suppose what you'd call a kind of racism of low expectations um and you know it's the kind of
00:09:46 a patronizing um approach which actually doesn't help hasn't actually helped um african americans
00:09:52 i mean a lot of the you know kind of programs attempts to you know engineer social engineering
00:09:59 positive discrimination all these things that mean they're actually they can be done and also
00:10:04 lowering standards like lower there's an argument that i mean it more extreme and there's there's an
00:10:09 argument that you know things like litter good good written english literacy are you know white
00:10:14 uh constructs and therefore you should lower standards in order to widen access to and of
00:10:19 course the obvious reports from someone like john mcwater who is a highly educated black man is
00:10:23 well we don't need the standards lowered we're perfectly capable what you know it's almost
00:10:28 saying that you know this is a kind of reverse racism um um you know you're saying that basically
00:10:34 they're saying that they did black people or can't be expected to reach the stand you know
00:10:39 good standards or you know in things that are fairly objective like you know literacy numeracy
00:10:44 you know educational standards in general and and and i think that clearly applies to
00:10:50 britain but we you know and so we that's the first book we've probably published but i mean
00:10:54 mean we've got quite a few people signed up so um i mean are you expecting i could i for years
00:11:02 yes yeah you know if i had a dollar for every aspiring author who said oh i can't i won't get
00:11:08 published with this i won't get much of that i mean are you expecting i would have thought you
00:11:12 would have quite a market of people who pretty much have given up the whole idea of trying to
00:11:17 get published i mean not because they're so outrageous but because you know the whole tenor
00:11:22 of the times is such that they just don't even bother yeah i mean i think it's also it's it's
00:11:27 people who are i suppose broadly speaking in various respects on the right um but it's also
00:11:32 like people who are kind of mavericks on the left um you know so for example i worked for another
00:11:39 press before i i came to to help set up forum and um i worked for polity press and i published
00:11:46 paul emery's book there for example if you're paul emery's book was despised about the white
00:11:51 Yeah, why the modern left hates the white working class. And, you know, Paul is undoubtedly a left-winger by any same standards.
00:11:59 I mean, in terms of economic, social democratic kind of policies and so on, you know, he is very much a man of the left.
00:12:05 But because he, you know, he's quite critical of a number of kind of the kind of progressive left package on particular cultural politics, as it's become, you know,
00:12:14 You know, he's been often attacked for being a right-winger or even among the more kind of outlandish realms of social media.
00:12:21 You know, he'd be accused of being a fascist, a red-brown fascist and things like that.
00:12:27 And, you know, I don't want Forum to just publish, I don't want us to become as narrow by just publishing, you know, people of another narrow band of views.
00:12:35 My challenge would be, you know, the left used to believe in free speech because, in fact, they used to be the progenitors of arguments for free speech because for a very good reason, because they appreciate that when you're in an unpopular position or you're in a minority, then you need the protection of free speech more than anybody.
00:12:53 Yeah. And so, you know, I would say that, you know, we want to publish left wing people if they've got something genuinely interesting and original to say that isn't just kind of reheating, you know, kind of what we've all become very familiar with in kind of current arguments, you know, if they want to challenge, you know, to challenge their own kind of natural audiences preconceptions and they want to make an argument which they think will, you know, fall outside the boundaries of what's become a very attenuated view of left wing progressivism, then come to us.
00:13:23 because we'd love to publish them.
00:13:24 You know, I would love to...
00:13:26 Paul's book did very well for us, you know, in my last job,
00:13:29 and there's a real market for it.
00:13:31 And what was very interesting about Paul's book
00:13:32 was the fact that, you know, one of the things I really want to do,
00:13:35 I want you to publish books that are read by people
00:13:38 who are not just from a very narrow social range, right?
00:13:41 Most of the books are always doing quality.
00:13:43 I mean, it's not really a criticism of quality.
00:13:45 It's just the nature of the beast.
00:13:46 Well, read by, you know, the people, the same kind of people,
00:13:49 Guardian readers, people who, you know, read broadsheet newspapers,
00:13:53 probably are disproportionately likely to live in london or the home counties but when probably
00:13:57 polish paul's book we were getting lots of messages on social media and so on by people who
00:14:02 were you know probably don't read many haven't read many books in recent years probably because
00:14:06 they don't there aren't many books published that they're particularly interested in um and you know
00:14:11 ordinary people from you know the provinces from you know brexit voters working-class people who
00:14:17 were writing support and saying things like paul this is like i haven't read a book this good in
00:14:21 years like you finally speaking to us in a way you know and and they really appreciate it and
00:14:25 i really like that because i just don't want to just be publishing books that are bought by
00:14:29 you know graduates who live in north london i want you know we want to be speaking to the whole
00:14:34 country did did so did paul's book sell quite well yes it did very well it was one of the
00:14:41 policies bestsellers the year it was published yeah um you know it really hit a nerve i think
00:14:45 because this is the point i mean i'm very pleased to hear that because this point is that also the
00:14:49 other side of the coin if one's going to look at it they've said people say uh oh what are you
00:14:55 complaining about i mean you know you've got jk rowling who's uh you know been very you know uh
00:15:01 false writing about what she says about trans and then she's hugely she's still published and then
00:15:09 i i spoke to douglas murray last week you know huge best-selling international best-selling
00:15:13 um obviously he's not woke um but i suppose you could say they are untouchable really because
00:15:21 they are so economically powerful yeah well i joke that you know if you sell two million copies you
00:15:26 can say what you like if you sell 10 000 copies you know which is not a bad number you're on a
00:15:31 sticky wicket if you sell less than that fewer than that then then you're going to be you know
00:15:35 the chances of cancellation go up uh incredibly which basically boils down to publishers who
00:15:41 claiming to have these high principles about you know kind of progressive
00:15:44 principles the principles magically disappear when a certain level of
00:15:48 numbers of sales are reached you know they're not going to cancel JK Rowling
00:15:52 because JK Rowling literally is one of the main reasons why Bloomsby such a
00:15:56 successful publisher and Douglas Murray sells so well and he's so popular but
00:16:01 you know ultimately the money will speak and it's the same with Jordan Peterson of
00:16:05 course where some people at Penguin you know some of the
00:16:10 younger staff were very upset about publishing them but funnily enough the
00:16:14 publisher found find that publishers find their spines when they know it's
00:16:18 gonna be a banker that's gonna make them huge amounts of money and it's
00:16:21 commercial business you know but I just wish we could get you know it seems to
00:16:25 me that different standards apply if to a small but there are small band of
00:16:29 people there aren't many Douglas Murray's JK Rowling's and Jordan Peterson's
00:16:33 right there you know they're a very small band of people there's loads of
00:16:36 people who do you know very well that you know either are you know they may still be put i mean
00:16:41 they may still be have been published but increasingly i'm talking to people and i'm
00:16:46 and they're saying well like i don't it's not i'm not madly keen on being published by people who
00:16:51 are obviously kind of a bit embarrassed by having me on the list and i think to well we won't be
00:16:56 embarrassed we're pleased to have you on the you know we're pleased to have you on the list um you
00:17:00 know and so you know hence we signed up for quite a few good people already you know we've got books
00:17:04 from Tony Shull coming and... Tony Shull? Yeah, who wrote the race report for the government.
00:17:10 Yeah, and Ed West, the Conservative commentator, is signed up to do his next book with us and
00:17:16 Danny Kruger, the Tory MP, who's kind of got quite, I think, an interesting perspective on
00:17:21 conservatism and Mary Harrington, who is quite, if you may know her from social media, she's,
00:17:27 I think, one of the most fiercely intelligent people, you know, one of the most fiercely
00:17:33 intelligent people on well i know and uh you know so we've got we've got quite a few people like
00:17:39 that and ben cobley who you may you may be aware yes he's been all these people have been on the
00:17:43 i'll have to pay more closely closely close attention to your who you're who you're interviewing
00:17:49 so i can sign them up well no no because i mean we would want all your authors on whether they
00:17:54 are left or right i mean i mean the point is uh you know if you say it's uh people who just don't
00:18:00 necessarily fit in who might feel a bit homeless actually yeah um can i ask one thing with because
00:18:07 i've been asked this by viewers in in terms of publishing this phenomenon of sensitivity readers
00:18:14 people who read through things before first of all you know george is it just a made-up thing
00:18:22 or is it really there and if so how do they operate well it's much more of a phenomenon
00:18:29 in fiction publishing right um i'm not aware of it in i mean in non-fiction publishing it's not uh
00:18:35 it's a different kind of color fish because sensitivity i mean those kind of issues if
00:18:40 they're raised in non-fiction publishing would be raised just by the editor in the normal process
00:18:44 of editing the book um it's a it's a special thing in i think almost exclusively in fiction
00:18:49 publishing where you've had you know i mean definitely i mean i'm not an expert on fiction
00:18:53 publishing is not my area but i know of them definitely happens because i mean you know so
00:19:00 forum is an imprint of swift um is our kind of parent publisher and we've swift has signed up
00:19:05 kate clanchy um because she was dropped by a previous publisher and kate clanchy has written
00:19:10 at some length on i think unheard about how her book was basically they attempted to basically say
00:19:16 it's just censorship i mean you can dress it up how you like but um you know it can you imagine
00:19:22 you know charles dickens or or you know henry fielding or whoever having a sensitivity reader
00:19:28 i mean it's ludicrous um it's a ludicrous attempt to censor the creative process i would say but
00:19:32 it's not as i said it's not something that really comes up in non-fiction publishing no no of course
00:19:36 i i yes i can see but in fiction at what stage would they come in do you think these sensitivity
00:19:41 readers when it's been edited i mean you know what's what stage well i mean at some stages
00:19:46 it's clearly being done retrospectively after after the initial there's been some kind of
00:19:52 some kind of bus stop or some kind of outcry usually on social media or whatever and then
00:19:57 i think i don't know i'm not i don't know for a fact but i'm i get the strong impression in
00:20:00 some cases it's been happening retrospectively but i i'd imagine it's now happening at an earlier
00:20:04 stage in the process like it's happening presumably when you the manuscript is submitted
00:20:09 at the same stage as the editing process um so yeah i mean that obviously you know if you know
00:20:15 you're going to have a sensitivity reader I suppose people will start to self-censor because
00:20:20 but it's very difficult to self-censor when I would suggest when you don't even know what kind
00:20:24 of really quite innocuous things are going to be deemed to be unacceptable and you know creative
00:20:31 people can't be self-censoring them on the basis of some imagined um you know kind of
00:20:39 sensitivity reader and what they their sensitivities they're kind of what basically
00:20:43 we're going to amount to ideological predisposition predispositions are going to be i would suggest
00:20:47 so um yeah i think that's to my best of my knowledge that's sort of that is how it works
00:20:52 but as i said it's not really my area yeah i know we've had on the program a number of times um
00:20:57 she's a friend of the channels actually lionel shriver and you know she's talked you know very
00:21:03 outspokenly about publishing in this sense and how it's actually going to destroy creativity
00:21:09 if it carries on like that um what is your i mean you've got a very interesting political background
00:21:16 or something i mean you know you uh you've been in publishing for seven years roughly now
00:21:22 but um you were politically active at one point i understand and you've had what they now always
00:21:27 call a journey um yeah is it right to say a journey or not really just a frustrated
00:21:33 So I was a Labour councillor in Cambridge, and I was a Labour activist for many years,
00:21:40 since I was 15. And yeah, I've left the Labour Party. And yeah, to a large extent, it's because
00:21:48 I feel that the left has been moving away from what I think has sound, the institutional
00:21:54 left, i.e. particularly the Labour Party, not exclusively the Labour Party, has been
00:21:58 moving away from the kind of values that I think the Labour Party and the left should
00:22:01 be standing for and I mean and particularly you know I mean the reason I was involved in the
00:22:07 Labour Party was because I wanted to improve a lot of the working class and the poor in material
00:22:12 terms chiefly and they're not solely but what is your background George in that sense what is your
00:22:18 oh I mean I'm kind of upper working lower middle class from Essex and I mean I don't have a
00:22:25 particularly you know quite normal background really I mean my parents were quite strongly
00:22:30 are quite strongly left-wing and you know the kind of principles that my parents brought me
00:22:38 up with haven't really changed in my mind like for example when it comes to issues of race and
00:22:43 sexuality and so on that you know they taught the things they taught me would just you know
00:22:47 treat people exactly the same as you would regardless of the color of their skin just
00:22:51 treat them like anybody else you know or don't you know their sexuality is not really important
00:22:56 it's what's important is what kind of person they are and just treat them you know normally
00:22:59 And I think those kind of principles have clearly, you know, the rage in ID politics in the Labour Party, where everyone is judged first and foremost on their, not their merit, not their hard work, not their ability to contribute, but their race, their skin colour, their gender and so on.
00:23:17 It just got so out of control in the Labour Party that it's like, I just got, I know, I mean, it's not the only problem with the Labour Party, but I just, and actually often this obscures the class issues.
00:23:27 you get to a point where you know diversity schemes basically end up
00:23:31 promoting kind of Nigerian princes or kind of very well-heeled ethnic
00:23:35 minorities where whereas you know the if you're white working class then you're
00:23:40 basically you know seen as I mean this is the last acceptable prejudice in the
00:23:44 country in this country is basically it's basically particularly white
00:23:47 working-class men they're they are enough that they don't get any you know
00:23:52 they'll see and their educational outcomes are what are the worst literally
00:23:55 the worst white working class boys do the work do worse than any other ethnic group at school and
00:24:00 yet you know i mean i'm not really interested in the white part of that so much as the working
00:24:05 class part of that but you can't get away from the racialization when that is the framing with
00:24:10 the left talks about everything rather than saying you know we want to lift up working class people
00:24:15 um who you know we want to improve their wages we want to improve their job opportunities we want to
00:24:20 and so on. The Labour Party just can't help but make it about race or about sexuality or about
00:24:26 gender. And I think it just divides people in a way which the Labour Party, as it was historically,
00:24:32 the kind of Labour Party I would like to identify myself, was about uniting
00:24:36 people, you know, and not just dividing the working class into ever tinier little chunks of
00:24:41 and we'll do this for the Muslims, we'll do this for, you know, no, like, they're just people who
00:24:45 want the same as most other people, in many respects, they want a good job, they want, you
00:24:49 You know, if they fall on hard times, they want a safety net, they want good education for their children, they want a good NHS.
00:24:55 And I just got the feeling that the Labour Party just isn't interested in those things unless it can slice and dice it into this kind of bulk-alised politics of identity.
00:25:05 And, you know, I think a lot of people have started to feel very alienated by that.
00:25:10 And so I drift away from the Labour Party and I've kind of, you know, become more and more open to what I would call kind of blue labour.
00:25:19 Yes, blue labour. You call yourself on, I think you refer to yourself, maybe not on Twitter, but on your website as Tory socialist, right?
00:25:29 Blue labour, I guess you might say.
00:25:30 Yeah, I mean.
00:25:31 Like Paul Embry.
00:25:32 Yeah, yeah. I mean, I think that what I would say is that we have this view in this country that if you're on the left on economic issues, so you believe in trade unions and, you know, good wages and industrial strategy and so on and strong public services and so on, then you have to accept a whole range of cultural positions.
00:25:53 You have to think that trans women are women and, you know, you have to be against Brexit and you have to, you know, have all these other cultural views.
00:26:01 And I just I think that's a very poor way of understanding things.
00:26:04 It's perfectly possible, I mean, if you look at the history of my great heroes are people like Ernie Bevin and Clement Attlee and people like that, who were, you know, patriots, who believed that Britain was a great country and were, you know, and who wanted to reform the country and bring the working class inside the institutions of the country and unite the country.
00:26:24 You know, I would like there to be a situation where we had a Conservative Party and a Labour Party who were both committed to a kind of common culture, who both were patriotic, reflected the views of the country and competed where the people actually are, rather than compete for the social, liberal, freed elections of people in a very narrow part of the country.
00:26:51 and i don't think the tories are so much i'm not joining the conservative party believe me
00:26:55 um because i don't there are a few honorable exceptions in the tory party but the tories
00:26:59 are almost no better on a lot of these issues they seem to be chasing the vote you know totally
00:27:05 misguidedly because even with the red wall they still seem to be that um you know totally unable
00:27:10 to reflect the views of a lot of the people who clearly voted for them in 2019. oh i would agree
00:27:16 i mean that's been shameful i would say almost you know that the way that they've squandered
00:27:20 you know people actually voting for them for the first time and it was a cultural i think a lot of
00:27:27 it was a kind of cultural vote actually and they just are still they still remain frightened of
00:27:32 these issues but obviously you were active and you wrote as i just i did a um mention there um
00:27:41 a long letter you know sort of uh uh or leaving the labor party and it was quite you know trenchant
00:27:48 in your in your criticism but that means presumably that you are pretty much politically homeless
00:27:54 would you say in terms of policy yeah i am i am i feel very politically homeless i mean you know
00:28:00 i'm aware of the sdp and i like their ideas and i i kind of don't have much to disagree with the
00:28:07 sdp i i personally i'm just a bit party political you know party politics i've had my fill um you
00:28:13 know i think that sdp are going to struggle to be anything other than a kind of micro party in the
00:28:18 current certainly in the current system so you know i i'm not i'm not but i mean you know the
00:28:23 thing about i would say there's about you know i was a councillor so i did all of the knocking on
00:28:28 doors sorting out dog mess um you know for for six six years uh five five and a half six years
00:28:35 and um you know what that was what changed so my politics has changed to some degree it's not just
00:28:41 uh you know it's not just that my i've stayed the same that i probably shifted i did shift a bit
00:28:46 because i represented a ward in cambridge that was quite you know cambridge you think cambridge
00:28:51 you think you know academics and leafy suburbs and professors and so on and obviously there is
00:28:57 plenty of that don't get me wrong but i i represented an area which still had quite a
00:29:01 considerable kind of what you might call kind of you know working class old school working class
00:29:07 out in a suburb of cambridge and i spent years knocking on their doors and asking them and and
00:29:11 And they changed my view, because if you have any kind of honesty and you really are prepared to, rather than just tell them what they should think, and you actually listen, you actually start to think, maybe they've got a point.
00:29:23 For example, I mean, I voted Leave in the Brexit referendum, but things like the EU, immigration, and a lot of these cultural issues, if you start to listen to people, you actually start to think, actually, maybe they've got a point.
00:29:36 And maybe a political party whose instinctive reaction to anybody who says that something that they don't want to hear is to just, you know, like the old Brechtigian line, we must dissolve the people and elect a new one.
00:29:46 Maybe we should try to, you know, listen or at least compromise with the electorate rather than attempt to just tell them that they're wrong, you know, that they're just ignorant and they're stupid and they should listen to their betters.
00:29:57 I mean, the Labour Party was founded by working class people and was founded to represent their interests and their views.
00:30:03 and you know clearly you know going to them and telling them that they're wrong on immigration
00:30:09 you know I'm not saying that you have to always reflect everything that they say but you should
00:30:12 at least listen and you might find sometimes that they have a point you know that not all wisdom
00:30:17 lies in you know I mean I say this as somebody who's a Cambridge graduate and you know and works
00:30:22 in publishing but you might find that you know it's not just people like me or you know or you
00:30:28 know people in Westminster and people in you know the professions in universities they might find
00:30:32 their wisdom outside their very narrow range of social and educational experiences if they just
00:30:37 listen to people and that really you know so I did move I suppose to the I wouldn't say to the
00:30:43 right I moved to be a more of a kind of communitarian who who believes that some you know
00:30:48 social institutions and structures that already there are really important and the globalization
00:30:53 and you know a headlong rush towards open-door immigration and these things has not done there
00:30:59 has not been in their interest it clearly hasn't been in their interests when i did one of the
00:31:03 books i did with um uh before my last publisher was um the dignity of labor by john crudas
00:31:09 he writes very movingly about he was a labor mp right he still is still just down in essex
00:31:15 uh in dagan um yeah and uh in fact i'm meeting him i'm meeting him for a drink this evening um
00:31:22 and um uh he did this book called um the dignity of labor um with with with me and um you know
00:31:28 You know, he writes very movingly about Dagenham and about how, you know, basically an area which was based on very stable working class communities based around the Ford car factory plant.
00:31:40 It was quite socio-conservative in many ways. It was based strongly on family, on patriotism, you know, but also on trade unions and so on.
00:31:49 It had a real sense of community, which was based partly on the fact that, you know, they were rooted in place.
00:31:54 this is our place, this is Dagenham, we're proud of working with our hands, we're proud of being in
00:31:59 the union, we're proud of our council houses and they're a real community and how that's been
00:32:05 decimated by not just by immigration by any stretch of the imagination but massive amounts
00:32:10 of demographic change in that area have made it to those people almost unrecognisable and when you add
00:32:15 to the fact that the economic hollowing out of globalisation and so on but the left has in my
00:32:19 view has become totally unable to criticise international capitalism bizarrely because
00:32:24 what is globalisation if it's not and free movement of labour and free movement of capital
00:32:28 if that isn't you know headlong globalisation and so you know and in the movement of international
00:32:34 capitalism but instead the left under new labour as well as under you know has embraced just
00:32:39 embraced it because of some kind of utilitarian calculation that ultimately GDP will be higher
00:32:45 and we can educate everybody to go to university so they can leave behind Dagenham or Wigan
00:32:50 or, you know, wherever it is in the country.
00:32:53 But people don't want to leave Wigan or Dagenham.
00:32:55 Not everybody does want to do that.
00:32:56 They want to live in where they grew up.
00:32:58 They want to live in, you know, to be able to live in the same area that they grew up
00:33:03 and know where it was, still have secure jobs, still, you know, have a sense of who they are
00:33:09 and place and stronger families and be able to go around the corner and see their mum
00:33:14 and so on, there's nothing wrong with that
00:33:16 but the Labour Party seems to
00:33:18 basically, and most of the left seems to take the view
00:33:20 that people who do want to do that, who don't want to go to university
00:33:22 and go and work in London or something
00:33:24 that they're somehow unambitious
00:33:26 the losers of globalisation
00:33:28 and they should just be made to suck it up
00:33:30 basically, and I don't believe that
00:33:32 and the Labour Party was not founded
00:33:34 to represent the interests of those people
00:33:36 and not the interests of
00:33:38 the small minority
00:33:40 of people who managed to leave their backgrounds
00:33:42 and become successful there's nothing wrong with becoming successful but it
00:33:45 shouldn't be a choice between you either stay in your home community and you know
00:33:49 watch it rot around you and watch you know your community fall apart or you
00:33:55 leave it and get out and you know I don't you people want to raise you want
00:33:58 to rise with your class not not not not from it and above it necessarily and you
00:34:04 know so people like you know John Curtis and Paul Embry Paul Embry's from the
00:34:07 same part of London originally and they they speak very movingly about this and
00:34:10 And, you know, if the Labour Party wants to get back on the conversation and start to talk to those people and not patronise them or insult them and actually represent the true views and interests of ordinary working class people, then I'm happy to rejoin.
00:34:25 But I'm not putting my money on it.
00:34:27 I think the chances of that are almost zero, I would have thought.
00:34:31 Well, that's what I've concluded.
00:34:32 To the point where you sort of think, well, possibly I may not know what you think about this.
00:34:36 perhaps like some uh parties political parties in europe labor should actually stop me from
00:34:43 pretending i mean they they why don't they just actually reform themselves or rebrand themselves
00:34:49 as a professional liberal uh left-wing radical party i mean that's what they are so you can
00:34:58 actually present that to people can't you well i think they i mean i think they would find what
00:35:03 I think they could do I don't think that they'd find it very I mean obviously everything is
00:35:08 influenced by first past the post which means that you know you have to have broad-based parties in
00:35:13 theory that can appeal widely and therefore the number of people who that would appeal to are
00:35:18 people in cities and so on and you know they clearly have an electoral base I mean where I'm
00:35:22 from Cambridge is full of people who would vote for that kind of party fair enough but if you're
00:35:26 going to you know you can't become that kind of party and expect you know the kind of provincial
00:35:33 working class people to just turn around and say oh well you know you're our betters we'll just go
00:35:38 along with whatever you say sir um of course they're not going to do that and it would be
00:35:41 more honest in they probably should split into at least three parties let's be honest it should be
00:35:45 a core and i far hard left party there should be a kind of kind of you know remain a middle class
00:35:52 liberal party and there should be like a communitarian old-fashioned working class
00:35:57 blue labor style party um well the problem is that within the mechanics of the labor party's
00:36:02 membership and activists the last group is almost totally unrepresented the the member the activists
00:36:08 and the membership is split almost completely between the hard left and the Keir Starmer left
00:36:14 of you know people who you know who basically wanted to ignore the not the the Brexit vote who
00:36:20 are very interested in issues of cultural diversity and stuff but they don't they're very
00:36:25 uncomfortable with um I used to see it when I was I was a student at Cambridge and I stayed in
00:36:30 Cambridge and we used to go out canvassing and you'd get students from you know I was a student
00:36:34 myself so I'm not criticizing all students but you know who clearly from quite had read some books
00:36:38 and were very you know very um right on kind of progressive types and then you go and knock on
00:36:43 the door of a council house in King's Hedges or somewhere it's a kind of working class estate in
00:36:47 in in Cambridge and the look of shock on their face as they realized that the working classes
00:36:53 are not what some Trotskyite theorists had told them in a book that you know a lot of working
00:36:57 lots of people are patriotic, they like the monarchy, don't want a routine on immigration
00:37:02 necessarily, and they might have perfectly, actually, they might have perfectly good reasons
00:37:05 for those views. They still might want a well-funded NHS, they might want good wages, they want
00:37:10 good jobs, but they don't want a bunch of, you know, and basically the whole Labour Party
00:37:14 has just become those 19-year-olds knocking on doors in council estates with a horrified
00:37:19 look on their face, now run the Labour Party, and they're still as horrified as ever. They
00:37:23 see traditional Labour, or people who were traditional Labour voters, probably in many
00:37:27 cases they're not then they are no longer they they see those people as embarrassing older
00:37:31 relatives so they kind of get your vote every four years but um we're not actually you know
00:37:37 you're kind of an embarrassment i wish you'd be quiet and just vote for us um and then you know
00:37:42 of course inevitably in the you know that that actually they did continue to vote labor despite
00:37:47 that kind of attitude for a remarkably long time the working classes in britain showed or large
00:37:52 swathes of them showed remarkable loyalty to the labor party for a long time yeah and
00:37:57 you know, the Labour Party under New Labour, and New Labour are also to blame, don't get me wrong,
00:38:02 they took those people for granted for a very long time, because they said, oh, you've got nowhere
00:38:06 else to go. It's like, well, I mean, that's an incredibly condescending, arrogant approach to
00:38:11 your voters, for a start. And secondly, in the long run, they kind of thought, actually, we do
00:38:16 have other places to go, you know, you know, they managed to alienate those people, those loyal
00:38:20 voters to such an extent that they started voting Tory, or they've stopped voting altogether,
00:38:23 or indeed they might have voted ukip or the brexit party or whatever um yeah no i think that yes it
00:38:29 was always a thing with the ukip and i i imagine as well the brexit party to a less extent huge
00:38:36 part of the vote was labor yeah they were ex-labor people and they sort of you know they weren't all
00:38:40 kind of free market fundamentalists that was the last thing they were actually what i find
00:38:47 interesting really is when you talk about blue labor george we've had paul embryo on the show as
00:38:52 as well it's basically the labor that i remember my parents being it's as simple as that it was
00:38:57 just not just blue labor it was labor you know um by way of sort of finishing i mean first of all
00:39:04 uh i want to the name of the publisher is forum right um and basically if website if you've got
00:39:11 a website and everything yes if you just google forum press um press uh then you know actually
00:39:16 maybe google swift forum press but to make sure that you definitely get us because we are an
00:39:21 imprint of swift press i see um yeah and we've you know so we have one book out now but i said
00:39:26 we've got a lot of buying kind of late this year and spring next year we're going to have you know
00:39:31 increasing number of books out and i you know since i was interviewed in the telegraph as you
00:39:36 may have mentioned and uh i've had you know i've been deluged with with people um emailing me and
00:39:42 you know it's clearly an interest and uh oh i think you're you're you're kicking it an open
00:39:46 door yeah no i'm well this week i've been rushing around london meeting lots of people and i've
00:39:52 almost got so many potential authors i can't keep up with them um so you know but but you know we
00:39:57 are not we i think we we have a rich team of people and as i said not just conservative i'm
00:40:02 i want i'm happy to publish conservatives and right-wingers because i think they have valuable
00:40:07 things to say they have a different way of looking at the world which we should listen to
00:40:11 but I don't just want it to be like that
00:40:14 I want people who are
00:40:16 I don't even, not necessarily left-right
00:40:18 is not necessarily the best way of thinking about it
00:40:19 but communitarians, enlightenment liberals
00:40:22 classical liberals
00:40:24 socialists of various different descriptions
00:40:27 even Marxists
00:40:28 if they've got something interesting to say
00:40:29 and sometimes they do
00:40:30 I want to encourage all of those people
00:40:33 to come and work with Forum
00:40:35 Well there you are, there's your chance
00:40:37 I want to just finish by asking you
00:40:41 not just things that you've
00:40:43 I mean Paul Embry's book
00:40:45 you publish
00:40:46 but if there are people
00:40:49 watching who have always been
00:40:51 labour and sort of listen to what you're
00:40:53 saying and thinking actually you know
00:40:55 that's exactly me
00:40:56 what books would you
00:40:59 suggest they read
00:41:00 two or three books
00:41:02 that you would recommend that you think
00:41:05 are good regardless of whether you publish
00:41:07 well I mean
00:41:08 it's going to be a kind of
00:41:10 the sort of obvious ones like David Goodhart's Road to Somewhere,
00:41:14 the book I published with Paulyty,
00:41:16 John Crudus's book, Dignity of Labour,
00:41:18 which I think is a great...
00:41:19 The Dignity of Labour, John Crudus.
00:41:20 It's a great book.
00:41:21 But I would also, I mean, I would encourage more widely
00:41:24 people to read to people like Christopher Lash,
00:41:27 who, The Culture of Narcissism,
00:41:29 and who I think is now,
00:41:32 actually from some time ago,
00:41:33 he wrote in the 90s, he's now dead.
00:41:35 But he is a great thinker
00:41:37 who really anticipated a lot of the,
00:41:39 particularly he's you know with things like about how you get the the rich become very radicalized
00:41:45 and they become separate from the rest of the community and so on he is a great prophet i think
00:41:48 so you know christopher lash i would i would recommend and obviously all forum books when
00:41:52 they come out all forms when they come out great well thank you very very much george joining us
00:41:57 and um all the very best with it i thank you i think you're going to have great success with
00:42:01 it well let's hope so thank you um that's it for this week so what you're saying is we will be back
00:42:06 next time so uh look forward to seeing you then thanks bye hello if you're enjoying the new culture
00:42:13 forum channel and you believe in our mission may i invite you to join our membership scheme
00:42:20 at the link below or on our website newcultureforum.org.uk our work is more important
00:42:28 now than ever and we have great plans ahead for the future but we can't do it without your support
00:42:34 from as little as three pounds per month you can help ensure that we continue on our mission.
00:42:40 As a member you'll receive a range of benefits including access to exclusive content,
00:42:46 invitations to our private events including here at our studios, free copies of our books
00:42:53 and much much more including of course our famous NCF mug. If you aren't able to become a member
00:43:01 then please help us by clicking this button and subscribing to our channel. It's completely free,
00:43:08 just remember to also click the bell icon so that you can get notifications when we post new videos.
00:43:16 Thank you.