New Culture Forum - April 27, 2022


The War On Whiteness & The West - Murray's Brave New Book Exposes How We're Taught To Hate Ourselves

Daily Wire: We Are Taking Culture BACK from Left Wing Hollywood, Disney & Other Woke Institutions War on Words: "We Publish What Woke Publishers Won't" - New Publisher Challenges Cancel Culture

Episode Stats


Length

51 minutes

Words per minute

157.99

Word count

8,062

Sentence count

278


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to So What You're Saying Is, I'm Peter Whitlaw. Now I'm delighted that this
00:00:25 week. My guest is someone who's been on the show a number of times before and
00:00:29 indeed has been one of our most popular guests and rightly so. Douglas Murray,
00:00:35 the author and journalist and the author of The Strange Death of Europe and after
00:00:42 that The Madness of Crowds. There's a new book coming out this week which is called
00:00:48 The War on the West. These previous two books sold hundreds of thousands of
00:00:53 copies and were translated into various different languages. He's known I'm sure obviously to all of
00:00:59 you. Thank you very much for joining us, Douglas. You're actually in New York at the moment, aren't
00:01:07 you? I am. It's a great pleasure to join you and you wish you were able to do it in person. Great.
00:01:12 How is New York at the moment? You know, it's great. Coming back, like London, you know,
00:01:19 we all had fears for it, but it's coming back. I always say there are basically two cities in the
00:01:26 world, everyone comes through at some point in their lives, London and New York, and I don't
00:01:32 think that's ever going to change. I hope it's not. Douglas, the new book, The War on the West,
00:01:40 can I start by asking you, I think it's a point that actually you make in the book, which is
00:01:45 is essential reading, that essentially when we talk about culture wars and when we talk about
00:01:53 you know woke ideology that these things are really rather inadequate to describe what has
00:01:59 actually been happening. You're so right, I'm so glad you say that because I don't want anyone to
00:02:05 misunderstand this. What I'm describing is not about wokeness, it's not about you know
00:02:14 gender pronouns or any here today gone tomorrow cultural war it is my best attempt to explain
00:02:25 the deep undercurrent of what is actually going on in our societies in the west to try to lay out as
00:02:32 soberly and as clearly as possible the incredible depth of the assault that has been going on
00:02:42 in our lifetimes on our society and it cannot be exaggerated i don't exaggerate it i i give
00:02:50 example after example in area after area but i want people to understand that what i'm describing
00:02:54 is as you know from having read it um a a cultural revolution that has gone on in our lives
00:03:02 and if i could sum it up in one way it would be this it's a cultural revolution that has meant
00:03:09 that we have moved in a couple of generations from being in the West in societies which were
00:03:15 broadly proud of themselves, had faith in themselves, had a sense of pride in their
00:03:22 accomplishments and a sense of gratitude of being born in such a place. In our lifetimes,
00:03:31 certainly over the course of the last two generations, that has been completely inverted
00:03:36 so that what we are living in at the moment is the x-ray opposite of that that we are told that
00:03:45 we have nothing to be proud of that we in the west are born in sin unique sin the rest of the world
00:03:53 is born into eden the we are told that white people are particularly uh to be blamed that
00:04:01 white people uniquely of all races must be from the cradle regarded as being complicit in appalling
00:04:09 atrocity. We're told that we have no heroes. We're told we have no culture other than culture that
00:04:17 we've stolen or appropriated to use one of the terms. Everything in our history, in our past
00:04:25 and present, has been ransacked, has been transformed into this light of absolute and
00:04:33 utter negativity to persuade us that the West is worst. And I think that nobody can understand any
00:04:44 of the comparatively frivolous things that are going on in our time without starting from there,
00:04:49 That we have been encouraged to love everything so long as we didn't have any hand in producing it.
00:04:57 We've been urged to revel in every tradition apart from the one we've been gifted.
00:05:06 It is extraordinary.
00:05:09 And I wondered, Douglas, you said for two generations, I would completely concur with that.
00:05:18 we've we've become used to it it's almost like uh we feel it's the natural order of things
00:05:24 you know um to to feel this way and behave this way one thing i i wanted to ask particularly
00:05:31 though is that over the past couple of years um particularly in 2020 what struck me was the sheer
00:05:39 speed with which the various sorts on the various institutions say in in britain and indeed in
00:05:45 America happened and it's almost like they were on some kind of starting block and then after sort
00:05:53 of George Floyd for example it was almost like it was like a lighting a touch paper and it was
00:06:01 almost like it was a kind of opportunity to put into action something that had been boiling away
00:06:06 for a while I mean does that sound about right to you? Absolutely, absolutely accurate, absolutely
00:06:14 It had been boiling away.
00:06:15 It had been boiling away in academia since the 70s.
00:06:19 Things like critical race theory that a lot of people have heard about
00:06:22 had been on the fringes of academia.
00:06:23 It had, as I explain in the book, it had had plenty of moments
00:06:28 in the cultural mainstream.
00:06:30 I mean, I don't like to only talk about academics
00:06:32 because sometimes you can overestimate the impact of academics.
00:06:35 Popular culture, in a way, is a much better example of it.
00:06:39 I give an example from the early 2000s, a book,
00:06:42 Stupid White Men by the documentary maker Michael Moore.
00:06:48 Impossible to think of a book titled Stupid Black Men.
00:06:56 And quite rightly, there's a chapter, Blame Whitey, again.
00:07:02 It's impossible to think of the opposite.
00:07:04 Michael Moore just says everything that's bad in human history,
00:07:08 you can trace it back to white people.
00:07:09 I mean, he's never heard of most of human history, clearly. He's as ignorant as he looks. But this had become part of the culture, this idea that you could sort of uniquely beat up on white people, for instance.
00:07:24 you could you could start to say things about white people you just we don't right you don't
00:07:29 say about any other race people were racist about other people in the past there is some residual
00:07:34 racism today um but but the only group of people you can just constantly insult for their skin
00:07:41 color are white people now in the west and um that's been brewing up but yes you're right it
00:07:47 was it was it was waiting for a moment and the george floyd uh killing was definitely such a
00:07:53 There were several reasons for that. One was that we were all in our solitudes, of course, forced by our governments to remain inside our houses and unable to see our nearest and dearest, unable to meet friends, unable to sit in the pub and talk and chat with people and try things out or have live events where people experimented ideas and said, no, I think you're wrong on that.
00:08:16 I think that we had already this isolation which meant we'd lost all
00:08:20 of our social antennae and then suddenly this movement,
00:08:23 Black Lives Matter and others, said you're allowed
00:08:26 to just kill black people in the United States of America.
00:08:29 And I think most people had a moment of even people like us,
00:08:34 you know America, like is that possible?
00:08:37 Can you do that, really?
00:08:38 Do policemen just have the right to go and kill people
00:08:42 on the streets if they're black?
00:08:43 Of course, the answer is no, absolutely not.
00:08:46 Not least because the policeman who killed George Floyd was responsible for his death is serving a life sentence in prison.
00:08:53 But as I say in the book, this was used as a way to claim that in America in the 21st century,
00:09:02 black lives are so unimportant that black people can just be killed at any point.
00:09:08 And that's just a total fabrication.
00:09:10 And I give the actual statistics of what the realities are in this and what the realities of policing in America are in a heavily armed society.
00:09:20 And they're nothing like most people think.
00:09:23 The statistics show that the public view is totally wrong.
00:09:28 But, as I say in the book, we have this magic lantern-like effect where anything that happens in America,
00:09:35 why we fight over the details is that everything that happens in America, if you get one of the
00:09:40 tiny details wrong, because of the light that is behind America, when it's projected onto the wall
00:09:47 of the world, even a tiny misapprehension and misrepresentation in that model, when blown up
00:09:55 on the world, becomes gargantuan and grotesque and appalling. And we have been persuaded in Britain
00:10:03 to fall for this. Not just that it's a truth of American life, which it isn't, but that it's a
00:10:10 truth of British life. And that was, as you rightly say, Peter, the moment where the revolution could
00:10:17 go mainstream and did. It's then that people like the mayor of London, Sadiq Khan, decide that they
00:10:24 have their moment to set up their Robespierrean committees on the public virtue. What was it?
00:10:31 The Committee on the Representation of History in the Public Realm, some similarly easy to trip off the tongue committee.
00:10:42 And he appoints a group of people who all clearly in different ways hate Britain to decide what our history should be.
00:10:51 Include the man who in Westminster Abbey insulted and screamed abuse at the Queen and others and then threatened to punch a black, as it happened, security guard escorting him out.
00:11:03 The perfect figure for Sadiq Khan to appoint to a committee to decide what my history and your history and our nation's history is or what it should be, who should be remembered and who should not.
00:11:17 It's at that moment that people seize their opportunity to make the cultural revolution go mainstream.
00:11:24 Yes, in fact, they were quite, quite open about it, Douglas.
00:11:28 I mean, with that particular commission of Sadiq Khan's, they said, you know, this will decide which legacies we can celebrate.
00:11:36 We should celebrate. Quite open about it.
00:11:39 The problem with these, all these institutions across British society, but pretty much it's the same in America.
00:11:47 is that they essentially were it was like kicking an open door wasn't it I mean this wasn't coming
00:11:55 actually from outside it was sort of coming from inside I mean you know again this is this sense
00:12:01 it brings me to this point really do you think when you talk about a revolutionary thing that's
00:12:07 been going on and that this was a moment for it to go mainstream do you think that this is actually
00:12:14 marxist in nature i mean in a kind of gramscian way because um it would appear to be so you know
00:12:21 like institutions having been hollowed out for decades but it is in part um i don't think it
00:12:30 should be seen as the sole explanation for it i think there's a a nascent movement i think you
00:12:36 You could say that a completely reasonable, non-conspiratorial view of it would be that we had a period of empire in the post-colonial period is arguably, I mean, you could say we're still in it.
00:12:53 I don't think we are by any means.
00:12:55 That's way out of date.
00:12:56 You could say that we're still in it and therefore we're trying to litigate the colonial era and that slavery is being litigated because we didn't before.
00:13:05 I mean, that would be like one very generous steel manning interpretation of what has been happening.
00:13:12 Of course, it ignores the fact that this country debated, got beyond this a long, long time ago now,
00:13:19 that America fought a bloody civil war over slavery more than two centuries ago.
00:13:24 I mean, it's wildly historically inaccurate and unfair to make that claim.
00:13:28 But that could be a claim that some people would make is we haven't really had the reckoning on that yet.
00:13:33 And that's what we're doing.
00:13:35 So I think that's misguided, but I think some people do actually think that, mainly because they don't know about anything that happened before the day they were born, and not much after that.
00:13:47 But anyway, the point is, yes, there are certain signs, and I give some examples in the book, of the sort of other deep underlays of what is challenging us on this.
00:13:57 I give the example, as you know, of the way in which every Western philosopher has now been pulled down, just as there's been an assault on our religious tradition in the West, the Judeo-Christian tradition and an endless subservience to anything that's Islamic, for instance, as we've discussed before.
00:14:14 and I've written about at length, just as we've had that assault on the Judeo-Christian religion,
00:14:20 so we've had an assault on our secular tradition in the West.
00:14:23 And that's one way you can see that this is a totalistic war on everything that the West has produced.
00:14:28 They war on the Western secular traditions and the Western religious traditions.
00:14:34 Every Enlightenment philosopher has now been taken down, sometimes quite literally from their plinths,
00:14:40 because they lived in an era in which colonialism was going on.
00:14:46 They didn't write enough against racism,
00:14:50 or they once said something that we now regard as racist.
00:14:54 And I say in the book, great, let's apply this across the board.
00:14:57 Let's apply it to one of the clearest philosophers who was racist, Karl Marx.
00:15:04 And as you know, and I had such fun.
00:15:07 Karl Marx's letters to Engels are filled with racist epithets.
00:15:14 The N-word, endlessly used, often linked to the word Jew.
00:15:19 He's profoundly racist against black people in his published writings, as well as his private ones.
00:15:27 David Hume, the great Scottish philosopher of the Enlightenment, is currently cancelled and has had his name prized off buildings in his native Scotland
00:15:35 because of one footnote in one of his essays.
00:15:40 Karl Marx remains completely easy to cite
00:15:44 and nobody cares that he was a racist by our modern standards.
00:15:50 And the most that anyone can say about this is,
00:15:52 well, he was a man of his time, to which one can say, who is it?
00:15:56 And then, and I've had this in recent days,
00:15:59 some of the Marxists say, well, we don't go to him for his personal fame.
00:16:02 We go to him for his economic theory.
00:16:05 Well, the same thing with David Hume, same thing with Thomas Jefferson.
00:16:09 We don't go to Thomas Jefferson for advice on how to get slaves.
00:16:14 We look to Thomas Jefferson for a great example of human bravery and extraordinary brilliance
00:16:21 and helping to come up with the most successful society in history, the United States of America.
00:16:28 OK. So you see in moments like this what, yes, you rightly say is a Marxist undercurrent.
00:16:35 It's one of the undercurrents. I don't think it's the only one.
00:16:38 But I'm so pleased you cite it because it is it is absolutely evident in that example of what they don't want to critique.
00:16:47 You mentioned that, you know, men being men of their time times.
00:16:54 But, you know, the whole movement has kind of gone lateral, hasn't it?
00:16:57 So, you know, you talk in the book because the book is actually in sections, isn't it?
00:17:02 You cover race, you cover culture, religion.
00:17:05 And I was very struck by a section on classical music where I think America has seen a particular attack on classical music.
00:17:14 But the mere fact that Mozart and Beethoven were writing at a time where there was slavery.
00:17:21 this is enough to somehow paint them as a kind of expression of white supremacy.
00:17:28 Yes, I mean, yes. There was a performance of Beethoven's Ninth in America the other day
00:17:35 where they got a black rapper to rewrite the words of the last movement and completely mauled the
00:17:45 whole thing, because you just have to, because you can't do a straight-up performance of Beethoven
00:17:49 90, because of whiteness. Douglas, you say, you know, this is a strain, the Marxist thing is
00:17:56 certainly an undercurrent of strain. Do you think that there is any element of cultural envy in any
00:18:04 of this? In which direction? Well, for example, for the achievements of Western civilization.
00:18:13 Oh, sure. I mean, one of the things I started realising as this book has started to come out is the deepest comfort that many people have about some of the truths that I describe.
00:18:26 I say at one point in the book, as you know, that there was certainly you just mentioned classical music.
00:18:32 There is a reason why the Western notation system exists as a system of Western musical notation.
00:18:39 And there is a reason why it is used worldwide.
00:18:43 It's not because it's white or was invented by white people.
00:18:47 It's not because it came from the West.
00:18:48 It's because it works.
00:18:50 Because in music, you need to be able to chart time and pitch.
00:18:55 And it is true that there are systems of notation in China and India that they've come up with.
00:19:00 But the one that works the best is the Western system of notation, which, by the way, at no less a university than Oxford University, there are attempts to get away, to do away with because it's white.
00:19:10 okay Oxford University's own music faculty again none of this is about fringe movements it's all
00:19:17 at all of our sensual cultural and educational institutions and at the heart of all of our
00:19:22 governments where we have to have diversity inclusion and equity instilled across the
00:19:28 civil service but just to return to this with Oxford and notation the argument of certain
00:19:33 professors is the western notation system no longer needs to be taught because it's a product
00:19:38 of white men flat out wrong it works and the way you can prove it works among other things is
00:19:45 when as i say in the book benjamin britain goes to bali he notates the gamelan music he hears and
00:19:52 which he reveres again i hate this talk of cultural appropriation most of the history of western
00:19:57 culture has been one of cultural admiration of other societies it's not us stealing it's it's
00:20:04 It's artists paying tribute to what they've discovered,
00:20:07 reveling in it, wanting to share it.
00:20:10 So anyhow, Britain writes the Gamelan music down
00:20:14 using the Western notation system and plays it back
00:20:16 and everyone is sort of amazed and pleased.
00:20:19 The opposite cannot happen.
00:20:20 It would not happen.
00:20:21 If you played a piece of Benjamin Britten's
00:20:24 to somebody who wanted to use an Indian
00:20:27 or Chinese music system, notation system,
00:20:30 and then ask them to play it back using that,
00:20:32 It would sound nothing like what you had just been played.
00:20:35 If you played a Mahler symphony to somebody using anything other than the Western notation system, or Beethoven 9, what would come back at you would not be anything like what you've just heard.
00:20:49 It's there because it works.
00:20:52 And it's the same with the scientific method, which the West came up with, which is being currently done away with.
00:20:59 And I give examples and after examples in the book.
00:21:01 and the Western system of mathematics, which is currently being done away with.
00:21:05 It happens to have come about, in the case of mathematics,
00:21:10 multiple cultures contributed to it, including Islamic culture, Arabic culture.
00:21:14 But the Western system of mathematics, as it has evolved,
00:21:19 like the Western scientific method, we have it, and the world has taken it,
00:21:24 not because it's white or was come up with by white people, but because it works.
00:21:30 The same with free market economics.
00:21:37 The same thing with so many things that are currently being destroyed.
00:21:42 But you say, Peter, just to come back to that central point, you say, is there some kind of envy?
00:21:48 Here's what I think has been going on.
00:21:52 Western people have lost the ability to say things like I've just said.
00:22:00 because they fear the consequences of saying them.
00:22:04 We have been, as I say, towards the end of the book, in a period of politeness.
00:22:10 The period of politeness involves Western peoples,
00:22:13 even if they know or prefer the Western tradition to say other traditions.
00:22:19 I mean, we obviously prefer our political tradition.
00:22:23 I mean, I don't know how many people actively would like to live in the Chinese Communist Party's dictatorship and think that that's a better system.
00:22:34 They may think in the abstract, some of them, well, it does this, that, and the other.
00:22:37 Oh, yeah. Do you want to live in it?
00:22:39 Would you like to be one of the people in Hong Kong who's had to end up submitting to it, having known a period of freedom?
00:22:46 So we recognize that things in our systems work better.
00:22:51 and yet we have become incapable of saying so because we fear what that means so we're being
00:23:00 polite we've had this period of politeness where you know to give an obvious example
00:23:07 if you're going to try to say something wise or come to a wise conclusion
00:23:13 You know, you could use Immanuel Kant, but it would be better if you could use a Native American tribes leader.
00:23:24 I give the example of Naomi Klein doing this in a hilariously awful work she wrote,
00:23:32 where, you know, she ends up quoting a set of total banalities
00:23:38 by an American First Nations tribal leader.
00:23:44 Why does she do it?
00:23:46 Even Naomi Klein can't actually think this thing she's quoting is interesting,
00:23:50 but it's who's doing the saying that matters.
00:23:53 This is part of the whole trend I'm describing,
00:23:57 that the thing is best if it's not from our tradition.
00:24:00 and we flatter other traditions.
00:24:03 And I think it's partly that, again, this self-distrust we've talked about before,
00:24:08 that if we were to say, well, I just think this is better,
00:24:11 like the Western system of democracy and the peaceful handover of power, for instance.
00:24:15 I mean, you know, there are plenty of societies that don't have that
00:24:20 and haven't had that historically.
00:24:24 It's a pretty amazing thing, a pretty central thing
00:24:27 that our societies in the West have managed to achieve.
00:24:31 It's better.
00:24:32 It's better than other systems, for sure.
00:24:35 Much better than clubbing your neighbours over the head
00:24:38 and taking their stuff,
00:24:40 which has also been part of the Western past.
00:24:42 But we've come to this place,
00:24:43 but we don't have the confidence.
00:24:45 We don't want to say that we think it's better.
00:24:47 We just sort of say it's different.
00:24:49 And then we go from different to other things are better,
00:24:51 so long as they're not ours.
00:24:53 actually i think one of the uh one of the bravest part i do the extraordinary brave of you actually
00:25:00 is along those lines where at one point in the book without giving too much of the book away
00:25:05 uh you talk about a possible answer that could be given by journalist christopher rufo
00:25:11 um and he's asked something along these lines what he's so great about i think it's what he's
00:25:16 great about being white i think he's he's uh yes and uh i can't remember quite what he said but it
00:25:23 was essentially rather trying to you know be evasive and because he obviously it was a trap
00:25:29 it was a trap um but you should say you know there was the nuclear option in a way where
00:25:36 you could actually start to say well this is you this is good that's good that um it's extraordinary
00:25:42 when i read that i just you know when you sort of i felt my goodness you know uh someone is
00:25:48 actually saying this uh something which actually should be perfectly sayable yes yes i i'm so
00:25:56 pleased you say that i as you know with my books i always try not to just take us one step further
00:26:03 ahead but take a sort of jump you know i like to i like to think of book writing as me putting my
00:26:10 my boots on and taking a great jump into the unknown.
00:26:17 So, I'm glad you mentioned this because one of the things which, you know,
00:26:24 I knew I had to tackle in this book, there's no way around it was what I
00:26:27 described as the war on white people.
00:26:29 Now, even saying that, as I say, is something which a lot of people just,
00:26:34 you know, a bristle at or immediately start sweating profusely.
00:26:39 There's no way of avoiding this issue.
00:26:43 Prominent race hucksters who are, again, not fringe figures like Robin DiAngelo,
00:26:51 the author of White Fragility, or the man who calls himself Ibram X. Kendi,
00:26:55 the author of How to Be an Anti-Racist, who also wrote a book explaining
00:27:00 how babies can be anti-racist, which includes at the age of two, I think,
00:27:06 You're meant to explain to babies that policies, not people, are the problem.
00:27:11 Yeah.
00:27:12 Good luck dealing with a two-year-old and trying to describe that, maniac.
00:27:17 Anyhow, but these people have said completely openly, there is no good form of whiteness.
00:27:27 Robin DiAngelo, who happens to be white herself, says this in White Fidelity.
00:27:30 She says, there's no good form of whiteness.
00:27:32 um and here's the rider you can't opt out right you can't opt out of being white and it's all bad
00:27:44 now i completely reject this and i think it's high time that people did
00:27:51 uh i think that these so-called anti-racists are the real racists of our time i've had enough of
00:27:58 them and i think it's time that people started to speak out against them as well
00:28:02 um it is a wicked wicked thing to do to say to any group of people that they are born into some
00:28:12 particular evil a unique evil and that no one else is and that they are evil from the cradle
00:28:19 and they will never and should never be able to escape it i think that is a wicked thing to do
00:28:26 would be a wicked thing to do it to to do to black people would be a wicked thing to do to
00:28:30 people from the Indian subcontinent from China or anywhere else and it's wicked to do it to white
00:28:35 people but it's the one form of this which we allow other racisms who are allowed in the past
00:28:41 but today it's this one racism that is permissible that's not to say that different racisms don't
00:28:47 exist but the only one which gets you positively wafted up in your society in 2022 is if you are
00:28:56 an anti-white figure and as i say these people are very mainstream figures ibram x kendi has a
00:29:04 position at boston university now only previously held a chair only previously held by the holocaust
00:29:11 survivor and nobel prize winner elie wiesel so these figures have pumped racism against white
00:29:19 people into our systems and i very much fear what comes next now one thing that could come next is
00:29:27 white people saying fine uh you're willing to talk about us like that we'll do it to you
00:29:34 that would be a disastrous conclusion to come to and as i've said a few times publicly before
00:29:41 i see elements of that i see elements of it and for instance the reinvigoration of interest in
00:29:47 the differentials of IQ between races. That's effectively a tool which some white people
00:29:54 and others are starting to play with as a very big stick to try to whack back where they think
00:30:01 it'll hurt the people who are currently racially abusing them. So you can see the outline
00:30:07 delineations of a sort of white backlash. That, of course, is not what I'm advocating.
00:30:12 What I'm advocating is a return to a, or indeed an arrival at, a reasonable estimation of ourselves.
00:30:20 And that's what, in the example I give that you mentioned, Chris Rufo, distinguished scholar in America,
00:30:25 who's written extensively on critical race theory, was on a platform with an American black commentator called Mark Lamont Hill,
00:30:35 who said, what is there that's good about being white, Chris Rufo?
00:30:38 And you're right, Chris Rufo dodged it, quite understand that.
00:30:42 um uh didn't realize that his sort of career ending question said i don't really like to
00:30:47 think in these terms let's say there are various ways you can answer that question one is to say
00:30:51 i don't like thinking in those terms and i'm not going to i mean after all i don't know about you
00:30:56 i'm fairly confident that you like me when you were born and brought up didn't think yourself
00:31:01 as white and didn't think you know i you know if somebody said who are you said well i'm a white
00:31:07 person i mean and it wasn't just because it was um more it was a the white people in the cultural
00:31:15 majority it was just that we were told not to think in those terms or sort of just accrued the
00:31:21 fact we didn't think in those terms whether we ever had in the past we don't now we didn't in
00:31:25 the late 20th century early 21st century so that was one way say i just don't like thinking in
00:31:29 terms another way was for rufo to say um effectively whiteness is like like europe is a sort of united
00:31:36 nations you know the whole world can be part of it as i described in the strange death of europe
00:31:42 that that effectively whiteness as it's being described there is a sort of
00:31:47 anyone can be it it's another thing and and another option as i say is the nuclear option
00:31:54 which is just because you see marklamont hill goaded chris rufer he said well i can tell you
00:31:58 what i like about being black and he says rather stereotypical things as it happens you know the
00:32:04 sense of community and the music and things. I thought, crikey, glad it wasn't a white person
00:32:09 saying that about black people. It's not far from, you know, wonderful sense of wisdom.
00:32:17 And so Mark Lamont Hill says, he says, but I can identify all these things I like about being
00:32:21 black. So why can't you identify anything you like about being white? And I say, well,
00:32:26 there is an answer you could give to that, which again, not to give away all of it, but it is
00:32:30 And it includes to say, well, actually, I don't like being asked to think in these terms.
00:32:36 But if you're going to force me to, I suppose I'll have to say the following.
00:32:40 And that includes that I'm the inheritor of the following traditions, the following accomplishments, following things.
00:32:49 um there is a reason why when a global pandemic breaks out we do not go to first nations people
00:32:59 or aboriginal communities in australia and ask them for help in creating vaccines
00:33:03 there is a reason why when we want to send a rocket to the moon or to mars
00:33:14 Nobody goes to find Inuit wisdom to help launch.
00:33:19 OK, we've been polite about some of this, but we know the facts.
00:33:27 And none of this is to say that therefore white people are superior or people of the West are superior by their nature.
00:33:35 But it's to say this is a system that has worked.
00:33:38 The reason we have political harmony, which, again, I mean, it doesn't feel like it to many people, but I can assure them that historically speaking, what we have in countries like Britain is political harmony.
00:33:53 You know, we don't, we solve problems at the ballot box, finally.
00:33:59 You know, we don't, as I say, club our neighbors to death.
00:34:02 um so i say there is this answer that people have not been willing to give but which i think they
00:34:10 may have to give at some point um because otherwise um white people in particular are
00:34:16 invited to spend their lives um apologizing for things that we didn't do um made to feel guilt
00:34:23 for things we had no connection with and i'm not willing to do that absolutely not willing to do
00:34:28 that. I have no historical guilt. I did nothing in the slave trade. I did nothing in the colonial
00:34:35 era. And I resent the tendency in our time to pretend that I have to do some kind of bowing
00:34:41 down. Yes, yes. No, I mean, this is how we've actually, Doug has just had our first conference
00:34:49 here, actually. And the theme of it was, in fact, believing in Britain and the West. And
00:34:55 and what what's clear to me is that people feel these things um they want to know in some ways
00:35:02 what to do you know they they want to know and i suppose i'm just of what i was saying is look
00:35:08 you know find out about your own history essentially you know you you can't really
00:35:14 rely on schools or whatever anymore so do that and teach your children and teach your children
00:35:20 about it. I want to ask one thing, we're talking about, when you say the West, okay
00:35:28 Europe of course, but this has been most sort of acute, this attack, in
00:35:36 America, in Britain, Australia increasingly, Canada, and I just wonder
00:35:43 Do you think it's also, Douglas, the sort of inevitable result of considerable demographic change?
00:35:53 You know, that when you have demographics changing in the way that they,
00:35:57 and indeed, of course, in Europe, as you wrote about in Stranger Things,
00:36:01 could you sort of say, well, this sort of is inevitable.
00:36:04 One culture is basically being forced out, you know, or rather it's being devalued
00:36:10 valued because there is no real interest in it from, you know, the growing demographic.
00:36:18 I think it's definitely a very significant element in it.
00:36:25 Try saying what is said about Britain in any other non-English-speaking country and see how
00:36:31 you get on. I wrote recently in one of the newspapers about some absolute fool I'd never
00:36:38 heard of before who turns out to present an incredibly unpopular show on LBC.
00:36:42 Yes, yes, yes. And she in this weird racist tirade against the British people said,
00:36:49 we're not such a great country actually, we're not a good country, we're not, no one really wants
00:36:54 to come here and us trying to turn people away is just us cutting off our nose to spite our stupid
00:36:59 racist faces. I invite her, if I can remember her eminently forgettable name, to go to any other
00:37:06 country and to tell them they have stupid racist faces which is just incredible i'm lucky to be
00:37:13 saying that in britain i tell her she's damn lucky to be saying that in britain because it's evidence
00:37:18 of our tolerance as a country that we put up with that sort of thing that sort of maligning malignant
00:37:24 insult um i'd have had a few things to say to her i can tell you if i'd have been on her show or ever
00:37:31 heard of it um but but this is this is totally common place and in part i think it has come
00:37:39 about because of demographic change that's true i think that the the the one of the reasons why
00:37:44 the english-speaking nations are particularly vulnerable to it is because we are all to some
00:37:49 extent downstream from american culture you know as i say the blm thing starts in america it has
00:37:55 very little connection to anything to have that happens in britain but immediately we get british
00:38:01 BLM on the streets, tearing at Churchill's statue, assaulting the cenotaph to the war dead in White
00:38:09 Hall, and deriding our precious little monuments, as one contest has called them. That's what you
00:38:17 get. Oh, let's also remember, whilst we're at it, Sasha Johnson, who hasn't been mentioned for some
00:38:22 time, the BLM leader in Oxford, who infamously said, we don't want to be equals, we want white
00:38:29 people to be our slaves. Sasha Johnson was a classic example of a race fader.
00:38:36 Exacerbated anti-white hatred in the UK, was shot in the head in South London, and immediately
00:38:43 politicians, including Diane Abbott, pretended she'd been shot for her political activism.
00:38:48 And it turned out, of course, the men arrested for shooting her were from a gang in the area,
00:38:53 a black gang, who went into the house party that this wonderful mother was at at two or three
00:38:58 o'clock in the morning in south London and shot at the party but there's nothing that they can't
00:39:04 try to push the sort of race agenda onto including black-on-black shootings in London so this is a
00:39:12 lot of this is just us being downstream from American culture but yes the question is what
00:39:21 I describe as politeness you're right to focus on the demographic thing because the politeness
00:39:26 happens on the international level but also on the national level on the day-to-day interactions
00:39:32 with people we sense that it would be politer and kinder if for instance we meet somebody who's
00:39:39 from afghanistan and we talk with them we it's not polite to say you know there's a reason you're
00:39:47 here mate and that you know millions of white people haven't moved to the tribal areas of
00:39:53 Afghanistan or Pakistan, there's a very obvious reason, isn't there? I mean, there is an obvious
00:39:59 reason. I mean, I know people like to talk about colonialism, but actually not very many white
00:40:03 Westerners wanted to go and settle in Pakistan after independence because it's not a very nice
00:40:09 country to live in. There's a very good reason why millions of people from the area wanted to move
00:40:15 from countries like Bangladesh and Pakistan to Britain and other Western countries because it
00:40:22 works better here but we sense that it would be very rather rude to say that and it sort of would
00:40:28 be so we're polite and we say things like what a rich culture you have there and that's not you
00:40:32 know that's not entirely untrue there's rich cultures everywhere around the world but we have
00:40:37 our culture and we have our inheritance and i see no reason at all why we have to pretend that we
00:40:44 don't or pretend that it's awful or anything else simply in order to be polite looking i mean looking
00:40:51 towards the future Doug, I remember
00:40:53 it was in
00:40:55 2016
00:40:57 President Trump in
00:40:58 Warsaw I think
00:41:00 said the central question
00:41:03 of our time is does the West
00:41:05 have a will to survive
00:41:06 I wonder whether
00:41:10 you see any calls
00:41:13 for new hope
00:41:15 you know after what we've seen
00:41:17 happening for example with Ukraine
00:41:19 in the sense that
00:41:21 on a practical level the west has seemed to come together right um but also people have been taken
00:41:29 aback have they not by um the sight of uh men staying at home to fight and uh the women leaving
00:41:37 things like this um and utter uh love of country all of those qualities and perhaps that might give
00:41:46 us the kick in the pants we need or do you think it's possible I mean I think that you know can't
00:41:59 be said enough that the people fleeing Ukraine have principally been women and children and met
00:42:06 non-fighting age by the way that's exactly the opposite of the 2015 migration crisis into Europe
00:42:11 where the women and children were left at home and the majority of people coming were young men
00:42:15 of fighting. So I have absolutely zero tolerance for that equivalence and for the people saying,
00:42:22 oh, you're keener to take in Ukrainian refugees than you were people who pretended to be Syrians
00:42:27 in 2015. A small proportion of them were and most of them weren't. So yes, I think there's been
00:42:33 enormous admiration across the West for the way in which Ukrainians, actually men and women,
00:42:38 have been fighting for their country. And there's always that question, of course,
00:42:42 of whether or not we would do the same.
00:42:46 I wrote about this recently in The Telegraph
00:42:48 when a poll came out showing that actually a near majority
00:42:52 of Americans asked if they would fight for,
00:42:55 stay and fight for their country
00:42:56 were something similar to happen in America,
00:42:58 said that they would not, they would flee.
00:43:01 And that's very, very telling.
00:43:03 But of course, completely understandable.
00:43:07 Of course, this included more Democrats
00:43:09 and Republican voters.
00:43:11 It's completely understandable because, I mean,
00:43:12 if America was invaded, I don't know quite who would invade it,
00:43:16 but why would you stay and fight for a country you've been told was racist
00:43:20 from its beginnings and evil from its beginnings?
00:43:23 Don't forget, again, this is not a fringe thing.
00:43:25 It's the New York Times, the so-called paper of record,
00:43:28 that set up the 1619 Project, which said that the aim of the project
00:43:33 was to reframe and recast the founding date of America to 1619,
00:43:39 which was the date that the first slaves were brought into the continent.
00:43:41 um so if you've been told that actually your nation was not a not not born in a heroic leap
00:43:49 of independence but was born centuries earlier when when slavery first came and you're of course
00:43:55 nobody in america anymore in britain knows that the slave trade was happening absolutely everywhere
00:44:00 in the world at the time and and of course was the bigger slave trade went east of as i write
00:44:07 about in the book, much bigger slave trade, was Africans being traded east to the Arab countries.
00:44:13 Why are there no descendants? Because the Arabs castrated every black male that arrived in order
00:44:19 to make sure they didn't have any descendants. And by the way, still in Arab countries, the word
00:44:24 Abid is used slave as the term for black people. That's still the term used. Okay, so, but if you
00:44:34 an american wondering whether to defend your country if you were hypothetically invaded
00:44:39 why would you if you were born your your founding was slavery you had alleged white supremacy
00:44:47 racism inherent from the beginning um the civil war didn't really happen uh um that uh you had
00:44:55 nothing good to say about yourselves in the 20th century that all of your founding fathers were
00:45:00 were appalling, that your heroes from the North and the South were equally bad in the Civil War,
00:45:07 that Abraham Lincoln was nothing, well, I mean, you know, what exactly would you be fighting for?
00:45:13 The people who express themselves willing to fight for America, I would guarantee are the people who
00:45:17 think that America has done something good generally in its past. Otherwise, there's no
00:45:21 damn reason not to flee for Canada. It's the same with Britain. I explain this in the book. Why do
00:45:28 they come for Churchill because they want to deeply, deeply moralize us in Britain. They want
00:45:33 to say you have no heroes. They've taken away everybody else because they were born or lived
00:45:38 in the era of slavery. They've ignored the fact that our country got rid of slavery uniquely among
00:45:45 civilizations and then policed the high seas at enormous cost of blood and treasure to try to
00:45:50 stamp it out across the globe. We ignore all of that, but we have no heroes left until the 20th
00:45:56 century then we have the greatest heroes in british history and they've decided to deride
00:46:01 winston churchill as a coward and a racist and an imperialist and accuse him of all sorts of things
00:46:06 he didn't do and again i lay this out in detail why do they do it because they want to demoralize
00:46:12 the british they want to say you have nothing now here's the thing historically speaking we have
00:46:19 been in a bit of that before and this is why there isn't the reason not to be downhearted
00:46:23 You're aware of the famous Oxford Union debate in 1934,
00:46:28 34, 33, 34,
00:46:31 where the famous king and country debate at the Oxford Union.
00:46:35 And the king and country debate at the Oxford Union was infamously,
00:46:38 you know, this house would not fight,
00:46:41 would under no circumstances fight for king and country.
00:46:44 And the house voted by a significant majority to approve that motion.
00:46:49 Of course, I mean, if you read the leader pages in the newspapers at the time,
00:46:54 the country exploded in rage at this defeat, pampered generation of Oxford students
00:47:03 who wouldn't take up arms to defend King and Country.
00:47:07 You could say, of course, that since they had grown up in the aftermath of the Great War
00:47:12 and seen a whole generation scythed down, that they would have reasons to be anti-war.
00:47:16 But here's the thing that people forget about that story, of course.
00:47:19 The people in the Oxford Union that night who said that under no circumstances would they ever fight for king and country were precisely the generation who went to do that a few years later.
00:47:30 So you never quite know what you might be capable of as a society or as an individual.
00:47:36 But here's something you can say with total clarity.
00:47:40 there is no reason to defend a society that has nothing good to be said about it
00:47:47 and that is a deliberate thing that has been foisted upon us in recent years and we have to
00:47:54 foist it back on the people who've been claiming it we have every reason to feel pride in what
00:48:01 has happened in our societies we have every right to say this may not be your culture
00:48:06 or your preference but it is ours we have every right to do that other societies do
00:48:14 other groups do and we have that right too so what i very much hope is that i can help
00:48:22 with this book arm people to know better the arguments and the facts they're just the facts
00:48:31 that are needed to push back against the people
00:48:35 who are trying to pull down everything in our society.
00:48:41 Well, Douglas, I think obviously it's going to be
00:48:45 a brilliant success, your book.
00:48:47 I see it, and this is totally spurious opinion,
00:48:52 but I sort of see it as being a kind of part of a trilogy, actually.
00:48:56 you know um you know the themes go the themes absolutely go together um and so
00:49:04 all the very best for it um douglas and um you know i think that
00:49:12 that's a wonderful interview you've given thank you very very much indeed um and um the book is
00:49:19 out ladies and gentlemen the book is out in two days time i think on the 28th of april
00:49:25 um and is that what if you can find a bookshop there are some bookshops that already have it
00:49:31 oh really oh right yes okay so um order early and often is my advice there you go um all right
00:49:41 well look thanks very much indeed for joining us douglas thank you it's been a huge pleasure
00:49:45 thank you that's it for this week so what you're saying is and um we should look forward to seeing
00:49:51 you next week. Thank you. Hello if you're enjoying the New Culture Forum channel and you believe in
00:49:58 our mission may I invite you to join our membership scheme at the link below or on our website
00:50:05 newcultureforum.org.uk. Our work is more important now than ever and we have great plans ahead for
00:50:13 the future but we can't do it without your support. From as little as three pounds per month you can
00:50:18 help ensure that we continue on our mission as a member you'll receive a range of benefits including
00:50:26 access to exclusive content invitations to our private events including here at our studios
00:50:34 free copies of our books and much much more including of course our famous ncf mug
00:50:41 if you aren't able to become a member then please help us by clicking this button and subscribing to
00:50:48 our channel. It's completely free, just remember to also click the bell icon so
00:50:54 that you can get notifications when we post new videos. Thank you.