New Culture Forum - April 18, 2022


Daily Wire: We Are Taking Culture BACK from Left Wing Hollywood, Disney & Other Woke Institutions

Why Can't Politicians Define "Woman"? The War On Whiteness & The West - Murray's Brave New Book Exposes How We're Taught To Hate Ourselves

Episode Stats


Length

26 minutes

Words per minute

186.78

Word count

5,015

Sentence count

152


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to So What You're Saying Is. I'm Peter Whittle. Now, my guest this week,
00:00:23 I'm delighted to welcome back, he's been on the show a number of times, Andrew Klavan, is perhaps
00:00:29 best known to you as the host of The Andrew Clavin Show on The Daily Wire which comes from America
00:00:37 but of course at the same time he is a prolific novelist author screenwriter and his latest book
00:00:46 which has just come out is called The Truth and Beauty now it's got quite a long subtitle to it
00:00:54 which i'm going to read because it's important um the truth and beauty how the lives of england's
00:01:00 greatest poets point the way to a deeper understanding of the words of jesus uh highly
00:01:08 appropriate i think you'll agree this being easter sunday and also for that matter st george's day
00:01:13 next week um thank you very much for joining up very very long intro there and thank you very much
00:01:19 joining it. It is a long subtitle but it's good to see you. Yes, before we talk about that I just
00:01:24 wanted to ask you a little bit the Daily Wire, well a huge amount seems to have been happening
00:01:31 there recently and I mean if I could just start off with one that is very very topical here at
00:01:36 least and that is we had this whole palaver about Disney going very very woke and then there was
00:01:43 this amazing announcement from the Daily Wire that in fact you were going to be starting to do
00:01:48 children's programming. Could you tell us a little bit about that and the context, the background to
00:01:54 it? Yeah. I mean, to get the idea of what's happened maybe five or six years ago, The Daily
00:02:00 Wire was me and Ben Shapiro and the mastermind behind it all, Jeremy Boring, in Jeremy's pool
00:02:07 house, the changing little house next to his pool with a card table doing a 15-minute podcast.
00:02:14 Because of Ben Shapiro's fantastic popularity and because Jeremy is kind of a genius about this, it has sprung up into this huge media company in this very, very short period of time.
00:02:29 It was really a wonder to see.
00:02:31 And all along, all of us agreed that the more important thing than doing commentary was getting into the culture, starting to take the culture back from the left.
00:02:40 Now, I have to say, this is something, a drum I've been banging for 20 years.
00:02:44 I mean, I lived in England for seven years.
00:02:46 When I came back to America, 9-11 happened, and I saw people apologizing to the terrorists
00:02:52 on television.
00:02:54 And I said, something has gone, while I was gone, something has gone terribly wrong with
00:02:57 our culture.
00:02:58 I had thought when I left for England, I was a liberal or a leftist.
00:03:02 When I came back, I discovered, in fact, that I had become, in my absence, a conservative.
00:03:07 And so I started to go to conservative groups and say, we have to do something about the
00:03:11 culture.
00:03:12 We have to work in the movies.
00:03:13 We have to work in publishing and all these things.
00:03:15 And they stared at me like I was out of my mind.
00:03:17 They really did not understand what I was saying.
00:03:20 20 years later, everybody understands.
00:03:22 But Jeremy really has been the one person with all our help, I'd like to say, but really
00:03:28 with him, his leadership has been the one person who has really done something about
00:03:32 it.
00:03:32 So he took, we were a capitalist country.
00:03:35 We took the profits that we made from subscribers and advertising and started to put it into culture, started making movies.
00:03:42 Now, every time the left cancels yet someone else or pollutes something else with their twisted philosophy, he responds by saying, OK, well, then we'll do something else.
00:03:55 So when Disney said openly, I mean, actually, it wasn't, they didn't mean it to be open, but they were caught by reporter Chris Ruffo talking about how they were going to spread, you know, their sexual agenda through Disney cartoons.
00:04:10 Jeremy said, well, great, that leads more audience for us because we will make good, clean family films and family entertainment.
00:04:18 And so that is now what we're doing.
00:04:20 And he's pouring a lot of money into it.
00:04:21 I think the investment he's got plans is a hundred million dollars.
00:04:25 This is, we're already making films for adults and that are, you know, our films don't even have to be conservative.
00:04:33 They just have to be not woke.
00:04:34 They have to be not leftist.
00:04:36 And that's really our only rule.
00:04:37 And they have to be entertaining.
00:04:38 They have to be good films.
00:04:40 And so we're already doing that.
00:04:41 We've got a publishing house where I'll be writing things and other people are writing things.
00:04:46 And it's it's for me, after 20 years of kind of spitting into the wind on this issue, it's incredibly gratifying to be a part of this.
00:04:55 I'm so grateful that I'm still around. I'm so grateful that I'm involved in it.
00:05:00 And it's been just a remarkable thing to see. And the thing about this, Peter, it was fruit lying on the ground.
00:05:06 I mean, all these years, this was the thing that used to drive me nuts as I used to go to these meetings and say, the audience is there.
00:05:13 You know, Fox News is a cable station, which is getting better ratings than the main news stations because of this audience.
00:05:21 Why hasn't Fox built a movie studio? Why hasn't Fox, you know, built a comedy channel and a teenage channel?
00:05:28 Well, we're doing all those things and it's just it's just wonderful to see.
00:05:31 I think pretty much aren't you sort of like in the absolute forefront in that case, The Daily Wire, in doing this?
00:05:39 On the cultural level, absolutely. On the cultural scene, we may be in the forefront. I'm not even sure anybody's behind us yet. I just think it has taken this long for conservatives. I don't know if it's the same in England, but here the conservatives are so busy with their charts and graphs and talking about the economy and talking about the statistics that they forget that politics is also a matter of the human heart.
00:06:04 and the human heart, as James Joyce told us, is, you know, the conscience is forged by artists.
00:06:10 And we really are being a part of that.
00:06:13 But it's just taken conservatives a long time to figure it out.
00:06:16 I think, if anything, I'd say, you know, Andrew, you have worked in the belly of the beast, as it were.
00:06:23 I mean, you know, you're hugely successful novelists, crime novelists.
00:06:28 And, of course, you've adapted some of your novels for the screen, big films.
00:06:33 answer um you know when you were working in that field i mean all the time before maybe now um was
00:06:42 it a source of endless frustration you said that you were always kind of a bit of a liberal i mean
00:06:48 were you were you liberal then did it did it get to you then or not really it didn't it didn't
00:06:55 right away because i'm a genre writer i write crime stories i in film i wrote ghost stories
00:07:00 which I'm very fond of. I love ghost stories. And so it didn't really become a big issue
00:07:05 until 9-11 and the Wars on Terror. And then I remember, I have this incredible memory when I
00:07:15 went in to do a pitch where I was trying to sell them a story. They actually asked me to bring in
00:07:20 a story about something. And I did this pitch and I thought in the middle of this pitch, I was
00:07:25 thinking, this is the best pitch I've ever done. These guys are going to bring in a pot of gold
00:07:29 and empty it into my lap to get me to write this film
00:07:32 because it's such a good fit.
00:07:33 I just felt like I was on fire, you know?
00:07:35 I got to the end of it
00:07:36 and we had just started the war in Afghanistan,
00:07:39 I believe it was.
00:07:41 And the guy said to me,
00:07:43 could we make the villains the American military?
00:07:46 And it had nothing to do with that.
00:07:49 The story had absolutely nothing to do
00:07:50 with the American military.
00:07:51 And just without thinking, I said,
00:07:53 you know, I don't think the public actually wants
00:07:55 to see our military as villains right now
00:07:57 while they're being shot at.
00:07:59 in the field I was out in the parking lot so fast I didn't even let the door hit me in the
00:08:04 backside I mean it was just that was the end of the conversation and that started to happen more
00:08:08 and more and when I started to write articles and actually speak saying you know I don't care what
00:08:15 you think about the wars I think there are two sides you can always it's America you should be
00:08:18 able to express both sides but I don't think it's right to make films making our soldiers look like
00:08:25 rapists and killers and idiots while our soldiers are actually being blown up by very bad people
00:08:32 and my phone stopped ringing i mean i i went from making quite a lot of money to having to basically
00:08:38 having to sell my house uh just to keep going because i was i was turned off like that i i can't
00:08:45 promise you that i was blacklisted no one ever said you're blacklisted uh no one ever called my
00:08:49 agent and said he's blacklisted, but you know, the old, uh, the old saying that Hollywood is
00:08:54 all about money simply isn't true. It is about money, but they can make a lot of money serving
00:08:59 just the left and foreign interests. You know, if they, if they can sell their stuff in China
00:09:05 and it attacks America, they'll, they'll do that. The, you know, the money is always there
00:09:10 and they have become, and with this woke thing now, I'm hearing terrible stories about, uh, racial,
00:09:17 you know quotas where people are being put on films and given credits on films without having
00:09:25 to do anything simply because they're black and this is especially true if the film happens to
00:09:30 be about have a black character in it or be about black people you are not allowed writing while
00:09:36 white is now a crime in Hollywood and all of these things I think have you know now in the
00:09:42 old days i would have said this is terrible but now it just is more more nachos for us at the
00:09:47 daily wire it's more stuff that we can do uh that that people are going to want to see because we
00:09:52 don't care what color people are we just care that they tell good stories and that ultimately
00:09:57 they believe in the good over the evil you know that's basically what we're looking for
00:10:01 um just before we leave that leave that i i wanted to to ask you there you you mentioned that
00:10:06 actually hollywood's not just about money and that they can make enough money serving the left
00:10:12 That's a very interesting point, you see, because I've sort of been thinking, I've been watching, I think, I feel, Hollywood sort of almost killing itself over the past few years, not just with the woke thing, but also with the actors and their anti-Trump sentiments, I mean, the way that they are, you know, talking about the deplorables, you know, that sort of thing.
00:10:33 I would have thought that that would mean people would stop buying tickets to see them.
00:10:39 But really, from what you're saying, you know, maybe not.
00:10:42 Maybe Hollywood can go on being like this.
00:10:45 Yeah, I mean, it's going to have it.
00:10:47 The only time it's going to get them is if we build an industry on the right that can compete.
00:10:53 And then they'll be in trouble.
00:10:55 I mean, look, the Oscars just happened over here.
00:10:57 The Oscars used to have an audience of 55 million people.
00:11:01 it was basically like the super bowl of entertainment we all talked about it we all
00:11:05 sat around the water cooler just debating which film should win this one i think had 15 million
00:11:11 people the one before had closer to 10 uh nobody's watching it and nobody's seen the movies either
00:11:17 because nobody cares about the movies the movies that used to be i mean if you go back to really
00:11:21 hollywood's peak which was 1939 the classic movies were also the best movies were also the
00:11:29 best-selling movies now the movies that are being nominated are films small little arty left-wing
00:11:34 films and the actors get up and make fun of half the country and wag their fingers at half the
00:11:39 country these are people by the way whose moral lives are not exactly exemplary and and yet they
00:11:45 are willing to tell us that if we voted for donald trump or if we even just don't believe
00:11:50 that our children should be taught sexuality in elementary school by someone we don't entirely
00:11:55 know if we believe any of those things we're terrible people and so these these guys who
00:12:00 have been given gifts by god amazing they're they're amazingly beautiful many of them are
00:12:05 amazingly talented actors and writers have decided that rather than just use those gifts to entertain
00:12:12 all of the public they are going to entertain half of the public and not even really half
00:12:17 and then scream at the other half that's not a good business model ultimately it may help them
00:12:23 in China, but it's not helping them here. And so it's like I said, it's just more opportunity for
00:12:28 us at The Daily Wire to build an audience. Now, with The Daily Wire, I should explain actually
00:12:35 that, you know, Andrew very kindly had me on his show. This is about two or three years ago now,
00:12:40 when I came over to Los Angeles. You are no, the Daily Wire is no longer in Los Angeles. At the
00:12:45 time, I seem to remember, Andrew, you were contemplating a move and everything. What's
00:12:50 actually happened you you're now in a different state aren't you yes uh you know it got to the
00:12:56 point i mean i i lived in a very lovely part of los angeles up in the hills by the time i moved
00:13:02 out every night i was going out and walking around my house with a gun uh to make sure that no
00:13:07 homeless people had moved in uh or were trying to uh that's how bad los angeles has become
00:13:13 and it was just terrible and for and for ben who you know has a family of young children he just
00:13:20 didn't want to do it anymore and so uh jeremy finally moved the industry to nashville tennessee
00:13:26 which i don't know if you've ever been to nashville but it's hilarious i'm there every
00:13:30 week and every week it's bigger than it was before and it's all angelenos it's all los angelenos
00:13:35 moving to nashville because it's a good town uh it's a welcoming town the regulations are low
00:13:41 the taxes i don't even think there are any state taxes i i moved to virginia because i have family
00:13:47 that i want to see in new york i have grandkids i want to see in new york and i can get to both
00:13:50 places in an hour by plane so it's a good place for me but everybody there is much freer much
00:13:56 happier the uh whereas in in los angeles and new york the covid lockdowns and covid rules are
00:14:03 endless you get to tennessee and you wouldn't even know such a thing has happened and the numbers are
00:14:10 basically the same the sickness numbers are basically the same so it really is a nice place
00:14:14 to be and it really has helped the industry thrive plus when you walk down the street people
00:14:18 greet you because they recognize you and they like you or in LA if they recognize you you better get
00:14:23 in your car and drive away as quickly as possible. Andrew your new book I think you know the truth
00:14:29 and beauty it's a quite lovely title and of course there was the the subtitle under it which
00:14:36 basically is the point of it if I just to to summarize it to say trying to get to the bottom
00:14:43 of what Jesus actually meant. Is that really what is via English culture or part of English
00:14:51 literary culture? Yeah, it started, I was having a conversation with my son,
00:14:57 who's a brilliant guy, he's an Oxford doctor in classics, and I was talking to him about how
00:15:04 puzzling some of the things Jesus says are, and the fact that some of the things that we quote,
00:15:10 like love your enemies or turn the other cheek are not things we would actually do in real life
00:15:14 and not necessarily things we actually believe in doing. And my son said to me brilliantly,
00:15:20 I thought, he said, you know, I think you're trying to understand a philosophy instead of
00:15:24 trying to get to know a person. And I thought that that was such a wonderful thing to say,
00:15:28 because when you know somebody, when you seriously know someone, you don't really think about their
00:15:32 philosophy of life. You think about what they would see if they were there. So I know my wife
00:15:37 very well. I think, oh, she would really like this movie that I'm watching, or she'd enjoy this book
00:15:41 because I know her. And so I went back to the Gospels. I actually taught myself Greek, though
00:15:46 not very well, but I taught myself enough Greek to be able to read the Gospels. And I read them
00:15:50 in a new way, which was simply like an autobiography or a novel where you just try to get to know the
00:15:58 main character. You just try to understand what he has seen. And thinking about it that way and
00:16:03 putting all theology aside. I mean, some of my Catholic friends are angry at me because I,
00:16:07 you know, put aside Catholic theology, but I also put aside Protestant theology and even Paul,
00:16:12 I don't even make any reference to Paul, just reading Jesus, what he's saying. And as I was
00:16:18 doing that, I found lines of poetry coming back to me. And they were the lines of poetry from
00:16:24 the romantic poets, which puzzled me at first. But I understood after a while, I started to
00:16:30 realize that the romantic poets when i'm talking about wordsworth coleridge keats um mary shelley
00:16:35 not a poet but one of the romantics they were actually living at a time that is so similar to
00:16:41 this one that it's uncanny uh the the revolutionary politics that grew out of the french revolution
00:16:46 the failure of those politics the disaster that those politics led to uh the tendency among the
00:16:53 intellectuals to cancel anybody who recognized that failure just like if you recognize the
00:16:57 failure of socialism and communism now you're canceled um the that attempt that the french
00:17:03 made in the french revolution to just rewrite all of nature they weren't just going to you know get
00:17:07 rid of the king and have a democracy no they were going to actually rewrite uh gender roles they
00:17:12 were going to rewrite everything and the rejection the ultimate failure of that and the rejection of
00:17:15 that and at the heart of it all the the beginning of non-belief the rise of science which gave rise
00:17:23 for the first time to people in what had been Christendom saying, you know what, not only do I
00:17:28 not believe in Christianity, but I may not even believe in God. And it was really the first time
00:17:33 that had become a totally acceptable thing to say. Although I shouldn't say totally acceptable,
00:17:38 Shelley was kicked out of college for being an atheist, but still it was becoming more and more
00:17:45 common. And these poets had to reinvent the human consciousness. They reinvented Western
00:17:51 consciousness for a new age. And in doing that, they came back to a lot of the truths that Jesus
00:17:57 had taught them. And so it was this wonderful revelation that what Jesus, Jesus was actually
00:18:02 saying something. He was actually telling you a way to live, a way to see the world. And as he put
00:18:09 it, he said, I want my joy to be in you. That's a quote you don't hear very much when people are
00:18:14 quoting Jesus, but that's what he was trying to accomplish. And, and that I think in some ways
00:18:19 was what some of these poets were trying to accomplish even when they didn't know that's
00:18:23 what they were trying to do. So it's not a book for poetry lovers. You know, in America, we don't
00:18:28 have any poetry lovers, so it would have been foolish to write such a book. But it's a book
00:18:32 about the lives of these guys and the thought and the things that happened, which are just great
00:18:36 stories. And then at the end, the last third of the book is revisiting the gospels from this new
00:18:42 direction. And it doesn't change what Jesus says. It simply brings it in to a modern understanding
00:18:49 of what jesus says it's the same jesus he doesn't change he's the same yesterday today and forever
00:18:53 but it is a new way or a new way for us to understand them and it's really uh it really
00:18:59 had a big effect on me and it's apparently from the people writing me and the reviews it's getting
00:19:03 on amazon it's having a big effect on on other people too which is also very gratifying because
00:19:09 i thought i'm never going to be able to sell this book i wrote it without telling anybody about it
00:19:13 besides my wife, I thought there's only one editor that I know of who would buy it.
00:19:18 I sent it to that editor, and he did buy it, and that has been so supportive at Zondervan,
00:19:24 and it has just been a really great experience.
00:19:26 But anyway, it's a really, it's different.
00:19:28 It's not a book anybody else has written, and I think it'll refresh the way you read the Gospels.
00:19:33 I think, as you say, some of the reviews you've been having, I mean, some of the recommendations,
00:19:40 I mean, you know, are euphoric.
00:19:43 Jordan Peterson, you know, is saying wonderful things about it.
00:19:48 Just to remember, actually, when we were talking before,
00:19:54 and you were actually, you were from a secular Jewish family, is that right?
00:20:00 Right.
00:20:00 And you converted to Christianity quite late, relatively late.
00:20:03 um and so is it right to say that christianity jesus is actually playing an increasing role
00:20:12 in your life do you think or yeah oh yes i think uh it's that c.s lewis line i can't remember it
00:20:18 exactly but he says something like you invite invite a carpenter in uh to fix something in
00:20:23 the house and he ends up tearing the whole house down and rebuilding it and that that has definitely
00:20:26 been my my experience uh it has been it's you know when i when i converted when i became a
00:20:34 christian i said to myself you know if this makes me nuts if it suddenly i can't talk about reality
00:20:40 anymore if suddenly i'm constantly walking around with a big stupid grin on my face saying how
00:20:45 blessed i am even though i just lost my job and my wife left me you know that that thing that
00:20:49 christians do where they seem to detach from reality i thought i'll i'll ditch it you know
00:20:54 I'll say I was wrong. But instead, it has made me a far more realistic person and more accepting of
00:21:03 the tragic nature of life, but at the same time, a lot more serene and joyful. I cannot, it is very
00:21:10 nice that my wife, who does know me very well, we've been married over 40 years, she turns to
00:21:15 me from time to time and says, you know, you're like a different person. Three weeks after I was
00:21:21 baptized she said you know you've utterly changed your you've got the serenity and this joy and that
00:21:25 has just continued uh and when i say joy it's what the poets called gusto i don't mean happiness i
00:21:31 mean a full involvement in life and a full acceptance of life with all its ups and downs
00:21:37 uh it has been a remarkable experience and i just you know i wish i could just sell it to people but
00:21:44 i know how awful it is to be preached to uh and i just hope that people will people who have been
00:21:49 taught, who've been guided by the default setting of modernity that tells you you're a fool if you
00:21:55 believe, that science has disproved it all, that no modern person would fall for this. I hope that
00:22:02 some people will at least be moved to put that aside and at least consider whether what this
00:22:08 man Jesus was saying wouldn't improve the way they're living. I remember we discussed when I
00:22:13 when I came to see you, I remember we talking about being a cultural Christian and I think I
00:22:19 asked you and I sort of said I you know I've always seen myself as being a
00:22:22 cultural Christian, is that enough? and I think you were very frank with me and
00:22:27 and I think you said well perhaps not you know I mean you know in other words
00:22:32 is one just piggybacking on something else? I mean you know you would sort of
00:22:39 say would you that you know you're missing something if you are just a
00:22:44 a cultural Christian how can you be just a cultural Christian isn't isn't that the question
00:22:49 really it it is you know this is a phenomenon in some ways this was the inspiration behind the book
00:22:55 this is almost the person I had in my mind when I was writing the book where people like like
00:23:00 Jordan Peterson to some extent uh Marcello Perra in Italy uh Douglas Murray have I got his name
00:23:06 right yes uh who all say they all say god is necessary and yet i can't believe or in in
00:23:14 jordan peterson's case i can't quite come out and say that i believe and i i think that
00:23:20 ultimately that collapses ultimately um in order to come to the conclusions the christian
00:23:28 conclusions you have to have the christian premises and and so i understand why they feel
00:23:34 that way. I grew up, as you say, in a Jewish family, but also I worked in Hollywood and in
00:23:40 publishing in New York and in LA and in London, all places where to say, you know, I'm a Christian
00:23:47 is really like confessing that, you know, you're doing something really nuts, you know. And
00:23:53 frequently people will say, well, I'm a Christian, but I'm not that kind of Christian, or they'll
00:23:57 make some excuse for it. Whereas instead, I really have come to feel that the logic is all on my side
00:24:04 uh the the science now also is all on my side there's some wonderful new books about that about
00:24:10 just the fact that uh that the science does not turn out to be uh this to disprove the the theology
00:24:18 of christianity and so i i ultimately think that that cultural christianity i get it i understand
00:24:25 why people like para and you know jordan and all that don't quite want to grasp it but i don't
00:24:30 think it will hold up and i think when the steamroller of the culture comes starts going
00:24:36 in the other direction as it so obviously is uh it'll flatten you well isn't this something
00:24:43 actually andrew that you could turn into a very good documentary for for the channel actually for
00:24:50 for uh daily wire i mean it seems you know a beautiful thought yeah it's a beautiful author
00:24:57 the thing um look thank you so much for talking about it the book is available is it not on
00:25:01 amazon here in britain i mean it's it's it's available now isn't it yes it is and i think
00:25:06 and i think they also publish it in england as well oh they right okay well that's it the truth
00:25:12 and beauty which is by andrew clavin uh i'm certainly going to read it um andrew look happy
00:25:19 easter to you and to you as well and happy st george's day yes thank you very much lovely to
00:25:26 see you again thank you it's great to see you as well take care bye that's it for um so what
00:25:31 you're saying is this week we will be back same time next week thanks very much hello if you're
00:25:38 enjoying the new culture forum channel and you believe in our mission may i invite you to join
00:25:44 our membership scheme at the link below or on our website newcultureforum.org.uk our work is more
00:25:53 important now than ever and we have great plans ahead for the future but we can't do it without
00:25:58 your support. From as little as three pounds per month you can help ensure that we continue on our
00:26:05 mission. As a member you'll receive a range of benefits including access to exclusive content,
00:26:12 invitations to our private events including here at our studios, free copies of our books
00:26:19 and much much more including of course our famous NCF mug. If you aren't able
00:26:25 to become a member then please help us by clicking this button and subscribing
00:26:31 to our channel. It's completely free, just remember to also click the bell icon so
00:26:37 that you can get notifications when we post new videos. Thank you.
00:26:49 You