New Culture Forum - April 12, 2022


Why Can't Politicians Define "Woman"?

Why Western Liberals Hate Orban's Hungary & Why Conservatives Have Embraced It Daily Wire: We Are Taking Culture BACK from Left Wing Hollywood, Disney & Other Woke Institutions

Episode Stats


Length

50 minutes

Words per minute

167.01

Word count

8,380

Sentence count

206


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to this week's edition of Newspeak, the New Culture Forum's current
00:00:10 affairs programme. My name is Emma Webb and I am joined this week by the director of the
00:00:15 New Culture Forum Peter Whittle and Caroline Fisk from Conservatives for Women. This week
00:00:20 in the news we've seen the victory of Orbán in Hungary as well as the latest news surrounding
00:00:25 women's rights and what has been hailed as a new suffragette movement so if we could begin by
00:00:30 kicking off by talking about the campaign that you're involved with caroline would you be able
00:00:33 to give us an update on exactly what that campaign is about and what your objectives are okay so i'm
00:00:39 caroline fisk from conservatives for women and the reason we formed was we became more and more aware
00:00:46 of how gender ideology which is about preferencing the idea of sort of an inner gender identity over
00:00:52 sex, how that was more and more being preferenced in law and legislation and spaces. So, for example,
00:01:01 that trans identifying males, you know, should they be allowed into women's spaces? Should they
00:01:07 be allowed into women's sports? Should they be allowed into NHS hospital wards? And so, so much
00:01:14 of this was actually happening and the government seemed to be behind it, the Labour Party getting
00:01:19 behind it. Politicians becoming fearful of even actually saying what a woman is. So
00:01:25 Conservatives for Women formed to challenge this, to say that biological sex is real,
00:01:31 that science is real, that we must pursue truth and we need open debate about this issue and its
00:01:37 policy implications. So therefore, so Conservatives for Women formed and then we teamed up with women
00:01:43 from other parties to form Women Uniting. And as the local elections are coming up, we thought this
00:01:48 is the ideal time to really take this out to the public. So we joined up with the Women's Rights
00:01:54 Network, which is grassroots women who are very concerned about this issue, and with Sex Matters,
00:02:00 which is Maya Forstater's group. Maya Forstater, yeah. Okay, so Maya lost her job because she was
00:02:06 tweeting about this issue, and she effectively was tweeting about the idea that sex matters,
00:02:12 and that sex is real and that women are adult human females and she lost her job.
00:02:19 So she's gone on to found sex matters and the three groups have come together,
00:02:24 really ideal grouping, and are taking it out to the wider public now and are saying with the run
00:02:29 up to the local elections we want to challenge all candidates and all campaigners and all the
00:02:35 political parties to say where do you stand on this issue and will you protect women's single
00:02:40 sex spaces women's sports and women's rights i've seen sorry can i just i've seen in the paper
00:02:47 like you've had a lot of coverage this week um but there are three of you aren't there
00:02:52 um so one of those be my awful starter okay so heather binning founded the women's rights network
00:02:59 and so what that is you can just imagine women getting so frustrated as you know so many things
00:03:06 happen, like they're watching on the television about, you know, men competing in women's sports
00:03:11 and at the highest level at the Olympics. So women found each other via social media, Mumsnet,
00:03:18 Twitter, and sort of said, well, what can we all do? I mean, we've really got to defend our rights
00:03:23 and we've got to defend science and the truth. So they actually formed grassroots groupings
00:03:28 and Heather really helped to bring them all together and to introduce women to each other
00:03:33 so we can talk and say what can we do so that's a really amazing grassroots movement and men and
00:03:41 women from all over the country can join that so it's an amazing threesome because we've got that
00:03:45 grassroots of anyone who's interested in this issue can join in then we've got women who have
00:03:50 associated themselves with political parties and we're really clear that we want all parties to
00:03:56 address this some people have said to us well will you go off and found a new party we're saying
00:04:01 absolutely not science is real you know the sexes are real so we want all the political parties to
00:04:08 engage in this and that's why we've united and then you've obviously got sex matters which is
00:04:13 becoming a little bit like a think tank really focusing on policy and really focusing on you
00:04:19 know facing into government and saying we need to talk about these matters so it's an ideal grouping
00:04:23 across the three groups by way of explaining to our audience why this is necessary what are the
00:04:30 I know, obviously, in the last couple of weeks, there have been a lot of news stories surrounding sex based rights and gender and particularly Labour Party politicians.
00:04:38 But across the board, politicians being very frightened of answering the question, what is a woman?
00:04:44 So would you be able to give our audience sort of a better understanding of the context from which this campaign is emerging and why it's necessary?
00:04:53 Gosh, it's a big question.
00:04:54 Okay, so one of the difficult things about this is it's become so big.
00:05:01 So the NHS has stopped really defending single-sex wards.
00:05:08 The NHS has stopped defending single-sex services.
00:05:13 So if a woman, she's going in for an intimate service,
00:05:16 and maybe she's a Muslim, she's Jewish, she's Christian,
00:05:19 and she says, I just want you to be absolutely clear
00:05:22 that the doctor or the nurse will be female.
00:05:25 Now, the NHS has kind of backed away of, you know, really understanding her question for how we all understand that question.
00:05:34 So that's the NHS prisons. Probably lots of people in this country don't realise that men are now in women's prisons if they identify as female.
00:05:45 Most of them will physically, you know, they won't have undergone any surgery or anything.
00:05:50 And so they're in prison. They might be violent offenders, but they're in women's prisons.
00:05:54 And we're saying that that's just wrong.
00:05:56 So it's right across our sort of public services that women's single-sex spaces are under attack.
00:06:03 And then, you know, it's going all the way up through language being under attack.
00:06:07 So probably lots of people listening have heard that politicians have become afraid to answer a straight question, what is a woman?
00:06:15 Right across the board, I'd say, because Rishi Sunak also didn't, didn't he?
00:06:19 On that National Health Service point there was a terrible case, I mean actually
00:06:25 it was a really upsetting case, where a woman said she'd been raped and they
00:06:31 effectively in this kind of Orwellian way said you couldn't have been raped
00:06:35 because there are no men on the ward. Well there was a trans woman on the ward
00:06:39 and they've now admitted that in fact you know he was there and he thought
00:06:45 the rape occurred but the thing is is that that's a fantastic example isn't it of ideology trumping
00:06:52 safety and the NHS absolutely so ideology has been trumpeting safety um so that's again prison
00:07:01 or hospital wards as you said but prisons but actually on safety sports it's not safe for um
00:07:08 bigger stronger men to be competing in contact sports with women but they are
00:07:14 An element of this as well, isn't it? It's the balancing of rights, because when women
00:07:19 are saying we want to protect our same sex spaces because of safety concerns, because
00:07:24 of privacy, sometimes because of, you know, just purely from embarrassment and wanting
00:07:28 to be able to feel comfortable and have those spaces, that that doesn't necessarily mean
00:07:34 you're saying that trans people, you know, don't have basic human dignity and shouldn't
00:07:40 be equal under the law and so on. But in the balancing of rights, why do you think it is that
00:07:46 trans and gender ideologies become so elevated to the detriment of women? Because obviously women
00:07:54 have started organising more and more around this in the last year or so and even in the last couple
00:07:59 of months. Is that simply because trans activists have been far more active than women's rights
00:08:04 activists? And do you think that this has been compared to a new suffragette movement? Do you
00:08:10 think that that's the direction that this is going to take okay so this is yeah the direction that
00:08:14 it's going to take is that women are absolutely standing up and saying we are part of the
00:08:18 conversation maybe that's just where we're trying to get to initially but so how did this get so
00:08:24 far so fast so a huge component of that seems to have been stonewall and i would like to you know
00:08:31 somebody to write the history of this that stonewall was a hugely respected organization
00:08:36 that fought for gay rights and so was present in almost all of our large institutions right across
00:08:43 the public sector, across local government, across the biggest, the banks and the supermarkets.
00:08:48 Pretty much all of our major corporations were members of Stonewall. So I think it's about four
00:08:55 or five years ago, Stonewall added the T to the LGB and really started prioritising gender ideology.
00:09:03 so you can imagine that if they're in an organization as a progressive presence
00:09:08 and people are used to respecting them and understanding that they are at the foreground of
00:09:15 preference prioritizing people's rights and dignity so when this comes along and Stonewall
00:09:20 is saying you know this is what we now need to do it's like everybody has listened and everybody
00:09:25 has thought okay this is what we have to do now I think added to that is everybody thought yeah
00:09:33 it's a small number of people.
00:09:35 So if there's somebody really in distress
00:09:37 with, you know, severe gender dysphoria,
00:09:39 I think pretty much all women,
00:09:40 and obviously our history is that we've accommodated
00:09:43 trans identifying people.
00:09:47 So, and I think it all still might've been fine,
00:09:49 but then we've got this huge social media movement
00:09:52 where more and more people are identifying as trans.
00:09:56 And I think women are saying, we can't take the numbers.
00:10:01 It was absolutely fine to be kind,
00:10:02 like in a nightclub, gosh, you know, once or twice a year, there might have been, you know,
00:10:07 a man who's a transsexual in the women's toilets and everybody just gets on and it's great.
00:10:13 But when there's more and more people, we're saying, hang on a second. We now, we need to
00:10:19 do a rebalancing here and we need to consider women's rights. And in the Equality Act, there's
00:10:23 other protected characteristics, religion, and religious women are affected by this.
00:10:29 strongly religious, Jewish, Muslim, Christian women, they can't go into a space where they
00:10:36 think there might be men if they're going to be getting unchanged, swimming, etc. So we need to
00:10:41 sort of say all the protected characteristics need to be in a conversation and all of their
00:10:46 rights need to be balanced. What do you think of the, so there are some people who've said that
00:10:52 the way that women have been, not only the way that women have been raised, but also the way
00:10:57 that women are being silenced when they try to object and actually speak up on behalf of their
00:11:02 own rights, that there have been some that have said that there is an element of misogyny in that.
00:11:06 Would you agree with them? I absolutely think so. So women have said we want single sex spaces
00:11:15 and we want to be able to discuss our single sex spaces. Now, when people have just sort of said
00:11:21 you can't discuss that um that's kind of like you know you need to be silent and there's another
00:11:28 thing that comes out always is be kind so i kind of love the way the people who say be kind are
00:11:36 never kind yeah no this is what i'm interested in a simple way rule of thumb they're going to
00:11:42 be nasty people yeah so i'm always just amazed by that because obviously kindness goes both ways
00:11:47 and yet the be kind is to women you lot must be kind so effectively they're saying
00:11:55 the trans identifying man he must be prioritized yeah and you must step back women's and you must
00:12:03 be kind and so there is a misogyny in that isn't there that um you know you take the hit well we're
00:12:10 actually saying you know one of our phrases is women are human you know we're all equals i have
00:12:15 say though, Carolyn, one thing that has surprised me is that more women aren't more up in arms
00:12:22 about it. Well, I can tell you why that is. It is fear. And it's a great thing, isn't it, that our
00:12:30 society, all those isms, you know, people hate to be called racist, they hate to be called sexist,
00:12:38 and that's great that we've got that far, but people hate to be called transphobic. It's
00:12:43 really been weaponized so it's just been very very successful that if you're in a workplace
00:12:51 and you know a trans-identifying person is using the women's loos and people's livelihoods are at
00:12:57 stake yeah a woman is um transphobic if she challenges that and then her livelihood is
00:13:03 at stake as well you see this to me is sort of stalinist it's stalinist yeah just calling
00:13:07 someone transphobic, which is a very strong word.
00:13:11 Even if you look at the people who get cancelled, that actually a vast majority, it seems, of
00:13:18 people getting cancelled, fired from their jobs, no-platformed, they're what would be
00:13:23 described as gender-critical feminists. And even in the, I think it actually goes, it
00:13:28 suggests how far we've gone in this and how entrenched the ideology has become, that even
00:13:33 in Maya Forstater's case the idea that gender critical beliefs are a protected philosophical
00:13:39 belief is itself absurd because it's not a belief it's a statement of biological fact
00:13:44 and so even that in some way makes it seem like it is less of itself if that makes sense. I know
00:13:50 and I my understanding is she had to fight it that way the way you know the Equality Act etc
00:13:54 is structured so it had to be structured as a belief. Because it's the only way you can fight
00:13:57 for it and yet um you know this is why well people like myself have sort of you know stepped up to
00:14:04 say our society must defend science mustn't we you know how do we go forward if we sort of start
00:14:12 moving away from science and that's true stalinist that scientists it's like um i can't remember the
00:14:18 name of the famous scientist's name is it so so winston um and when he he he um or lord even he
00:14:26 he came out and spoke out against this that even scientists are being told that they have to deny
00:14:31 science they have to deny statements of biological fact otherwise i mean there's another way of
00:14:36 looking at this i'd say it's not to diminish what you're doing but that i don't even know
00:14:40 how sincere actually the trans movement is i i when i say that i mean i don't i think that
00:14:49 it's being used right i just like the other ones you mentioned uh you know race and what i have
00:14:56 you um these are things are being used as a way of undermining and and actually sort of
00:15:05 trying to destroy our sense of what we are even you know i'll say basically i know that it's not
00:15:11 a conspiracy theory it's just not but basically i think it's a lot of it is in bad face i think
00:15:18 there's there's no real hurt it is a way of somehow fighting a political battle
00:15:24 and if you can demoralize people as much as they are currently are or make them
00:15:30 shut up and you know it's just there are t-shirts you can get saying be quiet if
00:15:36 you can't be this that another be quiet I mean you know corporates if chief
00:15:41 execs wear these there was one in the Sunday Times this weekend wearing this
00:15:45 sort of stuff. And I think it stings. But I think it is a kind of form of attack going
00:15:52 through all of our institutions. You're quite right, no one is going to say, you know, what
00:15:56 do you, if you say transphobic, what is the comeback from that? What is the, no, no, I'm
00:16:01 not transphobic, but I just feel this, you know, get it.
00:16:04 So, so for me, sort of slowly coming into this debate, I felt like the gender critical
00:16:10 feminists had absolutely focused on the women's rights angle and protecting women's single-sex
00:16:16 spaces and sports and so for me as a conservative i felt that what wasn't getting enough of an airing
00:16:22 was exactly what you're talking about that um actually undermining science we we all know that
00:16:29 you know there are two sexes that's how evolution happened um so to be undermining science it's one
00:16:35 of the foundations of our society and the pursuit of truth yeah so to be sort of running away from
00:16:41 truth free speech some people would say the absolute foundation is free speech and of course
00:16:47 on this is the premier issue where you're not allowed free speech you must not talk about it
00:16:53 you must be quiet and be kind so when science is undermined the pursuit of truth is undermined
00:16:59 um free speech free speech is undermined it's an attack on our society and how we live
00:17:05 and that's why we all must push back and say enough is enough and there are also implications
00:17:13 as well for the whole idea of self-id for free speech so this is something that's also been in
00:17:19 the press this week surrounding the government's decision on conversion therapy to not include
00:17:23 to have conversion therapy defined as being for homosexuals not including trans in that
00:17:30 because when conversion therapy is used to describe something that takes place with trans people
00:17:36 they're basically saying is conversion therapy is anything other than affirming somebody's self-ID
00:17:42 but this has come in the same week as this conservative MP has come out saying that he's trans
00:17:47 but also isn't going to change his pronouns from he him he's continuing to live his life as a man
00:17:54 and to be understood as a man you know referring to his biological sex um so obviously that there
00:18:01 have to be why did he say it then it was a very good question why did he say it but you know this
00:18:07 obviously has implications for free speech if um there are at least some activists stonewall namely
00:18:14 very unhappy that the government has made this decision because it means that there will be
00:18:20 other options open to people who are experiencing gender dysphoria other than just the medical
00:18:25 pathway. But even that alone, if somebody says, you know, I identify as, if I identify as a man
00:18:31 and you tell me, you know, are you sure about that, that that would almost be, that would be
00:18:36 conversion therapy. That's conversion therapy and made illegal. Well, it's the same as sort of,
00:18:40 know the whole movement of anti-racism uh we are going to make this institution an anti-racist
00:18:46 the implication being that it was racist before and how on earth do you say i am against this
00:18:52 what you mean you're racist it's all about the use of language and basically co-opting taking
00:18:58 over the language you know it's the same thing it's and it's but the but the point comes i mean
00:19:04 i think what you're doing is fantastic because i think you've hit on something by simply
00:19:10 very clear these things come down i think to something very simple you want to ask politicians
00:19:15 standing at the local elections so we picked the local elections just because well time to get
00:19:21 going well because they'll be on show and they're coming up yeah you're going to have your work cut
00:19:25 out going around the country but you've actually come up with something where you say define a
00:19:30 woman do you think a woman has a penis right or whatever that that clarifies it very very well
00:19:37 And, you know, the other very simple one is, will you defend women and girls' single-sex spaces?
00:19:43 Because all local authorities, you know, run swimming pools, playgrounds.
00:19:47 So the playgrounds will have toilets.
00:19:50 And like in planning, like say somebody's, you know, a great big new building is going up, new office space.
00:19:55 Will you ensure that there are single-sex toilets there?
00:19:58 So it's absolutely a local authority issue.
00:20:01 But Peter, I just want to go back to what you were saying, because we're building up a list of what's under attack.
00:20:07 And we said science, free speech.
00:20:11 We said something else there as well.
00:20:13 And you added language.
00:20:15 You know, our language is ours.
00:20:17 It's ours to evolve.
00:20:18 And that's a very democratic thing, isn't it?
00:20:21 It's not for anybody to come over the top of us and say, we're changing how you speak.
00:20:25 And this is a movement which is trying to say, we're going to tell you how to speak.
00:20:32 And we just say, no, you can't.
00:20:34 Nobody tells us how to speak.
00:20:36 that evolves democratically the thing is i think your grassroots grassroots movement
00:20:41 uh you know you say oh well people can't just come to us and say we're going to
00:20:47 we're going to uh change the way you think and watch how you say things
00:20:52 we no longer have the luxury of people defending us that's the point yeah the very people who
00:21:00 should be making these points in defense of us are just on board with all of this you know they're
00:21:07 on board with the whole thing yeah you know so basically everything has got to be grassroots
00:21:12 it's absolutely got to be grassroots and you know we're we're defending our way of life yes
00:21:18 um that sounds like a trivial phrase doesn't it but it's literally defending the foundations of
00:21:24 our society. Science, reason, free speech, language. And I'll add another one. I can hardly
00:21:32 get my head around it. But so this idea that, you know, that we can't really be sure. So the
00:21:39 British Library put out an email to its staff saying, you know, you shouldn't just automatically
00:21:46 sort of sex somebody gender them when you first meet them I mean so I'm when I saw you earlier
00:21:54 today I was meant to stand back from the integrity of my senses and and wait to find out from you
00:22:02 whether you were male or female. That surely has huge implications in that you're actually asking
00:22:06 and I and I mean there are safeguarding concerns around this too because I don't remember how long
00:22:12 ago this was it was probably before the pandemic um there was a sign i think it was oxford university
00:22:18 that was put up on a toilet door that said something like if you see someone in this in
00:22:22 this toilet that you don't think belongs here basically shut up don't say anything and so if
00:22:28 you're you were saying about you know the the bigger implications of this for our culture and
00:22:33 so on if you're telling people to deny what they believe to be true to say things that they believe
00:22:39 to be untrue and to simply to as a sort of almost as an automatic reflex to instinctively
00:22:46 step back from your own perception of things your own understanding of a situation you are putting
00:22:52 people in danger in the biggest sense never mind in the in the in the more narrow restricted sense
00:22:58 of allowing men into women's spaces and particularly spaces where there may be vulnerable women but on
00:23:05 broader sense this is surely a danger for the whole of society yeah okay so in at two levels the one of
00:23:11 just step back from your insta you know from your senses so that's challenging our very
00:23:17 kind of reasoning you know our linkage with our senses and how we quickly think i mean
00:23:22 you see if it's almost gaslight it's abuse so it's abusive but then to sort of the broader
00:23:26 safeguarding um but this has been going on i would say for a very long time uh in all sorts
00:23:31 different guises for example take immigration right take the issue of immigration um basically
00:23:38 now what what happened was that the narrative became pushed by governments cultural establishment
00:23:45 the lot that britain was a nation of immigrants right this is simply untrue right it's simply
00:23:51 untrue it was not in fact we had remarkably little for years and years and years whatever
00:23:56 you think about immigration but the idea was to somehow take away from people the ability to argue
00:24:04 their point about that um and also by putting huge sanctions and saying you know this what are you
00:24:11 saying you're out this isn't a good thing that diversity isn't strength so you know actually
00:24:16 there's not a jot or scintilla of evidence saying that diversity is strength right but somehow we
00:24:23 still keep saying it don't we and you wouldn't not say it and this that's a
00:24:28 triumph of of kind of the takeover in a way of language I think that those are
00:24:34 political issues what's particularly fundamental about this is it's our very
00:24:39 nature of how we define what we are by the way so I haven't brought in that
00:24:44 we've built up our list of what's under attack and honestly our sexuality I mean
00:24:49 all of us are either you know heterosexually attracted same-sex attracted you know I think
00:24:55 a small number of people are bisexual but this movement again tries to guest light us about our
00:25:01 sexuality and very particular gay people and tells gay people that they're transphobic if they don't
00:25:06 fancy someone who is identifying as that gender but did you see um so speaking of the denial of
00:25:12 reality there was a tweet a couple of weeks ago a trans person tweeted saying that they were
00:25:17 experiencing their first period cramps as a trans woman and women women see that and know that a
00:25:25 trans somebody who's transitioned from being male to female and identifies as a woman
00:25:30 is not experiencing the same things that a woman experiences they cannot experience the same things
00:25:36 that a woman experiences they can't get pregnant they can't have periods full stop so whatever that
00:25:41 person is experiencing or believes they're experiencing or saying they're experiencing
00:25:45 if a woman says no sorry that is not the same thing she is faced with a choice between denying
00:25:52 reality um or being accused of being a transphobe so actually at the very very core of it
00:25:58 describing this as abusive and gaslighting it's telling women that you not only is it trying to
00:26:03 erase women but telling women no your experience of yourself is is wrong and you're not allowed to
00:26:10 express your experience and surely never mind misogyny surely that is and I you know I would
00:26:15 never have never identified myself publicly in any way as being a feminist or possibly even
00:26:20 privately but that surely is the most anti-feminist thing that you could ever do to a woman I mean
00:26:27 look it's it's just absolute gaslighting of us and our sense of reality and that's why we've
00:26:35 come together and across political parties to say enough is enough. We're pushing back now.
00:26:42 We're reclaiming our language. We're reclaiming our right to speak. And we don't have the answers
00:26:48 yet. Of course, there's all kinds of areas where we can debate. But I just want to say all the
00:26:53 characteristics are protected. So we want to talk with trans identifying people, but say we're in
00:27:00 debate as well. And our rights matter. You've been writing and active for quite a long time,
00:27:07 Caroline, but you're probably going to have to get ready for people to really start being abusive
00:27:12 and things like that. Maybe they haven't already. Maybe they've already been rough to you, but
00:27:18 I think that such is the level of hatred and anger. This idea that somehow,
00:27:26 you know this to say this be kind thing this idea that somehow we are on the side of the angels no
00:27:33 you're not actually you just dislike you dislike you hate you resent those the emotions that i
00:27:42 feel come from these people all the time so before we move on to the hungarian elections if to it's
00:27:48 not really a lighter note but let's let's dip into this story anyway so another story that came out
00:27:53 up this week was the decision by um sterling university to drop jane austen from their
00:27:58 curriculum in order to decolonize it and um they have dropped it in favor of works by
00:28:05 an african-american author called tony morrison i have to admit i've never actually heard of
00:28:10 and their special authors module for 2022 it says here um includes black post-modernism gothic as
00:28:18 well as the aesthetics of the contemporary US and the African American novel. So the reason why I
00:28:24 raised this in this context before going on to the Hungarian elections is because what struck me
00:28:29 about this that I also thought was interesting is that for a long time people spoke about you know
00:28:33 the oppression of women throughout history and many people would have said that it was important
00:28:39 to have more female writers from British history in the curriculum and Jane Austen is one of the
00:28:44 premier British female authors and is is not only of significance to the UK but around the world
00:28:52 she's something that we have given to the world so it struck me as a particularly mad one that
00:28:59 she would be dropped in favor of an African-American because in African-American author
00:29:04 because not only is that from you know outside of the UK but also it's a it's basically a decision
00:29:11 to drop a female author.
00:29:13 So I just wanted to get your thoughts on that.
00:29:15 I think, look, I mean,
00:29:17 how many times have we talked about
00:29:19 cases like this on these programmes?
00:29:21 I mean, you know, and you say this seems
00:29:23 like a particularly bad one.
00:29:25 I've always thought Jane Austen had it coming, actually.
00:29:27 I mean, mainly
00:29:28 because, yes, what was it
00:29:31 that Woody Allen said?
00:29:33 What's a post-feminist? Yeah, the sort of women
00:29:35 who think the Sabine women had it coming.
00:29:38 But,
00:29:39 you know, I always thought she was
00:29:41 right for this because um you know the novels are about people in beautiful houses that were around
00:29:49 about the time of the absolute height of british empire um most of them would have been you know
00:29:56 you know they could be portrayed as having been exploitative all of this sort of thing so i think
00:30:02 that for example jane austen i think she was even possibly going to come off the money at some point
00:30:08 as well for currency but this happened I think what so this is just in line with you know what
00:30:14 all these people are doing I think what you will find is that the um BBC and these kind of uh
00:30:21 people who do period dramas um will be very very worried about maybe doing adaptations
00:30:28 unless they seriously change them I think I think this will go it's like a domino so like we have
00:30:34 Bridgerton on Netflix which has this vision of a multicultural Regency London
00:30:41 which is just simply just fantasy it's absolute fantasy in fact it's not doing
00:30:48 ethnic minorities any good really because if you're saying well this is
00:30:53 always the case you know people walking along mixed marriages
00:30:56 you can see exactly what you complaining about then that's what
00:31:01 people would say so i think it's got a actually it's a bit of a hostage to fortune that one wasn't
00:31:06 wasn't there also an architect who said that um that regency buildings were themselves white
00:31:12 supremacist or something to that effect they're always going to come for regency anyway just
00:31:17 because it's something that is beautiful and it's something from that period of history where
00:31:21 everything has to be cancelled i think that i think the idea you know like for example we were
00:31:25 very involved in the statues thing right and save our statues the obvious next target i've always
00:31:32 thought will be buildings it will be buildings why shouldn't it be you know they're going through
00:31:37 all these things the thing is with this sort of jane austen being cancelled um we can sit here and
00:31:44 huff and puff and get so angry but but still it happens you know there's still it happens because
00:31:53 the people doing it are the ones who have the power, in this case, university authorities.
00:31:58 Would you see this as being, you know, this particular case or cases like it as also being
00:32:05 essentially an erasure of British women's history? Well, I mean, I think, yes, you could say that.
00:32:12 But it's obviously part of the much wider movement as well. You know what, bringing it
00:32:17 back to my issues. So things like this, I guess I slightly let it go over my head when
00:32:25 I've got with me here, this is an LGBTQIA plus early years magazine. So it's targeted
00:32:34 two to five year olds. So people are producing this to be taken into our schools, two to five
00:32:41 year olds um i'll just read this out for people um as educators we have a responsibility to ensure
00:32:50 that our students feel included in our pedagogy so it becomes necessary to consider new strategies
00:32:56 that don't put the responsibility of changing gender dynamics on trans children one example
00:33:03 is normalizing not assuming pronouns um how old are these they're talking about kids of how old
00:33:11 two to five this has surely got to be extremely confusing for children who are in a period of
00:33:17 time where their imaginations are so malleable they basically have magical thinking if you told
00:33:21 them that they could become a cow then they would believe you so um sorry just to sort of
00:33:28 because this is related to Jane Austen you know when you're when you've got people producing
00:33:33 stuff for our schools targeted at two to five-year-olds and trying to say to those little
00:33:40 kids not to assume other people's sex I mean it's such a transgression on the integrity of young
00:33:47 children and growing into being able to know who they are and trust their senses and trust adults
00:33:54 and so that's why i've kind of left the wider debate behind about jane austen it's kind of
00:33:59 like going back to what we were saying about um safety and the bigger picture teaching that to
00:34:08 children is teaching them to not trust their own senses which surely puts them in extreme danger
00:34:13 yes particularly if they are being told that for the sake of affirmation for example that if all
00:34:20 of the adults around you and all of the authority figures tell you something that goes against
00:34:24 your judgment and your perceptions, then you ought to trust them and you ought to go against
00:34:29 what you believe to be right. That surely got to be extremely dangerous. I absolutely agree. It's
00:34:34 dangerous. Another piece that I had was a stonewall piece where, you know, again, showing
00:34:39 schoolchildren and it was clearly a man in the women's loos. You know, he had long hair, etc.
00:34:45 And the children were meant to discuss it. And the result of the little workshop was meant to be how
00:34:50 they should all understand that he had the right to be there and that you know the girls the school
00:34:55 girls should be kind and back off now that's absolutely a safeguarding disaster to tell girls
00:35:02 your immediate reaction when you are alone in a single sex what should be a safe space for women
00:35:08 with a man is to step back and be kind is is dangerous what happens to teachers and i don't
00:35:14 hear much about this who say enough about that enough with this i'm not teaching this
00:35:20 Where are they? Where are these people?
00:35:22 OK, I think there's a movement now, I mean, really big push from people like myself and all the campaign groups to say to the Department for Education, you can't back away from this.
00:35:32 You've got to really step up.
00:35:35 So before we move on to the Hungarian elections, I just want to ask...
00:35:38 This is becoming a bit of a kind of a totem.
00:35:40 It is, yeah.
00:35:40 Before we move on.
00:35:42 The Hungarian elections are like some kind of metaphor for something.
00:35:46 Yeah, I just want to ask briefly, do you think that this is a misrepresentation of the Equality Act
00:35:53 or a misunderstanding of the Equality Act on behalf of teachers and people in these institutions?
00:35:59 Okay, so groups like Stonewall have misrepresented the Equality Act.
00:36:04 They have said there's all kinds of guidance which says trans-identifying people must be allowed into the toilets or whatever
00:36:15 that match their gender identity.
00:36:18 And that isn't right.
00:36:19 The Equality Act is absolutely clear
00:36:21 that women have a right to single-sex spaces.
00:36:24 It's a little bit weak in the sense
00:36:26 that it's up to the organisations to invoke that right.
00:36:32 And so the EHRC, Equalities and Human Rights Commission,
00:36:36 has just come out with new guidance
00:36:38 affirming that organisations have the right
00:36:42 and the responsibility to look at it and and you know all the different protected
00:36:48 characteristics coming into play and where they need to to reassert women's right to single sex
00:36:54 spaces so that's a victory as you have said for all the grassroots campaigning um and that's what
00:37:02 we all need to do across all of these issues that's a very good note to leave that topic on
00:37:07 let's move on to the hungarian elections finally. There is a connection here if I can make one
00:37:13 actually is that um with the because we've just been in Hungary we made a documentary which um
00:37:20 I if they have people haven't watched I do hope they watch but a lot of them have got about 60
00:37:24 000 views for it so far um but this is a huge part of the appeal of the Fidesz party which means
00:37:34 faith and um Viktor Orban and that is that this basically they have the Hungarians have a real
00:37:43 suspicion of big ideological plans and ideas first of all they just have that because of their
00:37:50 experience of communism and everything but also um there's a desire amongst most people apparently
00:37:57 there because he's just won a fourth landslide victory uh also not to go the way of the worst
00:38:04 on these issues so like the and the for which he is hugely demonized which i think is probably
00:38:11 what you're going to ask uh hugely demonized has been long before the um ukraine war long before
00:38:20 that um every time he's elected because he's sort of they're kind of going against the general run
00:38:27 the way the West is going now on immigration, on families, so for example
00:38:33 again on the family issue they want to maintain the traditional family, the
00:38:40 demographics of Hungary like everywhere in Europe are going way down down down
00:38:43 so they wanted to sort of incentivize the family, the more children you have the
00:38:48 better tax situation you have. I'm putting it very crudely but that's it
00:38:51 without going into the technical sides of it but also the other point as well is
00:38:56 that whereas we have said in the West oh you know we've got a terrible declining population birth
00:39:03 rate we need more immigrants they're sort of saying no that's not the way to go if we want
00:39:09 to keep the country recognizably hungry then basically we should get Hungarians to have
00:39:16 bigger families and all of that that's that's basically the thrust and that's why he's so
00:39:23 hated obviously
00:39:25 by the sort of people that actually we've
00:39:27 fighting against now. Do you think that
00:39:30 one of the reasons for
00:39:31 the, I suppose you would say
00:39:33 the criticisms of or the resentment
00:39:35 of Hungary and the situation
00:39:38 in Hungary is that in many ways
00:39:39 the tables are turned
00:39:41 so I think it was in the
00:39:44 documentary you described or someone
00:39:45 described Orbán as being
00:39:47 an institutional conservative
00:39:49 and he's been very successful
00:39:52 over the last 12 years in building up all of these different institutions
00:39:55 and imbuing them with a conservative ethos
00:39:58 in the same way that you would say many organisations in the UK
00:40:01 have been imbued with a woke ethos
00:40:05 and through lobby groups like Stonewall being so influential in those institutions.
00:40:08 Do you think that part of the reason why there's so much criticism of Hungary
00:40:15 from particularly EU countries is because the tables are turned in that respect
00:40:20 and what we see in Hungary is an almost an inverse of the situation in our own countries.
00:40:26 Yes, exactly.
00:40:27 I mean, and also pretty much on its own in that sense.
00:40:31 I mean, you know, I found when I was there, I think I said this in the film,
00:40:36 that it was actually remarkably open-minded.
00:40:39 I mean, the whole thrust of it here and the coverage here,
00:40:43 not just from The Guardian and the left,
00:40:45 but also The Telegraph excelled itself this week on Orbán,
00:40:49 is that somehow it is this dictatorship that freedom of speech is no I mean I
00:40:56 think that this is a basic it's almost an anger that they've taken a different
00:41:05 route you know and interestingly one of your great heroes Roger Scruton is
00:41:11 hugely influential that's where I got this us folks this is like we got this
00:41:16 from the Scruton Cafe. They have something in Budapest, in this
00:41:22 college, but also in the town center, city center, called Scruton Cafe. A really
00:41:28 nice place, actually, to go, just to go, very nice, dedicated to his memory. And
00:41:33 they gave him the medal, they gave him a very big medal, you know, Orbán gave him
00:41:37 a medal before he died. And so they're very, very aware of him. Can you imagine a
00:41:43 A Roger Scruton cafe in downtown Bloomsbury here.
00:41:49 Can you imagine it?
00:41:51 What do you think, though, of...
00:41:53 Because obviously there are some things that I think rightly Hungary and Orban should be praised for
00:41:58 and things that conservatives in the West admire the Hungarians for,
00:42:04 for standing up for their own culture and their distinctiveness and so on.
00:42:07 But there are a lot of criticisms that I think need a response.
00:42:13 So, for example, Orbán's propensity to be very, very pro-Putin, particularly under the current circumstances, their hesitancy to sanction Putin over what's happening in Ukraine, and a number of accusations along those lines.
00:42:28 As you mentioned, also the fact that there are some who would accuse him of eroding democracy and of not being a friend of the West.
00:42:36 How would you respond to those criticisms?
00:42:38 The impression I got was they walk a kind of tightrope.
00:42:41 right? So they're in NATO and they very much celebrate that and everything, but then at the
00:42:47 same time they kind of... there's this very much this sort of we are hungry alone, so basically
00:42:52 I think a lot of the message of his election campaign was I'm not, you know, we are going to
00:42:57 stay out of this and all of that. Having said that, they've taken in nearly 400,000 refugees,
00:43:04 I think it's the third biggest amount taken in. So that rather gives a lie, for example,
00:43:10 to the idea that they are racist and anti-immigrants. I mean, you know,
00:43:18 because these people coming, obviously they have a border with the Ukraine,
00:43:22 and there's a big Hungarian ethnic grouping in the Ukraine too. But they sort of manage
00:43:30 very carefully to ride two horses. That's all I can say. But even if Ukraine weren't happening,
00:43:39 because when we started making the documentary, it wasn't, you know, we started, we were going
00:43:43 to Hungary anyway. You know, we sort of knew if he wins this again, there will be hell to pay
00:43:51 from the usual suspects. And sure enough, there has been really.
00:43:53 Do you think one of the aspects of Orbán's success has been helping to somehow possibly stay or improve on Hungary's demographic decline in a way that the rest of Europe's demographics are declining quite rapidly?
00:44:14 And Hungary's approach has been to focus on building families and reproducing rather than filling those demographic gaps by bringing in migrants.
00:44:26 So that's obviously one aspect of his success.
00:44:29 Do you think that, you know, obviously in that respect, having another term and possibly a term after that will go some way to helping them reach their target?
00:44:41 I think it's 2030.
00:44:42 Yeah, it takes a long time, I think.
00:44:44 So my question is, do you think that another Orban term, or should I say, what do you think
00:44:52 another term of Orban's premiership in Hungary?
00:44:55 Another one?
00:44:56 You mean after this?
00:44:57 This one, but possibly another.
00:45:00 What implications do you think that will have for Europe overall, and if that's going to
00:45:05 have any implications, particularly on, you know, obviously Orban is very much pro-family
00:45:09 and against a lot of this ideology coming up.
00:45:13 Yeah, I mean, without question.
00:45:15 I would say, it's a very interesting point, right?
00:45:17 It's quite a long-term thing.
00:45:20 I would say that essentially with the demographic point,
00:45:25 the point was made to us, you know, this is,
00:45:27 they've had limited, they've had some success with this.
00:45:29 This takes a long time.
00:45:31 It's a generational thing.
00:45:33 So you probably need another two terms or something
00:45:35 to see anything sort of really changing.
00:45:36 i think that he the demonization of him probably will intensify because the whole line we have
00:45:43 is that we need migrants because we're shrinking that's why so if you have someone who says
00:45:50 absolutely no you can do it the other way they're not you know they're going to probably
00:45:54 demonize even further i think one of the most interesting developments there is this thing
00:46:01 uh which we will be talking about on the channel in future called mcc which is a college
00:46:06 the matthias corvinus collegium um very um very much a patronized by uh sir roger scruden but
00:46:17 essentially it is a college which is for younger people who are already at university
00:46:24 it's like a conservative sort of hub and they're trying to build a conservative leaning
00:46:30 elite for the future for all the institutions um that's a long-term thing of course everyone
00:46:38 here the left here was oh it's just brainwashing like they don't do that you know um themselves
00:46:44 which of course they do that i think is a very interesting um institution how did i mean obviously
00:46:51 all banners had a big influence on this but how hungary is so anomalous amongst the other european
00:46:58 countries in how successful they've been at building conservative institutions how did they
00:47:03 do that how did they go about doing that where did it start how long did it take this the mcc
00:47:08 college has been around since the 1990s um i think there was already the ground was already
00:47:14 kind of quite well um prepared because of course you know they've been sort of uh colonized by god
00:47:22 knows how many people over 500 years and the last being the soviets there is such a resistance to
00:47:30 having to take on anything that looks like an absurd ideology they will not have it they will
00:47:36 not do it you know so there is the nature maybe of the people to begin with also a very sort of
00:47:43 slightly besieged mentality they have a strange they have the language you know you know it doesn't
00:47:47 it doesn't relate to anyone around all of that kind of thing but I think that
00:47:52 it obviously is showing success in the sense that with the college the MCC
00:48:01 college you know you need young people to go to that right and they have been
00:48:07 going in their thousands and so it's doing I suppose what it sets out to which
00:48:13 is looking at the future and saying we need a new kind of elite or rather conservative elite.
00:48:22 So I think that it's partly Orbán's doing because let's face it he's been there since
00:48:27 2010 but it's also in the nature of the people I think they're quite it's a rural country you know
00:48:34 know it's quite conservative anyway but you've got this little country which in
00:48:43 some ways is just become a bit of an intellectual sort of magnet I think on
00:48:50 that note we're gonna have to actually wrap things up so thank you so much for
00:48:54 watching thank you Caroline thank you Peter and please do like and subscribe
00:48:58 below and we will see you next time on you speak
00:49:01 hello if you're enjoying the new culture forum channel and you believe in our
00:49:07 mission may I invite you to join our membership scheme at the link below or
00:49:12 on our website newcultureforum.org.uk our work is more important now than ever
00:49:19 and we have great plans ahead for the future but we can't do it without your
00:49:24 support from as little as three pounds per month you can help ensure that we
00:49:29 continue on our mission. As a member you'll receive a range of benefits
00:49:34 including access to exclusive content, invitations to our private events
00:49:39 including here at our studios, free copies of our books and much much more
00:49:46 including of course our famous NCF mug. If you aren't able to become a member
00:49:52 then please help us by clicking this button and subscribing to our channel.
00:49:57 It's completely free, just remember to also click the bell icon so that you can
00:50:03 get notifications when we post new videos. Thank you.