00:03:30um i think what i was trying to to uncover in this piece would be uh you know multiple perspectives
00:03:38on on why that might be the case um i think um you know there there are many many people trying
00:03:45to diagnose this problem um my final conclusion was that it's it's probably very multifaceted
00:03:52and it's tied into the complexity of living in the 21st century and living especially in developed
00:03:57countries. But in the end, I think it's more of a, besides it being a bit of a spiritual malaise,
00:04:06you know, there's not really a feeling that there is any reason to have children
00:04:11anymore. It's also an uncoupling from, you know, between stimulus and response. We have a lot of
00:04:18ways to satisfy our most basic urges, but they're not the same as back in the day. So it was
00:04:27Essentially now, for example, you know, internet pornography does a lot of the jobs that, you know, the simple quests to copulate would do, you know, in more ancestral times.
00:04:38So we have many layers of intermediating, you know, products and services that kind of satisfy our, you know, the desires of the lizard brain.
00:04:48And between, you know, just existing and wanting to have children, there's just quite a few of these layers.
00:04:55and I think a lot of people just never make it to the other side
00:04:59or don't think it's a useful way to spend their time.
00:05:04There's quite a lot of sacrifice in having children
00:05:06and I'm not sure everyone's prepared to do that.
00:05:09Do you think, therefore, that means that, for want of a better expression,
00:05:14people in developed countries are more selfish now?
00:05:18I think the self-conception that exists in developed countries
00:05:24is like almost at a fundamental philosophical level different between what we call the developing
00:05:31and developed countries um this is you know partly based on kind of the the idea of the the liberal
00:05:37self-making self this uh this this rational agent that is constantly choosing um you know the best
00:05:45life and and constantly refining uh his or her options in life um it's also the market which
00:05:51only the only intermediary that the market sees is the individual so it's you know it's constantly
00:05:57interacting with you at the level of okay how can we satisfy your desires people are also very hard
00:06:04it's hard for them to predict what they might want in the future so the market typically
00:06:09works at the level of what do you want now you know what what's you know little instincts can
00:06:16we tickle in you what's what's hyper palatable what's you know interesting to you in the moment
00:06:21And all of these work more on people in developed countries rather than in developing countries where dependence on family structures is higher, dependence maybe on a metaphysical structure of the universe is higher.
00:06:35All of these ties that, you know, the liberal man does not have anymore because, you know, you don't really need your family anymore.
00:06:42You don't really need a metaphysical structure when everything's provided for you.
00:06:46I feel like that disconnect happens much more intensely in developed countries.
00:06:54And in a way, that's a positive, obviously, because it opens up options.
00:06:57It opens up a certain flavor of freedom for the people in these countries.
00:07:03But it also destroys many other kind of intangible aspects that might have value in themselves, but are very hard to measure, you know, in the in the one to one relationship that we have with the market and the state and everything here in the West.
00:07:21at one point you made actually in one of your recent podcasts or i think it was made by one
00:07:26of your guests but it is sort of interesting here is that there is a divide though is that
00:07:31in developed countries take america for example uh people in what you might call the upper economic
00:07:38sphere the the upper economic sections of society they too still tend to get married
00:07:45and they still have children it's basically the the further down the economic scale you go this
00:07:54is where things have dissipated it does that is that a familiar analysis to you
00:07:59yes absolutely i think this ties into into the concept of uh of luxury beliefs as well
00:08:07um the idea that you know luxury beliefs that's a that's a great what how do you how would you
00:08:14sum up luxury beliefs um beliefs that are professed by the upper classes with little to no consequence
00:08:23to them because their their actual lived experience is quite different or they're insulated by their
00:08:28wealth or prestige from the consequences of acting on these beliefs right um and that uh affect the
00:08:36the lower classes in a you know disproportionate way because they don't have these protections
00:08:41Or they, you know, they don't have a fallback, you know, like, for example, if someone wants to, you know, try to live a drug fueled polyamorous existence in their 20s, but they are the son of, I don't know, a lord or someone who's got a lot of insulation, both social and financial, then the consequences in their 30s and 40s won't be as intense as someone who, you know, goes on that path.
00:09:08If they're a 20-year-old and says, okay, this is my life now, there's no coming back from many of these things, and they do tend to end up as social dysfunctions at the bottom, but they seem like interesting things to profess at the top with little consequence.
00:09:26This isn't my concept. I think it was Rob Henderson who promoted this idea, and I think it's quite a useful lens on current situations.
00:09:38But I think it seems to be all of a piece with a general trend in society whereby I think it's even Robert Pullman has written about this,
00:09:50that people in what you call upper class economic sections of society, they tend to intermarry.
00:09:59I mean, even from the point of view of, you know, meritocracies, if you like, they kind of intermarry.
00:10:04So if anything, there is less movement as well between them and people beneath them in a way that there might have been more in the past, strangely enough, when it was all about social class.
00:10:19exactly and um i think you know immigration is a layer on top of this as well because you know
00:10:26what what you know relatively porous or open borders do like for example in the european union
00:10:31is you know there's there's a certain strip mining of of cognitive potential of human capital from
00:10:37this from the developing countries or from the lesser developed countries moving to um you know
00:10:43the great cities of europe and a big concentration there um and then you have what you mentioned as
00:10:49well assortative mating where you know people who are in the same you know either a social class or
00:10:54cognitive class tend to cluster together and uh and then either for purposes of uh yeah maybe they
00:11:00just like each other more you know they're in the same university or for the purposes of um you know
00:11:06legacy wealth maintaining wealth and families and building wealth then they they marry they stay
00:11:12married you know there's actually more to lose if you divorce and you have you're quite a wealthy
00:11:17individual so you know there's there's more incentives to stay together um for children as
00:11:22well there's you know social pressure so um there are a lot of incentives pointing towards people
00:11:27in the in the upper strata um you know leading leading much more conventional lives you know
00:11:33leading the the the much maligned lives of the the 1950s patriarchs which which they you know on
00:11:40on the front end they despise and they you know they counsel other people against but um you know
00:11:45know if you really look at life outcomes that's that's how they live I think so again just to
00:11:50pursue this point just one more one more time there's also sort of feeling that if you are
00:11:57going to question and undermine institutions in society whether it's the academic world whether
00:12:06it's the the legal world you know and crime and punishment that essentially if you are from
00:12:15a more privileged background you will again still have a cushion and it's all that the people
00:12:21basically from lower income groups simply do not have that if you take away the legitimacy of
00:12:30for example law enforcement and things like that they will be left with the consequences of that
00:12:37weren't they exactly and i think that at a very deep level this is a this is a theft from from
00:12:45the the so-called lower classes we can't i don't think it's even you know wise to call anyone lower
00:12:51class at the moment except for maybe certain demographics that are that are hated throughout
00:12:55but um you know most people are you know disadvantaged or done underprivileged or you
00:13:02know there's always a like kind of a contextual layer of you know why this is just uh you know
00:13:06a stroke of luck but sometimes it's it's not just bad luck it's it's you know lack of uh lack of
00:13:13basic life instructions like you probably need insurance you probably don't want to have children
00:13:20out of wedlock because you know things you know negative things happen maybe you have children
00:13:25you know when you're slightly more settled um there are different ingredients that you know
00:13:31back in the day used to be imposed by the the iron iron hand of the patriarch whatever we want
00:13:37to call it but they they were just uh that was the water we swam in you know there was a little
00:13:42there was stigma associated with not following these paths um there was uh there were you know
00:13:48old wives you know snickering in in corner rooms about you know people who hadn't done this so
00:13:53there are little mechanisms for enforcement it wasn't all just you know being uh exiled from
00:13:59from the village if you if you were if you're being bad and going against the grain but for
00:14:05all intents and purposes this was the the way of the community to maintain an equilibrium a positive
00:14:10equilibrium with pro-social goals yes um you mentioned you know if you just go back a little
00:14:18bit uh to the reasons for example population uh decline in the developed world uh and you said
00:14:27you know there has just been this break between stimuli and procreation actually that essentially
00:14:34on almost all fronts has been a break which is relatively new in in history um but also you go
00:14:42into the whole dating thing you get you know you you look at internet dating which is basically
00:14:48where all dating happens now um how is it reflected i mean how if you were to look at the
00:14:54way people now make relationships or try to um how what can you see there as patterns that might
00:15:02also throw light on this i mean this is one of the things you wrote about yes absolutely i think
00:15:09um you know in the in the dawn of internet dating it was expected that okay this is the
00:15:14the new algorithmic dating it will will help you find the perfect mate for you um and it sounded
00:15:21it really really great because you're okay there's so many factors that you can now match with people
00:15:25on you know it's much more certain that you'll find someone that actually reflects your values
00:15:29but what this ignored is that dating is basically competitive everyone wants the best mate everyone
00:15:36wants you know to to trade up as much as possible and in terms of how women and men date there are
00:15:43different strategies typically you know obviously at the moment we're told that that men and women
00:15:50are basically interchangeable they have the same erges and things like that but i think on this
00:15:54show we can maybe skip over explaining why that is not the case and so women will typically want
00:16:02overall obviously on average will want more commitment more longer-term relationships you
00:16:07know that would be the goal obviously even if they if they have some more casual relationships
00:16:11in the end typically they would want to need to settle down or have a longer-term relationship
00:16:16men on the other hand will date much more freely and they will date all across the spectrum you
00:16:23know women that are within their socioeconomic stratum women outside of that you know different
00:16:28different types of women um and these two dating strategies they clash when they're put together
00:16:34in these algorithms and they're all kind of united under the header of dating but they're essentially
00:16:39two markets trying to uh find equilibria that are different for for each of these so typically what
00:16:45happens in this algorithmic dating situation is that men that are at the top of the hierarchy
00:16:52you know say the five to ten percent of top men in terms of you know how they look or how they
00:16:57can present themselves on these apps you know show their socio-economic position all sorts of
00:17:03all sorts of good qualities they will date intensely because they have they don't they
00:17:08don't really have a cap on how much they can date and they might date a woman every night for a week
00:17:13or you know so they uh essentially essentially they corner the market and for women looking
00:17:18for a relationship they're like okay i i can go on a date with this guy and then essentially the
00:17:24guy maybe dates you once or twice but then this this never never calls back and this is essentially
00:17:29a weird equilibrium in which maybe let's say 80 of the bottom men they don't go on any dates at
00:17:35all or maybe i'm exaggerating but a very very large percentage of men don't go on any dates
00:17:40at all because the women tend to be pickier they want to go dating with the with the higher class
00:17:45men and the higher class men as well they don't mind having these dates with the women but they0.68
00:17:51won't commit so essentially a lot of people are locked in these um you know women trying to get
00:17:57a long-term relationship you know men at the middle and bottom not getting any opportunity
00:18:03to have a relationship and then these kind of harem's light for for guys that that are at the
00:18:09top of the hierarchy uh and that can you know all the cards are on their table but there's not
00:18:14really any incentives for them to just to settle down in any any way so um this is a bad balance
00:18:21this is a bad equilibrium um and it's it's something that's not very apparent from people
00:18:26that you know just look oh it's a dating app you know obviously find random people but because of
00:18:32this competitive nature and because of how the strategies are different um it's it obviously0.76
00:18:37what it does in terms of procreation and why it stalls it is that women cannot get the long-term
00:18:44relationships they want, the men at the top are not incentivized to settle down, and the men at
00:18:50the bottom don't even get to play the game at all. So no one's getting any time to have children in
00:18:58this combination. But this is kind of brutal, isn't it, Alex? I mean, it almost feels, I mean,
00:19:04But basically, it seems to me what this means is that the Internet is just reflecting the most kind of traditional idea about what men and women want.
00:19:16You know, that women want someone who's basically going to be a good father, a good provider, an alpha male, call it what you want.
00:19:25And also the men, on the other hand, are sort of wanting to spread themselves as far as possible, you know, with little consequences.
00:19:34I think the market provides, and I think in subtle ways people will, you know, will react on their biological settings and on the incentives that are presented to them.
00:19:48You know, if you look at this from the perspective of a single individual in this system, obviously you'd want to date the most interesting person that you can on that app.
00:19:57uh and if if a very high status man wants to go out on a date with with a woman she her incentives
00:20:04are to say yes of course you know let's go out there uh but what she doesn't know is that you
00:20:09know what what his state of mind is because he's you know he's spoiled for choice um him being
00:20:15spoiled for choice you know that kind of sets up his incentives as well because you know even if
00:20:19he wants to have a long-term relationship then you know he he is incentivized to think about it
00:20:25And he's incentivized to really, you know, take his time, maybe pick out a woman that's extraordinary with time and with a lot of exposure to different women.0.81
00:20:35It becomes very hard to make that choice because women are different.0.99
00:20:39They all have faults. They all have, you know, interesting qualities.
00:20:45So if you're just waiting for the perfect one, then you might be waiting for a very long time.
00:20:50it's also you know for men the the prospects of you know of dating tend to increase with
00:20:56socioeconomic status and with time men do require typically more resources you know
00:21:03a man at 38 or 40 is quite in his prime and he can you know maybe think about
00:21:08you know maybe playing around even more so the incentives kind of align for him as well to be
00:21:14continuing to stay on these apps and all of these little factors you know come together and
00:21:19and they result in this pretty hideous equilibrium for people trying to you know each each of them is
00:21:25trying to make a good life for themselves but overall it's uh it's not very good and for the
00:21:30for the guys at the bottom yeah there's not even there's no story to tell because no one no one
00:21:35no one swipes right there it's it's quite a yeah it's it's not it's not great do you think as well
00:21:42there's something in the view which is the bleak view um but it's one that seems obvious to me that
00:21:48in developed countries in the west um different countries that basically
00:21:54there's little sense anymore of a future and in the sense that people don't talk about it they
00:22:04they don't it doesn't it's not in the air you know so therefore if that is the case then
00:22:10why would you have children because the whole point of children of course is the future it's
00:22:15It is basically making sure the species goes on.
00:22:19And yet we don't appear anymore to think very much about the future
00:22:24or consider it as being a desirable, nice place to be.
00:22:30Yes, I think that's probably definitely part of the issue.
00:22:36Because on the one hand, you have this, you know,
00:22:38very direct individualistic, you know, rational agent idea
00:22:43of what it is to be a human, to, you know, to produce and go up in status and then be a consumer
00:22:51of different high status goods. And, you know, you can fill a life with all this distraction.
00:22:57Then on the other hand, you also have the idea that belonging to a lineage, belonging to a culture
00:23:02is pretty disgraceful. If you're not, you know, part of some exotic culture where that's still
00:23:07allowed. But if you're, for example, a British man, it's probably not a good idea to be making0.53
00:23:12a big deal out of the fact that you um you you know you you like britain in the context that
00:23:18you've grew up in uh you you would like to participate in creating your lineage to uh you
00:23:24know promote your country within you know whatever parameters you think are useful for it uh be be
00:23:30proud of of who you are all of this stuff so that's if you can't have a past why would you
00:23:36want a future there's there's not really that much to um to live for um except for the moment-to-moment
00:23:44enjoyment these things you mentioned there i suppose alex really are now are now considered
00:23:50low status things to have aren't they uh you know like a belief in your locality your nation and
00:23:58your family? Absolutely. These are chav things, if I remember correctly. Yeah, only people
00:24:08who are not enlightened enough to realize that we're all part of the global village
00:24:13and that, you know, borders are a human invention. Yeah, those people, they get to enjoy their
00:24:23their lineage what is it like therefore in romania are we is it the same situation um or
00:24:31you know or is it markedly different where you are um i think romania is kind of the quintessential
00:24:39country in in transition and where we're transitioning to is you know trying to be
00:24:44a worthy member of the of the kind of western empire and by this i mean probably american
00:24:50influence and um you know i it's we're not there yet but i think we're you know five five years
00:24:56down the line because this this is aspirational the west is aspirational whatever comes down the
00:25:01pipe from the west we'll we'll take it you know it might take a bit of time to for it to trickle
00:25:05down and you know now you know our elites you know the people who have studied abroad and worked
00:25:10abroad they are very much you know uh proud neoliberals um but uh you know the you know
00:25:18know your average man uh probably not yet but yeah as i said it trickles down these these beliefs
00:25:24really do trickle down is that something that you would both regret and resist presumably
00:25:30um yeah i mean i definitely used to be a very much part of of that class you know looking to
00:25:38the west you know trying to integrate i got a degree in diversity management at a fine western
00:25:45university so i i know the the lingo i know exactly what was expected of me um yeah after a
00:25:53while it became clear to me that uh that that wasn't a good direction to go so i i would
00:25:58personally resist it but i don't think it's uh it's it's a very mainstream view you were you
00:26:04were in london were you not for a while yes yes i was i was yeah and uh but you know a lot of
00:26:12people listening to you uh would think that you were born and bred uh american and now i mean but
00:26:18not not at all no right no no not at all i uh i just i watched so much television and believe me
00:26:24i tried to i tried to get a bit of a british accent or at least a british affectation when i
00:26:29was in the uk it just doesn't stick after a while you know when you're 25 it doesn't it doesn't work
00:26:35anymore no um when you say it's sort of coming down the line say to romania five years time it's
00:26:41would have already seen this is something that i've heard from we've had a guest on the show
00:26:45quite recently called frank ferrady uh who's hungary originally hungarian he sees the same
00:26:51thing happening in hungary um from which channels is it coming is it via netflix or is it the
00:26:59academic academic ideas how um i think it's mostly via netflix i would say it's via instagram it's
00:27:10why? Because now you have the so-called woke capital. Almost all multinationals have to
00:27:18have a layer of social justice embedded somehow, and they're promoting it in every way. I mean,
00:27:24I keep bringing up this example, but it was really funny to me because I went for coffee
00:27:28with a friend here, a childhood friend in Romania, and she was talking to me about abortion rights
00:27:33in alabama uh and it was quite shocking like she i would probably you know put good money on the
00:27:41fact that she didn't know the intricacies of local elections but she was very clued into
00:27:45into potential human rights abuses in in alabama and uh you know all the all the nuances of that
00:27:51debate and it was a bit interesting to me because this is i mean i i live in a small town this is
00:27:57not bucharest you know this this is you know it's it's been trickling down very hard and
00:28:01it's yeah anyone who speaks english but gets gets the bug yes um speaking of which you you mentioned
00:28:09the the sort of empire as you put it earlier um and you wrote a piece recently about called having
00:28:16babies at the twilight of empire which is uh i think fascinating you you mentioned a sum which
00:28:22now i please please do um excuse my uh ignorance of this have you had your child yet or have you
00:28:31had your baby it's imminent imminent okay well yes all the very best but you you you were talking
00:28:39about having a son during a period in which all the cultural dynamics are running against
00:28:46well sons could you say yes i think um i think it's it's less so um against the son if he chooses
00:28:58to be part of you know um of some some form of intersectional situation but if if he chooses to
00:29:05be a uh a masculine man then probably he'd he'd be bearing the full brunt of uh of uh the opprobium
00:29:14that we're uh reserving for for that um i i think the the the whole conversation on masculinity is
00:29:22is is very skewed and the idea that you know only men can have uh so-called toxic masculinity
00:29:30um yeah i think that there are many layers to this but i think it's it's quite it's quite sick
00:29:36the way we've positioned it and i was essentially i was worrying in that piece just thinking hey
00:29:41how could i help how could i as a woman uh you know lay the groundwork in a positive way for
00:29:48my son so um that i that i just enable him to be whatever he wants but also kind of
00:29:55maybe warn him of potential pitfalls if he's if he's a bit careless what um you know what
00:30:02conclusion did you come to how can you do that then i mean i i'm not you know making uh i don't
00:30:08mean to make light of a obviously a very big personal thing that's going to happen you know
00:30:13you're going to have maybe what what actually what did how did you decide how you could handle it
00:30:20um yeah i think it's um i think it's it's partly um an active stance like what am i going to do
00:30:30but at the same time i think my inclusions are more tied to what i'm not going to do
00:30:34um i'm probably not going to try to impose some sort of worldview um or you know just
00:30:41I'm going to try to create very good conditions of calm and, you know, a relatively prosperous childhood, you know, in a in a good in a good stable family.
00:30:54And I'm also going to let my husband take the lead in terms of a lot of things, something that's probably not you're not going to hear in many parenting circles.
00:31:05But I think, you know, there's no one better to teach a son than a man.
00:31:09um and obviously i'm not referring uh to his you know when he's a baby or a toddler then obviously
00:31:15i'll i'll be i'll be more involved and i'll be i'll be kind of the the main uh the rock but once
00:31:22once it comes to acquiring skills you know managing managing the world then probably my
00:31:27husband will be kind of the the main focus there and he'll be the one teaching him um it's it's
00:31:33quite hard not to be the the devouring mother nowadays and to uh to not try to be overprotective
00:31:39or or controlling or so yeah i think that's going to be my challenge and you know just yeah trying
00:31:45to be because i think a good starting point yeah i think any sort of boy now young kid is going to
00:31:55be faced is he not with being yet another product um representative of this terrible patriarchy
00:32:03that that's the problem isn't it i mean you know he's going to have he's almost going to have
00:32:08original sin on his head isn't he absolutely yeah i think it's um the idea of of um inherent
00:32:16privilege of you you know people treating you different just because of of how you look and
00:32:23systemic things, nebulous things, dark things. The problem with these arguments is that you
00:32:33can't disprove them. It's proving a negative. It's like, okay, proof to me that there is no
00:32:37systemic sexism. Well, where do you start and where do you end? Anyone who's engaged in debate
00:32:44club knows that proving a negative is going to be very hard. And this applies obviously to all
00:32:48sorts of other things systemic or or other so i think we're in a bit of a a stalemate and it's
00:32:54going to be very hard to to win the war of ideas on this one with people that are very entrenched
00:32:58and uh who might benefit from continuing the war um so yeah yeah just i think protecting and and
00:33:08uh setting people setting children up um with a little bit of critical thinking that's probably
00:33:14the only thing you can do and then you know good luck we wish you well well speaking of which when
00:33:20when when is your when is your baby due um at the end of june end of june so well look all the very
00:33:27best for that all right so thank you so much thank you for for joining us i hope maybe you'll join us
00:33:33again when you uh well maybe next next year when you're a little bit out of the woods as it were
00:33:39you know with the whole thing uh and uh come back and speak to us again but it's been delightful to
00:33:44talk to you thank you so much it was lovely coming on oh great thank you very much um that's it for
00:33:51this week on so what you're saying is and uh we shall see you next time and in the meantime please
00:33:57don't forget will you to subscribe thank you very much