New Culture Forum - May 26, 2021


Joshua Humphreys - We Must Cherish Western Civilization

Alex Kaschuta - Why The West Isn't Having Children Quentin Letts - How We Need To Stop Being Told What To Do

Episode Stats


Length

24 minutes

Words per minute

154.33

Word count

3,783

Sentence count

141


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to So What You're Saying Is. I'm Peter Whittle. Now before our show this week
00:00:28 I just want to say a very heartfelt thank you to everyone who subscribes to the channel.
00:00:34 We get new subscriptions every day, rising, and also to all of you who donate too.
00:00:41 Thank you very, very much. It's hugely appreciated by us and I hope we continue to do you proud.
00:00:48 My guest this week is out of the usual run of people that we have on the channel and all the
00:00:55 better for it. He's a man who does something which I'm sure you will find very, very interesting.
00:01:02 Joshua Humphreys is an author. He is the writer of comedy novels. He is a self-described traveler
00:01:10 and also he's the founder of something called the New Cavalier Reading Society. And he's joining me
00:01:16 now. He's in the Ukraine. He's joining me now. Thanks very much for coming on, Joshua.
00:01:21 You're very welcome. Thank you very much for having me.
00:01:23 No, it's a pleasure.
00:01:25 First of all, can you explain to me
00:01:27 what is the New Cavalier Reading Society?
00:01:31 So, functionally, it's a members-only group
00:01:34 dedicated to discussing humanity's most profound questions
00:01:38 as explored by its most ingenious minds.
00:01:42 And the way that translates to the real world
00:01:45 is that I have these books called,
00:01:48 they're my commonplace books, four volumes thereof,
00:01:51 and they're not available to the general public and when you become a member I send them to you
00:01:56 and then throughout a semester we all read the same pages from those commonplace books
00:02:01 and at the start of the week I pull four questions from the commonplace books from the reading
00:02:07 most often questions advanced by the authors themselves and all through the week we
00:02:15 try to answer those questions in our own time and then we come together at the weekend
00:02:19 and I lead us through discussions of everything we've been reading.
00:02:23 So I've noticed you have a massive following on social media, on Instagram.
00:02:30 Is that how you communicate mostly on social media?
00:02:33 Yeah, I'm told to branch out, but I don't have the time or the energy to use any other platform.
00:02:41 So everything tends to go through Instagram.
00:02:43 Right. But with the Society, why should people join it? What is it, you know, why did you set it up?
00:02:54 I set it up as a way to share the commonplace books. They are such unique volumes.
00:03:00 They contain, I think, something like 6,000 quotations from over 1,200 different authors.
00:03:07 And they range really from the very beginning of Western history up until the present day.
00:03:12 and anybody who is vaguely interested in western culture can get a much more uh interesting and
00:03:22 intimate look into what western culture means by engaging with its questions yes so in fact
00:03:29 you know this uh you you you mentioned in fact in i i've seen you you've written that this is about
00:03:35 really looking at western culture before as you put it universities crushed it yes how did they
00:03:42 crush it? I think I know. They crush it through first of all by tainting it with a kind of
00:03:50 original sin. They begin with certain premises such as Western culture is racist and then they
00:03:58 go around in circles trying to prove that Western culture is racist and that's the sole filter for
00:04:02 which they put 4,000 years of Western culture.
00:04:07 Yes.
00:04:08 So it is basically, did you sort of start this almost in a response
00:04:14 to this current situation we're in?
00:04:15 Because, I mean, it seems to me that Western culture is pretty much under attack.
00:04:22 No, my view of it under attack has only come into sharp focus the last two years,
00:04:29 particularly last year.
00:04:31 But in 2017, when I started it, I was very much outside of that realm.
00:04:36 And the more people that I've the more people that have become members,
00:04:40 the more people that have come through the reading society,
00:04:43 the more gaps I've found in knowledge and a greater inability to combat
00:04:48 Western culture's enemies intellectually.
00:04:50 Yes. Where did where did your interests come, you know, in looking at all of this?
00:04:56 so yeah so my itinerant aunt uh was a spinster her whole life and she would travel to egypt
00:05:04 every other year to venice in the intervening years she had the only tapes she had on vhs
00:05:10 were indiana jones so that kind of instilled an early love of the excitement of history
00:05:15 in me and then at university i have a history degree from the trove university
00:05:21 and the first lecture I ever attended was on the French Revolution
00:05:26 and it was given by Professor Bill Murray
00:05:29 who I'm not sure if he's still alive
00:05:31 but if he is I would very much like to thank him
00:05:34 and he would stand in front of a huge undergraduate lecture theater
00:05:37 and just speak on the French Revolution from memory
00:05:41 for 55 minutes moving in and out of French, English, German, Italian
00:05:45 it wouldn't translate for anybody
00:05:47 and by the end of these 55 minute lectures
00:05:50 We were just enthralled by the incitement of Western history, European history.
00:05:55 Yes. And that's something that's obviously stayed with you.
00:05:58 Absolutely. I made a point of having him as my tutor in all the subjects that he taught.
00:06:05 And then halfway through that degree, he was replaced as the professor of the head of the kind of Nazi department of the history faculty.
00:06:16 uh his replacement was not of the same caliber and so i had to seek other intellectuals if you
00:06:25 will but those you know that year and a half has always stuck with me yes you are you are uh you
00:06:30 you would uh say that primarily you are a writer of comedy novels um so you know basically what is
00:06:40 a what would you call a comedy novel then actually joshua what is that a comedy novel is a novel
00:06:46 that's written with the sole intention to amuse to make laugh uh i started out as a stand-up comedian
00:06:53 and performing in my own plays at university and then in my fourth year i had this lightning bolt
00:07:01 moment when i i picked up a handful of dust by evelyn wall oh yeah and by the end of the first
00:07:07 page i knew that it was smarter and funnier than what i was doing i was making frivolous
00:07:13 monty python kind of sketches and i just knew that i had to be writing novels or that i had
00:07:18 to incorporate the comedic element so i kind of i pitched them as as though you're reading a sitcom
00:07:24 or a will ferrell film on paper right and uh i mean can you just tell us a little bit about
00:07:32 you have talked about your education there but where are you originally from then josh
00:07:36 Melbourne, Australia, from the criminal classes of outer suburban Melbourne.
00:07:40 Right. OK. But you lead, it seems like quite a nomad's existence. Is that or is that wrong?
00:07:48 Nomad is a loaded word nowadays. I see myself as an exile.
00:07:53 Even now, I can't return to Australia. It's illegal.
00:07:57 But I, well, first, for economic reasons, I had to escape to Southeast Asia
00:08:04 because for four or five years i wasn't making enough money to live anywhere else and i fell
00:08:09 in love with that region of the world and uh at the moment i have to i have to move around at the
00:08:14 time because of usually visa restrictions yes as an australian you can maximum stay in three
00:08:20 for three months at a time in most places so i tend to uh fit around yes and uh you sort of take
00:08:28 people with you isn't that right to say i mean virtually speaking you know i i try to i have a
00:08:36 year for three years i ran a venice tour that i built uh in situ in venice and then last year i
00:08:44 turned that into a virtual tour so that's that can take people to venice and yeah i'm doing the same
00:08:51 for ancient greece this year planning on spending the rest of the year in greece
00:08:55 these are the very places that are the very foundations if you like of our our civilization
00:09:02 i mean i was very interested in one it's probably not the motto of the cabinet reading society but
00:09:09 i don't know maybe it is but you wrote it only the wise are free it's a quotation from cicero
00:09:16 yeah uh and i just i i don't uh subscribe to kind of civilizational freedom
00:09:27 uh i'm more subscribed to the latest stoic idea that it is wisdom that equals freedom right and
00:09:34 so and heraclitus said uh wisdom is is uh being able to see the one thing that threads through
00:09:41 all other things yes i just feel as though in order to be free from all temporal uh intellectual
00:09:47 constraints you have to be able to see the larger picture right and that's what i try to impart
00:09:53 but we don't really see or rather should i say freedom now in that sense has sort of become
00:09:59 rather perverted in the sense that now it's seen almost entirely as a matter of choice isn't it
00:10:05 it's seen as having choice in life but it's not really about that is it no that's a kind
00:10:12 of capitalist consumerism conception of freedom yeah which i don't at all ascribe to right right
00:10:19 so you pretty much plow alone a lonely farrow would it be right to say it would it's a very
00:10:25 lonely life not not lonely life it's a solitudinous life yes but i'm well aware that in order to do
00:10:32 the amount of work that i do and to write a novel a year i cannot have distractions like large groups
00:10:39 of friends right or uh yeah right but i mean what's interesting i mean obviously you know the
00:10:46 sort of things that we've covered on this channel we the the big preoccupations we've had and it
00:10:52 seems to me that um actually providing some platform or some association of society for
00:11:00 people to learn about things that once they might have taken for granted is extremely valuable i
00:11:07 mean do you see yourself as you know in some way providing a kind of service like that i mean do
00:11:13 you know is that what motivates it it definitely motivates it what motivates me is to uh have
00:11:21 people cherish what they do not know they should be cherishing right and to value things that we
00:11:29 are either on the verge of losing or that we've already lost and to value the means that we might
00:11:34 have the will to recover them at some stage yeah do you think uh i mean when we you know again one
00:11:42 of the things we've discussed endlessly on here unfortunately but we have to is the sort of you
00:11:48 know the woke attack uh is this something that you have a strong view on because frankly from
00:11:54 i can see it seems entirely uh well first of all hugely ignorant of the kind of things that you
00:12:00 talk about for starters but then also dismissive or indeed utterly hostile too i didn't know what
00:12:08 woke was until last year right uh but it's been a very it's been a baptism of fire figuring out
00:12:14 what it is yeah figuring out strengths and weaknesses and i firmly believe that
00:12:22 in the face of woke if you will if you in the face of woke arguments reason and logic is the
00:12:29 only thing that can stand up right but if they attack people who do not know what they're talking
00:12:34 about or who have the kind of uh prejudiced background against what they're talking about
00:12:43 We don't stand a chance.
00:12:45 Right.
00:12:46 So how do you confront them, then, with reason and logic?
00:12:50 Well, it's all about knowing.
00:12:52 I don't like to take an adversarial position, but it's all about knowing your enemy.
00:12:56 So in the Reading Society, when we have those four questions each week,
00:13:01 very occasionally the reading will be preoccupied with one subject,
00:13:05 such as ideology or Marxism or the Vietnam War.
00:13:10 And for that week, I would just make the focus
00:13:13 a kind of lecture that I give.
00:13:15 And so I can explain to people what Marxism is,
00:13:17 where it came from, what it does,
00:13:19 what its intellectual tricks and falsehoods are.
00:13:23 The same with ideology.
00:13:24 But I also direct them to a large body of wider reading
00:13:30 where they can find out as much as they possibly can.
00:13:32 The best writer on ideology I've ever read is Michael Oakeshott.
00:13:37 Yes.
00:13:37 Yes. The chance of you meeting somebody who's ever heard of Michael Oakeshott, minimal, I find.
00:13:45 Right.
00:13:45 But just to be able to tell someone to read Michael Oakeshott, I consider that invaluable.
00:13:53 What about someone like Roger Scruton?
00:13:56 Roger Scruton, I've never read him on ideology.
00:14:01 i try to stay away from uh books that uh purposefully espouse the cause of conservatism
00:14:09 yeah because i think that it has a kind of it has a bad name in public discourse and so if you
00:14:15 identify yourself as a conservative yeah you're very likely to immediately have your views dismissed
00:14:21 yeah and so we i mean we have read on conservatism by roger scruton but i do tend to direct people
00:14:28 through authors who do not kind of overtly identify it
00:14:32 as political in one way or the other.
00:14:34 John Ruskin is the, there are two authors,
00:14:38 John Ruskin and Nietzsche.
00:14:40 And just directing people to read Ruskin or to read Nietzsche,
00:14:44 neither of them identify as conservative,
00:14:46 although Ruskin does is in his autobiography,
00:14:49 but he claims it's a Homeric conservative.
00:14:53 But if you just get people reading those authors,
00:14:55 they will automatically come across values
00:14:58 that are anti-woke, that can fight woke,
00:15:01 and that don't plan to as a political conservative,
00:15:04 but you will find that the things that you value
00:15:06 align very closely with small-c conservatism.
00:15:12 What do you think has been the effect of the whole pandemic
00:15:15 and COVID on, you know, on our civilization?
00:15:20 I know that is like a massive question for a whole volume, I'm sure,
00:15:25 but it's not been a good one, has it?
00:15:28 No, it's the, I've always had a kind of inherent faith in humanity, in its goodness and intelligence, and the pandemic destroyed that.
00:15:38 Really?
00:15:38 Pissed on its ashes. I have never seen so many people so readily relinquish so much freedom in the space of a few months. It made me nervous.
00:15:49 yeah it's particularly isn't it australia your home country was it was quite extraordinary as
00:15:57 well wasn't it in its restrictions is is presently quite extraordinary i have uh actually informally
00:16:03 renounced my citizenship i no longer identify with that country or its people especially not
00:16:09 with its government they uh it's illegal to fly home you face uh mandatory imprisonment for two
00:16:16 weeks if you do fly home. If you fly home from India at present, the maximum penalty is ÂŁ33,000
00:16:23 for doing so. It's extraordinary. What is it like where you are at the moment from the point of view
00:16:31 of COVID? Ukraine is fine. There are thousands of people in the streets. Restaurants are open.
00:16:38 They had cases of falling, but there's still, I think, around 5,000 a day.
00:16:44 But I have a theory I'm working on that the more actual hardship a country has faced,
00:16:52 the less likely they are to overreact to COVID.
00:16:56 Because, I mean, you know, Ukraine's history is riddled with oppression and misery.
00:17:01 How can a virus do any worse than Russia?
00:17:05 I think actually that's a very interesting point,
00:17:07 because if you look at people are talking a lot about India at the moment it might well be you
00:17:12 know there are economic reasons as well for the number of cases there but at the same time it's
00:17:19 maybe a different attitude that people have as you say they have been nearer to life and death
00:17:25 I mean isn't this really what actually shows the the extraordinary sort of luxuriousness of the
00:17:32 west they can't handle it anymore is do you think that's the luxuriousness but also a i guess a
00:17:40 long-term denial and shelving of death we don't like to think about it we don't think it exists
00:17:45 we we hide our dead as soon as they're gone uh but india of course has a uh very influential
00:17:53 and transcendental religion so i imagine they they don't mind death too much because they don't think
00:17:58 it's all i'm very wary of overstating the case when it comes to covid yes but the thing is but
00:18:04 nevertheless you see you you introduced an interesting point though about again about
00:18:08 religion is that somehow if there is a religious framework in this society the attitude to this
00:18:14 kind of thing will be slightly different it doesn't mean to say that people are you know
00:18:18 going to be affected less but their attitude will be different whereas you as you're quite right
00:18:22 We've sort of discarded, at least officially, we've discarded religion in that way.
00:18:28 So therefore, we have to face that, my God, this might mean oblivion.
00:18:34 Yeah, we've not only discarded religion and any value in death.
00:18:41 We've also, how do I phrase it?
00:18:45 we've also numbed or kind of diluted our conception of living
00:18:50 to the point where it is so inane and uninteresting
00:18:55 that we need it to go on for as long as possible
00:18:57 in order for it to have been considered a full life.
00:19:01 Right.
00:19:01 I genuinely consider that anybody who is living their life
00:19:05 as fully as they possibly can at any one moment
00:19:08 does not consider death to be the worst of all outcomes.
00:19:13 Right.
00:19:13 That's taken directly from ancient Greece, but it's something that really I cannot overstress the importance of, but nobody listens.
00:19:25 Do you actually live yourself, therefore, by what was written in ancient Greece and by ancient Greek authors?
00:19:35 I mean, do you think that, therefore, that there is more to be got from them than there is, for example, from a modern self-help book?
00:19:45 Infinitely so. A modern self-help book is, first of all, probably written by somebody who needs self-help and external help.
00:19:52 The ancient Greeks didn't write in order to make money. They wrote to illustrate their way of life.
00:19:58 wife yeah and uh particularly the ancient heroic conception of living is uh when i when i first
00:20:07 made sense of it from uh the best author on the heroic conception of life is verna jaeger yeah
00:20:16 or c m bowra they elaborate and uh illustrate the heroic conception so clearly that it made
00:20:24 sense to me that that's what i have been arguing for for years already without actually knowing
00:20:30 just one thing i want to ask as well actually uh josh you you know you you travel around a lot
00:20:35 although of course i should imagine that's quite relatively might be curtailed at the moment but
00:20:40 um you know you live this life and you write um we had uh we have a writer here a journalist
00:20:48 called david goodhart and he you might have heard of him but he he was looking at brexit and he came
00:20:55 up with these two groups that we have now in our kind of societies australia britain america
00:21:01 anywheres and somewheres somewheres were people that basically drew a hell of a lot from their
00:21:08 surroundings from their locality and their nation and their family and anywheres were the increase
00:21:15 the people who essentially saw themselves entirely in an international context
00:21:20 um and you know somehow had very weak uh links to their locality uh you seem to me to be
00:21:30 possibly a somewhere in an anywhere's body uh would you say that is correct somewhere in an
00:21:39 anywhere's body perhaps i uh i don't want to get into the freudian uh analysis of the somewhere
00:21:48 and the anywhere but i imagine a lot of what i do is a reaction against my australian upbringing
00:21:55 feeling uprooted i had very strong scottish roots to my grandparents but when you grow up so far
00:22:01 removed from it uh you might be likely to attempt to recover it and that is how i see europe
00:22:07 I used to consider Australia an outpost of European culture.
00:22:12 I don't anymore, but perhaps that's why I do what I do.
00:22:18 Chris, just on this point, do you think it's not just something about your change of attitude, is it?
00:22:25 Australian society, are you saying, actually has changed?
00:22:29 Absolutely.
00:22:30 If you, my grandparents are dead, but they would not recognize the country that is currently floundering underneath Indonesia.
00:22:40 I consider it, I haven't studied it at any great length, I don't have a detailed hypothesis, but I think Australia used to be a European outpost in Asia.
00:22:52 It is now a, it's an Asian outpost. They've flipped, if you will.
00:22:57 Yes. Well, look, Joshua, what do people do if they want to join the New Cavalier Reading Society?
00:23:06 Can you tell them how they should go about it? Where should they go?
00:23:11 So if you go to my website, joshuahumphreys.com, or the Reading Society's website, newcavalierreadingsociety.com,
00:23:18 and you click on Join, there's a set of criteria that pops up.
00:23:22 and if you meet those criteria
00:23:25 then we welcome you within our ranks
00:23:27 otherwise
00:23:28 find me on Instagram, send me a message
00:23:31 and I can discuss it with you at more
00:23:32 greater length
00:23:33 and when's the next novel going to be coming out?
00:23:37 Hopefully December
00:23:38 I'm in Ukraine to work on it
00:23:40 half its characters are Ukrainian
00:23:42 immigrants to Australia so I'm here
00:23:44 researching all the Ukrainian
00:23:46 crazies that I can find
00:23:48 I'm in Greece
00:23:50 for the next three months to write
00:23:52 its first and second drafts, and hopefully by December it shall be ready.
00:23:57 Well, look, you know, thank you very much for breaking.
00:23:59 I know you write in the morning, don't you?
00:24:01 So thank you for breaking into your schedule and talking to us.
00:24:05 All the very best.
00:24:06 I think it's fantastic what you started and much needed at the moment, too.
00:24:11 Whatever your politics, I think it's much, much needed.
00:24:14 Thanks very much indeed, Joshua.
00:24:16 Thank you, Peter.
00:24:17 It's a pleasure.
00:24:18 Good, good.
00:24:18 that's it for this week and we shall see you next time in the meantime do as I
00:24:25 said please continue to subscribe once you thank you