New Culture Forum - March 17, 2021


Andrew Doyle On His New Book: Free Speech & Why It Matters

Has The Oprah Interview Damaged The Monarchy? Rod Liddle: The Woke Are Erasing 500 Years Of Western Civilisation

Episode Stats


Length

46 minutes

Words per minute

197.62

Word count

9,130

Sentence count

166

Harmful content

Misogyny

2

sentences flagged

Hate speech

2

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to So What You're Saying Is. I'm Peter Whittle. Now my guest today is someone
00:00:27 who's been on the show a number of times before.
00:00:29 I'm so pleased he's back.
00:00:31 Andrew Doyle is author, a satirist,
00:00:35 and, of course, the creator of that social media sensation,
00:00:39 Titania McGrath.
00:00:41 He's written what I might call a more serious book.
00:00:45 It's just come out.
00:00:47 Free Speech and Why It Matters.
00:00:50 Free Speech and Why It Matters.
00:00:53 Andrew, thank you so much for coming back.
00:00:56 Thank you for having me.
00:00:57 It's a pleasure. Can you tell me, Free Speech, Why It Matters, it says something, doesn't it, that you in a way have to write a book about this at the moment?
00:01:09 Absolutely. I never thought I would. I never thought I'd be writing a book to defend free speech.
00:01:13 That was a given to me. I thought that everyone just assumed free speech was the bedrock of a liberal democracy.
00:01:19 um but i i'm unfortunately i i have to say over the past particularly 10 years or so i a lot of
00:01:26 us have noted uh the way in which the principle of free speech has been eroded lots of people
00:01:30 have become very flippant about it as though they don't really care or they they even mock people
00:01:34 for being free speech warriors or free speech defenders and you would have thought that that's
00:01:38 quite a positive thing isn't it because it's it's quite it's quite important and the other very
00:01:43 serious thing that has happened now is that uh free speech has been politicized so you get a lot
00:01:47 of situations where people say oh these people are going about free speech they're just the far
00:01:51 right and they're trying to cover up their evil racism or or xenophobia or race or sexism or
00:01:57 whatever it might be uh and of course that's so sad because defending free speech is such an
00:02:02 honorable thing that is non-partisan it's got nothing to do actually with left and right and
00:02:07 yet it's it started to kindle these really dishonorable suspicions i think that that's a
00:02:11 that's a really sad thing and i so i wanted to address those issues uh and i wanted to talk
00:02:16 about the various threats to free speech that i perceive in society that are so often outright
00:02:21 denied by people there's a real sort of denialism going on people just saying there isn't a problem
00:02:26 even though you can cite numerous studies and people's experience it just shows that we we are
00:02:32 in a in a perilous state i think uh what you say there absolutely resonates with me from my
00:02:38 conversations i've had recently particularly with younger people uh at least in my terms younger
00:02:45 people uh in the sense that and i don't know whether you would agree with this once upon a
00:02:49 time you know the debate about free speech used to be uh between people who were free speech
00:02:55 advocates and those who said oh of course i believe in free speech but right that was the
00:03:01 always now it seems to me to be the case as i think you've alluded to there that they actually
00:03:08 don't believe in it they did it's not a but they just actually don't believe in it anymore
00:03:14 Yeah, I think time and again, there have been studies that have shown that younger people in particular are of the view that free speech ought to be curtailed in certain circumstances, particularly because they perceive it to be a threat to minority rights.
00:03:28 And they see this as a kind of zero sum conflict between free speech and minority rights.
00:03:34 I've cited a couple of those studies in the footnotes of the book.
00:03:38 So you'll be able to chase them up to see that I'm not, you know, this is absolutely verifiably the case.
00:03:42 Now, the argument I'm making is actually that that conflict is illusory, that in fact, the best way to defend the rights of minority groups and marginalised people is to ensure free speech for everyone.
00:03:54 And that's really why I think it's very important to make sure that people understand that the defence of free speech is not an attack on anyone's rights.
00:04:02 It's the opposite of that. And it's it's very sad to me that this misconception has become so widespread.
00:04:08 It is widespread. And I think sort of being put into practice, you know, you mentioned in the book, you say, you know, that the answer to hateful speech, for example, or bad speech is more speech.
00:04:24 yes so i think that's right that's all of the great civil rights luminaries of the 1960s
00:04:31 and and and further on into the 20th century knew this they knew that free speech underpinned all
00:04:36 of their causes this is why it coincided with the berkeley movement the university of berkeley
00:04:41 because free speech was part was part of everything and we also know uh from experience
00:04:46 and from research that all of the countries in the world today uh where free speech protections
00:04:52 are meager you also have uh the um oppression of minority groups they tend to the the oppression
00:04:59 is just much more intense in those countries where free speech is denied so the correlation
00:05:04 is is absolutely clear um and so there's all sorts of problems thorny problems that i try and unpick
00:05:11 in the book um and it's about sort of acknowledging a couple of things the first thing i did i do
00:05:17 acknowledge in the book is that speech can be hurtful that you know i think you'd have to be
00:05:21 sociopathic not to be aware that speech can hurt people's feelings and it can be cruel and it can
00:05:26 be wielded irresponsibly and all of those things and it can particularly be used to attack minority
00:05:33 groups and you we've all heard hate-fueled demagogues and and people um you misusing their
00:05:39 their freedom of speech but the point that i am trying to make is that actually censoring those
00:05:45 people and applying blanket censorship across the board is not in fact uh going to help minorities
00:05:51 it's going to make things worse for a number of reasons that I go through.
00:05:54 I don't know how much you want me to go into now, but but but I that's the argument that I'm presenting.
00:05:59 And my my sincere hope is that free speech skeptics in particular will read the book.
00:06:05 It's nice and short. It's to the point. It's not padded out.
00:06:08 In fact, you know, I wanted it to be a short, accessible book because, you know,
00:06:12 I didn't want to write things that I didn't need to write to make the argument clear.
00:06:15 But I do hope that those people who are wavering and I think most people are wavering,
00:06:19 because I think a lot of people do support free speech in principle, but are nervous about what
00:06:23 they now call hate speech. They're nervous about the potential for incitement. And they're nervous
00:06:28 about the way in which speech can be used to attack marginalized groups. And I acknowledge
00:06:32 all of those positions. I'm not here to trash them. I'm taking them seriously. And I work
00:06:39 through those arguments. And I hopefully try to come out the other end with a robust defense of
00:06:44 free speech in a persuasive way. That's my hope. That's my intention, whether I've fulfilled that
00:06:49 or not remains to be seen the thing is uh and it seems that there are two sort of two different
00:06:54 issues here uh which uh get conflated and probably rightly actually is that you've got the free speech
00:07:00 thing and then you've got the whole kind of um i know you don't use the word woke in your book
00:07:05 actually at all do you you don't use the word woke but you've got this kind of uh totalitarianism
00:07:12 which means that therefore it's possible is it not that some people would not read your book
00:07:17 because it's written by you that's exactly right i mean there are some uh well we call them woke
00:07:24 ideologues but there's something about this current social justice movement intersectional
00:07:30 uh movement um which has an inherent hostility to free speech not just a failure to defend it
00:07:36 but an active hostility against it and the reason for that as i outline uh is that its origins are
00:07:42 in the the uh post-modern theorists of the 1960s and 1970s for whom language was how our perception
00:07:49 of reality is constructed so there is an undue emphasis on language which is why today uh and
00:07:55 although i do believe that the current social justice movement is not true post-modernism it's
00:07:59 a kind of perversion of post-modernism but they do hold on to this idea and you hear phrases such as
00:08:05 words are violence yeah uh or you hear them talk about how language normalizes hate all of this
00:08:11 kind of thing which is an entirely faith-based position that is actually debunked by all of the
00:08:16 studies into the impact of language into the effects of media on popular on on the public
00:08:20 imagination so we can actually look at those things but but this movement isn't interested
00:08:24 in data it isn't interested in truth and it absolutely isn't interested in hearing an
00:08:31 opposing point of view because it has a kind of religious zeal and it sees all forms of dissent
00:08:35 disagreement as basically uh heresy so yes although it is true um that those kind of ideologues will
00:08:42 never pick up this book because my name is on it um we mustn't get so caught up in this culture war
00:08:48 to forget that most people are not culture warriors right so you've got the the extreme
00:08:53 culture warriors on the right and the left um and on the left they are particularly powerful
00:08:59 they're powerful in all of our major institutions art institutions cultural educational they
00:09:04 certainly dominate higher education um but they're still a minority right they're just a powerful
00:09:08 minority uh similarly the kind of culture warriors are on the extreme right they're a
00:09:14 massive minority too and the most people are somewhere in the middle so it's all very well
00:09:19 saying you've written this book in a persuasive way directly aimed at those who are unsure but
00:09:25 those people will never read it actually that's wrong because most people are open-minded most
00:09:31 people are not the woke uh that's just a very small minority which i agree i you know they won't
00:09:35 read it and that's fine it's not really aimed at them it's aimed at those who are somewhere in the
00:09:40 middle and i think that's to be honest i think that's most of us and i think that's that's
00:09:43 worthwhile i don't believe in giving up on persuasion i don't believe in saying well we'll
00:09:47 never win this fight so let's just go on the attack in other words join in the culture war
00:09:52 i'm interested in bringing the culture war to an end i'm not interested in being a culture warrior
00:09:56 no i mean the the thing about your book actually is it it's uh and i mean this in a complimentary
00:10:03 way it's sort of accessible and it's it's very explanatory i mean it doesn't assume
00:10:08 that people know i mean let's face it we talk about these things all the time pretty steeped
00:10:12 in it but but at the same time you know as you say not everyone is obsessive as maybe
00:10:18 maybe we are about it one thing you do mention one chapter you have um which i think is one of the
00:10:24 areas that most people would really really identify with is the one about hate speech
00:10:30 you've you know you've talked about it most European countries now have hate speech laws
00:10:35 they don't have them in America as such because of the First Amendment but where do you stand on
00:10:44 this actually Andrew I mean when it comes to hate speech which it seems to be basically expanding
00:10:51 It's very nature is expanding. Do you think that they that hate speech laws are a real threat to free speech?
00:11:00 I would say that hate speech laws are the biggest threat to free speech because we all agree that state censorship is unacceptable.
00:11:07 And this is the current present day manifestation of that.
00:11:11 We can have arguments about other forms of censorship and other forms of other threats to free speech,
00:11:15 such as cancel culture such as big tech censorship such as self-censorship that happens when you
00:11:20 create this culture of conformity in which we live and i'm sure we'll get on to that but if we're
00:11:25 going to go for state censorship well that's that is what hate speech laws are because that is an
00:11:30 example of the state saying we get to decide what you're allowed to say and what you're not allowed
00:11:35 to say um there couldn't be a clearer example in fact of of state censorship now the problem with
00:11:40 it of course as i've explained well there's that book by paul coleman called censored where he
00:11:44 The book is actually predominantly the transcripts of the various forms of hate speech legislation that occur across Europe, throughout European countries, and none of them have a shared definition.
00:11:55 You know, the European Court of Human Rights has acknowledged this, that there is no possible shared definition of hate speech because the concept of hate is so subjective and the concept of what is classified as offensive is similarly subjective.
00:12:08 And so we in this country have hate speech laws in the form of the Public Order Act 1986 and the Electronic Communications Act 2003.
00:12:18 In that case, of course, it stipulates that anything that is grossly offensive that is posted online can be prosecutable, can be a criminal offence.
00:12:27 So and that, again, such a subjective idea. How on earth can you possibly enforce that?
00:12:32 and we have seen in our country because as you say we don't have a first amendment we don't have
00:12:36 constitutional protections for free speech in the way that the americans do so what we have is uh
00:12:40 over a five-year period as i mentioned between uh um it was 19 sorry 2014 and 2019 the police
00:12:47 recorded 100 120 000 non-crime hate incidents the police as you know how and now routinely send
00:12:55 tweets out saying we'll we'll pay a visit to you we'll be knocking on your door if you say something
00:12:59 that upsets someone uh they're routinely arresting people for misgendering or the language that they
00:13:04 choose to describe other people now all of this is a serious encroachment on our liberties and and
00:13:09 i'm really worried about the way that people aren't taking this seriously enough there isn't
00:13:13 really an appetite you don't see politicians standing up and saying we need to repeal these
00:13:16 laws for precisely the reason that i mentioned earlier because the worry is that if you say you
00:13:21 don't agree or believe in hate speech laws people will say well clearly you're on the side of the
00:13:26 racists clearly want racist people to say racist things and actually that's absolutely not what
00:13:31 we're talking about here do you know that's absolutely true i don't think i've ever heard
00:13:36 any politician talk about these things in this country anyway um i think the point you you alluded
00:13:42 to it there you you talked about non-crime hate incidents we had harry miller on the show some
00:13:49 time ago he's the guy where the police turned up and said we need to check your thinking uh you do
00:13:54 mention that in your book um but the point about these short these things surely andrews that the
00:14:01 police these go on statistics don't they they go on records so people basically have them on their
00:14:08 on their records when it comes to employment checks and things yes for disclosure barring
00:14:13 service checks the dbs check it will show up that will certainly affect your employment prospects
00:14:17 and more to the point even if someone has simply made a complaint against you they are under no
00:14:23 obligation to prove that there was any hateful intent it is all about perception you can check
00:14:28 that yourself on the the government's hate speech website uh and the crown prosecution service
00:14:32 guidelines are very clear about this and the college of policing guidelines which are used to
00:14:36 to instruct police and they all say the same thing that you know if someone just you know if you said
00:14:40 something if you said something to me that was critical about my book well i'd say well how dare
00:14:45 you and we could have a big row about it and i could say well i perceived that you did that from
00:14:48 a homophobic point of view and it doesn't matter whether you did or not it doesn't matter what your
00:14:53 sexuality is or not it's just my perception of the situation and then i could phone the police
00:14:57 and that would in fact be recorded in those non-crime hate incidents even though there's
00:15:02 been no proof or investigation so that's that's one thing and that's a very scary thing in of
00:15:07 itself that then goes on to the official statistics for hate crime in the country which is why maybe
00:15:12 we're seeing a constant rise in hate crime because a lot of it isn't hateful or indeed criminal and
00:15:18 then as you say the other serious aspect of that is that you are then stigmatized and it could
00:15:22 possibly affect your employment so it does matter and also just you know what just in terms of sheer
00:15:27 principle if you would have asked anyone i mean including uh those on on the left if you'd have
00:15:33 asked them 15 20 years ago if you just said to them you know in by 2021 the police will in this
00:15:39 country will routinely be investigating people for non-crime no one would have believed you
00:15:45 absolutely no one so if we you know if we're talking about this slippery slope well there it
00:15:50 is in action, it's absolutely demonstrable. And the reason it keeps happening is because people
00:15:54 won't stand up against it and say, I'm sorry, enough is enough. In fact, it's going the other
00:15:58 way. You know, you had the Law Commission the other day pushing for expansion of hate speech
00:16:02 laws. I know that didn't necessarily go through, but the SNP are incredibly authoritarian. Humza
00:16:08 Youssef, the Justice Secretary, pushing through his new hate crime bill, which would see private
00:16:13 conversations in the home criminalised if they stir up hatred. No one seems to know what that
00:16:19 means of course but it doesn't matter it's just about setting a mandate for government to arrest
00:16:23 people for what they say in their homes there's even a section of that bill that talks about the
00:16:27 public performance of a play and he was asked about this in the scottish parliament and he said
00:16:30 you know a group of far-right people could get together and put on a play and as i said at the
00:16:35 time i don't know i don't know any neo-nazis but i know for sure they're not into amateur dramatics
00:16:39 i don't think i could deal with it you know no exactly no i think the point you've actually come
00:16:47 I was going to ask you actually next is that this subjectivity, first of all, is extraordinary to the point where Jordan Peterson tweeted something recently.
00:16:58 He had no idea about how the law was actually worded in this country and he was taken aback by it.
00:17:05 And he he tweeted. And I remember replying, saying, I'm afraid it is the case.
00:17:11 The next one down, I think, probably, Andrew, will be misogyny.
00:17:16 I mean, I think that this is kind of bubbling away, isn't it?
00:17:19 That this will become an aid crime. 0.91
00:17:22 Yes, these things are forever expanding.
00:17:24 And there's all sorts of groups who are, particularly when it comes to intersectionality,
00:17:27 which, of course, divides everyone up in terms of their various demographics.
00:17:30 They're going to keep pushing for this.
00:17:31 I remember seeing that tweet from Jordan Peterson.
00:17:33 And it doesn't surprise me because I think a lot of people in the USA and in Canada don't realise the extent of the problems in this country.
00:17:41 And part of the reason is they seem so unbelievable, don't they?
00:17:44 they seem so obviously dystopian i mean even that phrase you mentioned we need to check your
00:17:50 thinking you can't describe that as anything other than orwellian it is thought police that's
00:17:56 exactly what it is so you know i don't have much truck with these people who say oh well the use
00:18:00 of orwell has become a bit of a cliche yeah it's a cliche because it's so pertinent that's that's
00:18:04 the problem i think uh you know my own for my own experience in the london assembly uh i went to
00:18:11 had to question the police and i use this example of harry miller and in fact they actually made the
00:18:17 point that you made there which was simply that we have to be aware that these things escalate
00:18:22 that what starts out as something like that their automatic assumption despite what the judge said
00:18:29 in that case was that there was going to be a kind of escalation that therefore the implication
00:18:35 being there would be violence or whatever but well you know um philip k dick had a phrase for
00:18:40 that and that's pre-crime yeah um yeah by the way there has been the necessary research undertaken
00:18:45 into this do you know how many of those non-crime hate incidents did in fact develop into criminal
00:18:50 activity the answer is zero none there are no recorded uh incidents of where that has actually
00:18:56 happened so we know it's not true this is one of the incredible things about this whole movement
00:19:00 is there is this faith-based thing this idea that we just assume that this is the case it's the same
00:19:05 when people talk about systemic racism they will say oxford university is institutionally systemically
00:19:10 racist and then you'll look at the statistics that show you quite clearly that racism is one
00:19:14 of the least racist places in the not just the country but the world you know the incidents of
00:19:19 racism just rarely happen there but they will just deny deny deny they'll just say oh well then we'll
00:19:24 ignore that because that those statistics don't take into account lived experience or they'll come
00:19:28 up with some kind of nebulous reason why the data isn't correct and and it's a it's a failure to
00:19:33 confront reality and and similarly here you just get your things are taken on faith when uh reality
00:19:40 tells us something very different um so that that is another problem which which i suppose is
00:19:45 unrelated because that's more to do with the the social justice movement but but it is connected
00:19:49 isn't it it's completely connected uh you know if you were you know you've you've written plays
00:19:56 haven't you and you've written you know particularly you know for titania mcgrath being
00:20:00 one of them in edinburgh and obviously you are were a stand-up uh comic i think i imagine you're
00:20:05 not doing so much of that at the moment but there are no stand-up comics at the moment really
00:20:09 the ones doing it over zoom and i you know i admire their pluck uh but it's not something
00:20:15 i could ever do i i don't know how that would work really but with it but with this the scottish
00:20:20 proposals it particularly as you said affects performance and this thing about the domestic
00:20:29 arena being able to criminalize speech in the jury you know it is extraordinary is it not that
00:20:35 the prime minister for example has not just simply said sorry you know forget it you know
00:20:42 this is ridiculous there's been nothing and this is what is so worrying isn't it it's become really
00:20:49 difficult for politicians to stand up and do that because immediately the accusation is that they
00:20:54 are supporting some of the worst people in society because they say that they should be able to speak
00:20:58 um that's how that's why it's it's actually just very difficult for politicians who want to be
00:21:03 re-elected and also there has been a kind of cultural shift on this issue you don't really
00:21:08 get much defense even from artists performers you know a good comparison which i've used before and
00:21:14 i mentioned in the book i think is if you go back to the tony blair era when he was trying to push
00:21:18 through the racial and religious hatred act was that 2006 yes it was the one with rowan atkinson
00:21:24 where he protested i believe yeah that's right so you had comedians pretty much unanimous saying
00:21:30 this can't go through and that was that campaign was spearheaded by rowan atkinson as you as you
00:21:34 say and there were letters to the press and all sorts of things and and because you know comedians
00:21:39 understood that all it would take is one person complaining about an edinburgh show say a stand-up
00:21:43 show at the edinburgh festival fringe and then that show would be shut down while at pending
00:21:48 investigation by the police and of course financially that's ruinous uh for anyone who's
00:21:53 ever been to edinburgh as an act knows that they they plow a lot of money into it and they don't
00:21:56 get the return even if they're relatively well known so that would have been terrible so comedians
00:22:00 were you know absolutely unanimous and also they were they were about defending artistic expression
00:22:04 um however that's changed right so when the marcus meekin case occurred a few years ago the the
00:22:11 famous nazi pug case where he made a joke video of his girlfriend's pug dog and he taught it to
00:22:16 a nazi salute um and and respond enthusiastically to phrases such as zieg heil and gas the jews
00:22:22 not pleasant phrases that was the whole point of the joke it was the juxtaposition of the cuteness
00:22:27 of the animal and the horror of the phrases that that were the trigger phrases so um but of course
00:22:32 it was a joke it was even explained in the video that it was a joke you might say it was offensive
00:22:36 it was distasteful i understand why some jewish people who lost relatives in the holocaust would
00:22:41 be horrified by that joke but it was a joke nonetheless and and and yet he was prosecuted
00:22:46 in a court of law it went all the way and he was found guilty ultimately and he now has a criminal
00:22:51 record uh under the hate speech laws the communications act 2003 now that's a very
00:22:57 serious uh infringement on on civil liberties that's a real worry but at the time i defended
00:23:03 him one or two other comedians defended him uh basically none of the vast majority comedians
00:23:08 actually started attacking people like me who were defending him and that's in what 2017 around there
00:23:15 so something has happened between the only blair in 2006 there has been a kind of sea change
00:23:21 among artists and among creatives
00:23:24 where even they no longer trust artistic expression?
00:23:29 I think no longer trust artistic expression.
00:23:33 I would almost go further than that, actually.
00:23:35 In my experience, at least, not with comedy,
00:23:38 but in the arts, is that they're quite happy
00:23:41 to be the carriers of the message, it seems to me.
00:23:44 Yeah. Oh, it's so boring, isn't it?
00:23:46 You know, every time you go on Netflix or something
00:23:49 and you see a message telling you,
00:23:50 oh well this film made 50 years ago might have might have been made in a different cultural
00:23:54 context with different values and i'm thinking really i probably knew that because i'm not
00:23:59 stupid uh this patronizing you know coddling thing that these big corporations fit and i
00:24:05 think people are sick of it because when they see the way things are cast uh to prioritize
00:24:11 diversity it isn't that there are different racial groups being represented on tv i've never cared
00:24:16 about that and frankly i never used to notice it it's just not something that that that bothers me
00:24:20 um and it would be weird wouldn't it if if everyone in all the tv shows was white i would
00:24:25 say that's that is a problem but that hasn't been the case for many many years um but the reason
00:24:30 why people resent it is because they don't like being hectored because there's this sense isn't
00:24:33 there that what these tv program makers and filmmakers are saying is you lot out there
00:24:38 you're all evil racists and you need to understand that diversity is good we know that diversity is
00:24:44 good we're not racist we don't need to be preached at certainly not by avaricious corporations who's
00:24:50 The only goal really is to squeeze as much money as they can out of the rest of us.
00:24:54 Absolutely. Yes. Do you think with hate, hate speech laws, would you just repeal them?
00:25:02 Would you just get rid of them? You would.
00:25:05 Yeah, 100 percent. Just get rid of them. 0.99
00:25:06 I don't think hate speech laws have any place on the statute books of a liberal democracy.
00:25:10 I don't think the state has any right to decide what people can and cannot say.
00:25:15 There are some thorny issues around incitement.
00:25:17 incitement to violence as you know has always been illegal under english common law um and but i think
00:25:23 the threshold has to be very high you know i don't think it's sufficient to say that um metaphor
00:25:29 military metaphors for instance qualify as incitement to violence as was leveled towards
00:25:34 boris johnson when he was using praises like uh betrayal and surrender bill um you know political
00:25:40 language is combative and colorful that you know nobody's going to hear boris johnson use the word
00:25:45 betrayal and pick up a gun and go out and shoot people that's not how this works and i thought it
00:25:49 was quite shameful actually uh when certain politicians tried to connect his language to
00:25:54 the death of joe cox uh because you know in order to make that kind of accusation you better have
00:25:58 some evidence that there was a direct that there was causality there there is no evidence of that
00:26:04 whatsoever you know and and i think that's the problem and we know as well uh i mentioned this
00:26:09 in the book about media effects theory we have had six decades of research into the way in which
00:26:14 mass media consumption has an impact on public behavior and the answer is it doesn't people
00:26:20 aren't mechanically acting on cues and yet still again this is one of those things that's totally
00:26:25 taken on faith you remember in 2019 when the movie joker was out there were there were loads
00:26:30 of articles by people saying oh well this is irresponsible material this will cause young men
00:26:36 to go out and cause commit violence people were even fearing that young men would go out and shoot
00:26:41 up people in the in the cinema um there was a weird sense in which it felt like these writers
00:26:46 were sort of hoping for it in a way because it would confirm their prejudices but look there's
00:26:52 no evidence at all that that that that happens whatsoever and and you know the direct effects
00:26:57 model of media effects there is be completely discredited but people don't want to look at
00:27:01 the facts don't want to look at reality they want a simple solution you know when you see
00:27:05 some horrific thing like the christ church massacre where those muslim worshipers were
00:27:10 murdered by this far-right extreme terrorist evil let's just call it what it is evil man
00:27:16 and of course people want to come up with some solution that it's well because that's
00:27:21 inexplicable isn't it so what they do is they look at they look at the the websites he was looking at
00:27:25 they say oh look he shared this daily express article the week before the murders as though
00:27:30 that is in any way connected to the event itself uh and and like i say i have sympathy for that
00:27:36 when i hear a new story like that it it upsets me i want to know why and and it's much have a
00:27:42 simple explanation that can just say you know and this has always been the case doesn't you remember
00:27:45 back with the um the james bulger murder yeah um the immediate knee-jerk reaction by the press was
00:27:50 the responsibility was the filmmakers of child's play three because there was a copy of that video
00:27:55 at the home of the boys in fact i think as it turns out they didn't even watch the film because
00:28:00 there's a scene in the film on a train track on a it's actually a fairground ride but the press
00:28:05 said it was a train track and and that connected to the james bulger merger murder and again that
00:28:11 murder was inexplicable you you looked at that and you thought how could two 10 year old boys
00:28:15 possibly possibly torture and kill a small child and you want to make sense of it and so therefore
00:28:21 here's a solution it was this movie that did it they watched the film and then they committed the
00:28:25 act now so i get it but we have to as adults look into the research on this and and acknowledge
00:28:31 that there is no causality there is no connection there and that we're going to have to look for
00:28:36 answers elsewhere the one of the overriding problems surely in all of this as well is is
00:28:43 that whatever the laws have brought in because you know you talk about hate speech laws
00:28:48 unofficial or official bodies but not legal bodies if you like such as uh ofcom they've also
00:28:55 widened what is considered to be hate speech on television to an absurd level many people would
00:29:03 say but therefore the main problem surely the main threat to the whole situation is self-censorship
00:29:08 which i would i would suggest is now pretty much the default position isn't it it has to be it has
00:29:17 to be because i mean if you take the example of when um i can't remember the channel that ditched
00:29:21 the episode of faulty towers called the germans because in in that episode the character of the
00:29:26 major used a racial epithet and of course as john cleese said afterwards when he was writing those
00:29:32 lines uh the major is meant to be this old uh relic of a different time he says those words
00:29:39 in order that the the show is mocking him he's the he's the person we're laughing at for using
00:29:45 these antediluvian offensive phrases that's the whole point but but but this literal minded thing
00:29:50 all they hear is oh there's an offensive word therefore it's offensive therefore we need to
00:29:54 shut it down now that means of course let's extrapolate that let's take that principle
00:29:58 that means that any writer who wants to have a character who is morally dubious who says morally
00:30:05 dubious things well now because of this literal-minded interpretation it's going to be
00:30:08 very difficult to do that what if you want to represent some horrific act of violence or
00:30:14 horrific attitudes or ideas right because sometimes dramatists and artists want to delve
00:30:20 into those areas and want to want to represent those things faithfully but if you can't do that
00:30:25 without someone uh slapping a label on your work or indeed withdrawing your work or indeed saying
00:30:30 this work isn't going to be published because because this character is offensive then the
00:30:35 inevitable corollary of that is that artists will begin to self-censor and they do and i know they
00:30:39 do because they tell me they do i speak to artists all the time creators people contact me comedians
00:30:44 i have to say who do say that they're they're just not going to go into these areas and that
00:30:48 means that art suffers unless artists can be free to just follow their muse you know to to explore
00:30:54 things and and represent things as they wish then um the whole medium will suffer the whole
00:31:01 you know art can't work that way well it basically i'd say it's an attack actually on the very
00:31:06 foundations of culture uh you know you simply can't go on in that uh situation
00:31:13 which is why i always remind people and i do say in the book that self-censorship ultimately is a
00:31:18 choice uh and and of course i think i think if you want to be a true artist you have to
00:31:24 be free and you have to not um curb yourself on the basis of of other people however there's also
00:31:32 the reality of the business of living and most of us don't are not independently wealthy uh and
00:31:36 and you know kazuo ishiguro the great novelist kazuo ishiguro yesterday uh said that he was
00:31:42 very concerned not for himself he's an established novelist he's won the booker prize he's he's you
00:31:46 know he doesn't have to worry about about getting published uh or indeed selling books um but he does
00:31:53 he said that young writers today particularly young novelists are are not going to be free
00:31:58 to express themselves because they're not established that's the worry it's always the
00:32:01 worry with the younger generation with with new artists coming up is that they're now writing
00:32:05 within very tight limits of acceptability and uh although it's possible historically you know
00:32:11 artists have worked within those limits it takes sort of geniuses uh like da vinci you know uh if
00:32:17 it does because you have to find ways to work not to upset the vatican you know
00:32:22 that's the problem you know michelangelo if you're painting the 15 chapel
00:32:27 and uh you know you find ways to be subversive without there are actually some very subversive
00:32:33 images there but they got past the vaticans very smartly done but however we're not we're not all
00:32:37 able to do that and we do we should have that artistic freedom people have fought and died for
00:32:41 this you know how much of a uh uh free speech fundamentalist would you say you are and when i
00:32:50 say that you know people say oh well you know you know you shouldn't you know scream fire in a cinema
00:32:58 or whatever it's a bit of a that's a bit of a uh a red herring i think actually i think everyone
00:33:03 would sort of agree with that but for example i think it was christopher hitchens talked about
00:33:08 this you know and all well all well said you know is being able to tell people what they don't want
00:33:14 to hear but i mean should for example people who deny the holocaust should they should their free
00:33:22 speech be protected i think it should and the reason i think it should is the best way to deal
00:33:28 with those who are completely wrong about history and particularly from a malevolent intent is to
00:33:34 destroy their arguments using the evidence of history now you'll know for instance with the
00:33:39 case of David Irving who actually served prison time for denying the holocaust it was actually
00:33:45 Richard Evans the historian Richard Evans who took him down because he demonstrated how flawed
00:33:51 Irving's analysis was and it was irrefutable and it was far more powerful if you lock someone up
00:33:56 like that it just gives credence you know all of a sudden all of these conspiratorial people are
00:34:00 thinking oh well maybe he's got a point it gives him a kind of glamour glamorous sheen that he
00:34:05 doesn't deserve it makes him a sort of martyr figure and the best way i mean i know there's
00:34:09 a lot of concern about fake news and things like that but absolutely the best way to combat fake
00:34:14 news and and people being wrong about factual events is to counter it with with better research
00:34:19 and i'm also very concerned that the fake news for a start has generally been used as an epithet
00:34:25 or a way to write off inconvenient news uh things that people just don't agree with a lot of these
00:34:31 fact checkers that are employed by social media companies for instance are very ideologically
00:34:36 partisan and they will say things are factually untrue because they just don't want them to be
00:34:41 true that's a problem so you know absolutely i am i have to say an absolutist when it comes to
00:34:46 to free speech i don't approve of um holocaust denial of course or any kind of abuse actually
00:34:52 I'm very into politeness and decorum. I really disapprove of instability and I don't engage.
00:34:59 If someone's not civil, I won't engage with them. I'll just block them and move on because I want to talk to other adults who are able to have civil discussions.
00:35:06 But that is not incompatible with a free speech absolutist position. In fact, the two, as far as I'm concerned, are extremely compatible.
00:35:11 Yes. What what about this other big threat that we are?
00:35:17 Well, it certainly concerns the likes of me doing channels like this from big tech.
00:35:24 Do you take that seriously? Very seriously.
00:35:27 I think it's the next big free speech battle, because firstly, we have to win the argument.
00:35:31 We have to explain to people that this argument of whether they're private companies, they can do what they want.
00:35:36 That is an argument that's about 20 years out of date.
00:35:38 We have to acknowledge the sheer impact that social media has, the power that it holds.
00:35:44 It is the de facto public square. It is the main principal realm of discourse throughout the globe.
00:35:49 You know, this, you know, I mean, no, that we know that when a few companies have this kind of oligopoly, governments do intervene.
00:35:57 That's why antitrust laws exist. We know that there is a problem here.
00:36:01 And I understand that particularly those who are for the free market, libertarians, are often concerned about intervening when it comes to private companies.
00:36:08 But look, there's a way to there's a way to do this, because it isn't just the case that they're they have these terms of services which they enforce.
00:36:16 They will also destroy any competition in its nascent form.
00:36:19 You know, Parler was set up. This was a platform to rival Twitter and the social the social media tech giants collaborated to basically destroy Parler.
00:36:28 So it's not the case that you can just go off and set up your own Internet or set up your own.
00:36:32 It can't be done. So we have to acknowledge that.
00:36:35 And we have to talk about the issue that, you know, these are multibillion dollar corporations with more collective power than any nation state.
00:36:43 And yet they have none of the democratic accountability. That's a risk.
00:36:47 That's a threat to free speech. And it is one that we have to take seriously.
00:36:50 It's extraordinary, isn't it? The sort of people perhaps on the left, actually, you know, they find themselves defending these big corporations.
00:36:57 and say well you know they're just private companies you know they're just private companies
00:37:01 only because they agree with them yes that's all i mean it's utterly hilarious to me i don't think
00:37:07 you can call yourself left-wing if you're cheering on a multi-billion dollar corporation can you or
00:37:12 saying those people that you want them to decide on the parameters of acceptable speech i think
00:37:17 that's a really funny actually laugh out loud funny contradiction but i also think um that it
00:37:22 fails to recognize the power that they have and it's also very myopic because it's it's not
00:37:27 looking into the future well these people might agree with you at the moment certainly the biden
00:37:31 administration will have no appetite to deal with the problem of big tech censorship because they
00:37:36 tend to be aligned with their message but what happens in the future what happens when you set
00:37:39 this precedent and 20 years from now uh the the people who are in charge of big tech don't agree
00:37:44 with you anymore you'll have no recourse at that point because you spent years saying they should
00:37:48 be able to censor whoever they want well that's going to bite you in the end isn't it at the end
00:37:53 of your book actually you you you paint a possible scenario uh you're not saying this is inevitably
00:38:01 going to be the case but it's a quite a bleak one you know uh which is one of utter conformity
00:38:08 i don't think you have to go that far in the future because i mean i don't know about you
00:38:13 but i kind of feel that a bit now um that in you know that somehow this is what the way things
00:38:20 could pan out how do we stop that being the future i'm not as i say this is just one thing
00:38:27 you say could happen what do we do to sort of actually prevent that uh we've got to win the
00:38:34 argument uh i think too many people have accepted that or accepted the false premise that freedom
00:38:41 of speech uh threatens minority rights uh that that freedom of speech is something that is
00:38:46 dispensable really and and that you know we shouldn't worry too much about uh granting the
00:38:51 state these unlimited powers to control what we say and think we need to win that argument again
00:38:55 and i know that you know just looking at history it's not something something you know it's
00:38:59 relatively recent actually that we have free speech you know societies throughout history
00:39:03 generally haven't had this it's quite miraculous that we've achieved this and we should be grateful
00:39:08 for that but we've got to hold on to it it's not something that is you win the argument and then
00:39:13 you've got it forevermore no it's constantly going to slip away because that that is the nature of
00:39:17 human nature that they're always going to be power hungry people people megalomaniacs who are going
00:39:21 to exploit their power in order to control other people and so therefore we need to win the argument
00:39:25 again and again with each successive generation and this is my uh modest uh contribution to that
00:39:32 effort well i mean the thing is it is uh it's extremely succinct and i i think required reading
00:39:40 and and if but if you were to if you were to go into university and if you just say oh let's
00:39:46 discuss free speech and here's my my book on it and you know I've no axe to grind other than the
00:39:52 subject at the moment the way things are probably you get short shrift wouldn't you well that's the
00:40:00 problem that we face is that we have to win the argument but we also have to persuade people that
00:40:04 the argument is worth having in the first place yes uh and and with this incredible denialism
00:40:10 that we have you know since gavin williamson's announcement about the the state of free speech
00:40:14 on university campuses we just had across the board denialism uh from publications such as the
00:40:19 guardian from a lot of students from the nus uh from the union of colleges all just saying there
00:40:25 is no problem with free speech on university campuses and of course as i mentioned in the
00:40:28 footnotes i i link to a number of studies from groups such as the policy exchange unit uh just
00:40:34 showing the extent of of the stifling of of the free exchange of ideas on university campuses it
00:40:40 is verifiable denying that there is a problem is not going to fix the problem you can't just wish
00:40:45 these things away uh my hope is that sufficient numbers of people as i say there will always be
00:40:50 those intransigent intransigent people who are not going to pick up this book who will think that
00:40:55 it's all a lie a ruse because what i want is to be able to have a go at minorities with impunity
00:41:00 that's clearly what they're going to think because you know they're they are no longer capable of 0.88
00:41:03 argumentation they're too sort of ideologically captured but I think for the majority of people
00:41:08 and this does include the majority of students they will be open to having this discussion
00:41:12 I gave a talk at Aberystwyth University and the students were really up for hearing different
00:41:17 ideas being challenged it was actually the members of staff it was actually the academics who refused
00:41:22 to publicize the event because they said any talk that was a skeptical about the woke movement
00:41:27 would be against their diversity policy they hadn't even heard the talk and it was actually
00:41:31 the academics who are causing so many of the problems not the students so i have great faith
00:41:36 in the younger generation and i have the great faith in students generally and you know you can
00:41:40 always cite a few zealots with who go into student politics but they are always the minority they
00:41:46 always have been it's it's never been the case that the majority of students are even interested
00:41:49 in student politics um unfortunately those few who do get involved in those committees then wield
00:41:56 power and they get to decide what their what their peers cannot hear that's the problem really so i
00:42:01 would sort of urge i think it's really great uh there's the new free speech champions initiative
00:42:05 yeah um which which is actually you know targeting uh universities getting students involved set up
00:42:12 um groups i did a talk at the london school of economics there was a um a free speech
00:42:18 society there and i gave a talk for that that's now a few years ago to be honest um but that was
00:42:22 one of the early examples of of this i think someone actually tried to get them cancelled
00:42:26 with no sense of irony um that that is that is what we need we need more and more younger people
00:42:32 to be braver and to sort of say no we want to have these difficult conversations we're not 0.98
00:42:36 going to be shut down we're not going to let you say that a gender critical feminist is hateful and
00:42:41 transphobic even though she's never said anything that's hateful or transphobic yes you know we're
00:42:45 going to have the difficult conversations and if you don't want to participate you're free not to
00:42:50 you know but you what you don't get to do is to decide that we don't get to talk about it
00:42:54 Yeah, we the free speech champions people we had on the channel actually a while ago.
00:43:00 It's a great initiative. Andrew, have you ever been what's your experience been of your own free speech being curtailed?
00:43:10 Well, it hasn't really. You know, I don't I don't think I've been censored.
00:43:13 I don't think, you know, I've been booted off Twitter a few times. That's the extent of it.
00:43:18 But, you know, I don't believe, you know, I've got a platform.
00:43:21 You know, I'm in a very privileged position. I go on television, I go on radio, I write for the national press.
00:43:26 I mean, I can't then do all that and complain that my free speech has been taken away.
00:43:30 It absolutely isn't. But of course, this idea, I mean, I've had a lot of people tweet about my book saying,
00:43:37 oh, look at this person getting a book deal and complaining that his free speech has been taken away.
00:43:41 It's not a complaint I've ever made. It's perfectly possible to be concerned,
00:43:45 to be concerned about something that doesn't impact you directly.
00:43:49 And actually, the people I'm worried about are, you know, cancel culture disproportionately affects working ordinary people who don't have the resources, the financial resources to defend themselves, which is why the free speech union set up by Toby Young is so important.
00:44:03 But, you know, they don't have the ability or the platform to redress this problem.
00:44:10 This idea that cancel culture is just holding the powerful to account is completely backward.
00:44:15 It's completely wrong.
00:44:16 the people who get affected are the supermarket worker who loses his job for sharing a clip on
00:44:20 facebook or whatever you know it's normal people uh and so therefore i think we need to uh i i my
00:44:27 own personal circumstance i mean i have lost work uh for my opinions i've lost work for my um for
00:44:33 the jokes that i tell or whatever but i don't consider that you know that's that's fine that's
00:44:37 not i don't consider myself to be censored because i don't rely on the work that i've lost you know
00:44:41 I mean, it's not a good situation. I'm not going to complain about it because I have a platform and I like I said, I've got a publishing deal. Why should I worry? Why only worry about other people? Yes, that's what makes sense.
00:44:51 No, of course it does. Absolutely. And also, I mean, the fact is, this will speak to a huge number of people. I would say that more than any other comments we get on this channel, it's about the issue of free speech, about fear, about not being able to say what they feel. This is the biggest thing.
00:45:12 um andrew thanks very much it did the book it free speech and why it matters andrew doyle there
00:45:19 it's available obviously most people get these books on amazon now don't they uh but uh and it's
00:45:26 really really very worth it thank you very much andrew for coming on and uh you know talking to
00:45:32 us about it and um thanks for this contribution so uh thank you very much for having me i always
00:45:39 appreciate coming onto your show, Peter. Oh, well, thank you. We shall see you again soon.
00:45:43 I very much hope. Thank you very much. And that is
00:45:47 it this week. First of all, what you're saying is, please do
00:45:51 join us next week. In the meantime, do remember, won't you, to
00:45:55 subscribe? I say that every week, but please do, won't you?
00:46:00 Thank you very, very much indeed. Bye.
00:46:09 You