New Culture Forum - March 11, 2021


Has The Oprah Interview Damaged The Monarchy?

What Can We learn From Ex-Communist Nations In Building A New Culture? Laurence Fox: Why Im Standing Against Sadiq Khan To Be London's Next Mayor

Episode Stats


Length

43 minutes

Words per minute

163.57

Word count

7,045

Sentence count

220

Harmful content

Misogyny

2

sentences flagged

Hate speech

6

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00 hello and welcome to counterculture I'm Peter Whittle now before we discuss our
00:00:17 topic today would like to say to you please do subscribe won't you to the
00:00:23 channel we're now on something like 12 million views a hundred and nine thousand
00:00:28 subscribers but we want to keep that going so please do go on when you go onto the channel
00:00:33 press subscribe and then next door to it there's another pin there it's like a little bell
00:00:39 which is notifications that way you'll get all our programs as they come up so please do that
00:00:46 now it takes a big subject surely to knock covid and the pandemic and the lockdown off the front
00:00:56 to the newspapers, but that's what's happened obviously this week. The news has been dominated
00:01:00 by the interview given by Prince Harry and Meghan Markle to Oprah Winfrey. So today we're going to
00:01:08 be looking at the consequences of this, how seriously would it damage the monarchy, how will
00:01:16 it change public attitudes to the monarchy, and indeed should we even have a monarchy in the
00:01:23 future. Now with me to discuss this, I'm very pleased we have the journalist and author and
00:01:29 in fact biographer of Prince Harry, Angela Levin. We have Emma Webb from Civitas, Brendan O'Neill,
00:01:38 obviously very well known to you from all his various media appearances and editor of Spiked
00:01:42 Online, and Rafe Hadle-Mancou making a much welcome return, albeit remotely, to the programme.
00:01:49 I'm obviously rave for his historian and commentator and also has been doing a lot of royal commentary in the Australia, America, New Zealand over the past few days.
00:01:59 So thank you very much for joining us. Can I start with you, Angela?
00:02:06 This interview that went out in America on Sunday, in Britain on Monday, was it as bad as you feared or was it what you expected?
00:02:19 It was much worse than I feared.
00:02:23 I thought it might be an old repetitive thing
00:02:25 about how we've got to be compassionate to everybody
00:02:28 and things like that.
00:02:30 I was profoundly shocked.
00:02:33 At some point, I couldn't even say anything.
00:02:35 I was so shocked.
00:02:36 I thought it was incredibly nasty, really.
00:02:41 It was really washing proper royal linen in public,
00:02:48 which I don't think anybody should do.
00:02:52 I felt it was cruel.
00:02:54 I felt some sympathy for Meghan because I felt...
00:02:59 Some sympathy.
00:03:00 Sympathy for Meghan because I felt that it was very hard for her
00:03:04 to be in the royal family,
00:03:06 that she absolutely seemed not to understand what it was about at all
00:03:10 and various other things which we probably will come to,
00:03:14 you know, that she felt so depressed.
00:03:15 I don't think anyone should feel like that.
00:03:18 But when I thought about it a bit later, about five o'clock in the morning,
00:03:25 I saw that there were lots of holes in the claims that they made
00:03:29 and they didn't seem to sound solid to me.
00:03:34 Making statements, making accusations without going into the context of it,
00:03:39 the background of it, or who it was and the type of conversation that brought them up.
00:03:44 instead of which the royal family now has a thick dark cloud over it where everyone is blamed we
00:03:52 don't know if it's a senior royal who said the wrong things we don't know if it's a very young
00:03:56 junior employee who's just begun working in the palace or whether it's somebody in between
00:04:02 and i think to allow that is particularly to to encourage that thought amongst us
00:04:08 is very dangerous for the monarchy.
00:04:11 Rafe, how serious do you think the damage is
00:04:15 through this interview to the institution?
00:04:20 Well, the one good thing is, as King Farouk of Egypt once said,
00:04:24 at the end of the day, there'll only be five monarchies left,
00:04:28 five kings left, the king of spades, king of clubs,
00:04:31 king of arts, king of diamonds, and the king of England.
00:04:33 He is very secure in this country.
00:04:36 calling for the monarchy has always been strong
00:04:38 even in the darkest days of the 90s
00:04:41 the death of Diana in 97
00:04:44 support for the monarchy was surprisingly
00:04:46 now that our population shifts demographically in this country
00:04:51 with the younger population and recent immigrant sharing 0.89
00:04:53 less affiliation for the monarchy
00:04:55 but the monarchy here is still secure
00:04:57 but it's the damage that has caused to around Britain
00:05:01 to UKT
00:05:02 to our soft power status around the world
00:05:05 You look at America now, so the Americans see that they have their Britain shattered by this.
00:05:10 You look at our call from a former Prime Minister saying this is yet further evident to abolish the monarchy.
00:05:18 Similar calls now being heard in the Caribbean.
00:05:21 So this is not only a betrayal by Harry of his brother, his father, his grandmother, his entire family.
00:05:30 This is a betrayal of Britain too.
00:05:32 would you go brendan do you do you did you come away with the impression of the interview in a way
00:05:40 you know that sort of was that it was anti-monarchy i mean you're republican did did you think that
00:05:48 this was sort of direct directed at the institution i i thought the whole thing was grotesque to be
00:05:56 honest um not i'm not one to beat around the bush i thought it was a disgusting spectacle
00:06:01 What we had here were two incredibly wealthy, privileged, youngish people sitting in an unbelievably luxurious, luxurious mansion in California, telling the billionaire Oprah Winfrey how difficult their lives have been, how oppressed they are, what victims they are.
00:06:20 And it was incredibly decadent and lacking in self-awareness and completely tone deaf. 0.60
00:06:27 This is a country, the United States, where 40 million people lost their jobs as a result of lockdown, where millions of people have been plunged into poverty, where people are getting by on stimulus checks worth $2,000, which is about half the cost of the dress that Meghan wore for her interview with Oprah, which she will probably never wear again.
00:06:48 I just thought the whole thing, this playing of the victim card by people who are incredibly privileged was quite repulsive.
00:06:56 And I do think it will be damaging to the monarchy.
00:06:59 I've been a Republican all my life.
00:07:01 I'm now really worried that Meghan Markle and Prince Harry are turning me into a monarchist because I constantly feel the urge to defend the monarchy.
00:07:11 I'm opposed to the monarchy and ultimately I would like to see it abolished.
00:07:15 But my admiration for the Queen is growing all the time because she is really the only member of the British establishment who is holding the line, who is defending traditional values, who's defending tradition itself against this tsunami of crazy people and crazy new ideas, you know, right from Princess Diana to Meghan Markle, from the cult of revelation to the cult of emotionalism.
00:07:43 All of these trends have been banging on the Queen's door for the past 30 or so years, and she's held the line against them. So my admiration for her is growing. But I do think the monarchy will be pretty deeply damaged, particularly internationally, by what Harry and Meghan have done.
00:08:02 This is the point, isn't it?
00:08:03 Because this is this racism charge.
00:08:07 You've got to remember the Commonwealth is 70% non-white.
00:08:10 I mean, this is something that the Queen has dedicated her life pretty much to, wouldn't you say? 0.99
00:08:16 I mean, you know, Brenda mentioned there about public service and everything.
00:08:21 Of course, we all know, don't we, what the public service really is.
00:08:24 And it's not universal, is it, in the way that Prince Harry and Meghan have said?
00:08:28 Yeah, I think that I've actually, Brenda's just given me a reason to, one reason to like Meghan Markle, that she's made you into feeling like you might become a monarchist.
00:08:40 But no, I think that you've made a really good point there. And there is, as you say, all of these trends in society at large knocking on the door of the monarchy.
00:08:50 and what I thought was particularly jarring was the the sheer narcissism and as you say the lack
00:09:01 of self-awareness of Meghan and Harry in contrast to the Queen's speech the day before about
00:09:07 Commonwealth Day talking about a selfless devotion to duty which she really has epitomized throughout
00:09:15 her entire life and her career that it was just so obvious that um harry and megan particularly
00:09:23 megan have this absolutely rotten mindset and just bad ideas that are really at the core of a lot of
00:09:31 the stuff that they were saying um which is symptomatic of something in society at large
00:09:36 but they really did seem to be just um painfully out of touch and you know there were moments where
00:09:42 i was sort of pulling my jumper up and cringing because it was just so awful to watch and like
00:09:48 you said that you know the racism um charges that they made and as angela already pointed out you
00:09:53 know afterwards you you sort of step back to look at some of the claims they've made and there are
00:09:58 it's like moth bitten there are holes all over the place and the it was almost like an adam curtis
00:10:03 documentary the way they juxtaposed unrelated things to imply something that probably never
00:10:08 happened like the um references to race in relationship to um what they were saying about
00:10:15 um about Archie's title not being given the title of prince even though it's not protocol for him
00:10:22 to be given the title of prince but they were trying to make that into a an issue of racism
00:10:27 the worst the worst one for me actually was her saying that she was so depressed that she wanted
00:10:34 to die and she was desperate for help she went to HR in in the palace which is an extraordinary
00:10:43 choice because it's for staff it's not for the members of the royal family and they said to her
00:10:48 that she can't do anything about it because it might affect the institution she called things
00:10:55 the institution not the palace or the monarchy distancing herself and I thought how terrible
00:11:01 that was and then I thought to myself this is perhaps nonsense I mean Prince Harry went to seek
00:11:08 therapy when in his early 20s when he suddenly had this terrible throwback to his mother's death
00:11:17 and he got incredibly depressed and he acknowledged that his brother Prince William
00:11:22 was very helpful in getting him the right person to help him. Prince Charles went to seek therapy
00:11:29 when his marriage to Diana completely broke up.
00:11:32 And he helped Diana get help as well.
00:11:37 Harry, Kate and William set up this royal foundation
00:11:42 on which, or in which, mental health was absolutely prime,
00:11:47 that people should come out and they should talk about it
00:11:50 and not be ashamed.
00:11:53 And yet, what did he do?
00:11:55 He's Meghan's husband.
00:11:56 He must know countless people.
00:11:58 The royal family knows every good doctor and specialist in the country.
00:12:07 Why didn't he help her? Why didn't he make a few phone calls?
00:12:11 But the worst thing of all is that when you're pregnant, you go along to the obstetrician regularly and they ask you about your health.
00:12:20 And there was Megan's opportunity to ask about her depression and to seek help.
00:12:27 that the fact that nobody did anything is absolutely unbelievable.
00:12:33 It doesn't have the ring of truth to me about the therapy thing.
00:12:38 When I saw it, it sort of seemed like, oh, they don't believe in all this stuff,
00:12:42 and therefore they basically stopped her doing it, right?
00:12:45 But the fact is we all know that going right back to Princess Margaret,
00:12:49 they had therapy. 0.59
00:12:50 They all believe in it.
00:12:51 Yes, exactly.
00:12:52 So it's a nonsense.
00:12:54 Sorry, Ralph, yes?
00:12:55 No, yes. We have to remember, Meghan Monkle isn't a 19-year-old Diana. This is a 39-year-old woman and an extremely successful American actress who moved to L.A. That jungle, that competitive jungle, worked her way up through there, which is not an easy thing to do.
00:13:10 This is a strong-willed woman, a determined woman, who's friends with people like Serena Williams and George Clooney, etc.
00:13:17 The idea that she's not capable herself of reaching out for help, for paying a psychiatrist of her own.
00:13:23 She could have a permanent psychiatrist with her if she wanted to.
00:13:27 I don't buy it at all.
00:13:28 In fact, I don't believe anything that this woman says when it's not corroborated by clear evidence.
00:13:34 We see none of that.
00:13:34 And to lay that most insidious and incendiary charge of racism, the worst charge you can make in this climate, to lay that at the festival of Buckingham Palace without any evidence, and without naming the person, or providing any context in terms of how it was said, where it was said, with what tone it was said, and so forth, and not to name the person, placing a shadow, casting a shadow over the entire whole family in an inexcusable calumny.
00:14:02 brendan you know if you think back to uh diana's famous famous interview with panorama which has
00:14:10 actually been in the news a bit lately hasn't it because of the way in which she was uh got by
00:14:14 bashir uh do you think this is qualitatively different i mean at the time when we watched
00:14:20 that i remember the monarchy was a low ebb it seemed very mortal as an institution uh but here
00:14:26 we are you know 25 30 years later and it's actually been going quite great guns so do you
00:14:33 think it's this is worse in its effect or for the monarchy or not as bad that's a good question i
00:14:43 think um there are similarities between the diana interview and the harry and megan interview
00:14:49 i'm afraid i was never the biggest fan of diana i know that was that's that's a blasphemous thought
00:14:55 in some circles but one of the first ever jobs I did in journalism actually the first piece of
00:15:00 reporting I ever did in my whole life was go down to the mall when everyone was camping out
00:15:07 essentially so that they could see the funeral cortege and interview people who were camping
00:15:11 out I was very young at the time and I was slightly bamboozled by people's behavior so I
00:15:16 wanted to discover why people were doing this and I didn't like the cult of Diana I didn't like the
00:15:23 way in which she was held up as this figurehead of new britain the people's princess who would
00:15:29 transform us all into these kind of open therapeutic emotional creatures and get rid of the stiff upper
00:15:36 lip and all that kind of stuff so i was never a huge fan of the diana effect the way she was
00:15:41 invested with this emotional power by people like tony blair and alistair campbell um there were
00:15:47 echoes of that in the Harry and Meghan interview. And in fact, Meghan name checked Diana, and she
00:15:53 said that she had talked to one of Diana's friends and asked her for advice. But it was also different
00:15:58 as well, because I think one key difference is that Diana, Diana, I don't think wanted to take
00:16:05 the monarchy down. Diana didn't express contempt for the people of Britain. In fact, she said she
00:16:11 wanted to be the queen of people's hearts. Now, we might think that's a bit saccharine, etc. But
00:16:17 But she did express an affection for the people of Britain.
00:16:21 What Harry and Meghan did, they actually expressed contempt for the people of Britain.
00:16:25 They expressed contempt for the royal family by spreading all these unsubstantiated rumours about racism and so on.
00:16:33 But they also expressed contempt for ordinary Brits, the way they talked about how the supposed bigotry of the tabloids filters down into society at large.
00:16:43 And Meghan openly said that the tabloid newspapers had tapped into a part of the British people, which is their alleged racism.
00:16:52 So they have this horrible view of ordinary Brits as a kind of latent racist mob who are so menacing and horrible that they had no choice but to flee the country.
00:17:03 That's what's different. Diana had affection for the people of the UK and, in fact, wanted to bond with us.
00:17:11 Harry and Meghan seem to have turned their back
00:17:13 not just on the monarchy
00:17:14 but on British people as well
00:17:16 and that's the thing I think
00:17:17 that will stick in many people's throats
00:17:19 I was going to ask you
00:17:21 obviously you followed Harry round
00:17:24 for quite a while
00:17:25 but quite a few years ago
00:17:28 when he was still a soldier
00:17:29 he made a comment that Britain wasn't a very nice place to be 1.00
00:17:32 he famously made this
00:17:34 which people have tended to forget
00:17:36 I don't remember that
00:17:39 to be honest
00:17:39 But what I do know is that Diana instilled in both her sons a sense of duty from a very early age.
00:17:48 She came from an aristocratic family and she cared about the monarchy.
00:17:52 She was off in Sandringham when the Queen was there and she was invited for tea and to play hide and seek.
00:17:59 And so she knew exactly what it was for a child and she wanted her children to be devoted to this country.
00:18:06 and she treated them very well so that Harry, as little as possible, felt that he was the spare.
00:18:14 She boosted him. And when Harry got fed up with being in the limelight and wanted to leave,
00:18:22 he said to me that he felt that he couldn't desert the Queen, that he felt so proud of her
00:18:29 and admired her so much that he would stay here
00:18:33 and try and work out a life around her
00:18:36 because his sense of duty was so strong.
00:18:39 And his other sense of duty was to go to William
00:18:41 because he realised there was a huge burden
00:18:43 and he thought that he could help him with this.
00:18:46 So it's in his genes, really.
00:18:49 And suddenly now he thinks it's the most terrible place to be.
00:18:54 What I thought was terrible in the interview
00:18:56 when he said that his father and his brother were trapped and that's such an angry word it's like
00:19:04 saying they're imprisoned and they've got no idea about what's going on it was very patronizing as
00:19:10 well and he hadn't realized he was trapped until Megan told him and I think that's another key
00:19:19 the fact of how much she controls him
00:19:21 and how much he has to do to please her.
00:19:27 And I think that's why he looks a shadow of himself
00:19:31 because he's working so hard to please her,
00:19:34 he's besotted with her and thinks that she is beyond human,
00:19:39 which is what she wants, I think.
00:19:42 And he's terribly stressed that he doesn't feel he's making her happy.
00:19:47 You see it in him.
00:19:48 He's nervous, he's twitchy, he looks depressed.
00:19:53 The way that she, in that interview, but also in other interviews as well,
00:19:56 the way that she seems to look at him physically,
00:19:59 it looks as if, I mean, maybe you can get the body language experts in,
00:20:02 but she looks at him almost as if he's a child or an object or something.
00:20:07 And the way that he behaves around her,
00:20:08 particularly in that scene during one of those little separate bits,
00:20:13 not the main interview, during the Oprah interview,
00:20:15 where he's sitting there feeding the chickens,
00:20:17 and he's almost sitting there like a lobotomized child and the way that he speaks is quite
00:20:23 frighteningly similar to somebody who is has been like radicalized or they're in a cult in the sense
00:20:28 that it's almost like he's not speaking his own words where he talks about um having done the work
00:20:33 and the you know he's almost like he's educated himself um and when he talks about racism he's
00:20:39 really absorbed these ideas but it doesn't sound like he's it's him who's speaking not that i want
00:20:44 to suggest that he's not you know responsible for his his own part in this but i think the dynamic
00:20:49 between him and megan is really interesting because toxic yeah completely and and it's um
00:20:55 well it's it's it's the narcissism again isn't it really um one thing's quite interesting sorry
00:21:01 yes it's not an important point that phrase that he said i didn't know i was trapped but i didn't
00:21:07 realize it and uh you know everyone's quite correct on this point he reminds me a bit of
00:21:12 the Duke of Windsor, in the sense that neither of them were very clever, they're not the
00:21:17 brightest sparks in the Christmas tree, and they were easily dominated, and in fact looked
00:21:21 for that domination, and the shift in the power play was so evident compared to when
00:21:26 they were first engaged to that Oprah Winfrey interview, where her hand was on top of his
00:21:32 hand, she was controlling, and she's the Yoko Ono for the royal family now, in the sense
00:21:39 This woman has actually radicalized, inserted new ideas into his mind.
00:21:44 Remember, this chap is now making accusations of racism,
00:21:47 because the same chap was happy to don a Nazi uniform and a swastika,
00:21:50 who referred to one of his Pakistani colleagues by the racial etiquette.
00:21:57 He's transformed himself completely in the way that Megan has tried to bring the royal family into the cultural wars.
00:22:04 This is a classic case of the culture wars affecting yet another institution in this country.
00:22:11 Hypersensitivity, the snowflakes versus those who put duty first.
00:22:15 Issues which we would just brush off become deeply offensive to these people.
00:22:19 These are issues which they simply can't get over.
00:22:22 Incidents which probably are forgotten by most people.
00:22:24 They still hurt and have feelings about it.
00:22:26 I think it's very interesting that Harry before used to go around and talk to people.
00:22:32 He was very good with damaged soldiers psychologically and physically, but now he's turned into a sub-lecturer.
00:22:41 You know, Megan lectures all of us as to how we should behave and what we should think.
00:22:49 And she takes it on a world brand. The UK platform is far too small for her.
00:22:55 She's always talking about globally. And she had the audacity to say just before this interview came out that she is going to, you know, bring compassion to the masses.
00:23:10 And you think to her yourself, well, hang on, what about the compassion at home?
00:23:15 And she said, and continue to do what is right and what is good.
00:23:20 So she's elevated herself to a sort of goddess that nobody must criticise, no one must disagree with, because she knows better than anyone.
00:23:31 And then you think, well, you are an OK actress, but where's your credentials to do this?
00:23:38 And she just genuinely feels that.
00:23:40 And so Harry worships her and will say and think whatever he's told to do.
00:23:46 I think also what Rafe was saying earlier about when you asked about Princess Diana,
00:23:51 I think that lots of elements of that interview felt scripted,
00:23:58 not from Harry, but particularly between Oprah and Meghan.
00:24:01 And I think a lot of the allusions there were intentional.
00:24:04 And it almost seems slightly psychopathic if you look at the comparisons between the way that Meghan has dressed in identical outfits multiple times to Princess Diana.
00:24:16 Her talking about, as Rafe mentioned, meeting up with one of Diana's friends.
00:24:22 It felt like there was something very intentionally manipulative about it.
00:24:28 I think that's to keep Prince Ariana leaving.
00:24:31 As Rafe said earlier, though, as well, that she's a very shrewd and ambitious person.
00:24:44 And there's no way that somebody who's that, not to say that somebody who's ambitious or successful can't get depressed, but there's no way that she's as thin-skinned and innocent as she's putting across.
00:24:54 when she was talking about the fact that she had to god bless her she had to google the national
00:24:59 anthem because nobody gave her any training from the firm in how to sing the national anthem and
00:25:04 that she felt lost because she had to learn some hymns she's an actress and she learned script
00:25:08 and and the fact that also that she um when she said that about um the way that she was talking
00:25:13 about the queen there is this complete lack of um respect and i don't i think that's a willful
00:25:21 ignorance on her part that she said that she didn't think that um she would have to curtsy
00:25:25 to the queen behind closed doors as if the queen isn't really the queen that it's just some show
00:25:30 for the public and it's absurd that she could even suggest that she was truly that ignorant and naive
00:25:36 the thing is i think i mean i'll ask you brendan here um the thing is is that we're talking about
00:25:43 her and what kind of character she is or we could be talking about diana but the ultimate thing is
00:25:49 is that when these things happen with the Royal Family,
00:25:52 basically support for the institution stays remarkably stable, right?
00:26:00 I'm not talking about the monarch here.
00:26:02 But when it comes to Republicans such as yourself, for example,
00:26:06 it never really goes above 20%.
00:26:09 I think that the worst, it went to about 20-something percent
00:26:12 during the Diana years, and it kind of went back.
00:26:15 do you think this is different this time or or do you think that they will weather this
00:26:22 uh just like they weathered 1995 96 97 um well you know i i'm i am a republican but i don't want
00:26:32 a republic on the basis of megan markle uh driving the knife into the monarchy that's not
00:26:39 the kind of public i'm streaming off and in fact when i hear left-wingers in the in the media and
00:26:45 online and in various debates i've done when i hear left-wingers talking about megan markle
00:26:50 as the woman who will single single-handedly turn britain into a republic i just think they
00:26:56 sound completely mental i mean that's not how it works the whole point of a republic as the name
00:27:02 itself suggests is that it's it's about the public it's about trusting the public to make their own
00:27:08 political decisions and in particular to elect their own head of state it's not about cheering
00:27:13 on one house against another or cheering on um a shrewd identitarian operator from the u.s as she
00:27:21 throws insults at the monarchy so i i think it's those people who are saying this could propel us
00:27:27 towards a republic i think they're being incredibly naive this is not how a republic comes about and
00:27:33 This is not how a republic should come about.
00:27:36 And that's why in this discussion I am firmly team queen
00:27:40 because the queen is behaving with dignity.
00:27:43 She is someone who has completely sacrificed herself
00:27:48 to public duty and to her constitutional role.
00:27:52 And I think the clash that we're fundamentally witnessing
00:27:54 is a clash between the culture of narcissism
00:27:58 as represented by someone like Meghan Markle
00:28:00 who is obsessed with herself obsessed with advertising her virtue advertising her wounds
00:28:06 telling everyone about herself all the time in this very confessional way versus someone like
00:28:12 the queen who represents the stiff upper lip keeping it all in keeping yourself together
00:28:17 and giving yourself over to something bigger than yourself and that's what the queen represents so
00:28:23 this is a fundamental culture clash between the new cultures of self-obsession and the old cultures
00:28:29 of loyalty and duty and sacrifice and that's why I'm on the side of the monarchy in this discussion
00:28:36 but I think um I think the monarchy will ride this out but I think a lot of the support even
00:28:43 for the institution I think is bound up with support for the queen I think there is a huge
00:28:48 amount of love in the UK for the queen because of her longevity because of her seriousness because
00:28:54 of her lifelong commitment i think when she goes the monarchy will be in trouble and that's when
00:28:59 it will become an interesting discussion potentially i think you see the interesting
00:29:03 thing there is that um you say that but but rave maybe you could you know give us your your thoughts
00:29:09 on this uh this idea that oh but when people talk about the monarchy they are talking about the
00:29:14 queen um the queen's always had very high favorability rates you know with the public
00:29:20 But, as I said, the institution, even during the dark days, actually, when people say, do you want it to continue, they say yes.
00:29:28 And then the pollsters say, do you want Charles or William or something?
00:29:34 But if you add all the options up, it still comes out as a significant majority for the institution, does it not?
00:29:42 It is, absolutely.
00:29:43 You have to remember that in a country like Britain, which is the world's longest continuous constitutional democracy, we have no great celebration of an Independence Day or a Republic Day or the anniversary of any great war of liberation or anything like that.
00:29:59 It's the monarchy that is actually the central focal point of our nation, not only institutionally, but also culturally and socially.
00:30:08 You know, the Queen's role is both as head of state, which is receiving ambassadors, going on state visits and so forth, but it's also head of the nation.
00:30:16 It's the person who basically becomes the focal point for outpourings of patriotism, displays of unity when the Queen attends a service at St. Paul's Cathedral.
00:30:26 It's as the mother of the nation, really, whereas the abbey is for the head of state.
00:30:32 And there's that role which is the only thing left in this country, I would say,
00:30:38 that has a chance of binding the people together, because it stands above class divisions,
00:30:43 it stands above race, it stands above politics.
00:30:46 It's a neutral institution to which we can basically draw hope from in the sense of it
00:30:52 being a grounding institution when everything else changes so rapidly and dramatically.
00:30:56 the monarchy is a rock that helps us to know our place in our island story do you think can i ask
00:31:01 whoever wants to answer answer this actually but it's my perception it's going a bit against
00:31:07 received wisdom maybe but you know the argument with the monarchy was always somehow or other
00:31:12 that it was going to become gradually more and more irrelevant now it's my perception that
00:31:16 strange enough has not happened that for all sorts of reasons possibly because of the culture
00:31:22 what we're always talking about on this programme.
00:31:26 It's actually become symbolically very relevant again.
00:31:30 And in fact, if you look at the statue argument,
00:31:33 it's almost like you think, I'm rather surprised
00:31:35 they haven't come for the monarchy yet
00:31:37 because it's the living embodiment, isn't it, of that history.
00:31:41 Would you say that it feels more, as Rafe just said,
00:31:44 it's one of the few things that actually can legitimately
00:31:47 and harmlessly bring people together?
00:31:50 I think very much that the Queen has become a sort of grandmother to all her citizens when the pandemic struck.
00:32:00 And it was really scary. I mean, we were lost, really, because it was so powerful.
00:32:06 And suddenly the life we'd led, we could no longer lead.
00:32:11 And when she came on with her speech, which was very unusual for her to speak outside of Christmas Day,
00:32:19 there was 112 words I think she said but she changed the mood of the country by saying you
00:32:27 know we will overcome this we will get better you know we must be strong and people really needed
00:32:35 that and and felt more comfortable and that she would somehow sort it because she's the core of
00:32:44 this country you see that i'd say the most interesting thing about that speech was not
00:32:49 actually so much what she said which was great but the fact that 24 million people watched it
00:32:53 that's right you know in other words it's showing that she has a masterful way as well of saying
00:32:59 things without saying them not being political whilst also being the last stand against all of
00:33:05 the nonsense and i think that that is why i am so concerned that when harry apparently told oprah
00:33:14 by the way can you make it clear it wasn't the queen or prince philip that had said these
00:33:18 apparently racist comments that in a way they presuming that it's not going to be prince
00:33:26 william because it's very unlikely and and they also said very nice things about william and kate
00:33:31 during that interview he essentially put the boot in against prince charles which i think
00:33:37 and he but it's it's it's the suspicion like you said the dark cloud hanging over them and i think
00:33:43 that prince charles doesn't have the same level of hold or charisma as the queen does over people
00:33:51 and obviously there are some people who think that it should skip to um william and kate and
00:33:57 And to some extent, Kate embodies a lot of those virtues that stand in absolute contrast to Meghan Markle.
00:34:03 And Meghan has framed it as if this is a PR fight, that the narrative are pushing this false narrative about Meghan and Harry.
00:34:13 And she said something in the interview that said, you know, you don't have to, you know, hate one of us and love the other one.
00:34:19 It doesn't have to be framed in that way. But the fact of it is.
00:34:21 After having framed it that way.
00:34:23 She framed it in that way and also the fact of it is that she does embody the opposite of the virtues that Kate embodies.
00:34:30 Kate is really the heir of the queen in terms of the sort of matriarchal archetype that the monarchy encompasses all of the values that we associate with the monarchy and why it's such a good thing for this country.
00:34:45 I don't think that you can avoid that clash and the contrast really brings out, you know, Meg.
00:34:52 I think that Prince Charles will change when he becomes king.
00:34:58 I think he's very cautious about upsetting his mother
00:35:01 or doing things that aren't right at this stage in her life.
00:35:04 I spent a year with him before his 70th birthday
00:35:08 and the way he reacts to young people, 1.00
00:35:12 getting them off the streets and millions of people
00:35:15 down around the country and giving them a chance to live.
00:35:20 He's very popular when he goes around, but he's somebody like, you know, like a sort of deputy prime minister, as it were, who can't actually call the shots because he's respecting his mother.
00:35:34 But I think once he does become king, that that will change and we will find that he can manage it in his own way.
00:35:42 He won't be the same quite right.
00:35:44 Can I sort of, you see, again, we're doing actually what we've got to be careful not to, which is we talk endlessly about the personalities.
00:35:52 I know this is terribly important in this case, but it's the institution I'm thinking of really here.
00:35:57 I'm sorry. And, you know, I've got a bit of a grudge going here with Brendan as a great monarchist.
00:36:05 But the thing is, is that the way I see it is this, if I can explain.
00:36:09 I remember when I was living in America
00:36:11 during 9-11
00:36:12 there were people who wanted to
00:36:15 express their extraordinary patriotism
00:36:18 when the country was under attack
00:36:19 but they hated
00:36:21 Bush
00:36:22 but they felt that if they had started
00:36:25 criticising Bush they would have appeared
00:36:27 treacherous and disloyal
00:36:30 and it sort of occurred to me then
00:36:31 isn't this the greatest situation
00:36:34 we've got therefore where we've got a figure
00:36:36 who you can go and cheer
00:36:38 if you want
00:36:38 and you're not making a political statement you see the difference is what kind of a president
00:36:45 would you want brendan if you want a president would it be a ceremonial one or would it be a
00:36:50 powerful one well you know i'm i'm a radical democrat i know that's not particularly popular
00:36:58 and i'm sure most of the public would not agree with me i want a unicameral um parliamentary
00:37:05 system so i want to get rid of the second chamber i think the house of laws is completely out of
00:37:10 date and a disgrace to democracy yeah you know these unelected peers i think is terrible um
00:37:17 and i think if we have a head of state he or she should be elected i think we should also have more
00:37:23 power democratic say so in the workplace in everyday life i'm in favor of more referendums
00:37:28 i thought the brexit referendum was one of the greatest political events of modern times i'm just
00:37:33 a huge fan of democracy and that's that's the very simple reason why i'm opposed to having a
00:37:40 hereditary head of state it's really as simple as that but but things are complicated now and i think
00:37:46 you're right to suggest that the monarchy has become bound up within the culture wars and i
00:37:51 increasingly find myself on the side of the monarchy not as an institution but certainly as an
00:37:57 idea. But I think monarchists have to face up to the fact that the monarchy is an institution
00:38:05 out of time, out of its time. And I actually think many ordinary people in the UK admire
00:38:13 the Queen enormously and support the institution of the royal family. But there are growing
00:38:20 numbers of influential cultural elites, media elites, various powerful people who would view
00:38:29 the monarchy as outdated, archaic. And the monarchy runs counter to so many contemporary
00:38:35 trends, like the trends for self-revelation, emotionalism, speaking your truth, as Meghan
00:38:43 Markle ridiculously puts it. So the monarchy, I think, faces a political, cultural struggle
00:38:49 to remain intact and you know the great power of the monarchy always lay in the fact that it could
00:38:56 maintain an aura of mystery it was um it floated slightly above the real world and things you know
00:39:04 behind palace doors we didn't really know what was going on it was a mysterious institution
00:39:09 whose power derived from its mystery and now it's under extraordinary pressure to join the culture
00:39:16 in which we're all supposed to let it all hang out and express our sorrows and advertise our pain
00:39:22 and signal our virtue, that is going to be a very corrupting culture for the monarchy. So I think
00:39:28 people who support the monarchy should actually treat very seriously the threat posed by contemporary
00:39:35 culture, because I think that, even more so than Meghan Markle, that is what is going to grate
00:39:41 against the monarchy in the coming years.
00:39:43 Can I ask what, George, going back to personalities again,
00:39:48 what do you think, I mean, you know,
00:39:51 when you're talking about Meghan and Harry,
00:39:54 you know, one of the views seems to be that sooner or later
00:39:57 this marriage is going to end anyway. 0.58
00:39:59 You know, basically once she's done what she's going to do,
00:40:03 you know, bang, he's off.
00:40:04 Does that sound frivolous to you or does that sound possible, likely? 1.00
00:40:08 Her history is that she uses people until she no longer needs them and then drops them.
00:40:16 The point is, though, that she's needed to stay with Harry because the royal tick is what's giving her all these opportunities.
00:40:30 But you can see he's fallen really behind her and he doesn't want to stand up to her.
00:40:37 I don't know what you think.
00:40:38 Yeah, I agree.
00:40:39 I think it seems as if he is sort of in her shadow.
00:40:47 And whilst she needs him for her purposes, as it were,
00:40:53 I do wonder how sort of psychologically sustainable it is for him.
00:40:59 I mean, obviously, we don't know what's going on behind closed doors,
00:41:02 but it doesn't seem as if it's a particularly healthy relationship.
00:41:07 And as we're talking about earlier with the comments that he made about his his family members being trapped and it was almost like, you know, I was trapped and I didn't realize I was trapped until she told me that I was trapped.
00:41:22 But now I'm free because she said that I'm free and everybody else is trapped, you know.
00:41:26 Isn't that the very definition of woke? I was I was asleep and now I is woke.
00:41:30 exactly but it but there's there's something a bit sinister in that that makes me think that you
00:41:36 know she's obviously got a huge amount of sway over him um he doesn't seem to he seems sort of
00:41:41 almost like a shell of his former self um so i don't know how sustainable that is i have no idea
00:41:47 whether or not it's their relationship is sustainable over time but i don't think it's
00:41:52 it doesn't it doesn't appear to be from the outside like a particularly uh emotionally
00:41:56 healthy one but Harry hasn't got very much to offer to all these things that she's doing he
00:42:03 can't act he he was in the army but that's not relevant now um he hasn't got a qualification
00:42:10 in anything else so um he hasn't found a real place where he can be whereas Megan is is doing
00:42:19 masses and um I don't think that that's necessarily a healthy way for a couple to move forward you've
00:42:26 got to look at many of the social memes at the moment with the two of them you know and they've
00:42:30 been you know in their faces have been reversed and she's leading them along like a little child
00:42:37 yeah well look thank you very very much all of you for um for sharing your particular truths with us
00:42:42 today thank you thank you very thank you brandon thank you very very much emma and um thank you
00:42:51 Thank you very, very much, Angela.
00:42:53 That's it for this week.
00:42:55 As I said at the very beginning,
00:42:56 please do remember to subscribe, won't you?
00:43:00 And, well, God save the Queen, actually.
00:43:02 Thank you very much.
00:43:03 Bye-bye.