New Culture Forum - March 08, 2021


What Can We learn From Ex-Communist Nations In Building A New Culture?

The Continuing Scandal Of Muslim Grooming Gangs & The Failure Of Our Institutions To Deal With It Has The Oprah Interview Damaged The Monarchy?

Episode Stats


Length

42 minutes

Words per minute

158.29

Word count

6,676

Sentence count

173


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to counterculture. I'm Peter Whittle. Now on this program obviously we've
00:00:18 talked a huge amount about the culture war which is currently raging behind virtually all of our
00:00:23 news headlines and indeed we will continue to do that but is it just a
00:00:28 Western thing or indeed is Central and Eastern Europe also experiencing a
00:00:34 culture war similarly here we are more and more worried about restrictions on
00:00:40 free speech and the growing sense of being behind trample lines of what we
00:00:46 can and cannot say what we can express what can eastern and central europe tell us when it comes
00:00:56 to free speech can it give us warnings about the way in which we are going now with me to discuss
00:01:03 these issues i'm very pleased we have guests some of whom actually grew up under communism
00:01:10 first of all we're joined by frank ferrady who's a friend of the show he's been on many times
00:01:16 He's Emeritus Professor of Sociology at the University of Kent and, of course, an esteemed author and journalist.
00:01:25 Also, we have Anishika Kolek, who is an artistic curator and co-founder of the Passion for Freedom Festival.
00:01:35 James Bartholomew, the author and journalist, and also the man behind a campaign to have
00:01:43 a museum of communist terror established here in the UK, and Emma Webb from Civitas.
00:01:50 Thank you very much for joining us. If I can start, please, with you, Frank. I mentioned
00:01:56 about the culture, which you write hugely about. Is there anything comparable, and I
00:02:03 I know I'm taking it as a very broad stroke here,
00:02:06 but is there anything comparable in Central and Eastern Europe going on?
00:02:12 At the moment, I think the culture war is raging all over East Europe.
00:02:20 I think in many respects, it's very powerful in the four V countries of Slovakia,
00:02:29 the Czech Republic, Poland and Hungary.
00:02:31 and certainly I'm kind of impressed by the fact that in many respects Hungary has become the
00:02:39 bastion of the other side of the culture war because I think in Hungary what you've got
00:02:44 is a unique determination by the prime minister to basically argue that number one we're not
00:02:52 globalists we believe in national sovereignty number two we take the past very very seriously
00:03:00 Number three, we take the legacy of European civilization, which includes everything from the Judeo-Christian tradition all the way to Rome, to the Enlightenment, as part of our culture.
00:03:13 And he has gone so far as to say that he's prepared to become a totally at-and-at conservative, somebody who is even prepared to reject what he calls the American type of liberalism.
00:03:29 in order to safeguard the cultural legacy and heritage of Western civilization.
00:03:35 So the way that he looks at it and the way that the government looks at it
00:03:39 is that Hungary's role, in many respects, is to play an active role in the cultural war
00:03:46 in order to ensure that the Hungarian nation and Hungarian culture actually survive.
00:03:53 The problem that Hungary faces is that having been invaded by an army of NGOs from the West
00:04:02 and having been dominated and kind of influenced by this kind of Netflix, Hollywood kind of culture,
00:04:09 which demean everything to do with sort of Hungary's tradition,
00:04:15 he feels that instead of just merely reacting, occasionally sort of acting as that kind of backlash,
00:04:23 You've got to take the initiative.
00:04:24 You've got to decide what kind of world you want to live in.
00:04:28 And I think in that sense, he is, along with some Polish colleagues,
00:04:33 the only people in the European continent at the moment
00:04:37 who are actively at the official governmental level
00:04:40 taking a serious role in fighting back against
00:04:45 what we in Britain experience as cancel culture.
00:04:49 I'm fascinated to hear that, actually.
00:04:51 You say council culture there, Frank.
00:04:54 I just want to ask you more.
00:04:57 What general form is the cultural war taking there?
00:05:00 Is it just very similar to what we're seeing here in America
00:05:03 and in the Western Anglosphere?
00:05:07 Well, I think that in East Europe,
00:05:10 if you take, for example, Slovakia, Poland, Hungary,
00:05:16 you'll find that there's a very big division
00:05:18 which mirrors the distinction in Britain
00:05:21 between the London metropolitan elite
00:05:24 and the rest of the nation,
00:05:27 between Northern England, let's say.
00:05:28 Similarly, in Hungary,
00:05:30 Budapest is much more likely to be similar,
00:05:35 not entirely, but in large measure,
00:05:38 to San Francisco or to London
00:05:40 than the rest of Hungarian societies.
00:05:43 And that kind of tension exists
00:05:45 in all these East European nations
00:05:47 to a greater or lesser extent.
00:05:49 I also wanted to add on that note that when it comes to the situation in Poland,
00:05:55 there is also a huge number within the society that travels not just on holidays
00:06:02 and just to visit the museums, but also people that actually work abroad.
00:06:06 And they had to work abroad through the communist times.
00:06:10 At that time, it was only communist bloc that we were allowed to go and work.
00:06:14 But then obviously after the fall of the communism, the financial situation was so horrendous that all the youngsters had to work abroad and not only.
00:06:25 And now some of these people are coming back and they're telling their families how is it to live actually in the West.
00:06:32 And I have to say that as a young person moving to Britain, to London in 2002 after completing my studies, I was very naive.
00:06:40 I thought that people in the West, they appreciate freedom.
00:06:43 They understand the price you pay if you lose it.
00:06:46 And I could observe that it's not such an ideal picture.
00:06:49 And obviously with years as things progress and we slowly losing freedoms here,
00:06:54 I can give exact examples of how this process happens step by step here now,
00:07:00 and not just be born into communism and already have this situation upon me.
00:07:06 me and people go back to Poland whether they come to work here and then they go
00:07:12 back and talk to families and tell the stories how does it look like or they
00:07:17 might be moving back because they experience the situation here and they
00:07:21 just have enough and they don't want the children to be subjected to this
00:07:25 indoctrination at schools and to the council culture to the fact that you
00:07:30 cannot talk openly about things where for us we've been there we've done that
00:07:34 and we don't want to live like this you're you're nodding along there frank absolutely i think that
00:07:41 a lot of hungarians have decided to go back to hungary even though they have higher living
00:07:48 standards uh here in england for a very simple reason that they don't want their kids to be
00:07:54 indoctrinated in schools and they have this kind of sensibility that their way of life is being
00:08:01 looked down upon and regarded as kind of a second-class one and therefore you've got
00:08:06 it's something that i was quite surprised i imagine that a lot of hungarians here would
00:08:11 get brainwashed into you know sort of woke you know sort of bbc culture and although some you
00:08:17 know react like that the large majority of them have kind of resist that they feel that there's
00:08:22 something there that's not really them and and for that reason many of them have become sympathetic
00:08:28 of brexit many of them have you know decided to kind of go home and they kind of there's a kind
00:08:34 of tension here which is on the one hand they would you know ideally like to continue living
00:08:38 here but they realize especially if they got children that it's much better for them to
00:08:44 to live in hungary where they they exist in a culture that is it actually takes their way of
00:08:49 life seriously i don't think it's only only the fact that um there's the indoctrination and there
00:08:56 there is one and only truth but I think there's also the discrepancy between the
00:09:01 reality of life and the things that we are being told and told to believe and
00:09:07 so obviously most of these people they live in the neighborhoods that are not
00:09:11 well-off they go to normal schools they have to deal with normal problems they
00:09:16 they are not part of establishment that can fence themselves off from everything
00:09:21 that goes on the ground and I think that this is another point that we
00:09:25 recognized from the communist times where if you were at the top of the power you could have
00:09:30 whatever you wanted and if you were down below you didn't have that but also you had to shut up
00:09:36 yeah james um i remember you know when we spoke before and you came on the channel actually to
00:09:42 talk about the museum um you know you we were discussing the way in which young people actually
00:09:49 know almost nothing actually about communism in our education system i mean i'm you know from what
00:09:56 anishka and and frank have been saying there about the indoctrination um it is the case isn't it that
00:10:03 sort of western children have no idea about really the crime not just the crimes of communism but
00:10:11 even what it actually was yes this is absolutely right i mean there are two levels here the first
00:10:17 one is that they are taught very little about communism. 70% of young people, I think it
00:10:24 was one of your own studies, worked out that 70% of young people as 18 to 24-year-olds
00:10:33 had never heard of Mao, who arguably was the most important figure of the 20th century,
00:10:40 certainly responsible for more deaths than any other person
00:10:45 through famine and torture and death and murder.
00:10:49 But they've never even heard of him,
00:10:51 which seems to me an extraordinary failure of our system.
00:10:54 But even when they do get taught about communism,
00:10:57 they do tend to get a greywashed version.
00:11:01 It's not saying that, for example, Stalin wasn't a nasty man.
00:11:05 They say he was tough, and that's admitted,
00:11:09 and that people suffered and even died.
00:11:12 But it is greywashed to the extent that one of the revision books that I came across
00:11:18 invited students to consider the pros and cons of the collectivization of farms,
00:11:25 a process in which 3.9 million people died in Ukraine alone,
00:11:31 and I think is comparable to asking about the pros and cons of the Holocaust.
00:11:36 It is appalling and shocking, I think, the downplaying of just how bad the collectivization of farms was and just how bad the Cold War and even Cold War is a bit of a euphemism, the Soviet takeover of Eastern Europe, which is a more accurate way of describing it.
00:11:57 and their desire to create an empire of communism,
00:12:02 that the effect on the people who endured that is barely mentioned.
00:12:07 It is seen entirely from Stalin's strategic point of view.
00:12:11 And when it goes well, it goes well for Stalin.
00:12:13 That's the prism through which it is seen.
00:12:16 And I think this is a badly oriented and reprehensible way of viewing history
00:12:23 to the extent that they are taught history at all.
00:12:26 Yes. I mean, this is obviously a big deal,
00:12:30 young people not knowing actually anything about communism.
00:12:36 But it really brings up another thing, doesn't it?
00:12:38 We can't therefore sort of learn, can we, from, if you like, the warning signs.
00:12:44 People here have become very, very complacent, have they not, about their freedoms,
00:12:48 and in a way that I'm sure Anishika or Frank simply are not.
00:12:52 Yeah, totally. I think people don't see the signs of the times and the example already that was given of Mao. People are completely ignorant of the history of China. They don't understand the Chinese Communist Party as it currently is because they don't understand the historical trajectory to get to that point.
00:13:11 They don't understand how China became communist or what happened during the Cultural Revolution at all.
00:13:16 And so when you see people on television talking about when they're in relation to statues or in relation to Black Lives Matter,
00:13:25 and you see academics actually using the phrase cultural revolution, they know what they're talking about.
00:13:31 But the rest of the people who are watching the news don't understand the implications of what is being spoken about.
00:13:38 and they also don't understand the implications of the things that they see
00:13:42 and they very easily misunderstand those things
00:13:45 or they try to fit it into a framework that makes sense to them
00:13:48 because ironically, when our education system is criticised
00:13:53 for being too Eurocentric, in some ways it is too Eurocentric
00:13:57 in the sense that we only ever criticise European countries
00:14:00 and European history and Russia has sort of fallen outside of that.
00:14:05 there isn't really a very even-handed approach to looking at communism and the evils of communism
00:14:11 as was already mentioned yes um frank you mentioned at the very beginning netflix
00:14:18 um you know and this kind of netflix version of life i think we sort of all know what we're
00:14:25 talking about really um that i know you're using that as a maybe an emblematic way but that is
00:14:32 what sort of in if you'd like it it's infecting eastern europe or in central europe well i think
00:14:41 it's understandable that american soft power is extremely influential throughout the world
00:14:49 and if you're a teenager in hungary or poland you know you listen to american rock music you
00:14:57 listen to mtv you know people watch uh hollywood films they the american celebrities the american
00:15:04 stars have this incredible cachet even now and what people often forget is that when you when
00:15:11 you listen to the words of these songs or when you watch a netflix uh sort of program they kind
00:15:18 of subliminally send out a very clear message so you know in the average netflix film you know it's
00:15:24 almost unthinkable that a heterosexual man could be sensitive or could be a nice individual.
00:15:32 It's almost unthinkable that a white person could in some shape or form be morally superior
00:15:39 to a black person. It's unthinkable in all these things that a child could be anything other than
00:15:47 the font of wisdom. So when you're looking at the characterization that's kind of promoted,
00:15:52 it's always the adults who are thick and insensitive it's always the children who possess
00:15:57 the wisdom it's always certain minorities oppressed people who have this incredible
00:16:03 fluidity and flexibility and what you've got is almost either unwittingly or consciously
00:16:09 a continuous degradation of what i call western cultural norms and i think that what what you
00:16:17 find is that if you go to budapest or if you go to cracow or warsaw and you go into the trendy
00:16:22 cafes there you the young kids naturally have internalized all this stuff you know and they
00:16:30 that kind of that genderist politics is quite influential in the universities they think it's
00:16:36 really really cool you know to kind of experiment in the way they're doing the silicon valley
00:16:41 it's natural it's quite understandable and i think that for a very very long time the
00:16:46 political leaders in east europe the older generation didn't really comprehend this they
00:16:51 they were completely unaware of the influence of this because they didn't really understand
00:16:56 what happened in britain or in in in the western society and it's only now that some of them are
00:17:02 catching up and realizing that if you basically outsource your entertainment and your culture
00:17:08 and your kind of cultural way of life to Hollywood,
00:17:12 then you are going to have a real problem on your hands.
00:17:15 You're going to lose control over your own society.
00:17:19 And I think to that extent, they're experiencing it in an intense form
00:17:23 what the French have been complaining about for a very, very long time
00:17:27 as kind of they become aware of French culture
00:17:30 gradually becoming extremely Anglicized.
00:17:32 But the big difference is that French and English culture share,
00:17:36 The trendy cultures share many of the same norms,
00:17:40 whereas in Hungary there is still a very big fundamental chasm
00:17:43 between their way of life and the Netflix way of life.
00:17:47 Well, exactly.
00:17:49 It's interesting because the Pew Institute did some extremely thorough research
00:17:57 and showed that if you looked at Western Europe
00:18:00 and then Eastern, for want of a better, Eastern and Central Europe,
00:18:03 There was an absolute divide right down the middle in terms of attitudes to what we might call social and moral matters, same-sex marriage, for example, patriotism, even the component that religion played in your sense of your nationality, you know.
00:18:22 you know james why do you think there is such a huge difference and what what do you think also
00:18:30 the consequences of that will be maybe going into the future with regards for example the eu
00:18:36 sorry with the difference between what and what well between essentially uh the culture
00:18:44 of western europe uh extremely liberal on these issues as opposed to the socially very conservative
00:18:51 values of Eastern and Central Europe?
00:18:56 Well, a number of things I could say about this.
00:18:59 One is to try, I think you're on the right track.
00:19:02 I think that what the New Culture Forum is doing is right
00:19:05 and that there is a culture war going on.
00:19:07 However, let us step back a moment
00:19:11 and remember where we were, well, where I was.
00:19:14 I'm older than any of you, I think,
00:19:16 except perhaps Frank, I don't know.
00:19:17 But remember where we were some in the 1950s, 60s, when the Communist Party in France and Italy was very, very strong, getting polling 20 percent plus.
00:19:31 And where, you know, even then, the idea that communism and that kind of control was still thought of by many people as a good idea.
00:19:41 And now we've had the resurgence of Corbyn, and McDonnell is clearly somebody who has a lot of sympathy with communism,
00:19:48 throwing the Mao's red book across the House of Commons.
00:19:53 But we're not in the stage where the popular, where people generally are willing to buy into it.
00:20:00 They're not that interested.
00:20:02 And indeed, you might say one of the problems for those who believe in this
00:20:06 is the fact that, contrary to Marx's predictions,
00:20:11 the working class have not got poorer and poorer.
00:20:14 The poor working class has diminished in number,
00:20:16 and we're now overwhelmingly a middle-class society
00:20:19 of people who have clean jobs, administration, and so on and so forth,
00:20:23 who have our holidays around the world.
00:20:27 And they're fighting up against,
00:20:29 if you look at it from the other point of view,
00:20:31 their struggle is with the fact that many people
00:20:34 are very happily having very bourgeois lives,
00:20:36 They may be subliminally taking in Netflix messages, but they're actually living a totally bourgeois life.
00:20:43 And they really will have to lose all their sense of what their own interest is to give that up in any major way.
00:20:52 I don't think we're just talking about the material side of life.
00:20:58 I think it's more about actually what you are allowed to say when and how and whether you are allowed to actually think freely publicly in a public sphere.
00:21:08 And this is where my worry lies heavily that we've already lost it and the speech is heavily censored from the point of your workplace.
00:21:24 in scotland now it's also talking about now policing your speech in at your dining table
00:21:31 so the the boundaries are being pushed and pushed and pushed and what worries me the most and and i
00:21:38 was thinking about it early on as we are as we've been talking is that there are certain patterns
00:21:44 and certain things emerging so we've all been fooled with um communists and socialism because
00:21:50 the intentions were good now the people that are denying us freedom to think and speak freely
00:21:56 they also say they have good intentions they want to improve the society they're doing it for our
00:22:02 own good so why do we oppose what's wrong with us we must be evil and what do you do with evil
00:22:10 people maybe in the past you were sending them to the gulag or giving them the bullet at the back
00:22:17 of the head straight away now what do you do you make sure they have no place in the public sphere
00:22:23 they lose their job they hunt it down of the social media of the area where they live from
00:22:30 their colleagues that's how you do it and then add to that the artificial intelligence and the
00:22:36 possibility of controlling people people's lives through that and we don't have to look far we look
00:22:42 to China the social credit system what have you done you cannot travel now you
00:22:48 cannot take the train oh no you shouldn't go to this university and
00:22:52 every move will be monitored why did we have the facial recognition system tried
00:22:57 in this country with no permission from us a year ago was it a year ago why was
00:23:02 it tried without our permission and step by step we're losing these freedoms and
00:23:08 step by step we're being lured into this false sense of security is because we care i really
00:23:15 care about all of you and i want the good for you james do you want to come back on that point that
00:23:22 it's not actually just about the economics absolutely yes i mean that's a that's in a
00:23:27 way there are many different axes in which you can analyze a society and the one that you just
00:23:32 mentioned is absolutely fair and i agree that it's it's damaging and it's right that that people like
00:23:39 us should push back against it and i think a pushback is taking place um i mean without wishing
00:23:45 to predict the future i think that the force of the force of nature will be that the bbc if it
00:23:53 continues to be so woke will continue to lose viewers bbc is much more pernicious i think than
00:23:59 Netflix because it really is pushing a whole series of values and a whole series of guilt trips
00:24:05 which may appear subliminally and subtly in Netflix movies but the Netflix movies are often watched
00:24:11 without people realizing what the underlying message is meant to be. So I feel that maybe
00:24:19 I'm Panglossian about this. I feel that people you are part of the pushback and that's great
00:24:25 but the pushback will continue and you have you are not alone you have a whole lot of people who
00:24:30 are apolitical who instinctively agree with you i think uh that that's very nice to hear but um i
00:24:37 do think that the the point really i would say is that there are many most people actually uh feel
00:24:44 the way that anishka feels i they feel very very uh disenfranchised uh and what they can say
00:24:51 the point is this is that they're not in influent influential positions that's the point
00:24:56 it's all the influential positions from education right the way through where this is the case um
00:25:02 frank you know obviously you're you know you're emeritus professor of sociology at kent
00:25:08 you've lived an academic life um the the general situation on our campuses
00:25:17 you know whilst one is not going to try and maybe compare it to you know communist hungary
00:25:24 or whatever but it it is so serious that it does make one feel does it not that there is a kind of
00:25:30 form of creeping totalitarianism i mean some of woke people have actually been called cultural
00:25:38 totalitarians haven't they i think we need to get the balance on this it is very difficult
00:25:45 and i'm particularly worried about the power of self-censorship yeah which pervades the classrooms
00:25:54 and the seminars uh just to give you an example uh the day after the brexit referendum uh i went
00:26:01 into the senior common room and everybody knows that i was one of the well one of the only
00:26:07 professors who supported brexit and i'm looking around and i and everybody's crying like in a
00:26:13 clinic so i write it up i did an article for the times higher on how people in universities hated
00:26:19 brexit and and and what a shame it was next day and for the next few days i get about 60 70 emails
00:26:28 from other academics saying frank i totally agree with you what you say is absolutely right
00:26:34 but i don't think that i could say it you know i'm not a professor like you or i don't think i
00:26:40 want to be ostracized and essentially they're saying that they're too scared to you know
00:26:45 essentially echo the views that i put forward and which they believe in and i sent them back the
00:26:51 same email i said look you're not living in stalinist russia you're not living in nazi germany
00:26:57 why don't you stand up and make sure your voice is heard and i think that you know that kind of
00:27:03 message of empowering people to find their voice is very important because I do think it's not too
00:27:11 late on campuses you know as long as people have the you know even a small number of people are
00:27:17 prepared to stand up at the moment the situation is really from bad to worse I don't know if you
00:27:22 saw a report that was published yesterday I think it was a report about Canada and America
00:27:29 which showed that only about 18 to 20 percent of the of academics that were interviewed indicated
00:27:37 that they wouldn't even talk to somebody who didn't share their political views
00:27:43 no they wouldn't even have a conversation with them never mind anything else and when you have
00:27:48 that kind of polarization on campus that kind of attempt to shut discussion down
00:27:53 then then we have a problem and i think what you say peter about influence is important
00:27:59 You have to remember that almost 50% of young people now go to universities.
00:28:04 Higher education is the most powerful institution in our society
00:28:08 because the products of higher education then go and run businesses,
00:28:13 they run the media, they run all the influential institutions of our society.
00:28:17 So I do think we should bear this in mind when we talk about universities.
00:28:23 Emma, we've talked an awful lot about the situation in universities.
00:28:28 I heard it remarked actually
00:28:31 yesterday that in fact
00:28:32 which backs obviously what Frank is saying up
00:28:35 is that in fact
00:28:36 conservatism and conservatism
00:28:40 actually just don't even figure
00:28:41 it's not like they just don't even
00:28:43 figure actually in the argument anymore
00:28:46 in colleges
00:28:46 there seems to be
00:28:49 an assumption on the part of some academics
00:28:52 that the consequence
00:28:53 of being academic
00:28:55 is that you become
00:28:58 left wing politically um and that is all sort of tied in i i think with the assigning uh moral
00:29:06 values to holding particular political or cultural opinions uh the the thing that worries me most
00:29:13 though and and this is off the back of what anishka was saying there as well is that
00:29:17 we're sleepwalking into these things it's not necessarily you know a particularly conscious
00:29:24 thing what worries me most is that within the universities but also you know in the media with
00:29:30 the BBC there's a sort of increasing tacit acceptance that certain restrictions on our
00:29:39 liberties are acceptable in a way that I think my parents generation just would have instinctively
00:29:47 rejected and I worry that people my age and younger are more softened to having these sorts
00:29:55 of things removed because as Anishka said that they're doing it in the name of you know it's for
00:30:02 your own good and there's nothing more sinister than somebody telling you that you should have
00:30:07 your freedoms taken away for your own good and for the benefit of society and that is the thing
00:30:11 that I think is most worrying and that going back to the beginning of this discussion I think is
00:30:16 where it would help for people to have a better understanding and education of communism.
00:30:21 It's why George Orwell's books are not only so popular, but also so brilliantly accurate
00:30:25 in the way that he satires these things, because he really understood the kind of sinister
00:30:30 but slightly comical way that these things unravel.
00:30:33 And even when Orwell is taught in schools, he isn't taught well.
00:30:40 He isn't taught in the context of the Cultural Revolution in China.
00:30:43 Nobody mentions Salson Aitzen within, you know, the context of discussing Orwell at GCSE, for example.
00:30:53 So I think that's one of the reasons why it will be useful for people to have a better education about communism
00:30:57 and also particularly, you know, the history of post-Soviet countries
00:31:04 so that maybe we could have a little bit of resilience against these sorts of things amongst the younger population
00:31:11 because I think that instinct of rejection
00:31:14 is still there amongst older people,
00:31:16 but I worry that increasingly less so amongst the younger people,
00:31:19 particularly because of the power of culturally influential things
00:31:24 like Netflix.
00:31:25 It might not be explicit the way that they state the values,
00:31:28 but the fact that they're tied into the entire worldview
00:31:31 that is being put forward as this kind of cultural mythology,
00:31:34 that's the thing that worries me
00:31:36 because that cultural mythology is not reality.
00:31:39 but the exposure to it is so great for young people
00:31:44 that it changes the sorts of things they're willing to accept from the government
00:31:48 On the note of the movies and culture
00:31:51 I just wanted to make a point
00:31:55 that it seems that the communists have been softened in the image
00:31:58 when it comes to Hollywood and the movies
00:32:00 it hasn't been analysed as in depth as the Second World War
00:32:04 so that was the first thing
00:32:06 and quite often you would see the movies
00:32:08 were actually it was more like a comedy so like with this berlin wall that the mother doesn't know
00:32:12 because she was in a coma and it's and i've been to the cinema to watch this movie with my brother
00:32:18 and when we came out he was heartbroken and he said that he couldn't stand people laughing
00:32:23 because he could see the family being broken and our family was affected by communists too
00:32:29 and we also went through horrendous experiences because the family had to separate so um so this
00:32:35 is one point i wanted to make and the other thing that i was thinking about is that um within the
00:32:41 education um it's not looking at uh at in-depth analysis of the elements of of what came together
00:32:50 to to make it happen and the results of it and i think it would be it would be worth to
00:32:56 to also dig deeper there um you can say something james yes um i was going to say i think the key
00:33:04 thing that has influenced Britain, both in terms of what you've been discussing and in terms of
00:33:11 sympathy for communism, emerges from the end of the Cold War. People of my generation,
00:33:21 whether you were on the left like Attlee or whether you were on the right
00:33:27 like Thatcher, either way you knew what you stood for and it was not communism.
00:33:33 So the fact that communism existed and seemed to be a threat
00:33:37 united liberals and conservatives in an awareness of what they did value,
00:33:42 of what was important to them.
00:33:45 And gradually we have, well, particularly I would say liberals,
00:33:49 have lost sight of that thing that we have in common.
00:33:53 And they now regard conservatives as the better enemy
00:33:56 without having the counterpoint of seeing that communism
00:34:00 was a much bigger enemy than conservatives.
00:34:02 And so now, as it were, the energies to fight and combat and be virtuous and think of yourself as virtuous are going towards conservatism and the established order, you know, what I would regard on a fairly, not exactly minor, but minor compared to gulags, compared to mass murder.
00:34:24 They are putting their energies into conservatism and hating conservatism in various forms of behavior and men, whites, old people, instead of realizing that actually we are part of a civilization that values liberalism in its general sense, freedom of speech, democracy.
00:34:45 and these are things which liberals and conservatives have in common.
00:34:49 And people have lost sight of this important thing
00:34:52 that those on the left and the right have in common.
00:34:55 But I have a fear that the left seems to be overtaken by ideology
00:35:00 that is on the verge of being like a cult way of thinking.
00:35:04 It is a cult, I think.
00:35:06 Where they don't see the value in conservatives.
00:35:09 They don't see the value in actually having this balancing act
00:35:12 between the left and the right and what's in the middle.
00:35:15 and actually having the middle where people can be one leg here and one leg there so and and the
00:35:21 cult's approach is actually to erase anything that doesn't agree with the cult's beliefs and
00:35:28 ways of behaving and the other thing that i was also thinking is about looking at the social media
00:35:34 and how quickly we moved into censoring people removing people and without actually looking into
00:35:42 okay, if you say there is fake news or if exactly other countries are maybe influencing
00:35:48 the discussion there, let's educate the society, let's educate the children how to look at
00:35:54 this and that. No, we're moving into censoring people, we're moving into removing people.
00:35:59 So instead of trying to bring people up, we're actually pushing them down because we know
00:36:04 better what is better for you and we care about you. So we're going to do what we want
00:36:09 to do.
00:36:09 Can I just ask, I can ask Frank something, but before we leave that, you know, we mentioned a bit about young people going back, like Tate of Poland or whatever. Are they, I mean, it's anecdotal, but are they kind of appalled and fed up by the fact that you can't say anything here anymore? Is that the impression you get or have they taken it on board?
00:36:33 No, people are fed up and it's not natural.
00:36:36 And also a lot of families move back because of terror attacks
00:36:40 and people just have enough of this.
00:36:44 Frank, you started out by saying, talking about Hungary
00:36:48 and how it was sort of almost, well, not quite just on its own,
00:36:52 but it was sort of acting as an opposition to the Caribbean culture war.
00:36:58 First of all, are you in favour?
00:37:01 Do you think that's a good thing?
00:37:02 And also, should we do what they're doing?
00:37:07 Yeah, I think so.
00:37:08 I think that at the moment there's a kind of embarrassment and reluctance to say,
00:37:14 we too need to sort of take up the war of culture
00:37:20 because at the moment we're at the receiving end all the time.
00:37:23 And our way of life is being diminished and pathologized.
00:37:28 And what we have in response is a very half-hearted, you know, sort of kind of series of backlash.
00:37:34 And at the moment, we're losing every single battle.
00:37:37 If I look back the last 20 years, on every single question, you know, we've lost ground.
00:37:43 And we've been forced to become embarrassed and apologize for who we are.
00:37:49 Whereas I think that what's really needed is a much more robust, proactive thing,
00:37:54 thing where instead of us reacting, you know, we take the initiative. So take what I think is a key
00:38:01 question here in Britain, which is, you know, what do we think of Britain's past? You know,
00:38:06 are we going to apologize for Britain, you know, not being always, you know, sort of honorable,
00:38:12 always doing the best thing? Or are we going to say that on balance, you know, there's something
00:38:16 wonderful about what Britain has done over the centuries and we're going to praise it and we're
00:38:22 going to make a virtue out of it. And we're going to really celebrate being British. Now,
00:38:27 I say that as somebody who wasn't even born here, who's not even English.
00:38:30 You prove our point in a way, Frank. You're proving our point.
00:38:35 I mean, unless you do that, then you're going to be continually wrong-footed. And I think
00:38:40 what Orbán, the prime minister in Hungary, has done, and he knows that it's a very difficult
00:38:47 job that is undertaken is to actually say that the future of Hungary and for that matter of Europe
00:38:54 at the end of the day is going to be decided on the terrain of culture you know the future
00:39:00 is not simply reducible to economics it's not simply reducible to material possessions and
00:39:06 material goods it's it depends upon the meaning that we can end our human experience what does
00:39:13 it mean to be a human being what does it mean to be a member of a family and then you know just
00:39:19 yesterday i was talking to one of his advisors and he made the point that the one good thing
00:39:25 about the pandemic that helps people like us is a very simple lesson which is that in the pandemic
00:39:31 we've learned that despite all the globalist propaganda if you want to be safe you know you're
00:39:39 to be much safer in the nation because the nation will look after you. The EU is not going to watch
00:39:44 you back. The IMF is not going to watch you back. The World Health Organization is going to watch
00:39:48 you back. So first of all, it's a nation. Secondly, it's your community, you know, where you live,
00:39:55 that is going to be backing you up. And finally, your family. You know, if you'll be really safe,
00:40:00 whether you're in Hungary, Poland or England, you're going to be relying on these institutions,
00:40:04 these traditional resources, not on some abstract international institution.
00:40:09 And I think we have to use these experiences like the pandemic
00:40:13 to promote the kind of arguments that we think are really quite important,
00:40:17 aggressively and not reactively.
00:40:19 And I think what we need are more intellectuals, we need more artists,
00:40:24 we need more people in the media who can play these roles
00:40:28 because that's the area where we're very weak at.
00:40:31 very few conservative filmmakers, very few conservative rock stars, very few conservative
00:40:39 celebrities, and all the rest of it. And that kind of popular culture is an important resource.
00:40:45 And we're going to think of finding ways and means of inspiring the young to make our values
00:40:52 look cool, rather than the way it looks at the moment as being tired, boring, you know,
00:40:58 sort of oh who wants to be you know who wants to listen to that kind of stuff and i because i think
00:41:02 that what we're discussing here amongst ourselves is actually quite exciting right it can be turned
00:41:08 into into a real buzzy kind of set of ideas and that's what we got to aspire to and not just rely
00:41:14 on east europe to do this but here in england you know we got to use the resources that were left
00:41:19 behind by brexit that wonderful moment of feeling that we're a nation harness it to to some kind of
00:41:27 positive project.
00:41:29 Well, Frank, I mean, thank you. It's a great way to leave.
00:41:31 And I have to say that, you know,
00:41:33 when you talk about Orban, I mean,
00:41:35 you know, those celebrities
00:41:37 and those media people you mentioned,
00:41:40 they have done such a
00:41:41 demonising job, as you must know.
00:41:43 I mean, he's virtually, you know,
00:41:45 beyond the pale completely,
00:41:47 which I think proves our point, actually.
00:41:50 From that point of view.
00:41:51 Thank you very much for joining us, Frank.
00:41:53 Thank you very much indeed, James.
00:41:55 Thank you, Anishka. Thank you, too.
00:41:57 That's all for Counterculture this week.
00:42:01 So please do subscribe, won't you?
00:42:04 We need you to subscribe.
00:42:06 It's totally free.
00:42:08 Anyway, we shall see you next time.
00:42:10 Thank you. Bye-bye.