New Culture Forum - October 20, 2020


Are Cities Dying? What's The Future For London & Other Cities Post-Covid?

The Positive Case For The British Empire (& Cecil Rhodes) - A Balanced Approach To Imperial History David Kurten: Why I Launched The Heritage Party To Combat The Progressive & Globalist Agenda

Episode Stats


Length

37 minutes

Words per minute

185.38

Word count

6,959

Sentence count

125


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to Counterculture. I'm Peter Whittle. Now today we're filming this in the
00:00:20 centre of London. It's pretty deserted. In fact it's as deserted as it was in March really at
00:00:27 beginning of the official lockdown. There are a great many fears now about the future for London.
00:00:34 But not just London, which of course accounts for something like 25% of Britain's GDP. What about
00:00:41 the other cities around our country and indeed internationally? Is the era of cities over? If
00:00:48 they do survive, what will they look like? Now with me to discuss this, I'm very pleased we have
00:00:54 Austin Williams from the Future Cities Project, Robert Pohl who is a property developer and might
00:01:02 well be known to you as well as the founder of the Save Our Statues Twitter campaign,
00:01:07 and Rafe Hadelman Koo from the New Culture Forum, historian, commentator and also author of a book
00:01:14 about particular aspects of British London history called A London Peculiar. Can I start by asking you
00:01:22 please uh austin uh are cities dying uh it's a tricky question isn't it because obviously
00:01:31 in the current situation with coronavirus there has been an economic collapse which has seen
00:01:37 uh the centers of cities hollowed out um but that's not the same way as you might have seen
00:01:43 in in the last 20 years of shrinking cities or in 40 years of people moving to the suburbs
00:01:50 um and a kind of a conscious exodus in some ways this is a much more kind of anarchic um nihilistic
00:01:57 and dangerous kind of trend which is that people have given up in some ways on the city in many
00:02:03 respects one is it's given up on the city as a metropolitan arena of culture of the center of
00:02:08 excellence of productivity so a lot of that has been given up they've been given up in as much as
00:02:13 uh the idea that we should give back to nature and the cities are somehow an abomination
00:02:18 where we've trampled over nature
00:02:21 and now some people are seeing the benefits
00:02:23 of the coronavirus pandemic
00:02:25 by saying that we can allow nature
00:02:27 to reclaim the city
00:02:29 and in some ways there's the idea that
00:02:31 cities, by building cities or by creating
00:02:33 cities, that's an expression
00:02:35 of humanity's
00:02:37 hubris. So in
00:02:39 cultural terms, in philosophical terms
00:02:41 I suppose, we're living in a very weird
00:02:43 dangerous age where the city
00:02:45 the concept of the city
00:02:46 and somehow has been kind of undermined and I think it needs to be reclaimed for all the very
00:02:51 reasons the opposite reasons that I just described um it's interesting awesome because I've always
00:02:57 thought of the city uh in the abstract as being kind of you know the expression of civilization
00:03:05 actually um and so I would regret the fact that it appears to be therefore declining I mean would
00:03:14 you agree with that do you see them in that way or do you see them as hubris as you just said
00:03:18 sorry i hope i was making myself clearer than i obviously was no they are centers of excellence
00:03:24 cities are cultural hubs they are a symbol of civilization obviously the opposite of a city
00:03:31 is rurality and that idea of you know feudal life or living off the land is something which i thought
00:03:37 we put behind us and the move towards the city has always been an expression of development
00:03:42 If you take a look at China, I mean, China has only recently, maybe in the last seven years or so, become 50 percent. It's now 61 percent urbanized. And that is a symbol. That's a very clear national expression of their development above what they were 40 years ago, which was peasants in the fields.
00:03:59 So, I mean, on all levels, cities have been expressions of development, of civilization, of cultural progress.
00:04:08 And I think those things need to be put back on the agenda.
00:04:11 Partly what I'm saying is that the word's development, the word progress, is always characterized in quotation marks.
00:04:19 And it's a very dangerous trend that we seem to be giving up on those things, which is why, in some ways, the fact that now cities are being hollowed out has been accepted by many people.
00:04:29 There's an almost blasé-ness to the fact that London is empty.
00:04:32 The idea that we now look to cities like Delhi and say,
00:04:36 isn't it wonderful, the clean air and we can see the mountains.
00:04:39 This is an abomination.
00:04:41 I think the fact that cities are congested,
00:04:44 in some ways they are cluttered and they're uncomfortable and they're ugly,
00:04:47 is the beauty of them.
00:04:49 And if we give up on that, then we're just going backwards.
00:04:53 That's something we have to stop.
00:04:54 I think something there that that about London basically you know people not really caring or
00:05:04 seeming to care do you agree with this this is something that strikes me I've I've been very
00:05:10 surprised by how people are quite happy just to you know as Austin put it kind of give up on the
00:05:15 thing Rafe yes and I think something which I would point out as being rather indifferent to what we've
00:05:21 historically because of course people have always escaped from the cities during times of pandemic
00:05:25 and pestilence for centuries if you look at that you know the great medieval text the decameron
00:05:30 the florentines went into the tuscan countryside to escape the black death and but then came back
00:05:35 cities have survived for millennia enduring plague and pestilence and have always bounced back
00:05:40 despite having huge swathes of their population decimated during those and whereas what we see
00:05:47 today is nothing by comparison. However, we have this extraordinary reaction from the
00:05:53 populations of these cities. Of course, we have technology now that makes it not as essential
00:05:58 or necessary to be part of the city, but it is this giving up, you know, and you often
00:06:02 wonder where is that London that I was born into, and I think all three of us here are
00:06:09 Londoners born and bred, you know, but that old blitz spirit, it was Churchill who said
00:06:13 the maxim of the British people is business as usual
00:06:16 and that was coined for the Blitz
00:06:18 and it just seems as if we've lost that.
00:06:20 This is no longer the city that it once was.
00:06:23 Robert, would you agree with that?
00:06:24 Do you find that you are saddened
00:06:27 by what's happening with London at the moment
00:06:29 or are you matter of fact about it?
00:06:32 Definitely agree with it and would say sad
00:06:35 and agree with what you said about the city
00:06:38 as a mark of civilisation.
00:06:40 If you look back through history
00:06:42 when people have built cities they're not just building shelter or somewhere to live they're
00:06:48 also constructing a story about themselves and identity about themselves as well the decisions
00:06:55 they make the way they choose to build the style they build in the types of buildings they put up
00:07:02 the types of monuments they put up all these things come together to form an identity and if
00:07:08 you look at some of the rise and falls of civilisations over time, I think it's notable
00:07:14 that I think the rise and the fall can begin and end with the city really. It begins when
00:07:21 people coalesce, they come together, they work together and share ideas and create that environment
00:07:28 where you can prosper and innovate and build. And then conversely, the city can also be the
00:07:37 seat of the end or the decline of the civilization so if you look at the
00:07:43 decline and fall of Rome as an obvious example yes it fell when they lost in
00:07:49 battle to the Goths and the Vandals but really they'd lost that way before they
00:07:54 even went to the battlefield you know it was because of the decline that had
00:07:57 been taking place in Rome for so long that they lost that and
00:08:03 really that I mean that was probably for three reasons I would say it was there
00:08:10 was a economic collapse there was a political collapse and there was also a
00:08:16 moral collapse and we're seeing elements of those things now in in London
00:08:21 economic collapse we talked about with the with the virus politically well I
00:08:27 think it's true certainly that over the last recent decades people have lost
00:08:32 of faith in a political class but I think more interestingly morally we're seeing with Rome it
00:08:39 was the introduction of Christianity really I think which obviously brought many benefits
00:08:45 but also Gibbon talks a lot about how that led to the undermining of the of the value system
00:08:51 in Rome and I think that's what we're now starting to see quite a lot of with we've talked about
00:08:56 attacks on statues and other things and the values that we that we that we held as a people
00:09:06 things like achievement and courage and these kind of things that we've held as good values for so
00:09:15 long has suddenly been undermined really by the imposition of a new religion not in this sense
00:09:23 Christianity but really the religion of of wokeism I suppose that is that is
00:09:28 replacing those values with new ones. Yes I think it's interesting is it
00:09:33 because you know if you try to capture the essence of London what it might be
00:09:37 maybe a few generations ago it would have been something that had grown up
00:09:41 organically i a shared story a shared history now if a Londoner is basically
00:09:48 defined by somebody as somebody who signs up to a whole set of values you
00:09:53 know rather nebulous but that's how that's how it is i mean would you say uh austin that you know
00:10:01 there's been this narrative that london is is just great place that everywhere else should emulate
00:10:07 and therefore what that seems to have done is to have fostered a hell of a lot of hostility
00:10:14 to london from outside you know you you feel it and we see it in comments and on the channel you
00:10:20 know people sick to death of hearing about how great London is do you think people outside
00:10:25 London think it's sort of getting its just comeuppance um well I don't I'm not too sure
00:10:32 about that I mean obviously there is an animosity um that is built up uh with Brexit and I'm
00:10:38 sure that there's plenty of people on the other side of the channel who um have an equal
00:10:42 and opposite kind of view about the UK and and its uh and its metropolitan elite um but
00:10:47 But I want to just go back quickly on what you just said earlier, because I think that the characterisation of the city is very interesting.
00:10:55 There's a very great book called The Soul of London by Ford Maddox Ford, which was written 120 years ago.
00:11:02 One of the first kind of modernist analyses of urban geography in some respects.
00:11:08 And it's just really interesting because he explores the city of London at that transition point as Victorian Britain was coming to an end.
00:11:16 And he cycles in, he takes buses, he takes a car, he walks, and he takes a look at the boundaries and the framework.
00:11:23 And effectively, he still doesn't really understand what London is, but he knows it when he sees it.
00:11:28 There's a metropolitan spirit to the city, to the capital.
00:11:34 And there's also a wonderful aspect of you can have hidden lives within the city.
00:11:40 So it's a very public arena, but you can also go back and you can be a private citizen.
00:11:43 And so that's one thing which I think is important to realize, the metropolitanness, because the difference between a city and the opposite is characterized in urban studies by being opposite to the rural, by being such one context.
00:12:00 The other context is the number of people in a certain area. You can then define it as being not a town, but a city.
00:12:07 But the third aspect, which is the indefinable one in some respects, is that kind of cultural or multicultural shift which takes place between what you would expect to have in a village or a town and an agglomeration of many people.
00:12:23 So I'm much more interested in that third representation of the cultural metropolitan spirit, which is an indefinable thing, but you know it when you see it, as opposed to maybe just a characterization of the number of people living in a certain area.
00:12:36 So once you have that, then you are defining your city context on certain beliefs that London represents, whether it represents the blitz spirit, as has been mentioned, whether it represents kind of the history of Churchill and before, or whether it just represents a wonderfully multicultural city to enjoy.
00:12:56 you know and that's i think that's kind of really important the fact that many other people now
00:13:00 look to london and say you know it's dirty it's congested um you know it has kind of all kinds
00:13:06 of social problems etc so be it that's what comes with city development uh and i think we we have to
00:13:13 take the rough with the smooth when we talk about cities and for me you know like new york uh paris
00:13:19 shanghai uh london these are cities which are robust uh they have their problems but that's
00:13:25 part of the joy i think would you go along with that rave i mean do you think that
00:13:30 the metropolitan spirit of london was a happy one even before covid i think it was a happy one if
00:13:38 you had money and if you were part of the professional class i think it was very much so
00:13:43 um unfortunately i mean there are there are many londons and there have always been many
00:13:48 londons depending on where you're from and what your interests are and so forth but what i've
00:13:52 seen ironically is with the increased heterogenization of London it's become
00:13:57 increasingly homogenized by which I mean there's been a sterilization of culture
00:14:02 in London over the course of the past 30 odd years as it's become too expensive
00:14:06 for people from the artistic or creative communities for example to continue to
00:14:11 live in London there was a time in the 90s when there was an action and the
00:14:15 2000s when there was no chance of the the creative types of East London going
00:14:20 to Berlin but now there are more of them living in Berlin because rents there are a quarter
00:14:24 of the price that they are in London and London has gone through this process whereby all
00:14:29 of those wonderful corners that I think epitomised the glory of London was its different areas
00:14:36 whether you were in Hampstead or in Southwark but all of the parts of central London that
00:14:40 had those wonderful glorious spirit of old London have been gentrified and essentially
00:14:48 now resemble Zurich on steroids, really,
00:14:51 just places for management consultants and lawyers and bankers
00:14:54 and people involved in the professional world to live in.
00:14:58 And the working classes have been pushed out
00:15:00 and completely erased from the visual scene in central London,
00:15:04 now having to commute from zone 6 at 5 in the morning
00:15:07 to do jobs in central London.
00:15:10 And so there's been this sterilisation, I think, of London,
00:15:13 which is now chrome and steel,
00:15:15 and that beating heart that I liked,
00:15:17 whether you were a Cockney Kostermonger from the East End
00:15:20 or a Duchess from Belgravia,
00:15:22 you had that wonderful spirit in London
00:15:24 or an Arty from Hampstead.
00:15:27 And that's lost and gone, I think.
00:15:29 Now, it's been replaced by multiculturalism,
00:15:31 and so we now have Russian oligarchs where there were duchesses,
00:15:35 and we have in Tower Hamlets now the Cockneys have gone
00:15:38 and been replaced by Bangladeshis.
00:15:39 But the problem I'm finding is that no one actually has any knowledge
00:15:43 of the history of London.
00:15:44 And so for me as a historian,
00:15:45 it's that idea that is a city still a city
00:15:48 if there's no collective memory
00:15:50 if nobody knows about the Great Fire of London
00:15:52 if nobody actually knows that
00:15:54 you know, that
00:15:55 Tom Bride's Fleet Street has connections with Shakespeare
00:15:58 and Milton and all the rest of it
00:16:00 and to me, London then
00:16:02 seems to be less than it was
00:16:04 and it simply becomes a capital of the world
00:16:06 rather than a capital of England
00:16:07 and it's as stated as the capital of England that I think
00:16:10 is most important
00:16:12 so ironically in a way
00:16:13 I do wonder whether
00:16:15 And a silver lining to Covid might be the fact that with office rents plummeting, as they will do, I'm convinced, over the next few months, you may see over the next five, ten years, rents and life in London becoming easier and cheaper and more affordable.
00:16:31 So there might be actually a chance to actually bring back some of the artistic and cultural and less professional side to London.
00:16:40 Would you go along with that, Rob?
00:16:41 Yeah, I'd agree certainly with the idea of sterilisation and the loss of that sense of history and identity, coming back to what I said earlier about the city telling a story really about what that people is.
00:16:54 And if you lose that, then you lose part of your identity. And yes, we're seeing that in the architecture in many ways.
00:17:00 we're now seeing in recent years
00:17:03 obviously an increasing series of
00:17:05 increasingly grotesque skyscrapers
00:17:08 I think in my view, dotted around the city
00:17:10 breaking up, disrupting that urban fabric
00:17:12 where you once had areas with some kind of cohesion
00:17:16 of how they looked in terms of style and size
00:17:19 how tall these buildings were
00:17:20 that's disrupted
00:17:23 when you look at the older photographs or drawings of London
00:17:25 you feel something about the identity
00:17:29 of what that city is which i think is lost now um and um yeah i think i think it it is it's
00:17:36 breaking down that identity and we're seeing that um they're now it's being replaced with something
00:17:42 a lot more amorphous i suppose when we look at the statues again um they're getting rid of the
00:17:48 historical ones and replacing them with these amorphous blobs like the fourth plinth or an
00:17:53 anonymous every woman statue which maybe on some superficial level someone says oh that's a
00:18:00 reflection of me but it's it's not really a reflection of your identity it doesn't reflect
00:18:04 your past it doesn't reflect your future what you aspire to these things are being lost and the
00:18:10 population is a transient one as well there's no vested interest that I see now from from the
00:18:16 middle classes from anybody in the city now and from the wealthy as they used to be when they
00:18:20 would patronize and be great philanthropists to me that's all gone
00:18:23 there's no longer a vested interest in London by those people who are here well
00:18:27 I mean this is the crucial point you know we you mentioned there about the
00:18:31 Duchess and the Costa Munger was it but I mean we're getting very Baroque here
00:18:36 but but you know famously Noel Coward song London Pride was exactly that it
00:18:42 was you know from the rich to the anchor and crown and as Londoners I sort of
00:18:48 you've bought into that you felt it you absolutely felt it but it seems to be that now many people
00:18:55 don't actually feel welcome in in london i mean people who maybe were grew up here or whatever
00:19:02 because enormous numbers of people are leaving and for example in in my case in the in the
00:19:10 summertime you know there was no movement in the property market during the covid thing
00:19:15 until we had these big demonstrations and then some social unrest and they went berserk and it
00:19:22 was people basically I assume moving out I think I mean this is one of the problems isn't it Austin
00:19:28 that you know if people move out you know whether it's to work at home or not this is a bad you
00:19:36 know this is a bad trend for any city you know working from home could actually be be the death
00:19:44 of the city couldn't it of course of course of course but um the the unreality of me being on
00:19:49 a tv screen while you're all having a kind of um rough and tumble barney around the table can i
00:19:54 just chip in on one thing that was said earlier and then i'll come back to your question which
00:19:57 is that one two things well one is first of all i think i've mentioned multicultural city i don't
00:20:03 support multiculturalism um i find multiculturalism the divisive policy whereas multicultural
00:20:08 cultural nature of society is wonderfully warming, I think. Secondly, I'm a great believer in gentrification. It's about improving areas that are down and out and lifting them up. The fact that there are, you know, there are victims as well as successors to that policy is obviously a tragedy. And maybe there should be more of it. But in some ways, there's a counter response in the urban design world and architecture world where people are celebrating the kind of poverty of the areas and
00:20:38 giving a certain nostalgic romanticism and saying we should preserve it,
00:20:42 whereas actually I think they should be lifted out of poverty,
00:20:44 and that takes development and progress and innovation.
00:20:48 So the fundamental to the question, the earlier question,
00:20:52 is that the shift in what's happened, as Robert was saying,
00:20:55 about this kind of moral collapse,
00:20:57 historically you might have seen moral collapse
00:20:59 because there was something else on the agenda, on offer.
00:21:02 There was a, you know, from the Greeks to the Romans, et cetera, et cetera,
00:21:04 there was a developmental motif,
00:21:07 Whereas now you find that the driving focus is nihilism, is that there is no agenda, it's just a destruction of what is.
00:21:15 I mean, I hear you can use the parody of ISIS, but there is something kind of strange going on here where there's a refutation of what we stand for without putting anything in its place.
00:21:24 As a matter of fact, thinking that putting something in its place would be even worse.
00:21:28 So there's a risk averse precautionary approach to development.
00:21:32 But coming back to that kind of final point about the movement, obviously it depends, you know, if you are in a nihilistic age, then people moving out becomes part of the problem.
00:21:43 Whereas if you look back to Alvin Toffler, say, in the 1970s, talking about the wonderful science fiction opportunities of tele-cottaging, as he put it, you know, living in villages and commuting to London virtually, that was innovative, that was science fiction, that was futuristic, that was grit.
00:22:02 and you know i love that concept so no you can't throw the baby out of the bathwater i think there
00:22:07 is something about what's happened which is you know that here we are i'm having a chat with you
00:22:11 in a studio and i'm a long way away there's something kind of fascinating about the
00:22:15 democratization and the the fact that this technology has become accessible to everybody
00:22:20 that's great but but the reasons why it has is an absolute tragedy uh and so therefore we have to
00:22:25 kind of try and dissect those two things the fact that people are moving out of london for whatever
00:22:29 reasons is a is a scandal um and i think that employers um are as much to blame as the people
00:22:35 themselves so you know the fact that employers are allowing people to swan around and not come
00:22:40 back that nobody's being forced to come back to their businesses uh that city centers are being
00:22:45 cleared out of workers and nobody is demanding that they go back so there's there's there's a
00:22:50 collapse of nerve in this conversation as well which i think we need to need to address so it's
00:22:55 It's not just, you know, the city is moving on like it always has done historically,
00:23:00 where rich people move to the city centre and poor people move out,
00:23:03 and then that transforms itself when the rich people move to the suburbs,
00:23:08 the poor people come back again.
00:23:09 Now, that's been a historical movement in most cities for the last 200, 300 years.
00:23:13 This is different, right?
00:23:15 This is a collapse of a belief in the city,
00:23:18 which is, I think, something which history has never shown us before.
00:23:22 You said, though, that we are actually talking really here, I would say,
00:23:24 about a central London issue because if you actually look at local businesses in the suburbs
00:23:29 and outer areas there you aren't seeing the same devastation of the high streets local shops are
00:23:35 actually you know showing some some improvements in their business fortunes because all the office
00:23:40 workers are actually staying at home and going for coffee to the local area or going to the local
00:23:44 for the local to the local W H Smiths or whatever it's those shops in the centre of town which
00:23:49 which are a problem and that's why I think you watch I mean one of the glories of London also
00:23:53 as I said, is the fact that it is a series of villages,
00:23:56 you know, 30-odd villages that were absorbed into the greater city.
00:23:59 And so this idea which you have in Paris also of the 15-minute city,
00:24:03 where basically everything you do is within the local region.
00:24:05 So you've got your doctre, everything you need is around you,
00:24:09 rather than travelling great distances.
00:24:10 You know, people living in Ealing have no idea what life's like in Barking.
00:24:14 They probably know more about places in Africa than they do about Barking
00:24:17 because London is so vast.
00:24:18 And I think that's one of the things which we're going to see,
00:24:20 least in the short term is people staying very much in the suburbs but also in their areas and
00:24:26 so the economy as a whole isn't that isn't as bleak but it's going to just basically have to
00:24:32 re-evaluate itself because what we've seen really is just a fast forwarding of the inevitable decline
00:24:37 of the high street and retail because of because of online shopping and so forth but it was a 10
00:24:42 or 15 year process has been sped up with no with not much time for for an adjustment i think it's
00:24:47 quite interesting this is yes sorry austin you coming sorry i know it's impossible to chip in
00:24:52 but i i i reject that right because that's the reinvention of the rural as far as i'm concerned
00:24:58 i mean i i'm i don't believe in the 15-minute city i don't agree with kind of localism it's a
00:25:03 it's a it's an it's an apology no offense to you i mean i'm not saying you're saying this but
00:25:07 historically for the last 20 years uh from richard rogers onwards the idea that you create this kind
00:25:12 of lack less density means what that you're going to go back to creating urban villages
00:25:18 i thought we created cities to to get out of villages so the idea that we're creating i don't
00:25:22 mind we have local areas that we can all relate to but conceptually i think that we have to consider
00:25:28 the metropolitan as a coherent body rather than a fractured region of satellites because that is the
00:25:34 destruction of the city itself well i agree with you entirely you know the great urban historian
00:25:39 H.J. Dios wrote about the suburbia and said it combines the worst elements of the city and the
00:25:43 countryside and the best elements of neither and it is rather of a vacuum so I'm entirely in keeping
00:25:49 with you on that I'm merely saying what I think is actually the reality on the ground. Can I just
00:25:54 point out here you're talking about why people go and the money and everything can we be frank
00:25:59 about this when you talk to so many people about why in this case they're moving out of London
00:26:06 it is for much more if you like nitty-gritty reasons they're sick of the crime for example
00:26:13 which appears not to be able to be managed in any way let alone punished they are they are sick too
00:26:20 obviously of the sheer cost of it they're sick of the overcrowding the extraordinary overcrowding
00:26:26 there is and they feel increasingly that it's not familiar and not only that it's not familiar but
00:26:32 that they shouldn't want it to be familiar that's a crucial point that if you somehow feel that you
00:26:39 know if you don't feel that anyone living in london is a londoner then somehow you are not
00:26:44 wanted on journey as my father would say you know hence people are actually leaving because they no
00:26:50 longer recognize it do you accept that me uh not not really i mean i think uh london has probably
00:26:59 been more crime ridden uh in the 1970s than it is today even though there's a different scale and a
00:27:04 different problem uh to be addressed i think that overcrowding you know if you look back historically
00:27:09 1939 was the most overcrowded time for london's housing um we then moved to the suburbs in the
00:27:15 1960s and the population went down the fact that then infrastructure hasn't kept up and there's
00:27:21 been road closures so there's increased traffic congestion i mean it's an interesting fact that
00:27:25 nobody ever believes when i tell you is that in 1964 you had the same number of cars on the streets
00:27:30 in london as you have in 19 2020. uh you know there's there hasn't been any decline it's just
00:27:35 the fact that the amount of road space has disappeared so it's it appears more worse and
00:27:39 we're also culturally attuned to seeing congestion as a problem rather than being a factor of city
00:27:44 life so i just think that you know the nature of the conversation has has changed i think that you
00:27:49 know people are moving out for all kinds of reasons partly because they've given up on maybe
00:27:55 what it means to live in a city and they you know whatever i mean there's many reasons and i don't
00:28:00 think we can use lowest common denominator um excuses to to to talk about the general trends
00:28:06 but i also think that there's a a a mood within the metropolitan area of having more foreign
00:28:14 people within it is has always been a good thing i think it's always been a sense that's what it
00:28:20 means to be a world city if you go to singapore uh it's kind of one of those wonderful experiences
00:28:25 where you can almost see the future of what a city could be because it's it's it's it's all
00:28:31 shades all populations all countries are are are engaging in the city there and it's just
00:28:37 marvelous to watch and you see this kind of cultural yeah but i mean i would go back to
00:28:42 uh rafe's original point that all sounds very nice on paper surely austin but fact is if you
00:28:47 do have a situation where the story of a city no people no longer know it they no longer they don't
00:28:55 have to know it for a start so i don't just mean that the history of the tower of london i mean
00:29:01 the cultural nuances of a city when all of those things start to go and it to me then it just
00:29:06 becomes does it not a kind of landing strip it just becomes like a an airport departure lounge
00:29:12 i mean it's all very well that you've got this glistening economic activity but no one has any
00:29:17 real sense of place there hence i would suggest they can give it up very easily which is what
00:29:23 we're seeing that's fair enough isn't it that's fair enough i mean i think so they so they can
00:29:28 give it up and so they can move on so they can travel around i don't have a problem i don't
00:29:33 think people have ever had this idea of knowing their history in the way that you seem to be
00:29:37 suggesting i mean i'm dreading the fact you might test me on my knowledge of certain street names
00:29:42 and all the rest of it because i don't have it myself and one thing about london which has been
00:29:46 always been a phenomenon and less so in the last 10 years when the buses have really kind of taken
00:29:51 off is that people have traveled by underground and have never conceptualized distance time or
00:29:56 the relationship of different areas because you go down underground and you pop up where you want
00:30:00 to be and you don't really understand where you are that to me the mystery of london is
00:30:05 is part of the part of the enjoyment of it there is a problem when a city is so transient when
00:30:11 people come in here for a relatively short period of time they may be here for 5 10 15 years and
00:30:16 and then they move on because of their jobs in the city and so forth,
00:30:19 because you do lose those community roots that are essential,
00:30:23 not only to a sense of what it means to be a Londoner,
00:30:25 but what it means to be somebody from, you know, from Southwark
00:30:28 or from, you know, from Hanwell or whatever else.
00:30:31 There are those really vital community bonds
00:30:33 which are completely being erased and eradicated.
00:30:36 You know, I can't think of a single city in modern history
00:30:40 which has, in the space of 20 years,
00:30:43 It's gone from being a majority indigenous population
00:30:46 to a minority indigenous population.
00:30:48 London now ranks as the second or third most multicultural city in the world,
00:30:53 apart from Toronto, New York and London
00:30:55 are the three most multicultural cities in the world
00:30:57 in terms of where people were born.
00:31:00 But those cities were not always immigrant cities.
00:31:02 Britain's, I mean, London's always had a small immigrant population,
00:31:04 but the speed of which it happened
00:31:06 and the space of 20 years in which it happened is unprecedented.
00:31:10 And that's discombobulated as a society.
00:31:12 And that's one of the reasons that you have this evidence of white flight taking place.
00:31:16 I mean, in Barkingham, Dagenham, it was amazingly, on numbers, I can't remember,
00:31:20 but in the double digits in the space of a few years leaving,
00:31:24 because of that sense of no longer recognising their place.
00:31:27 A friend of mine, you know, for 50 years working in one of the gentleman's clubs in St James's,
00:31:31 said he was the only person left on his street who hadn't arrived there within the space of the last 15 or so years.
00:31:37 And I've often jokingly said, if the Cockneys had been a tribe in the Amazon, the UN would have sent a force in to preserve them.
00:31:44 But yet here they're in the urban jungle and no one seems to care that they've been displaced after centuries of living in one location.
00:31:51 You would disagree with that, Austin, would you not?
00:31:54 Well, yes. Well, I only shouted, I mean, sorry, I've been speaking too much.
00:31:58 I shouted out Shenzhen, which in 1985 was a was a series of villages of 30,000 people.
00:32:06 And it's now a city of 15, 18 million people.
00:32:09 So the speed of transition that London is seeing has got nothing on what China has done.
00:32:16 Obviously, it has an authoritarian state to help it on its way.
00:32:19 I appreciate that.
00:32:21 But, you know, I think that there are and there are problems, social problems that come with that loss of history.
00:32:27 I understand all of those things. But in some ways, if you have a dynamic sense of progress and where you want to be, then you can carry people with you.
00:32:35 I remember I'm older from the 1960s when my local village in South Wales was, you know, having houses built when the motorway was being built, when we could then travel to Cardiff much more quickly.
00:32:46 And it was a joy. We saw that as progress, that we were no longer isolated, that we were then going to be connected to the wonderful metropolis of Cardiff, if you excuse the expression.
00:32:56 but we lost something right we lost something but that loss was more than compensated by the
00:33:03 gains that we had because we saw the future in a positive light I think what we have today is
00:33:08 seeing the future in such a negative we saw we have so much trepidation about visiting the future
00:33:13 that we therefore want to safeguard what we have or look back to the past in some kind of
00:33:17 in some kind of nostalgic way that's the problem it's the it's the it's the perspective I think
00:33:21 which is wrong um well what do you sort of think what do you see at the future and i mean
00:33:27 what if you take how it is now how it is going at the moment you know when you look forward do you
00:33:34 look forward and think with some kind of optimism or do you think actually it's not going to be a
00:33:39 place that i particularly want to be anymore i mean you you were born you and you you live here
00:33:44 like we all do yeah um well i suppose just following on from what you were saying i mean
00:33:50 know there'll always be an element of churn in a city of people passing through in any healthy
00:33:55 successful city um but it's not to say it doesn't also need an element of the population that's
00:34:01 a bit more firmly rooted and has a longer term interest in it i think you know you need both
00:34:05 you need both those things really um for the future i i don't know i think it's yes it's not
00:34:11 so much um well immigration per se as it is perhaps the the lack of identity that's what you
00:34:17 and you were saying it's the perhaps that multiculturalism when when there's a
00:34:22 loss of of a kind of a more overarching London identity with that is the
00:34:29 problem and yeah I don't know I think I'm fairly pessimistic I suppose about
00:34:33 the future in that respect well when I walk on my way to to come here when I
00:34:38 walk from my flat to the station there is this brand spanking new crossrail
00:34:44 station for Woolwich there which was obviously meant to open last year originally then this year
00:34:51 now it's going to be in apparently 2022 you know I'll wait and see until that happens but there's
00:34:57 you've got this sort of feeling wait a minute if you were actually looking at transport now and the
00:35:02 way London is now after co you wouldn't build this thing you just wouldn't build this thing
00:35:06 because it's just that the whole thing has changed so much there won't be the number of people to
00:35:12 actually uh to use it so i mean i i am quite pessimistic about it very for you well it's
00:35:19 interesting because car travel is more or less back to pre-covid levels as is bicycling
00:35:23 is public transport that's the real issue here and whereas in most cities about half of people
00:35:27 commute to work in public transport here is 80 percent and it's still that fear of public
00:35:33 transport that's the issue so it remains to be seen whether whether actually things do improve
00:35:38 i'm not that i'm not as pessimistic and of course if people are watching this and thinking well why
00:35:42 does any of this matter to me, whether people can get to work on the trains or not, is because
00:35:47 if London was an independent country, it would almost be in the G20 of the economies, you
00:35:52 know. It's a quarter of the country's economic output comes through London, and one third
00:35:59 of the tax take for the nation. And just as Britain was a net contributor to the EU, London
00:36:04 is a net contributor. So everybody in the country really has a vested interest in seeing
00:36:09 London thrive, as long as it's, you know, thriving in the right way.
00:36:13 Although I think a lot of people actually now are actually, you know, rubbing their
00:36:19 hands. They think that London's been way too arrogant for way too long. Anyway, I
00:36:25 still, I guess, love it.
00:36:27 I was only going to throw in, just for the sake of saying it, the famous Gramsci
00:36:31 quote of pessimism of the intellect, optimism of the will. So, you know, in our
00:36:37 minds we know that things are looking bleak but you know in our human abilities to transform things
00:36:43 we should be optimistic well that's a that's a very we we've been talking a lot about grancy
00:36:49 actually on this program recently austin but never heard that one before actually so great thank you
00:36:54 look listen austin thank you very much for joining us this morning thanks very much robert thanks
00:36:59 rave um that's it for counterculture this week uh in the meantime uh we mentioned the save our
00:37:05 Statues campaign at the very beginning of the program please do subscribe
00:37:10 won't you and join us it's been great to see how much support there is for that
00:37:16 campaign saveourstatues.org.uk or at Save Our Statues on Twitter and of course
00:37:24 please do subscribe to our show and channel won't you we still want you to
00:37:29 do that. So see you next time. Thank you.