New Culture Forum - October 18, 2020


The Positive Case For The British Empire (& Cecil Rhodes) - A Balanced Approach To Imperial History

Sacred Music: The Unsung Battleground In The Long March | Culture Wars Are Cities Dying? What's The Future For London & Other Cities Post-Covid?

Episode Stats


Length

29 minutes

Words per minute

131.89

Word count

3,935

Sentence count

145


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 hello and welcome to so what you're saying is I'm Peter Whittle now with history and the academic
00:00:29 world very much in the news. I'm delighted that my guest today is Professor Nigel Bigger.
00:00:35 Nigel is Professor of Moral and Pastoral Theology at the University of Oxford. Many thanks for
00:00:43 joining us. You're welcome, glad to be here. I want to ask something which is very sort of
00:00:46 pertinent and quite current at the moment. I believe that this week is the final date for
00:00:55 public submissions on this on the statue of Cecil Rhodes at Oxford this is
00:01:02 obviously something's been going on for a long time yes what is your view on on
00:01:08 the statue my view is that the statue has come to signify certain things about
00:01:17 the past and the present that are untrue. So Cecil Rhodes, turn of the 20th century,
00:01:27 buccaneering capitalist, believer in British imperialism, is now debited with all the alleged
00:01:36 sins of British colonialism. So three or four years ago, 2015, 16, when the first agitation
00:01:45 to have his statue in Oxford High Street taken down happened, the meme put about Rhodes
00:01:55 was that he was South Africa's Hitler and that he was responsible for genocide in South
00:02:01 Africa and that he was a racist.
00:02:05 And since then I've done a lot of research on Rhodes and South Africa and historically
00:02:11 that is just not true.
00:02:15 But Rhodes has become a symbol of colonialism and racism and I think what motivates the
00:02:22 agitators to try and remove him from his pedestal is that they want to say that the fact that
00:02:29 this racist, white supremacist, imperialist stands over Oxford's High Street and the
00:02:35 fact that people let that happen is it is a sign that actually racism reigns
00:02:43 among us here in Britain so it's a kind of incarnation of the racist mentality
00:02:49 that infects the whole of Britain and I think that's also empirically untrue I
00:02:53 mean I don't know much I don't know an awful lot about the situation of racism
00:03:01 Britain I've no doubt it exists but just for example in universities at the
00:03:10 moment there is a higher proportion of black and ethnic minority students in
00:03:18 British universities relative to the population than white British the
00:03:25 proportion of academics is slightly the proportion of professors is slightly
00:03:28 lower but if you're talking about Asian minority professors the proportion of
00:03:36 Asians that related to the population is higher than white so to assume that we
00:03:40 have a I don't I don't know we have a problem but to talk as many people do as
00:03:44 I'm I was sorry to see Prince Harry talking as if Britain is structurally
00:03:51 institutionally essentially racist it's just not true therefore I think the
00:03:57 statue should stay because what it is said to signify it doesn't signify now
00:04:02 if we have a if you want to help disadvantaged minority students then by
00:04:09 all means let's create scholarships or do something constructive taking down
00:04:13 the statue doesn't help anybody but the point is really nice was that truth
00:04:18 doesn't really play a part in any of this does it I mean you know when you
00:04:22 say it's just not true. I would say that many of the people who don't like the idea of statues
00:04:28 being taken down know instinctively it's probably not true, but the force of the argument on the
00:04:34 other side seems to make it impossible, doesn't it? Well, yes, what you say is sadly true. I mean,
00:04:43 I was shocked and slightly perplexed initially about how the educators didn't, first of all,
00:04:50 how careless they were with the truth but then in early 2016 I published a
00:04:57 quite long essay in Standpoint magazine setting out what I thought to be the
00:05:02 truth about Rhodes and you know giving chapter and verse and whatever and the
00:05:07 response I got to that article was nothing I mean no one has responded to
00:05:13 it. I'm told that there was a quotation that was being put around in 2015-16 that was alleged
00:05:27 to have come from Rhodes in which he appears to advocate the killing of as many Africans as
00:05:33 possible. In my article I dismantled that quotation and pointed out that in fact it's a fabrication
00:05:41 of three different elements, one of which was fiction.
00:05:44 I'm told that that quotation has now come down
00:05:47 off the Rosemus Fall website.
00:05:48 I've not checked for myself.
00:05:49 So there has been some reaction,
00:05:51 but there's been no, as it were, rational reaction.
00:05:54 So you're right.
00:05:56 It's been a bit of a lesson for a naive academic like me
00:06:02 that politics doesn't always run on truth.
00:06:07 Maybe that doesn't surprise you quite so much.
00:06:11 But, so then it becomes, of course, politics, whether it's, you know, Rosemouth Fall agitation or other kinds of wokery, or whether it's Scottish nationalism, runs heavily on emotion.
00:06:25 And the question is, when emotions are running high, what's a reasonable person to do?
00:06:33 Well, there was a very good example of that. I mean, I know you've talked about it a lot before, but you wrote a piece, well, in The Times, didn't you, in 2017?
00:06:41 which was basically putting forward that and please correct me if I'm wrong that
00:06:45 we need a more nuanced attitude to colonialism yes and that meant looking
00:06:51 at the maybe the good and the bad and from what I can see you were greeted
00:06:58 with a tsunami weren't you first of all of students and then of academics
00:07:02 basically criticizing you yes that that's right that was just over three
00:07:08 years ago and so again I was shocked at the intemperate and careless
00:07:18 reaction of academics and people from Cambridge and London and even
00:07:25 Oxford so I responded as carefully as I could to some of the claims they made in
00:07:33 writing. And again, I noticed that no one responded to what I had said, but some people
00:07:39 kept on belabouring the fact that, or just labelling me as racist and white supremacist
00:07:48 simply because I held what I thought was a pretty moderate and anodyne view that the
00:07:55 British Empire contained good as well as bad. I mean, right now I'm in the process of writing
00:07:59 a book about that, and actually I think it contained rather more good than bad.
00:08:03 When's the book out, actually?
00:08:05 Late next year.
00:08:07 Will you come back and talk to us about that?
00:08:09 Absolutely, absolutely.
00:08:11 Can I ask as well, Nigel, on this front,
00:08:14 I think people would agree with you when they're being rational,
00:08:18 if they are, that that is the case about the British Empire.
00:08:21 But would you just give us some instances, therefore,
00:08:25 of how you think it was a good thing?
00:08:27 We're hearing at the moment about all the evil,
00:08:31 But what would you say were virtues and the good things?
00:08:35 Well, there are two things, Peter, I'd pick out.
00:08:38 At the moment, you will notice that the phrase
00:08:41 colonialism and slavery is running around all sorts of institutions.
00:08:48 You know, national trust, museums are keen to make
00:08:51 the uncomfortable bits of British history plain and to expose this.
00:08:58 Now, putting those two together, of course, rather implies that
00:09:01 colonialism is slavery.
00:09:05 Now, so there's a half-truth there.
00:09:07 The half-truth is that yes, the British Empire in its early days
00:09:12 for 200 years from the early 1600s to the very early 1800s
00:09:16 was involved in the slave trade.
00:09:19 That is true. That was awful.
00:09:23 Lots of Brits starting in the second half of the 1700s
00:09:26 began to think it was awful.
00:09:28 and as is quite well known people like William Wilberforce and others spent 50 years
00:09:36 first of all working to have the slave trade abolished and then the institution of slavery
00:09:44 in the empire. So between us and slavery is that. So why are we identified with what went before
00:09:52 then, and not with the 50 years of endeavour. And the abolitionist movement was a very popular
00:09:59 movement. It wasn't just highfalutin MPs. There were popular petitions going to Parliament.
00:10:06 But then, here's another thing. From 1807, when the slave trade was abolished in the empire,
00:10:14 until the end of the British Empire in the 1950s and 60s, the British Empire was consistently and
00:10:21 actively committed to suppressing slavery, the slave trade across the Atlantic, across the Indian
00:10:28 Ocean, in Latin America, in Africa, in Asia. So the first thing I'd say what was good about the
00:10:36 British Empire was we repented of slavery 200 years ago. And we then spent the best part of
00:10:44 a century and a half suppressing it all over the world. So let's remember, you know, the bad bit.
00:10:51 let's also remember the more recent good bits.
00:10:54 So that's the first thing.
00:10:55 The second thing I can say much more briefly,
00:10:58 and that is that between May 1940 and June 1941,
00:11:07 the only major military power in the field
00:11:11 against European fascism, with the exception of Greece,
00:11:15 was the British Empire.
00:11:17 So...
00:11:17 Yes.
00:11:19 Yeah, I think there's...
00:11:20 I mean, let's be clear, in the course of the 300 odd years of the British Empire, bad things happened, some terrible things happened, but then if you look at the history of any nation state of long standing, even bright new shiny liberal Sweden has skeletons in its historical cupboard, we all do.
00:11:43 Were there any other things that you would sort of point to that were sort of not responses to a situation such as, obviously, the rise of Hitler, but were infrastructural things or philosophical things that were a good thing about the empire?
00:11:58 Yes, so two things.
00:12:00 I mean, Britain from the 1840s was committed to free trade around the world.
00:12:09 And the evidence is that, yes, on the one hand,
00:12:14 what that meant was that British manufacturers of cotton
00:12:17 could put some Indian peasants who were producing less fine cotton out of business.
00:12:26 That's true.
00:12:27 But it also allowed Indian entrepreneurs to come to Britain to look at manufacturing in Manchester,
00:12:35 to take the machinery back to India, to import the expertise, to set up steel factories in Bombay
00:12:42 that then out-competed Manchester.
00:12:45 Right.
00:12:45 Right. So, and if you look at the statistics of wages and infant mortality in Africa from 1910 to 1960,
00:13:00 certainly in East Africa and West Africa, there's a consistent, not dramatic, but consistent increase.
00:13:09 So in other words, health and wealth did increase slowly. So there's that.
00:13:14 And philosophically, of course, Britain, in terms of political philosophy, Britain has
00:13:25 been a home of liberal political philosophy, the notion that the political freedom is really
00:13:30 vital, the notion of representative institutions.
00:13:34 And so when, for example, Indians like Gandhi or Nehru came to study in Cambridge or London,
00:13:47 they imbibed these liberal views, took them back to India, and then used them against British rule.
00:13:54 So in a sense, we were the author of our own demise.
00:13:58 But the empire was always in kind of two minds.
00:14:02 I mean, there was always a liberal streak in it.
00:14:04 that actually put imperialists on the back foot when Indian nationalists started saying,
00:14:10 well, you know, live up to your liberal credentials.
00:14:14 There are also two other aspects.
00:14:16 I mean, perhaps they're too superficial in their reading,
00:14:19 but there's the view that the British Empire almost came about by accident,
00:14:24 you know, that it sort of just kind of organically emerged.
00:14:30 Yes.
00:14:30 and also that the manner in which it went was very significant I mean you
00:14:36 know throughout this post-war period in the ease with which British just simply
00:14:40 let yes I mean they sort of both of those things say something yes I mean
00:14:47 people sometimes yes so when people talk about colonialism and slavery in a sense
00:14:54 they they essentialize it they say you know the Empire was essentially slavery
00:14:59 And some people talk about the imperial project as if someone woke up in London in 1600 and said,
00:15:04 oh, let's go and conquer the world.
00:15:08 The truth is that the British Empire, and this is true of most empires,
00:15:12 grew up not entirely by accident, but in a very kind of ad hoc way.
00:15:18 So initially Queen Elizabeth wants to fend off the Spanish,
00:15:26 So she commissions Walter Raleigh and Francis Drake to go off and harry Spanish shipping and to set up naval bases in North America.
00:15:37 Then the East India Company wants to trade with India.
00:15:42 So people go out to India to trade.
00:15:45 And then in the early 1800s, people go out to India to trade.
00:15:52 But also, since they're now responsible for government, they want to govern well.
00:15:56 and they see quaint local practices like having widows burn themselves on the funeral pyres of
00:16:04 their late husbands, and they're appalled, along with many Indians, and they cooperate with Indians
00:16:11 to ban the practice. So the motives for empire were very wide-ranging. No doubt at some point,
00:16:19 at certain points, certain Britons were racist, they were contemptuous of natives.
00:16:26 Many Britons were not contemptuous of natives, many Britons in fact were fascinated by the
00:16:33 foreign cultures they came across and in India invested a lot of time in learning languages,
00:16:39 in recovering ancient texts. So yes, the empire began all over the world for all
00:16:48 sorts of different reasons which is why whatever it sins, it's hard to say the thing was essentially
00:16:54 evil because it depends which bit you're talking about and what period you're talking about and
00:17:01 where you're talking about so in terms of the beginning you're quite right and in terms of the
00:17:04 end yes i mean um it it began to dissolve into the commonwealth it didn't end it dissolved or
00:17:15 loosened into a different form. It dissolved in different ways. I mean, by the 1930s, the
00:17:26 predominantly white settler colonies, Australia, South Africa, New Zealand, Canada, were effectively
00:17:32 independent, except I think for foreign defence and military matters. And there was always
00:17:39 a sense in principle that colonies would have to become independent in the end, but it was
00:17:51 thought in Africa in particular and to some extent in India that Africans and Indians
00:17:56 weren't ready for independence, and that was truer of Africa than India. But what brought
00:18:03 about the disillusion of the empire in Africa and India was partly the Second World War,
00:18:11 Britain was exhausted, and partly the rise of nationalist sentiment, that often the nationalists
00:18:22 educated in Britain, and nationalists were impatient, and there's some good reason to
00:18:30 suppose that it's a shame that nationalists were so impatient because
00:18:36 Africa's development might have been better if British colonial rule had had
00:18:43 withdrawn more slowly and gradually than it did but it didn't the British
00:18:51 didn't seem to disappear the Commonwealth remains and of course close
00:18:55 relations with um australia new zealand canada uh in in the five eyes intelligent program militarily
00:19:03 culturally still remains and is is a live factor and to a large extent the the post-war liberal
00:19:10 international order that america came to uh lead uh was shaped by the british empire
00:19:20 it's interesting you know when we look at the commonwealth because you mentioned prince harry
00:19:23 a bit earlier and i think at one stage amongst you know the inane remarks that he's making
00:19:30 he said something like we have to look at the uncomfortable aspects of commonwealth
00:19:36 and this was a while ago yes but the fact is that it's entirely voluntary bodies yes
00:19:42 people actually actively want to join it don't they yes and i believe that there is at least
00:19:47 two countries that were never in the british empire that um applied and have been accepted
00:19:53 so i think mozambique which was portuguese and rwanda which was uh belgian um yes i i think
00:20:00 harry was was being a bit loose with his language he probably meant the um the uncomfortable um
00:20:07 bits of the imperial past of most of the present commonwealth well i think that language is
00:20:13 terribly important yes don't you yes um you mentioned at the beginning there and how basically
00:20:20 colonialism and slavery are seen as one and the same thing one defining the other yeah but we've
00:20:27 actually gone a step on from that now it seems to me if you look at the past few months what's been
00:20:31 happening with the black lives matter protests and also the way in which our institutions uh
00:20:37 the National Trust, but also the British Library, the British Museum,
00:20:43 they appear to be defining British history in terms of slavery now.
00:20:49 I mean, this is the message that's coming over, isn't it?
00:20:52 That actually it's all based somehow on slavery.
00:20:56 I mean, I've had sort of liberal, well-educated friends of mine saying,
00:21:01 well, all of our institutions are based on slavery.
00:21:03 and this is just simply factually, historically ridiculous, isn't it?
00:21:09 Yes, it is ridiculous and I wish my book were being published next month, not next year
00:21:16 because what distresses me about what you say,
00:21:22 the fact that leaders of our cultural institutions have bought into this tale
00:21:28 that British history equals colonialism,
00:21:32 equals slavery, equals evil.
00:21:35 It's just so historically ignorant.
00:21:37 Just historically ignorant.
00:21:40 And it's necessarily the people at the top of institutions
00:21:43 have fallen over themselves to buy into it.
00:21:46 So, I mean, one can't object to museums or country houses
00:21:54 owned by the National Trust pointing out
00:21:57 that, let's say, Harewood House near Leeds, where I used to live,
00:22:04 that the wealth on which that was built was from sugar plantations.
00:22:11 So, you know, let's be honest about that.
00:22:13 There are people, there are families that profited from slavery in this country.
00:22:19 But you might point out at the same time that the only reason that the British were able to transport slaves across the Atlantic was because Africans sold slaves to them.
00:22:35 Therefore, there are Africans, and maybe even, let's say, British Nigerians or British West Africans, who have slave skeletons in their cupboard too.
00:22:46 but we never hear about that so that's so let's have a balance here and as I was saying earlier
00:22:55 that there is the connection between Britain and slavery has both good and bad my impression is
00:23:02 the National Trust British Museum are all fixated on the bad whereas there's a good story that's
00:23:11 more recent, about which people know very little. I imagine most people know about Wilberforce
00:23:19 and the campaign to abolish it. I imagine most people do not know about the extent of
00:23:24 British imperial commitment to suppress slavery worldwide for the following 150 years.
00:23:30 I think it's just not emphasised, that's the point, it's not emphasised.
00:23:35 So, if the head of the British Museum or National Trust were to ask me, I'd say, tell the bad bits, yes, let's be honest about that, but please tell the good bits too, so that people don't get a distorted picture of the past.
00:23:51 I noticed in Oxford there is the Pitt Rivers Museum
00:23:57 which is devoted mainly to natural history and anthropology
00:24:02 and there was an article in I think the Telegraph
00:24:08 Sunday Telegraph a couple of weekends ago
00:24:10 about someone who's published a book about
00:24:13 the British sacking of Benin in Nigeria
00:24:18 and it's all about the brutality of that event.
00:24:26 And this fellow who works in the museum wants to talk up and expose the brutality of British colonialism.
00:24:33 At the same time, the head of the same museum has withdrawn a set of shrunken heads
00:24:41 which had been on display and these were taken from South America
00:24:47 where the natives had the custom of cutting off the heads of their enemies, shrinking them down,
00:24:54 sewing up their lips and eyes to preserve the virility and the power of their enemies to somehow augment their own power.
00:25:02 And she took these off display because she worried that people would have racist thoughts
00:25:06 about the gruesome and primitive nature of this South American culture.
00:25:13 And my response in last Sunday's Telegraph letters pages was to say, well, let's have a level playing field, folks.
00:25:21 If you want to get upset about British brutality and gruesomeness, fine.
00:25:26 But let's also see, be allowed to see, the brutality and gruesomeness of a South American culture.
00:25:36 Either that or don't tell us what you think.
00:25:39 Just show these things.
00:25:41 Let's judge for ourselves.
00:25:43 So when you look at what's happened over the past few months and the fact that this is now our institutions, the speed with which these institutions have started to sort of capitulate and emphasise these particular things such as slavery, it's obviously embedded, it's embedded in the institutions.
00:26:02 and i just wondered you know whether you see as it were the pendulum swinging back at all to
00:26:10 a more measured approach or whether this is going to be the ongoing orthodoxy from now on you know
00:26:19 um my answer is yes or no i think this is the orthodoxy we will have to live with for a while
00:26:26 but it is a generational thing is it not so we we have in charge of institutions
00:26:31 I guess people in their late 40s early 50s who were educated in a certain period and if you
00:26:40 follow imperial history you as you'd expect there are fashions and so I guess it's about the 1990s
00:26:48 early noughties the kind of fashions that we see expressed in public now have reigned before then
00:26:57 There was a much more measured appraisal of the British Empire.
00:27:02 So my view is, you know, we've got people in charge and in prominent positions
00:27:05 who will express these views.
00:27:09 That's frustrating for someone like me.
00:27:12 However, my perception is that there is a reaction gathering.
00:27:18 I suppose I'm part of it.
00:27:21 And I am able to speak freely, thanks not least to you.
00:27:25 I am about to publish a book unless someone tries to stop it.
00:27:30 And judging by just going back three years to the ruckus about my own views on colonialism in the press,
00:27:42 The Guardian virtually ignored the ruckus.
00:27:45 Everyone else paid attention and letters to the press were overwhelmingly in favour of my views.
00:27:53 and this is really important
00:27:55 there are plenty of people out there
00:27:57 with non-white skins
00:27:59 British Indians
00:28:01 British Iranis
00:28:03 British people from Nigeria
00:28:06 who agree with me
00:28:07 so I think
00:28:09 there's no need to be despondent
00:28:10 but we do have to be persistent
00:28:12 the only thing I know to do
00:28:15 in the face of irrational emotion
00:28:18 is to keep telling the truth
00:28:20 and hope that
00:28:22 people who are not so excited will listen
00:28:25 and maybe in time those who are excited
00:28:27 will calm down and listen too
00:28:28 I suppose that one way we could sort of maybe
00:28:31 tell that things have really started
00:28:33 to change is if when your book comes
00:28:35 out the BBC
00:28:37 decide to make a programme about it
00:28:39 you know
00:28:40 well that would be different wouldn't it
00:28:42 well yes yes let's see if
00:28:45 that happens
00:28:46 in the name of balance
00:28:49 right now
00:28:50 So the wokest have the field, let's have a bit of balance in future.
00:28:56 Well look Nigel, thank you very much for joining us today and when you do, when the book comes out then it would be wonderful to have you back to talk about it.
00:29:03 I'd be very glad to come back and thanks for the chance to talk Peter.
00:29:06 It's a pleasure. That's it for so what you're saying is today. Obviously please remember to subscribe, won't you, to the channel and we'll see you next time. Thank you.
00:29:20 Transcription by CastingWords