New Culture Forum - July 10, 2020


Borders & Social Boundaries Matter: Why Humanity Must Relearn The Art Of Drawing Boundaries

How We Reverse The Left's Long March And Take Back Control Of Britain's Institutions Marc Sidwell Reads From His Book: The Long March - How The Left Won The Culture War

Episode Stats


Length

47 minutes

Words per minute

149.26

Word count

7,046

Sentence count

111


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to So What You're Saying Is. I'm Peter Whittle. Now I'm delighted that my
00:00:26 guest today is somebody we've had on the show before. Frank Feredi is the Emeritus Professor
00:00:32 of Sociology at the University of Kent. He's the author of numerous critically acclaimed books.
00:00:39 When he was on last time, we were talking about his book, How Fear Works. This time,
00:00:45 he has a new book out, it's just come out, which is called Why Borders Matter,
00:00:51 why humanity must relearn the art of drawing boundaries thanks for joining
00:00:58 us again Frank when people hear about when when usually on this program we're
00:01:05 talking about borders it means just one thing and that is national borders but
00:01:11 can you just give us an overview that your book is about something much wider
00:01:18 than that yep basically what happened was that I was asked to do the
00:01:25 introduction to the philosophy day in Holland on the pub on the subject of
00:01:32 borders and when I began to look into giving this lecture I realized that not
00:01:39 only were national borders being contested and called into question
00:01:44 people are saying borders are somehow evil or immoral or exploitative but every border every
00:01:52 boundary that has been important in giving meaning to human experience is not seen as somehow
00:01:59 discriminatory or immoral so the border between children and adults is not seen in a highly
00:02:08 sort of dubious kind of a way and the symbolic boundary separating children from adults is often
00:02:15 called into question. You probably will have heard all the debate about the conventional
00:02:20 boundary between men and women and people now see that's an unfair distinction between men and
00:02:26 women. There must be a whole lot of other sexes that are not taken into account. We now call into
00:02:33 question the boundary between human beings and animals and argue that in fact you know there
00:02:39 is a lot more similarity between some animals and humans than we suspect the border between
00:02:46 public and private is being pulverized and gradually you cannot make any more distinctions
00:02:53 and what became very very clear to me is that any form of important cultural distinction
00:02:57 that has given meaning to human experience is now being contested.
00:03:03 And that's how the book came about.
00:03:04 I'm trying to explain the connections between why it is that precisely the same people
00:03:11 that call for open borders are also the same people that query the conventional distinction
00:03:18 between men and women and are uncomfortable with the distinction between the private and the public.
00:03:24 I mean, there is a sort of paradox, is there not, at the heart of this,
00:03:29 is that you've got this desire for what you might call openness, no borders.
00:03:35 On the other hand, we seem to be living in a more and more prescriptive time.
00:03:41 I mean, that's a paradox.
00:03:44 It's a paradox, and it's something that I address,
00:03:46 because what's very interesting is that the kind of people that denounce the policing of border
00:03:55 and they say it's violent and it's unjust and that should never happen in a civilized society
00:04:02 are also the same the same people who are very busy policing culture so you have this new movement
00:04:10 against cultural appropriation where people are continually sort of scrutinizing who is wearing
00:04:17 what kind of haircut. Is a white person allowed to write about a Native American or a man? Can a
00:04:26 man write about a woman? And all these identity cultural groups are policing one another to make
00:04:33 sure that you don't infringe on that. So you have this interesting development where, and I make
00:04:38 this point is that the people that are against distinctions are only against the distinctions
00:04:45 that are rooted in the past, are only against the distinctions that have given meaning to human
00:04:50 experience over the centuries. They've created their own ways of protecting themselves. I think
00:04:56 the most striking example is that in the United States, there's been this tremendous hostility
00:05:03 to trump building that wall on the mexican american border and you think well the people
00:05:09 who were hostile to walls and borders you know would be open to everything but they are the same
00:05:14 people who are continually agitating for safe spaces they want to have their own safe space
00:05:20 where they're in a sense kind of cut off from criticism immunized from being offended so there
00:05:27 is a kind of interesting parallel going on here a double standard where some borders are attacked
00:05:33 And these are the borders that I think are really important.
00:05:36 And the new ones, which are very personal, very private, identity-based,
00:05:40 they're kind of recreated as the new kind of borders that are legitimate from their point of view.
00:05:48 Do you feel, Frank, that you...
00:05:52 Would it be right to say that you are therefore pro-borders in the nation-state sense?
00:05:58 well it was a bit of a journey of discovery because historically i always presumed in
00:06:07 favor of openness of allowing as much movement and migration as possible i myself come from
00:06:14 an immigrant family so i'm quite sympathetic to people having to have the freedom of movement
00:06:20 but what i'm against and what i've learned is a really big problem is is when the very idea of
00:06:27 border is called into question. And the reason for that is because we need national borders
00:06:36 as a way of creating communities. I think one of the things we learn from history
00:06:41 is that communities are bounded in space. Right from the Greeks onward, we learn that the walls
00:06:48 of the city-state provided the context within which public life could occur, where citizens
00:06:55 could trust each other and engage with each other and similarly today we need national borders
00:07:01 in order for democracy to function in order for public life to work because unless we have
00:07:07 citizens who are being able to uphold to account the political system we're in big trouble and
00:07:16 who are citizens well the citizens aren't world citizens kind of living in the abstract
00:07:22 although some people would claim it would be much better if we were all citizens of the world,
00:07:27 they're actually citizens of a particular space where they've over the centuries been
00:07:34 generationally created and where there are links and responsibilities that people, citizens
00:07:41 afterwards, the generations that preceded them and the ones that come after that. And even
00:07:46 immigrants who decide to become immigrant citizens when they come to a country they still become at
00:07:53 that point bounded and in a moral sense they become part and parcel of that kind of community
00:08:00 that exists within those borders so it's right to say isn't it that obviously when you started out
00:08:07 politically frank and the with the when you founded the revolutionary communist party
00:08:12 I would have thought the whole basis of that international Marxism
00:08:16 was total internationalism, no borders.
00:08:21 Has this been a gradual... What changed?
00:08:24 Has this been a gradual journey for you to this belief now?
00:08:29 Well, I think that there's often been a lot of confusion on this,
00:08:33 both by the left, by Marxists,
00:08:36 and people who are sympathetic to what I see as being a universalist.
00:08:42 I think the German philosopher Immanuel Kant quite rightly talked about universalism as being a positive development and quite rightly he talked about the need for humankind to see themselves as having something common that's very precious and needs to be preserved.
00:09:03 and therefore as members of a human species we do have a degree of responsibility for each other
00:09:11 on the moral plane but at the same time as we have that we also aren't just simply human beings
00:09:18 we're people that are born into a particular family we're people that are born into a particular
00:09:24 community we have neighbors we have family members we belong to a particular nation and therefore
00:09:30 Therefore, whilst morally we take responsibility for the whole of the human species, we have a different relationship with those to whom we are accountable, the ones that are part and parcel of the space that we inhabit.
00:09:46 And it seems to me that once you begin to understand the situation like that, you can be both generous in terms of kind of being committed to the freedom of movement while taking very, very seriously.
00:10:00 the nation state national boundaries especially today when there is so much of an attempt to
00:10:06 destroy the sense of national commitment and national identity we have to bend the
00:10:13 stick in a different kind of direction that would have been the case in the past do you think uh
00:10:18 you know one can believe in uh freedom of movement if you like in a broad principle sense
00:10:23 I suppose. But would you say, therefore, that, for example, the historic mass migration that,
00:10:31 say, Europe has been seeing and Britain's been seeing, would you say that that therefore must
00:10:35 therefore be destructive to the idea of community and borders? Well, I think the situation is a
00:10:45 little bit more complicated than that. The way that I look at it is that obviously people in
00:10:50 a particular community have got the right to make a decision and decide you know whether they want
00:10:56 migration or not you know it's their responsibility they have the authority to have the final say
00:11:03 on how the system should work but to me the real problem uh with migration is not migration per se
00:11:12 i think the real problem is that in places like britain in france belgium many parts of western
00:11:19 Europe we have a regime of multiculturalism and what multiculturalism does and what it says
00:11:26 is basically uh you can come into our society you can come into our community
00:11:33 and you can decide on what terms you want to live there you don't have to be like us
00:11:39 you don't have to be part and parcel of a common community and under those circumstances what
00:11:45 what multiculturalism does is it corrodes the nations into which migrants and immigrants come
00:11:52 into. Because instead of forging a sense of unity and deciding and discussing what is it that we
00:11:59 have in common, the question doesn't get raised. Instead, people are told, well, you live your life
00:12:05 in accordance with your culture. We'll live our own life in the way that we see fit. And you end
00:12:11 up with a lot of parallel worlds and parallel societies and that is what is destructive it's
00:12:16 the to me the real problem is multiculturalism rather than simply you know the you know people
00:12:22 coming in because if people came into britain on different terms they knew they had to learn
00:12:27 english they knew they had to be british they knew that they had to sign up to the values that
00:12:33 you know sort of are part and parcel of our history uh then the problem would be very different
00:12:38 so it's the response really isn't it of countries like ours to immigration which is the problem i
00:12:45 mean uh there's just to before we leave this part of it there's also a problem surely that
00:12:51 with multiculturalism um you also have a an established country which might not even believe
00:12:58 necessarily anymore in imposing actually what would be the the culture the national culture
00:13:05 In other words, you hear in a crude sense this idea of signing up to the culture you're living in.
00:13:11 That's very weak, that feeling now, isn't it?
00:13:15 Yeah, I mean, this is obviously the reason why we have multiculturalism in its form,
00:13:21 because the political establishment in Britain, the cultural establishment,
00:13:27 is very uneasy with the traditions of Britain, with the history of Britain,
00:13:33 with the kind of values that made Britain what it is
00:13:36 and is much more comfortable about trying to sort of move away from that
00:13:43 and, in fact, often uses immigration as a medium
00:13:49 through which sort of new values can be imported and celebrated.
00:13:55 And I think it's very often the case that, you know,
00:13:58 If you kind of look at the Netflix or Hollywood or the BBC in terms of what is valued in the world,
00:14:09 it's almost never the case that what is valued are kind of authentic English or Scottish or Welsh kind of values.
00:14:17 What is celebrated is some kind of, you know, kind of confused mixture of cosmopolitan, you know, sort of fashion that is the latest, you know, sort of fad.
00:14:31 And to that extent, they have got no interest in creating a more homogenized political culture.
00:14:40 In fact, what they celebrate is not the homogenized political culture, but what they call diversity.
00:14:45 And what diversity means is, you know, the more the merrier, difference is inherently good.
00:14:53 And under those circumstances, we do run into a bit of a problem.
00:15:00 What you're talking about, it seems to me, really, was very well illustrated by the Brexit argument.
00:15:07 And indeed, by this notion that I think David Goodhart talked about of anywheres and somewheres.
00:15:14 anywheres are the people who are the citizens of the world
00:15:17 and almost take
00:15:19 you know celebrate the fact
00:15:21 they have no roots
00:15:22 they want to be rootless
00:15:24 and the somewheres are the people who have a sense of
00:15:26 locality and attachment
00:15:29 you'd say that
00:15:31 that is pretty much
00:15:32 really what you're actually talking about
00:15:35 isn't it as well
00:15:36 yeah to a considerable extent
00:15:39 you do have people
00:15:40 who pride themselves on the fact
00:15:43 they continue on the move. They boast about the fact that they feel just as home in Hollywood as
00:15:50 they do in Paris or in Berlin. And they, you know, sort of kind of cultivate this cosmopolitan image
00:15:59 whereby they have, you know, they kind of haven't got the sensibilities. They don't really take
00:16:06 seriously the customs of the cultures into which they were born. And it is interesting to know that
00:16:13 these people who are so ruthless, the anywheres, at the same time, when you kind of scratch the
00:16:20 surface, are totally obsessed about space as well. But it's not the space which they were born into,
00:16:29 it's their personal space. And in the book I talk about how, particularly in the United States,
00:16:35 you now have this obsession with personal boundaries and with personal spaces that somehow
00:16:41 you need to keep people at a distance from you you got this very privatized notion of space and
00:16:47 if you go on amazon there are dozens and dozens of self-held book books that advise you how to
00:16:55 defend your personal space how to kind of maintain your private sphere so you know even though they're
00:17:01 very comfortable anywhere in the world they actually aren't totally relaxed uh because they
00:17:07 feel exposed by the world they live in and they are trying you know in an escapist way move away
00:17:14 but at the same time try to create some kind of a personal safe space for themselves you know where
00:17:20 they can this they can be distant from the rest of the world there is a sort of i feel a slight
00:17:26 moral superiority attached to this too that somehow you are you are better person for wanting to be
00:17:35 basically itinerant you know that this shows something about you
00:17:41 it does and i i think it kind of comes across in the most condescending way in the united states
00:17:47 where you often hear people saying oh most americans haven't got a passport you know
00:17:53 they don't travel to the south of france or to mallorca like we do and you know i i love
00:18:01 traveling so i've got no problems with going all over the place but if you know just because people
00:18:06 don't have passports and they haven't been to benidorm doesn't really mean that they're morally
00:18:12 inferior and the same people who think in this way that have this sense of moral superiority
00:18:19 always use the same expression you always know what they think because they think of themselves
00:18:25 as being aware and and they think that you know they're in a position to raise our awareness
00:18:34 moral insight into the world and what it is is basically what they're saying is that our
00:18:41 ruthless values that is not bounded in space that is not contained within the conventional
00:18:47 sort of symbolic boundaries somehow superior than those poor little people who actually
00:18:54 you know sort of enjoy being english somehow there's something wrong about these people when
00:19:00 they wave an english flag you know sort of it's okay for them to wave their flags because they
00:19:05 got their equivalent you know what a flag is but it's not okay for an english person to wave a flag
00:19:12 so i always make the point that you know whenever my friends who are these uh cosmopolitan uh types
00:19:20 who think they are really aware you know i always make the point of you kind of look down upon
00:19:24 people waving a national flag but look how much you're waving your rainbow flags all the time
00:19:30 and how how you think that that is so much a symbol of moral authority where in fact all you're doing
00:19:37 is just branding yourself in a slightly different way your uh book is extremely thorough about
00:19:45 almost the whole human experience in terms of borders so as you say you said at the beginning
00:19:50 about men and women about adults and children when it comes to adults and children there
00:19:58 it seems and I think you point this out that there is on the one hand a kind of infantilization
00:20:03 process going on with adults isn't there and I suppose what would the what would the parallel
00:20:10 one be with children they're being what they're being made into adults or or what how on a daily
00:20:16 basis would you see that working frank you know how would you see what would an illustration of
00:20:21 that be well a very good example of the what i call the adultification of children when they kind
00:20:30 of treated like not only adults but also as in some shape or form morally superior to an adult
00:20:38 is when a really cool yummy mummy goes shopping with her daughter and instead of the mother
00:20:45 telling the daughter what clothes to buy she asks her daughter what should i wear you know
00:20:50 make a suggestion the daughter tells the mother how to dress and it's when you get the yummy
00:20:56 daddies you know boasting about the fact that they wear the same t-shirts as their sons and
00:21:02 and they listen to the same music as their children,
00:21:04 they really love the fact that their children's best friends,
00:21:08 instead of their dads and their moms,
00:21:11 you know that you really are in trouble when that occurs.
00:21:15 And I think that the most grotesque way in which children
00:21:19 have become adultified and adults have become infantilized
00:21:24 is when you look at Extinction Rebellion,
00:21:26 where you have someone like Greta Thunberg
00:21:29 being put on this pedestal as this moral authority who's entitled to lecture these horrible adults
00:21:36 who have made the world so bad for little 14 15 year olds and instead of saying well get off the
00:21:42 pedestal greta and do your homework instead of uh they basically take the knee in front of her and
00:21:53 and kind of ask her whether she's you know she wants to get a nobel peace prize or something
00:21:58 So there is a kind of what I call socialization in reverse, where the relationship between adults and children, at least morally, are often reversed.
00:22:08 And the boundary goes completely between adult authority and children.
00:22:13 But this is something that you see to be global. It seems to me that this is almost entirely a Western thing.
00:22:21 You know, America, Britain, the English-speaking part of the world.
00:22:26 Is this really the case in other cultures?
00:22:29 What I'm thinking of, Frank, is that where there is still a strong religious structure, for example,
00:22:35 or moral structure, this doesn't really occur so much, does it?
00:22:40 I think this is very, very strong in the West.
00:22:45 It's particularly powerful in the Anglo-American sphere and in Northern Europe,
00:22:50 the Scandinavian countries. It's less so the case in Spain, in Greece and in the Mediterranean
00:22:58 countries. And of course, thankfully, much of Central Europe and East Europe and the Balkans
00:23:05 have been immunized from this. But I think it's important not to be complacent because in my
00:23:12 travels I've noted that these kinds of ideals percolate through what I call
00:23:19 American or soft power yes remember that people watch Netflix everywhere all over
00:23:26 the world China India East Europe and you watch a Netflix program and I can bet
00:23:34 you my 10 pounds against your pan that in that Netflix program the child will
00:23:39 come across as sensitive, morally superior to the dissolute, you know, sort of bad-tempered
00:23:46 adults. There's a kind of message that comes across almost subliminally. I think for that
00:23:52 reason, you'll find that increasingly amongst the middle classes in Shanghai, or amongst
00:23:58 the middle classes in Osaka or Tokyo, some of this kind of cultural sensibility is also
00:24:05 becoming quite influential quite powerful and and and therefore um unfortunately uh even those
00:24:12 societies that have a more sturdy confident cultural outlook uh even they are susceptible
00:24:19 to internalizing some of the do you think that uh you know moving on to the points you make about
00:24:29 the public and private sphere in adult behavior, or indeed in young people's behavior, do you
00:24:37 think that there is anything in the idea that younger people have essentially given up their
00:24:45 privacy? They don't mind this blurring. They don't see any distinction. They're quite happy
00:24:51 to put it all out there on social media. Is that where that's come from?
00:24:56 well i think the younger people are the are the beneficiaries if you want to use that word
00:25:03 of the dissolute behavior of their uh adults uh kind of predecessors i think
00:25:10 it's been happening for a few generations now that the private sphere often is seen as a very dark
00:25:18 bad space and where stoicism or the stiff upper lip or trying to take your family too seriously
00:25:28 and close the door and speak in ways to members of your family that's different to the rest of
00:25:35 the world, those things are seen as negative for a very, very long time. And I remember as far back
00:25:41 as 1990 being involved in a debate where we were arguing about this emotionalism that was really
00:25:48 kicking in which then acquired its most caricatured form when Princess Diana died
00:25:54 and yet its national outpouring of grief where people were competing with one
00:25:59 another who is most upset people crying in public and where I remember when
00:26:05 Prince Charles I think was criticized for not crying in public and and having
00:26:11 this stiff upper lip as somehow that was morally inferior to what good people
00:26:16 did. So this has been going on for a very, very long time. And the present generation with their
00:26:20 social media have inherited a world where there is no value attached to private life. There's no
00:26:28 value attached to being on your own. In fact, the value that is attached is to people who open up
00:26:35 in public, you know, the reality TV format where politicians freely talk about their mental health
00:26:41 problems their alcoholism their faithlessness with their partners their sexual problems where
00:26:48 they can talk about anything and the more you talk about the more private the thoughts are that you
00:26:53 reveal the more you're praised for being brave right you know the more you are seen as a genuine
00:27:00 authentic politician if you're a politician that says no actually i'm not here to talk about my
00:27:06 mental health issues i'm here to talk about policies and what i've done that is seen as
00:27:10 somehow a blemish on their records so we have created a world where private life you know sort
00:27:17 of it's important conventional senses has got no real uh moral authority attached to it but
00:27:24 increasingly seen as a as something negative you know in privacy you beat up your partner you abuse
00:27:31 your children in privacy the families distort the uh the well-being of kids so in that sense
00:27:39 open the door you know that's the argument open the door because they don't trust you
00:27:43 and the idea of a closed door has now become a metaphor for something negative something
00:27:49 depraved and you'll find very often that there are books called the they got the third closed
00:27:55 door in the title and they always signify that there's something uh disgusting or degrading
00:28:01 taking place behind that closed door what effect do you think frank has this whole
00:28:07 COVID episode had on the idea of borders I mean here we are you know in the you know socially
00:28:14 distant time we are and you know people are being stopped from traveling and all this
00:28:20 what do you see as being the effect this will have on the phenomenon that you're writing about
00:28:27 yeah it is it is very very interesting because um uh on the one hand uh what the lockdown did
00:28:37 was to uh reinforce this kind of sensibility uh that uh is very much concerned with safe spaces
00:28:48 that very much wants to have this kind of personal boundary around you all the time and i think
00:28:54 a lot of people
00:28:56 who are against
00:28:58 national borders, but who
00:29:00 like safe spaces
00:29:02 were also the people that loved being in lockdown
00:29:05 and weren't particularly bothered by it
00:29:06 and are usually the ones that are
00:29:09 less comfortable
00:29:10 about leaving home
00:29:12 when the lockdown is finished.
00:29:14 So for them, the lockdown
00:29:15 was not an experience that was negative.
00:29:18 It was something that corresponded
00:29:20 to their pre-COVID
00:29:22 kind of sensibility so you have that on the one hand but on the other hand what you also have
00:29:27 is that because of this global upheaval because of this terrible epidemic we've become conscious
00:29:36 of the fact you know that borders do matter we've become conscious that not just national
00:29:42 borders matter but the border between Lombardy and the rest of Italy is really quite important
00:29:48 And we now are in a situation where all of a sudden we realize that even though we're part of the same human race, nevertheless, there are very differential experiences and different cultural reactions which correspond very much to borders and boundaries.
00:30:08 So it kind of has reinforced perhaps the strength of that.
00:30:13 But nevertheless, the bad news is that what COVID-19 has done
00:30:19 is it's reinforced many of the regressive cultural tendencies
00:30:25 to do with symbolic boundaries.
00:30:27 And the example that I want to bring to your attention,
00:30:30 which occurred after I finished writing the book,
00:30:34 it would happen before I would have written a chapter on it,
00:30:36 is the way in which, in recent weeks, the boundary between the present and the past is being called into question.
00:30:46 Where all of a sudden, thousands of people are trying to fix their problems of the past by going around and toppling statues.
00:30:57 all of a sudden you know people are you know sort of having you know very strong
00:31:02 views about how people behave 250 years ago and it's become very fashionable now
00:31:09 to give little lectures to criticize oh George Washington didn't you know weren't
00:31:14 you aware of the importance of gay marriage and George Washington you know
00:31:20 what was your position on LBGTQT kind of issues it's almost as if we're kind of
00:31:26 in a condescending way reading history backwards and instead of realizing that
00:31:32 you know they've gone that was 200 years ago the past is the past we live in the
00:31:36 present there's a clear boundary between them we kind of very sort of
00:31:41 promiscuously destroying that very important boundaries so we can become
00:31:46 lost in this world where the present and the past almost sort of surreptitiously
00:31:52 intermesh but don't you think that that what has happened over the past month or so you've been
00:32:00 describing that that has arisen out of people being lost anyway i it's not they're trying to
00:32:07 be lost in other words they have no sense of history you must have had these conversations
00:32:12 i certainly have with people who don't quite understand what i mean when i say but you can't
00:32:17 judge someone from 500 years ago what they think about LGBT as you say or
00:32:23 or slavery even actually you can't you can't do that they don't understand what
00:32:28 you mean yeah I mean I think they're lost but it isn't just simply a question
00:32:37 of not understanding it I think that at least a section of the establishment
00:32:44 particularly in the cultural sector is very conscious about the need to
00:32:50 distance sort of our communities and our people from their history to detach
00:32:56 them from the legacy of the past. I think that there is a project that has
00:33:01 been going on for some time where you systematically call into question any
00:33:07 redeeming feature that for example British history could have. So it's
00:33:12 interesting that he kind of you know now regard uh vincent churchill who's probably a the most
00:33:20 significant historical symbol of britishness and you kind of turn him into this petty criminal who
00:33:27 is single-handedly responsible the famine in bengal and who's you know sort of uh is the
00:33:34 most racist individual in the world and you erase his role in terms of mobilizing uh society to
00:33:42 stand up to the you know to the nazis that becomes relatively unimportant and what you're doing in
00:33:47 that sense is you're diminishing britain's heroic episode during second world war you turn that into
00:33:55 a kind of a mundane uh minor historical footnote that's what you do and then you do that with
00:34:01 everything because what you also call into question is you know lincoln you know we used
00:34:06 to think that lincoln was a really good guy you know for abolishing save now we kind of want to
00:34:12 topple down his statue because you know he might have had some kind of uh blemishes on his historical
00:34:18 record so what we're basically doing is creating a year zero notion of history a year zero where
00:34:27 anything that's possibly good begins now and it begins with the toppling of statues and it begins
00:34:35 with you know getting rid of uh labels of aunt jemima of you know food packages and anything that
00:34:43 has preceded before then is like the bad old days not the good old days it's just a bad old
00:34:49 days nothing good about it it's just bad and i think that is more than just being lost that is
00:34:53 an attempt to deprive society of its signposts its historical signposts
00:35:03 how seriously do you take what's been happening
00:35:09 very seriously i think that two things come to mind
00:35:14 as usual the real problem for me is is the reaction to what's happening
00:35:19 and the kind of moral cowardice of the authorities
00:35:22 and the reluctance to basically hold the line.
00:35:29 In fact, you know, there is no line to hold as far as they're concerned
00:35:32 because that boundary, even the boundary that, you know,
00:35:36 sort of exists between the rule of law and the breaking of law
00:35:41 is now open to question and it's quite debatable.
00:35:45 uh and you know when that occurs when you have for example the police in a sense dancing with
00:35:54 demonstrators as they did in extension rebellion or taking the knee as they've done in the more
00:36:01 recent blm demonstrations instead of behaving as police officers they basically uh pretend to be
00:36:09 regular guys you know who have no no special responsibility for the
00:36:14 maintenance of water so you got on the one hand that kind of cowardly response
00:36:18 where you you know at every single study it's probably the best personified by
00:36:24 the bishop archbishop of Canterbury you know just to well be who in a sense you
00:36:31 know casually says well no we're not sure whether Jesus Christ was white in
00:36:37 fact he probably wasn't white because he was born in the Middle East you know so
00:36:41 that's the end of the discussion and then he says oh we're setting up this
00:36:45 review board to decide which statues can be toppled over in our churches you know
00:36:53 which ones we no longer need anymore just like kind of out of the blue so you
00:36:57 have you know I live near Canterbury this beautiful Canterbury
00:37:01 cathedral with it with dozens and dozens of beautiful historical statues and figures uh
00:37:09 they've been there they've been part of the cathedral for centuries they are what makes
00:37:13 the cathedral and if lbs's way well the cathedral is going to look like a bowling alley there'd be
00:37:20 so much space there when all those statues are removed that you can you might as well set up a
00:37:25 bowling alley there because that will have more theological significance and what will be left
00:37:30 after he's done his business interesting you know you say about the boundary between the past and
00:37:36 the present that's broken down and they want to break down uh obviously there's a old the
00:37:42 definition i think of edmund burke came up with of society as being those who were before us those
00:37:48 who are now and those are in the future uh that is the that is the whole uh essence of a society
00:37:54 in a nation um and really in a way that is being obliterated is it because these people like
00:38:02 wellby they're not acting like custodians they're acting as though they have kind of
00:38:07 omnipotence aren't they they their judgment comes first
00:38:11 yes i mean i i think there's a phenomenal degree of uh moral arrogance yeah where you uh basically
00:38:21 look back upon what people did in the past
00:38:24 and you
00:38:26 kind of regard them as these
00:38:28 morally inferior beings
00:38:30 this kind of condescending tone
00:38:32 towards individuals
00:38:34 who made history
00:38:36 in circumstances
00:38:37 that are very different to now
00:38:39 and who were
00:38:41 in every respect
00:38:44 quite naturally products of their time
00:38:46 and instead of
00:38:48 understanding and
00:38:49 you know and and and interpreting those lessons that the past has given us you kind of write them
00:38:57 off there's nothing to learn from there it's simply a relentless series of mistakes and errors
00:39:04 that were committed and and we're now here to fix those problems so instead of engaging with very
00:39:12 real problems the present people like wealthy and others are very busy fixing problems that may have
00:39:19 been thrown up two three hundred years ago and i think that that kind of attitude uh is one where
00:39:24 in a sense it leads to a situation where people uh will become detached from their culture
00:39:30 it will encourage people to be detached from their nation they become detached from their
00:39:35 communities it's almost like we're asking people to start all over again start anew
00:39:41 you know it's zero year zero business finally in fact just on this whole trouble that's been
00:39:48 happening i wonder whether you could comment on this i read very interesting piece in the spectator
00:39:54 recently uh this week in fact which was saying that this isn't quite what it seems what's going
00:39:59 on that in fact this is a reaction by the elites to having been disagreed with in you know the
00:40:07 referendum uh with trump the rise of populism that somehow this is this is not it does feel
00:40:14 different i i i would say that myself it feels different but the insurrection is not about
00:40:19 economics it's it's not about equality it's not about class it's essentially anger at being
00:40:26 disagreed with at the ballot box do you think there's anything in that i think there is something
00:40:33 in that in that uh you know people i mean i'm always surprised how there are people who voted
00:40:42 for remain and they cannot forgive people like me for supporting brexit i would have thought
00:40:47 after a few months you know we go on live we have a pint and we say well it's been done let's let's
00:40:54 move on but no they're they as far as they're concerned this has been a sin that's been committed
00:40:59 and they're very very angry about it and similarly you know people you know fear this kind of
00:41:05 populist movement that has emerged in many, many countries.
00:41:10 They are really worried about the fact that Trump managed to get elected, despite their
00:41:16 confidence that someone like him would never come anywhere near the president.
00:41:20 So obviously they are very angry and sometimes even insecure.
00:41:24 So that is very much part of this scenario.
00:41:28 And it explains why it is that the world has become so, so polarized.
00:41:33 Yeah.
00:41:33 There's also a little bit more than that.
00:41:35 which is, we have to remember that what we're seeing is a new phase of the culture war.
00:41:41 The culture war has been going on for some time now,
00:41:44 where the issues have been debated, you know, sort of and argued.
00:41:49 And unfortunately, despite the success of populism, despite the success of Brexit,
00:41:57 despite the fact that people voted for Trump, the other side is winning the culture war.
00:42:02 and you can see it I mean just take an example that has a lot of people in
00:42:08 America reeling over the American Supreme Court which is meant to have a
00:42:14 conservative majority which is meant to have it's meant to be Trump's court yeah
00:42:19 the way people did this court has decided last week or the week before to
00:42:26 give new employment rights to lb gt qt whatever uh how many members of the alphabet are there kind
00:42:34 of kind of people and in you know and i'm not against people having employment rights but
00:42:39 basically the uh this was a an incredibly important judgment that kind of reinforces
00:42:47 the power and the influence of identity politics the weaponization of identity within the workplace
00:42:53 in America. And if that's happening under Trump, and it's happening under the guidance and the
00:43:03 decision of a so-called conservative Supreme Court, then you can imagine, you know, sort of
00:43:09 what the problem is at the moment. And I think that, you know, we are in a world where in Britain,
00:43:16 very few people, there's very few of us that are prepared to say, I don't support the Black
00:43:22 lives matter movement i'm an anti-racist you know and i've been entries all my life but i think the
00:43:28 politics of blm is wrong you know how many people have you heard stand up and be counted on it
00:43:34 because many people deep inside know that this movement has got a lot of flaws you know there
00:43:40 are a lot of problems with it but people are too scared to open their mouths and and and raise their
00:43:46 voices so you know it is a problem that we face with and and the present moment you know sort of
00:43:53 is one where the the battles the very important battles about the soul of our community is being
00:44:01 fought out and i think that one side is not doing very much you know sort of to fight back on the
00:44:07 on the battlefield it's been an unbelievable unbelievably weak i mean as somebody who was
00:44:12 a marxist when black lives matter is called marxist what is your reaction do you think that
00:44:18 that is a caricature or i mean do you what is what what would you call them i wouldn't call
00:44:25 them marx if you go on their website and they are a movement that has brought together different
00:44:32 elements of identity politics on their website therefore intersectionality they basically say
00:44:39 that the nuclear family is dubious and questionable, therefore trans rights, therefore all these
00:44:46 different identity group rights. And that's really what they've done. They kind of brought that
00:44:50 together, which is at the moment the main medium through which the culture war is being fought by
00:44:59 essentially sort of promoting different identities and trying to destroy the one identity that we
00:45:06 think is important which is the identity of the nation which is the identity of being american or
00:45:12 british or french or whatever that's the one identity that they don't subscribe to but every
00:45:17 single other identity is kind of put into the mix as a way of of imposing a new kind of set
00:45:24 of cultural norms upon our life can i ask you uh while we finish uh you said we're in this stage of
00:45:33 a culture war we're in this particular stage of the cultural uh what do you think the next stage
00:45:40 would be the way things are looking at the moment i think for some time to come uh the the battle
00:45:48 ground the very important battleground will be on how we view and use our legacies you know what kind
00:45:57 of uh value we give to our history what kind of value we give to the institutions that have been
00:46:05 created over the decades how many of those institutions and how many uh aspects of our
00:46:12 legacy can be preserved and hold on to i think that's that's a really important uh sort of
00:46:17 battleground because if we lose uh sort of the history if we lose our past if we forget where
00:46:25 we come from then i think we'll be in a very difficult position so for me this is one of the
00:46:31 most uh important areas that we need to engage with and we've got to use all of our resources
00:46:38 to be able to put up a good fight and not allow the year zero uh cultural entrepreneurs
00:46:47 to win this battle i couldn't agree more uh thank you very very much indeed for that
00:46:54 thank you for joining us today for your time uh the book is why borders matter by frank verani
00:47:01 uh and it's out now uh so please do look it up won't you uh that's all for so what
00:47:08 you're saying is this week um i'll see you next week thank you very very much indeed thank you