New Culture Forum - July 05, 2020


How We Reverse The Left's Long March And Take Back Control Of Britain's Institutions

The Campaign For Common Sense: The Freedom To Comment, Discuss and Debate Without Fear Of Reprisal Borders & Social Boundaries Matter: Why Humanity Must Relearn The Art Of Drawing Boundaries

Episode Stats


Length

41 minutes

Words per minute

168.67

Word count

7,024

Sentence count

205


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to Counterculture. I'm Peter Whittle.
00:00:16 Now, the New Culture Forum has just produced a new book. Here it is,
00:00:21 The Long March, How the Left Won the Culture War and What to Do About It.
00:00:26 It's by Mark Sidwell. That title pretty much sums up the discussion that we're going to be having today, and in particular, the second part, which is what we can do about it.
00:00:37 I'm delighted that we have been joined by the author, Mark Sidwell, who is also Deputy Editor of Smith Magazine, and a great friend of the channel who's been on before, Melanie Phillips, one of our best-known columnists and author of such books as All Must Win Prizes and Londonistan.
00:00:56 and Rafe Hadelman-Ku, historian and commentator from the New Culture Forum.
00:01:03 Thank you very much for joining us today.
00:01:06 Mark, I want to start really by asking you that what you talk about in the book,
00:01:12 what you write about, is what appears to be a very haphazard history
00:01:17 as opposed to, if you like, some plot.
00:01:20 Can you explain?
00:01:21 That's right.
00:01:21 So the Long March is a strategy, a revolutionary strategy, that was formulated in the late 1960s by a German radical called Rudi Deutschka.
00:01:31 It was based on some earlier work in particular by Antonio Gramsci, the Italian communist,
00:01:37 and it was taken up much more widely after that and notably by Herbert Marcuse in America, who was sort of the godfather of the new left.
00:01:44 But essentially what Deutschka said was instead of using violence, which another wing of people that he was associated with in Germany were trying, you could instead try a long and slow and quiet revolution where you took over the institutions of a culture and so gradually changed the whole cultural frame around such that socialism, communism, these sorts of ideas might actually be able to get the traction that otherwise they couldn't.
00:02:10 Melanie, is that sort of a picture you'd agree with?
00:02:13 I mean, do you agree with the concept of the Long March, actually?
00:02:18 Well, I have myself written several books about all this over the last 30 years.
00:02:23 So I certainly do agree with it.
00:02:26 The question is why it happened.
00:02:28 And in my view, it was entirely, as Mark Sidwell suggests,
00:02:35 the people that he mentions were the were some of the key the key people but the interesting
00:02:42 thing to me was that western society fell for it and the question is why and i believe there
00:02:48 were a number of reasons in britain and in europe i believe that there was a profound
00:02:55 cultural demoralization after the second world war which left the elites the cultural elites
00:03:03 the political and intellectual elites vulnerable to a set of ideas which otherwise wouldn't have
00:03:08 been given house room and consequently the way the way was left open for these ideas to be seeded
00:03:17 into the institutions which as mark said well uh has just explained uh was the strategy that you
00:03:24 can overturn a culture and a society you can overturn a society from within by getting into
00:03:30 the institutions of the culture and basically turning their values inside out and upside down
00:03:37 you subvert from within and in britain i believe that was done to the letter and america too
00:03:45 do you do you think the same rave that basically this was although it was intentional it was
00:03:53 almost by not default but also the fact that the as it were the establishment in britain
00:03:59 was, as Melody said, so demoralised,
00:04:02 it actually sort of, they didn't resist.
00:04:04 I mean, that's just as important, isn't it?
00:04:05 That's right.
00:04:06 And in fact, if you speak to KGB operatives,
00:04:09 it should be said, demoralising a society
00:04:11 is one of the ways in which you actually do
00:04:13 engage in revolution by undermining
00:04:15 and subverting the establishment.
00:04:18 So whilst I agree entirely that there wasn't
00:04:20 any great conspiracy, it must be noted, however,
00:04:22 that it was 20 years after the 1968 protests
00:04:26 and uprising on Marxists that we actually saw
00:04:29 the biggest change coming into being, particularly in Britain. It was 1997, after all, that the Blair
00:04:34 administration came in. And one has to actually remember, or even point out, how many members of
00:04:40 that Labour cabinet were actually former communists. Alistair Darling, John Reid, Alan Milburn, Peter
00:04:46 Mandelson, Stephen Byers. These were card-carrying communists. Even Tony Blair admitted after the
00:04:51 fact, with Lord Peter Hennessy, that he had been a Trotsky. So you've got that entire class of
00:04:57 people coming in, not just to politics. Andrew
00:04:59 Ma, George Galloway pointed out, used to
00:05:01 hand out communist pamphlets outside
00:05:03 King's Cross Station. So
00:05:05 whilst there wasn't a great conspiracy, you had
00:05:07 a group
00:05:09 becoming the new establishment who
00:05:11 were basically Gramsciites or
00:05:13 trained very much in these arts.
00:05:16 And I think the Blairite
00:05:17 administration is important to point to. I talk
00:05:19 about quite a lot in my books and I think that
00:05:21 would be surprising to people because we think
00:05:23 about the Blairites as
00:05:24 the opposite of the revolutionary Labour
00:05:27 party and you know going against the unions and and so on and really is very very sort of free
00:05:33 market in one thing or another but but i think in many ways they played a crucial role in
00:05:37 undermining um the history and the traditions that that provided that sort of stability there
00:05:42 was a real year zero quality to tony blair that whole business of of no no statues no history
00:05:49 will take photos of ministers in front of shiny new buildings the the past was a problem that
00:05:54 needed to be dealt with or ignored. Is that something you'd recognise, Melanie? Do you think
00:05:59 we're overstating the importance of Blair or not in this? Well, clearly, the left was instrumental
00:06:07 in doing all this. The left took over the universities in the sense that it became the
00:06:16 kind of default position. I think that much is unarguable. But what's being left out of this
00:06:24 discussion so far is the role played by the conservative movement the small c conservative
00:06:29 and large c conservative party and that's because it didn't play a role the crucial thing was that
00:06:36 the conservative movement over the last half century in my view has progressively forgotten
00:06:42 what it has to conserve and when all this was happening and i don't buy this idea that the
00:06:49 Blair administration was full of communists. I mean, that's just ridiculous. They didn't have
00:06:54 to be communists to do all this. It was a generally accepted progressive worldview,
00:07:00 which came out of the universities going back decades. It was to do with the obliteration of
00:07:08 truth, the substitution of subjectivity and opinion for objectivity. And I believe all that
00:07:15 That came out of what I would call the demoralization out of the Second World War and the Holocaust, this idea that the Holocaust hadn't happened in some benighted part of the world.
00:07:27 It had actually happened in the very epicenter of Western civilization and European culture.
00:07:33 And I believe that that did a terrible thing in that it basically demoralized the West, particularly Europe,
00:07:40 which came to believe that modernity itself had produced this terrible thing.
00:07:46 Britain was demoralized because it came out of the Second World War bankrupt, in hock to America.
00:07:52 It had famously lost an empire, was losing an empire and not finding a role.
00:07:57 And that's why it eventually went into the European Union. It believed that Britain was finished.
00:08:03 Now, along came Mrs. Thatcher in due course and said, up with this I will not put and Britain isn't finished
00:08:08 And we're going to put the mojo back into Britain. Not that she quite expressed it like that.
00:08:13 But anyway, but the fact was that all this time and including Mrs. Thatcher and under Mrs. Thatcher, the conservative movement, Small Sea and Large Sea, didn't realize the cultural revolution that was underway.
00:08:26 And that was because they didn't think in terms of culture. They only thought in terms of economy and politics.
00:08:32 and especially after the Soviet Union fell
00:08:34 and it took a long time for the Soviet Union to fall
00:08:36 I mean ideologically it was falling
00:08:38 a long time before the Berlin Wall
00:08:41 but before the Berlin Wall actually fell
00:08:44 when Soviet communism fell
00:08:48 and I remember these discussions at the time
00:08:50 the conservative movement said to itself
00:08:52 well what do we do now for an encore
00:08:54 we've won
00:08:55 our fox has been shot
00:08:57 the danger is over
00:09:00 what do we do now
00:09:01 in terms of an ideology in terms of an idea that can galvanize us all these decades we've been
00:09:07 fighting uh soviet communism and now it's over what do we do now and the answer was
00:09:12 we hang our hat on liberty and i remember thinking that was a catastrophic error because that brought
00:09:19 them into line with the left and they were unable to see that while the left championed liberty or
00:09:25 i would say libertarianism and the social and cultural sphere and did the kind of damage that
00:09:30 your new book talks about the right was doing the same thing in the economic sphere and they
00:09:37 kind of met in the middle and the conservative party in britain the conservative movement in
00:09:41 the west never understood and still does not understand the depth and profundity of the
00:09:50 cultural evolution that was underway and which we can now see has emerged in all its horror
00:09:55 i think uh you've you've you've mentioned there the horror uh how do you think i mean well you've
00:10:04 alluded to it though many but how do you think the results of the long march are being seen
00:10:10 currently in this particular cultural crisis we're going through at the moment of the past
00:10:17 what basic month six weeks which has gone with extraordinary speed i mean where do you think
00:10:23 the long march features in that is it in the actual response of our institutions for example
00:10:28 well i mean everyone's so amazed that all the you know the toppling of the statues
00:10:35 uh the onslaught on the cultural history of britain and the west and it is a terrible thing
00:10:42 to see but this has been going on for at least three or four decades i reported on this uh in
00:10:50 the 1980s I was writing columns about this and then books about this the idea that education
00:10:57 could no longer be assumed to be what it actually is which is the transmission of a culture down
00:11:05 through the generations because the culture was deemed to be racist, colonialist, white and
00:11:11 exploitative and consequently it couldn't be taught because all those terrible things and
00:11:17 children had to be taught instead that Britain was born in sin, in imperial sin. And that was related
00:11:24 to the whole sort of movement of transnationalism, which held that the Western nation itself was
00:11:32 fundamentally illegitimate. And only transnational institutions and laws, the United Nations,
00:11:39 the European Union, the International Court of Human Rights, and so on and so forth,
00:11:45 you're being called a human rights uh these things had legitimacy which which which trumped
00:11:50 the sovereignty and legitimacy of uh domestic uh legislation um and so this has been the cultural
00:11:58 default for you know for decades and this idea that nobody could gainsay any of these ideologies
00:12:07 there were many other ideologies that came forward multiculturalism transnationalism um all kinds of
00:12:14 isms the idea that no one could gainsay them because they were all about the betterment of
00:12:19 the world this idea that the left has that it stands for virtue and so anybody who opposes it
00:12:24 is not just wrong but evil and must be extirpated that's been going on for decades i mean you know
00:12:32 those of us who've been in the trenches in all this for all this time have found the platforms
00:12:37 on which we are able to stand, diminishing in number almost by the day. This has been going on
00:12:44 for years. Academics who have transgressed the cultural orthodoxy on campus in areas such as
00:12:53 environmentalism or scientism, they have been fired, their job prospects have been removed,
00:13:03 They have become social pariahs. This has been going on for years. And so what we've now seen is the complete collapse of the institutions, the people in authority who faced with literal violence and vandalism on the streets in pursuit of this whole agenda of what I would call cultural totalitarianism.
00:13:28 no other idea is to be permitted they are giving in and giving up and running away
00:13:35 and enabling this to happen that is what is the shock of to me of the last uh few weeks
00:13:42 but the idea that this is something new that you know suddenly we've got a cultural evolution is
00:13:48 ridiculous so i don't know anybody who said that this is a new phenomenon at all i mean it
00:13:53 definitely has been around for decades um and certainly you know churchill once said we shape
00:13:58 our buildings thereafter our buildings shape us and that used to be the case but the problem is
00:14:02 now our institutions have cuckoos in the nest and they have actually absolutely no connection at all
00:14:07 with the culture the environment the values the principles that led to the institutions being
00:14:12 being created in the first place and so i think if anything if we're going to solve this now
00:14:17 we really only have a short space of time because i think the tory party is very complacent now
00:14:23 thinking that it has this 80-seat majority and that it's got the public on side.
00:14:27 Well, we know full well, as Mark's pointed out in his book,
00:14:30 if the general election were held only between those aged 18 to 24,
00:14:34 there would have been over a 400-seat majority for the left.
00:14:37 So really, there has to be something that's done in the next little while on this point.
00:14:42 Yeah, and something I say on the book is that I think it's helpful
00:14:45 if you're trying to work out strategies forward or what to do about this
00:14:48 to stop being complacent and to accept that the Long March has succeeded.
00:14:53 And that was true before recent events, but I think recent events confirmed it.
00:14:56 I talk about the sacking of Roger Scruton by a sort of Twitter mob.
00:15:01 A Conservative Party that could tolerate that and indeed actively make sure that that happened
00:15:05 is no longer in any meaningful sense a Conservative Party.
00:15:08 If they wouldn't stand up for their premier philosopher in public,
00:15:12 then obviously they are not conserving anything meaningful.
00:15:16 So the loss has happened. The Long March has succeeded.
00:15:19 The institutions, importantly, as I argue in the book, are now not very good at doing their jobs because they're hopelessly politicised and they're spending all their time on pushing these agendas rather than being able to police or do any of the things that matter, like educate people.
00:15:34 But you have to accept that and then work out what sort of insurgent strategy you want to try.
00:15:39 But if you're complacent, just think, well, it's all right.
00:15:41 It was just one side or another.
00:15:43 We're still playing this all out.
00:15:44 It's not like that at all.
00:15:45 Before we come to, you know, what actually one can do about it, I would ask, Melanie, particularly, obviously, your book almost had prizes, you know, about the education system.
00:15:56 This is at the nub of it, isn't it?
00:15:58 You said earlier on that schools really should be passing on culture and that's the point of education.
00:16:04 That's entirely gone.
00:16:05 but you know you you were writing your book it was quite some time ago but it was obvious
00:16:10 presumably that by then the left had more or less overtake taken over the cultural educational
00:16:18 establishment in schools I mean yes it was obvious by then to me anyway I wrote that I think that
00:16:26 book was published in uh um 96 i think um and uh it got howled down um and i wrote about the
00:16:36 education system in that book uh almost our prizes and in the context of a moral breakdown
00:16:41 because i i could see that it was a cultural moral breakdown as well it's the whole idea of
00:16:47 the culture and the the values and the principles upon which the west was based uh the attack upon
00:16:53 all that lay behind the attack on the education system. But I wrote
00:16:57 subsequently a book which was published in 2010 called The World
00:17:01 Turned Upside Down, The Global Battle Over God, Truth and Power, in which
00:17:06 I moved it all on very considerably. And I
00:17:09 looked then at what was causing this. It's not enough just to say
00:17:13 the education system is rotten, which it is, or the universities
00:17:18 are rotten, which they are. One has to look at what
00:17:21 what the rot consists of um and um it seemed to me and it still seems to me um that uh what's
00:17:30 happened is that uh the west which is founded basically upon biblical morality and people
00:17:38 don't like to talk about this but it's from the hebrew bible mediated through christianity
00:17:43 that the west gets values which the secular world tells them tells itself it invented
00:17:49 values such as conscience, law, compassion, putting the interests of others above yourself
00:17:58 which is the basis of a civilized society. Now the Long March got rid of all that and replaced
00:18:06 it by man-made ideas called ideologies. Now the point about an ideology is that it does not
00:18:12 admit to any kind of challenge and what we're living through is a kind of millenarian reprise
00:18:18 In the Middle Ages, millenarian Christians believing that the perfection of the world, the end of days, the perfection of the world was on hand, extirpated anybody who stood in their way.
00:18:35 And, you know, our modern ideologies are very much like that.
00:18:39 They're all utopian, so they're all impossible.
00:18:42 When they're shown to be impossible, they move on to other ideologies, which are also utopian and also impossible.
00:18:47 as these things fail they uh take victims they make victims of people who they light upon as
00:18:55 scapegoats and whom they punish and then they turn on each other and all these things we've seen you
00:19:02 know the world saw in the middle ages we are seeing played out now in a man-made ideological
00:19:08 uh framework um and uh so this is what we're grappling with um and you know you talk about
00:19:16 to do. Shortly before he died, Roger Scruton had been brought to despair by all this, and he had
00:19:24 come to the conclusion, and he said in perfect seriousness, that because the universities,
00:19:30 which are supposed to be the crucible, after all, of knowledge, free thinking, the free expression
00:19:39 of ideas without which knowledge and reason cannot survive they have turned into vectors of
00:19:46 unreason and authoritarianism and i would say totalitarianism and they are destroying knowledge
00:19:54 and consequently roger concluded that the only way that we could begin to get ourselves out of this
00:20:01 was to close down the universities by which he meant keep the bits that are good which is basically
00:20:07 the hard stuff, the science, which is based still broadly on objective truths, and get
00:20:15 rid of the humanities, because the humanities have been almost completely captured by ideology
00:20:21 and propaganda. And, you know, if you have young people who are going through this system,
00:20:27 then it's not surprising that they are behaving in the way that they are behaving.
00:20:31 Do you think, Mark, that Scruton's idea, which I remember when he came on the programme, would you agree with that?
00:20:40 I mean, do you think the time has come to disestablish these places?
00:20:43 It's slightly hard to know how you even begin that task, but certainly in the book, as I point out,
00:20:48 Blair's massive expansion of university attendance was a complete cultural disaster
00:20:53 and didn't succeed on any of the social goals that he was nominally trying to achieve as well.
00:20:58 and that's been a huge problem
00:21:00 and that certainly needs to be reversed
00:21:01 but where's the political will
00:21:04 for something on that scale?
00:21:06 But certainly a defunding of the humanities
00:21:08 is the way to go
00:21:09 unfortunately the government funding doesn't account
00:21:12 for all of the funding that the humanities
00:21:14 receives but I've said so many
00:21:16 times on this programme over the
00:21:18 months that you've gone from
00:21:20 a situation where you had a two to one balance
00:21:22 for two liberals for every one conservative
00:21:24 in the academy
00:21:26 to one now where it's eight or nine to one and that's happened really over the
00:21:30 space of 20 years. I spent eight years at university, five was in the
00:21:34 humanities, three was in law and I've seen that process take place and you
00:21:39 know but you're perfectly right you know when you have over 50% of students now
00:21:43 of young people going to university this is the exact forum where
00:21:48 change needs to happen if we're going to see any attempt to reverse the march
00:21:51 through institutions but it's not just the universities where I should say also
00:21:55 Also, the few conservatives that there are at universities are in the STEM areas because they actually have to test theories with analysis and data.
00:22:05 But actually, it's the entire concept of educating people from the age, you know, give me a boy when he's seven and I will show you the man.
00:22:12 And if you speak again to people who understand these things, they will tell you that basically it takes 20 years to have a cultural revolution in terms of creating a system whereby you have a child going up through the entire education system,
00:22:24 taken to believe the new values that are being brought in
00:22:27 because this really is a post-modernist revolution
00:22:30 this is something about Jacques Derrida and his entourage
00:22:33 who basically said that there are no truths
00:22:35 there's an infinite number of explanations and interpretations that you can have
00:22:39 and so any society that has no truths
00:22:41 has to replace it with a nihilistic world
00:22:47 and that's what we have now
00:22:48 and so there has to be some means by which you can actually
00:22:51 take into check teacher training colleges the primary school system the secondary school system
00:22:57 where fewer than 10 percent of teachers actually vote Tory there has to be some overhaul and how
00:23:02 that can be done who knows but really it takes someone I think like Dominic Cummings and Michael
00:23:07 Gove as really the only people I can think of right now who are in a position to influence
00:23:11 government policy in a way with the sense of any chance of happening if it's to happen at all and
00:23:16 it's quite, talk about a mountain. Do you think, Melanie, do you have any sort of faith at all in
00:23:23 say the, what you might call the conventional political leadership? Rave just mentioned
00:23:28 Dominic Cummings and Michael Gove. I mean, do you, what's your reaction when you hear those names?
00:23:35 I laugh. I'm afraid I don't think that any of them has the will to take on any of this. I mean,
00:23:44 Boris, you know, from all we know of him, is a natural libertarian.
00:23:48 Now, you know, it is said he's been changed by his illness.
00:23:54 So he's become more of a kind of, you know, he's become an aficionado of the big society in a way that he wasn't previously.
00:24:04 Well, that may or may not be true.
00:24:05 But all this sort of the deeper cultural stuff, he's not going to want to go near.
00:24:11 And you can see they are running away from it.
00:24:13 having said that um i mean well michael gove made a you know a big speech uh at ditchley uh a few
00:24:20 days ago and in you know it was a very impressive speech everything michael does is very impressive
00:24:25 it's it's very intelligent and it's very thoughtful and it's backed up by a great deal of knowledge
00:24:30 um very well crafted and he made some you know very useful and important points but he avoided
00:24:36 at all of this yes he was he was making the point you know how did we lose britain how do we how do
00:24:44 we get the how do we not see what happened in the brexit vote how have we lost the faith of all those
00:24:52 people now all those people aren't sitting around you know in the famous red wall seats they're not
00:24:57 sitting around saying you know what that derrida has got a lot to answer for they're not doing that
00:25:02 They're not saying it's all postmodern. It's beyond, you know, it's ideology that people don't think like that, but they are reacting against the society which has been formed by these ideas.
00:25:13 they're reacting against it because they know it's wrong they want their country back they want to be
00:25:19 able to belong to a culture that they recognize that they identify with that they know was built
00:25:26 upon hundreds of years of history for which their ancestors fought and died for the liberties that
00:25:33 were given all these things they know almost instinctively and they're reacting against
00:25:39 the attempt, which has been wildly successful until that Brexit vote, to put all this into
00:25:47 reverse. Now, the political class just won't go anywhere near this. They perceive that the world
00:25:55 has changed. They think they can't be like Cnut and, you know, stand in front of the waves of
00:26:02 progress and hold them back. They think they can't turn back the clock. They think it's to put,
00:26:07 to turn back the clock they think that in order to restore a kind of cultural order is to put back
00:26:14 the clock and unfortunately they are therefore hell-bent on continuing down this uh path has
00:26:21 been said of nihilism um which they don't recognize that they don't even think they don't allow
00:26:28 themselves to think in these terms uh because they say what can we do it's all too big you know it's
00:26:33 it's the church the church is you know responsible well to a large extent that is true but i do very
00:26:40 much believe that culture very much is a top-down thing and that um cultural leadership is absolutely
00:26:47 crucial and if you had a prime minister and very senior minister if you have a prime minister who
00:26:55 articulated what i've just been saying and kept on and on about it and also said you know up with
00:27:01 this we will not put we are no longer going to fund these ridiculous courses they are ridiculous
00:27:06 for these reasons they are telling lies these are the lies they are telling this is propaganda
00:27:13 it's not true what they say then you would find that they you know i believe the whole atmosphere
00:27:20 would change almost overnight not that would win the war but it would be a start and without that
00:27:26 we can't proceed properly
00:27:28 yes but I mean I agree entirely
00:27:30 I think we're all on the same page with regards to that
00:27:32 but I think that the Tory party is
00:27:34 aware or at least there are figures
00:27:36 there and I will again say I think
00:27:38 single upcomings particularly on this point
00:27:40 because this is the man who understands
00:27:42 that there's been the inversion that's taken place
00:27:44 in the support base for the Labour party
00:27:46 and for the Tory party and it's now the low income
00:27:48 people in the north etc who want
00:27:50 cultural security who are
00:27:52 on side with the Conservative party
00:27:54 and of course we've always known Boris Johnson
00:27:56 and was a token right-winger on cultural values
00:28:00 and those sorts of issues.
00:28:02 But yet it has to be the case, surely,
00:28:04 that they know that there's an existential crisis
00:28:05 facing the Tory party
00:28:06 if they don't use the next 10 years wisely
00:28:09 for the very reason that I pointed out earlier.
00:28:11 Those under 30 are not voting Tory
00:28:13 and the Tory party will be facing oblivion
00:28:16 if it doesn't take into account this fact
00:28:18 and try its best to change that.
00:28:20 And having hemorrhaged so much support now
00:28:23 over its handling of Covid and coronavirus,
00:28:24 it actually is, I think, cultural issues, a strong stance on these things
00:28:29 which will give it a chance to actually reconnect with that Redwall base
00:28:32 and shore up its support for the future.
00:28:34 Well, I'm sure that's true, though, but who's going to stand up and do it?
00:28:37 And I think Melanie's right on this.
00:28:39 Culture can come from politics as well.
00:28:42 In fact, in some ways, Margaret Thatcher understood that as well,
00:28:44 although she didn't always fight it so much on the cultural front,
00:28:48 but she could be very strong.
00:28:49 And Boris does have an opportunity, but he's not taking it in the way that, say, Macron did in France a little bit.
00:28:59 I think it's interesting, actually, when you talk about the cultural onslaught that we've had over the past 40, 50, 50, 60 years now,
00:29:10 quite often people, they sense it, they know it, they feel got at, they feel undermined, but it's often very incoherent.
00:29:18 they don't quite know how to protest but but then along comes an issue what might seem like a small
00:29:25 one which is the moment is the toppling of statues for example that seems to crystallize it for them
00:29:32 i think it seems to it crystallizes it for them actually i think wait a minute this is wrong i
00:29:38 feel personally affronted by this that's right i'm and it was very you know you can't get more
00:29:45 more physical uh material manifestation of the destruction of a culture than the toppling of
00:29:50 every statue uh matters uh and you know you can see it goes from you know people who okay they had
00:29:57 you know view you know they they were slavers uh and then it progresses uh to the point where
00:30:03 they are taking down statues of people who were anti-slavers and reformers um so uh yes um i think
00:30:11 that um it's uh uh it you know it's it's a very uh vivid illustration when we talk about you know
00:30:20 we have already touched on what what one could possibly do are we sort of agreed that basically
00:30:25 maybe we should get rid of humanities departments i mean is that what would you say mark well you
00:30:32 know i mean the humanities in its true form is is at the heart of true education and western
00:30:37 culture. I have a book on liberal education in the Greek sense, which is enormously important.
00:30:44 The tragedy of all of this is the left going into institutions that really matter, like
00:30:49 the police, like the schools, like the universities and the humanities departments, gutting them,
00:30:53 putting on the skin suit of them, and then saying, look at me, you need to bow down and
00:30:58 worship this thing that used to be a good institution. And that's the horror of it.
00:31:03 And one good thing about Michael Gove's speech,
00:31:06 which I agree, of course, was dancing around the issues,
00:31:08 was that he was trying to use competence
00:31:10 as a way of dealing with the takeover of these institutions.
00:31:15 If they became practically wise again,
00:31:18 able to get things done and see whether what they did actually worked
00:31:22 and what the consequences were,
00:31:23 that is actually one way of cracking down on politicisation.
00:31:27 But not enough.
00:31:28 But isn't it, sorry, isn't it the point of,
00:31:31 I agree with something Melanie said there,
00:31:33 You do feel that if just people did talk, you know, as a good leader should talk, just talk about these things and say I'm outraged and we will not put up with this or whatever it is, this is a great country, all of these, that somehow people would feel reassured and less, well, as they are now, I think, rather frightened and angry.
00:31:54 Do you see any chance that people will actually start to, you know, well, change our political culture and actually start talking about these things?
00:32:02 Well, conversations are being had, but unfortunately not in the mainstream media.
00:32:06 You have to come onto platforms like this,
00:32:08 and you can't have those conversations on all of social media
00:32:11 because you'll be suspended and banned,
00:32:12 as we've seen yesterday with Graham Linehan,
00:32:14 banned from Twitter for having said, you know, men aren't women, though.
00:32:18 I mean, that is the extent to which we're living in this Kikogadian,
00:32:22 post-revolutionary world of ours.
00:32:25 The problem with getting rid of institutions like the humanities, of course,
00:32:28 is that there'll be nowhere left to teach history.
00:32:29 I mean, we have to actually provide people with a standard of education
00:32:34 where actually they recognise and appreciate Western civilisation and culture for what it is.
00:32:38 Because basically what we're seeing is an onslaught against Western civilisation,
00:32:43 against the individual and the logos.
00:32:46 I mean, Melanie is quite right.
00:32:48 This is akin to a millenarian movement here with the flagellants now being virtue signalling.
00:32:53 There's a direct connection there.
00:32:55 So in my view, one of the solutions to this, and I've said this for a while,
00:32:58 would be to actually try to set up private educational institutions,
00:33:02 such as A.C. Grayling was able to do it on his side,
00:33:05 but as you see in America, there are very effective colleges present,
00:33:09 and if we can somehow create universities that teach the classics,
00:33:12 that teach history and the greatness of Western civilisation
00:33:15 and cultural values without this blatant bias,
00:33:18 that would be one solution,
00:33:19 because I can't see that simply getting rid of the humanities
00:33:22 is a solution when you're going to have a population
00:33:24 who have no context at all in which to put the buildings
00:33:27 and the statues around which they walk
00:33:29 every day. Although I would
00:33:31 say possibly that one of the reasons we've
00:33:33 got this problem at the moment is because they have
00:33:35 absolutely no context anyway.
00:33:37 They've not been taught it.
00:33:39 Mark, you mention in the book about being
00:33:41 a dissident.
00:33:43 I don't know. First of all, do you feel like
00:33:45 a dissident and how should a dissident live
00:33:47 in that case?
00:33:49 Well, I talk about in the book how being
00:33:51 a dissident is a very unpleasant life.
00:33:54 One shouldn't think
00:33:55 I talk about the examples in
00:33:57 communism in Eastern Europe and so on. You shouldn't think being a dissident is going to
00:34:01 necessarily change a regime. You shouldn't expect it to accept that you have a different view and
00:34:07 not treat you very badly. The story of dissidents is of people who did something that they felt that
00:34:13 their conscience didn't allow them not to do. But there are high costs that come with that,
00:34:17 and most people don't want to do it. And even if you do do it, the fact you then get shouted down
00:34:22 and banned and lose your job is very effective at silencing other people.
00:34:27 So it doesn't necessarily help.
00:34:28 It may even help the regime in crushing public opinion.
00:34:33 So unfortunately, the choice for most people, as you see, is silence
00:34:38 and some form of sort of collaboration with what goes on.
00:34:42 Even though people know in their own consciences that there's nonsense being talked,
00:34:47 they don't feel that they can say it.
00:34:48 They don't feel safe saying it, which makes the problem worse and worse.
00:34:52 And that's why, you know, things like bankrupt communist regimes could go on for many decades when, you know, they should by all rights have fallen.
00:35:00 And it's very hard to find ways through this.
00:35:03 It's partly about simply creating the possibility of public speech, public acknowledgement of the reality.
00:35:10 And then that can cascade and then people can feel that they too can speak up.
00:35:15 That can change a culture very fast.
00:35:17 And we've seen that to a degree with Gavin Williamson stating that universities have their last chance now to protect free speech.
00:35:23 You know, whether that's going to be enforced is another question altogether.
00:35:26 But it actually is, and one way in which you can start this rolling is to have a commitment to free speech,
00:35:32 to actually have an assertive policy on behalf of the government whereby you actually ensure that there is academic freedom
00:35:38 and you don't have cases of people losing their position or not being hired in the first place for holding contrary views to the mainstream.
00:35:44 and also an acknowledgement that you have now a vocal minority
00:35:48 who are basically in positions of power
00:35:52 where we have a situation where we have the Eloy and the Moorlock really
00:35:55 where you have this elite ruling who aren't reflective of the population
00:35:59 and so I think really there will be a time for us to actually try to infuse
00:36:03 the grassroots with some sort of, with some of the fire
00:36:06 that we want to see amongst our younger population.
00:36:09 Melanie, you know, do you feel like a dissident actually?
00:36:13 I mean, in our culture. Do you feel like a dissident?
00:36:17 I wouldn't use the word about myself, dissident, because I associate that with the heroes who fought behind the tyrannies of the Soviet Union.
00:36:30 And, you know, I think I should be quite careful about not suggesting that we are in that kind of situation.
00:36:36 We are still a free society. We're still a democracy. We still have a raucous public sphere.
00:36:42 The fact is that within that raucous public sphere, there have been significant encroachments in the last several decades, I would say, on people's ability to say things which are contrary to the orthodoxies.
00:37:01 Now, have I felt that personally? Absolutely, I have felt that personally.
00:37:04 um uh i i wrote a little memoir called guardian angel uh which was published in paperback a
00:37:11 couple of years ago uh which detailed precisely what happened to me when i started saying all
00:37:16 this when i was still considered to be part of the left when i was working for the guardian back in
00:37:22 the 1980s and subsequently um uh you know you can look at uh the books that i've had published
00:37:31 um with the exception of londonistan which was a book about britain um and which was not until
00:37:39 about one month before it was published in america was not going to be published in britain
00:37:44 um it was published in britain by the skin of its teeth a small publishing house literally
00:37:49 publishing out of someone's front room came and published it other than that over the last 20
00:37:54 years or so my books have been published in america um uh so you know um and and i'm fortunate
00:38:02 i have a you know i'm i'm still employed uh uh in uh national newspapers um but my goodness me
00:38:10 it becomes ever more difficult to hang on uh when uh the you know when the the entire uh cultural
00:38:19 intelligentsia world is trying to stop people who contradict these orthodoxes from having any
00:38:28 platform at all. I mean, for example, not just in Britain, but also in America, I do quite a lot of
00:38:34 public speaking in America, but it's been a great source of frustration to me over the last 10-20
00:38:41 years that the people that I speak to in America are people who broadly are on my side, broadly,
00:38:47 because the people who are on the other side, the left, will not have the discussion.
00:38:56 You see, you can't even open up the discussion.
00:38:59 They won't have the discussion.
00:39:01 They replace discussion and debate by insult, character assassination,
00:39:06 and other terrible manoeuvres to silence you.
00:39:10 Now, in my view, people who do that do that for one reason only.
00:39:14 they are too frightened to have the debate because they know their position is built on sand
00:39:20 which makes it even more frustrating that one can't actually have the discussion so to that
00:39:26 extent I mean I have felt very you know very uh very much at the sharp end of all this and but
00:39:33 there's a whole number of us who have felt like this for some time and as I say I wouldn't like
00:39:37 to exaggerate it because you know especially now there is the internet there are now many more
00:39:42 avenues uh open to all of us uh we can all self-publish uh you know uh we can i can you
00:39:49 know put a camera in front of myself and go online um that's all available to us nevertheless
00:39:56 um uh given what's out there um and given the um still the uh the the the kudos the the credibility
00:40:08 the public credibility that comes from being published or hosted on mainstream media platforms
00:40:15 these are still I think small pickings I know there are some people who have you know made
00:40:21 stellar reputations out of being dissidents on the net but they are very I think they are few
00:40:28 and far between most of us don't have that good fortune. I think the internet is incredibly
00:40:38 be important. As for those
00:40:40 platforms you talk about there
00:40:42 and how it's becoming more difficult for
00:40:44 people who go against the orthodoxies
00:40:46 possibly those platforms
00:40:48 themselves are now
00:40:50 losing reputation and losing
00:40:52 traction. I mean I'm thinking of the mainstream
00:40:54 the BBC and whatever
00:40:56 but look we'd have to
00:40:58 end it there. The book again is called
00:41:00 The Long March How the Left
00:41:02 Won the Cultural War and What to Do About It
00:41:04 by Mark Sidwell. Melanie
00:41:06 thank you very much for joining us today uh thank you mark as well thank you rave and uh we shall
00:41:13 see you next time of course when it comes to the book um please do go on our website and contact
00:41:19 us and we can happily send you a copy but also it is downloadable for free um so however you
00:41:26 want to read it thanks very much thank you bye
00:41:36 You