New Culture Forum - July 03, 2020


The Campaign For Common Sense: The Freedom To Comment, Discuss and Debate Without Fear Of Reprisal

Peter Whittle: We Are Proud Of Our Great Country's History How We Reverse The Left's Long March And Take Back Control Of Britain's Institutions

Episode Stats


Length

23 minutes

Words per minute

198.6

Word count

4,681

Sentence count

—


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 hello and welcome to so what you're saying is I'm Peter Whittle now a recent poll showed that 78%
00:00:28 of people now feel that they have to walk on eggshells when they're discussing certain
00:00:33 issues. That poll was part of the launch of a new campaign called the Campaign for Common
00:00:40 Sense. I'm delighted that I'm joined today by the founder and director of it, Mark Lehane.
00:00:46 Hi, Peter. Thanks for having me in. Campaign for Common Sense, why?
00:00:50 I suppose it comes from a feeling I've had growing over the last few years, where my
00:00:56 background is education. I'm a third generation teacher. Teaching's in my blood and I've worked
00:01:01 with young people on and off for sort of 17 years or so. But I've had a growing feeling that across
00:01:07 a whole range of issues, it didn't matter how good we made our schools, because I've been really
00:01:12 lucky to be involved in school improvement and school reform for over a decade, it doesn't matter
00:01:17 how good we make our schools, too many young people are going off to university or into the
00:01:21 world of work and suddenly finding all that freedom of thought and knowledge that we've
00:01:26 encourage them to amass they can't use because there's an expectation they think a certain way
00:01:31 they speak a certain way and i just think it's reached a point where it's not actually bringing
00:01:35 people together the kind of political correctness if you want to call it it's actually forcing people
00:01:40 apart and i was sort of moaning to someone about it over coffee and they said to me well what are
00:01:45 you going to do about it and um and here i am i kind of felt moved to do something well how do
00:01:50 people get involved with it i mean what what actually will how will it operate can you just
00:01:54 this is a campaign so so so what do you do what will you do so really what we
00:01:59 want to be is try and bear sort of a sensible grown-up voice in the debates
00:02:03 around lots of these sensitive tricky issues so it could be around the stuff
00:02:08 we're seeing in the news at the moment about historical statues identity
00:02:12 politics stuff around the transgender rights thing or more general sort of
00:02:17 political correctness in the workplace or in the culture and media and what we
00:02:21 want to try and do is rather than just wade in with an opinion we want to do research we want
00:02:26 to poll people to find out what the public genuinely think we might want to go and do some
00:02:30 focus groups or hold some events so we can talk to real people across the country and then use
00:02:36 what we learn from those people to inform our contribution to the debate because I think one
00:02:40 of the things we often have is activists on both sides of issues try and convince everyone else
00:02:46 that they're the only people that are right and then the other side are nasty and actually our
00:02:50 approach is going to be there's probably a lot of common ground on all of these issues and when we
00:02:54 disagree we can disagree nicely so in terms of how people can get involved we're encouraging
00:02:58 people to go to our website read our launch report subscribe to our email updates on what
00:03:03 we're doing the website is campaigncommonsense.com right if they go along there it's very easy they
00:03:08 just put their email address in we'll keep them up to date and we're going to build things from
00:03:12 there will you sort of have meetings and things you know or events things like that yes that's
00:03:17 right and so obviously we'll do the usual kind of stuff in the world of Westminster and in London
00:03:22 because there's a lot of stuff going on there but most importantly we do want to be doing events
00:03:26 around the country we want to take this to the real world and you know not just the London bubble
00:03:30 yeah good I think something like 84% of people in your poll thought that there should be more
00:03:40 common sense abroad in in in Britain what actually would you how would you
00:03:46 define common sense that's what is it what is it to you that's a really good
00:03:51 question to ask and lots of people have asked us what do you mean by common
00:03:54 sense and particularly people have asked us that if they're very skeptical about
00:03:57 what we're trying to do but for us when we're talking about common sense we
00:04:00 really mean some of those widely held truths that the general public or the
00:04:06 vast majority of people would hold to be the case yeah that's not so it's an
00:04:09 eternal truth indeed one of our sort of founding statements is that we don't
00:04:13 believe anyone has a monopoly on right or wrong necessarily but for us by
00:04:17 common sense what we mean is those overwhelmingly those overwhelming
00:04:20 understandings that the vast majority of people hold to be true they might
00:04:23 evolve over time but they're most things they're things that most people can
00:04:27 identify with and our concern is that with the rise of sort of what some
00:04:31 people would call political correctness this common sense has kind of been
00:04:35 pushed to the edges when making policy or decisions and it's been replaced
00:04:39 by specific interests for minority activists people with a very passionate strongly held belief
00:04:45 but they're not views or beliefs that are held by the majority of people and they've replaced the
00:04:49 sort of common sense widely held truths that the majority hold you you you mentioned actually as
00:04:54 well the in the survey that in fact you know there's these various numbers large numbers of
00:05:00 people who just want politicians to be concerned with public sort of services and things like that
00:05:07 isn't that right, as opposed to minority interests, is that right?
00:05:12 Yeah, so we've been through a really interesting, or we're still going through a really interesting
00:05:17 time, aren't we, with coronavirus, and we did a poll with over 2,000 people just a few
00:05:23 weeks ago about what the impact of coronavirus was on, what they thought government should
00:05:28 focus on, and just under 80% of people felt that because of the crisis we're going through,
00:05:34 government should now prioritise common-sense approaches to things rather
00:05:38 than and public and public services rather than political correctness so as
00:05:43 someone said to me you know maybe if the government spent more time focusing on
00:05:47 pandemic preparation than policing Twitter or telling people what pronouns
00:05:52 they should use we might have been in a better position when coronavirus reared
00:05:56 its ugly head earlier on this year yes yes it's also isn't it the case that
00:06:02 quite a few people expressed opinions about, to be completely up to date, the issue of statues and
00:06:10 things. You actually had this in your report, didn't you, but long before this issue actually
00:06:14 has come up in the way that it has now. Yeah, so when we were doing our polling to try and
00:06:19 understand where public opinion was and what issues were particularly pertinent, we did ask
00:06:24 people stuff around historical statues. It wasn't a big issue in the UK at the time, it's been a
00:06:29 much bigger issue in the United States for a while but we did ask people about that and
00:06:33 interestingly enough when we asked people what should you do as controversial statues
00:06:36 just over 60% of people felt we should preserve them leave them where they are and learn from
00:06:41 them rather than remove them now we put that in our launch reports it's an interesting topic we
00:06:47 didn't think it would be so hot button and literally in the last week or so we've really
00:06:51 seen it rise up and again I saw a poll earlier on this week done by YouGov about the statue that
00:06:56 was pulled down in the docks in Bristol and they found that only 13% of people thought that pulling
00:07:03 it down was the right thing to do. There was a small majority of people that thought it should
00:07:07 have been removed but through legitimate means but only a tiny proportion of people felt that
00:07:12 was the right way to go about it and again think about that there'd been a really well organised
00:07:17 movement in Bristol in recent years to try and remove that particular statue through legitimate
00:07:22 means and when that mob went down to the docks and pulled that statue down and
00:07:27 stuck it in the water they made a mockery of the hard work and the legitimate
00:07:32 moves that all those people have done over years and it's just really not
00:07:35 fair it really this kind of thing really upsets the broader public because it
00:07:40 cuts across that very strong sense we have in this country of fair play yeah
00:07:44 I mean fair play but also presumably as well you know many of the people who
00:07:47 respond to your your survey would feel very angry generally about what's
00:07:54 happening you know in terms of you know cultural criticism increasing sort of
00:08:00 like would appear to be attacks on you know street names yeah all of these
00:08:06 things I would have thought that that would have been a very mainstream feeling
00:08:08 well it is again when we did our polling we found that round about four in five
00:08:12 people felt that there was a blame culture in this country that was making
00:08:16 certain issues worse and four and five felt they had to walk on eggshells
00:08:20 around certain issues they wanted to engage in issues they wanted to
00:08:23 understand what people that held different views than them thought but
00:08:28 they were really nervous if they tried to wade into those discussions they
00:08:31 might use the wrong terminology or be perceived to say the wrong thing and
00:08:35 then they'd be called out by a mob and actually two-thirds of people told us
00:08:40 that they felt the political correctness was actually making things worse you
00:08:43 political correctness start off as a really good thing it was about how could we be kinder to one
00:08:47 another could we think a little bit more about how we interact with one another and the words
00:08:52 we use to be more sensitive and over time sadly it's been politicized and it's grown into a
00:08:58 movement that's trying to tell people not just what to say but what to think and people can tell
00:09:04 what's going on people aren't happy about that they're finding it repressive and it's really
00:09:08 important that i point out here this is not like a white middle-aged right-wing bloke thing we could
00:09:14 see from our polling that there was a majority support for the kind of concerns that we were
00:09:20 examining from people all across the country from all across the political spectrum and all age
00:09:25 groups so this can't be pinned down to like a you know a gammon type issue these are mainstream
00:09:31 views held by the majority of people the challenge is why aren't more of our political leaders and
00:09:37 and our cultural leaders stepping up to the mark
00:09:39 and addressing it.
00:09:40 Why do you think that is?
00:09:42 So I think part of it is a concern,
00:09:45 a fear of being called out by the activists.
00:09:48 I think there is a fear of the mob
00:09:50 and I completely understand that fear.
00:09:53 I mean, one of the things that I suppose radicalised me
00:09:56 to think about these issues,
00:09:59 bearing in mind education is my background,
00:10:01 was to see what happened just over a year ago
00:10:03 to Sir Roger Scruton.
00:10:04 so people watching this
00:10:07 won't necessarily know
00:10:08 but Roger was involved in
00:10:09 my previous organisation
00:10:11 Parents and Teachers for Excellence
00:10:12 we were an education campaign group
00:10:14 he was a really wise guy
00:10:16 a really great source of advice and wisdom
00:10:18 we had him on the show actually last year
00:10:20 yeah what a lovely guy
00:10:21 and then to see him dragged through that
00:10:23 when he was trying to do a good thing
00:10:25 to see the way the then government
00:10:27 treated him
00:10:28 and then for it to all happen
00:10:30 just before he felt very very ill
00:10:32 that was appalling
00:10:33 we shouldn't let stuff like that happen
00:10:35 and for me
00:10:36 one of the things we're at risk of forgetting
00:10:39 in these sorts of debates
00:10:41 is that just because
00:10:43 even if Roger had held the views
00:10:45 that were ascribed to him
00:10:46 even though he didn't
00:10:47 even if he had
00:10:48 we mustn't forget the fact
00:10:50 that there are loads of people in this country
00:10:52 that share views that
00:10:53 maybe a few years ago were okay
00:10:55 but are not in our mainstream
00:10:57 and we wouldn't necessarily advocate those views now
00:11:00 but we can't just write them off
00:11:01 we can't write off previous generations we can't write off people from particular backgrounds
00:11:06 because there's more to life than just the views people hold there's things like friendship
00:11:11 and love and common interest with colleagues and so on and so forth and i think if we bring
00:11:16 everything down to politics and whether or not people hold the right kind of views in the end
00:11:21 we're all going to fall out none of us will focus on what we've got in common and that is not a way
00:11:26 to have a happy fulfilled society i mean how do you think broadly how do you think we ended up in
00:11:32 this position i mean where basically people feel what used to be called if you like the silent
00:11:38 majority feel you know that basically they can't really say what they think or all the things that
00:11:44 are in your survey how do we end up at that situation so i think part of it is just that
00:11:50 um all of these really well-meaning initiatives to try and make life more sensitive and inclusive
00:11:55 lots of them have ended up being counterproductive
00:11:58 and they've been subverted
00:12:00 and they've ended up pushing people apart
00:12:01 so absolutely we should try and watch
00:12:04 what we're saying when we're debating ideas
00:12:06 with people to try and be more sensitive
00:12:07 that's now potentially in a lot of areas
00:12:10 slipped over into policing
00:12:11 exactly what people can and can't say
00:12:13 but on a more practical level
00:12:15 I think the reason why this movement
00:12:17 has been able to get where it is
00:12:18 in terms of the slightly authoritarian
00:12:21 wokeness to call it what you like
00:12:24 I think it's because most people are getting on with their day jobs.
00:12:27 They're earning a living.
00:12:28 They want to keep a roof over their family's heads
00:12:30 and provide for their friends and family.
00:12:32 They're too busy getting on with the real world
00:12:34 to look at what's been going on in some important cultural institutions,
00:12:38 be it our universities, our legal system, the political system,
00:12:42 and stuff like that.
00:12:44 And so what it's meant is that decisions in those places
00:12:47 have increasingly over time been made not to reflect and support
00:12:52 and underpin broader common society but actually to to reflect the interests of those activists
00:13:00 that have been involved in those institutions so minority activists have been able to push their
00:13:04 views and then it's been easier for those institutions to over time gradually accommodate
00:13:09 those views and then hold those views themselves whilst the rest of us are getting on a bad day job
00:13:14 I don't think it's been done deliberately it's just how values change through society and let's
00:13:20 not forget lots of really good stuff has come over the years as societies have progressed
00:13:26 and we've adopted hopefully more enlightened values and that's only happened because really
00:13:31 inspiring people have started off pushing ideas that were initially minority views and have now
00:13:36 become mainstream accepted views so it's not in and of itself a bad thing but it's just I think
00:13:41 some bad ideas have taken over in recent times you were a teacher as you've mentioned you know
00:13:46 what has your experience been in the teaching?
00:13:50 You mentioned universities there, but in schools.
00:13:52 I think this is a flashpoint for many people.
00:13:56 Have you found that there is a kind of groupthink mentality in schools?
00:14:02 I mean, if you are not of a certain point of view,
00:14:06 maybe, say, take soft left or hard left, I guess, even,
00:14:09 if you're more conservative, are you beleaguered?
00:14:14 so there's there's no doubt um that the teaching profession in this country is generally of a sort
00:14:22 of centre-left orientation and the overwhelming majority of people in there um hold the kind of
00:14:30 views you would you would ascribe to that now i don't personally as a sort of centre-right i guess
00:14:34 i identify with the conservative party and i'm small c conservative generally in my values i don't
00:14:40 have a problem with that per se because actually when you get into a classroom and you're working
00:14:44 with kids overwhelmingly your personal politics and philosophy don't don't come into it yeah but
00:14:49 where it is starting to creep in is and probably has done for a long time but it's become more
00:14:55 visible in recent years is around the pastoral uh support that we're giving pupils right and um and
00:15:02 in some subject areas it's starting to creep in where various teachers and teacher training
00:15:06 institutions and other educators are pushing for for instance the what they call the decolonization
00:15:11 of the curriculum they want what we teach the children to not be sort of you know our island
00:15:16 story and teaching kids um the common history that we have as citizens of the united kingdom now
00:15:23 but to teach kids a particular version of that and in particular version that the sort of radical
00:15:28 left would identify more with so um you know all kids going through the corner will examine
00:15:32 the british empire and the history of the british empire and indeed you know a lot of the damage
00:15:37 that the british empire did and lots of the terrible things that were done in its name as
00:15:40 well as the the upsides but there's been a greater movement in recent years again by a small minority
00:15:46 of teachers to make that even more radical but around the pastoral side of things you'll probably
00:15:51 remember last year last summer there were some protests outside some schools in Birmingham
00:15:57 about the kind of sex education that schools were rolling out and there was some concern by some
00:16:02 parents in the community about the kind of sex that was being taught I have to say I was with
00:16:08 the school on that in terms of how they were going about that but what I did find concerning
00:16:12 was the general tone with which the teaching profession spoke about the community in question
00:16:18 it was quite dismissive it was quite anti the concerns those parents held and I think we we
00:16:24 have to remember as public servants we're there to serve our communities and we have to bear their
00:16:28 concerns in mind not dismiss them so what we're starting to see in schools around for instance
00:16:32 the trans the transgender kid issue and working with children that maybe think they identify to
00:16:39 a different sex than one they're born to i think those kind of things are starting to bubble up in
00:16:42 schools now um like as part of the wider culture wars and i think we need to be really mindful
00:16:48 about how we go about dealing with that because if we're not careful the kind of angry debates
00:16:52 that we've seen in broader society will end up in our schools and i don't think that will do anyone
00:16:56 any good oh no i mean we've seen just uh quite recently uh jk rowling you know getting monstered
00:17:03 basically by actually her her former stars of her you know of the movies harry potter movies and
00:17:09 actually there was a school yesterday it was on the bbc news site i saw there was a school in sussex
00:17:14 that wrote out to all of its families yesterday to announce that one of the school houses that
00:17:19 was going to be named after jk rowling yes would no longer be named after jk rowling because the
00:17:24 head teacher felt that what she'd said was transphobic now that is entirely the school's
00:17:29 right to do that you know i think as a head teacher you have to run the school as you see fit
00:17:33 however i think that's a really problematic decision that our head teachers made because
00:17:39 first of all there's nothing in what jk rowling said that the vast majority of the population
00:17:43 would disagree with in terms of the the blog she'd written and the tweet she's done
00:17:47 um i think she's taken a very sensitive a very empathetic approach to the issue but more worrying
00:17:53 was in the letter that the head teacher sent out
00:17:56 they tried to claim that they weren't taking a view
00:17:58 on this issue and that they were just being inclusive
00:18:00 and actually they'd clearly come down
00:18:03 on one side of that issue
00:18:05 it's not a majority held opinion
00:18:07 if I recall from our polling
00:18:09 something like 61% of people felt
00:18:13 that when it came to transgender rights
00:18:14 we'd either gone too far in this country already
00:18:18 or had it about right
00:18:19 so there was no majority view to shift things
00:18:22 you know so that's a good example of where someone in the public sector has made a decision which
00:18:26 they think is the right decision it's out of kilter with wider public opinion and it's also
00:18:31 clearly a very political decision they've made and i just think if i was a kid in that school
00:18:35 remember staff in that school they held a different opinion to that their ability to express that
00:18:40 opinion has now been completely suppressed and these are not issues where the debate's been had
00:18:46 and done with these are sensitive issues that we're still working our way through and i don't
00:18:51 think we should shut down that kind of discussion. That's the point, actually, isn't it? I mean,
00:18:54 you talk about the public sector, but then in that case, as well, Body Shop have piled in,
00:18:59 haven't they, on top of JK Rowling, and very dismissively, actually, and very rough, but you
00:19:04 can absolutely understand, can't you, why people who are in that 61%, for example, how they sort
00:19:12 of feel that even though they're in the majority, they sort of think, this is what's going to happen
00:19:17 if I actually what if I say something out of turn this this is what might happen okay they won't get
00:19:23 you know a name changed on the street or something it's not the same situation but
00:19:27 it's it basically just you know brings about a certain kind of attitude doesn't it you should
00:19:33 think actually I better keep my mouth you know walk on eggshells and and what's been really
00:19:40 insightful and actually quite worrying is the number of people that have got in touch with us
00:19:43 since we launched their campaign a few weeks ago
00:19:46 to say, you know, thank you for doing this.
00:19:48 I wish I could speak out about X or Y, but I didn't.
00:19:52 You know, even if they wanted to do it in their own time,
00:19:54 on their own social media or whatever,
00:19:56 their worry is that they will be reported to their employers
00:19:58 or called out at, you know, organisations they work with,
00:20:01 and then they won't be able to take part in it.
00:20:03 And it's such a shame because there is such a positive message
00:20:07 to sell about all of this, which is,
00:20:09 in this country, we have a huge amount in common.
00:20:12 we share an awful lot in common even around supposedly contentious issues we've got a really
00:20:18 good track record in this country of either muddling our way through or coming to um a
00:20:24 consensus about how we should deal with things and and i think we should be really proud of that
00:20:29 that's not to say there isn't more we can do but actually most people have got an awful lot in
00:20:33 common with with other people and even where we disagree we've got a really good track record in
00:20:38 this country of disagreeing really nicely resolving our differences through
00:20:41 democratic means or other means and getting on with one another what would
00:20:47 success look like then for you with this campaign I mean what would you consider
00:20:50 to be I know you've been tweeting some things lately but have you managed to
00:20:55 affect any sort of change or what would what would your idea be of oh that's
00:20:59 actually a little victory you know that's a good little victory yes so obviously no
00:21:04 one organization or one person is going to change things themselves and actually
00:21:07 this is really about what would success be if more people felt that they were
00:21:11 able to speak their mind help other people try and do the right thing and
00:21:15 not have to worry about inadvertently offending someone or upsetting someone
00:21:20 okay and then being and then facing consequences because of that and there
00:21:24 was a lovely thing yesterday again it's on Twitter and Twitter is not the real
00:21:28 life I get that there's a lovely thing yesterday where some wallies on Twitter
00:21:32 had tried to report an academic to the university of reading who she worked for uh because she'd
00:21:40 come out and the academic had come out in favor of black lives matter and said that she was really
00:21:44 glad that that statue had come down and some people tried to report her to the university
00:21:48 of reading and they rightly said no academic freedom they can hold their views and we will
00:21:52 back them and then i sort of jumped in and said well you know i hope the university of reading
00:21:56 and reading's my hometown so i've got an interest here i hope they'll support people that had other
00:21:59 views like pro-Brexit views or gender critical views or what have you and their official
00:22:05 Twitter account came back and said of course we would academic freedom is for everyone
00:22:08 on all issues and all views.
00:22:10 Now if we could get more universities coming out and stating that and living by that, more
00:22:15 companies, more organisations that could come out and say that, then we'd all be much better
00:22:19 off because we don't have to agree.
00:22:21 The body shop can hold their view, that's fine, so long as they don't then enforce that
00:22:25 view on their staff or their customers then we can all muddle along and get on.
00:22:28 that to me would be success people feeling they can step out engage with
00:22:32 their friends family in real life and not have to worry if they've
00:22:36 inadvertently upset someone well look I hope you have successes in that case you
00:22:41 know I mean I really do and how so you did mention how people get involved can
00:22:46 you tell us what the website is again yeah sure so our website is a campaign
00:22:50 commonsense.com and if people go there there's a join us form on the front page
00:22:54 we're not going to harass them with loads of emails it just means we can
00:22:58 keep them in touch with what we're doing and most importantly if we see good
00:23:01 good stuff going on good news stories we can share them with people and if we
00:23:05 need to mobilize people to try and get involved in some other stuff we can let
00:23:09 them know at short notice well that's great well thank you very much for
00:23:12 coming on thanks very much and actually our first in a long time socially
00:23:18 distant we are actually quite a distance aren't we thanks very much
00:23:24 that's it for so what you're saying is this this week and we will see you next
00:23:29 week and I hope you have a nice time in the meantime thank you