New Culture Forum - September 26, 2020


Britain Is Being Racialised By The Left Through Toxic Identity Politics & Victimhood Mentality

Moralitis - Is Woke Groupthink A Mental Malady? Can A Cultural 'Virus' Be Cured? Trump May Have Flaws But He Is A Bulwark Against The Radical Left. America Needs Him.

Episode Stats


Length

39 minutes

Words per minute

176.94

Word count

7,029

Sentence count

184


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to So What You're Saying Is, I'm Peter Whittle. Now my guest today is one of the
00:00:27 new rising stars of commentary on the mainstream media. Anaya Falarin Iman is a columnist for
00:00:35 Spiked Online. She's also a director of the Free Speech Union and founder of the Equinaya Project
00:00:42 and she's with me now. Thanks very much for joining us. Thank you for having me. You have been doing,
00:00:50 well, the ghastly mainstream media as we have to call them, you know, being one of the new media,
00:00:55 but basically you've been talking particularly recently haven't you about obviously Black Lives
00:01:01 Matter but also it's wider issues isn't it about free speech those are the things that really seem
00:01:07 to concern you yeah yeah I guess I've been catapulted into more mainstream consciousness
00:01:14 from the kind of Black Lives Matter conversation but I've been very interested particularly over
00:01:18 the last two years in the issues of freedom of speech Brexit and democracy and identity politics
00:01:23 and all of the kind of big picture questions that I think are shaping public discourse at the moment.
00:01:28 Yeah. And, I mean, so how did you start this?
00:01:34 I mean, how, because you've actually started a foundation yourself, haven't you, called the Equiano Foundation.
00:01:40 Yes, no, it's called the Equiano Projects.
00:01:42 Yes, it's a new organisation launched very recently.
00:01:45 And it's to some extent in response to Black Lives Matter,
00:01:48 but it's something that I've been thinking about for about a year now.
00:01:51 I think that when we talk about issues of race and racism, it's very, it's very heated,
00:01:56 it's very difficult, and there's an increasing inability to have a kind of nuanced and complex
00:02:01 conversation about these issues without it being just massive generalisations and with a lot of
00:02:07 heat but not a lot of light. And so the Equiano Project is an attempt to respond to that, that
00:02:12 difficulty and kind of bringing people together that are really challenging, honest thinkers on
00:02:16 these subjects and having really nuanced and interesting conversations about this, but also
00:02:20 championing the more universalist response to race and racism we hear a lot about identity politics
00:02:27 kind of race consciousness and essentially arguing that race is the kind of primary organizing
00:02:33 principle of society i i reject that conception of society and essentially champion a universalist
00:02:40 one a universalist one so based on what the enlightenment yes exactly i think that this
00:02:46 this idea that you know all men are created equal even the martin luther king tradition of the
00:02:50 the content of your character, not the colour of your skin.
00:02:53 And I think that that's what we should be aspiring to actually manifest in society.
00:02:57 And I think we were going that way.
00:02:58 And actually now we're seeing a kind of re-racialisation of society,
00:03:02 where race is now, you know, the defining way that you should view the world,
00:03:06 whether that's through white privilege or black victimhood,
00:03:09 and it's homogenising people based off of race.
00:03:11 I think that's a massive step backwards,
00:03:13 and I don't think that's how we create a harmonious society.
00:03:18 But do you find that, I mean, to me, what you think seems entirely logical and commonsensical,
00:03:23 but do you find there is, in the media, you know, that your views are considered to be rather eccentric?
00:03:30 I mean, you know, in the media, I'm talking about that.
00:03:32 Yes, no, I think so. I think, I mean, we know a lot about the kind of sensationalism in the media,
00:03:38 and I think it's very, very convenient to have a kind of narrative that's very simplistic,
00:03:43 very black and white, and often reactionary and conflicting.
00:03:46 And I think the identity politics, one, suits that particular narrative very easily.
00:03:52 And I think the one that I'm essentially advocating for, I would agree with you, it's actually quite commonsensical.
00:03:57 I think it rings true with most people's instinct that, no, we shouldn't be judging people by their immediate physical appearance.
00:04:03 We should actually be treating everybody as equals and treating them equally.
00:04:08 And I think that, unfortunately, that's kind of been challenged in recent years with the rise of this kind of new type of thinking.
00:04:14 I mean it's come to the fore in a huge way recently but it's been bubbling along there
00:04:22 for a long time I mean in your own life you know when was the first time you really sort of came
00:04:29 across what we call maybe woke politics or these kind of attitudes much more sort of as you say
00:04:36 racializing of everything when's the first time you really came across yeah I would say probably
00:04:42 in university but i think i definitely saw seeds with it when i was younger and so one thing about
00:04:48 me i've been to various different types of schools so when i for my first secondary school my first
00:04:53 couple years i went to a private school and then i went to a local comprehensive school which was
00:04:57 really ethnically diverse and when i was at that comprehensive school uh it will i saw a kind of
00:05:03 emergence of a kind of racial politics i mean there was a kind of uh the the black kids kind
00:05:08 of hung out together and there was a lot about kind of uh you know being black and what that
00:05:13 meant and so a lot of those things were kind of emerging during that time but it wasn't too uh
00:05:19 defining or limiting in the way that i think it really catapulted when i went to university
00:05:24 and seeing the emergence of kind of decoloniser curriculum and critical race theory which
00:05:29 essentially uh argue that race is the most important characteristic that society is kind
00:05:37 kind of fundamentally and institutionally racist and the various things that we must do in order
00:05:42 to kind of reorder society against what they kind of conceive of as kind of racist roots and so
00:05:48 that's university was definitely where I saw the most palpable conception of this woke politics
00:05:55 that we're seeing now transform our institutions. Did you see or have you heard about say President
00:06:01 trump's speech last night about critical race theory uh he made a similar one didn't he at
00:06:07 mount rushmore but last i think yesterday's it was basically about the ways to stop it he's just
00:06:15 defunded hasn't he federal spending on this i mean do you think that's a good thing i mean
00:06:22 did you think it was a good speech yeah no i thought it was a brilliant speech i think and
00:06:27 and particularly where a lot of this wokeness, so to speak, is coming out of America.
00:06:33 You know, I'm a big fan of America, but this is an example of American cultural hegemony dominating.
00:06:39 And so there's pros and cons with that.
00:06:41 And so they're obviously feeling it in a really strong way.
00:06:43 And I understand why he did it.
00:06:45 I mean, you know, I think a lot of it is response to the kind of 1619 project,
00:06:50 which is trying to essentially rewrite American history to argue that its roots were racist to the core.
00:06:56 And I think that that's a really dangerous thing. I think that will change how Americans perceive their history and in turn perceive themselves.
00:07:04 So I think it's incredibly serious and I understand why Donald Trump did it.
00:07:07 I think it's unfortunate that we're at the point where we are not necessarily able to utilise more democratic mechanisms of making the case against critical race theory,
00:07:19 that we essentially have to ban it but I understand why it is being done because I think
00:07:25 critical race theory which argues that racism is embedded and endemic in our society is incredibly
00:07:31 divisive and I think I think it's a racist ideology. Well it is in the end isn't it I mean
00:07:37 it is sort of it it goes through old-fashioned liberalism and comes out the other end in a very
00:07:44 extreme porn but I mean I know you say about banning it I think that from what
00:07:49 I can gather he's banned funding for these various things like bias you know
00:07:55 bias training or things like this unconscious bias and I think you know a
00:08:00 lot of people looking from here and thinking why can't we do something like
00:08:04 that I mean why because I think the point you make is a very important one
00:08:07 which is that it's a pity we've got to do it that way so what do you do in a
00:08:13 Win hearts and minds, is that what you do?
00:08:16 Well, this is the thing.
00:08:17 I think, unfortunately, in Britain, and I hope this will change,
00:08:20 I think we are facing a massive collapse of political authority.
00:08:25 I think we should not necessarily have to take those kind of drastic measures,
00:08:29 but we're in a situation where, I mean, in the kind of Black Lives Matter protests
00:08:33 and the height of it, Churchill was boarded up
00:08:35 and we couldn't even have really a political authority
00:08:39 that was willing to even defend basic kind of history,
00:08:43 the things that actually give us a lot of pride
00:08:45 in a sense of national identity and common belonging.
00:08:49 And so in an ideal situation,
00:08:52 we would hope that, for example,
00:08:53 people in positions of authority that create culture
00:08:56 or even kind of define politics
00:08:59 would actually have the confidence to be able to say,
00:09:02 no, that's not the society that we live in.
00:09:05 These basic fundamental democratic values or liberal values
00:09:09 are not racist. Actually, these are the things that many people are trying to cross the channel
00:09:14 to actually get to. I think we should be very grateful for them and cherish them and say
00:09:19 that in a very powerful way. But a lot of political elites don't have the confidence,
00:09:24 and so sometimes that means drastic measures have to be taken.
00:09:27 When you say a lot of political elites don't have confidence, I mean, there are various
00:09:32 particular elites that don't have the confidence, aren't there? I mean, we're talking about
00:09:36 the West if you like aren't we on the whole and I mean basically it's not just
00:09:41 they don't have the confidence I'd say there's been a positive more collapsing
00:09:46 confidence but also it's this change in the the various challenges coming to
00:09:53 culture seem to be coming from within the institutions you know so we've seen
00:09:58 like the British Library and the British Museum very quickly I mean were you
00:10:02 surprised at the speed with which these things happened during the Black Lives
00:10:07 Matter thing it just seemed to happen like that didn't it? Yeah I think it was
00:10:10 it was an unbelievable speed and I think it does show that the erosion that has
00:10:15 happened over a very long period of time that the kind of fail-safe so to speak
00:10:19 that we would have that would put brakes on any kind of rapid transformation
00:10:24 have been eroded over such a long time so whether that is that is that the kind
00:10:29 media which would hope would be able to any kind of political movement that emerges they should be
00:10:34 able to hold them to account ask them difficult questions that didn't happen they were all
00:10:38 championing them or so many of the institutions that we otherwise would have relied on to
00:10:43 yeah put the brakes essentially on any kind of rapid change capitulated very very quickly and
00:10:48 I think yeah part of that has been a you know a lack of faith in the ideals that we talk about
00:10:55 the Enlightenment and Liberal values to bring about a kind of better society or even the fact
00:11:01 that they're not actually articulated in a meaningful way from from very early on anymore
00:11:06 and so a movement that makes bold and radical claims about our society in such a kind of
00:11:12 powerful way can can just change things so quickly and I think yeah I think it's a stark reminder
00:11:19 of where we are at. I saw you wrote something recently saying that something I think is just
00:11:24 undeniable which is that the right lost the culture war a long time ago i mean you know
00:11:31 there's no point in actually sort of talking about it being a battle that it was it was lost
00:11:36 but that the only way it can be turned around is if i think you said if the conservatives or
00:11:41 conservatives should we say start conserving again yes um i i really believe that i think i mean if
00:11:49 If we just take the Tory party, many of the things that we would regard as,
00:11:56 even just me, the example that I just gave earlier about Winston Churchill,
00:11:59 I mean, Boris frequently framed himself as the kind of champion of Winston Churchill.
00:12:03 This is just a trivial example.
00:12:05 But they haven't been able to stand up.
00:12:08 And I think that that shows that conservatism for a long time,
00:12:12 the kind of ideological, philosophical basis that defines it,
00:12:16 has not really been powerful enough for a very long time now.
00:12:20 And so I think until they do that, until we start to actually,
00:12:25 or Conservatives more broadly, start to actually stand up and defend these things
00:12:29 and not be afraid to actually do this in the face of being called racist
00:12:34 or all of these different things, then I think things will continue
00:12:38 because at least the left, or the woke left in particular, there isn't a line.
00:12:43 I don't think there's a point where they'll say, I'm going to stop.
00:12:46 I mean, a lot of people, when the kind of statues were originally being toppled,
00:12:50 people thought, oh, well, you know, they're just kind of slave owners,
00:12:53 we don't mind having them toppled, but it didn't stop.
00:12:56 I mean, now we're seeing the University of Edinburgh
00:12:59 changing the name of the David Hume Tower, and so there's no end.
00:13:03 And I think the Conservatives will have to be the ones, really, that draw a line on this.
00:13:09 But they're just not, are they? They're just not.
00:13:13 I mean, you know, why do you think they're so reluctant?
00:13:15 i mean we've talked about this on this show quite a bit before you've had okay you've got trump right
00:13:20 but then you've also got president macron for example saying look this is french history better
00:13:26 or worse uh you know and it's not going to change why is it that you know everyone's been so
00:13:34 lackluster politically i mean in the government do you think i think i think there's a complex
00:13:39 range of reasons for that i think some of them are historical reasons i think um for example
00:13:44 when we saw in the 20th century, you know, with the kind of, with the rise of authoritarianism
00:13:51 and kind of Nazism, I think a lot of people associated kind of more strong fourth right,
00:13:57 right wing politics with something that was kind of destructive and negative. And I think,
00:14:02 as well as the kind of collapse of the left, when with the kind of fall of communism, I think the
00:14:07 left lost its kind of belief that there was an alternative as well. And so I think, yeah, I think
00:14:12 philosophically for for both the left and the right that they are struggling to find what they
00:14:17 really mean and I think even from a kind of conservative perspective even some of the kind
00:14:24 of religious underpinnings that used to underpin conservatism aren't even there either so I think
00:14:28 many of the things whether that's religiously or philosophically that would drive conservative
00:14:33 politics they haven't really been able to respond to the changes that things have happened so I
00:14:39 think it's going to be a deep kind of introspection and reflection to be able to find what kind of
00:14:47 society going forward do we actually want to create and conserve. You've actually said as
00:14:54 well that we're living in a very therapeutic society. What do you mean by that? Well I think
00:15:00 we see it with many of the politics at the moment and I think identity politics is a really good
00:15:05 example of that um that the way in which people uh get recognition or get authority in the
00:15:12 political sphere is by a grievance-based identity i think we see it um in many ways with kind of
00:15:18 trans activism we see it to a to a lesser extent with kind of just the feminist movement but i
00:15:22 think the black activism is is one of the you know most palpable examples of that at the moment
00:15:29 it's not a politics which advocates for agency or kind of responsibility and kind of taking control
00:15:35 of one's life and directing oneself into wherever destination we want to go. It's a
00:15:42 kind of demand for recognition. It's a demand for kind of external forces to kind of do
00:15:49 something for us. And I think that's a very disempowering form of politics. I think it's
00:15:57 one which leaves people not feeling able or capable to be able to take control of their
00:16:03 life but i think it manifests itself in a range of different ways it's sort of as you say it's like
00:16:10 putting the victim and at the top it's the primary thing about someone where you stand on the
00:16:18 victimhood pantheon exactly and this is it's not even necessarily an accident i mean part of the
00:16:24 kind of critical race theory and all of these things is this view of kind of intersectionality
00:16:29 which argues that we all have various kind of identities and they intersect and where you
00:16:38 are on that kind of intersectional hierarchy essentially places you as more authentic so for
00:16:45 example that's why you know if you are a straight white male you're perhaps morally not as superior
00:16:52 as someone that is a kind of black trans woman and so yeah it's almost it's a kind of victimhood
00:16:57 hierarchy and i think that's very much uh how our politics is is shaping at the moment so as a woman
00:17:05 a black woman where do you stand on it i mean i i've often tried to work out as a as a gay man
00:17:11 you know white man where do where do i say i think that i must still be sort of like pretty much you
00:17:16 know low in sense that i'm you know a white man um but i get this kind of like a special pass i
00:17:23 guess you know because okay but the thing is how interesting on that point the most hostile
00:17:30 reactions i've had whenever i've spoken anywhere had been from the gay lobby because i'm kind of
00:17:36 like the wrong i have the wrong views now this must happen to you too surely yeah and i think
00:17:42 this is not because you're a gay man you know yeah um i think this is what happens with identity
00:17:50 politics, I think there was a really interesting case, I mean, perhaps in the 60s, when there was
00:17:55 very specific forms of discrimination based off of people's identity. There was this concept by
00:18:00 this post-colonial theorist called Spivak, called strategic essentialism. So for essentially
00:18:06 strategic purposes, you would homogenise in order to kind of advocate for your collective interests.
00:18:11 And I thought that that was effective during the 60s, when there were specific forms of
00:18:15 discrimination but we are not living in that society anymore and actually that
00:18:19 new form of essentialism that has emerged is massively holding people back
00:18:23 so actually if you are a kind of free-thinking contrarian or or just
00:18:27 an independent minded ethnic minority that doesn't really the things that are
00:18:32 being said doesn't really align you're seen as less authentic and so it's a new
00:18:35 form of stereotyping that people are actually wanting to be stereotyped and I
00:18:40 think, yeah, I think it is very problematic. I mean, do you get, you know, do you get abuse,
00:18:49 you know, I mean, you're online a lot, aren't you? I mean, do you get abuse for your view? I mean,
00:18:55 when you've criticised Black Lives Matter, for example? You know, interestingly, you know,
00:19:00 I'm still figuring out, I'm still figuring out why, but I don't seem to get as much abuse as
00:19:05 other kind of commentators that I've seen on this particular issue, criticising Black Lives
00:19:10 Matter. I think that I personally don't generally go after people. And I do, I'm very kind of
00:19:17 specific with my arguments. And I think, I think, yeah, I don't try and get too involved in the kind
00:19:23 of back and forth kind of conflict, which I think is really unproductive. But I do get criticism,
00:19:28 of course, and in some senses, I welcome it, I want criticism. But in terms of personal attacks,
00:19:33 I think, I think for a lot of people that support Black Lives Matter, they often don't know where
00:19:38 to fit me you know I've got dreadlocks I'm not necessarily in the Tory party or anything like
00:19:44 that and I think it seems to confuse them I think because this week we had a good example of one of
00:19:55 those sort of fights in the media with Calvin Robinson who has been on this channel a couple
00:20:01 of times uh quite recently in fact and uh he really was ripped apart wasn't he on on twitter
00:20:08 and they were calling him all sorts of awful names and things um and i thought the pressure
00:20:16 in that situation is really intense actually yeah i think um the situation with calvin of course what
00:20:23 he went through was completely unacceptable but i think it was a really important moment
00:20:27 in terms of just exposing just the vitriolic nastiness and I think it's really telling
00:20:32 because particularly those that advocate for Black Lives Matter they frequently position
00:20:37 themselves as coming from a place of moral superiority and doing the right thing but when
00:20:42 the light is often shone on their perhaps contradictions the nastiness comes out I think
00:20:47 that's very telling and I think yeah the more that they do that I think the more it reveals that I
00:20:52 don't think this is a a movement based off of kind of principle based off of
00:20:57 trying to genuinely create a better society is one that has filled with a
00:21:01 lot of vengeful and resentful undertones and I think someone like Calvin who is
00:21:06 you know an ethnic minority man who has his own thoughts and disagrees with it
00:21:11 that's almost the worst thing that can happen to them because that challenges
00:21:15 their whole you know conception that they're speaking on behalf of you know
00:21:19 all people that are black or what have you and that's just not true you know you mentioned the
00:21:25 Tory party there I mean do you ever think of okay you're building quite a career as a commentator
00:21:32 at the moment but do you ever think of being politically active I mean I know you were in
00:21:36 the Brexit party yes did you actually stand no I did stand I stood for the Brexit party
00:21:43 for that specific issue of Brexit and that was incredibly important to me just you know respecting
00:21:49 such a powerful democratic expression and i i thought the whole situation that happened for
00:21:54 four years was essentially immoral and so yeah so it was important for me to show that um yeah there
00:22:00 are a very broad range of brexiteers and so in terms of specific party politics um i would say
00:22:07 that at this moment it's not necessarily something that i would be involved in um but i because i
00:22:14 think there are too many issues underlying the political parties at the moment to actually affect
00:22:21 the kinds of change that I think needs to happen. But give us just a few what are the underlying
00:22:29 problems? Well I think part of the things that I've been saying I think if we even lack the basic
00:22:35 ability to call out what you know we saw in those protests which was it wasn't even you know law and
00:22:41 order it was just the basic application of the rule of law which we would hope you know in a
00:22:46 liberal you know society would be able to do that and i think that it shows that um the kind of
00:22:51 political will um needed in order to kind of respond to whether that is the kind of therapeutic
00:22:58 and kind of child-centered learning education not the kind of traditionalist approach which i support
00:23:03 or all those kinds of things i think it seems unlikely i mean i don't have um complete lack of
00:23:08 faith but i think um these are some of the demonstrations that that show that um i think
00:23:14 we're not necessarily at the precipice yet which would be needed to i think hopefully
00:23:19 get some life back into the political parties so really it comes down doesn't it to what we were
00:23:24 saying before that essentially if they're not going to take on in any serious way these cultural
00:23:30 issues then you're not interested really is that right you would personally not be interested in
00:23:35 Well, I think, I do think, I mean, there's a quote, I think, from Andrew Breitbart, I think he said, politics is downstream from culture.
00:23:44 That's right. We live by that here.
00:23:46 Oh, really? I think there's a lot of truth in that. I think, yeah, I think there's a lot of truth in that.
00:23:53 And I think that if the culture within our society is, I guess, what cultivates a sense of, you know, agency, responsibility, a sense of kind of a vibrant democratic spirit.
00:24:04 And if you're not willing to be part of the process that ignites that,
00:24:09 then I think you're going to have a very lackluster politics.
00:24:12 Yeah, yeah.
00:24:13 I think which is what we've got, actually.
00:24:16 This point on Brexit is not unlike Claire Fox.
00:24:19 You know, that was the one specific thing.
00:24:22 But they saw it very, very clearly in terms of this wasn't a real attempt.
00:24:27 Presumably, this is how you saw it.
00:24:28 A real attempt to overthrow, you know, for better or worse,
00:24:33 a decision that was made you know and uh but that really brings just one other thing i think it's
00:24:39 quite interesting i think you've touched on this before and that is that absent from all of the
00:24:45 discussions and the protests and things any kind of real talk about class or inequality
00:24:52 almost nothing this is not this is not one of their preoccupations is it the you know the identity
00:24:58 would you call them identarians you know this is not really one of their concerns is it
00:25:03 Yeah, I think this is actually one of the most disturbing, in some senses, aspects of this kind of cultural malaise that we're experiencing.
00:25:12 I think it very much suits a kind of politics that isn't really interested in getting to the deep rooted issues of kind of extreme inequality or the different issues that are affecting society.
00:25:24 So it stays on these superficial things like people's gender or their race.
00:25:30 And I think, and I would fundamentally disagree with the idea that your race in Britain can hold you back in life.
00:25:38 I think Britain perhaps should actually almost congratulate itself on its achievement in terms of going from a society that was, you know, colonial and all of the things that happened in the past to be able to forge a society that people from all different backgrounds can achieve great heights.
00:25:59 And so, yeah, I think that the kind of identity politics is a massive deflection from actually perhaps a class politics.
00:26:08 I wouldn't necessarily think class is the, I wouldn't take a class reductionist perspective,
00:26:13 but I would definitely argue that class is perhaps a more significant determiner of your ability to access different spaces than your race, most definitely.
00:26:25 Oh yeah, but my fear is that it's growing. If you look at social mobility, if you look in education, people who get on now have usually been privately educated, or far more than maybe when I was growing up. Far more, and I was sort of a teenager in the 70s. And far more social mobility, I think half and half at Oxbridge, public, private.
00:26:50 No, I completely agree on that. And this is another thing that's really interesting
00:26:54 with the race issue. And this is a statistic that many people don't know about. So for
00:26:58 16 to 30 year olds, black people that live in Britain, they're actually at income parity
00:27:04 with their white counterparts. Now that's very significant upward levels of social mobility
00:27:09 from ethnic minority people of the previous generation. So their children are actually
00:27:13 doing really, really well. So when it comes to actual social mobility, ethnic minority
00:27:20 are actually doing much better than their white British counterparts.
00:27:24 So what's really interesting, again, is that a lot of the time
00:27:28 even these kinds of quotas or diversity schemes
00:27:32 end up benefiting middle class and the minority.
00:27:37 And then the people that are facing various structural barriers
00:27:41 regardless of race are completely ignored.
00:27:44 And a very similar thing happens in America as well.
00:27:47 Yes. There's a fundamental difference, though, in racial history, isn't there, between Britain and America?
00:27:54 And, I mean, again, one of the interesting things is the ease with which it's been adopted here somehow being, you know, the same history.
00:28:02 And it's really not.
00:28:04 Yes, I think it's very concerning that in some senses, particularly many of these Black Lives Matter activists,
00:28:11 have wanted to have a similar history to America, which is one that is full of trials and tribulations
00:28:17 and also triumphs, but not one that can be reasonably compared to Britain. I think anyone
00:28:23 that tries to import the American racial culture to Britain cannot be taken seriously. There are
00:28:29 many fundamental differences. I mean, the overwhelming majority of African-Americans
00:28:33 obviously came as a result of transatlantic slavery, and they had the history of kind of
00:28:39 Jim Crow and the civil rights movement.
00:28:40 So they have a relatively unified history
00:28:42 that's very different to the black British story,
00:28:45 which is one of heterogeneity,
00:28:47 whether that's the kind of wind rush generation
00:28:49 to more recent people from kind of West Africa
00:28:52 and to even kind of black British people
00:28:56 from hundreds of years ago.
00:28:57 So it's very disparate in terms of the story.
00:29:00 It's not one that is unified,
00:29:02 but also for example, in America,
00:29:04 there was laws against interracial relationships.
00:29:07 In Britain, actually, a black Caribbean man is more likely to have a kid with a white woman than a black woman.
00:29:12 So we're talking about one that's a much more kind of integrated history.
00:29:19 Actually, working class people, particularly in the 70s and 80s, were at the forefront of anti-racist activism.
00:29:26 And black and white people stood together in a much more unified way.
00:29:30 In Britain, in America, kind of poor whites and poor blacks don't necessarily have a unified politics.
00:29:36 so there's so many differences and I think it's I mean the whole controversy over
00:29:40 Adele's kind of outfit as kind of trivial as it was it really highlighted that you know we have
00:29:48 things like the Notting Hill Carnival which brings together people of all ethnicities and American
00:29:54 people didn't understand that you know they thought it was cultural appropriation when actually it was
00:29:58 completely normal here in Britain so I think that we we import the American narrative at our peril
00:30:03 Yeah, but I mean, isn't that something that we vaguely imported as well, the whole cultural appropriation argument?
00:30:09 It's sort of, not quite, it's lapping around the edges, isn't it?
00:30:13 Yes, it's not taking off as powerfully in Britain, but it's definitely something that we have been hearing more and more of.
00:30:22 And it goes back to what I was saying in the beginning in terms of what the Equiano Project tries to promote,
00:30:27 which is a universalism, and one that focuses on the future and what kind of society we're trying to create.
00:30:32 Because are we really saying that we should all stay in our fixed, you know, essential racial or cultural silos?
00:30:40 How can we create a kind of an integrated society, a kind of with bonds of solidarity and community if everything is defined so rigidly?
00:30:48 And we have our own version of that in Britain with kind of multiculturalism as a public policy,
00:30:54 which basically categorises people based off of cultures and seeks to kind of manage them in that way.
00:31:00 So we have our own kind of version.
00:31:01 But I think it's not working.
00:31:04 The thing is with multiculturalism here is that, you know, as an idea, it was being challenged, oh, 10, 15 years ago.
00:31:12 I mean, Angela Merkel made a speech about it.
00:31:15 We have to accept it's not worked.
00:31:17 Cameron did.
00:31:17 David Cameron did.
00:31:19 But it's still very much the default position.
00:31:23 And certainly, for example, in local councils, it seems like it hasn't trickled down.
00:31:28 The idea that somehow we should have, we should say we are a multi-ethnic society with an overarching, you know, unifying set of values.
00:31:36 But it's very much now still, I think, in the lifeblood, in the cultural lifeblood that we're multicultural.
00:31:44 It's a fundamental difference.
00:31:45 I think America is actually, they've taken a leaf out of our book there, haven't they?
00:31:52 Because it was always a melting pot in America, but not anymore.
00:31:55 No, exactly. I mean, there was a thing, I think it was in the New York Times where they were going to start capitalising B for black and W for white and saying that they're specific, distinct, separate cultures.
00:32:06 And yeah, I think that's a horrifying step. I think that's a backwards step.
00:32:09 What we should be doing is even, you know, I get the multi-ethnic, but sometimes I just think we shouldn't even have to think about things in that way.
00:32:18 we are british citizens and and we are all you know stand on an equal footing and should be
00:32:23 conceiving of ourselves as as one nation and and we don't have that again back to what we were
00:32:29 talking earlier about the confidence to just reject all of this type of politics and say that it's just
00:32:34 not working and and i think it's i think multiculturalism does a lot of damage to
00:32:39 natural social cohesion but also to the cultures that people are seeking to protect because if you
00:32:44 are for example this is obviously a generalisation but if you if you are
00:32:48 perhaps a gay Muslim you know man you you won't be seen as as authentic as
00:32:54 perhaps a kind of so-called traditional Muslim leader and and that keeps people
00:32:59 actually in a very static position that's not a progressive society in my
00:33:04 opinion you're in your twenties aren't you yes okay we're hearing a lot and I
00:33:12 think with a lot of justification of the extraordinary level of indoctrination in
00:33:18 education we've certainly talked about it on these programs some people though
00:33:25 seem to slip through the net and I wonder how you sort of slip through the
00:33:30 net how does it work I mean if you're going from school to university and
00:33:34 just look honestly when I've spoken like at university things entirely the same
00:33:39 views about virtually everything so I mean how did you how have you managed as it were to come out
00:33:47 the other end and with your own thoughts your own your own judgment intact yeah I think that's a
00:33:53 good question um yeah I would agree with you that was something quite astonishing I when I speak at
00:33:59 universities have you always had views I mean I'm sorry but have you been political how long have
00:34:04 you been political really and I think I became perhaps politically conscious at about 14 years
00:34:08 old I think I'm very lucky so my mum you know she is a very conservative minded and from very young
00:34:16 she kind of engaged my sister and I in political thinking and ideas and kind of encouraged us to
00:34:22 kind of question everything and so going into environments of kind of ideological conformity
00:34:28 I think I already had a kind of suspicion of anything that was too powerfully trying to say
00:34:35 what to think versus how and so i think instinctively um i think i'd by the time i'd already
00:34:41 got to university i'd cultivated um a kind of sense of suspicion towards those things and um
00:34:46 and yeah so i i i distanced myself from that kind of uh that kind of ideological conformity quite
00:34:53 early on but i think it is hard you know at university i think it is um the tide is very
00:34:59 one way i remember being very surprised that that um despite the fact that the country overwhelmingly
00:35:04 voted you know one way in regards to the brexit referendum i i didn't i wasn't exposed to any
00:35:10 pro-brexit um opinion and and so how can how can we cultivate you know independent-minded you know
00:35:18 responsible citizens when the brain of our society is is just so conformist i think it's um i think
00:35:26 there's a lot to do when it comes to the education and university sector well uh it's sort of closing
00:35:34 closing in on itself isn't it I mean some people like Roger Scruton have said the only thing we
00:35:39 can possibly do is actually certainly with the humanities just if they're gone forget about them
00:35:46 start new things up you know I think it's a chance you know yeah I think more and more people things
00:35:51 um well look it's been lovely to talk to you and what's on the cards for you now what are you going
00:36:00 to be doing next so i think the equiano project for me is really uh the where my focus is in at
00:36:06 least for the for the medium term i think with the unconscious bias diversity training all of
00:36:11 these things coming down the pipe um to many organizations i think that i'm trying to create
00:36:17 an alternative one that kind of champions the things that we've been discussing about you know
00:36:21 our common humanity emphasizing what what unites us not what divides us and i think that people need
00:36:27 to be aware that there is an alternative to this thinking one that is actually
00:36:31 promoting harmony not constant division well how can we how can people become
00:36:36 involved is it something where they can become involved yes and they become
00:36:39 members yes you can go on to the equianoproject.com and I think yeah
00:36:44 there's information in terms of how to get involved in terms of even events so
00:36:47 we're starting kind of community events where people can be part of
00:36:52 participating in shaping this conversation not just our expert-led
00:36:55 events. So there's many different things that people can actually get involved in to be part
00:37:00 of this conversation and changing this extreme division that we're seeing in regards to race.
00:37:08 Well, thank you very, very much. What we'll do, we'll put on the programme when it goes out a link
00:37:13 to the project. And also, obviously, I mentioned the free speech union with Toby Young. You're
00:37:20 doing quite a bit of work with you know aren't you yeah you're on the board yes I'm on the board
00:37:25 and um yeah no I think it's a brilliant organization I think as I said earlier in
00:37:30 terms of you know as we get more to the precipice it in some sense necessitates a response and now
00:37:36 we're seeing much more organizations starting saying no you know we're not going to just allow
00:37:41 this to drive through such an amazing you know country and society that we live in and the free
00:37:46 Can I ask you one final question?
00:37:49 No, no, because you say when we go towards the press peers,
00:37:54 I don't mean you to be too literal-minded if you don't,
00:37:56 but what would that look like, do you think?
00:37:59 Well, I think that, you know, when the Black Lives Matter protests came about,
00:38:04 I mean, first and foremost, I hope that in nowhere, anywhere now,
00:38:07 I don't think we're going to get to the point of America,
00:38:09 which is these riots and things going on,
00:38:11 really horrific violence and dangerous stuff.
00:38:14 I think that that's completely too far.
00:38:16 But I think at least with the Black Lives Matter protests, I think we saw a kind of window in terms of where things could go, where everything is defined by race in every single element and layer of our society that kids are being taught, you know, about white privilege and these types of things.
00:38:31 I think that that is a road that we don't want to go down, that we shouldn't go down.
00:38:36 And I hope that when people will observe the things that have happened over the last few months
00:38:41 and realise that each of us individually as well as collectively now needs to kind of say no,
00:38:46 whether that's in our workplaces or in our schools, in our organisations,
00:38:51 we don't have to essentially capitulate to this thinking.
00:38:56 It would take a bit of guts then, weren't it, for people?
00:38:58 No, I think it does take guts, but I think nothing worthwhile is easy, especially something as precious as the society that we have today.
00:39:09 And I think hopefully that will inspire people to perhaps become much more active participants in shaping and defending what we value.
00:39:18 Perfect. On that note, thank you very, very much. Thanks.
00:39:20 Thank you for that. Next week, we'll be back.
00:39:25 in the meantime I'd like as I always do at these programs to remind you of our campaign
00:39:31 saveourstatues.org.uk please do subscribe to that as well as subscribing to this
00:39:39 it's obviously going great guns so thank you very much and see you next week