New Culture Forum - September 21, 2020


Moralitis - Is Woke Groupthink A Mental Malady? Can A Cultural 'Virus' Be Cured?

Nick Buckley MBE - Sacked For Criticising BLM Despite Helping 1000s Of Children Britain Is Being Racialised By The Left Through Toxic Identity Politics & Victimhood Mentality

Episode Stats


Length

51 minutes

Words per minute

173.26

Word count

8,861

Sentence count

266


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to Counterculture. I'm Peter Whittle. Now, Covid is not the only virus that's
00:00:19 dominating our country and our news at the moment. There's a new one in town, it's called Moralitis.
00:00:25 It is in fact the title of a new book, Moralitis, a Cultural Virus, which aims to explain why wokeism and why political correctness and indeed why hard left ideology appears to have taken such root and is dominating all of our discourse at the moment.
00:00:46 Now we're going to be looking at the roots of this virus and indeed how we can possibly eradicate it.
00:00:52 With me to discuss this, I have Robert Olds, who is director of the Bruges Group, and he is one of the authors.
00:00:59 His co-author is Dr. Neil McRae, Mark Sidwell, who wrote the New Culture Forum publication The Long March,
00:01:09 and Rafe Hadle-Manku of the New Culture Forum, historian and commentator.
00:01:14 This is a very arresting title, so I wonder if it is a virus, where did it originate? Presumably not in Wuhan.
00:01:22 Well, you can argue that the virus came from the French left bank, but really it began with the Frankfurt School in the 1920s, even before the First World War.
00:01:32 They put this out there as a way of trying to win the culture war, as a way of creating a communist revolution or a socialist revolution to overthrow the old order.
00:01:43 And Hemingway himself said that first things happen gradually, then they happen suddenly.
00:01:48 This has been out there, it's been in operation, it's been gradually infecting people, it's been fermenting, the virus has been mutating and getting more and more virile and driving more and more people into a state of a mental malady that's really now beginning to have a massive impact on our society.
00:02:07 And we see this in the United States at the moment.
00:02:09 We see it in the United Kingdom with Extinction Rebellion
00:02:12 and the acceptance almost in some quarters of political violence,
00:02:16 terrorism even, which is the official term for political violence.
00:02:22 We see it in the United States where Black Lives Matter are running amok,
00:02:26 which they all have a political agenda.
00:02:29 And that agenda is the overthrow of things which we hold dear,
00:02:33 such as capitalism, free markets, free enterprise, representative government and democracy,
00:02:40 the rule of law.
00:02:41 They want to smash these things as well as our loyalty to institutions and beliefs
00:02:46 such as the faith, family and the flag.
00:02:49 And they think that out of this chaos there will be some better society that will come out of it.
00:02:53 That's really the agenda that was put out there originally
00:02:56 when moralitis, the virus that we've identified, would put into our society
00:03:00 and it's now creating havoc.
00:03:02 Neil, when you say moralitis, why moralitis? Why are you calling it that?
00:03:11 Well, in the book we describe this long process that Roberts just mentioned, going back to the critical theorists of the Frankfurt School.
00:03:20 Basically, they introduced cultural Marxism. They realised that the civil democracies of Western Europe wouldn't be persuaded by overt revolutionary rhetoric, so they needed to be persuaded in other ways.
00:03:38 and that nothing really changes unless the culture changes.
00:03:42 So what we had was the beginnings of cultural Marxism in the 1920s.
00:03:47 But this is a stake that has kind of slivered through stealth through Western society.
00:03:53 And if you talk to what we call woke younger people now, they wouldn't call themselves Marxist.
00:04:01 So this is, in fact, success of cultural Marxism.
00:04:05 It's managed to work, it's managed to weave its way into the fabric of our society without being named as such.
00:04:15 And so cultural Marxism is something which is obviously very, very destructive, but it's a Marxist wolf in very fluffy sheep's clothing.
00:04:28 Like Covid, most people don't know they're infected.
00:04:31 Yes. So if you look at the terms, I've often used the term progressive liberal establishment, and I've often quite naively treated those terms progressive and liberal as interchangeable.
00:04:44 And what we've seen very recently with Black Lives Matter and the response to the coronavirus is that those in the establishment, the intelligentsia who call themselves liberal, are not very liberal at all.
00:05:01 And you'll see very recently in the likes of The Guardian, the word liberal has almost disappeared from the discourse.
00:05:09 they no longer even need to pretend that they're liberal it's all about the progressive side now
00:05:15 the progressive track it's all about change and that change when you strip away the veneer is
00:05:23 cultural marxism and they take a viewpoint to politics it's not about the rational arguments
00:05:29 the evidence or debate and compromise that we would reach in politics it's all about taking
00:05:35 a moral position and they think they are morally superior and can impose their will on other
00:05:41 people. And all progressive movements took some moral high ground and spread through
00:05:47 saying there's people on the inside which is us, we speak the correct language, we are
00:05:52 woke, we know the correct terms, we know how to navigate our way through woke politics
00:05:58 and then there's people on the outside who don't use such terms and they are the ones
00:06:03 to be shamed they're the little people who are not as sophisticated as us not morally enlightened
00:06:08 they're lesser both socially and morally and this is how one way important way how it spreads that's
00:06:15 one of the main justifications for socialist movements now or even communism or in back in
00:06:22 the in the 1930s or 40s the the nazis argued that they were morally superior now of course it's just
00:06:28 just the communists who just say well okay our system might not have worked it didn't work
00:06:32 we created poverty but it was somehow morally better because capitalism had exploitation as
00:06:39 if you know their system didn't but they would they only really argue it on on moral ground
00:06:43 because there's actually no real evidence so that's one reason why the sort of we use the term
00:06:47 moralitis it's people taking a position and arguing that they are somehow superior to others
00:06:54 because they use the correct terms whereas we don't um mark you know you read the long march
00:07:01 Neil and Robert you seem to be putting pretty much at the Frankfurt School's you know feet
00:07:10 this whole thing your analysis is slightly different isn't it in in when we're talking
00:07:15 about the long march yeah but I mean I think it's related I mean we both in our books talk about the
00:07:21 Frankfurt School and I think you know this book does does two things extremely well the I understand
00:07:25 that the virus reference isn't isn't actually driven by the pandemic but that's certainly
00:07:29 very timely and it helps to get the point across very nicely and I think it understands quite well
00:07:36 where we are and the sort of craziness of the current position we've ended up in and the
00:07:42 origins of the Frankfurt School. Maybe something that I sort of take a slightly more different
00:07:48 tack on is the history of how we got from there to here. I mean there are more sort of direct,
00:07:53 maybe slightly more conspiratorial than you're suggesting but I don't think there's a direct
00:07:59 route necessarily from the frankfurt school to where we've ended up but it's unquestionably
00:08:03 they would have been glad to see where we've ended up and it's true that the the direct
00:08:08 marxism goes away though of course it's important to say that uh it's not very far below the surface
00:08:14 if you're looking at black lives matters if you're looking at extinction rebellion these are both
00:08:18 openly marxist organizations really uh socialism communism are you know waiting in the wings in
00:08:25 in Novara media and people like Jeremy Corbyn. So all of this cultural Marxist stuff does
00:08:31 lead back in the end to, very quickly, to people who have socialist, even communist
00:08:38 goals. So that's worth saying. I mean, something I think is worth thinking about today that
00:08:45 isn't, the infection model maybe doesn't capture perfectly, I mean every metaphor has
00:08:49 its limits, is there's a lot of suppression that's going on as well. So yes, there's
00:08:53 disinfection, people are picking up these ideas because they're fashionable or whatever, but also
00:08:57 it's not that everyone agrees, it's that there are quite a lot of people who are being frightened
00:09:01 into keeping their mouths shut or indeed into saying what they know isn't true. And it's
00:09:08 important to understand that's going on as well. Can I explain about the illness metaphor? Because
00:09:12 I think it's very important that we've been talking about cultural Marxism and talking about
00:09:16 as if it's a deliberate process. We divide moralitis into people who are contagious,
00:09:24 real shrill zealots, people who are real active proselytizers for cultural Marxism.
00:09:32 They're a minority. They're a minority. Most people in society who are afflicted with moralitis
00:09:39 are what we call carriers so whereas the contagious super spreaders are the ones
00:09:45 that assert their authority in the establishment and get promoted into high
00:09:49 positions and the likes of the BBC and they get promoted in universities and
00:09:53 our other institutions most people including the younger generations who
00:09:59 don't have positions of power they are carriers they're going with the flow and
00:10:03 you said mark a lot of that is about fear that they they they will just comply but there's no
00:10:10 doubt that if you talk to some younger people who we would class as moralitic or woke they really
00:10:18 have internalized a lot of these very subversive ideas can i it's interesting in the in your book
00:10:26 here which uh there's a fair amount of wry humor i think in your is that right to say as well but
00:10:31 You say here super spreaders. They're most likely to be found in the following places. Critical social sciences, women's studies, medical studies, black studies, student unions, campaigners for minority social justice causes, momentum in the Labour Party, teacher training institutes and teacher unions, the arts, the marketing industry, and the Duke and Duchess of Sussex.
00:11:00 so that brings me to you
00:11:03 this thing
00:11:05 is discriminating isn't it
00:11:07 in the sense that it doesn't affect everybody
00:11:09 we were talking about people being
00:11:11 who are the people who would be
00:11:13 most infected with this and do you think
00:11:15 well it's most present
00:11:17 and prevalent in our national
00:11:19 institutions and in our departments
00:11:21 of education when that is really the core
00:11:23 that's the black heart of where this happens
00:11:25 you may say the pathogen was created
00:11:27 in the Frankfurt School
00:11:29 but it's schools in general which are actually the petri dishes that are breeding this as i've
00:11:34 said recently you know give me a man and give me a boy till he's seven and i'll show you the man
00:11:38 but we now have a system whereby we have a boy from the age of zero to 18 or 21 who is being
00:11:44 infected and exposed and you know to this viral load of moralitis when he's not a boy anymore
00:11:49 he decides he's going to become someone of the gender exactly exactly and well does the virus
00:11:54 actually promote abnormalities on that level.
00:11:58 But I think what's happening, though,
00:11:59 is not only is this a question of moralitis,
00:12:01 it's a question of demoralising as well.
00:12:03 That's one of the after-effects.
00:12:04 You know, Yuri Besmanov, the former KGB official
00:12:07 who was actually a teacher along with Jordan Peterson
00:12:09 at my old university,
00:12:11 wrote about this process by which the KGB
00:12:12 would try to destabilise societies by demoralising them.
00:12:16 And whether this whole process has been one of conspiracy
00:12:19 or whether it's merely the disastrous convergence
00:12:23 of different accidents.
00:12:27 We are in this position where they actually have taken control
00:12:29 over these institutions, and the effect is a destabilizing of society
00:12:32 through demoralizing it, and it's an effort to supplant
00:12:36 the existing orthodoxies and the existing ideologies
00:12:38 and the existing morality with one that's entirely foreign.
00:12:42 And the problem there, ultimately, of course,
00:12:44 is that you weaken the national body,
00:12:46 and once you weaken the national body, you expose it to other pathogens.
00:12:50 And, you know, when you have systems of mass immigration
00:12:52 with other cultural values coming in,
00:12:54 suddenly the existing body isn't able to defend itself
00:12:56 against these foreign interventions.
00:12:59 And I think that's really the larger problem.
00:13:02 The woke brigade may not actually win,
00:13:04 but they may weaken the existing national body so much so
00:13:07 that it's open to defeat in other ways.
00:13:10 Yes, I mean, there's certainly a big theme in my book is
00:13:12 the institutions that get taken over by these ideas
00:13:17 become so obsessed with them,
00:13:19 lose track of the things that they're actually there to do in the first place.
00:13:21 And it's one of the terrifying things to find ourselves, you know, in the middle of this pandemic, dealing with the virus.
00:13:28 And all of our national institutions seem to be not very good at their jobs, but very good at, you know, all the moralitic, as you say, things, worrying about those, but not actually the things they should be doing.
00:13:39 I think actually the British state has been exposed as being alarmingly weak, isn't it?
00:13:45 I mean, when I say weakened, you know, as you say, in all of its responses, it seems entirely incompetent now.
00:13:52 I mean, what I wanted to ask earlier with this is that you were talking about, you know, how the body becomes weakened.
00:13:59 If you're talking about the society, the country, isn't half of the problem the lack of resistance from people who should be resisting?
00:14:07 I mean, i.e. your Conservative Party, for example.
00:14:10 Well, absolutely, but weakening the body politic, weakening the society making it more vulnerable to other infections.
00:14:18 Of course, one of the main implications, one of the main symptoms of moralitis is, of course, a failure to, or lack of,
00:14:26 turn the nation state into the enemy that you want to undermine, the institution that has nurtured freedom in this country,
00:14:31 the most inclusive identity, the nation state, is being undermined, and they open, they support mass immigration.
00:14:38 And ultimately, that could really be the death knell of wokeism, not through people resisting it from within the UK, but really replacing in a sense that by inviting in more people from developing nations who come from cultures who are distinctly conservative, very, very strictly conservative.
00:14:58 conservative and this gives a sort of a change because they will believe that immigrants would
00:15:02 be there as agents of some kind of revolutionary change they may find that it will be actually a
00:15:06 very different revolution if indeed there were to be completely open borders which of course
00:15:12 don't actually exist in the uk at the moment there is there isn't complete open free immigration
00:15:16 neither neither is there in sweden but of course the balance is changing and so there is going to
00:15:21 be a cultural shift and it's going to be very different to what the what the woke brigade as
00:15:26 it were have been have imagined you can draw a parallel slightly with the iranian revolution
00:15:31 right where you had this alliance between the left-leaning students and the right wing ayatollahs
00:15:37 to overthrow and topple the shah's regime and the idea that the students were expecting this
00:15:42 new valhalla to be ushered in by it but of course they were the first ones to be strung up another
00:15:47 way around looking at that and the assumption is that the new groups socially conservative religious
00:15:56 perhaps uh will you know be very very strange bedfellows and and and the woke are going to get
00:16:01 a shot well what about if the woke turn around and actually adapt those cultures i mean the novelist
00:16:09 uh michelle huelbeck uh in his a recent book yeah talked exactly about that that in fact you know
00:16:15 these liberal academics at the sobon uh this was in submission sorry uh actually they convert to
00:16:21 Islam and it's great. He's got two or three brides, he's got all the rest of it. You can
00:16:28 see that happening can't you? I'm not sure that I can see that happening except in you
00:16:32 know what is I admit a very good novel but but it seems to me that what's much more likely
00:16:37 is that I mean we're talking about immigration we're still talking about relatively small
00:16:41 numbers and we're talking about numbers that go into very tight communities and self-segregate.
00:16:47 So that's really what happens, I think, is that it becomes separated, and the important
00:16:51 thing is that these intellectual networks, the universities and the schools impart those
00:16:57 values to new generations, and that I think is much more powerful and resistant to other
00:17:03 cultural forces that might be around, partly because people, the young, the new generation
00:17:08 start to learn what they should say if they want to get on, if they want girlfriends,
00:17:12 boyfriends, jobs, all the rest of it, so that I think is an extremely powerful force.
00:17:17 Well, this is why we sort of can come back on to the Duke and Duchess of Sussex.
00:17:21 Some people are particularly vulnerable to moralitis because they are either A, on the make,
00:17:27 or B, they just want to get on, or of course C, they find that they will adapt to the most intolerant ideology.
00:17:34 To be woke is to have a great deal of power over other people because you can shut them down in an instant.
00:17:42 You can just say, I disagree with what you're saying, you are racist, you are transphobic,
00:17:46 or any other name that could be associated with a mental illness
00:17:51 gives a great deal of power to people
00:17:53 and really it's those who are authoritarian in their nature
00:17:57 will adopt moralitis and the symptoms that come with it
00:18:01 because it gives them the opportunity to impose their will on other people.
00:18:05 So it's not that these are the same people who in other circumstances
00:18:08 would have been backing the Nazis
00:18:10 or would have been backing state communism in Eastern Europe
00:18:14 because it gave them an opportunity to lord it over other people
00:18:17 and they thought they were morally superior and progressive.
00:18:20 And to do that, you need to have a mindset that you only see moral absolutes
00:18:25 and that there is only right and wrong
00:18:28 and that you are somehow morally superior and should be respected,
00:18:32 should receive the benefits of your moral superiority and your social superiority
00:18:36 and have the opportunity to lord it over other people.
00:18:40 In which case, if there is just a new intolerant ideology that comes along,
00:18:44 they will adopt that.
00:18:45 This just happens to be,
00:18:47 mobilitis just happens to be the most
00:18:49 intolerant ideology of our age
00:18:51 and that's why people are
00:18:53 jumping onto it. And sugared over
00:18:55 the top of course. And as soon as another
00:18:57 intolerant ideology comes and if the state
00:18:59 ideology changes, they will move
00:19:01 as quickly as possible. But I think we should be careful
00:19:03 about saying they. I mean, the reason
00:19:05 it works so much is it's us.
00:19:08 It's part of human nature, yes.
00:19:10 Being human is that, you know,
00:19:11 it's the mob psychology
00:19:13 And Jordan Peterson is very good on this.
00:19:15 I think, you know, you should always think about, you know, the Nazis and think to yourself, I would have been a member of the Nazi party.
00:19:21 Maybe I wouldn't have been, you know, out there in the front, but I probably would have been because most people were.
00:19:26 And that's how it goes.
00:19:27 Jesus Christ was, you know, crucified by his people.
00:19:31 That's how people are.
00:19:33 So these intolerant ideologies are precisely so dangerous because there's something in you, me, everyone around this table, even,
00:19:40 who are, there's something seductive there that can get to us.
00:19:44 Or even if you just want to get on,
00:19:45 if you want to navigate your way through school and university
00:19:48 and come out with a good grade
00:19:50 and then get a job now in the City of London
00:19:52 in a financial services or a law firm,
00:19:55 you're going to have to be parroting these lines.
00:19:57 You're going to have to go into diversity training.
00:20:00 You're going to have to be saying the official sort of state ideology.
00:20:06 You're going to have to be talking about your unconscious bias
00:20:07 and apologising endlessly for your white privilege
00:20:10 or whatever privilege you believe that you have
00:20:14 as a way of advancing through the system.
00:20:17 And that's really one of the key aspects.
00:20:20 So some people in Eastern Europe supported communism,
00:20:23 not because they were really deep-down communists,
00:20:25 it's because they just wanted to progress.
00:20:28 They wanted what was best for their families.
00:20:29 They wanted to have the opportunity to have a better life.
00:20:33 And to do that, they had to have their party card
00:20:36 and they had to show and feign their support.
00:20:40 And if we're going to sort of, you mentioned Jesus Christ,
00:20:43 but in there, in the Bible,
00:20:46 Jesus sort of speaks about the hypocrites
00:20:49 and people who would be praying in public
00:20:50 and how awful that was.
00:20:52 This is exactly the same phenomenon
00:20:53 as people showing that they have some moral superiority
00:20:56 over others, all as a way of advancing themselves
00:20:59 and advancing their position in society
00:21:01 and, at the end of the day, their own economic clout as well.
00:21:05 But Peter, you ask where is the Conservative Party in all of this?
00:21:08 And I think that is one of the greatest tragedies of Covid,
00:21:11 was the fact that you had a party with a huge amount of public support,
00:21:15 a huge majority, and really had the opportunity to effect real change here.
00:21:19 And unfortunately, Covid arrived out of the blue.
00:21:22 I mean, you know, expect the unexpected and completely sideswiped the government.
00:21:28 A government that was really very nimble.
00:21:30 It was really much a cabinet government in name only.
00:21:33 We know Dominic Cummings is the real power behind the force.
00:21:36 Boris Johnson is not really a conservative socially in any way whatsoever,
00:21:41 but Dominic Cummings had his ear to the ground.
00:21:43 He knew full well that the Tory party would be facing an existential crisis
00:21:46 if it wasn't able to actually connect with the socially conservative Red Wall of the past.
00:21:52 And, you know, just as Tony Blair started a 10-year revolution from 1997,
00:21:57 this was supposed to be, really, ideally, the 10 years
00:21:59 with which you could have actually had a real attempt to combat this rise of wokery.
00:22:06 And yet we're seeing so much support for the Tory party hemorrhaging now
00:22:09 that you wonder whether they actually will have a full 10 years to actually try to institute.
00:22:14 There's some positive things we've seen, really, with the civil service and with the BBC being restructured.
00:22:19 And that needs to go across all of the quangos, the public institutions.
00:22:23 Teacher training colleges need to be restructured.
00:22:25 Universities need to be given full warnings on this.
00:22:27 Cancel culture needs to be declared war on.
00:22:29 And, you know, just as Trump gave that terrific speech that he did on July the 4th in front of Mount Rushmore,
00:22:35 with the best speech of his entire presidency, standing up for American values and for traditional values and for common sense and reason,
00:22:42 this is an opportunity we have here to do exactly the same sort of thing.
00:22:45 And leadership is sorely lacking.
00:22:47 Well, and not only lacking, but, I mean, remarkably illiberal in the approach to, well, to COVID, first of all,
00:22:53 and to other things like lifestyle values as well.
00:22:56 Boris Johnson going from being someone who's anti-nanny state
00:22:59 to bring on the nanny state to slim us all down.
00:23:02 Well, the Conservative Party surrendered and went over to the other side
00:23:06 in the culture war in the early noughties, for nearly 20 years now.
00:23:10 Oh, I'd say earlier than that.
00:23:12 Of course, under Thatcher, there was a failure to realise
00:23:16 that the long march through the institutions was underway
00:23:19 and just thought that freeing up the market and trying to make civil servants
00:23:23 act in a way that mimicked the private sector was enough. Of course it was a complete failure
00:23:29 because it failed to realise the enemy that was working away and rotting at the system.
00:23:33 But then in the Conservative Party itself and some very prominent people in the Conservative Party
00:23:38 at the top of our government today had embraced cultural Marxism. The book A Blue Tomorrow which
00:23:43 was published shortly after the 2001 general election. Lordid Gramsci spoke about that in
00:23:50 In a justification for the recent Conservative policy that was praising FDR, again, there
00:23:56 was this idolising of Gramsci and thought that if we had to play this game, and instead
00:24:02 of looking at issues which affect ordinary people, the voters, the things that really
00:24:09 matter such as the economy or education, there was this navel gazing and this belief that
00:24:14 they had to go down the path of identity politics.
00:24:18 So for much of the Conservative Party, they're almost sort of being hoist by their own petard
00:24:22 because if you play the other side's game, they win because they're the ones that are setting the rules.
00:24:27 So the Conservative Party did, as you mentioned, Rafe, to have this great opportunity
00:24:30 to break down the Red Wall and embrace social conservatism
00:24:34 and put something back into our society, rebuild our society,
00:24:38 but it had already given up too much to the identitarians who want to spread division.
00:24:44 And there used to be so much sort of talk about, oh, we have to be more inclusive in the Conservative Party and we have to – it was all just a self-criticism.
00:24:52 We had even the person who criticised Conservatives who gave the term – invented the term the nasty party, which was used against us for years.
00:25:02 They even elected that woman as leader. That's how bad the situation was.
00:25:06 thankfully they you know she was shown that it wasn't really up to the job which i'm sure
00:25:13 she would agree with now but the conservative party really does have to be the party that's
00:25:19 going to be rebuilding our society and instead of it has to move away from this this belief that
00:25:25 they need to play the other side's game well i think i think that i would say we've discussed
00:25:30 this with him on the show for i think they just many of them still don't quite understand it
00:25:34 I just think that they haven't just, you know, basically surrendered.
00:25:39 Quite often they, you know, how many times in the arts have you heard,
00:25:43 oh, well, you know, arty, you know, they're arty types, they tend to be left.
00:25:47 You know, no, this is a different order that we're talking about here,
00:25:52 a different order entirely.
00:25:53 Rafe was talking about what needed to be done and how it might not be done now.
00:25:58 You actually have specific ideas in this book, which are a lot dissimilar,
00:26:03 but I mean it's interesting because I mean they will resonate with people you
00:26:08 talk about you know the promotion of plain speak you know how would you
00:26:15 promote plain speak and well you know what would you what would you give us an
00:26:21 example as plain speak we make the point to the general point about remedies how
00:26:26 we reverse this march through the institutions how we how we remedy this
00:26:31 this illness is about the first thing is awareness so the patient has to know that they're ill yeah
00:26:38 and the doctor has to know that there's a disease to be treated so we have to have awareness that
00:26:45 something has gone very badly wrong and language is of course so powerful to cultural marxists
00:26:53 you know control the language you control the debate and and we use so i'm not sure it's the
00:26:59 the best example but something i was thinking about on the way here today was this term
00:27:03 political correctness so i've always um issued that term i've never liked it because it it's
00:27:11 it actually does it actually a communist term isn't it that's where it comes from but the most
00:27:16 people don't know that and most people use the word as something which is oh it's a bit of a
00:27:23 burden you have to watch how you say things and all that but it sounds like it's actually a good
00:27:28 thing really political correctness and well-meaning yes indeed indeed and it it's like a a euphemism
00:27:38 which um people even if they're sort of mildly criticizing it they think that um you know
00:27:44 underlyingly it's a good thing and and i think that we need to get away from these
00:27:53 um terms that are like masking the wolf in sheep's clothing and i think it's a good thing
00:28:00 that we are now using the term woke because what has happened to woke five years ago people were
00:28:07 calling themselves woke on the left as a good thing now they know it's been discredited hardly
00:28:16 anyone is using that term the thing is i i'd agree with that the problem is i think it's exactly
00:28:21 same with political correctness very few people would call themselves oh i'm i'm politically
00:28:26 correct and proud i mean the point is you know they become terms of humor and abuse but they are
00:28:33 still so powerful that everyone abides by them yes but i think there isn't enough laughter is useful
00:28:38 though you know laughter is it's a good sort of um way of clearing the air i mean the the cover of
00:28:44 the book has the the npc uh meme on it which was extremely successful on the internet the idea of
00:28:50 of people who have adopted this ideology becoming non-player characters in a computer game who
00:28:54 don't have any mind themselves. This is a very harsh criticism but very funny and got some
00:29:00 traction precisely because of what it spoke to, what people were giving up to be part of the
00:29:04 ideology. And that does carry some weight. Titania McGrath on Twitter. But I grant you it's not the
00:29:12 complete solution. I mean I think there probably are things, it doesn't seem like he's going to
00:29:17 do any of them there are things that Boris Johnson could do but I mean one
00:29:21 that struck me in there there was another one that was something to do
00:29:24 with you know using the power of the state to control some of the sort of
00:29:29 ideological spread within the civil service and places like that now Donald
00:29:32 Trump in America just a few days ago maybe a week ago has said it's more as a
00:29:36 gesture but it does lay down a marker said federal workers can't be trained
00:29:42 into critical race theory uh and against sort of unconscious bias uh in in federal agencies that
00:29:48 that seems like a good marker to sort of use the bully pulpit of the state to stop that sort of
00:29:53 thing from happening uh but i i sincerely doubt that's going to happen charles moore wrote an
00:29:59 article in the telegraph saying the civil service has become uh you know completely infected with
00:30:03 woke um civil service or critical theorists obsessed by race and we've actually got a
00:30:09 got a questionnaire in the book to spot these people and uh we need to you know so they can
00:30:14 we can identify who has been infected and who's uh who's sort of adopted this this this ideology
00:30:20 who's got moralitis so of course we can then look at perhaps appointing them into uh into another
00:30:26 career because this is the they believe that anything from the conservative party is bad
00:30:33 uh anything anything that's part of the existing structures anything that's a great institution
00:30:37 when the Conservative Party goes back hundreds of years,
00:30:40 that must in its history, so therefore that must be done away with.
00:30:44 And the civil service will stymie everything from this government,
00:30:47 water it down and wreck it at every opportunity,
00:30:50 purely for the sake of doing that.
00:30:52 So we really do need to reform the civil service,
00:30:55 and if the government needs to be very much on top of this,
00:30:57 I know the will is there, but they need to adopt our questionnaire
00:31:02 just to identify who are the ones that are infected.
00:31:04 Because this week alone you've had, whilst you've had Trump speaking out against critical race theory,
00:31:08 you've had in the British Parliament £4,000 being spent on unconscious bias training.
00:31:14 And as someone pointed out, what is the point of having an 80-seat majority
00:31:16 if you can't actually stop this happening within your own workplace?
00:31:20 I think, one, you're talking about speech again, Neil,
00:31:24 I think, one, you can sort of turn it on its head and say you can actually identify these people by some of the words they use.
00:31:30 So, for example, the word, you know, you were talking about political correctness being communist in origin,
00:31:37 but, you know, the word problematic is always used now.
00:31:41 Something is problematic.
00:31:43 They don't actually say this is wrong or we're going to give it, this is problematic, this is concerning.
00:31:49 You know, these sorts of words, which sound very sort of, they sound almost mild,
00:31:54 but that is a way of spotting.
00:31:56 Inappropriate is another one.
00:31:57 Yes, inappropriate, that's an old favourite.
00:32:00 What's interesting as well in your book, I found actually one of the most interesting
00:32:06 parts was that at the end you go into great depth into the armed forces actually and I
00:32:13 think you know I looked at it and thought well you know that's worth another book actually.
00:32:17 But I've always sort of tended to hope that that is the one area where basically you know
00:32:25 things haven't basically been invaded but it's not the case is it well no it was a case that the
00:32:32 the police have fallen now the now you the police are you know they're essentially they're the
00:32:37 militant wing of the guardian newspaper and as they've become more and more in woke they've
00:32:42 become more and more intolerant and more and more militarized and the police forces uh that are in
00:32:47 in regimes such as scotland which are the most woke they're the most uh can be the most vicious
00:32:52 police forces and they literally arrest more than 3 000 people each year for things they put out
00:32:57 electronic communications that the the state doesn't you know deems uh inappropriate or
00:33:04 problematic uh and the armed forces is also now going through this whole process the fire brigade
00:33:10 of that fell long ago you know their standards you know they've got lower standards now for
00:33:14 women and and people of different ethnicities to become a fire for what used to be called a fireman
00:33:22 The armed forces is now falling.
00:33:24 There's something called the Wigston Report into inappropriate behaviours
00:33:27 where they look at spotting people who may be right-wing
00:33:31 and maybe one of the signs that they have to clamp down on
00:33:36 is the people who are patriotic.
00:33:39 They've got to watch out for patriotic people
00:33:40 and working-class young men who may have traditional values.
00:33:44 They are now, in a sense, public enemy number one in the armed forces
00:33:48 and their behaviour is being firmly watched.
00:33:50 so what would you if you know this is top brass stuff so isn't it basically the same as what's
00:33:57 been happening in the church you know well it's not really top brass stuff because the
00:34:01 the army top brass know that this is wrong because the army top brass as you've said
00:34:06 they've got fighting experience they know exactly what's required you need to have
00:34:09 the very best physical specimens of the nation fighting forces but you've got management
00:34:15 consultants coming in you've got these non-military appointments being brought in
00:34:20 to shape up the army as if it's any other institution.
00:34:22 The army is not any other institution.
00:34:25 It's a very unique set of skills you have to have
00:34:27 if you're actually going to be prepared to kill another person.
00:34:30 And the idea that you can simply just introduce
00:34:34 a whole, you know, regulations about inappropriate behaviour
00:34:37 when the behaviour of the army is by instinct,
00:34:40 inappropriate by our domestic civil standards,
00:34:43 but they're in situations which require inappropriate actions by our standards.
00:34:47 But the army top brass understand this full well,
00:34:48 And the army top brass has spoken out against the fact that women have lower physical requirements
00:34:53 when clearly they're not up to the task required for those front-line positions.
00:34:58 But, I mean, something I talk about in my book is that not just in the army,
00:35:02 but in all of these institutions, really a large part of the problem, I think,
00:35:05 has been the growth of managerialism, as you say, management consultants,
00:35:09 but it's often people who are employed directly as well,
00:35:12 because the problem is that precisely takes all these institutions,
00:35:15 which, you know, the NHS, the church, whatever,
00:35:17 They all have their own distinctive professional cultures, the things that they're there to do, the police.
00:35:23 And then it says, no, no, no, there are these universal managerial approaches, and we're going to bring in ideas from elsewhere.
00:35:29 And it'll be the same ideas in every place, and we'll take away your distinctive culture and your distinctive goals,
00:35:35 and we'll replace it with these universal, apparently anodyne, apparently very neutral managerial virtues.
00:35:41 and that's how every single institution becomes lousy at its job and becomes taken over by the
00:35:46 same ideas and it's very difficult to fight against and you know the military perhaps seemed
00:35:53 better at holding its own because it has such a very distinctive culture but we shall see it's
00:35:59 not good news. It's interesting that when the army took on the they had various different
00:36:06 attempts at advertising campaigns and there was one which was just you know
00:36:11 caused uproar because it showed I think a soldier stopping to pray a Muslim
00:36:17 soldier stopping to pray in the middle of battlefield and you know and this was
00:36:21 sort of just you know so completely unreal and the other soldiers are told
00:36:27 not to answer the radio while he's doing all of this they stopped their mission
00:36:32 yes but the one that they followed that was um one which was aimed fair and square at the woke
00:36:39 younger generation if you remember do you remember this it was like aimed at soy boys and people
00:36:44 like that and sotty do you know the one i mean that was a huge success for them it was a huge
00:36:50 success how do you account for that well this is one of the reasons why companies as well end up
00:36:57 being taken over by these ideas it comes in through the hr departments and it's partly because the hr
00:37:01 departments are less connected to you know the professional goals and ideals of these companies
00:37:06 but it's also because they want to recruit young people and the universities are you know very
00:37:11 strong breeding grounds of these ideas so in order to recruit they feel that they have to
00:37:17 celebrate these ideas to bring in to bring in the new generation of workers so that that doesn't help
00:37:23 but what happened to celebrating people uh giving them an opportunity to better themselves to excel
00:37:29 to be aspirational, to see the world, to have an attractive uniform, to be fitter and stronger
00:37:36 than other people which is attractive to the opposite sex and what about celebrating
00:37:40 those things which the army recruited on, proven biological reasons that young men are interested
00:37:47 in and that something a working class lad from Luton can aspire to be something better and serve
00:37:53 his nation rather than a woke ideology in a structured environment. It will give him discipline
00:37:58 and something that he needs, that would be a greater social benefit.
00:38:04 It would be a stabilising force in this country.
00:38:07 It would give people something to believe in
00:38:08 and then they would have the opportunity to go back into their communities
00:38:11 and be proud and strong and upstanding members of society
00:38:16 as we would expect most soldiers to be.
00:38:19 That would be a lot better rather than giving in to this woke ideology.
00:38:23 And I think, Mark, you make the point there that employers believe that they have to get all their recruits from university.
00:38:31 And I think that's got to change, one of the things that's got to change.
00:38:34 And I think that increasing numbers of employers are realising that people who've gone to university are not three years better than the people that haven't.
00:38:45 In fact, in many ways, they're three years worse, because these universities, and I'm not just talking about the former polytechnics here, I'm talking about Russell Group universities, are acting these days like madrassas.
00:39:00 I mean, it doesn't matter what course you do at a university, it could be a STEM subject, you'll still get all this unconscious bias stuff.
00:39:09 the whole culture it's pervasive all this woke ideology for any student whatever
00:39:16 they're studying so I think if I were an employer I'd be thinking rather than do psychometric tests
00:39:24 weed out people with supposed far-right views as you mentioned Robert for the army
00:39:29 psychometric tests to weed out the woke because they're going to come in and cause trouble
00:39:37 The last thing we want to do is have an army out there of woke, armed soldiers,
00:39:43 which are deeply politicised, see things, they're not there to obey orders,
00:39:46 they're there to impose their will on other people.
00:39:51 But even in a small business, in fact maybe it's even more important in a small business,
00:39:56 where you've got a good team that harmoniously work together and could be actually very diverse,
00:40:01 but you bring in someone who is full of this woke ideology they can cause a lot of difficulty.
00:40:08 Oh yes, definitely and one of the distinctive things about it I think is the moral authority
00:40:13 that the people who are instructing that way feel at a very young age and the need that older
00:40:19 people who should you know have more authority feel to defer to them. It's the power of the young
00:40:23 which is it's quite like the cultural revolution and Mao and you know struggle sessions of
00:40:28 of young students, Red Guards over old people.
00:40:32 It does feel a bit like that.
00:40:33 I mean, it astonishes me slightly
00:40:34 that very powerful people will now defer to the young woke.
00:40:39 I'm not quite sure why they still have that authority
00:40:42 over the old, but they do seem to.
00:40:46 Just briefly to round off,
00:40:48 however this situation came,
00:40:51 whether it was absolutely pure Long March,
00:40:54 whether it was more random, however,
00:40:56 we've ended up with now um and it causes people utter bewilderment and and despair i would say
00:41:02 actually uh how long have we got to change it seriously how long you know you know are we
00:41:12 talking generations or how long have we actually got before the rot is too deep
00:41:19 well i've said already in the next 10 years as far as i'm concerned is the time to do it because
00:41:23 Because those people under 25 at the last election, if they had been the only ones to vote, there would have been something like an 80% majority for the Labour Party.
00:41:34 Nobody in that age group has any interest in the Conservative Party because they've been through this education system where they're taught that Toryism is evil and that Tories have no compassion and so forth.
00:41:43 And if that's not addressed by the Tory Party, whose voting base is getting older and older, there will be an existential crisis for the party and for the country.
00:41:52 And so it is a very short period of time.
00:41:53 And I agree with you entirely about the university system.
00:41:56 I mean, people often assume that Brexiteers don't have a university education,
00:42:00 meaning therefore that they're less educated.
00:42:02 But I think very much so is the case that those people who went to university
00:42:05 have been through this madrasa system and have been exposed to these ideologies
00:42:08 and have become dimmer as a result of that.
00:42:12 And so, yeah, it's a very short period of time,
00:42:14 and it has to be a focus primarily on the educational system,
00:42:18 restructuring or getting rid of teacher training colleges completely
00:42:20 and having a different way to train teachers
00:42:22 who aren't exposed to these ideologies
00:42:25 or the post-modernists and post-structuralists.
00:42:29 And then at the university system,
00:42:30 simply ceasing to fund all of these grievance studies courses
00:42:34 so that people aren't exposed to these theories
00:42:36 which have absolutely no basis in science whatsoever.
00:42:39 And any universities that embrace cancel culture,
00:42:42 their funding is ended too.
00:42:44 And that the government should actually reward
00:42:45 or protect those who are cancelled
00:42:47 by giving them other appointments.
00:42:49 There needs to be a real proactive stance taken on this, because if you don't actually have an aggressive stance rather than merely a defensive one, there's no chance at this stage in the game.
00:42:59 That's why you like the virus analogy, because we believe the government needs to treat this as a public health emergency.
00:43:06 We've got outlined how this can be tackled. It's a mental malady.
00:43:10 It's also affecting, genuinely affecting, people's mental health when they get the symptoms of marvellitis.
00:43:19 it can really damage people so we're actually actually helping people as well as saving our
00:43:24 society from from people who are there to wreck it and have put this virus out there to wreck our
00:43:30 sort of civilization i do actually believe we are winning the culture war uh of course they
00:43:36 the other side started it to try and ruin culture to have this year zero which you spoke of this
00:43:41 mark the the and the red guards analogy which is completely very fitting uh they've just changed
00:43:48 the colours of their uniforms in many instances. What we have is they've unleashed this culture war
00:43:56 but to win it, which we are, we do need to fight back, we need to seize the commanding heights,
00:44:03 we need, as Rafe showed, we need to sort of show there is an opportunity, people can
00:44:08 get on in society if they're not woke and indeed actually if they're free thinking,
00:44:12 they have diversity of opinion, they have an open mind as people who aren't infected with
00:44:16 with movilitis have, then there's opportunity for them and people will quickly move, they
00:44:23 will quickly change their position once they see that there is another way and that the
00:44:27 intolerance of movilitis isn't the only way to move up in society. But I think we are
00:44:33 winning the culture war and you can sort of see signs of this on the internet where there
00:44:39 will be sort of certain woke shows or videos which will be ridiculed. Gary Lineker's argument
00:44:46 that because there's fish and chips we should have unlimited immigration into the UK, that
00:44:53 received about a handful of likes and literally thousands of dislikes. Most people are commonsensical
00:45:02 and realise this is an absurd situation we've got ourselves in.
00:45:09 But we really have to stand up.
00:45:11 Otherwise, the minority, because in any system,
00:45:14 the Bolsheviks in Russia were only a small minority,
00:45:18 but they got the commanding heights and imposed their will.
00:45:21 Genuine Nazis were probably only ever, no more than 15%
00:45:25 of the population in Germany and Austria.
00:45:29 Radical Islamists are still probably a minority within Muslim countries,
00:45:34 but aggressive extremists such as the woke or these other movements
00:45:41 can achieve power and impose their will if the 80% who have just let it happen,
00:45:47 and the 80% is very relevant.
00:45:49 George Orwell in 1984, Winston Smith was pleading,
00:45:53 if only the 80% would stand up to the party, we would be free of this.
00:45:58 and so I think we are winning, but we've got to fight back
00:46:02 and we have to seize the commanding heights
00:46:04 and we have to say no more and we can put a stop to this
00:46:07 and hopefully through that there'll be rationality returned to our country again.
00:46:12 I think I at least increasingly feel it's a question of taking away the money.
00:46:17 Like you say about universities,
00:46:20 essentially whether it's your BBC licence,
00:46:24 whether it's the Arts Council or even corporations,
00:46:28 to stop buying Ben and Jerry's or whatever?
00:46:31 I didn't think I'd be the most pessimistic person in the room,
00:46:34 but in a way I am.
00:46:35 I think this talk about winning the culture war is just...
00:46:39 I don't see it.
00:46:40 The culture war is lost.
00:46:41 They own the commanding heights.
00:46:43 They own every single institution.
00:46:45 They are not a large number of people,
00:46:47 but they're a small number of people in control
00:46:49 of all the major elite networks, all the intellectual networks,
00:46:52 and we all have to swim in that world,
00:46:55 and it'll be like that for a while.
00:46:57 and I think you say in the book, you know, it's going to get worse before it gets better.
00:47:01 Now, I do think it'll work out in the end, but I actually see it as a much longer project.
00:47:07 You've got to come up with ideas.
00:47:09 The Frankfurt School, these awful ideas, took a very long time to work their way through.
00:47:14 The free market ideas of Margaret Thatcher, it was a 50-year project or so to bring those through.
00:47:20 We need that again.
00:47:21 Brexit took us decades.
00:47:22 Yeah, exactly, Brexit, exactly the same thing.
00:47:24 So, you know, liberty, common sense, these things, we need new arguments for these in the way that we needed new arguments for the sort of free trade liberalism of the 19th century for the 20th century.
00:47:35 And that is a generational project and that's going to take decades.
00:47:39 But the short term, it's going to be rough.
00:47:43 I mean, I share Robert's optimism and it's an optimism which kind of goes to odds with what a lot of commentators like yourself, Mark, think.
00:47:53 I mean, working in a university, I could see some green shoots coming through, very small number, and they don't get enough support.
00:48:03 But what I see happening now, this year, is some dramatic developments.
00:48:09 So coronavirus was not a cultural Marxist movement, but the response to the coronavirus pandemic has been a boon to cultural Marxism.
00:48:19 And alongside the coronavirus pandemic, we've had the Black Lives Matter movement and we've had also the Extinction Rebellion trying to make the most of this weakness at the moment as well.
00:48:35 but inevitably they have pushed far too far and at the moment they think that their
00:48:42 cause is being advanced by what's going on at the moment. It isn't and I think that young people,
00:48:53 partly for economic reasons because there's a massive carnage that's going to come about
00:48:58 through the coronavirus response, I think younger people are going to realise that their future
00:49:05 is not with woke ideologues who want to shut the universities down,
00:49:11 want to shut the schools down, want to shut the government down,
00:49:14 want to smash down the statues.
00:49:17 Younger people will see that these are not the priorities.
00:49:21 This is not a bright future for them.
00:49:24 Woke ideology is very dark and they'll begin to see the light.
00:49:29 I very, very much hope so.
00:49:31 Plus society naturally produces antibodies,
00:49:34 people who object to the status quo and these people who have differing ideas to the established order
00:49:40 are often, because they're free thinking, often very magnetic personalities that people are drawn to
00:49:46 and these antibodies, the natural parts of society, these contrarians, can really take many people with them.
00:49:55 So really there is a sort of natural defence mechanism within the body politic as it were.
00:50:00 I think that the interesting thing about the movements we're talking about and the trend
00:50:05 is they are apparently totally leaderless.
00:50:09 There is something about that.
00:50:11 There are no charismatic leaders, they don't seem to need this,
00:50:16 which shows you the strength they have in the institutions.
00:50:19 There are no, are there anybody, is there anybody that you can point to
00:50:22 and say that's the famous, that, that and that, there's not.
00:50:25 So it's interesting.
00:50:26 But listen, gentlemen, that's it, I'm afraid.
00:50:29 um but uh thank you very very much for coming in thank you robert neil mark and rafe um and um we
00:50:37 will be discussing this again i can guarantee it maybe two or three times more this year you know
00:50:43 if not more but make a series out of it uh thank you very much for watching um i must ask you two
00:50:50 as well just to have a look at our new campaign site save our statues.org.uk we've had a great
00:50:57 response to it so far in terms of subscription and people donating so
00:51:01 please join them won't you and we'll look forward to seeing you next time thank
00:51:06 you