New Culture Forum - February 08, 2021


Campus Freedom - The Threat To Free Speech In University & Academic Life

The Battle To Preserve Our Statues & Cultural Heritage Is Not Over Despite Positive Gov't Statements Mike Graham: The Media - Past, Present & Future. Tales From The Frontline.

Episode Stats


Length

46 minutes

Words per minute

161.1

Word count

7,536

Sentence count

152

Harmful content

Misogyny

1

sentences flagged

Hate speech

1

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to Counterculture. I'm Peter Whittle. Now universities should be by word for
00:00:18 free speech, original thinking, freedom, but really as we enter 2021 they seem to be the
00:00:26 very opposite of that. Whether you're talking about the academic world, the
00:00:30 orthodoxies there, or whether you're talking about just simple free speech,
00:00:34 people coming to speak at universities. On all of these fronts it appears that
00:00:39 restrictiveness is the order of the day. So this is extremely worrying obviously
00:00:45 for our culture because this is the very very centre of it. Now with me to
00:00:50 discuss these issues I'm very pleased that we have Professor Jeremy Black. He
00:00:55 is Emeritus Professor of History at the University of Exeter. He's also a Senior Fellow at Policy
00:01:02 Exchange on their History Project. He also happens to be the most prolific historian,
00:01:08 having written something like 160 books. Then there is Dr Philip Kisley, who is the Lecturer
00:01:17 in Performance and Cultural History at the University of Leeds, and also has been on the
00:01:22 show a number of times before so it's good to see him and emma webb as usual i'm pleased to say
00:01:28 who is an associate fellow at civitas there are all sorts of aspects as i said in the introduction
00:01:35 to this particular subject of freedom in the academic world on campus can i start by asking
00:01:42 you jeremy uh not that long ago i think phil it was david davis who suggested that there should
00:01:49 be some sort of legislation brought in to guarantee free speech in universities.
00:01:57 This was just a proposal but how did that strike you when you heard that?
00:02:04 Well I think that we all agree about the problem and the problem is that universities,
00:02:10 particularly in the humanities and social sciences, are offering often a very slanted
00:02:15 account and those who don't fit in with that whether they're teachers or students are you
00:02:22 know in difficulties the question is how best to deal with that and that's a different issue
00:02:28 because when i looked at that free speech i thought yes well i could admire that in some
00:02:33 cases but what happens if that is used on behalf of for example a holocaust denier or somebody
00:02:40 of that type so i'm a bit worried about the notion of primary legislation on the matter but i'm very
00:02:46 happy to be convinced i do not have confidence in universities ability to regulate themselves
00:02:53 and in fact i would say the situation has grown radically worse since david davis made what i
00:02:59 think was a helpful intervention because i think that the so-called diversity and equality agenda
00:03:06 and the way that's been weaponized in terms of decolonization is actively distorting teaching
00:03:13 and research syllabuses and wrecking careers ophelia you know at this point that jeremy just made about
00:03:20 universities uh him not trusting universities to regulate themselves this is the the shocking thing
00:03:26 in a way i thought about what david ever said is that we'd actually got to a point where you know
00:03:31 some sort of legislation might be necessary.
00:03:34 Do you think it's overstating it or not?
00:03:40 It's a really difficult one, but no, I don't think it's overstating it.
00:03:44 I agree with essentially with what Jeremy said.
00:03:47 And I was just thinking about what are we talking about here?
00:03:51 We're talking about freedom of speech,
00:03:53 but we're really talking about the freedom to tell the truth, aren't we?
00:03:58 And that's really what it's all about. It's the freedom to tell the truth as we see it.
00:04:05 And that works in lots and lots of ways in terms of research, in terms of impact, in terms of learning and teaching.
00:04:12 I think if we shy away from that, we do two things. First of all, we keep silent.
00:04:19 if we're cowed by an orthodoxy, if we see an orthodoxy on campus and we keep silent.
00:04:27 And that's bad. That's bad for individuals.
00:04:30 It's bad for scholarship, for scholars, and it's bad for subjects.
00:04:37 The other thing that we might do as well is tell lies,
00:04:41 because if we don't say what we think and we don't say what we perceive to be the truth,
00:04:47 then we'll fall in line and tell lies
00:04:51 because we feel as though we have to.
00:04:55 And that's just the worst possible thing we can do.
00:05:01 I'd probably say that that's been happening.
00:05:04 I'd say that that's been happening.
00:05:06 So I'd say that maybe something does need to be done.
00:05:10 The difficulty is untangling what needs to be done
00:05:13 and thinking about, well, where do we separate this idea of orthodoxy
00:05:21 and where do we get to the idea of really pushing debate
00:05:25 and really thinking rigorously about ideas?
00:05:28 There have been studies done on this, haven't there, Emma,
00:05:31 about the state of freedom, for want of any,
00:05:35 I think Policy Exchange did one and Civitas itself has done one.
00:05:39 which did the general sort of results seem to be that it was actually in a bad way
00:05:45 I mean Jeremy's alluded to it that it that something like 48 universities
00:05:50 were considered to be very restrictive when it came to free speech and another
00:05:54 70 were sort of moderately restrictive but we're talking about different
00:05:59 things aren't we we're talking about academic orthodoxy and freedom and we're
00:06:03 talking about student freedom the ability to say what you think or or just to hear
00:06:08 certain speakers yeah I think it's the two are kind of tangled into each other
00:06:14 because the issue with academic freedom is as already mentioned it's about the
00:06:20 freedom to pursue and to talk about truth and to discuss different ideas and
00:06:24 so in an academic setting it's obviously particularly important to be able to do
00:06:29 that and one of the issues that has been highlighted by these reports like the
00:06:34 policy exchange report that was published last August and one of the
00:06:38 authors of that was Eric Kaufman who's made this point very well in the past
00:06:41 that this is this is about the ability to to access truth to discuss to discuss
00:06:48 things and and the that I think the the chilling effect that that has if the
00:06:56 environment amongst the academics themselves is one of restriction then
00:07:01 that students are not going to be able to learn the value of free speech from
00:07:05 the academic community and one of the interesting findings actually from the
00:07:09 policy exchange report was and this is I think absolutely horrifying they found
00:07:15 that I think it was 54% of academics said that they would would be
00:07:23 uncomfortable sitting next to a sort of vocal leave supporter at lunch how many
00:07:31 And 54% and 37% said that they so that was how many would feel comfortable. And 37% said that they would feel comfortable sitting next to somebody who had gender critical views in the trans debate.
00:07:49 So these academics don't even feel comfortable being near their conservative peers.
00:07:55 The policy exchange report showed that there was discrimination in the publishing of journal articles, in promotions, in pretty much every area of academic life.
00:08:05 And the impact that that has on an individual academic's ability to even think truthfully and think honestly, I think that has a limiting effect because obviously if you're afraid, if you feel you have to self-censor, the obvious thing to do is to intellectually censor yourself as well so that you don't accidentally wrong speak.
00:08:30 you have to prevent yourself also from wrong thinking and I think that obviously has an
00:08:35 impact on on the student body as well because they're not they're not learning from the academic
00:08:39 community yes yes sorry can I can I just can I just follow up on that because I think it's a
00:08:46 really it's a really good point and it reminds me of something I think what Emma's just said is is
00:08:52 reflected in in in the funding mechanisms as well for research and the criteria for for you know
00:08:58 awarding funding for research that is in a way it's a kind of roundabout way of censoring as
00:09:07 well you're only going to get funding for a particular kind of research I would say you
00:09:12 are certainly not going to get funding for say conservative leaning research around around
00:09:18 heritage around nation around ideas of identity that differ from from from the identitarian I
00:09:27 would suggest yes i agree with that entirely and i do think that it is getting worse as a result of
00:09:33 this decolonization agenda i think getting worse as a result of the way in which universities
00:09:41 evaluate the teaching and research of their staff in accordance with what i think one could fairly
00:09:48 say as wokish norms so i think we all agree and i think what emma and philip has said is completely
00:09:53 correct the question is as always how on earth do we move forward from here yeah that i think is the
00:10:00 problem now as i understand it you know you can read those pieces that rachel sylvester is putting
00:10:06 out in the times as a sort of mouthpiece for whitehall speak there is an argument that is
00:10:12 going on within government against the notion of what they call culture wars and the argument being
00:10:18 that that's what characterised Trump and that that was a mistake and he mustn't see it in Britain.
00:10:24 Problem with that is that if we leave a situation in which the government, we do have a conservative
00:10:30 government with the largest majority for a long time, if we do, if we're not prepared to do
00:10:36 something now, then I don't think anything ever will happen. So if it is a case that they don't
00:10:41 wish to introduce primary legislation, and maybe primary legislation would not work, I do not know,
00:10:47 then one has to think about other means. Now one of the obvious means, and I'm sure Philip and Emma
00:10:51 would agree with me on this, is the financial clout. If you have universities that are behaving
00:10:57 in an egregious, discriminatory fashion, then quite frankly every time that they ring up a
00:11:05 minister and ask for money, the minister should say to them, well look, I'm interested in what
00:11:09 you have to say, but I'd rather not deal with a body in which the university seems to be incapable
00:11:15 of providing freedom of speech for either its students or its staff maybe you should address
00:11:20 that before you ask for any more cash now if universities were told that then they would get
00:11:27 their clear their act up but they are certainly not going to clear up their act other for any
00:11:31 other reason so it's got to be a kind of financial imperative then that's i that's a really really
00:11:36 good point and one of the things that has been pointed out again with the policy exchange report
00:11:40 and Eric Kaufman has made this point is that whilst there is a sort of institutional protection
00:11:49 for people's emotions in a sense through the decolonising side of things that we don't have
00:11:56 the same kind of systemic to use their own language protections for free speech and one
00:12:01 of the suggestions was that we could have a particular post in the office for students
00:12:06 that would be responsible for protecting academic freedom and I think that the financial side of
00:12:14 things, the funding side of things is really really important particularly with the you know
00:12:19 the grants making process is another example of that because one of the ways that I think is often
00:12:26 not discussed as much as the obvious restrictions on academic freedom is the way that people who
00:12:32 may not necessarily um sink in the sort of let's say critical theory style of of speaking um people
00:12:41 are forced to funnel their research through particular methodologies which are basically
00:12:45 just ideologies and they're forced to funnel their work through these prisms in order to get funding
00:12:51 in order to get published in order to get promoted and so we need to look more deeply at the the
00:12:59 the institutions themselves and one way to do that is through looking at the financial side of things
00:13:05 but that's something that potentially somebody in a post at the office for students could do though
00:13:10 i would be not necessarily so optimistic that they would succeed because it's a huge job
00:13:15 because it's something that's been going on for you know since the 60s really yes um but i think
00:13:20 that that's a really important point that we need to remove the the waiting in the direction of
00:13:25 emotional protection back at least in some balance with protections of academic freedom of free
00:13:31 speech because at the moment i think people's research is getting all tied up and restricted in
00:13:36 this very reductive use of language and methodologies yes it has all become about
00:13:41 language has it not really jerry well i mean that's a major thing but i think it's at all
00:13:48 levels first of all i agree with everything emma said but i think one can also ratchet it up i
00:13:52 I mean, one of the sadnesses is that because now you are having very prescriptive teaching practices in order to encourage people to think in certain ways, that affects, for example, how postgraduates are taught.
00:14:07 It therefore affects the kind of person who would wish to be a postgraduate and the next generation of academics.
00:14:14 I think Emma is absolutely right and Philip is absolutely right about the funding councils.
00:14:19 I have to tell you I do not have any confidence in the funding councils at all and what is
00:14:25 fascinating in my own subject which is history is you will often find work that is of better
00:14:31 quality and that seeks to engage with the public much more that comes outside the funding councils
00:14:37 as often is written by non-academics now that is really sad you would have hoped that academics
00:14:43 would try and engage more with the public which are ultimately the people funding them
00:14:48 But there seems to be this sort of traison des clercs, this idea that in some way they must stick to the ideology.
00:14:57 But the other point, the people who we're not really talking about, and the group that I feel most sad on their behalf, are undergraduates.
00:15:05 I can recall feeling very, very sad when I had undergraduates that they felt, and people who said this to me were doing either history degrees,
00:15:15 politics degrees or interestingly enough for me because I'm interested in the subject job
00:15:20 degrees and they said that they felt very much that they were you know being pressurized to
00:15:27 argue in a certain way that they were mocked by their tutors if they didn't take the greed line
00:15:34 that they were worried about their marks and remember for a lot of jobs you can't move forward
00:15:38 unless you get a 2-1 and you know and they would say to me you know is it a fair comment that this
00:15:44 seems to be institutional prejudice. And I would say to you, you're almost certainly correct. I
00:15:50 would say to you that almost certainly you'll have absolutely no lie in the university's
00:15:58 complaints procedures. The only advice I could give people was to choose courses, and I would
00:16:05 actually add degree subjects, but choose courses where the lecturer seemed less prejudiced. So
00:16:13 One of my advice now to students or potential students is not to apply to a department doing either history or English, which puts decolonisation as a major theme of what it regards as its ethos.
00:16:28 Because in a way, what it is doing is closing down debate. There is no point doing a history or English degree unless debate is part of the agenda.
00:16:37 and to the best of my knowledge we still live in a democracy and to the best of my knowledge
00:16:43 we still believe that in a democracy there are a variety of views that it is legitimate to hold
00:16:48 but one of the few places where that does not seem to be accepted as the university structure
00:16:53 Philip did the whole decolonization phenomenon which Jeremy was just describing there
00:17:01 how does it how does it actually sort of affect your area you know your what you teach
00:17:07 I mean, is it something that is dominant now in your particular area of cultural history?
00:17:14 Oh, yes, I think it is certainly.
00:17:16 But I defend my corner very vigorously.
00:17:21 And I kind of, you know, personally, I teach post 20th century British cultural history.
00:17:27 And that's not me just, you know, looking and putting my head in the sand.
00:17:31 That's me thinking about Britain, mapping on globally, thinking about various kinds of histories.
00:17:37 But I think the problem comes down to this, that it becomes a zero-sum game.
00:17:44 Now, everybody who's interested in knowledge wants to broaden their knowledge.
00:17:48 But as we've seen from the latest example, which was Leicester, I think, wasn't it, this week, where they decided to kind of jettison completely Chaucer in favour of,
00:17:59 i think they described it as themed style kind of degree programs um that's that's a zero-sum game
00:18:08 that that's that's that's you know weighing kind of uh you know importance there and and and reducing
00:18:15 a particular kind of heritage a particular kind of identity to absolutely nothing and i think
00:18:22 that's the key problem it's either or and it shouldn't be is it sort of it's an attack surely
00:18:27 isn't it on knowledge and it it's an attack on our knowledge isn't it really it's it's interesting
00:18:33 because they almost have sort of lifted the sheet up you've shown us what's given us a sort of
00:18:37 cheeky glimpse of what's really going on which is that they now view it was right they now view
00:18:42 academia as or their their sort of relationship with their students and teaching as a manipulative
00:18:49 exercise it isn't giving them the tools and the curiosity to explore whatever they like and
00:18:55 teaching them on the subjects that the academics have particular expertise on but not limiting the
00:18:59 students in any way it's as as said you know like it's a zero-sum game we're going to remove
00:19:05 some things from you with the intention of manipulating you down a particular path in
00:19:09 accordance with a particular ideology that is accepted by the university and all the universities
00:19:15 and i think there are some exceptions to this buckingham have been a very notable exception to
00:19:20 it but there isn't really anywhere that you can go to escape this i remember when i when i you
00:19:25 know did my undergraduate and then did my postgraduate was exactly the same thing there and
00:19:29 no matter i did a jewish studies master's degree and even there the the gender and sexuality and
00:19:35 things and were being woven into it um there's nowhere that you can go to escape this line and
00:19:40 it's obviously things have progressed since then um but there isn't really anywhere that that these
00:19:46 students can go and because particularly for undergraduates when you're in your
00:19:50 late teens you don't have the capacity yet necessarily to really understand
00:19:57 what's going on with these methodologies and things that are being fed to you
00:20:00 that are quite manipulative and if you get stuck on that path because you are
00:20:05 really coerced to because of your need for career progression either in
00:20:10 academia or outside by needing to get the grades you have really two choices
00:20:14 you can either write satirical essays that mock the system and see if you can
00:20:19 get away with it in order to get the good grades or you have to really force
00:20:24 your brain into it and you're I imagine there will be lots of students who are
00:20:28 left thinking this doesn't feel right but I don't really know why and I can't
00:20:32 quite wriggle myself out of the straitjacket I've been put into I think
00:20:37 Emma's absolutely right and I think the interesting thing about the Leicester one
00:20:40 and I think it's actually that they're proposing with the exception of
00:20:44 Shakespeare to ditch everything prior to 1600. I think the interesting thing is
00:20:49 unusually that got into the public domain what is really striking what your
00:20:54 listeners may find more alarming is that this is being pressed further and faster
00:21:01 in many institutions but not getting into the public domain and as Emma says
00:21:06 it ends up washing out and to you know the listeners here are people thinking of going to
00:21:11 university or their parents or friends it ends up to them being given what is in some respects
00:21:17 at best seriously distorted and at worst almost manipulative if not a deliberate and aggressive
00:21:25 form of brainwashing and I just think that's an enormous pity I mean the state is putting vast
00:21:31 amounts of money into the university sector the university sector in science engineering medicine
00:21:37 is doing an enormous amount of good work crucial work during the covid epidemic but also crucial
00:21:43 if britain is to make the success of itself but i have to say i am extraordinarily dubious about the
00:21:49 quality and ethos of two main areas one many of the not all not all there are good people but
00:21:56 many of the as it were uh teachers in the humanities and social sciences but secondly
00:22:02 and in a sense um in a way more troubling it's university administrators because it's often
00:22:08 university administrators who are directing the system the kind of people that sit there on
00:22:14 diversity committees the kind of um you know time servers that get made vice chancellors or deputy
00:22:20 vice chancellors and you know the joke used to be those who can do those who can't teach
00:22:26 absolute rubbish those who can't actually become university administrators and university
00:22:31 politicians those are the people who are producing a system which harms good teachers but even more
00:22:40 seriously really is distorting our values as a democracy and harm which i think is a social
00:22:48 problem and of course is making life very difficult as emma says for for young people
00:22:54 who want to think for themselves which is what we should be encouraging i think um just just to add
00:23:00 to that yeah sorry just just one final thing on that and jeremy uh mentioned the word value there
00:23:07 and i've just been i've got a piece of paper next to me i've been doodling the word value all over
00:23:11 it uh there you go um um and and one of the one of the um one of the interesting things about why
00:23:21 that decision was made and who made that decision the the point is a well-made one about university
00:23:27 administrators but the other one is that they said something about well this is what the students
00:23:32 want you know this is this is the you know it must be good for them so this is what the students want
00:23:37 and i think i think the whole sector over the last i don't know seven or eight years or so has been
00:23:42 led by the nose by something called the national student survey which is which is you know ranks
00:23:48 universities in terms of student satisfaction and it's this idea of you know we'll give them
00:23:54 exactly you know whatever they want as long as they're happy and and if we're talking about
00:24:02 values not only kind of academic values but ethical values as well i think that's really
00:24:07 dubious actually just going going on from that point a bit uh you took you're discussing the
00:24:13 humanities there we were talking about the humanities i mean some people i think it might
00:24:18 have been i don't want to take his name wrong in vain here but i think it was was sir roger
00:24:22 scrutin he said that they were pretty much over i mean that they were beyond help you know i mean
00:24:29 is that being too drastic you know i i i never think anything's over and i never think it's
00:24:40 beyond help and and because i always i always i always want to turn things around we've already
00:24:45 talked about language and we've already talked about um the use of language and what that does
00:24:52 So I present research that absolutely and self-consciously avoids using that language, because if you use the language of your opponents, then you lose immediately.
00:25:05 I'm getting published and I'm kind of and I'm publishing the kind of stuff that I want to.
00:25:12 So I don't think the battle's lost.
00:25:15 And there are great individuals in institutions up and down.
00:25:21 We've already mentioned Eric Kaufman, for example, up and down the country
00:25:25 who are thinking freely and thinking rigorously.
00:25:31 But by God, it's an uphill struggle. It's an uphill struggle.
00:25:34 I think one thing that also happened quite recently was there was a bit of controversy
00:25:40 surrounding the giving of an OBE to Kathleen Stock,
00:25:46 who professed philosophy down at Sussex.
00:25:50 And again, this is quite interesting, I thought,
00:25:52 because they were just, these were views that she had
00:25:55 that were sort of questioning, shall we say,
00:25:58 of the rightness of allowing transgender women 0.88
00:26:02 into changing rooms, into, you know, female laboratories.
00:26:08 and 600 academics wrote a letter basically condemning the fact that you've been given the OBE.
00:26:16 Isn't it the matter, therefore, that really, you know, you have to, almost on a personal level,
00:26:22 you have to sort of fit in with a set of views, I mean, regardless of your discipline.
00:26:27 Isn't that the case at universities and academics? It certainly is for students, surely.
00:26:31 Well, I think you're right. I mean, in many senses, the best advice you can often give somebody starting their professional career in any profession, in any job, is to try and find friendships and develop friendships outside your workplace.
00:26:47 I think that's important. I don't know Catherine Stock. I imagine she was felt that if she'd been provocative, she'd have had several thousand people complain.
00:26:57 And you can usually find 600 idiots to sign something against anybody.
00:27:01 So I wouldn't I wouldn't worry about that.
00:27:03 So but the the I think the more substantive point is this, that the joke used to be it didn't really matter what the academics said because the students ignored them and still went on through life.
00:27:18 And actually, the as it were, they were taught didn't have an effect that might have been true for some people in the past.
00:27:26 I'm not actually convinced it was true. I certainly don't think it's so easy now.
00:27:32 And I think that one of the developments of the last 30 years has been that higher education has institutionalized itself.
00:27:41 It's become a very, very, very large industry. As a very large industry, it's got a lot of lobbyists.
00:27:48 It's got a lot of vested interests, particularly municipal authorities built into it.
00:27:53 And its value system is has become one which it seeks to inculcate. Now, I think it's fair to say there was never a golden age, but I think it's fair to say that the idea in the part was that people engaged in debate.
00:28:08 And it was through debate, through the Hegelian notion of thesis and antithesis and synthesis that subjects moved forward.
00:28:16 The trouble is that if you argue that there is a correct answer and that what a surprise that correct answer is my answer, whoever me is, then you end up with a situation in which academic value goes out in terms of actually encouraging people to develop their ideas.
00:28:36 and instead of which the university becomes a place in which you put a stamp on somebody
00:28:42 and that stamp says we have approved this person they have the right values and they are employable
00:28:51 now I think there is a degree to which that that is getting towards an Orwellian system a 1984 system
00:28:57 and I think that's very unwelcome and as I said we are supposed to be a democracy
00:29:03 If we were in a state like Belarus, then you could say that we have university humanities departments that fit in.
00:29:11 But I do not think that they are appropriate in a democratic society where it should be acceptable to have views to be a conservative.
00:29:20 It should be acceptable to have views that you don't agree with critical race theory.
00:29:24 You should be able to have a whole host of ideas that are ones that are not those that are illegal.
00:29:33 It is illegal to be, obviously, in terms of race or sex or, you know, some other, for example, libel.
00:29:42 There are laws that constrain what we could and should say.
00:29:46 But within those bounds, there should be a freedom of thought and an expression.
00:29:51 And I'm afraid to say for many people there isn't.
00:29:53 And I agree with Philip. You can navigate your way through.
00:29:57 I mean, I essentially realised quite early on that I had to raise funds outside the university in order to finance my research and go to archives, because there would be absolutely no way that a conservative like myself, working on military history, high political history, was going to find favour with the funding councils.
00:30:19 And it worked. But as Philip says, it's not easy. And it's much easier to be somebody that just fits in with the system, not least because many of these people are rather shallow individuals who actually believe in those sort of the sort of values that they that they affirm.
00:30:37 if i could just pick up on one of those uh one of those points which is
00:30:42 we're all great points it's it's not just the ideas that are debated now it's actually the
00:30:50 very notion of debate is seen to be white supremacist yes yes yes so if you so if
00:30:58 really you know where where do you go from there what do you do then do you have a knitting
00:31:04 competition or do you i don't know what you do best gardens i don't know i don't know what you
00:31:09 do but so so there's there's a sense that and i think that's that's a really cynical way of
00:31:16 of pulling apart the system i don't i'd be surprised if people really thought that was
00:31:23 the case it's what it's what douglas murray calls brute politics and and of course we see it in
00:31:29 academia just as we see it everywhere else but it's something else it's the it's the twitterization
00:31:34 of academia as well it's it's this it's these short kind of little um sound bites of of nonsense
00:31:42 that the the academics just like everybody else kind of latch on to and academics as much as
00:31:48 everybody else more so kind of love to put out there you're laughing in kind of recognition
00:31:54 about that yeah i this this also goes back to the point about values because what the
00:32:00 what sort of character are students being teached taught what's a bad education
00:32:08 we're totally non-judgmental here emma don't worry what sort of values are they what sort of values
00:32:15 and character are they being taught because they're not being taught a democratic character
00:32:21 they're being sent out of the university into the world without an understanding of a true
00:32:28 understanding of tolerance and negotiate back to scrutiny a sort of negotiation living in a
00:32:33 particular you know particular settled community with people as a democracy is in terms of the
00:32:39 nation and also locally there is a sort of negotiation to that that it has to be part of
00:32:45 the character and the universities are teaching the absolute opposite of that they're teaching
00:32:49 intolerance, reductive, closed-minded thinking. And obviously there are some exceptions to this.
00:32:56 There are some people, you know, for example, at Oxford who have a really good sound understanding
00:33:01 of, you know, character and the importance of character formation through education and so on.
00:33:07 And I mentioned Buckingham as well. And, you know, this isn't a sort of sweeping generalisation
00:33:11 across universities, but it does seem to be, you know, something that has permeated through the
00:33:17 entire culture of the universities and sort of goes hand in hand with as was already mentioned
00:33:22 the way that the industry that the universities have become this huge industry really and so
00:33:29 there is always going to be this economic um incentive for them to keep pushing for these
00:33:34 things and um and it's just you you're what sort of uh future generations are you producing i think
00:33:42 So it was a sort of sinister element to that. And also going back to the language point, a few years ago, I think it was, and I may be misremembering this, but there was a very small scuffle over the teaching of Anglo, Norse and Celtic studies at the University of Cambridge.
00:34:02 and there were some people who had said that they felt that even the title of the course
00:34:09 was somehow white supremacist and this goes back to what you were just saying that you know that
00:34:16 democracy meritocracy all of these things are now viewed as being somehow inherently white
00:34:23 supremacist or complicit in whiteness and therefore they've just got to go and you asked
00:34:29 before whether you know is this the end of the university i think something is gone at the sort
00:34:35 of core of the culture of the point of a university even if it can still be salvaged
00:34:42 the the light seems to be sort of being extinguished in that sense and i think
00:34:45 there's something sinister and worrying about that oh uh extremely why i i think as well you
00:34:52 you talk about you know how you know students come out the other end i when i speak to people
00:34:59 who have been recent undergraduates you know and this goes to the root of I
00:35:03 think what we're talking about here is this there isn't a real belief in
00:35:07 freedom actually not not really I mean you know that there used to be this sort
00:35:12 of argument I'm for free speech and then your opponent was I'm for free speech
00:35:18 but you know and they would then list a lot of things and that gives you
00:35:22 something to argue about but I think now many of the younger people coming out of
00:35:28 college actually prefer safety and security and lack of offense and those trump everything to do
00:35:36 with freedom is that would you is that familiar that that scenario to you i i think there's a
00:35:45 there's a sense that the idea of um debate as we just talked about but the idea you know swapping
00:35:52 ideas and and and and thinking about different points of view has is is is fast going out of the
00:35:59 window and and and that that positionality of you think this and i think that it's not that anymore
00:36:09 it's i am right and virtuous you are wrong and wicked yes and so i i agree with you philip can
00:36:16 offer you an idea about how best to describe this we are moving from a three-dimensional culture to
00:36:24 a two-dimensional yeah yeah i think that's it what you are talking about philip is a classic
00:36:30 three-dimensional i think this is an original idea of mine i don't know some maybe i'm not but
00:36:35 i've never heard anybody else say it and give it to me jeremy and i'll steal it well that's fine
00:36:39 let me give it to you in a three-dimensional culture not only do you have differing viewpoints
00:36:45 But you also have depth through techniques like irony, through, you know, and I'm afraid to say that the kind of characteristics we think about as classic British three-dimensional culture have been wiped out by becoming instead a two-dimensional kind of coercive sentimentality.
00:37:08 And in coercive sentimentality, it is only some views and some emotions that are acceptable.
00:37:15 And those emotions and sentiments have to be expressed very simply.
00:37:20 So Emma making sophisticated points is completely unacceptable, totally unacceptable,
00:37:26 because obviously, if somebody believes that the sentiment is that of affirming the concept of white supremacy,
00:37:35 than anybody that suggests that maybe one needs a bit more complexity
00:37:40 is somebody, by their very act of doing so,
00:37:44 is throwing a spanner at the entire works of this new system.
00:37:49 So I do feel...
00:37:50 Now, there's several things to say, I mean, with reference to Peter's question
00:37:54 about the one that both of you...
00:37:56 I think this is a fascinating discussion.
00:37:58 I hope you get people listening to it.
00:38:00 With reference to Peter's question, we've got two separate things here,
00:38:03 which is one a general cultural issue in other words how far are we talking about things that
00:38:09 are going wrong with British culture as a whole and secondly how far are there specific dimensions
00:38:16 in the universities and if so what should we be thinking about to address the university issue
00:38:23 as opposed to the cultural issue now I think that Peter this is a very good topic because I think
00:38:28 What you've got is a general cultural problem, the rise of sentiment, the idea that you should feel something rather than you should think it and that you validate things through feeling, not thinking.
00:38:41 I think that's very much a cultural trope. And you could see all sorts of things, the reaction to Lady Diana's death, the politics of Tony Blair, a whole host of things when you get sent to the rise of sentiment.
00:38:54 but separately there is the institutional practice of it in universities and I think
00:39:00 both Emma and Philip are absolutely right in drawing attention to it I think it is an issue
00:39:05 and I think given that the government spends so much money on universities it wouldn't be hard
00:39:11 I mean what I think it was Philip who used the phrase brute politics from Douglas Murray it would
00:39:18 not be harmful as the government every so often used the politics of treasury funds to simply say
00:39:24 to people this is not acceptable we don't wish or intend to fund as a university what clearly is
00:39:32 not providing so we are only going to fund your science side and you can think about what else
00:39:37 you want to do to improve your other side i i think this brings us really neatly back to the
00:39:43 idea of censorship and freedom of speech because what i think this stuff does it it it's cynical
00:39:52 and it it assumes wickedness and it assumes evil before anybody's opened their mouth and and and
00:39:58 that is that is related to characteristics um and often you know as much as anything else and and
00:40:05 And so there can be in some institutions a sense of fear that comes from that.
00:40:16 So it goes full circle in a way. It goes full circle in a way.
00:40:20 And it's that initial and central lack of goodwill.
00:40:26 And that's what's really, really worrying and really, really scary about thinking today.
00:40:32 At the very beginning, at the very beginning of the programme, just to round off here, Jeremy, you said that you didn't have that much faith in the universities regulating themselves.
00:40:46 and and then you you you told us why but then we did recently have what appeared
00:40:52 to be a kind of victory for free speech didn't we at Cambridge where there was
00:40:56 the definition which was going to be set as being that you should respect other
00:41:02 views and this was there was a campaign against it and in fact now it's just you
00:41:08 have to tolerate others views so do you know about the summer this was seen as
00:41:12 some kind of great you know triumph but that's the case of universities
00:41:17 regulating themselves effectively no I suspect also that part of the kickback
00:41:23 against some of the two-dimensional culture that is developing the in the
00:41:27 universities I'm gonna steal that one now too and the sentimentality is that
00:41:32 there will be some academics and some students who kick back against the the
00:41:37 the consequences of this on the quality and rigor of research and thinking I
00:41:43 think because that there's a sort of there's always a laziness to ideological
00:41:47 thinking and that's what you kind of get with the brainwashing inculcating
00:41:50 people into thinking about you know when the people talk about a feminist 1.00
00:41:54 reading of or I said I don't know what other types of readings of there may be
00:42:01 but all sorts of critical readings of different things it's teaching people to
00:42:05 think a set of beliefs and then to apply that to any given piece of literature or whatever and I
00:42:13 think some of the kickback within the institutions like in Cambridge and there have been other cases
00:42:19 elsewhere as well will not necessarily although in that instance it may have been coming from a
00:42:26 sort of principled position of academic freedom but that you have to have respect for other
00:42:31 people's beliefs if you are going to have at least a degree of rigour because otherwise everybody
00:42:37 is just forced into this lazy two-dimensional culture of thinking yes uh uh can i just say
00:42:46 yes the decision in cambridge was welcome but cambridge and oxford are unusual in that the
00:42:52 academics there have more power and you will notice that it was the vice chancellor of cambridge and
00:42:57 his cadre who were pushing the more restrictive um formulation in other words they were pushing
00:43:05 the political correctness and i'm a cambridge alumni and i can tell you alumnus i can tell you
00:43:10 if you read the stuff that comes out of cambridge all the time it's full of uh politically correct
00:43:16 garbage that really you know when i started my academic career in 1980 i would have given a very
00:43:22 low grade to if somebody had written that in an essay and yet that is now the vice chancellor of
00:43:27 cambridge so i i i do not i do not have the confidence well you may think that i'm being
00:43:34 unfair i tell you that is a view of many cambridge graduates no no so you may think i you may think
00:43:40 i'm being um you may think i'm being unfair peter but the reality is that in most universities the
00:43:48 The, as it were, the juggernaut of the equality and diversity bodies are pushed through, and it really, often to the exclusion of any concern about the welfare of the staff, the welfare of the students, the intellectual rigor.
00:44:10 I mean, intellectual rigor is gone. I mean, as both of my colleagues are saying, if you look at the language that is used in many of these documents, the language is ridiculous, the grammar is often absent, and the process of cause and effect are confused so that they prove themselves from, in fact, the conclusions they have already drawn.
00:44:33 I mean, it is just garbage. But unfortunately, that is the way up. And, you know, as you mentioned policy exchange, I'm on the history matters thing. And in fact, the rather brilliant policy that was followed was simply to publish some of these documents in extenso.
00:44:51 Because once you read what is being said, you realise how idiotic a lot of it is.
00:44:56 The difficulty is, where do we move forward?
00:45:00 That, Peter, is what you must encourage a debate on.
00:45:03 What is it possible to do?
00:45:05 And how can a Conservative government, which has a parliamentary majority,
00:45:10 act in order to try and ensure freedom of thought and freedom of speech
00:45:15 and much more importantly a democratic culture that is inculcated for the next generation
00:45:21 rather than being told remarks and ideas which by their very nature are anti-democratic.
00:45:28 Just to follow up on that, it might be that that next generation brings those ideas to the university
00:45:36 and the university doesn't give them to that generation.
00:45:41 so we we've got i mean we're on this program now it will it will get a lot of views as this channel
00:45:48 always does there are there are different channels like it all talking about free speech all talking
00:45:52 all going against the identitarian orthodoxy there are you know best-selling authors who
00:45:59 who are doing similar kinds of things and young people are flocking to to to people like sam
00:46:05 harris douglas murray jordan peterson or all of those people um so maybe maybe those young people
00:46:13 are going to go to the university with a different set of ideas and challenge the orthodoxy themselves
00:46:19 and and maybe it's up to us to support them right well that that's very nice just don't say it too
00:46:24 loudly philip because big tech might hear you and then shut us down all right so so so be careful
00:46:30 all right thank you very very much jeremy thank you very much philip thank you very much
00:46:35 Emma for that. That was Counterculture. Thank you to my guests again. Great
00:46:40 discussion I think. We will see you next week. Thank you, bye.