New Culture Forum - February 02, 2021


The Battle To Preserve Our Statues & Cultural Heritage Is Not Over Despite Positive Gov't Statements

Big Tech & Free Speech - Has Online Censorship Gone Too Far? Dave Rubin - What Now For USA Under Biden? How Can Non-Woke In UK & USA Fight Back In Culture Wars?

Episode Stats


Length

31 minutes

Words per minute

165.49

Word count

5,219

Sentence count

69


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to Counterculture. I'm Peter Whittle. Now a few weeks ago there was an
00:00:18 announcement which seemed to be full of promise. It's from Robert Jenrick which was about how
00:00:24 statues from now on were going to have some form of legal protection and he wouldn't just be at
00:00:30 the mercies as he put it the baying mob so that seems like a very very good thing although at
00:00:38 the same time certain statues do still seem to be coming down or indeed at threat then there is the
00:00:45 whole question also of our street names and indeed there is a question of the ongoing cultural assault
00:00:52 which is still going on. Only last week we heard, for example, that one university was going to
00:00:59 downgrade the teaching of Geoffrey Chaucer in favour of issues to do with gender, sexuality
00:01:06 and race. So in other words, it is far from over. Indeed, that might just be one battle
00:01:14 that we're talking about. So joining me to discuss these things today, we have Richard Bingley,
00:01:19 who is the General Secretary of Save Our Statues, Robert Pohl who runs the Save Our Statues Twitter
00:01:25 campaign and Emma Webb co-founder of Save Our Statues. I want to start if I can with you Robert.
00:01:35 This announcement that was made by the Minister for Housing and Communities, Robert Jenrick,
00:01:41 this is a lot of you know it was very very well received, it was very welcomed,
00:01:47 but can you just explain to us what exactly it actually means in practice how will it actually
00:01:53 be working yeah this uh the new rules basically extend protection to all statues in england
00:02:05 of which are about 12 000 um so not just those that are currently listed which is about three
00:02:12 and a half thousand of them it will mean that all any proposals affecting these statues including
00:02:19 plaques and memorials will require some kind of planning permission which also will therefore
00:02:28 have to go through due process including some kind of public consultation so this is definitely
00:02:35 a welcome protection if not a final answer that solves all all our problems necessarily but it
00:02:42 does certainly seem like a step in the right direction is it actually uh is it actually
00:02:48 in law already how will it work well it's not just a proposal is it it's just something that's
00:02:55 going to be initiated when they are saying it will be introduced in the
00:03:02 spring or March I think more specifically was reported in one place
00:03:08 yeah by amending a few pieces of current legislation around the planning process
00:03:14 so yeah it should it's not not in quite yet but should hopefully be coming in
00:03:19 in time for some of the statues that are currently being looked at by councils
00:03:25 because their processes normally take a number of months anyway including consultations so
00:03:31 yeah the timing wise we we are expecting this to come in in in the next month or two
00:03:37 Richard Richard being there does this mean job done
00:03:42 not really although I would say it's it's ironic isn't it you try and get a green wheelie bin and
00:03:49 it takes you months out of the council you try and save a statue from the government
00:03:54 legislation sort of telling us that we can't remove them and and the local councils move
00:03:58 within days and i'm just giving you an example of exeter where um you know they pass a council
00:04:03 motion at the front end of last week at the same time as the secretary of state announces that
00:04:08 statues are to remain uh and and before we know it it's i'm picking up local information from
00:04:14 exeter that that statue removal could be very very soon um so i i think it's it's really
00:04:21 great news isn't it that we're hearing from the national government but actually the reality on
00:04:27 the ground for the next few weeks are that left-wing councils that were planning to
00:04:31 remove this stuff are actually accelerating their plans so they're kind of is that right
00:04:38 they're sort of getting in before as it were this spring is that really what it seems like
00:04:43 yeah i think as well what we saw around the city of london as well their attempt to try
00:04:49 to remove the statues as quickly as possible despite the fact that Historic England had
00:04:55 actually contacted them about these two statues. I think they're, Rob correct me if I'm wrong,
00:04:58 that they're in Guildhall and they were contacted by Historic England. They didn't give a response
00:05:04 and they were basically told that presumably although this isn't currently in legislation
00:05:10 that this is the government's position and that they shouldn't be removing them because they're
00:05:14 in a grade one listed building. They have to apply for planning permission and go through the whole
00:05:19 process and that was the the idea that Robert Jemmerich had behind this is that there should
00:05:24 be due process and I think again correct me if I'm wrong that he under these new rules would
00:05:31 have the ability to step in and have the final say if there was a dispute between Historic England
00:05:36 and these councils to make sure that they that they can't remove these things but I think that
00:05:41 we could end up with a situation that even obviously it's been described as retain and
00:05:47 explain uh that that doesn't necessarily mean that the fight is over because as we've seen with some
00:05:53 of the plaques that have been suggested uh in in other places particularly in scotland sometimes
00:05:59 they are actually quite ideological and uh ahistorical so i think probably they're still
00:06:05 going to be an uphill battle on that front that is that that is right to almost say this is battle
00:06:11 number two isn't it i mean if it's retain and explain as amber said you know it is um
00:06:17 basically we're talking about these you know contextualizing plaques aren't we that's what
00:06:22 we're talking about rob yes absolutely um he's talked about as i said putting due process around
00:06:31 the retain but there is no mention of any process around the around the explain and
00:06:36 And in terms of making sure councils actually approach a balanced view towards those, engaging historians or born people from across the spectrum, there's nothing like that.
00:06:51 So that definitely is a fight, I think, that we still have to fight.
00:06:57 um the important thing is for now that hopefully hopefully no none will be moved if these rules are
00:07:04 followed um and the retain and explain is applied um again yes like emma says the the idea is that
00:07:12 historic england will now have they're basically compelled to object to any proposals to move them
00:07:17 because the retain and explain is their official policy and yes if uh if the council then insists
00:07:23 on going forward um the secretary of state can intervene so that does seem like good protections
00:07:31 there but around the plaques we don't know we need to we need to come up with some kind of way
00:07:35 to to put some process around that i think i think at the moment today we're actually recording this
00:07:42 on the 25th of january and this is quite an important day is it not because the people who
00:07:48 tore down the Causton statue in Bristol have been in court have they not Robert yes they were in
00:07:57 the magistrates court today and pleaded not guilty oh which is quite unbelievable in itself not sure
00:08:04 how they're doing that but they also opted for a trial at the crown courts in a couple of weeks
00:08:12 time uh so yeah we're still still to see what's going to happen here um but it seems like they're
00:08:21 prolonging the process really and perhaps wasting more exactly public resources and doing so and
00:08:26 taking it wasting a lot of money what about the whole thing with street names richard this is
00:08:32 something again which exercises people so much i mean it's not just you know this is not covered
00:08:38 by any of this is it i mean can councils just sort of like we've heard of i think it was in birmingham
00:08:45 he came up with these sort of ideas for what was it now inspiration avenue and humanity close
00:08:52 and diversity lane and uh which all sound a bit like beatles songs but in fact
00:08:58 actually you know they are real suggestions um you know what power do people have over that if any
00:09:05 Well, the power rests with the council because if there are new street names to be made,
00:09:13 then the council usually speaks to local historians and establishes what might be the
00:09:23 correct context. So the problem has been occurring where we have current street names.
00:09:31 You know, I'm thinking in Ealing, the Havelock Road or Havelock Street and down in Plymouth, the Sir John Hawkins Square, which has been, well, it's not been renamed yet.
00:09:43 They've just blanked out. They've just erased the name of the square. There's actually, you know, it's a blank square at the moment.
00:09:48 What's the proposal for that, Richard?
00:09:50 The proposal is to change it from Sir John Hawkins Square to Jack Leslie Square after a third division football player back in the 1920s.
00:10:02 So the changes have to occur under the Public Health Act of 1925, and there has to be some form of public consultation.
00:10:12 Usually changes are made in very, very extreme circumstances.
00:10:16 we do have a situation in Devon where a road was named after somebody who was subsequently convicted of paedophile offence
00:10:26 and so therefore no one is contesting that road name change
00:10:30 but what we are picking up as a campaign across the country
00:10:33 there's a lot of road name changes going on that one would say were historical references just being erased
00:10:41 You know, Victoria Road, Victory Road, anything imperial colonial roads, those types of things.
00:10:51 And then, of course, people such as Causton, Picton, Sir John Hawkins, where their name is used in a road,
00:11:00 likely to face sort of being erased over the next few years.
00:11:04 So the public don't really have much consultation over this.
00:11:06 that the council goes about deciding how they consult and then it's up to the public basically
00:11:11 if they don't like it to take the council to the magistrate's court which is expensive
00:11:15 and it's usually found against members of the public. Quite recently Jacob Rees-Mogg said that
00:11:22 the one silver lining to this whole thing has been that it's actually reminded us of the number
00:11:28 of great heroes we've got. I mean that is putting should we say the ultimate positive spin on it
00:11:34 isn't it really it's definitely putting more of a positive spin on it than i think it deserves but
00:11:39 it is definitely true that like i think this was the case with um the statues in in the consultation
00:11:47 over the statues in guild hall that i i think rob has um numbers on this something like 71
00:11:55 of um people were actually in favor of keeping them not removing them and this
00:11:59 the statue that richard mentioned in devon that had was it more than 7 500 signatures to try and
00:12:07 keep that statue so what we know is that these statues are being removed and the street names are
00:12:12 being renamed against the public's wishes and it is jacob reese mogg is is right it is true that i
00:12:20 think this has become a rallying point for people um because they they they feel very strongly about
00:12:26 this and obviously they want to protect their heritage but i i think it would be going too
00:12:31 far to say that it's exactly a silver lining because people shouldn't have to defend these
00:12:36 things they shouldn't be under threat in the first place and the council should never have
00:12:39 been in a position where they could just bypass due process and do things even when there is due
00:12:44 process in place just ignore it which is why the stuff that rob has been doing is so good with the
00:12:50 um petitions to to give people that platform and that voice and i think what um has been suggested
00:12:56 by robert gemrack and also oliver dowd and the culture secretaries on side um to give people a
00:13:04 voice on these subjects i think that that that's something that should be built into the process
00:13:09 and it shouldn't be possible to ignore it this has does have implications if it you know if it's
00:13:15 coming in in the spring it certainly has implications isn't it for all these i think 130
00:13:20 council reviews that were going on not least of all in london actually i mean i'm you know my
00:13:25 old friend uh said he can't i mean you know essentially presumably that's his plan in tatters
00:13:31 is it not richard well um no i i'm not sure i i just feel that that all i'm really supportive
00:13:43 of what Robert Jenrick's trying to do. The problem is now that this is now internecine
00:13:50 cultural warfare. So it seems to me that when we have the political tide of maybe a conservative
00:13:56 government at the centre and Labour councils running the cities, that the Labour councils
00:14:01 spend their time in the cities trying to remove all this stuff and then going to the courts of
00:14:05 appeal because they disagree with the Secretary of State. And then you're going to see the flip
00:14:09 side. You know, if Labour win and Sadiq Khan is re-elected as mayor, the Conservative Council
00:14:16 sort of come back into power and they try and build more statues or they try and, you
00:14:21 know, retain what they've got. And the Labour Secretary of State, you know, is deciding on
00:14:27 the calling and they're the ones that are deciding ultimately what statues remain, what statues go.
00:14:32 I think we've got to get beyond this. It comes back to the education system teaching our history
00:14:36 confidently. It comes back to knowing our human rights and civil rights better. It comes back to
00:14:42 adults speaking more confidently to their children about Britain's history, most of it good, but
00:14:49 warts and all. And it comes back to, you know, the public sector doing things like having a British
00:14:56 flag and pictures of prominent British personalities throughout history in town halls, you know, in
00:15:02 schools at the moment we are completely agnostic as a country around our values and history
00:15:09 and that is why we're in the mess we're in today i i i would agree that i i think that the problem
00:15:14 is that for example if you say we should have flags and and pictures of people in school i
00:15:20 couldn't agree more with you all now i couldn't agree more but you've got the teaching people
00:15:25 haven't you they're not going to just sort of like say yeah sure we'll put up a picture of the queen
00:15:29 I mean, you know, the idea is just almost inconceivable now, isn't it?
00:15:33 Yeah, I think part of the problem, and Richard has alluded to this, is that because the Conservative government has had no option but to step in on this, because it's such an outrageous situation,
00:15:45 the left, who created the problem in the first place, have seen this as an opportunity to politicise our heritage.
00:15:52 heritage. So in the politicisation of our heritage, they've actually won the biggest
00:15:56 victory because this is going to continue to be a politicised issue around things that
00:16:02 really should be outside of that sphere and untouchable in that respect. And I think that's
00:16:08 why we've ended up with situations like the suggestion from the head of the Runnymede
00:16:14 Trust that the culture wars is just some made up thing, but it's the Tory party that are
00:16:19 trying to stir up their base in this culture war and with all of these culture warriors and that
00:16:24 somehow it's in their benefit as if it was them that would originally been toppling the statues
00:16:28 and graffitiing things and wanting to remove street names even though it's completely absurd
00:16:32 basically a conspiracy theory and it's becoming something that is almost accepted on in the left
00:16:38 we saw david olasoga he wrote an article for the guardian suggesting the same thing
00:16:43 they're flipping it as to suggest that actually it's the defenders of our heritage that are the
00:16:49 ones with the reductive the ahistorical approach approach to our history and so in that sense I
00:16:56 think that that's a much more profound battle that is going to go on for decades and and is
00:17:04 much more difficult to win than simply saving a couple of statues here and there because as
00:17:09 Richard says, you know, with the changes in the political environment and a new government coming
00:17:15 in, they've already laid the groundwork for this to become a sort of flashpoint issue. Yes, I think
00:17:22 as well, you know, that I think that the time is coming where, you know, Save Our Statues will have
00:17:27 to be slightly wider in its remit. I mean, you know, there is no getting away from it. It's been
00:17:34 absolutely you know vital the to concentrate on statues but I think that it's it's an across the
00:17:40 board thing Rob did you see our you know our friend Chaucer was about to be cancelled in
00:17:49 the University of Leicester for example I mean we're going back to education here but apparently
00:17:54 you know to be replaced or to be downgraded and replaced by more issues along the lines of gender
00:18:02 uh sexuality race etc uh this is pretty much par for the course now isn't it
00:18:10 it is yeah um it was very sad to see uh but not perhaps surprising i think from leicester as well
00:18:20 which is becoming a notoriously woke university it's the same english department that has a
00:18:26 professor who wrote about the green unpleasant land suggesting that gardening is racist and
00:18:32 who is responsible for the National Trust reports and into the stately homes and slurring
00:18:40 people like Churchill. So it's coming down to the same people there who are becoming
00:18:46 ever more prominent and having more influence. But yes, I think for Chaucer in particular
00:18:53 it was very sad I have an English degree as well and when I when I studied it at
00:18:59 Oxford doing old and middle English was actually compulsory so and I look back
00:19:05 at it really with some kind of great gratefully I think that we had the
00:19:09 opportunity to learn it and understand the origins of our our written literary
00:19:14 culture which is now going to be taken away I think from these people even as
00:19:18 an option to do it uh which yeah it's very sad yes they also get things spectacularly wrong don't
00:19:25 they emma some of the universities there's there's a story isn't there for me is it scotland
00:19:30 they're the university of york yes yeah so the um the the famous hear no evil see no evil speak
00:19:38 no evil monkeys that come from yeah they come from um 17th century japanese culture and then
00:19:44 obviously became very popular after that around the world and uh the university of york were
00:19:50 putting on an i think it was an art history conference and some of the promotional material
00:19:55 used the and it was to do with the senses and it had some silly name something about orality
00:20:01 and orality and um the sort of stuff that you would imagine from a woke conference and they
00:20:08 used the this the picture of these monkeys as part of their promotional um promotional literature to
00:20:14 advertise the conference and then the people who had organized it the academics came out with this
00:20:21 strange struggle session apology that actually the monkeys were racist um or could be viewed
00:20:27 as racist and so they they apologized for having used them um and many people pointed out that
00:20:33 actually it's quite racist of them to look at some monkeys and black people might be offended
00:20:39 by this because they are just 17th century japanese monkeys after all and if anything
00:20:44 it's actually quite offensive to japanese culture to suggest that their traditional
00:20:50 art of these monkeys is somehow offensive to i think they said the black ethnic minority
00:20:58 indigenous but now in this country we use indigenous to mean presumably not indigenous
00:21:03 They obviously have taken the phrase over from the American woke context on this.
00:21:10 So it's something more sinister than just getting it spectacularly wrong.
00:21:16 But I actually got a quote here that's worth reading out because it reads like a religious creed,
00:21:24 like something that you might, in a cult, something that you might say as a way of sort of your confession.
00:21:30 um that the academics said we bring this to your attention so that we may be held accountable for
00:21:37 our actions and in our privileges do and be better very strange so this is almost like the washing
00:21:46 of feet isn't it richard i mean this is like uh as i said this is well actually the whole idea
00:21:52 of woke indeed which is about i am i am awake you know i am renewed well i mean it's stronger than
00:22:01 that isn't it because it is it's almost a self-loathing you know it's it's a dismantlement
00:22:05 of one's own confidence uh one's family's heritage it's it's very sad to watch i mean i just sort of
00:22:12 pick up on the leicester case uh in more commercial terms you know because i worked in universities
00:22:16 for for a few years uh as a lecturer and and universities of businesses leicester has 20 000
00:22:24 students has a very strong brand because of course it had the foremost genetics department and and
00:22:32 uh one of these academics sir alec jeffries um founded digital um forensics sorry not digital
00:22:40 forensic but forensics uh and and basically digital fingerprinting and the rest of it you
00:22:45 know it's a massive expert on on on chromosomes and sort of tracing people's genetics back
00:22:51 and then you know for 30 years the police have been able to get evidence on the back of that
00:22:55 so leicester in terms of law enforcement and the security world has has a terrific reputation um
00:23:02 but i i don't think it's helpful for them if if if there are media stories going around the world
00:23:08 that they're literally erasing the best aspects of of english history that that is going to reduce
00:23:14 their student numbers especially when students are paying nine thousand pounds per year to basically
00:23:18 be taught online at the moment because of covid restrictions i'm interested to see in three years
00:23:23 time what the student numbers will be at leicester university i think it'll be like the bbc
00:23:28 these organizations that push an unpleasant self-loathing agenda will lose their customers
00:23:34 and their customers will eventually when they're stopped for forcibly being customers you know like
00:23:41 like with the BBC Life TV, they will just walk away to other alternative, credible organisations.
00:23:47 And there's 130 universities in the UK. If Leicester want to do that, then I'm not going to
00:23:52 condemn it. It's up to them. But I think others will benefit from their lack of confidence in
00:23:57 British history and the brand. Yeah, I think Richard has picked up on a really important
00:24:03 point here, because the vice chancellor of the university who has said that the reason why
00:24:07 they're doing this so they're not actually it's not just it's not just
00:24:11 bear wolf which horrific that they would get rid of it probably the first piece
00:24:16 of what you might call multicultural English literature because of its
00:24:21 connections to the Danish ancestors of the people who came to to Britain they're
00:24:27 not just getting rid of the early medieval stuff like sir Gawain and the
00:24:30 Green Knight and Chaucer, they're also looking at reducing the number of course content,
00:24:40 let's say, on people like John Milton, Christopher Marlowe, John Don. They're basically tearing
00:24:47 out the foundations of the English language and preventing students from having any ability
00:24:52 to understand the point of even studying English literature in the first place. But the thing
00:24:57 that is so interesting is that in doing that it's not just that they're doing it because they're
00:25:00 trying to decolonize the curriculum it's also because um the vice chancellor thinks that this
00:25:07 is in their commercial interests he thinks that this is going to help the university become a
00:25:12 global player and attract attract more students and climb its way up the ranking so it just sort
00:25:18 of goes to show that it's the same as as with the the big tech and a lot of the considerations there
00:25:25 that they are taking, as they perceive it, the market into consideration
00:25:29 and they actually think that this is something that is going to be
00:25:34 in their overall benefit financially long-term.
00:25:36 And I think the fact that they think that there are market forces
00:25:39 that are pushing them in this direction is very worrying
00:25:41 because it gives them so many more incentives
00:25:44 other than just the cultural pressure to just keep purging.
00:25:48 But there is this kind of alliance, is there not, Robert?
00:25:51 There's this kind of alliance, isn't there, between,
00:25:53 actually whether it's a university or a company you know even and uh and their commercial interests
00:26:00 and wokeness you know that there is this sort of strange that it's used isn't it it's actually kind
00:26:06 of wokeness is used either as a pr uh a method or indeed it's sort of as you say is a way of
00:26:13 attracting uh trade and commerce yes i think it shows how wrong the university of leicester's got
00:26:21 it and we've seen the same in other institutions where they speak amongst themselves to like-minded
00:26:28 people who are now seem to be infiltrating lots of our public institutions and think that they are
00:26:35 somehow representing the future but when it comes down to exposure to the real markets
00:26:40 and commercial the commercialism of that it's very different so like Richard was saying we
00:26:46 we have seen the reality for leicester is that number student numbers have fallen year on year
00:26:52 over the last few years they have gone from making a profit to making a loss and they have fallen
00:26:58 from 17th to 77th in the university rankings so it certainly doesn't seem to be paying dividends for
00:27:06 them and that's the reality i think when um yeah when commercialism actually strikes its home i
00:27:14 know that this is a time where we should sort of be you know to an extent celebrating with the
00:27:19 announcement of protection for statues and it seems that we're pouring on the agony a bit but
00:27:24 i i do see that this is an ongoing absolute ongoing battle uh richard uh the prime minister
00:27:31 recently said there's nothing wrong in being woke um uh is he right i didn't see what he said he
00:27:41 He said there's nothing wrong with being woke. People were talking about Biden being very woke.
00:27:46 And he said, well, there's nothing wrong in being woke.
00:27:50 Well, you can't blame him. He's got to win an election.
00:27:54 We can say different things, but he does sometimes have to say these kind of David Cameron, you know, hug a hoodie type things.
00:28:01 That's what any leader has to do. I think, you know, when you scroll back to saving statues and public realm,
00:28:08 at least we've got a prime minister and a home secretary and a community secretary
00:28:12 that have not just spoken out against violence last year and the bang mob but they've done
00:28:17 something about it and i'm personally for that i'm really looking forward to the legislation
00:28:24 coming through and we just need to keep up the fight in the interim and then take it from there
00:28:29 as a group have you got anything to add yeah i think i imagine probably his comments were coming
00:28:37 from a foreign policy considerations um he was being quite literally diplomatic i think um
00:28:45 obviously there are tensions that already exist with biden being an irish and all that um and so
00:28:51 we don't want to give him any excuses to be more difficult than uh than he needs to be um but that
00:28:58 said you know there are lots of reasons why we could have criticized um boris over the last couple
00:29:05 of months you know when churchill was being boarded up and he was silent and that somewhat
00:29:10 undermined his own sort of churchillian credibility in the way that he presents himself
00:29:15 but i think richard is right that we are um astronomically lucky to have a culture secretary
00:29:22 and a community secretary who has common sense and guts um enough to stand up um to this kind
00:29:29 of nonsense and in the grand scheme of things saying it's okay for people to be woke it doesn't
00:29:36 really have any implications and you know it's important for people to have free speech and
00:29:40 freedom of conscience and if they are woke they are woke so strictly speaking it is okay to be
00:29:44 woke we just personally happen to disagree with that um and we'll fight them tooth and nail on
00:29:50 their attacks on our statues well actually when we're talking uh you know you mentioned church
00:29:55 it's interesting churchill has become this absolute sort of emblem of this whole thing
00:30:00 in a way and then in fact we had recently with with uh biden taking over now the churchill bust
00:30:08 has now gone out of the white house again you know uh it was taken out by the last democrat
00:30:14 obama and then it was pulled back and now it's taken out and so it's sort of like this odd thing
00:30:19 that's been going on however that's by way of saying in a very nice segue into uh my my final
00:30:24 remarks here which is that uh we actually have our own bust here of church which is
00:30:30 here i'm going to show you this is beautiful this this little creature uh this is in fact
00:30:36 uh a copy of the bus of church by oscar neiman which is down at chartwell one of the most
00:30:42 fascinating uh houses in britain churchill's home um and uh it's it's a it's a beauty it's a it's a
00:30:50 lovely copy given to me actually recently my 60th birthday for uh by uh rafe hadle mancou now you
00:30:57 know rafe he's always usually on this sofa here um and i know a lot of people have been saying
00:31:02 well where's rafe these days and and that's because unfortunately rafe is having to deal
00:31:06 with a family illness at the moment he will be back uh he's not here in person but he's here in
00:31:12 spirit in in in israel so uh so uh i hope everything goes well soon rafe thank you very
00:31:18 much thank you richard thank you rob for that and uh we shall see you next time and please
00:31:25 don't forget to subscribe will you thank you bye