New Culture Forum - January 27, 2021


Big Tech & Free Speech - Has Online Censorship Gone Too Far?

Heresies: Still A Free Country? Why We Need To Stand Up For British Liberty The Battle To Preserve Our Statues & Cultural Heritage Is Not Over Despite Positive Gov't Statements

Episode Stats


Length

29 minutes

Words per minute

184.86

Word count

5,481

Sentence count

—


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to Counterculture. I'm Peter Whittle. Now a few years ago here at the New
00:00:17 Culture Forum we had a Smith lecture, a lecture we do every year, which is all about the growing
00:00:23 problem of censorship on social media. Then we were talking, this is four years ago, we were
00:00:30 talking about things such as shadow banning and losing your followers and everything. But in the
00:00:36 past couple of weeks we've really gone to a whole new level. Obviously I'm talking about President
00:00:43 Trump being thrown off all social media platforms effectively. This has shown really to a wider
00:00:50 public the extraordinary power of big tech. How big actually is the threat they pose to free speech
00:01:00 and for that matter what in fact can we do about it? Not just the public but people like us who do
00:01:06 shows like this. Well with me to discuss this I'm very pleased to have the co-host comedian
00:01:14 Constantine Kissin of Trigonometry, who's been on the show before, Tom Slater from Spite Online,
00:01:22 and Bradley Strotton. I want to start, if I may, Constantine, with you. You've said,
00:01:31 I've been very struck by a couple of your tweets recently, and you were talking about, you know,
00:01:37 having had russian heritage how you explain to people you know of what is happening now in the
00:01:46 west what maybe you know they were used to under soviet russia and uh how we in fact are losing
00:01:54 various values and in fact you know we once took for granted um do you think it is do you think
00:02:02 that it is that serious? I do think it's that serious and the direction of travel has been
00:02:09 very very bad for quite some time but I think one of the things that nobody even in the Soviet
00:02:14 Union quite imagined is something as powerful and as ever-present, omnipresent as big tech
00:02:22 and the power that big tech companies now have is beyond anything that Joseph Stalin would have
00:02:27 imagined in a wet dream it's really quite something and i think what we have seen not only in the last
00:02:33 week i've been warning about this as you know peter for years now uh because the power and the
00:02:39 opportunity to behave in this way was always there but what we've seen particularly the moment for me
00:02:44 was actually something that many commentators in the uk missed it was i believe in november just
00:02:49 before the election when the republicans who had clearly been storing up uh the story about hunter
00:02:55 biden joe biden's son and his various dealings in in ukraine and china and elsewhere uh they tried
00:03:01 to get that story out via the new york post that story was censored uh new york post twitter account
00:03:08 was suspended anyone who attempted to share that story uh was suspended as well and i think that
00:03:13 was really the moment that big tech made their play they decided who they wanted to win in the
00:03:20 election and they decided that they were going to use the power that they have uh in order to in
00:03:26 order to do that now i'm not saying that was the deciding factor my point is they tried to interfere
00:03:32 and they got away with it a large section of the establishment jumped on board they were quite
00:03:36 happy they were quite happy to endorse that sort of action and so therefore it's no surprise to me
00:03:41 that big tech have now taken the next step which is to suspend a sitting president's account uh to
00:03:47 delete the accounts of many other people we've all seen in the last week that a lot of people have
00:03:53 been removed from the platform a lot of people uh have been unfollowed from particular accounts and
00:03:58 so on and and the worst of all of course is the story with parlor where we keep being told that
00:04:04 if you want freedom of speech well build your own twitter platform well parlor did that and of course
00:04:09 immediately their server access access to payment processes their access to bank accounts their
00:04:14 access to absolutely everything was shut down and so this libertarian argument which people have
00:04:20 been throwing at me for a number of years now which is you know if you don't like twitter's
00:04:24 terms of service go and join something else that no longer applies as i always said it wouldn't
00:04:29 because these companies are natural monopolies they will have immense power and as we've seen
00:04:34 in the last week they will use it and uh what surprises me most about this peter just to finish
00:04:41 uh my point is how ignorant politicians are what of what's happening my view and i know and i sound
00:04:49 conspiratorial when i say it and i don't like sounding this way and i don't like making this
00:04:54 point but given what we've seen now the question we really should be asking is are we ever going
00:05:00 to have another free and fair election ever again that is really the question that should be being
00:05:06 us here. And if I were a politician, that would be at the very forefront of my mind, because if I'm
00:05:11 a politician, I'm seeing my power seep away into the hands of these bearded, you know, hoodie
00:05:17 wearing nerds in Silicon Valley. Tom, do you think that when we sort of hear, oh, people are very
00:05:23 concerned about what happened with President Trump, for example, but basically it's not just people
00:05:29 who would support him, it's people on the left too. Are you convinced of that? I mean, it seems
00:05:35 to me that the what you could broadly call the left have been you know rather happy about what's
00:05:41 happened with big tech and the president it's been strange how happy they've been about it now for
00:05:47 narrow partisan reasons that makes sense um they've recognized for a long time that silicon valley is
00:05:53 in some way a kind of ally in the project of crushing people they happen to dislike i think
00:05:58 it'd be disingenuous to suggest that the censorship has been there's been anything other than largely
00:06:03 in one direction so far but at the same time i am staggered by the naivety or the willingness
00:06:10 to go along with this and people who claim to be on the left as you say effectively making
00:06:14 a ultra libertarian argument in the favor of the right of these billionaires to be able to control
00:06:22 what is now the public square um and just the mere fact that for now they happen to broadly
00:06:26 speaking align with your own political biases and prejudices doesn't seem to me to still be a good
00:06:32 reason to concede the principle that the Jack Dorseys and the Mark Zuckerbergs of this world
00:06:36 should hold that kind of monopoly power. I think it's worth saying to people, what's worth kind
00:06:41 of pointing out, whilst the censorship has been broadly speaking in one direction, when it's this
00:06:46 unwieldy and this huge, like something like big tech and big tech censorship is, there are going
00:06:50 to be plenty of people who are going to get caught in the crossfire of this. We've seen that in recent
00:06:55 years where you've seen some of these companies, for PR reasons, I would imagine, kind of engage
00:06:59 kind of tit for tat censorship you know you silence and proud boys account you go after some
00:07:03 anarchist and antifa accounts at the same time we've also seen uh radical feminists are probably
00:07:09 the main constituency i would say on the left who have been swallowed up by this kind of
00:07:13 censorious machine so far because they happen to believe as most people do that are there is such
00:07:18 a thing as biological sex but at the same time it's quite clear that it is in one direction but
00:07:23 nevertheless this marks a precedent and the thing about donald trump and the reason that you're
00:07:28 even seeing some world leaders um angela merkel for instance president of mexico a few others
00:07:32 actually start to get a little bit nervous about this is because they have crossed the line with
00:07:37 this it was pretty much accepted that donald trump was going to lose his accounts after he
00:07:42 stepped down the fact that they decided to move before the inauguration is very significant because
00:07:47 it's breaching a line that even big tech didn't want to which was to effectively come between
00:07:51 a president and the public if they're willing to do that there really is no one else who is safe
00:07:57 And whilst for the moment, as I say, the censorship seems to be in one direction, the principle has already been conceived.
00:08:03 Yeah, I think that the left are failing to consider the broader implications of big tech censoring the democratically elected president of the United States.
00:08:12 If they're willing to do that, then who aren't they willing to censor?
00:08:17 and yes I think that as you said that the main constituents on the left are the
00:08:23 radical feminists who are simply just advocating for the existence of
00:08:27 biological sex and yes it is it is it's full of nuance and and obviously
00:08:35 difficulties that obviously are going to come to light I what you what did you
00:08:40 feel when you saw this uh whistleblower piece of footage it was on social media today actually
00:08:50 uh we're recording this on uh friday the 15th of jack dorsey saying this is actually just the
00:08:55 beginning constantine i mean he said he says this is just beginning was that selectively kind of
00:09:02 uh presented or should we take him at face value what he says yeah well obviously i don't know
00:09:09 because i wasn't there i i think project veritas have done some good work in the past uh i i was
00:09:17 not particularly struck or impressed by this clip that we've seen today i think he was probably
00:09:22 referring to the fact that there would be some other accounts that this is probably from a few
00:09:27 days ago i would imagine the accounts he's talking about have already been taken down and petra
00:09:31 uh but but yeah i mean the fact that big tech will will go further uh is is something we should all be
00:09:37 thinking about and actually i wanted to pick up on on both tom and bradley's points
00:09:41 about where this is going if you think about the left and the right in this conversation and i'm
00:09:46 someone who's very much in the center uh everyone who has been quote unquote cancelled in the last
00:09:52 couple of years your jk rowlings your graham linehans the people like that that's exactly
00:09:58 who's going to be being censored in the future so the left have a lot to worry about and that's why
00:10:03 i'm so surprised that as tom says they've gone for these very short-term tactics on this issue
00:10:09 this is going to come back and bite everybody everybody left right up down in the back side
00:10:15 and that's why a lot more people should be concerned about it than i think they are at the
00:10:20 moment and we've seen this throughout history when whenever whenever you dig a hole for another
00:10:26 you always end up being the one that falls into it and i just it it boggles my mind hard as that
00:10:31 is nowadays to boggle my mind that people are not seeing do you think that uh rad do you think that
00:10:39 sort of younger people are aware of this on social media i mean people just friends of yours maybe
00:10:44 who just use it as a on a daily basis are they aware of censorship at all i mean have they been
00:10:51 over the past few years i mean the people i've spoken to have largely been putting forward
00:10:56 the um kind of private property argument that we see endorsed on the left that you know twitter can
00:11:01 do whatever they want because this is their private property but i think that as we've just
00:11:05 discussed if twitter are willing to censor the democratically elected president and we've seen
00:11:10 censorship from all kinds of big tech organizations with um you know youtube and talk radio just a
00:11:17 few eight weeks ago yes um that we we really need to be considering what role big tech plays in our
00:11:24 regulation of our um public domain and our public sphere and i think that the way that we overcome
00:11:30 this is by uh making big tech accountable for uh that rig that regulation so and in order to do
00:11:38 that they need to be take more of a publisher role so this is the crucial point i'm sorry i'm glad
00:11:44 you brought this up actually i because i think a lot of people watching you know uh i would include
00:11:50 myself in that they don't know the ins and outs of this thing there is there is the kind there is
00:11:55 the thing you brought just brought up brandy which is that essentially there is this problem
00:12:00 at the center of everything isn't there are they publishers or are they just a platform
00:12:05 and a lot of this comes down to this particular thing doesn't it called section 230 can you um
00:12:13 could you tom explain that actually just explain what it means what is this section and what is
00:12:19 it set up what is the problem that it has set up so as you say section 230 or 230s the americans
00:12:26 would refer to it is largely speaking referred to as the kind of first amendment of the internet by
00:12:30 which they mean it removes civil liability for platforms online platforms uh for things that
00:12:36 they use as post which if you want a big open platform for discussion and debate is actually
00:12:41 a good idea because companies which were in some ways liable for what they use as posted in relation
00:12:46 to anything defamation incitement whatever would either shut down moderate heavily or preemptively
00:12:53 censor to a very severe degree but the other part of that law is it also gives them some latitude
00:12:58 to moderate um even things which are just kind of generally deemed to be otherwise unacceptable
00:13:03 and so you do create this tension as it's been largely more discussed in the us than the uk but
00:13:08 are they a publisher or are they a platform and various moves from both the left and the right
00:13:12 of politics in congress to suggest that if you're not going to do what we want then maybe that
00:13:17 sub that status of yours should be revoked i mean the thing that's worth remembering is if we want
00:13:22 these platforms to not be censorious bases you do want them to be platforms but they're going
00:13:27 to be platforms which conform to something resembling a free and open discourse and the
00:13:32 issue is that the the legal structure that exists in the us in spite of the first amendment um allows
00:13:37 for them to practice censorship which goes far beyond what which what would be acceptable in
00:13:41 a court law in the us and we're increasingly seeing as well with censorious writ being extended
00:13:46 over all sorts of countries and what's interesting now is you're starting to get a little bit pushed
00:13:50 back to that we saw uh poland recently announcing a law which would effectively allow people to
00:13:55 appeal in court if social media companies censored something which wasn't prohibited under polish law
00:14:01 we're going to see more of that tension play out i think because you effectively have in this sense
00:14:06 censorship being um extended into areas which even sometimes quite censorious national
00:14:13 policies wouldn't touch and this is something that's really at the heart of this so it's not
00:14:16 as if you want these i don't think you really want these platforms to be publishers because
00:14:20 they would seem to be the kind of online forums that do have value that do allow for a modicum
00:14:25 of discussion the issue is how do you make them platforms in a genuine sense i guess in a genuine
00:14:30 free and open way and given that we've seen as constant in this reference the fact that they're
00:14:34 willing to crush any competition towards them in the form of parlour or whatever the question then
00:14:40 does come back is to what form of intervention regulation self-regulation who knows that would
00:14:46 force them to go down the line that was more liberal in that sense so that sounds like a
00:14:51 contradiction in terms but we have whatever conversation we have about this we have to start
00:14:55 from the recognition that this is not just neat little websites that we're talking about these
00:15:00 things constitute the public square in the 21st century and their decision to have a material
00:15:05 impact on our freedom of speech if not strictly legal impact on it and whatever discussion we
00:15:09 have we have to start by accepting that because a lot of people who are deluding themselves by
00:15:13 claiming you know it's just like an online forum it's not that it's something far bigger and we
00:15:18 have to take it very serious what what stage actually tom is the polish proposal act it's
00:15:24 not law yet is it it's not law as far as i can tell it's just been proposed so far what's kind
00:15:29 of interesting it almost goes in the opposite direction of some of the laws that we've seen
00:15:33 in europe in recent years you know germany had the net dg law which was effectively putting
00:15:39 pressure on social media companies to take down illegal content almost in the opposite direction
00:15:44 and in that sense was actually leading to some of the problems i was alluding to if you take away
00:15:48 section 230 you have a situation where you had facebook being very pre-emptive being very overly
00:15:54 cautious you saw satirical accounts finding themselves censored for mocking politicians etc
00:15:59 so in a way what we're seeing from poland it's early days you know it's not as if the ruling
00:16:03 party there is particularly liberal by any stretch of the imagination so i don't want to lionize it
00:16:07 too much certainly without seeing all of the detail but it's an interesting push in the opposite
00:16:12 direction which is suggested laws in relation to censorship will be decided by democratic nation
00:16:17 state and that we are concerned and do not want to allow these huge companies to almost interfere
00:16:24 and extend censorship beyond the bounds through which we as a society decided it should be so
00:16:29 it's an interesting development in that respect and pj if i may add yeah yeah i was just going to
00:16:33 say i think uh tom put his uh finger exactly on it in that i think what what we're talking about
00:16:39 here is not really although the power they have is is overwhelming and overwhelming power obviously
00:16:46 will lead to corruption i do think this is more a case of a bunch of people who never intended
00:16:52 to be the owners of the public square having to contend with things that never existed before
00:16:59 the ability for a person to type something into their phone and start a massive rally somewhere
00:17:05 didn't really exist until 10 15 years ago so they're they're dealing with the fact that these
00:17:10 platforms they've created uh have externalities they have consequences which they didn't
00:17:15 anticipate and they're having to try and find some balance because they're under a lot of pressure i
00:17:19 mean look at sam harris the great thinker uh who came out only a week ago and said that he was
00:17:25 delighted that donald trump was censored uh on twitter and he thanked jack dorsey for doing so
00:17:31 so if you are jack dorsey you're under pressure from both sides and you're having to try and work
00:17:36 out what the right path is but as tom i think rightly says what has happened as a result is that
00:17:42 being under all of this pressure the we're in this unique position now where actually you know
00:17:48 we saw with talk radio's youtube channel being taken down talk radio is regulated by ofcom in
00:17:53 this country right so the things that they were saying were not illegal and they were allowed to
00:17:58 said on their radio station but were not allowed on youtube that is a preposterous state of affairs
00:18:05 if you think about it because it tells you that the youtube is actually regulating things much
00:18:10 harsher than our own legal representatives would want them to do and yet they're doing that because
00:18:15 they're under so much pressure from both sides and i think this is why the political aspect of
00:18:21 this is so important politicians need to make make it clear to the big tech companies what the rules
00:18:27 should be and that's why i am encouraged that there are yes it's in poland yes it's not yet
00:18:32 law yes we don't know exactly the details but i think uh politicians and our legal representatives
00:18:37 uh legislative representative need to start telling the big tech companies where the lines are
00:18:43 what do you think uh what do you think the chances of that are i mean uh you know i know that we need
00:18:50 to have this but the what what tom outlined there in poland is there any chance of that here i mean
00:18:58 that they could be so unequivocal uh i i to be honest with you i almost think it doesn't really
00:19:04 matter what the british government does on this what matters is what the american government does
00:19:08 on this and the next president of the united states is and uh very left-wing journalist
00:19:14 glenn greenwald has done a lot of good work on this and he's basically shown that the joe biden
00:19:19 cabinet is packed full of executives from the big companies big tech companies so i'm not that
00:19:25 optimistic they also give a lot of money to both sides of the political spectrum both here and in
00:19:30 in the united states uh and so yes the political system is filled with money and people from big
00:19:36 tech uh so yeah the idea that politicians will be uh super keen to do this um is is yeah it's
00:19:44 for the birds i think but that is probably the only route can i ask you actually brad you know
00:19:50 i i know that uh you know without wishing to sound patronizing you know younger people in
00:19:56 their 20s one one observation I've made is that they are much more I mean this
00:20:01 sounds extraordinary but they're much less passionate shall we say about
00:20:06 censorship they tend they you know this idea of free speech doesn't have such a
00:20:11 purchase as maybe it would have done a few years ago it's almost like they're
00:20:16 more concerned with concepts like safety and concepts like not offending and
00:20:23 things like this would you say that's a true characterization or not really yes i would say i
00:20:28 think that the problem with young people today is that they're endorsing ideas that are kind of
00:20:32 packaged as heretical as if they're really trying to punch upwards and that this is what um this
00:20:38 kind of censorship or of donald trump has been it's been a punch of the this kind of establishments
00:20:44 uh that that should be censored and they're fighting these kind of fictitious systems of
00:20:49 oppression that these white supremacist patriarchies if you will yeah and and
00:20:54 obviously these ideas do have their roots in the academy it's what young
00:20:58 people are being taught we've seen that the post-modernism is completely taken
00:21:02 over all that students are learning so that they're really trying to fight
00:21:06 things that don't exist and they're not too concerned with the material reality
00:21:12 that we're facing yes when we sort of look towards the future whatever
00:21:19 happens politically i mean you know we do this channel here and constant you've been doing
00:21:25 trigonometry for for longer we we do the you know what is the kind of what is the lookout i mean
00:21:32 you know it's do we have a kind of you know sort of damocles over us or what and if so you know
00:21:39 what should we do well this is the thing peter i think i don't know why we haven't spoken about
00:21:46 this aspect of it uh in the past but i imagine that you are having to make decisions about
00:21:51 guests you have or don't have on the show conversations you do or don't have on the show
00:21:56 we obviously at trigonometry do the same because uh you know we we're trying to do the work that
00:22:02 we do but if we get deleted from youtube today that that will obviously stop right so everybody
00:22:08 is basically now in a position where you're probably not only seeing avert censorship from
00:22:12 the big tech companies you're also going to see a lot of self-censorship from people who are trying
00:22:17 to preserve what you know the channels of self-censorship from people who are trying to
00:22:23 preserve what you know the channels the business whatever it is that they've created and i think
00:22:28 that is probably the most detrimental and deleterious aspect of this whole thing and going
00:22:33 forward i'm afraid uh what i see is we're all going to have to be extra careful if i may offer
00:22:39 For a note of optimism, I always think that human beings respond to incentives.
00:22:45 And if you create incentives for people to fight this, to create alternative platforms,
00:22:51 to create decentralized social media platforms, to integrate Bitcoin into microtransactions
00:22:58 online, because that's again decentralized and less subject to government control, you
00:23:03 well see that this was actually the beginning of a process which leads to a completely different
00:23:10 online space as a result that is great hope what it really needs is sort of like uh i don't know
00:23:18 sort of a a big like elon musk figure or something someone like that to actually come along and
00:23:25 create a whole new sort of system as a a kind of global competitor to what we've got isn't that
00:23:33 really what it needs well perhaps but i think this is one of the things is that we've been slightly
00:23:38 kind of hostage to fortune or just waiting for either these big tech companies to kind of sort
00:23:43 themselves out in line with liberal principles or hoping someone would create an alternative now as
00:23:49 you say someone of elon musk stature might be able to pull it off in a way that parlor certainly
00:23:53 wouldn't they were crushed as constantine was saying um in very short order obviously in the
00:23:58 the wake of the kind of tension of last week but again the difficulty there is how do you not only
00:24:05 kind of take on these platforms which have these various stories policies but also the way in which
00:24:11 the tech firms as we saw with the parlor situation not only control the major platform shall we say
00:24:17 in the major search engines but broadly speaking the kind of infrastructure of the internet i mean
00:24:21 when apple and google removed parlor from their respective app stores that basically meant that
00:24:28 that closed parlour off to any new users
00:24:30 on the vast majority of smartphones in the world.
00:24:33 And then when you saw Amazon Web Services boot it off,
00:24:36 what was it, days later,
00:24:37 that took it off of the internet entirely
00:24:39 and created this kind of contagion effect
00:24:41 that Constantine was talking about,
00:24:43 where again, anyone who was working with them
00:24:45 in relation to banking or payment or whatever,
00:24:47 was suddenly very scared of touching them.
00:24:49 So again, we've gone from a discussion about
00:24:51 why don't you just leave and set up your own platforms?
00:24:53 Why don't you just leave, set up your own platforms,
00:24:55 set up your own cloud-based servers,
00:24:57 set up your own payment set up there's a certain point at which this becomes kind of insurmountable
00:25:02 you know bar for the intervention of someone of such supreme stature that they would be able to
00:25:06 make it happen so what solutions to this are i don't know um i think there's a lot of people
00:25:12 talking about there'd be some sort of online bill of rights online how you do that on a global basis
00:25:17 i don't really know would make much sense but at the very least i think we do need to recognize
00:25:21 that this is serious and knock down those arguments which try to suggest this is like
00:25:25 a restaurant kicking you out for upsetting the customers all the ridiculous arguments we've seen
00:25:29 recently these companies have a material hold over vast ways of discussion and the first step
00:25:37 to reckoning that is recognized you know this is why we do channels like we do why you write what
00:25:42 you do it is extraordinary is it not that here we are in 2021 and actually this is the hottest issue
00:25:49 You know, this would, you know, I think I'm a bit older than most of you, you know, the idea that we would actually be talking about the pros and cons of free speech is quite extraordinary and disturbing, isn't it?
00:26:02 I mean, this point has been made so many times, but if you do pick up, like I did last night, 1984, you know, again, and just flick through it, it is quite, quite disturbing.
00:26:15 Do you not find that we are actually even having to have these discussions now?
00:26:19 this is really frightening and i think it also reminds us that whilst there was a lot of kind of
00:26:24 techno-utopianism around the internet when it first came out these um mechanisms and these
00:26:29 technologies they won't just liberate us kind of on their own terms kind of by themselves they do
00:26:34 wrap themselves around and are wielded by people in politics they respond to our culture and our
00:26:39 culture is increasingly censorious and what's so striking is i mean obviously we've seen issues of
00:26:44 censorship on a legal level in the uk be wrapped up in recent years but if you even think about
00:26:49 America, it's so striking that in the land of the First Amendment, the arguments over freedom of
00:26:55 speech are seen as not being applicable to the online sphere. You know, America is a country
00:26:59 in which card-carrying liberals in the form of the American Civil Liberties Union or other groups
00:27:04 went to the wall in the 1970s defending the right of Nazis to march through Jewish towns because
00:27:09 they genuinely believed that sunlight was the best disinfectant, that if you, again, allowed for
00:27:15 censorship of these extreme people, then civil rights activists and everyone else would be caught
00:27:19 up in the mess of that but really profound principles and now what we're seeing is that
00:27:23 even in a country like america which has this rich free speech history um history of supreme
00:27:29 court judgments this very firm line and all of these things that the culture particularly in
00:27:33 elite institutions is such that censorship can still be wielded by other means and what we're
00:27:38 seeing now especially with the the marriage of big tech with the democratic party as constantin was
00:27:43 alluding to before is outsourcing of hate speech laws to the private sector. I think
00:27:49 it just reminds me, not in Britain where we have this longer history of hate speech legislation
00:27:54 and restrictions on speech, but even in a country like America this kind of Anglosphere culture
00:27:58 which is very hostile to the idea of freedom of speech can make itself felt even if it feels like
00:28:04 the constitutional legal protections against censorship are very strong. It just seems to be
00:28:09 rampant at this point to the point where it's just knocking down all the court.
00:28:11 I think the point that Constantine made earlier actually as well about self-censoring doesn't just apply to what we might do, it applies in everyday life as well.
00:28:23 And I think increasingly people actually just preempt any kind of problem. And I think, you know, that is that is an incredible worry.
00:28:33 But look, gentlemen, thank you very, very much for joining us. I mean, this is we're going to be revisiting this on a regular basis.
00:28:38 something tells me um but thank you for joining us to talk about it um and um we will hopefully
00:28:46 see you in a few months time and see what is progress if any has been made so thank you very
00:28:53 much to brad to constant and to tom uh that's it for counterculture this week and we will see you
00:28:59 next time thank you very much bye
00:29:08 Thank you.