New Culture Forum - January 16, 2021


Heresies: Still A Free Country? Why We Need To Stand Up For British Liberty

Brendan O'Neill - Covid, Class & The Decay Of Cultural Confidence In The West Big Tech & Free Speech - Has Online Censorship Gone Too Far?

Episode Stats


Length

26 minutes

Words per minute

147.55

Word count

3,841

Sentence count

118


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 On Friday evening I had a constituency surgery and a woman about my age was complaining that
00:00:10 she had one relationship failed because they couldn't see each other and she had a new
00:00:16 boyfriend but he lives on the other side of the Welsh border and therefore they weren't able to
00:00:20 meet. This isn't something for government or the state to be involved in. It's not even the
00:00:27 physical act of the removal of the freedom it's the demonization of those
00:00:32 people who want to argue in defense of freedom that has most concerned me in
00:00:37 recent weeks I said so why are you ringing me and he said I need to check
00:00:43 your thinking so I just laughed and said right let me get this right you're the
00:00:49 police and said yeah and you want to check my thinking he said yeah I said
00:00:54 have you any idea what that makes you he said no I saw there's a book called 1984 by George Orwell
00:01:02 now that's a dystopian novel you're using it as a police operator
00:01:24 Britain doesn't feel very free at the moment, and that's bad news, for Britain certainly,
00:01:36 but also for the world, because uniquely British identity and our long history is rooted in
00:01:43 the ideal of individual freedom.
00:01:48 What does liberty mean to you and why does it matter?
00:01:52 I think that English, the British tradition of liberty is something which we've all grown
00:01:59 used to, perhaps we're too used to it and take it too much for granted, but it has always
00:02:05 been based on the assumption that you're free to do something unless there is a law
00:02:10 that tells you that you can't.
00:02:13 Over the centuries, Britain has been known as not just a free country, but the free country,
00:02:20 an island of liberty, a refuge from royal absolutism and from the totalitarian ambitions
00:02:27 of fascists and communists alike.
00:02:32 I spoke with former MEP and historian of British liberty, Dan Hannan, about how that happened.
00:02:40 What made Britain so different? What happened here?
00:02:44 We were beneficiaries of a lot of happy accidents.
00:02:50 One of the accidents was simply geography.
00:02:53 If you're an island, you generally don't need a big land army to defend yourself.
00:02:59 An island can be defended with a navy and a territorial militia, neither of which is
00:03:04 a particularly good instrument for internal repression.
00:03:08 So in England and then Britain, unlike in most of Europe, when kings wanted things, when they wanted money or taxes from their subjects, they had to ask nicely by summoning a parliament.
00:03:21 They couldn't compel by force of law in a way that some of the more autocratic states could do.
00:03:27 The other thing which I think is an underrated miracle in the English-speaking world is the wonder of the common law.
00:03:35 this system that you know grows like a coral with each case serving as the starting point for the
00:03:42 next I mean nobody would invent it if you're trying to come up with a legal system from first
00:03:46 principles you would say you write down the law you make the general abstract principle and then
00:03:51 you apply it to a specific case the idea that no one does that that it just kind of grows organically
00:03:57 I mean who would invent that right where did it come we don't really know right it predates written
00:04:02 history. But again and again in the story of the English-speaking peoples it has turned
00:04:07 out to be the real hero, the force that has held autocratic government at bay and preserved
00:04:13 personal freedom.
00:04:16 In the 21st century the idea of personal freedom has become so commonplace that we barely give
00:04:22 it a second thought. It's hard for us now to appreciate just how radically different
00:04:29 the ideas of individual liberty are to how most of humankind has always lived.
00:04:36 We are unbelievably privileged to live in an age and in a place where we have some mechanisms
00:04:44 to hold the government to account and some notion of the elevation of the individual
00:04:48 above the collective. It's almost impossible to stress just how weird this is in the long
00:04:55 sweep of things. You know, maybe 10,000 years ago somebody worked out that if you put a
00:04:59 seed in the ground, crops will grow, right? It took about five minutes for somebody else
00:05:04 to work out that it was easier to nick your neighbour's crop than to spend all year tending
00:05:10 to your own. And then comes the really pernicious discovery that if you want to maximise the
00:05:16 utility to yourself, you regularise the theft, right, through a series of tithes and tolls
00:05:22 and taxes so civilization was born in tyranny and for most human beings most of the last 10,000 years
00:05:30 was the story of oppression and serfdom and caste and misery and history was the story of the top
00:05:36 one percent of the top one percent the rest of us were were scratching out a miserable existence
00:05:42 dawn to dusk in the fields and then comes this extraordinary breakthrough that happened more or
00:05:49 or less in the language that you and I are now talking, this idea that the rules are
00:05:55 above the rulers, that the people in charge don't just get to make up the law as they
00:06:01 go along, that above the king, or the biggest guy in the tribe, there is this invisible
00:06:05 but ineluctable force of a, you can't see it, you can't touch it, you can't taste it,
00:06:09 but it binds the king as surely as it binds his poorest subject.
00:06:14 And that beginning of the rule of law, which leads to property rights, which leads to some
00:06:20 independent magistracy to enforce those property rights, which then leads to the development
00:06:25 of intellectual property and the beginning of innovative free market society.
00:06:31 That was first the property of English-speaking peoples and a handful of people in the nearby
00:06:38 parts of northwestern Europe.
00:06:39 But then, in the 20th century, it began to spread around most of the world, and it has
00:06:46 elevated and ennobled our species in a way that we just don't seem able to recognise.
00:06:52 We must be the most ungrateful generation ever to have lived.
00:06:58 Britain's never been perfect, but the miracle was that what happened here happened at all.
00:07:06 ideas of individualism and personal freedom took hold early and never quite
00:07:13 let go and for all our imperfections we exported our best values across the
00:07:20 world ending the slave trade spreading common law and the parliamentary system
00:07:27 you talk about the the English speaking peoples and you've written about the
00:07:31 importance of the sort of the Anglosphere of the countries that sort
00:07:34 have inherited this tradition out of Britain. Do you think that's still true today that there's
00:07:38 this relationship around the world? I think in general the countries that are beneficiaries of
00:07:45 the limited government, common law, private property based tradition that began in the
00:07:51 Anglosphere are other things being equal are going to be better off than the ones that are not right
00:07:56 so these values explain why Hong Kong is not China you know they explain why Singapore is
00:08:03 not Indonesia they explain why Bermuda is not Haiti you know and indeed for that matter they
00:08:07 explain why they explain why Israel is not Syria we tend not to think of Israel as a former British
00:08:12 colony but it has the same property-based common law system and the same regulatory model as most
00:08:17 of the the core anglo-sphere countries so you know if you in with the kind of Rawlsian veil
00:08:23 of ignorance if you didn't know where you were going to be born and you just had to make the
00:08:26 choice, would I rather be born in a common law country, you would take it.
00:08:32 But today, we find our oldest values under threat. For the best of reasons, the passing
00:08:40 nightmare of Covid-19 has seen unprecedented curtailments of basic liberties.
00:08:46 Do you think people in Britain today still care about liberty?
00:08:51 It's a very good question.
00:08:52 I think people do care about liberty when it's easy.
00:08:56 But at times of threat, that's when you stress test it.
00:09:02 And that's what alarms me about the debates we're currently having during these lockdowns.
00:09:09 An epidemic or a war or an earthquake or disaster of any kind flicks switches in our brains.
00:09:16 It makes us more authoritarian, more collectivist, more intolerant, more tribal.
00:09:21 It throws us back on our basic kind of hunter-gatherer heuristics.
00:09:27 And just as the Second World War was then outlasted by a whole series of government prohibitions
00:09:35 that had been supposedly brought in contingently but then were not removed when the peace came.
00:09:41 So I'm afraid that the same may happen as we come out of lockdown.
00:09:44 So after 1945, the apparatus of state control that had been sold as part of mobilisation,
00:09:53 in many cases remained in place for decades, arguably some of it even now.
00:09:56 So we had rationing until 1954, we had ID cards until 1952, we had full conscription
00:10:03 until 1960, but when you look at the economics of it, most of the controls put in place in
00:10:09 the first half of the 1940s weren't really removed until the Thatcher
00:10:13 government in the 1980s and in aspects of education and healthcare we still
00:10:17 have them. I'm afraid I can I can see a similarly bleak future when I look at
00:10:24 the world as it hauls itself out of the pupa of lockdown. We will also have been
00:10:31 metamorphosed and not in a good way you know that there will be a shift in power
00:10:35 globally to more authoritarian countries but much more alarmingly inside our heads
00:10:40 there will be an authoritarian shift and you can see that already in the
00:10:43 political debates in most countries. In other words unless we reinvigorate our
00:10:49 commitment to liberty we will emerge less free as a country in small ways and
00:10:55 large. Our Prime Minister Boris Johnson used to be firmly and publicly opposed
00:11:01 to the nanny state now he wants the government to make us all lose weight I'm not normally a
00:11:09 believer in nannying or bossing type of politics but the reality is that obesity is one of the real
00:11:18 co-morbidity factors it's losing weight is frankly one of the ways that you can reduce your own risks
00:11:26 Clare Fox, a former Brexit party MEP and now Lady Fox of Buxton, is also worried by what she sees.
00:11:35 Boris Johnson, who's sort of somewhat libertarian, you know, traditionally in his previous writings and so forth,
00:11:41 but now not only is he pursuing these policies, which as you say, maybe in a temporary sense one can understand,
00:11:48 but he's talking about virtual ID card programmes, he's talking about needing the state to make us all thinner.
00:11:55 He seemed to have moved much further towards using state power in the long term to change things.
00:12:02 There has been a systematic attempt by the government, led by Boris Johnson, who called himself a libertarian,
00:12:12 to argue against freedom in this period.
00:12:16 And that is actually harrowing.
00:12:19 And I don't think they've made a particularly consistent job of it.
00:12:23 But what they've said is that there are other things that are more important than freedom.
00:12:29 And each and every time they've said that, it chips away at that notion of freedom being a foundational value.
00:12:36 And constantly we're told safety is the thing, you know, or health is the issue.
00:12:42 And of course, once you establish that freedom is just this piddling little thing that we don't have to worry about.
00:12:47 But the most important thing in life is, for example, longevity or health.
00:12:51 then the consequences of that in the long term will be very far-reaching.
00:12:58 Meanwhile, we have witnessed the opportunistic eruption into our closed-down public squares
00:13:04 of a radical movement determined to paint our history as shameful and tear it down.
00:13:12 What's worrying is not that you have a tiny handful of lunatics
00:13:18 who think that it is somehow okay to attack the statue of Winston Churchill or Robert Peel or
00:13:24 Abraham Lincoln. I mean, how absurd do you want to, you know, in the US even attacking the statues
00:13:28 of abolitionists and, you know, every country has a lunatic fringe. You know, we don't get any
00:13:34 special exemption there. The really alarming thing was the way in which official Britain
00:13:39 humoured and indulged this lunatic fringe, the way in which politicians and police chiefs,
00:13:46 universities, corporations, premier footballers drop to their knees often literally in order to
00:13:54 appease this these these angry young blockheads. As things stand we will emerge from the pandemic
00:14:02 into a country not only far less free but also stripped of the heritage and heroes that might
00:14:08 remind us of our best values and all of this is happening at the worst possible time as we exit
00:14:15 the European Union needing to assert our sovereign identity again and as a
00:14:20 liberal forces of all kinds gain power around the world. Now more than ever we
00:14:28 need to remember who we are as a free country and assert our British identity
00:14:33 as a nation founded in liberty. There's an old response that everyone used to
00:14:38 know when a busybody turned up and started trying to impose rules on the
00:14:42 rest of us, it's a free country." In August 1647, Sir Thomas Fairfax was appointed Constable
00:14:52 of the Tower of London, a public honour to reward the general who led the new model army
00:14:58 to victory over royalist forces in the Civil War. When Sir Thomas made his first tour of
00:15:04 inspection of this ancient fortress, he asked to see a great treasure that was kept there
00:15:10 for safekeeping, not a gold crown or royal jewels, but a crumbling roll of vellum.
00:15:18 When Sir Thomas held this ancient document in his hands, he said that it was this, the
00:15:24 great charter itself, Magna Carta, already then over 400 years old, and the ancient principles
00:15:31 contained inside it, that his men had always been fighting to restore.
00:15:38 and again in the history of Britain and the English-speaking peoples, we see this special
00:15:43 relationship to liberty. Instead of demanding that freedom be granted as a novelty, the
00:15:49 cry has gone up that our ancient liberties have been taken away and need to be restored.
00:15:58 Harry Miller, whose freedom of speech was challenged by the police for tweets over trans
00:16:02 issues and took his case to the High Court, understands his very 21st century struggle
00:16:10 in terms that Sir Thomas too would have understood.
00:16:18 You ended up being in Britain of all places, being visited at your place of work by the
00:16:23 police who wanted to check on your thinking. How did that end up happening?
00:16:28 happened because I'd been posting on Twitter about proposed reforms to the
00:16:32 Gender Recognition Act and obviously that criticised the sort of ideology of
00:16:40 trans that people can change sex so I'd not gone at anybody I've not attacked
00:16:45 anybody I've not called for trans people to be attacked harassed or anything
00:16:50 whatsoever like that so I was fairly certain that everything that I posted
00:16:54 was was absolutely spot-on but one day in January 2019 I got a phone call from
00:17:00 PC Gull of Humberside Police and he said that somebody from down south had
00:17:06 complained to the police that they had 30 transphobic tweets published on my
00:17:11 account Harry the owl and I said to the police officer okie dokie so are any of
00:17:17 them criminal and they said oh no none of them are criminal I said but this is
00:17:21 absolutely this is just absolutely crazy I'm not going to stop tweeting I'm not
00:17:25 going to stop expressing a political opinion and what you're saying is just
00:17:31 utter nonsense and I refuse point-blank to comply and then we talked some more
00:17:38 and this was a 34-minute conversation 34 minutes and we'd established that I'd
00:17:43 not committed a crime by about minute one and so I found that I found that very
00:17:49 insidious, quite chilling, quite scary. I'm an Englishman and Englishmen and women know
00:18:00 that we are free under English common law to do precisely as we please and say precisely
00:18:07 what we please up to the point that we hit a legal restriction.
00:18:13 The statesman and philosopher Edmund Burke, himself writing a century after the Civil War,
00:18:19 and looking back to the glorious revolution of 1688, put it this way,
00:18:26 in the famous statute of the Declaration of Right of the time of William and Mary,
00:18:32 you will see that their care was to secure the religion, laws and liberties that had been long
00:18:39 possessed and recently endangered. And what he meant by that was simple. Britain didn't need to
00:18:47 modernise its way to liberty. Liberty is our heritage here. Freedom ebbs away when we forget
00:18:55 who we are, when we turn away from our past.
00:19:00 We're incredibly lucky to have inherited what we have, to have lived, to have been born
00:19:06 in this country at this time, you know, and what we have inherited is an extraordinary,
00:19:11 gorgeous, complex tapestry that is far beyond the ability of any one generation to have
00:19:17 sewn on its own right and that does imply a commensurate obligation on us to improve it
00:19:24 and repair it and then hand it on securely to those who come after right our children are not
00:19:29 just a random set of individuals born to a different random set of individuals if you are
00:19:33 born in this country or if you grow up in this country regardless of where your grandparents
00:19:37 were born you become heir to that tradition you have your your little share of that tapestry
00:19:44 and with it comes your share of the obligation to have a sort of repairing lease on it right
00:19:49 to make sure that that we maintain it intact and that we improve it where possible think of it
00:19:55 like this this used to belong to my great grandfather it was given to me by his daughter
00:20:03 my grandmother it's nothing very special but it's a little kit that he used to carry
00:20:09 in World War One as some old matches and a uniform mending kit. Perhaps you have
00:20:17 your own family heirlooms like this. Things that are passed down to you to
00:20:23 be looked after and then given on hopefully to future generations. British
00:20:31 Change liberty is like that, an inheritance of freedom.
00:20:44 Obviously we're the inheritors, as you're suggesting there, of a very long liberal tradition
00:20:48 in Britain and the United States, I mean, you know, back and forth as to how liberal
00:20:52 as a country it was, but there was always a very long commitment to that value.
00:20:56 And as the inheritors of that, do you think there's a responsibility there to sort of
00:21:00 carry it forward and hand it on to the next generations in some sort of shape.
00:21:05 There's a lot of disputes in recent months over whether history needs to be revised,
00:21:12 dumped, only looked at through the most malign lenses, British colonial history, British
00:21:26 brutality. And many of those things are, by the way, true. Britain has a lot of blood
00:21:32 on its hands over the years, but it has other traditions as well. And I think that we have
00:21:35 been rather complacent about bringing that history alive for people. So I would be in
00:21:43 favour of that sense of history coming alive. And actually, you know, I found when I stood
00:21:49 as a Brexit Party MEP, I always try to, you know, quote some historical figure when I
00:21:55 gave the speeches at Brexit Party rallies. And people would often say, you know, they
00:22:01 wouldn't necessarily have heard of, you know, Tom Paine or the levellers or the, you know,
00:22:08 what happened in the historic sense of people fighting for freedom. And it gave a sense
00:22:13 of continuity or a sense of a tradition, as you rightly point out, that's very important.
00:22:18 And we have never needed that tradition more than we do today.
00:22:25 We have to acknowledge that this is a great and freedom-loving country.
00:22:30 And while the vast majority have complied with the rules,
00:22:34 there have been too many breaches, too many opportunities,
00:22:37 for our invisible enemy to slip through undetected.
00:22:41 COVID-19 has seen a shocking break in our traditional liberties.
00:22:45 we are increasingly ruled by decree without parliamentary oversight.
00:22:51 Worship, political protest, even dancing, drinking, singing and sex
00:22:58 are prescribed or fenced with rules.
00:23:03 Sir Graham Brady, chairman of the powerful 1922 committee
00:23:07 of backbench Conservative MPs, felt compelled to speak out.
00:23:11 In fact, you've said, if these kinds of measures were being taken in any totalitarian country
00:23:17 around the world, we would be denouncing it as a form of evil.
00:23:23 Why have you taken such a strong stance on this?
00:23:25 Well, obviously there are a number of different concerns about the response to COVID, and
00:23:30 a lot of people have talked about the balance between the economy and public health and
00:23:35 the questions of whether we're prioritising one age group over another and so on.
00:23:39 been well aired over the last several months of the Covid response. What started to shock me
00:23:49 was that we were getting such a level of intrusion into very personal aspects of people's lives
00:23:58 with virtually no comment but in many ways the most shocking thing is the way that people are
00:24:04 instructed as to whether they are allowed to meet their children or their
00:24:08 elderly parents or whether they're allowed to have friends over for a
00:24:15 barbecue or whatever it might be. Whatever your view on the necessity of
00:24:20 these restrictions it is vital that we understand how much of a break they are
00:24:26 from our liberal traditions. The Covid restrictions we've seen brought into
00:24:32 force in recent months, turn all of that on its head and we move instead to a
00:24:40 world of very detailed restrictions where people are confused as to what
00:24:45 they're allowed to do, what they're not allowed to do, who they're allowed to
00:24:48 meet, whether they can be with two people or six people or eight people, or if
00:24:52 they're in Wales or Scotland they can see children as well as six adults. These
00:24:57 These are, I just think, very, very worrying changes and people do start to get used to
00:25:07 different approaches, if they're allowed to become ingrained, if they go without objection.
00:25:14 I think the danger is that too many members of the public start to expect government to
00:25:19 tell them how to live their lives.
00:25:23 When this terrible period is over, we must be ready to repeal the restrictions of our
00:25:29 traditional liberties, not preserve a grim and joyless new normal.
00:25:44 British liberty is a tradition to be cherished and preserved, one that has made the world
00:25:50 better in countless ways, and more importantly, allowed ordinary Britons to live their lives
00:25:56 as they chose.
00:25:58 What does liberty mean to you? Why is it so important to have the...