New Culture Forum - December 21, 2020


Brendan O'Neill - Covid, Class & The Decay Of Cultural Confidence In The West

What Is The Great Reset? Explaining The World Economic Forum's Controversial Initiative Heresies: Still A Free Country? Why We Need To Stand Up For British Liberty

Episode Stats


Length

46 minutes

Words per minute

167.96

Word count

7,814

Sentence count

—


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to So What You're Saying Is, I'm Peter Whittle. Now before I introduce our
00:00:27 guest this week just want to say that we are nearing a hundred thousand
00:00:30 subscriptions on the channel now which is great news but if you want to make it a
00:00:36 hundred thousand for Christmas then please do subscribe you can just simply
00:00:40 go to the button where it says subscribe it's a red button and then there's one
00:00:44 next to it which is a bell which is notifications what that means is you get
00:00:49 notifications of all of our programs as they come up so please do do that won't
00:00:55 you uh now my guest today is somebody who was on the channel towards the very beginning i'm very
00:01:00 pleased he's come back uh brendan o'neill is journalist and columnist and editor of spiked
00:01:07 online he's also very well known to you i'm sure for his numerous appearances right across the
00:01:12 media uh how are you then brendan i'm good thanks peter how are you oh not so bad um from which tier
00:01:19 are you talking to us i'm speaking to you from tier two so i have i've had some of my liberties
00:01:26 restored but not all of them i mean i'm in the kind of halfway house between liberty and tyranny
00:01:31 how does it actually how do you deal with it personally in your own life brendan i mean how
00:01:36 how far do you go along with it you know what what's your approach my approach is that the
00:01:42 whole thing is horrendous and it makes increasingly little sense and i find it incredibly frustrating
00:01:50 i was against the first lockdown even back in march and april there weren't that many of us
00:01:55 who were critical of the lockdown back then but i've always been wary of lockdown as an approach
00:02:01 to something like covid 19 or any kind of virus because i just don't think it worked you know you
00:02:07 can't hide the virus away you can't put it in a cupboard and hope that it disappears it's always
00:02:13 going to spread it's always going to come back it's always going to do what it does so i was
00:02:18 always of the opinion that the best option was that we should take certain measures definitely
00:02:23 offer protection the elderly and the medically vulnerable but allow everyone else to judge their
00:02:30 risks for themselves carry on working carry on socializing i think this government made a
00:02:36 catastrophic error back in march and it's now finding itself going in and out of lockdown
00:02:43 and we're destroying the economy so in terms of how i deal with it i find myself
00:02:48 increasingly frustrated that we seem to live under a government that promised us we would
00:02:53 take back control but has actually assumed more control over our lives than any other government
00:02:59 in living memory and that really is something that can't just simply be um you know reeled
00:03:05 back on i mean once things are in place isn't it the nature of these things that they just stay in
00:03:11 place i think that's a really important point um you know many people have said throughout history
00:03:18 that it's it's very easy to give your freedoms away or to have them taken away it's much more
00:03:22 difficult to get them back again and um i think we can see this actually in the way people talk
00:03:29 about the new normal i find the new normal to be one of the most terrifying phrases of our age it
00:03:34 makes me think of Brave New World, you know, this new normal that experts, cleverer people than us,
00:03:40 have designed for us, which we will all soon be living in. Jonathan Van Tam gave a glimpse of it
00:03:46 when he said, you know, maybe we'll be wearing masks for years, maybe we'll be socially distancing
00:03:52 for years. And I think that kind of the promise of a new normal is one that that horrifies me.
00:03:58 and what it speaks to i think is that um when people assume almost total control over our lives
00:04:05 to the extent where they could tell us when we could leave our house who we can hug at christmas
00:04:11 whether we can go to work or not what we should be eating in pubs if we want to enjoy a drink
00:04:16 i mean incredible amounts of control over how we live they're not just going to relinquish that
00:04:22 they're not just going to give that up and there are a lot of people out there who like telling
00:04:27 people what to do and they've had a real taste for authoritarianism over the past year and i think
00:04:33 it's going to be a really big wrestle to get our freedoms back from those who've taken them away
00:04:38 have you been surprised though by the way in which many people at least in this country have
00:04:44 responded i mean in terms of going along with it i have been surprised um you know i think initially
00:04:55 I was incredibly disappointed when such vast numbers of people were telling opinion pollsters
00:05:02 that they thought lockdown was the right approach. If anything, they wanted the lockdown to last
00:05:06 longer and to be firmer. I was really disappointed with that. It was upsetting for me, you know,
00:05:12 having been on the side of majoritarian opinion for the past four years, probably for the first
00:05:17 time in my life in relation to Brexit, to suddenly find myself as a small minority who was saying,
00:05:25 you know let's not lock down so that was a bit distressing and i think but i think it's become
00:05:30 more complicated over the year i think initially people were in favor of a short sharp lockdown
00:05:36 because let's not forget boris promised us it would last for three weeks and it only had one
00:05:41 aim the aim was simply to prevent the nhs from being overwhelmed by covid cases lots of people
00:05:47 thought okay that sounds sensible we can cope with three weeks let's do it but of course it morphed
00:05:52 into three months and then it became six months and then we had another lockdown and we're probably
00:05:57 going to have another one in january and the aim now is almost to prevent anyone from getting
00:06:02 covid 19 which was never the aim in the first place so there's been mission creep there's been
00:06:07 an extraordinary amount of mission creep in relation to lockdown authoritarianism so i think
00:06:12 people have had the wool pulled over their eyes to the to a certain extent they were promised it
00:06:17 would be a short you know a quick dose of medicine but actually it's turned out to be almost a year
00:06:24 long experiment in extraordinary levels of authoritarianism i think my impression from
00:06:30 speaking to people i know and this includes people who are pro lockdown as well as people who are
00:06:35 anti-lockdown i think most people are publicly they say they're in favor of the lockdown because
00:06:42 that's the done thing and if an opinion pollster phones you up and says do you think we should
00:06:46 lockdown you say yes because you don't want to be called a granny killer you don't want to be
00:06:51 demonized as someone who who doesn't care about people's health and so on but i think in their
00:06:56 day-to-day lives people are finding ways around the lockdown so it's a it's a kind of very british
00:07:02 approach where publicly we say yes of course let's do the right thing but privately we know that
00:07:07 there's more to life than hiding from a virus we also have to connect with people we have to visit
00:07:13 loved ones we have to visit lovers we have to go to the pub we have to do all those things that
00:07:18 make life worth living so i think people are i think most people are breaking the rules but
00:07:26 publicly they will say yes the rules are a good idea i i would go along with that i think that's
00:07:31 my experience too when you look at some of the regulations though brendan take pubs for example
00:07:39 it seems almost that they are actually being targeted you know doesn't it there's there is
00:07:44 absolutely no logic to it i think that's absolutely right they there's no other explanation except
00:07:53 that certain people in positions of authority hate pubs i mean that's the only explanation i
00:07:58 can come up with for some of the new rules which as you say make no sense whatsoever and um the
00:08:05 rules seem increasingly arbitrary, they seem strange, they don't make sense to people. I think
00:08:10 that's one of the reasons people are finding a way around them because no one is going to live
00:08:14 under rules that don't make sense and which do not seem to have any logic beyond controlling
00:08:21 fun. I mean that seems to be one of the drivers behind the pubs rules in particular. But if you
00:08:27 you look at the pub's rules this idea in tier two for example where many of us currently live
00:08:35 you have to have a substantial meal if you want to go to a pub that makes no sense you know how
00:08:41 on earth does ordering burger and chips make you safer from a virus why is that different to
00:08:46 ordering six pints um and and the point is i think that a lot of people in officialdom just don't
00:08:54 like the idea of people going to a pub and getting drunk they don't like the idea of old-fashioned
00:09:00 wet pubs you know wet pubs are those kinds of pubs there are still a handful in existence
00:09:05 which just serve booze mostly to working class people let's be honest about it very often to
00:09:11 older people there's actually one near where i live and um when i used to pop in there for a
00:09:17 drink sometimes if i ever did that at lunchtime you just see all these old men sitting at tables
00:09:23 reading a newspaper probably widowers you know having two or three pints to pass the day
00:09:29 a really important form of social engagement or just getting outside of the house for those
00:09:33 kinds of people and i often think to myself what became of those old men during the lockdown you
00:09:40 know what did they do where did they go presumably they were stuck at home and had very little
00:09:45 connection with the outside world and that i find really depressing but i think um those kinds of
00:09:52 pubs wet pubs where people go to have a drink are seen as unacceptable and they have been for a long
00:09:57 time by the kind of do-gooders of the public health lobby and i think some of those public
00:10:03 health types and also government ministers seem to be using covid to pursue some fairly nanny state
00:10:12 classist policies designed simply to control the kind of joy people can pursue and i think the more
00:10:20 they do that the more people will say listen what's really going on here are you actually
00:10:24 trying to protect us from a virus or are you just trying to control certain aspects of human behavior
00:10:30 that you happen to disapprove of and i hope more people start to ask that question i think it's a
00:10:36 very i find it heartbreaking actually uh you know uh what you just described brendan when you talk
00:10:42 about class here i think this is an important point is it your perception maybe it's too broad
00:10:47 a brush stroke here but is it your perception that people middle-class people tend to be more
00:10:55 in favor of lockdown you know that that is my perception anyway uh that somehow this is as you
00:11:01 say do-gooding you know yes i think there's i think there's a really important class dynamic
00:11:10 to the lockdown situation and i think um primarily it's because there are lots of people out there
00:11:17 and you and i peter are probably in that group although we also happen to be um free thinkers
00:11:23 but there are lots of people out there who could carry on working during lockdown right they were
00:11:28 at home they could still do their jobs they could still have their zoom meetings they could get
00:11:34 their food delivered by the young guys working for deliveroo and it was a nice experiment for
00:11:40 some of those people you know three months at home many of them might have a garden
00:11:44 they have open spaces their house is probably quite large their jobs are secure either because
00:11:51 they work in the public sector and they were handsomely furloughed or because they can kind
00:11:57 of expertise or academic work or journalistic work from home there are lots of people who are
00:12:03 comfortable which meant that the lockdown was probably quite a pleasurable experience but then
00:12:08 there's another section of society who either had to keep on working you know people who work in
00:12:13 supermarkets dustbin men you know of course there was never any discussion
00:12:18 about furlough in dustbin men can you imagine the country would go to rack and
00:12:21 ruin if that happened delivery guys you know all sorts of people who are still
00:12:27 working and I've seen a few people say that you know there wasn't really a
00:12:31 lockdown at all all there was was comfortable people staying at home for a
00:12:36 few months and working-class people doing work for them still farming their
00:12:41 food delivering their food stacking the shelves in supermarkets and so on so there was a really
00:12:46 important class divide i think in relation to lockdown um and i think that the media didn't
00:12:53 reflect the breadth of opinion in this country because of course the media is dominated by
00:12:59 the kind of people i've just described people from largely middle class backgrounds fairly
00:13:04 comfortable lives you know probably went to university probably live quite comfortably and
00:13:10 they didn't reflect what was happening to the rest of the country where millions of people have been
00:13:16 set up to lose their jobs you know furlough for many people is really a an extended form of
00:13:22 of employment as soon as it ends they will be unemployed um small businesses have collapsed
00:13:28 high streets have collapsed small retailers are going to collapse and the massive businesses like
00:13:34 amazon are going to benefit from that all these incredibly important shifts are taking place that
00:13:40 are going to have a very punishing effect on working class people lower middle class people
00:13:47 small businesses those kinds of people are going to suffer enormously whereas massive corporations
00:13:53 have benefited and the middle classes have benefited as well that class divide i think
00:13:59 is incredibly important and i think those tensions are probably going to come more to the surface
00:14:04 over the next few months i i think so it's interesting as well there's people you described
00:14:09 there who work at home and middle class people glorified working from home should be careful
00:14:16 what they wish for because they could find themselves suffering the same kind of outsourcing
00:14:21 that working class people did at the very beginning of globalization
00:14:27 absolutely right and i i often think that in relation to university lecturers in particular
00:14:33 you have all these university lecturers who are saying you know we can't possibly go back to
00:14:37 university we can't have face-to-face lectures it's not safe for us we'll do it all by video
00:14:43 and i'm sure there are lots of university administrators who are stroking their chins
00:14:48 and thinking that's a good idea let's make a few videos keep them in a library and sack
00:14:53 all these lecturers and save ourselves lots and lots of money and just do video conferencing and
00:14:58 and video lecturing from now on.
00:15:01 I do think they have to be very careful
00:15:04 that they don't get what they're talking about
00:15:05 because if we really do move into the so-called new normal
00:15:11 in which everything is done via Zoom,
00:15:15 every conference is done online,
00:15:17 people are not needed in a physical space anymore,
00:15:20 apparently you don't need that physical connection,
00:15:22 we're constantly being told,
00:15:25 a lot of people will lose work as a result of that.
00:15:27 if everything shifts to being online or being pre-recorded,
00:15:31 there are lots of middle-class people
00:15:33 who may rue the day when they cheered on the lockdown
00:15:37 and cheered on these massive social and political
00:15:39 and economic shifts that have taken place in the UK
00:15:42 over the past year.
00:15:45 That I think is a little way off,
00:15:50 but I think what's gonna happen in the short term
00:15:52 very quickly is working class communities
00:15:55 going to feel the rough edge of these policies in a way that I think the government doesn't
00:16:00 understand yet. And we have to bear in mind this is a government which enjoys its healthy
00:16:07 democratic mandate primarily as a result of voters in red wall areas who turned in their
00:16:13 millions away from the Labour Party to give Boris Johnson an unprecedented mandate. If the government
00:16:19 now treats those communities like rubbish and conspires in the destruction of their high streets
00:16:25 and their small businesses and their jobs i think it could face punishment of the ballot box in the
00:16:31 future so if the government is serious about leveling up it really needs to start thinking
00:16:37 very seriously about how to recover those areas that are going to suffer so enormously as a result
00:16:43 of the lockdown experiment yes i mean you you wrote recently actually brandon about uh how boris
00:16:52 had sort of bottled it on the culture wars and i think at the time you related it to the red
00:16:57 war because uh not only say of covid and the effects of covid but the very things that those
00:17:02 people in the red war care about cultural issues that you've written about um the government
00:17:09 appear to be utterly spineless on those two i mean do you think they've lost the red wall vote
00:17:18 um i think i think they've probably still got it for the time being only because labor is so
00:17:23 dreadful i mean the you know the great renewal of the labor party under keir starmer that hasn't
00:17:29 quite happened and and in my personal view keir starmer is proving to be really tepid and boring
00:17:36 and tame technocratic um and of course you know as i've argued for years and years and years
00:17:43 working class voters are not stupid they understand politics and they know that keir starmer was the
00:17:50 author of labor's disastrous second referendum policy which would have involved overthrowing or
00:17:57 voiding the largest democratic vote in the history of this country something that millions of red
00:18:01 wall voters voted for, which is Brexit, of course, they know that Keir Starmer pushed Jeremy Corbyn,
00:18:08 who was a natural Eurosceptic, towards the second referendum policy. They don't forget those things.
00:18:14 So Labour, I don't think, is going to recover the red wall areas anytime soon. So the Tories
00:18:20 will probably benefit from that. I think they will hold on to these votes by default for the time
00:18:26 being but that could change because i do think boris is proving to be a bottler i think he is
00:18:33 bottling out of some of the big issues of our time he he was not nearly vocal enough during the black
00:18:39 lives matter uprising for example when statues were being pulled down and um old comedy shows
00:18:46 were being banned and university curricula were being supposedly decolonized and and when you had
00:18:53 massive national institutions like the natural history museum um expressing shame about charles
00:18:59 darwin charles darwin arguably the most important scientific figure in history or um you had the
00:19:06 british museum saying that it would hide things and and express shame about the people who founded
00:19:11 the museum i mean we had this extraordinary bizarre outburst of self-loathing among the
00:19:17 institutions of this country the institutions that are supposed to stand up for cultural excellence
00:19:24 and for the very good british tradition of understanding the world understanding nature
00:19:31 understanding history those institutions completely went crazy this year in a way that i
00:19:36 think was quite striking and as all of that was happening boris was not saying the kinds
00:19:42 of things he should have been saying he should have been making speeches about the importance
00:19:47 of British culture. He should have been making speeches defending British history. He should
00:19:52 have been making speeches saying, we don't tear down statues in this country because we recognize
00:19:56 that history is a complicated, complex, colorful process. He should have been making all these
00:20:02 kinds of comments, but he kind of took a back seat. He said a couple of things here and there
00:20:06 about the Winston Churchill statue in Westminster, but more broadly, he took a back seat. And I think
00:20:12 that was a real test for Boris and I think he failed it because there was an open invitation
00:20:18 to him to get involved in the culture wars, to get on the right side in the culture wars, to defend
00:20:26 the ideals of freedom, excellence and understanding history in a clear way and he didn't do it and I
00:20:33 think lots of voters will have clocked that as well and they will be asking themselves why is
00:20:38 boris not taking a stand against the kind of woke divisive identitarian politics that we don't like
00:20:46 yes because i think a lot of the of the the vote actually you could say the last general election
00:20:51 it's hard to actually uh bring data on this out because i don't think it is there but a lot of
00:20:58 it would have been on these cultural issues even if just in in the sidelines um you know you say
00:21:04 he's a bottler at the same time you you mentioned about these institutions over the summer was quite
00:21:09 extraordinary uh you say they went sort of crazy do you think though that they were using covid i
00:21:16 don't mean to be conspiratorial here but it was seen as a kind of opportunity to to use that word
00:21:22 to reset the culture that's how it does appear to me yeah i think it's in my mind it's more
00:21:32 i think it's more that the establishment has gone mad i mean i really when i think back over the
00:21:37 past year and think about all the various things they've done i do think there were flashes of
00:21:42 madness and that's the only way i can understand it the reason i'm a bit reluctant to um talk about
00:21:49 the the idea of a reset or as you say you know i definitely don't subscribe to any conspiracy
00:21:57 theories about COVID having been a plandemic or anything like that that's I'm not interested in
00:22:02 those arguments the reason I'm not I primarily don't think they're useful is because I think
00:22:07 officialdom at the moment is is too useless even to conspire in something like that they I just
00:22:14 don't think they have the gumption or the wherewithal to do anything that the conspiracy
00:22:18 theorists are talking about the way I see it is that they've kind of gone mad and I know that's
00:22:26 a very useful way to describe it but i do feel that that's what's happening it's been a long
00:22:31 time coming and you peter will know this because you've been writing about these issues for a long
00:22:35 time in relation to culture and in relation to cultural cowardice and censoriousness and
00:22:42 the reluctance to stand up for those kinds of values um that's been a long time coming it's
00:22:47 been growing in universities for example which have become factories of censorship and conformism
00:22:54 rather than citadels of uh intellectual experimentation it's been growing in art
00:22:59 galleries which have you know willingly withdrawn exhibitions if they call the fence it's been
00:23:06 growing in the theater world which of which has has also um self-censored in response to threats
00:23:13 of violence or threats of boycott you know for a long time we've seen the cultural institutions
00:23:18 and the academic institutions in this country losing their nerve caving into woke mobs and
00:23:25 refusing to do what they're supposed to do which is to defend cultural freedom freedom of expression
00:23:31 and freedom of the intellectual mind and so that's been happening for quite a long time and
00:23:36 i think what has happened in 2020 is that all of that stuff reached a crescendo because you had
00:23:44 the covid thing which meant everyone was forced to stay indoors and go slightly stir crazy then
00:23:50 the lockdown ended with the explosion of the black lives matter protests where you had this huge
00:23:57 crazy um identitarian release of energy which then i think exacerbated all those trends and
00:24:04 that's when you have these institutions coming out and saying well yes we must express regret
00:24:09 about the existence of charles darwin or we must self-flagellate endlessly for our links to slavery
00:24:16 300 years ago you had all these institutions lining up to express essentially self-loathing
00:24:23 to say we are disgusting institutions and we should be ashamed of ourselves that's what they
00:24:27 did but i think it the way i see it is that it was it was the nadir of something that had been
00:24:34 happening for a long time which is the decay of cultural confidence in this country and that's
00:24:41 something that boris and others in his government could do something about that's something they
00:24:47 could talk about something they could be honest about but they've backed off and um i think that's
00:24:53 probably one of the greatest errors they've made this year i think the lockdown was an error but
00:24:57 But in some ways, I think their unwillingness to defend the cultural liberal gains made by this country over the past 300 or 400 years in the long term, I think that could prove to be the greater error.
00:25:13 It's interesting that, you know, when Boris did finally say something about Churchill, you know, and the Churchill statue, sort of almost he'd been dragged in front of a microphone.
00:25:23 people felt very happy about it they only wanted I think reassurance and they they just wanted to
00:25:30 feel that someone was sort of fighting their corner and and yet as you say nothing since then
00:25:35 I think particularly too I think something you wrote recently Brandon about his his lack of
00:25:41 response to or support for President Macron where that was a perfect case where you had freedom of
00:25:48 expression, and you had the president in France saying what he should be saying, but nada, nothing
00:25:54 from Britain. To me, that was so disturbing. I mean, we had firstly the beheading of Samuel Pati,
00:26:05 the school teacher whose supposed crime was to show caricatures of Muhammad to his class of
00:26:12 pupils in a discussion about freedom of speech. For doing that, he was beheaded in the streets of
00:26:18 on the outskirts of Paris. Absolutely horrific crime, a crime not only against one man but
00:26:24 against the French Republic and against the idea of freedom of speech. There was so little said
00:26:31 about that by government ministers in the UK. France is our neighbouring country. It's 30 or
00:26:38 40 miles away. It's our oldest frenemy in a sense. We've had lots of conflicts with France
00:26:45 but we've had lots of connections with france too um they said almost nothing about that and and
00:26:51 strikingly teaching unions you know teaching unions said very little also or when they did
00:26:57 eventually make a statement it was incredibly um cowardly and timid and didn't mention the
00:27:04 fact that this was a radical islamist and that he killed someone for the crime of um
00:27:10 essentially showing a cartoon of muhammad to school children so that was a really disturbing
00:27:16 episode i'm not a particular fan of president macron um but he i thought he handled the patty
00:27:23 atrocity incredibly well he um defended freedom of speech every school child in france uh took
00:27:31 part in a minute's silence for patty and also had a lesson on freedom of speech in his honor
00:27:36 and i think school kids in britain should have done the same thing this is our neighboring
00:27:41 country where someone was beheaded for a speech crime and we should have spoken about that more
00:27:47 clearly the government's unwillingness to do that i think was very revealing because it does suggest
00:27:54 that it is less um capable than we might have thought of taking the right side in the culture
00:28:01 wars of standing up to identitarianism and of being willing to say things that might prove
00:28:07 controversial to guardianistas but would probably touch a nerve with most ordinary people in this
00:28:14 case what they could have said would have been you know nobody has the right not to be offended
00:28:21 everyone has the right to criticize religion mock religion and to express themselves in any way they
00:28:28 choose and no one should ever be attacked or persecuted for doing that if the government
00:28:34 had made a statement like that in response to the petty killing that would have been incredibly
00:28:39 powerful it also could have encouraged school children in britain to learn about freedom of
00:28:44 speech as they did in france but none of that happened and over the year lots of these things
00:28:51 have taken place you know terrible attacks in france also in nice there was an attack three
00:28:57 people were slaughtered for the crime of being christians and no word about that either i mean i
00:29:04 the bishops of england got more angry about the internal market bill than they did about the
00:29:10 murder of three christians in nice in our neighboring country and that tells you a lot
00:29:15 about the rot in some of our institutions in this case in the church of england they express no fury
00:29:21 over those atrocities in france um and what what this suggests i think is that this this failure
00:29:28 to offer solidarity to france when it was suffering uh terrible attacks by islamist extremists
00:29:34 that suggests that our government has lost its nerve and if it can't even stand with
00:29:39 a neighboring country when it's when its people are being attacked for expressing themselves
00:29:45 then you do wonder when it is going to stand up for any kind of values at all
00:29:49 so that was a shameful episode on the part of our government brendan what do you make of the
00:29:55 the fact that you just mentioned there samuel patty beheaded uh for basically exercising free
00:30:02 speech explaining free speech uh this was a a terrible murder that happened in a in a country
00:30:08 which is near to us but it's still in another country and yet george for of george uh george
00:30:14 Floyd sorry killed in America or you know basically reasons we know and what happened
00:30:22 after that was that there was a sort of at least in the West an eruption of action and
00:30:29 protest and all the things we've just discussed but there's not been from what I can see in
00:30:35 any Western country any similar phenomenon basically because of what happened in France
00:30:42 is extraordinary is it not i mean shouldn't we all be putting out pledges saying why we stand
00:30:48 for free speech just like we did with racism absolutely and i think the difference in the
00:30:54 response to the killing of george floyd and the killing of samuel pattie i think is incredibly
00:31:00 revealing and really also quite depressing because um you know everyone was horrified by the killing
00:31:07 of george floyd everyone who saw that video of him being the the knee on his neck and
00:31:14 it was an incredibly unforgiving horrific thing to watch and people around the world were shocked
00:31:19 by that and i think people around the world were right to ask questions but to do so to
00:31:25 the neglect of so many other issues and so many other tragedies that took place this year i think
00:31:31 that's really something that's worth interrogating and thinking about why that happened i think what
00:31:36 happened after the killing of george floyd um i think the response to it fed into a pre-existing
00:31:43 narrative and the pre-existing narrative was one which says that modern america is a pretty evil
00:31:49 country it suffers from the original sin of racism um it's not a nice place britain is not far behind
00:31:57 in the stakes of evil you know we're we've got the crimes of imperialism and slavery to contend with
00:32:03 we should take part in far more self-flagellation about all the awful things we've done.
00:32:08 In other European countries, there's also that sense of historical self-loathing.
00:32:13 Belgium, for example, Germany, and France too, this sense that we are sinful countries,
00:32:19 born in sin, we've done terrible things historically. What I view as a very regressive
00:32:25 way of understanding our countries a very backward way a very um a way of understanding
00:32:32 our countries that doesn't appreciate the complexities or the wonderful nature of the
00:32:37 things that our countries have done that narrative had existed for a while and i think what happened
00:32:43 in the aftermath of the killing of george floyd is that all those things became a massive flashpoint
00:32:50 and the killing of george floyd the protests about george floyd soon became about other
00:32:55 things entirely. So the protests about George Floyd in Oxford, for example, became about taking
00:33:01 down the statue of Cecil Rhodes. The protests about George Floyd in Australia became about the
00:33:07 way in which Aboriginal people are treated in Australia. So there was this strange thing where
00:33:13 that terrible killing in Minneapolis gave license to all sorts of strange,
00:33:19 woke identitarian demands and and really intensified them and that was a moment at which
00:33:25 i think some of our politicians could have stood up and said listen we all agree the killing of
00:33:30 george floyd was horrific we all agree the police should treat people equally regardless of their
00:33:35 skin color or where they come from but what's happening now is something different what's
00:33:39 happening now is an anti-western anti-american anti-british form of woke politics which is
00:33:47 pro-censorship which is going to devastate our universities by filling them with even more
00:33:53 nonsense and which is going to divide people further through pushing ideas like critical race
00:33:59 theory which says essentially that all black people are victims and all white people are racists
00:34:04 politicians should have stood up and said listen we criticized the killing of george floyd too but
00:34:10 we're not going to open the floodgates to these divisive identitarian agendas but they didn't do
00:34:15 that and i think the way in which um the george floyd killing became almost the defining event of
00:34:22 the year far far more than samuel pattie as you say i think that reveals that lots of different
00:34:28 agendas have been attached to the george floyd killing and it's being exploited i would say
00:34:35 by certain people on the left to push through an agenda that they had already wanted to push through
00:34:40 and i think that's pretty unforgivable as well uh you you mentioned there you know basically
00:34:47 all the strange things that happened in the woke agenda in in the wake of george floyd
00:34:53 of course trump did actually say some things and he's one of the few politicians who talked about
00:34:59 critical race theory by name um would you say that what seems to be obviously you know a new
00:35:07 president president biden would you say that that change will be seen as a vindication by the woke
00:35:15 agenda yes that's what worries me about biden's victory um you know i think it will embolden the
00:35:23 more regressive elements in western politics it will embolden the woke agenda i think joe biden
00:35:29 and kamala harris are they're woke people i mean harris has her pronouns in her twitter biography
00:35:36 now that might sound like a small thing but it's actually incredibly significant because
00:35:40 declaring your pronouns telling people you are a he or a she or a they that is really a way of
00:35:46 indicating indicating to people you are part of the correct crowd you have the correct ideology
00:35:52 you have the correct views you're woke you're a good person and i think things like that are
00:35:58 very significant i also think it's significant that joe biden played a key role in pushing the
00:36:03 the rape panic on campuses and the idea that men accused of rape on campuses should not
00:36:11 enjoy all the rights of due process. He was quite central to those kinds of arguments.
00:36:17 He also pushes the new divisive ideas of racial identity politics. So the fact that
00:36:23 those two now are essentially the two most powerful people in the world, I think is really
00:36:29 important that we've we've heard stories from the biden camp that one thing they want to do for
00:36:34 example is create a a situation where countries can be declared to be climate criminals if they
00:36:41 don't adhere to the eco agenda or if they destroy their own environments in a way that is unacceptable
00:36:47 to america or the united nations or whoever else it might be so we could see woke imperialism
00:36:54 before long we could see america throwing its weight around in relation to smaller countries
00:36:59 but doing so in the language of wokeness and environmentalism and political correctness and i
00:37:04 think that worries me enormously in relation to trump i've never been trump's biggest fan i think
00:37:11 he has lots of problems but the fact of the matter is that this year trump made a few speeches that
00:37:19 had me cheering out loud and had me wondering why other politicians in the west aren't saying
00:37:25 similar things he did an excellent speech on cancel culture at mount rushmore where he said
00:37:31 cancel culture is authoritarian it's about forcing people to bend the knee to an ideology they don't
00:37:37 like it's tyrannical and it runs counter to american values he did he made some very good
00:37:43 comments on critical race theory he did a very good speech saying we're losing sight of martin
00:37:49 luther king's vision uh where people should be judged by character rather than color and we're
00:37:54 we're heading into a world where colour has come to be everything. I agreed with all the points
00:38:00 he made and the question I was asking myself is why Boris hasn't made similar speeches, why other
00:38:06 Western leaders haven't made similar speeches. Macron made some good comments too about the
00:38:12 threat of Islamist terrorism and the importance of freedom of speech but all of that stuff is still
00:38:18 there isn't enough of it there isn't enough people in political life and in public life
00:38:25 defending the values of freedom defending the values of tolerance and defending the values
00:38:31 of equality of opportunity and instead too many of our political class are going down the rabbit
00:38:37 hole of identity politics and woke politics and biden's victory unfortunately i think will push
00:38:44 that process further and we have to wait and see if there'll be another populist backlash.
00:38:50 Brendan, on freedom of speech, you've written about this for years. In fact, you did a report
00:38:56 five years ago, I think. Was it about campuses, wasn't it? And free speech on campuses. Do you
00:39:02 think that the situation is worse now in more restricted than then? I mean, do you think it's
00:39:10 actually become more embedded yeah so um spike did a i think we did three reports in total
00:39:17 looking at the state of freedom of speech on campuses in the uk um we were inspired by a group
00:39:23 in the us called fire um the foundation for individual rights in education which does a
00:39:28 similar report in in relation to american universities and what we found is that freedom
00:39:35 of speech on british campuses is pretty much dead um it's it's in a very powerless state there are
00:39:41 numerous codes of conduct and speech codes and no platforming rules which essentially make it
00:39:48 very difficult to express certain ideas in a university but more importantly there's a real
00:39:54 culture of self-censorship i think people get a very strong sense and not necessarily a wrong
00:40:00 sense that if they say certain things they will be demonized they will be hounded they might even be
00:40:06 thrown out of their jobs people are people have a very clear understanding that there are certain
00:40:11 things you're not allowed to say anymore for example on the issue of transgenderism we've
00:40:17 seen numerous feminists being no platformed from universities because they don't think a man can
00:40:23 become a woman and they question aspects of transgenderism and doing that on a british campus
00:40:29 has become tantamount to blasphemy and most people respond to that fact by simply not
00:40:36 expressing themselves so there's a real culture of censorship coming from both university
00:40:42 administrators and also from student unions and also there's a culture of um self-censorship
00:40:48 and i experienced some of that myself when i was invited to speak at at oxford university in 2015
00:40:56 i was supposed to speak with timothy stanley in a debate about abortion but it was cancelled
00:41:02 because a group of feminists threatened to turn up because they thought it was unacceptable for
00:41:07 two men to have a discussion about abortion and they said they were going to turn up and prevent
00:41:13 the debate from going ahead and the authorities church college which is where it was due to take
00:41:19 place they agreed with the protesters and they cancelled the event and that was a good example
00:41:24 of how you often have a connection between the intolerant millennial generation or the
00:41:31 intolerant generation zed and um officialdom or the authorities who are too cowardly to stand up
00:41:39 for the values of freedom of speech and intellectual inquiry so i think on universities at the moment
00:41:45 the key problem is that the new intake of students are the kinds of young people who have unfortunately
00:41:51 been educated and socialized to believe that they should never have to experience offensive ideas
00:41:59 so they tend to be you know pretty snowflakey pretty reluctant to engage in free robust debate
00:42:06 and then on the other side you have too many university authorities who are unwilling to
00:42:10 to put the clear, frank case of the right to cause offence,
00:42:16 the right to inquire into all ideas
00:42:18 and the right to question orthodoxies.
00:42:21 And the combination of those two things, I think,
00:42:24 means that universities have become pretty censorious
00:42:27 and sometimes quite chilling places.
00:42:30 We're finishing off now, but more than anything else,
00:42:35 I think the comments that I get
00:42:37 and questions I get from people is,
00:42:39 We all see this. We all see the restrictions on free speech happening across the board to a greater or lesser extent.
00:42:48 But what do we do? What do we do about it?
00:42:52 We've been talking about politicians standing up.
00:42:55 But what do you think people can do?
00:42:59 Because it's not like we have to explain the issue or anything to anyone.
00:43:02 They understand the issue.
00:43:04 Well, that's the million dollar question.
00:43:07 And it's something I ask myself all the time.
00:43:09 what can people do about this pretty terrible situation we find ourselves in where freedom of
00:43:14 speech is so undervalued in even in the institutions that ought to be defending it um i think a lot of
00:43:21 people are asking themselves that question there have been some really positive um flash points
00:43:26 over the past few years you know some students have set up free speech um societies in order to
00:43:33 have as many debates as that as they want um of course we have the free speech union set up by um
00:43:38 toby young which i think is doing great work and we have our own form of media too you know
00:43:45 your podcast other podcasts where people are creating new spaces where there are no restrictions
00:43:51 on what can be said and where people are free to question the new orthodoxies as as frankly and
00:43:58 as they want so there are positive things happening but i do think that question of
00:44:02 what more can we do is something we have to ask ourselves and i think uh the key thing is is to be
00:44:08 a bit brave and and to always refuse to self-censor because i think lots of people would feel inspired
00:44:15 by that i mean i think one person who's done that very well is um jk rowling now she's not someone
00:44:21 i agree with on most political issues particularly brexit she's very anti-brexit i'm very pro-brexit
00:44:28 but her on her her willingness to carry on criticizing the excesses of transgenderism
00:44:35 even in the face of death threats and rape threats and misogynistic abuse and so on.
00:44:41 That, I think, is quite inspiring. Now, of course, she's too big to be cancelled,
00:44:46 she's too famous, she's too rich, she's a global phenomenon, so it's not easy to drag her down,
00:44:52 whereas it is easier to drag other people down. However, I think the more we have people like
00:44:58 that who are willing to put their necks on the line, the more it will send a signal to others
00:45:03 that they should try the same thing so i think that's really the only approach and i think we
00:45:07 have to put more pressure on government ministers and politicians to take a similar approach
00:45:15 because unless politicians start to put their necks on the line and to stand up for the right
00:45:20 of people to express themselves then i think lots of other people um probably won't feel the
00:45:26 confidence to do that in their own lives so put pressure on politicians to defend freedom of
00:45:31 speech put pressure on boris to stop bottling out of these key issues and in our own lives and our
00:45:38 own public lives we should say what we want to say and say it clearly and frankly and then deal with
00:45:45 the consequences the more of us that do that the more i think we will start to resuscitate freedom
00:45:50 of speech well thank you for that very much brandon thank you uh a great way to end um i do hope that
00:45:59 you have a lovely christmas and uh and that you hug a lot of people and you meet up and you don't
00:46:06 all wear masks and everything um and look uh maybe see you in the new year brandon and uh
00:46:12 thank you for that hopeful and constructive uh point at the end there it's very very important
00:46:16 thanks uh that's it for this week uh so what you're saying is uh we shall see you next time thank you
00:46:29 You