New Culture Forum - December 18, 2020


What Is The Great Reset? Explaining The World Economic Forum's Controversial Initiative

Peter Hitchens: The Left's Long March Through UK Institutions Is Complete Brendan O'Neill - Covid, Class & The Decay Of Cultural Confidence In The West

Episode Stats


Length

35 minutes

Words per minute

144.82

Word count

5,152

Sentence count

—


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 hello and welcome to counterculture I'm Peter Whittle now as we draw to the end of 2020 we've
00:00:20 had a hell of a lot of new rather grim buzzwords this year we've had the new normal we've had
00:00:28 to build back better, whatever that means. But the one that our viewers seem to be most
00:00:33 interested in and want to hear about most is the Great Reset. This is something which
00:00:37 actually has already been announced by the World Economic Forum, but actually how planned
00:00:43 is it? What actually is it? What does it entail? Who's behind it? And how seriously should
00:00:49 we take it? I'm very pleased that today we've got two people very well qualified to talk
00:00:56 about it, first of all, James Delingpole, who has been a great guest on this channel in the past.
00:01:03 James, of course, is a well-known columnist and broadcaster and host of one of the best
00:01:09 podcasts out there, that's the Delingpod. And joining us from Poland, we have Ben Sixsmith,
00:01:15 who writes for Quillette, for Spectator USA, and for The Critic. Welcome, gentlemen. Thanks
00:01:22 very much for joining us um first of all uh james uh the great reset this is something which is sort
00:01:29 of quite open and out there this was something a term used by the world economic forum well quite
00:01:35 some months ago um can you actually just explain what it what it actually means not the people
00:01:43 behind it so far we'll talk about that but actually what is the idea of the great reset
00:01:48 um well to cut to the chase it is it is technocracy and technocracy is a totalitarian
00:02:00 political philosophy uh in the way that fascism is and and communism is and marxism is and and
00:02:08 nazism is the the usp of technocracy is that instead of evil dictators or or um or central
00:02:20 committees the decisions over your life are made by experts let's call them technocrats
00:02:28 a sort of unelected elite who will decide every aspect of your life in a way not unakin to
00:02:37 the chinese social credit system you won't have you won't have any property it will be allocated
00:02:46 to you by this benign elite depending on how well you behave yourself um the amount of energy you
00:02:54 use will be rationed according again according to their their dictates one of the one of the
00:03:00 fundamental one of the pillars of tech is the idea that we need to move away from a money-based
00:03:10 economy to an energy-based economy and this is why it is so intimately bound with the green movement
00:03:20 that that i i suppose the reason that i find this easier to grasp than a lot of people
00:03:28 is because i've been studying this kind of a thing this kind of thing for a long long time
00:03:33 and i realize now that um the last decade or so with environmentalism is just another facet
00:03:47 of this um the the technocratic master plan um this year the green issues have mutated into
00:03:57 COVID-19, which of course is a completely engineered scare, which has got nothing to do
00:04:05 with epidemiological reality. They've managed to turn a kind of routine into something so
00:04:15 important that we should destroy our economy, shut down small businesses, enforce arguably
00:04:24 compulsory vaccines this is this all aligns with the with the great reset plan and it's happening
00:04:31 at an accelerated rate now under cover of the the oppressive measures that have been introduced by
00:04:38 governments supposedly to deal with this terrible viral pandemic uh ben uh it's fairly right to say
00:04:48 isn't it that sort of the march to the technocracy is is one of the features of our time is it not
00:04:55 so it's definitely a feature of our time as uh technology and the ability to systematize
00:05:03 the kind of data of our lives and our behavior becomes more advanced corporations and governments
00:05:09 are making uh more use of it uh to make money or to control us in particular ways that they find
00:05:17 uh beneficial either to them or to us i see uh james who who were the guiding lights behind the
00:05:26 great reset um well i suppose klaus schwab is one obvious candidate for sort of um the evil mastermind
00:05:41 the kind of he even looks a bit like blofeld all he needs is a persian a white persian cat to
00:05:46 complete the picture um he's got this sort of sinister well i mean i suppose all german
00:05:51 accents strong german accents sound sinister to uh to english ears but he does have one of those
00:05:57 and he founded the world economic forum in in 1971 and he's been believing this stuff all
00:06:03 along so it's not this is he's had plenty of time to gestate his his evil master plan
00:06:10 he he probably got the idea um or at least yeah he got the idea from somebody called
00:06:17 david rockefeller and david rockefeller was was one of the heirs to the obviously the
00:06:23 the rockefeller standard oil fortune um and in i think again in 1971 um rock of david rockefeller
00:06:34 with Zbigniew Brzezinski founded the Trilateral Commission which is the organization whence a lot
00:06:44 of this great reset stuff um emanates um the Trilateral Commission has some very high-powered
00:06:52 figures in it I mean the entire Jimmy Carter cabinet were were members of the Trilateral
00:06:58 commission so was um george hw bush and and george w bush so it's these people have been at a high
00:07:08 level of influence for for decades and they've been able to infiltrate uh all manner of um
00:07:17 influential positions notably when it comes to treating make treaty making so that a lot of the
00:07:24 a lot of the kind of international treaties which we now we think of as as you know part of our our
00:07:30 world were actually like trojan horses for the great reset or whatever you want to call it i
00:07:37 mean it has different it has different names the fourth industrial revolution is another one
00:07:42 build back better is one of its slogans uh the new normal is a kind of colloquial way of putting it
00:07:49 we've we're being asked to to put aside our to forget about the old world that we enjoyed before
00:07:55 covid19 we've now got to get used to this world where where we have health passports where we have
00:08:02 masks all the time where we have to accept that it's perfectly acceptable for the economy to get
00:08:09 closed down on the basis of a of a of a bad flu which we've never done before uh it's the great
00:08:16 reset is happening now call it what you will it is actually happening is that would you
00:08:24 go along with that man or not i mean uh i would definitely go along with elements of it uh
00:08:32 i suppose where i might draw something of a distinction is between uh there's a fine line
00:08:39 between conspiracy and kind of elite consensus so i don't necessarily think there's been
00:08:45 uh very coherent uh plan all along but there are definitely networks by which uh influential people
00:08:56 can meet discuss organize and out of that develops uh these kind of uh technocratic or corporatist
00:09:07 ideas so for example i'm not sure that uh everyone wearing masks and not being able to
00:09:13 go inside a bar was part of any grand plan. But definitely since COVID-19, events have been
00:09:21 exploited to push particular agendas, as James says, technocratic agendas, corporatist agendas.
00:09:31 So that's definitely true. It just depends on how much foresight you think has gone into it.
00:09:39 is that the basic difference then for you james do you actually think you know you think actually
00:09:44 that no i think it's a distinction without a difference it doesn't really matter whether you
00:09:49 call it a conspiracy or a or a elite consensus it's entirely irrelevant to this to this discussion
00:09:57 it's about what is actually happening who sat around the table when or how much agency was
00:10:04 involved the fact is that it's happening now one of the questions that people are asking this
00:10:09 year is why are they doing it doing this because they're looking at looking at the extraordinary
00:10:15 coordination of government policy around the world the the way for example that that with
00:10:23 with a few brave exceptions like sweden belarus bizarrely um brazil countries around the world
00:10:31 governments around the world are acting in lockstep they are imposing lockdowns even though
00:10:38 there's no evidence that lockdowns make any difference in fact they probably make things
00:10:41 worse to the for for covert 19 they they prolong it it's they prolong the period before it becomes
00:10:49 endemic and before we built up herd immunity uh they do crazy things like impose masks at the
00:10:56 very point where the where the the virus has has passed its past its peak and begun its its slow
00:11:04 slope downwards and the the sort of the rational response to this would be to say well they know
00:11:13 what they're doing they are they are following the science but it's clear to anyone who looks
00:11:18 into it with any any care that they are not following the science there is another agenda
00:11:24 there is an agenda well beyond the the medical one and and again you have to look at the the
00:11:32 economic consequences why why are they destroying the hospitality industry why are they destroying
00:11:38 small businesses the answer is unfortunately we don't like we don't like to think of these things
00:11:44 because it sounds so dystopian and terrifying but this is all part of the plan this at a high level
00:11:51 um supranational bodies are are coordinating to destroy the the the economy as we know it
00:12:01 and replace it with this great reset and i fear that we've reached the point where we cannot rely
00:12:10 on sovereign governments to protect us from this uh it's it's up to us the people to to what's going
00:12:18 on and respond quickly before it's too late before we have no more freedoms i mean my only hope in
00:12:25 in the very very short term is that that trump manages to overturn this election steal by biden
00:12:33 whose slogan by the way is build back better why is that why is why is why is why is biden's
00:12:40 campaign slogan the same as that of the great reset why is it that one of biden's first
00:12:48 announcements as so-called president-elect not that that post has ever existed and i think it
00:12:53 exists largely in his imagination and the imagination of the mainstream media but why is
00:12:59 it that one of the first things he said was that americans need to wear masks for the next next
00:13:04 month it's because masks are a symbol of of the government's ability to control a cowed and
00:13:11 compliant populace when we wear masks we whether we think we're doing it for medical reasons or
00:13:18 not what we're actually doing is endorsing the great reset we're enabling it and i fear that
00:13:26 this is not the time to make frankly frivolous distinctions about whether it's a conspiracy
00:13:32 or a or an elite consensus because once you start throwing in words like conspiracy what you then
00:13:40 do is open the opportunity for people to say yeah it's not really happening because we know that
00:13:45 conspiracies don't happen well i'm sorry it is happening it's real it's happening now
00:13:52 when you you talk there james about you know hospitality etc and i can totally understand
00:13:59 this point ben maybe if you can address it that if you look at like britain at the moment
00:14:03 um you know pubs are facing virtual wipeouts because of the rules and it does seem to appear
00:14:11 to many of us that actually which well why why you know if you can have people going shopping
00:14:18 in high streets why therefore would you sort of example highlight pubs is it because
00:14:23 you basically don't like pubs is what what is actually going on here i i think there's
00:14:29 definitely a huge problem when you have these these kind of large communities such as the world
00:14:35 economic forum which are populated by the leaders of governments and the
00:14:41 executives of the biggest multinational they start thinking very much in terms
00:14:47 of the interests of those governments and those multinational and then the
00:14:52 smaller businessmen the owners of pubs of hotels of smaller shops get kind of
00:14:58 shunted to the side and we have definitely seen through this pandemic
00:15:02 more and more capital has gone upwards towards large corporations like Amazon.
00:15:12 And definitely we can see through organisations like the World Economic Forum,
00:15:20 this is a way for them to put their interests first ahead of the smaller businessmen and the
00:15:27 smaller communities. Well, you see, I want to sort of pursue this point, you know, the difference
00:15:33 between, as you say, a conspiracy and what you call elite consensus. If I can take the cultural
00:15:40 example, during COVID, we've had the most extraordinary cultural onslaught, you know,
00:15:46 from all of our museums, we've had the toppling of statues, we've had this sort of, quite openly,
00:15:52 People, in fact, they use the word reset. You know, we've got to reset the way we look at our, I don't know, for example, our repertory, whether it's a theatre or in concert halls.
00:16:03 Now, the thing is, is that it seems undeniable that this is actually being used as a way of basically forwarding certain agendas to make sure that when we come out of it, things will not be the same.
00:16:18 there seems to be some truth to that one thing that I think this kind of great reset rhetoric
00:16:25 does serve to do is it's a way for corporations and governments to kind of plaster a social
00:16:33 conscience on themselves so there's this very popular phrase now woke capital where you can
00:16:39 find kind of the richest people on earth you can get Jeff Bezos posing as if he's some kind of
00:16:45 activist. Because he says that black lives matter, even when
00:16:50 his workers are urinating into water bottles, because they
00:16:54 don't have time to go to the toilet. So this kind of cultural
00:16:59 progressivism, I think it's very much pushed as a way for
00:17:05 corporations to give themselves a big smiley, friendly face in
00:17:10 public and appeal to the kind of uh educated and high status uh cultural people who might otherwise
00:17:20 look down on their business practices uh i know this is a very basic point but is this left or
00:17:27 right can you even put it in those terms james no no it's not it's it's not left or right it's it's
00:17:36 it's something else i mean one of the points i agree with with ben on is it's not it's not
00:17:43 communism it's not fascism it's just like them in in in the sense that they are all collectivist
00:17:50 ideas it's all ultimately the battle between those who want to control other people's lives
00:17:57 and those of us who want to be to be left to live our lives as as we choose and this is this is the
00:18:04 age-old divide was always you know it it's it's um it's what it's what the battle of salamis was
00:18:12 was fought for for example the birth of western civilization so we've been we've been fighting
00:18:18 this battle anew uh every every century and almost every every decade um this is our in a way this
00:18:28 is our world war three this is the we imagined those of us who grew up in the shadow of the
00:18:33 second world war that when world war three came if it came it would probably be a shooting war
00:18:39 and we'd all be fighting we'd all we'd all be in um i don't know harrier jump jets or tornadoes
00:18:45 whatever the latest plane was fighting the russian fox bats or the or the chinese whatever but
00:18:51 actually this is a different kind of of of warfare it's it's it's war without shots being fired but
00:18:59 in a way it's all the more dangerous because it's more insidious you can't always see who the who
00:19:05 the enemy is and it the enemy in our own country for example is people that we never ever would
00:19:14 have imagined would have been the threat you know cuddly amiable buoyant positive boris johnson he
00:19:23 it turns out is very much part of the problem michael gove clever clever principled or formally
00:19:30 principled a a guy who you thought would somehow get um issues like the importance of of liberty
00:19:40 has now completely sold out to this this and by the way the guy who also said we've had enough
00:19:47 of experts suddenly he sold all our souls to these very experts who not so long ago he professed to
00:19:55 distrust um these are very very dangerous times and i think that there is a definite information
00:20:03 deficit i don't think that um you know i i i look at people on loosely our side of the argument
00:20:13 people like douglas murray say douglas is fighting a very very good war uh with regards to woke
00:20:21 culture the the culture wars and stuff but i don't think he's really engaged with the great
00:20:26 reset or look at toby young again fighting a very good war on the free speech front and also on the
00:20:33 coronavirus front but not really getting why it matters so much that president trump um gets back
00:20:40 in because he is probably the only bulwark in the world right now uh against the the great reset i
00:20:46 mean all the other governments you know look at look at look at um trudeau's canada look at our
00:20:51 own government look at angela merkel um i can't believe somebody chose to skype me randomly in
00:20:58 middle of that that's so annoying um uh all the other other leaders have bought into this and um
00:21:07 it's the point i was going to make is that it's a bit like isaiah berlin's hedgehog and the fox
00:21:18 that the fox knows lots of little things the hedgehog knows one big thing most people are
00:21:24 foxes they're fighting their individual in individual theaters of of this great war but
00:21:31 very few people have grasped the massive big overarching picture that green issues
00:21:39 covert 19 trump china the great reset united nations agenda 2030 are all part of the same
00:21:51 massive problem and until you understand that until you go really deep down the rabbit hole
00:21:57 you really do not understand what is going on in the world right now and in a way you should
00:22:02 you should inform yourself or shut up because this is serious right uh what would you say to
00:22:09 that ben i mean you've you've you have written have you not that this is uh you know that uh
00:22:14 this is as you put it just sort of something which is is it what just sort of happened almost
00:22:19 organically that there isn't anything behind it is that correct to say um i don't think i'd
00:22:25 necessarily say uh there's nothing behind it i mean for example the great reset uh klaus schwab's
00:22:33 idea of stakeholder capitalism that's his uh big idea he thinks businesses should be uh reoriented
00:22:41 in a manner where they're not just uh creating profit for their shareholders uh but they're
00:22:47 acting in the interests of everybody it affects i mean this is an idea he's been pushing for decades
00:22:53 uh and covet 19 has just given him another chance to uh throw it into the political arena a little
00:23:01 bit like how uh 9 11 gave uh hawkish people the chance to push for a war in iraq they'd already
00:23:11 wanted to fight uh so i wouldn't say there's nothing behind it at all it's more that i think
00:23:17 uh there's less uh organization there's less deliberation there's uh different actors coming
00:23:25 together uh but definitely even if there isn't that level of organization uh that others might
00:23:35 see it's still a concern when elite people are coming together in forums where uh we
00:23:43 the common people don't really have any opportunity to contribute so i wouldn't
00:23:48 say there's nothing behind it i just think um it has less coherence maybe than james is suggesting
00:23:57 uh would you say that this is something i'll ask you both that you you're talking about the kind
00:24:06 of the great reason but is this something that is just applies to the west for example i mean
00:24:12 you know you're in you're in uh uh poland then but i frankly when it comes to covid the way that
00:24:20 it's been uh handled it's remarkable how many parts of the world we don't actually know very
00:24:25 much about? I mean, I don't know. Does this idea have purchased, for example, in Russia? Does it
00:24:31 have purchased in Asia? I think it's very intimately connected with the development of
00:24:37 technology. And as the means to analyze people's lives and break people's patterns of behavior down
00:24:47 into data uh get more sophisticated uh it's to be predicted uh sadly that corporations and
00:24:55 governments will exploit it so i think we need to ask questions uh not just about uh the misdeeds
00:25:02 of governments and the misdeeds of corporations uh but just how uh we want to manage technological
00:25:10 progress. Because as leaders gain the abilities to do things on a greater level, they're naturally
00:25:20 going to use it unless we protest before they have the opportunity to do so. So I think as well
00:25:26 as just talking about ideas, we need to talk about technology and how we want to, I guess,
00:25:34 channel technological progress in the future because otherwise you do end up with uh chinese
00:25:40 social credit systems and uh i don't know super computers taking over the world do you want to
00:25:48 come in there james yeah yeah i i don't know whether you any of you have read alan bakari's
00:25:56 book on how big tech tried to steal this presidential election big tech decided
00:26:04 the moment that trump was first elected for his first term as president in in 2016 um big tech
00:26:10 decided that he was never going to win again and they would it would marshal its forces and a good
00:26:16 chunk of its of its um you know uh workers and it's and it's it's money to to to create in the
00:26:25 situation where you know using its algorithms for example to ensure that slanted news stories
00:26:31 against trump who got in front of people's attention especially swing voters and so on
00:26:36 i think that definitely one of the the most urgent needs right now is that big tech gets
00:26:46 reined in and you're already seeing this to a degree with for example i think the trump
00:26:51 administration has just tried to said that facebook needs to divest itself of um instagram
00:26:59 and one of its other holdings um i'm quite excited about this new project by tim berners lee tim tim
00:27:12 berners lee is is setting up this this startup which i think is designed to stop when you when
00:27:20 you when you when you use the internet or whatever it's designed to stop you having to give up so
00:27:26 much of your valuable information to the big tech companies i mean you think you think about the
00:27:30 implications of that that that twitter and facebook and i suppose google uh have this massive
00:27:39 china style social credit system uh enabling database on us they know almost everything about
00:27:46 us they know all our dark secrets this has given them the most extraordinary and dangerous power
00:27:53 and also it's given them a massive revenue stream but you think about it i mean no industry or no
00:27:59 company lasts lasts forever you know all the think of all the companies that were around
00:28:03 in the early days of the motor car very few of them made it and and uh you look at the companies
00:28:08 now i mean uh look at look at the companies that were powerful at the beginning of the 20th century
00:28:14 most of them most of them count for nothing now in the same way i think we there has to be we have
00:28:20 have to look forward to a future in which facebook google um twitter and so on uh maybe even tesla
00:28:28 do not have this extraordinary outrageous power they do at the moment and i think one way of doing
00:28:35 that is to sweep away their revenue stream by denying them our information which is what they're
00:28:42 feeding on like vampires uh yes uh ben would you say i mean carrying on from james point there that
00:28:50 it's been quite interesting and extraordinary over this past i don't know decade maybe the
00:28:56 willingness with which people actually do give up information you know to me it seems extraordinary
00:29:03 that the idea of privacy uh for example is something that he says doesn't seem to worry
00:29:09 many people yeah it's true i think we're just not conscious of doing it i mean there's this
00:29:15 term the digital footprint uh but the difference between a real footprint and a digital footprint
00:29:20 is like i can't see the uh the former uh and so when we're googling away when we're watching
00:29:28 youtube videos when we're posting our tweets and we're posting our photos we just don't have this
00:29:33 sense that somewhere all of our information is being logged and could well be used uh so it's
00:29:40 something we need to become more conscious of and it's something uh where we need to change our
00:29:46 behavior uh or other people are going to be thinking of ways to change our behavior for us
00:29:52 i would like to ask just uh before we're ending um just carrying on really from that here we're
00:29:57 talking about how people have given up their information uh although there might be uh signs
00:30:03 for rebellion there actually about some people but are you surprised or disappointed or happy or what
00:30:11 by the way in which people in britain have reacted to this situation james can i ask you first i mean
00:30:18 the general reaction to covid well somebody yeah somebody on twitter um this morning quoted the
00:30:29 the lawyer in germany in 1933 who'd looked on aghast as the german people basically surrendered
00:30:41 all their freedoms gave everything away to this horrible new new party the national the national
00:30:47 socialists and in a way i see the british people similarly sleepwalking to disaster
00:30:57 we we have this national myth don't we about the about the blitz spirit and we have this we have
00:31:02 our archers flicking up flicking their two fingers at the french to show that you know that they
00:31:07 they still got their bow pulling fingers string pulling fingers and uh we we have this we have
00:31:14 have this idea of ourselves as as being suspicious of big ideas but ultimately unwilling to sacrifice
00:31:21 our freedoms um we we haven't gone in for those oppressive regimes like the french have gone in
00:31:29 for or like the like the russians we're different we think but actually i think 2020 has tested that
00:31:37 national myth to destruction that we have become cowed compliant we've been very susceptible to
00:31:46 the government's propaganda and we've put ourselves in a position where it's it's become
00:31:53 very very hard for those very few of us who are fighting for the old normal fighting for our
00:31:59 our freedoms to to get our case across and to persuade people just how urgent this how desperate
00:32:09 this situation is i you know it's touch and go i think whether whether we are going to get our old
00:32:16 normal back i'm one has to be optimistic you know uh pessimism the pessimism of the intellect
00:32:23 optimism of the will one has to maintain that um i think rather than going down the peter hitchens
00:32:31 route where you know it's all it's all going to be crap until we go to heaven when when we enjoy
00:32:37 god's god's blessing i i i couldn't i couldn't be that black-pilled but i do think that these
00:32:43 are the darkest times anyone anyone living has experienced actually i'd say it's even worse than
00:32:49 even those of the second world war you know my father um says this you know that this is what
00:32:56 this is much worse than the war this is this is just like really really dangerous and we need to
00:33:03 wake up to it yes uh on that on that point uh ben uh it does seem at least just i have no data for
00:33:12 this is purely anecdotal that younger people seem remarkably uh compliant there's a there's a there's
00:33:19 a kind of um class differential too is i would say that on the whole middle class kids are the
00:33:26 ones who are masked up you tend to see them walking down the street in their masks for example
00:33:31 you know um in a way it's not ever been actually even suggested they have to do that
00:33:36 Do you think that's fair or not? I mean, do you think younger people seem to be you think they'd have a bit more rebellion in them, maybe?
00:33:46 I mean, I'm slightly less exercised by mask mandates than James.
00:33:54 But if we had a if we had an argument about COVID-19, we'd be here for 10 hours and it would all be a bit pro wrestling.
00:34:01 But definitely, I think there's a kind of sense among young people that being good, being self-righteous is a kind of status symbol.
00:34:13 So that's why we've definitely seen people who they take a kind of perverse pride in scolding people who aren't quite as sensitive as they are to the possibility of infection.
00:34:27 people ratting out their neighbors, people shaming people on social media, because there's
00:34:34 such so much kind of cultural capital in virtue signaling and showing what a good person you
00:34:39 are. And definitely, that seems to be true across all ages, but especially for young
00:34:46 people, because it's a way of elevating yourself above other people showing how what a good
00:34:55 person you are i think that definitely seems to be an impulse actually behind an awful lot of the
00:35:00 activity going on at the moment um uh james thank you very much for joining us thank you very much
00:35:05 and and to you too ben thank you very much for joining us um and uh we will to be continued i'm
00:35:12 sure at a later date thank you very much thanks um that's it for that's it for counterculture
00:35:19 this week so we shall see you next time thank you very much bye