New Culture Forum - December 13, 2020


Peter Hitchens: The Left's Long March Through UK Institutions Is Complete

News From The Front Line In The UK Culture Wars -- Save Our Statues Campaign Update What Is The Great Reset? Explaining The World Economic Forum's Controversial Initiative

Episode Stats


Length

41 minutes

Words per minute

174.03

Word count

7,287

Sentence count

237


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to So What You're Saying Is, I'm Peter Whittle. Now last week I made an appeal to
00:00:27 about subscriptions and i have to say you really rose to to the occasion because we had 3 000 new
00:00:34 subscriptions thank you very very much for that it's very easy to do and it's entirely free you
00:00:39 just go on and you press the subscription button and then next door there's one saying notifications
00:00:44 that means that you get all the programs as they come up so you won't miss anything so please do
00:00:50 subscribe and get us to 100 000 uh by christmas um now i'm delighted that my guest today is the
00:00:58 author and journalist peter hitchens peter has been on the show a couple of times before and
00:01:04 got some of our biggest audiences so i'm thrilled that he's back uh this time of year particularly
00:01:09 you're very much in demand actually peter not that you always aren't but that you've been quite on
00:01:14 on the media quite a lot haven't I? Not as much as I would have expected given
00:01:20 that at the beginning of the current crisis I was one of the very few voices in British
00:01:27 media who was against what was going on. So far from that giving me a sort of monopoly
00:01:32 position as someone who was in great demand, it didn't, particularly the BBC which to begin
00:01:38 with barely noticed my existence and has since then given me one or two sort of concessionary
00:01:43 spots but actually i think i've been on the bbc less during these past nine months than probably
00:01:49 any other time since i started being honest at all i think one of the things about crisis has
00:01:56 been the bbc's deep unwillingness to even acknowledge that there's an argument and therefore
00:02:01 people like me are not welcome do you think when you look at the bbc and for that amount of sky and
00:02:06 the others they all seem to be singing pretty much from the same hymn sheet the only the only striking
00:02:12 exception has been talk radio where I've been a welcome guest every week on Mike
00:02:17 Graham's show which has been terrific a lot of people have have listened to that
00:02:21 and have taken some sort of comfort from it but in general there has the seems
00:02:26 to have been pretty much everywhere a an acceptance that what the government is
00:02:33 doing is right that is making a correct and proportionate response to what is
00:02:36 going on I think that's that's really absurd in a country which supposedly
00:02:42 prides itself on having a diverse and competitive media that everybody is so
00:02:46 diverse and so competitive that they all do the same thing the polls seem to
00:02:51 suggest that too don't they about the public well I think fear which is what
00:02:59 this is fundamentally about is an enormously powerful propaganda tool and
00:03:03 Once you frighten people into thinking that they're in a genuine danger
00:03:06 by taking certain precautions and behaving in certain ways,
00:03:09 they can reduce that fear.
00:03:10 They will probably do that.
00:03:12 And I think whether there's cynicism involved or not, I don't know.
00:03:18 But the fact is that undoubtedly a sage advised the government.
00:03:23 I have a pinned tweet on my Twitter account quoting the document
00:03:26 that if they wanted more compliance, they would have to frighten people more.
00:03:31 I put it in very basic, clear English, but that's what the advice from SAGE said,
00:03:36 and they've followed it, it seems to me.
00:03:38 Yes, I started out really by thinking, well, these polls are very suspect,
00:03:44 but then what you notice is people walking down the street wearing masks in the street
00:03:50 when actually that's never even been suggested so far as I know.
00:03:54 No, no, it's extraordinary people go far beyond what might be expected.
00:03:57 and there is a if they've come across somebody not wearing one of these garments then quite often
00:04:05 there's a scene rather like the remake of Invasion of the Body Snatchers where they look at you as if
00:04:11 you were some kind of alien monster and I can often feel people tempted to give me a stern
00:04:18 talking to and then I hope they're untempted by the prospect of getting a pretty stern talking
00:04:23 you back so they don't but i i think that uh the it there is a really cultish and highly superstitious
00:04:31 aspect of this i am myself superstitious i admit there's no point denying it i don't walk under
00:04:37 ladders i don't ride my bicycle on friday the 13th it's silly i know it's silly but i do it
00:04:43 it's motivated by the fact that the world is an uncertain place and i think well why tempt it
00:04:48 But I wouldn't even begin to try a rational justification for it or try to persuade anybody else to do it.
00:04:55 But almost all of the things which we're being asked to do are basically superstitious.
00:04:59 There isn't any sound experimental work which actually suggests that any of it is either proportionate or any use.
00:05:07 But people are plunging into it as if they had all joined an almost Jonestown cult and were completely enraptured by it.
00:05:19 But do you think people in this country, for example, would once not have done that?
00:05:25 I like to think not, but I'm not sure. I think fear is a very powerful motivator.
00:05:32 What we've never had before is a generation brought up almost entirely in a highly conformist electronic culture.
00:05:40 Electronic media make people conformist.
00:05:42 They make them laugh at the same jokes, read the same books to the extent that they do have the same tastes,
00:05:47 because it very quickly imposes on people an idea of how they ought to behave.
00:05:51 People want to fit in, and none of us is innocent in that.
00:05:56 And so, first of all, television did this, and then color television redoubled it.
00:06:00 And then when the Internet came along, there was an even more powerful conformist force.
00:06:06 So I think possibly more so, but I wouldn't like to say that the great roast beef fed Britons of another generation
00:06:12 would have been any less responsive to similar beliefs if they had the levels of propaganda directed at them that we have.
00:06:21 And there is incessant propaganda.
00:06:23 I'm very aware of it because I resisted the announcements at railway stations,
00:06:27 the constant posters the uh the advertisements in the newspapers all pushing the same thing over
00:06:32 and over again has there ever in peacetime been so much money and effort expended on
00:06:37 propaganda by any government in a free country when you first started talking about this i suppose
00:06:46 it would be in march uh you were very much your position i don't mean to uh get it wrong was it
00:06:55 it just simply that lockdowns had there was no proof that lockdowns worked well my first my first
00:07:01 position which has never altered had been that whatever the the problem was the government's
00:07:07 reaction was disproportionate to it that no evidence had really been put forward which
00:07:12 justified the severity of the the self-harm which the government was doing to the country
00:07:18 and it is this enormous self-harm and evidently so in many many ways now there are circumstances
00:07:24 is when you do have to harm yourself for the general good.
00:07:27 I didn't think there had been,
00:07:28 and since then I haven't thought there has been enough evidence to do that.
00:07:34 And I examined several things.
00:07:36 One of the things I examined was the record of Imperial College as a predictor,
00:07:40 which is not good.
00:07:42 Everybody's discovered this now,
00:07:43 but to write it back in March was quite heretical.
00:07:46 The other thing was simply to look at what the figures actually meant
00:07:49 and the work of people like Professor John Yonides,
00:07:52 who was casting doubt on the levels of fatality being claimed for the disease.
00:07:59 And also the extraordinary, almost prophetic warnings issued by Professor Sutrid Bakhti
00:08:06 of the University of Mainz, who's well worth looking at now.
00:08:09 Because one of the things he foresaw, for instance, was the huge, terrible impact on the healthy old
00:08:14 who would face a life of isolation, but also the general impact.
00:08:19 And I thought these people were speaking certainly enough sense to be given a hearing.
00:08:25 And what I noticed was that they were not being given a hearing.
00:08:28 And I was relying on them, people who knew much more about me,
00:08:32 both about viruses and about immunology and about statistics.
00:08:37 And they seemed to think there was something wrong.
00:08:38 And I thought this was a case worth making.
00:08:40 And then when I came up against quite considerable sort of general disapproval of what I was doing,
00:08:46 of an angry nature, I've had a rule for a long time.
00:08:49 if my opponent is angry with me
00:08:51 then he's angry because he suspects
00:08:53 I may be right
00:08:54 it's almost invariable
00:08:56 I remember being like that myself
00:08:58 because I must have a certificate somewhere
00:09:01 I'm one of the few people who has actually changed his mind
00:09:03 and in the process of doing so
00:09:05 I found that
00:09:07 I was often very angry
00:09:08 with people who were expressing my inmost doubts
00:09:11 and if you've got a good case why get angry
00:09:13 what would be the point
00:09:14 when I started facing anger
00:09:17 I thought there's something going on here
00:09:19 that I need to persist with.
00:09:21 Do you think, we're now in the middle of December
00:09:25 and this is going out,
00:09:27 would you have thought we would be in this position
00:09:30 in December back in March?
00:09:33 No, I had no idea it was going to go on this long
00:09:35 or be so profound or so serious.
00:09:37 My imagination simply didn't encompass
00:09:39 the depths to which we've sunk
00:09:43 and the level of damage that we've done to ourselves.
00:09:45 It simply didn't cross my mind that it would ever be so bad.
00:09:47 But do you think that what has happened is pure incompetence, because there are a lot
00:09:56 of things around now, you hear a lot about the idea of a great reset, for example, that
00:10:01 this is being used. Do you think this is entirely, because people make the point often that this
00:10:09 is an international thing, so basically it's not just that this country has gone crazy
00:10:13 crazy or whatever but do you put it down just to complete incompetence or just the rottenness
00:10:19 of the British state? Well a lot of my experience in reporting over the years particularly of the
00:10:25 British political system and the British political class has led me to believe that incompetence and
00:10:30 stupidity are neglected explanations for what goes on. I don't think the people in government
00:10:38 who are responsible for taking the major decisions back in March are particularly competent or
00:10:42 particularly wise or experienced.
00:10:45 And I think that people, once they've made a serious mistake,
00:10:47 are very loath to admit it, and so they continue.
00:10:50 You've probably been in a car with somebody
00:10:52 who's too proud to admit he's taken a wrong turning,
00:10:55 and will drive for miles in the wrong direction
00:10:57 rather than admit that he's made a mistake.
00:10:59 That's the kind of position we're in,
00:11:01 where we have a proud, arrogant, and vain driver
00:11:06 who will not admit that he took a wrong turning in March,
00:11:09 and so drives us on, on the hope that somehow
00:11:11 He'll get back to where we were, but without actually taking the simple action which would achieve that.
00:11:20 He won't do that.
00:11:21 So I think that I've seen no evidence of any other explanation.
00:11:26 It's also not quite true that everybody else has done it.
00:11:29 Note particularly, obviously the Swedish example which everybody goes on about, which is complicated
00:11:36 but clearly the primacy of an actual serious scientist, Anders Tegnell, the head of policy,
00:11:45 with the government unable to tell him what to do, has made a big difference.
00:11:48 But also a neglected country in this is Japan, whose constitution prevents it from engaging
00:11:55 in the kind of thing which a lot of Western countries, including us, have done,
00:12:00 and which has had a very low death rate,
00:12:03 and which has largely returned to total economic activity and open society by now.
00:12:09 Unnoticed and neglected, as Japan so often is,
00:12:12 because its example is often very disturbing to equivalent Western countries
00:12:16 who realise when they look at Japan how much better they could have done things
00:12:20 and don't like to admit it.
00:12:22 There are quite a few areas of the world we don't actually hear very much about.
00:12:25 We don't.
00:12:26 I mean, I have this in the argument about the legalisation and decriminalisation of cannabis.
00:12:32 When I point out that people say, but it's been proven that prohibition doesn't work as much.
00:12:36 As a matter of fact, if you go to both Japan and South Korea,
00:12:40 you'll find they enforce quite strong laws against marijuana possession.
00:12:44 And as a result, its use is much lower.
00:12:46 And either silence falls or various attempts are made to pretend that Japan or South Korea
00:12:52 are in some way so alien from our experience that they can't possibly be examples.
00:12:56 But these are advanced, law-governed, free countries by the standards of the modern world,
00:13:01 and they've achieved things we haven't, and here again in Japan.
00:13:04 One of the things they seem to have achieved is a great deal of higher standard of health among the old.
00:13:10 Do you think this is going to go on?
00:13:13 I mean, do you think that even though there have been these vague ideas that all restrictions are going to be off in Britain by April or something?
00:13:25 I mean, you probably don't like making predictions, but do you see us wearing masks into the future?
00:13:33 I think a lot of people would like to.
00:13:34 I get the strong impression that quite a lot of people actively like wearing masks as a symbol of their goodness.
00:13:43 whatever it may be
00:13:46 and I think a lot of people also like to see people wearing masks
00:13:50 because it maintains the atmosphere of crisis
00:13:53 even though it goes well beyond
00:13:56 as you've rightly pointed out
00:13:58 the legal requirements of the government
00:14:00 though those may be extended
00:14:01 I've never ruled out a British government
00:14:05 taken by the Victorian provincial government in Australia
00:14:10 where there was practically a dictatorship and masks
00:14:13 you couldn't leave your house without one, and people were confined to their homes by
00:14:17 a pretty severe, I won't call it a police state because it's silly, but by a pretty
00:14:23 severe use of the strong state against people who you would have thought were living in
00:14:28 a free country, but they turned out not to be. And the events in Melbourne are very disturbing
00:14:32 to anybody who previously thought that the English tradition of law and liberty would
00:14:37 resist that kind of thing.
00:14:39 you think that you mentioned Melbourne we're in the centre of London and just
00:14:44 talking before we started it's it's dead quiet around here do you think that
00:14:49 cities now you know we're meant to be living in the century of the city are
00:14:54 we not do you think that they are basically now going to be in decline
00:14:59 because it's certainly I mean there are things have been done which may well be
00:15:05 be irrevocable i think i've often said that johnson is the general ratner of the railways
00:15:11 he's more or less persuaded people that it's too dangerous to travel by train and public transport
00:15:16 in general and the those of us who do still travel by train and see the effect which is the trains
00:15:21 are largely empty the stations are largely empty the railways have had to be effectively re-nationalized
00:15:27 and they are now receiving gigantic government subsidies to keep them going how can that be
00:15:33 maintained. If people don't go back to work because the other things happen, huge numbers
00:15:39 of employers have discovered that they can dispense with expensive big city offices and
00:15:45 get large numbers of their staff to work from home. Are they going to be keen to renew leases
00:15:51 on enormous offices when by simply handing out a few laptops they can tell their staff
00:15:56 actually we don't need you to come in anymore and avoid a huge expense? So commuting, the
00:16:01 era of commuting may well be for many people and some jobs obviously you have
00:16:05 to be there but for many you don't may well be at an end the total transformation
00:16:09 of the world of work and a total transformation of the nature of big
00:16:13 cities and particularly a city like London which has been a commuter city
00:16:16 for a long time the center of it has been kept alive by people who coming in
00:16:20 by day who leave by night has it affected you in that way or were you always
00:16:25 working at home no no I don't work from home I've worked from home for the
00:16:29 minimum period during this during the initial period I felt I thought it was
00:16:35 pretty much impossible to go into the office and so I didn't but as soon as it
00:16:40 was possible I went back and I've been going to work daily for some months now
00:16:45 what's been happening as well during this period is being what I would call a
00:16:51 pretty intensive cultural onslaught I don't know whether you see it that way
00:16:57 I know you've talked about our institutions.
00:16:59 You wrote very recently about the case in Eden with the school masks.
00:17:03 But that's pretty much one of a kind, you know, of what's been going on for a long time.
00:17:09 The thing is that that would have happened anyway, whether this was going on or not.
00:17:14 And probably the same amount of fuss you made about it.
00:17:17 What I wrote was about the misunderstanding that people have,
00:17:21 that this is still a live war in which conservatives are actually fighting against.
00:17:27 the sort of people who want to shut down dissenting opinions among school teachers.
00:17:33 That battle's been lost, and the law has been passed, the Equality Act of 2010 has been passed,
00:17:37 and that is the instrument by which all the old ideas of an older country were dethroned,
00:17:46 and a new set of ideas were enthroned, and the law will now back them,
00:17:50 particularly in places like schools.
00:17:52 But in the state schools, from the letters and emails and calls
00:17:59 I receive from parents of people at state schools
00:18:01 complaining about the sort of political indoctrination to which they're subjected,
00:18:05 this has been going on for a very long time.
00:18:07 And that anybody should be surprised that it should arrive at Eton amazes me.
00:18:13 Eton is not immune from these immense pressures
00:18:16 just because it charges enormous fees and has a fancy dress uniform.
00:18:20 I suppose it's what I was thinking as well of the response of our museums and institutions to
00:18:28 the Black Lives Matter protests and it's the speed with which there was this capitulation
00:18:36 or at least shall we say coming out and sort of almost declaring their hands you know it's almost
00:18:40 these people have been there for a long time but they used this period but I think again you need
00:18:48 to be unobservant not to have noticed it before i mean andrew roberts's complaints about what was
00:18:52 done to the to the national army museum for instance but anybody who's an enthusiastic
00:18:56 museum goer as i might will have noticed over the years increasing uh correction and uh and
00:19:01 purging of museums to make them into organs of propaganda for the new uh the the new cultural
00:19:08 regime i've been warning about this since 1999 i can't tell you uh one of the few pleasures i
00:19:16 I have in life is saying I told you so and I told everybody so. I wrote my book, The
00:19:20 Abolition of Britain, in 1998, 1999, in the belief that I was issuing a warning that people
00:19:28 might act on. As it happens, I was writing an obituary for a country which had already
00:19:34 effectively died. Nobody gave a damn or cared in the slightest. And 20 years later, the
00:19:39 thing is now got an iron grip on every institution and every current of thought. And I'm totally
00:19:45 unsurprised by this why would you be the say it's it's like allowing termites to burrow into every
00:19:52 part of a building for years and years and years and failing completely to combat this even though
00:19:56 you know it's going on and then being surprised when the building collapses before he arrives
00:20:02 it's been coming a long time and now it's here would you i told you sir yes would you
00:20:08 therefore sort of go along with the gramscian idea that essentially there has been an infiltration
00:20:14 or they shouldn't.
00:20:15 Well, it gives it too much direction
00:20:18 to cause an infiltration.
00:20:20 What happens is there's an education was,
00:20:22 a generation was educated
00:20:24 in the late 1960s and early 1970s
00:20:28 in the new ideas,
00:20:30 which emerged fundamentally from Euro-Communism,
00:20:34 which was itself a growth out of 1968,
00:20:36 both out of Prague and Paris.
00:20:38 Out of Paris, the cultural sexual revolution.
00:20:41 Out of Prague, the realization
00:20:43 that old-fashioned communism was finished
00:20:45 and that if socialism was to make any progress,
00:20:49 it had to cast completely to one side
00:20:52 all the old Bolshevik rubbish
00:20:53 and return to much more exciting cultural 1789, 1848, 1871 routes,
00:21:00 which it did.
00:21:01 The revolution ceased to be a Leninist business
00:21:05 of working-class seizure of the barracks
00:21:09 and the post office and the railway station
00:21:12 and became a middle-class seizure of the television studio and the newspaper and the university.
00:21:18 And when these people who emerged from their universities in the late 60s and early 70s
00:21:22 arrived at positions of influence, then they began to exert that influence.
00:21:27 Why wouldn't they? That's what they thought.
00:21:29 That's what they wanted. That's what they believed in.
00:21:31 And they'd be brought up to believe in it and educated to believe in it
00:21:34 in the great revolutionary times of the 60s.
00:21:37 And nothing had ever happened since then to put them off it.
00:21:39 But you
00:21:41 I believe
00:21:43 particularly think that the Blair
00:21:45 government was crucial in this
00:21:47 respect. Well the Blair government was the political
00:21:49 moment. Political. What had happened
00:21:50 the cultural, all the cultural and moral changes
00:21:53 had pretty much already happened
00:21:54 but what the
00:21:56 what infuriated the left was that they
00:21:59 couldn't get the political and state
00:22:01 power and once they got the
00:22:03 state power, the moment
00:22:04 you must remember the moment when the
00:22:07 Blair government took power
00:22:09 the BBC which had long been in the hands of people of this kind
00:22:14 treated it as if it was a moment of joy and glory
00:22:17 it was a new dawn
00:22:18 we had an aerial film of Blair's boring car going to Buckingham Palace
00:22:23 we had a completely uncritical recording of the fake demonstration in Downing Street
00:22:29 which anybody who knew anything about London must have known it was a fake
00:22:32 because normal human beings can't get into Downing Street
00:22:34 of people waving Union Jacks
00:22:36 Because all the people who were waving those Union Jacks hated the Union Jack, which by
00:22:42 then for them become a symbol of heaven knows what.
00:22:45 But they agreed to wave them because that was what they were asked to do.
00:22:48 And all this was reported as if it was, as I say, a new dawn by BBC and it was welcomed
00:22:53 by the academy, it was welcomed by apparently everybody in the cultural world as the beginning
00:23:00 of something new.
00:23:01 because the state was now in control and below within 15 years.
00:23:06 Huge numbers of things had been changed,
00:23:08 and the word husband had disappeared from official documents.
00:23:10 The whole idea of the institution of lifelong marriage was pretty much in their bin.
00:23:14 The sexual revolution was well underway.
00:23:17 And then the crowning moment, of course, was the Equality Act of 2010,
00:23:21 which Harriet Harman piloted through the House of Commons
00:23:25 with what I might say was very slight opposition from her Tory opposite number, Theresa May.
00:23:31 who was later praised by Trevor Phillips for her keen enthusiasm for politically correct causes.
00:23:37 Can you explain, actually, Peter?
00:23:38 I mean, a lot of people hear about things like the Equality Act,
00:23:42 and they don't really know what it was.
00:23:44 What was it just, how did it set up the situation?
00:23:48 Well, let me give a simple example of one which is very telling.
00:23:52 I mean, people think this is a Christian country by law and nature,
00:23:56 and for many centuries it was.
00:23:58 And if you look, as I advise people to do if they're trying to get to the grips of what the British Constitution really is,
00:24:04 at the Coronation Service itself, clearly a profoundly and explicitly Protestant Christian ceremony,
00:24:10 which declares the nature of this country and what sort of country it's like.
00:24:15 So if you then get an act of Parliament which says that basically all religions are equal,
00:24:22 and you may say that you find that an attractive idea if you don't yourself either adhere to Christianity
00:24:26 or you don't adhere to any religion at all or you adhere to another one and you say well good
00:24:31 why shouldn't all religions be equal that's a point of view I don't happen to share it but it's
00:24:36 a point of view I can quite understand people holding but if you do that while proclaiming
00:24:41 that what you're doing is creating equality between religions you are actively dethroning
00:24:45 Christianity as the principle that's an example of it and there are these protected characteristics
00:24:49 now again you say of course I hate discrimination against women and I hate racial discrimination
00:24:53 and frankly who doesn't but the protected characteristics go much further than just
00:24:58 disapproving of the hatred and discrimination against the people who are named they actually
00:25:04 give those protected characteristics a special a special status which means that anybody who can
00:25:08 be deemed to have attacked them not doing by your standards of mine they may not have done so
00:25:15 anybody who can be deemed to have attacked or threatened them is thereby in danger of losing
00:25:20 his or her job or in some other way being punished.
00:25:23 It's the basis of a whole new idea of what is good
00:25:27 and what is bad and what is wrong and what is right.
00:25:29 Second side it, the McPherson report
00:25:32 into the Stephen Lawrence murder
00:25:34 with this extraordinary declaration.
00:25:35 So it actually comes out specifically
00:25:38 against colorblind policing.
00:25:41 And it says that a racialist instance
00:25:43 is anything which anybody believes to be one.
00:25:46 And you have a subjective form of justice
00:25:49 written into the Constitution.
00:25:51 The consequences of these changes are huge
00:25:54 and spread out over everything.
00:25:56 This is the way people can and do behave.
00:26:00 They're vast.
00:26:00 People didn't notice them at the time.
00:26:02 You know, we-
00:26:03 Of course they're presented as,
00:26:04 and undoubtedly parts of this are attractive.
00:26:10 You can't say, well, actually no,
00:26:15 I want this to be more racial discrimination.
00:26:20 That's a disgusting thing to say.
00:26:21 And so if somebody says, well, this law will mean there's less of it,
00:26:25 it's very hard to oppose, even though there is an element in it
00:26:29 which has nothing to do with opposition to racial discrimination
00:26:32 and actually simply is in the business of enthroning a new ideology
00:26:36 and changing the nature of law.
00:26:39 So, for example, to come right up to date with this Eden situation,
00:26:45 they are falling foul of the law they fall of they've fallen foul specifically of the equality
00:26:50 act of 2010 when the headmaster uh and the and the provost i believe consulted uh their lawyers
00:26:58 who i doubt very much were cheap or inexperienced lawyers uh what those lawyers came out and said
00:27:04 was that they were in danger of breach of the equality act 2010 which is specifically just in
00:27:09 in case anyone was in any doubt, specifically applied to private schools
00:27:13 by a statutory instrument which was then approved by
00:27:17 a recent Conservative government. So there isn't any doubt that it applies.
00:27:23 You know, when people read about that
00:27:25 or when they read about the BBC and the Proms, when they read about the
00:27:29 British Library, the British Museum, I have to say
00:27:33 I don't know what kind of correspondence you get, but there is
00:27:37 a level of dismay amongst people um i get emails what do we do we know this is happening what do
00:27:45 we do peter i mean if people come to you and ask that what do you say to them what when they say
00:27:50 but what can we do well i asked them how they voted in 2010 right and most of them say i voted
00:27:55 conservative and i say well that's what you voted for right now you've got it tough i'm afraid i
00:28:01 And I have, this is, what happened, this is the other crucial part of the Blair Revolution,
00:28:06 which again I detailed in, particularly in my book, The Cameron Delusion,
00:28:12 the huge efforts devoted by the Labour Party, which had long wanted to do this, I have to say,
00:28:16 to ensure that what it did would never be reversed.
00:28:19 And the method that it chose was to browbeat and bludgeon the Conservative Party
00:28:24 into adopting the Labour Party's programme.
00:28:26 and that is largely what the was it the 2001 election one that was postponed by foot and
00:28:33 mouth that was largely what it was about uh was was was absolutely pounding the Tory party so hard
00:28:39 that they would never dare uh stand again on conservative program and then the this reached
00:28:48 its eventual triumph with the the election of David Cameron as the leader of the conservative
00:28:54 Party on what was clearly a program of basically Blairizing the Tory party, which he then did.
00:29:00 And the Tory party became so Blairite that the BBC was prepared to actually back it more
00:29:05 or less, which I believe it did in the 2010 election.
00:29:08 And that was if they had permission, having become a Blairite party, they had permission
00:29:12 to enter government again.
00:29:14 And the BBC's only disappointment was that they didn't win outright, I think.
00:29:18 They were preparing, they had all the camera angles ready for a triumphal arrival of David
00:29:22 Cameron and Downing Street was the last he couldn't win a majority so they couldn't do that
00:29:28 I mean do you do you think I think you said uh that basically conservatism only stands a chance
00:29:35 if the when the Tory party goes is that right yes my view has been if if the conservative party
00:29:43 were your were your car it would be permanently beside the road emitting clouds of steam and smoke
00:29:48 If the Conservative Party were your accountant, you'd be bankrupt.
00:29:51 And if the Conservative Party were your lawyer, you'd be in jail.
00:29:54 In every area that it operates, it completely fails to fulfill the promises,
00:30:02 the very mild promises which it makes.
00:30:04 It's a useless and worse than useless organization.
00:30:07 It lies like a great rotting hulk across the path of proper conservatism.
00:30:14 And I spent seven long, hard years before 2010 trying to persuade people that the most vital thing that you could possibly do if you wanted to fight new laborers to get rid of the Conservative Party and build a properly Conservative formation.
00:30:31 And I might as well have wasted my breath. Particularly I remember a meeting of the Bruges Group, for heaven's sake, which I was invited to address.
00:30:38 think and I think it was in 2009 I made this point to a group of people who
00:30:43 regarded themselves conservative and my second David Cameron was greeted with
00:30:48 such non-enthusiasm that I began to believe in global cooling the
00:30:52 temperature the room fell by several degrees Fahrenheit and I got almost no
00:30:57 applause at all and many of the people who were present there have written to
00:31:00 me subsequently saying but you were right and I said of course I was right I
00:31:03 knew I was right I told you but you wouldn't take any notice that's why I
00:31:06 have no sympathy with any of them now. Politics has moments. If the Tory party had properly
00:31:13 lost, it did lose the 2010 election, remember, if it had properly lost it in such a humiliating
00:31:19 way that it couldn't get into office, then that would have been that. The fundraisers
00:31:25 wouldn't have been able to operate, they couldn't have raised anything. The party would have
00:31:29 collapsed, there would have been a space. In that space, it would have been possible,
00:31:33 there would then have been the necessary condition
00:31:36 for the creation of a genuinely conservative movement
00:31:39 but what I would call roughly a British Gaulist movement
00:31:44 which is what I would favour having
00:31:45 there would have been the space for that to happen
00:31:47 it wouldn't have been guaranteed that it would happen
00:31:50 but what was absolutely certain was that it wouldn't happen
00:31:52 if the Tory party survived
00:31:54 all those people who voted to save the Tory party in 2010
00:31:57 saved Blairism
00:31:58 what are the chances of something happening now?
00:32:02 in my view zero
00:32:03 I mean, I've been saying for some time, the country is finished.
00:32:06 I keep going to my publishers and saying,
00:32:07 will you please put my books together into one huge Dominic Sandbrook-sized breeze block
00:32:13 called The Obituary of Britain.
00:32:15 It's all over.
00:32:17 But the abolition of Britain is actually still in print, isn't it?
00:32:20 Oh, it sells more and more.
00:32:22 It probably sells more now than when it first came out.
00:32:25 People reading and discovering, finally, what might have been some use to them 20 years ago,
00:32:29 but it is now just reminiscent.
00:32:30 But when you say Britain's finished, is it just Britain or is it the West?
00:32:37 Well, I'm not going to go into it. I know this is the country I know best. This is the one that I've researched. This is the one where I live. This is the one I most urgently care about.
00:32:47 And I've been saying for years, people say, what should I do? I say, leave. And people laugh. They think I'm joking. I was never joking. I meant it.
00:32:56 so if I if I were if I were 30 I would have left longer I've never seen a
00:33:02 country more finished I've seen some finished countries do you think people
00:33:07 care they don't understand they don't understand and the real problem in all
00:33:14 this is that people don't understand I sometimes think that you have to have
00:33:19 had a Marxist-Leninist Bolshevik training to understand politics most people
00:33:23 haven't had one. They believe. They're terrible at believing what they're told, which also
00:33:32 von Bismarck long ago was against. You never believe anything until it's been officially
00:33:36 denied. It's a watchword, particularly for journalists, but it seems to me for any wise
00:33:40 citizen. They believe what they were being told. They believe the appearance instead
00:33:44 of the substance of things. They believe slogans. They believe brand names. People, for good
00:33:50 sake in this country they buy instant mashed potato if you could sell them instant mashed potato you
00:33:53 can sell them anything including the conservative party when you say it's finished does that not
00:34:01 affect how you live your life well i i'm i'm a fortunate person and i i but and i'm better i
00:34:08 can escape as a result a lot of the consequences from this but ultimately i can't escape them all
00:34:15 if I were in my 30s I would leave
00:34:19 now it's too late for me to remake a new life
00:34:21 I don't believe in going to other people's countries
00:34:23 and becoming a parasite there
00:34:25 you have to go there and work and make a living
00:34:27 and pay your way and pay your taxes
00:34:29 the other thing about leaving is of course
00:34:31 that you don't feel so keenly responsible for
00:34:34 and so deeply wounded by the destruction
00:34:38 of what you love going on all around you
00:34:40 it's a different thing
00:34:42 you become an exile
00:34:43 but the truth is this country is in such a mess that and recent events have deepened that mess
00:34:51 quite considerably particularly the economic aspect of it that that's been my view I can't I
00:34:56 can't escape it what about the chance it's dying on my lips as I say it but what about the chance
00:35:06 of a new political party do you think there's any chance for that would that restore some sort of
00:35:12 Not faith, I'm not saying you don't have faith. Optimism.
00:35:15 I have political faith. Faith is not a thing for politics.
00:35:19 Temporal faith is a folly in my view, but the thing is here, this is a practical thing,
00:35:25 in the two-party system, and I approve of the two-party system very strongly,
00:35:28 I think it's essential to liberty to have two more or less equally matched parties
00:35:33 striving against each other, one always ready to take over from the other,
00:35:36 and the inch of difference between them is where we all live,
00:35:38 we all live and if we don't have that then we lose something huge also i think proportional
00:35:43 representation is a recipe for permanent liberal coalition government post election coalition
00:35:48 which in which the public have no say whatsoever i find that repulsive i don't want it but if you
00:35:54 have a two-party system you can't create a new party until there's a vacancy the labor party
00:36:01 arose out of the decay and collapse of the liberal party and until the tory party collapses there
00:36:06 there won't be any vacancy for another conservative formation.
00:36:10 Otherwise, people you can set up, I could go home now,
00:36:12 I could set up a political party, so-called,
00:36:15 but it would bear the same relation to a real political party
00:36:18 as a Hornby 00 train set bears to the old London and Northeastern Railway.
00:36:23 Fun to play with, but absolutely pointless for any serious purpose.
00:36:29 You're not going to get Newcastle on time on it.
00:36:33 You have, I think, referred to yourself today,
00:36:35 Britain's obiturist. It's quite a long death throes.
00:36:41 Well they often are, aren't they? There's a lot of ruin in a nation, as Adam Smith, but I don't think he foresaw there was quite as much ruin as there was.
00:36:49 Look at us, look at the spending of the current Chancellor, look at the borrowing, look at the destruction of so much of the service economy on which we had become dependent.
00:37:04 how can this have a good outcome go down to Felixstowe count I rang them up a few years ago
00:37:12 I said how many of the containers coming into Felixstowe are full I said all of them I said
00:37:17 how many of them going out of Felixstowe are full and they said well quite a few are empty
00:37:21 and quite a few of those that are full are just full of garbage being exported to China for
00:37:25 recycling there is no balance between between what we make and what we buy we are not paying
00:37:32 our way. And people say, oh, well, these days you can create money relentlessly and it doesn't
00:37:36 matter. The world has changed. It didn't have this ridiculous Thatcherite housewife idea
00:37:42 of economics. But I'm sorry. Once a nation gets a reputation to not pay its bills, then
00:37:48 eventually the world's lenders, the people who buy the bonds, start looking askance at
00:37:57 what you've done. And I would think quite possibly the way in which this will affect
00:38:01 just most abruptly, will be in a decline in the value of the pound sterling.
00:38:06 Argentina, this is amazing, Argentina was once one of the great hopes of the world.
00:38:11 It was a country which people thought was going to be possibly the equal of even the United States in economic power,
00:38:17 but it chose to follow foolish and dangerous economic and political paths,
00:38:21 and now it's scrabbling on the upper limits of the third world.
00:38:27 This could happen. Countries can actually destroy their prosperity.
00:38:30 I don't believe the figures of spending money that we haven't got
00:38:39 and borrowing money that we can't afford to pay the interest on
00:38:41 if it goes up even by half a percent.
00:38:44 Enormous beyond all bearing,
00:38:46 incomparable with any peacetime behavior before.
00:38:49 I can't believe that people are so undisturbed by this.
00:38:53 Perhaps they simply don't understand.
00:38:56 Well, I don't know.
00:38:57 But either that or there's a huge willingness to pretend that it doesn't matter.
00:39:00 It's interesting, when you look at the superficiality of day-to-day politics, people like, not
00:39:08 that you do very much, but people like the Chancellor are seen as somehow being this
00:39:13 sort of very bright, great white hope for the future, and yet in fact, probably what
00:39:18 they're doing is the most irresponsible thing imaginable, surely.
00:39:21 Well, the only thing is, in response to that, of course, is that Rishi Sunak is probably
00:39:26 one of the people in the government who is most aware of the danger that the government
00:39:29 is courting and who, by being inside it,
00:39:32 possibly restrains it from greater follies.
00:39:34 It's not much of a comfort to me.
00:39:37 One can't doubt that the man's intelligent.
00:39:40 I suspect he knows more than he says.
00:39:42 But would it be better if he parachuted out of the government
00:39:45 and handed over the treasury to somebody
00:39:46 who believed in all this stuff?
00:39:48 Hardly.
00:39:49 But it's a choice between worse and worse, doesn't it,
00:39:52 rather than bad and good.
00:39:53 And as for Boris, we're still calling him Boris.
00:40:00 I call him Johnson.
00:40:01 I won't give him an honorific and I certainly won't use his stage Christian name, which
00:40:06 isn't even the one he uses among friends.
00:40:09 But therefore, if prognosis is as bleak as that, then he's sort of quite a fitting emblem,
00:40:14 is he not?
00:40:15 How do you mean?
00:40:16 Well, in the sense there's this sort of person who came along who essentially is possibly
00:40:23 just an act maybe
00:40:25 with very little
00:40:26 depth behind it?
00:40:29 Well I think that's true
00:40:30 but that hasn't ruled out quite a lot of other people
00:40:33 from being Prime Minister
00:40:34 I always thought that Blair
00:40:37 was essentially an act
00:40:39 and that the real
00:40:40 power and decision making in his government
00:40:43 took place elsewhere but it didn't matter so much
00:40:45 because he certainly didn't face
00:40:47 or attempt to deal with anything like this
00:40:49 but
00:40:50 it's
00:40:51 in his case I think
00:40:54 there was a complete misunderstanding
00:40:56 of the kind of person he was
00:40:58 I think have I got news for you
00:41:00 and I'm not joking here
00:41:01 bears a very heavy responsibility for creating him
00:41:04 as a famous person
00:41:06 and as a figure in politics
00:41:08 with a higher reputation
00:41:10 than he could possibly have gotten any other way
00:41:12 it would have saved both him
00:41:14 and us from a lot of trouble
00:41:16 if they hadn't done that
00:41:18 well life is funny
00:41:21 like that isn't it um peter thank you very very much again for coming in and and um i hope well
00:41:30 i i i hope we don't have to talk about the progress of what's happening with the pandemic
00:41:34 in six months time but i do hope maybe you come back next year well if you're happy to have me
00:41:39 yes i'm ready to come always nice of you to ask you know and uh you're always welcome thank you
00:41:45 you very much indeed, thank you. That's it for this week. Please subscribe, won't you?
00:41:50 And we shall see you next time. Thank you.